So for anyone not caught up on the case, it was resolved 2 month ago when Garam released the full School Violence Committee Document (Eunseo, the "victim", had previously shown the public only the first 3 lines of the document). Turns out the person who called themselves the "victim" (we call her Eunseo) and said she got bullied by Garam was actually Garam's friend in middle school, but they decided to stop being friends because Eunseo kept talking behind all of her friend's backs. Eunseo was salty she lost all of her friends and decided to hack into an ex-friends Facebook account (to make it look like it wasn't her who did this) and post pictures of another ex-friend (12 y/o at the time) where they were only wearing their underwear. This was very traumatic for the girl whose pictures were posted online because she still had to attend school after students saw her half naked so she called Garam and asked for help. Garam tried to reach Eunseo, but she wouldn't pick up so frustrated Garam cursed a couple of times over text and when they eventually met up Garam coursed and yelled at Eunseo some more and asked her to delete the photo and apologize. Eunseo later went to the schools violence committee and asked them to punish Garam for the cursing over text and Garam got the lvl5 punishment (most common punishment in her school). It was never bullying, because before that incident they were literally friends. Oh yeah and also, to avoid punishment, Eunseo transferred schools and then continued to spread rumours about Garam in the new school. So yeah, Garam's career got ruined by a jealous former (fake) friend who couldn't stand to see Garam achieve her dreams. If you wanna read the SVC document, here's the link: twitter.com/oncemimosa/status/1557479971052048384?t=Ax6IxNOSisxuGWDa4F9NsA&s=19 Also this document is helpful if you wanna read more about the case: docs.google.com/document/d/108cJs2GeHfWbn9I9-yzMEYvkXMJA3UExd7aH67skXaY/edit?usp=drivesdk
i will never forgive hybe for failing to protect a minor whose reputation got ruined for the rest of her life. i don’t think someone would ever be able to recover from the damage done, especially a girl this young. it’s really a shame that the company would care more about their own reputation than their artist‘s well-being, dropping her completely than trying to clear her name.
I think they tried to clean her name because I remember that during that time everyone was hating on HYBE for letting a bully stay in the group and everyone was wondering why she was so important to the company, I think they really tried to keep her but the public opinion didn’t help because people were about to start boycotting the group if she stayed so yeah
hybe literally tried all they could to keep her and people were bashing hybe for keeping her in the group now when hybe ends her contract y’all still hating gosh kpop stans are never satisfied
It's such a shame seeing how talented everyone is in this group and seeing what they've been able to accomplish I can't help but feel so bad for Garam. She was chosen on the strength of her talents and deserved to live out her dreams. She would've achieved so much had her company and the public not been so quick to throw her under the bus.
It’s sad how Eunchae lost the only other member that was in the same age range as her. It would’ve been nice to have been with someone who had similar experiences as her
So it seems like you have not seen how Eunchae is doing huh. She is loved by all members as the team's youngest. She is having the time of her life. Do not trust? Why don't you watch all of their videos? You wrought this 6months ago is so fckin funny. You have had plenty of time to catch up with how Le Sserafim has been doing.
@@yongdol73maybe read it first before coming up to ppls cuz they were saying being at the same age with an another person whos the same age as u will be fun?i know that eunchae is having fun times with other members but having fun with another person that whos the same age as u will be fun,if ur eunchae u would know how it feels like to lose someone the same age as u,pathetic
The flavor she put in her dance and her standout charm on camera were so distinct that I can clearly picture her in the new choreos. I miss everything about her. I know which parts are for her voice.
@@tfwhatsdatgirl Dude, if that's a rumor, why would she have her agency contract cancelled? Don't think as you please. The more that happens, the worse her image is and the worse she can get back into the entertainment world. Moron.😮💨
Please think about the victims. Overseas fans, look back on yourself how stupid you think. I'm also a big fan of Le sserafim, but no matter how much I think about it, I think you guys are intelligent anti. 🤬
She was the reason I stanned le sserafim. When she was removed, I no longer can look at le sserafim the same again. Her voice is so beautiful, unique, very special. She has every quality to be an idol. Gosh I miss her. I hope one day she will be on stage again.
Hybe lost out on a talent that could take Le Sserafim to Blackpink heights potentially. Garam's voice is irreplacable. She was a singer and had a great stage presence.
I want her back soo freakin bad. I really wish Hype could have stood up for her more and not have given up on her like that, even though they knew it was a lie and still gave up. she was my ultimate bias, and now, looking at them performing without her really makes me feel some sort of way. like imaging her in some formation or saying she could have done this, or she would say that I don't know, but I really wished she was able to come back cause I feel like something is missing in the group without her there.
my garam...i miss you so much and i'm still here in 2024, watching your fancam and probably will for a while. i can't wait for your acting debut and i'll support you in everything that you do. i love my fimmies but it's just not the same without you. just know that you have so many fans supporting you in your new career. you'll be forever our perfect center and amazing vocalist. you're so talented and didn't deserve any of this. i miss OT6 le sserafim and i miss you
Um, i don't think she can. Knetz really hates her, and majority of her fans are international. I hope she at least start her youtube channel and just update us with what she's up to.
@@Everyonesaytouswoo.ah3987 not sure what it’s like in Korea but if Fergie can rejoin the black eyed peas without backlash then any artist should be able to go back into their former group but that’s just my opinion 😁
@@saddieplays3615 I'm not against the girl. But imagine performing knowing probably half of your audience didn't want you there.. Also, can y'all share the link of an article/news regarding her being innocent, I wanna read
the day that garam makes a comeback is the day that i will wuote literally burst into tears. her comeback as a soloist will seriously shake the k-pop industry. we love you garam, we’re all rooting for you!!! ❤️🐰
I feel so sorry for this girl. Damn, to go through all of this immediately after debuting at the age of 16… and to think that she was actually defending a friend for being a victim of sex crime :/ i hope life treats her well after this. Also, she has the most beautiful long hair i think i’ve ever seen in kpop
@@lillian9o0 They Kicked her out After Ppl Started Cyberbullying her for Bullying? Literally Hypocrites and It hasn't been proven if she did bully like wth
The fact that there’s still some Korean netizens lurking about criticizing Garam even tho majority of what she’s accused of speaks volumes. They on hate her for edited photos and for defending a friend from a juvenile sex criminal (even tho she was literally going against someone THAT EVIL). Are you guys actually against bullying or are you just looking for a convenient target to cyber bully?
SHAMES ON HYBE. Protecting a minor is what should've come to your mind at first. No research or clearing up for her reputation and just being selfish is DUMB.
Kim Garam tried very hard for the debut, she had potential, she was a girl with a kind soul, but you kicked her out of the band le sserafim without spoiling your reputation. I'm disgusted to see that you didn't bother to clear her name, you just feared for your reputation, or rather for the money you would lose. This is a very low act Hybe entertainmant Someone who will delve into your company, your groups. Learning about this your "heroism" will not be about the best opinion. After all, Garam is a young for this intident
@@aesthetic4762 no one's really sure whether or not she's interested in being an idol anymore.. according to a recent update from her friend, she's currently just focusing on her studies to enroll in college
To anyone who asks, why did you support her when you only knew her for "2 weeks" ask yourself this question: If this situation had happened to any of the other girls of lesserafim would you have fought for them? If you would have fought for them and not for Garam then your problem was with Garam to begin with, not with the situation being about bullying
Why I am crying , I wish I could bring her back she looks so happy, why RUclips is recommending this video while I'm still waiting for them to say it's just a joke....
Garam is innocent! Yoo Eunseo candidly took pictures of her classmates wearing bras, how could she say she was a victim? Garam scolded Yoo Eunseo for just coming out to protect her friends, Garam did nothing wrong!
Does society ever learn? Again and again we hear a rumour, the rumour is blown up way out of control, and people start hating without even knowing if it’s true or not. There are always multiple sides to a story, and sometimes we don’t ever get to know the full story either. ‘Innocent until proven guilty’ is therefore such a nice term, cause using this way of thinking under these type of situations, we can prevent straight up bullying itself to what can be an innocent idol. I also don’t understand how people can feel good about talking trash about Garam, as if it makes them any better themselves. They hate because they think she is a bully, then become a bully themselves. It makes me nauseous of the idea that Garam could be innocent and is dealing with a bunch of people dragging her down and wishing for her to leave her group. Please do better guys, she is a human too, at the end of the day.
At least the company should had clear her name before letting her go of the company, they just let media ruin her life and future. I hope once justice is served
See she isn't even my bias, but she still deserve a chance she has the potential to become a star, I'm not sure if she's a bully or not but that was the past and we shouldn't just neglect her talent and dig inside her past, everyone deserves a second chance even there crime was big or small
Kim garam her voice was so satisfying, but hearing that hybe kicked her made me sad Garam had a friend *eun soo*(i mean bully) who spreaded fake rumours about her to destroy her life of becoming idol (*eun soo* admitted that she spreaded fake rumours) And now garam is getting bullied at school😭😭😔😭 EDIT: if you are a hater of garam dont reply me
is seriously ? Then they tell her to get off the stage, to kick her out of the company and then they tell her: "We love you, I'm waiting for your debut" HOW HYPOCRITE KOREANS ARE (of course, not all but mostly) in the 21st century but you just the same time doesn't pass them
Yesterday I read on my own national internet news: There is an idol company in South Korea that deliberately manipulated the country to hate and frame Garam...
![[MPD직캠] 르세라핌 직캠 4K 'Blue Flame' (LE SSERAFIM FanCam) | @MCOUNTDOWN_2022.5.5](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/eKjQorPQqco/mqdefault.jpg)
![[제39회 골든디스크] LE SSERAFIM (르세라핌) - 'Intro + Pierrot + CRAZY (EBM Remix)' ♪ | JTBC 250106 방송](/img/1.gif)
So for anyone not caught up on the case, it was resolved 2 month ago when Garam released the full School Violence Committee Document (Eunseo, the "victim", had previously shown the public only the first 3 lines of the document). Turns out the person who called themselves the "victim" (we call her Eunseo) and said she got bullied by Garam was actually Garam's friend in middle school, but they decided to stop being friends because Eunseo kept talking behind all of her friend's backs. Eunseo was salty she lost all of her friends and decided to hack into an ex-friends Facebook account (to make it look like it wasn't her who did this) and post pictures of another ex-friend (12 y/o at the time) where they were only wearing their underwear. This was very traumatic for the girl whose pictures were posted online because she still had to attend school after students saw her half naked so she called Garam and asked for help. Garam tried to reach Eunseo, but she wouldn't pick up so frustrated Garam cursed a couple of times over text and when they eventually met up Garam coursed and yelled at Eunseo some more and asked her to delete the photo and apologize. Eunseo later went to the schools violence committee and asked them to punish Garam for the cursing over text and Garam got the lvl5 punishment (most common punishment in her school). It was never bullying, because before that incident they were literally friends. Oh yeah and also, to avoid punishment, Eunseo transferred schools and then continued to spread rumours about Garam in the new school.
So yeah, Garam's career got ruined by a jealous former (fake) friend who couldn't stand to see Garam achieve her dreams.
If you wanna read the SVC document, here's the link:
twitter.com/oncemimosa/status/1557479971052048384?t=Ax6IxNOSisxuGWDa4F9NsA&s=19
Also this document is helpful if you wanna read more about the case:
docs.google.com/document/d/108cJs2GeHfWbn9I9-yzMEYvkXMJA3UExd7aH67skXaY/edit?usp=drivesdk
i love you so much for giving the truth. I want Garam back so much
it's so unfair. i wish she could return
I want my Garam back so bad🥺
@@ranefallx5573 i hope not in le sserifem. Because hybe
Man so unfair😢
i will never forgive hybe for failing to protect a minor whose reputation got ruined for the rest of her life. i don’t think someone would ever be able to recover from the damage done, especially a girl this young.
it’s really a shame that the company would care more about their own reputation than their artist‘s well-being, dropping her completely than trying to clear her name.
justice baby
@@WasabiMintChoco Justice does not serve that way. For the one who ruined her life, brimstones and inferno are the Justice.
I think they tried to clean her name because I remember that during that time everyone was hating on HYBE for letting a bully stay in the group and everyone was wondering why she was so important to the company, I think they really tried to keep her but the public opinion didn’t help because people were about to start boycotting the group if she stayed so yeah
hybe literally tried all they could to keep her and people were bashing hybe for keeping her in the group now when hybe ends her contract y’all still hating gosh kpop stans are never satisfied
the moment they stopped protecting her midways and let her fend for herself is where they failed though
Garam is the perfect center for Le Sserafim, the music was better when her voice was there. Her vocals, visual, stage presence are irreplaceable.
Stage presence garam?
@@roseanneliesseyes beetch
@@roseanneliesseyes
@@roseanneliesse yes
Agree
It's such a shame seeing how talented everyone is in this group and seeing what they've been able to accomplish I can't help but feel so bad for Garam. She was chosen on the strength of her talents and deserved to live out her dreams. She would've achieved so much had her company and the public not been so quick to throw her under the bus.
Hybe only protecting bts
@@Anne-wm5sn nowadays they don't even protect BTS😢
학교생활을 찾아봐
@@shinigamilight786we army do
It’s sad how Eunchae lost the only other member that was in the same age range as her. It would’ve been nice to have been with someone who had similar experiences as her
Yes she's so young compared to the rest
So it seems like you have not seen how Eunchae is doing huh. She is loved by all members as the team's youngest. She is having the time of her life. Do not trust? Why don't you watch all of their videos? You wrought this 6months ago is so fckin funny. You have had plenty of time to catch up with how Le Sserafim has been doing.
@@yongdol73 Is it that bad to have another member who's also around the same age?
There's a 3 year difference between her and Kazuha
@@yongdol73maybe read it first before coming up to ppls cuz they were saying being at the same age with an another person whos the same age as u will be fun?i know that eunchae is having fun times with other members but having fun with another person that whos the same age as u will be fun,if ur eunchae u would know how it feels like to lose someone the same age as u,pathetic
it's crazy how even if le serafim has just had their 3rd cb we're still stuck in this era and miss her
Segundo ya que "fearless" es su debut
Real :(
Their debut was amazing and if you look at the numbers the view counts for their fancams were 10x what they are now
FOR REAL! 😢❤
yeah for real....I'm crying
If she is still in le sserafim, she will be the most popular member in the group and in the same level of popularity with IVE Wonyoung
too bad people didn't want that
Kakao didn't want that
@@bubblegum_55
The reason i hate that company and don't stan any of its groups.
she really had a big it girl potential , let’s not forget that she is the fastest idol to reach over 50m tweets in only a week
@@piraateeboa228850MILLION??
The flavor she put in her dance and her standout charm on camera were so distinct that I can clearly picture her in the new choreos. I miss everything about her. I know which parts are for her voice.
She was so talented , y’all broke her dreams 😢
Think about numerous people whose dream were broken by her, you silly
@@yungcho6637 the rumors were proved false multiple times, the school literally came out and said it themselves
@@yungcho6637 think about how she was literally proven innocent by garam's school itself, you silly
@@tfwhatsdatgirl Dude, if that's a rumor, why would she have her agency contract cancelled? Don't think as you please. The more that happens, the worse her image is and the worse she can get back into the entertainment world. Moron.😮💨
Please think about the victims. Overseas fans, look back on yourself how stupid you think. I'm also a big fan of Le sserafim, but no matter how much I think about it, I think you guys are intelligent anti. 🤬
Garam's voice has given a new soul to this song
Visual. Center. Face of the Group. She can be everything.
bully too
@@iluvstrwbrriesnop3
@@iluvstrwbrries she is NOT!!!!
Garam=🚮🚮
@@chaelisa_jensoo. es como tu i tú madre entonces, córtate i grábalo ❣️
She was the reason I stanned le sserafim. When she was removed, I no longer can look at le sserafim the same again. Her voice is so beautiful, unique, very special. She has every quality to be an idol. Gosh I miss her. I hope one day she will be on stage again.
Same :
Same for me.Fearless era isn't the same without her :(
same
She deserves the biggest apology..
Even after 2 years her voice melts my heart
This song will forever be Garam's song, no matter what!
IKRR BLUE FLAME AND SOUR GRAPES ARE GARAMS SONGS IDGAF WHAT PEOPLE SAY!!
@@Staniell_1no one gaf about u either
@@urhypeboyok jealous ahh
You will never be forgetten, love you garam #justiceforgaram
Lmao
@@yurikim3703 something funny?
shes innocent..
@@yurikim3703 what is it ?
@@yurikim3703 The only funny thing here is you
This will always be GARAM’S song no re-recording will ever erase her 😊
Hybe lost out on a talent that could take Le Sserafim to Blackpink heights potentially. Garam's voice is irreplacable. She was a singer and had a great stage presence.
Fr she easily can be one of the best visual of 4gen too😢
Poor girl didnt know she would be Hybes first victim 😢.pathetic company 🚮
I want her back soo freakin bad. I really wish Hype could have stood up for her more and not have given up on her like that, even though they knew it was a lie and still gave up. she was my ultimate bias, and now, looking at them performing without her really makes me feel some sort of way. like imaging her in some formation or saying she could have done this, or she would say that I don't know, but I really wished she was able to come back cause I feel like something is missing in the group without her there.
I MISS YOU!!! 🩷
my garam...i miss you so much and i'm still here in 2024, watching your fancam and probably will for a while. i can't wait for your acting debut and i'll support you in everything that you do. i love my fimmies but it's just not the same without you. just know that you have so many fans supporting you in your new career. you'll be forever our perfect center and amazing vocalist. you're so talented and didn't deserve any of this. i miss OT6 le sserafim and i miss you
yes and me doing this to whenever I miss her which is everyday
I hope she debuts again 😢😢
Same but as a soloist
@@Eclipwzeeh no
まだ全然ガラムのこと恋しい
Hoping Garam can still comeback on stage or on camera again
Um, i don't think she can. Knetz really hates her, and majority of her fans are international. I hope she at least start her youtube channel and just update us with what she's up to.
If knetz hate her then...
I HATE KNETZ
@@sjsendo5264 well Knetz hates the innocent person it shows how dumb they are 😂
@@safinamoral2055 who is Knetz?
@@xlichera_ a korean netizens
See how this company used her and how Knetizens ; international fans wasted this talent so much just because of jealousy especially korean "fans"
Look at the movement of Garam's hair, how beautiful it is
Its 2024 and i still go back for this fancam. I really hope that they will never take this video down
If HYBE knew what’s best they’d just put her back in the group and issue an apology cuz she’s def the main visual vocal 😢💗
Is it possible to put her back in the group after terminating the contract?
I honestly think it's best for her to not be back.
@@Everyonesaytouswoo.ah3987 not sure what it’s like in Korea but if Fergie can rejoin the black eyed peas without backlash then any artist should be able to go back into their former group but that’s just my opinion 😁
@@oreki1996 why? Because proof has been released of her bieng innocent
@@saddieplays3615 I'm not against the girl. But imagine performing knowing probably half of your audience didn't want you there.. Also, can y'all share the link of an article/news regarding her being innocent, I wanna read
She really could’ve been an it girl contender if HYBE weren’t stupid
Is there someone in 2024?
No matter how hard HYBE tries to erase her she will always be on my heart and mind her presence is tattooed on my skull.
I love her. Her voices so feminine and the way she moves her hair so flawlessly ❤❤❤
I don't blame Hybe, I blame the fans for putting pressure on Hybe and immediately believing that Garam was a bully
Those people who came for her for no reason are the real "BULLIES" ☹️☹️
솔직히 ㅈㄴ 매력있음
the day that garam makes a comeback is the day that i will wuote literally burst into tears. her comeback as a soloist will seriously shake the k-pop industry. we love you garam, we’re all rooting for you!!! ❤️🐰
GARAM 從你的立場文來看 我就知道你很堅強 今後無論去到那裡你也能好好生活下去
加油!
I WANT KIM GARAM`S SOLO DEBUT
she gonna be an actress
Same she definitely deserve a comeback even if it's her solo I hope some day she gets that chance
i miss her sm
After watching Coachella i just miss her fr
나도ㅋㅋㅋㅋ
I feel so sorry for this girl. Damn, to go through all of this immediately after debuting at the age of 16… and to think that she was actually defending a friend for being a victim of sex crime :/ i hope life treats her well after this. Also, she has the most beautiful long hair i think i’ve ever seen in kpop
She could’ve been Wonyoung and Karina status :(
No way u are so bad
ルセラの事めちゃ好きではないけど、ガラムの映像だけは永遠に見てる
Hybe,how could you lose this beautiful angel?
やっぱりとても綺麗な声で、初々しくもオーラがあり、懸命な姿に心惹かれる😢ここからさらに力をつけてどんどんパワーアップしていくんだろうなと思っていただけに残念…。もうどうしようもないことなんだろうけど戻ってきてほしいよ😢
A visual and a pretty voice, gurl we will miss you😭
What happened to her?!
@@lillian9o0 she got kicked out
@@lillian9o0 they kicked her out
yea i miss her a lot
@@lillian9o0 They Kicked her out After Ppl Started Cyberbullying her for Bullying? Literally Hypocrites and It hasn't been proven if she did bully like wth
It's a shame how Hybe and Source Music crumbled to public scrutiny while pushing a group with a anti-conformist concept and message
The fact that there’s still some Korean netizens lurking about criticizing Garam even tho majority of what she’s accused of speaks volumes. They on hate her for edited photos and for defending a friend from a juvenile sex criminal (even tho she was literally going against someone THAT EVIL). Are you guys actually against bullying or are you just looking for a convenient target to cyber bully?
SHAMES ON HYBE. Protecting a minor is what should've come to your mind at first. No research or clearing up for her reputation and just being selfish is DUMB.
Le sserafim is just not the same anymore. Garam was perfect for the group, now it just feels incomplete...
Kim Garam tried very hard for the debut, she had potential, she was a girl with a kind soul, but you kicked her out of the band le sserafim without spoiling your reputation. I'm disgusted to see that you didn't bother to clear her name, you just feared for your reputation, or rather for the money you would lose. This is a very low act Hybe entertainmant
Someone who will delve into your company, your groups. Learning about this your "heroism" will not be about the best opinion. After all, Garam is a young for this intident
Miss you garam💗
Le sserafim is still ot6 for me
本当に可愛い。ガラムちゃんの甘い歌声が大好きです。
I always support and love u my girl , Please be strong and don't get sick, I will always be by your side.🫶🏻🫶🏻🫶🏻💘💘
you're the brightest when you dance 🥹🫶🏻
Bring her back. She completes the group. The aura she brings to stage……
exactly like it’s not too late to add her back 😭
Its impossible for her to comeback..
Tho I wish she can but I hope she debutes in a other group
She has a lot of potential
@@Sanjiscumslut I hope she gets another contract....maybe she can be in I land??
@@aesthetic4762 no one's really sure whether or not she's interested in being an idol anymore.. according to a recent update from her friend, she's currently just focusing on her studies to enroll in college
You think it will ever happen? I hope it so much.
I will never forget her
가람아 언제나 응원한다😄
❤❤❤❤❤
SAME
Tanks for that
아까운 인재 한명을 잃었어..
가해자는 있어도 피해자는 없는 사건 으로 연예계에서 사라진게 아쉽네, 이런저런 사건사고만 없었어도 찐팬 진짜 많았을텐데 그래서 내사랑은 쌈무에게로~
영상은 평생 안내려가고 계속 있었음 좋겠다
Hybe tried to destroy garam's influence by releasing a five person version of this song,but failed😂
If they really wanted to destroy her influence they would have made a 5Person Version of Sour Grapes.
Don't be ridiculous.
ガラムちゃんが恋しい😢💗
A genuine smile 100% of the time. She was having the time of her life.
We need a redebut WITH A DIFFERENT COMPANY. #JusticeForGaram
To anyone who asks, why did you support her when you only knew her for "2 weeks" ask yourself this question:
If this situation had happened to any of the other girls of lesserafim would you have fought for them?
If you would have fought for them and not for Garam then your problem was with Garam to begin with, not with the situation being about bullying
WE MISS GARAM, WHY DO YOU HAVE TO TERMINATE HER? 🥺 Imagine how she feels knowing she won't be performing on stage again? 😭
I HOPE I CAN SEE HER AGAIN SMILING ON STAGE 😭😭
@kazuhawebs oh this comment is only for those who support her. If you don't like her, then mind your own business 😊 Takecare!! 🤍
Sorry I Hate her
@sana gf tf not you and we didn’t ask you
@yeojin why are you even in the comments of her fancam if you dislike her so much...it's giving obsessed
thank you hybe for not deleting this fancam
6명중에 가장 쿨하고 매력적인 외모를 가진 특별한 아이 💖✨️ 마음만 조금 곱게 먹고 살았다면 K팝 레전드로 성장할수 있었을텐데
볼수록 아깝다 김가람
이미 지난 상황은 돌아오지 않느게 아쉽죠...
I dont know why but i miss her alot❤
She is prefect idol for me
The more i see her fancam the more i love her❤
Why I am crying , I wish I could bring her back she looks so happy, why RUclips is recommending this video while I'm still waiting for them to say it's just a joke....
Garam is innocent! Yoo Eunseo candidly took pictures of her classmates wearing bras, how could she say she was a victim? Garam scolded Yoo Eunseo for just coming out to protect her friends, Garam did nothing wrong!
I prefer the songs with her vocals included
She has a sweet voice and I miss this 😔
The rumors and lies of others ended up harming her and ruined her dreams and dimmed her shine.
ルセラを知ってから初めて見たけど、
すんごい綺麗で存在感があってダンスもめちゃくちゃ上手いね…
またどこかで見たい
You're the bestest Kim Garam 💝💐🫂👑✨
Does society ever learn? Again and again we hear a rumour, the rumour is blown up way out of control, and people start hating without even knowing if it’s true or not. There are always multiple sides to a story, and sometimes we don’t ever get to know the full story either. ‘Innocent until proven guilty’ is therefore such a nice term, cause using this way of thinking under these type of situations, we can prevent straight up bullying itself to what can be an innocent idol. I also don’t understand how people can feel good about talking trash about Garam, as if it makes them any better themselves. They hate because they think she is a bully, then become a bully themselves. It makes me nauseous of the idea that Garam could be innocent and is dealing with a bunch of people dragging her down and wishing for her to leave her group. Please do better guys, she is a human too, at the end of the day.
But she is a bully though.
rumors MY ASS ! her whole school confirmed her being a bully . stop this bullshit . she IS a bully .
@@ppjskh and how the f do you know that ??
@@ppjskh you only hear things from stupid people in social media w out knowing anything. calm tf down lmao
@@ppjskh she was the victim of bullying, there’s evidence
she was the moment.
She was so talented, people ruined a 16 year old girl's life, y'all broke all her dreams 😣😖😫😭
she could’ve been 4th gen’s IT girl 😢
She really could have she had the voice the visuals the dancing the vibes and the hair
5人のLE SSERAFIMに慣れてきてたのに今日になってこの動画が急に流れてきて、やっぱりガラムが大好きだなぁって実感したけど悲しくなった😭
I miss her soo muchh 😢❤
her dreams were crushed within two weeks. hybe failed to protect this gal, we all miss you garam
การัมฝึกและเทรนนี่มาตั้งนาน ก่อนเดก็ต้องฝึกซ้อมตั้งเยอะวันละหลายรอบ แต่ต้องมาเสียอนาคตเพราะคนๆเดียวที่ปล่อยเฟคนิวส์ออกมามั่วๆ ทำให้เกาหลีกับอินเตอร์โถมด่าและสาปไม่หยุด สุดท้ายก็จบด้วยการที่การัมโดนยุติสัญญา ตอนนี้โคตรคิดถึงคิมการัมเลย ยอมรับว่านี่เข้ามาด้อมนี้ไม่ทันตอนเปิดตัว รู้สึกโชคร้ายที่มาเจอการัมตอนเธอออกไปแล้ว ยังไงเซรีนก็จะรอเธอนะคิมการัมรีบกลับมาไวๆนะ🧸💖✨
best center
忘れようとしても忘れられない、ガラムちゃんがだいすきです
Will never forgive those who bullied her out of the group. She would've been my bias :((
She WAS my bias I miss her so much :((
Kim Garam we love u .. stay healthy ... 💜👏
하나 확실한건, 가람이를 진짜 위했다면 데뷔 전에 해결하던지 계약해지를 해서 얼굴이 덜 알려져서 빨리 잊힐 수 있도록 해주던가 했어야함. 이게 뭐냐고 진짜...
진짜 이말은 공감백프로네요.
서로 상처죠..
All Koreans vent their problems by criticizing Kim Garam
@@magi7857 exactly
At least the company should had clear her name before letting her go of the company, they just let media ruin her life and future. I hope once justice is served
I miss u :c
Please bring kim garam back i really miss her 😿😿😿
garam no only garam no
How beautiful and fabulous is garam's hair
See she isn't even my bias, but she still deserve a chance she has the potential to become a star, I'm not sure if she's a bully or not but that was the past and we shouldn't just neglect her talent and dig inside her past, everyone deserves a second chance even there crime was big or small
nope
@@iluvstrwbrries yep
@@iluvstrwbrries Yes and the fact that you doesn't agree doesn't change anything bcz it's true
lmao yall insane. Think of the person who got bullied and their family. Y'all are crazy thinking "its just the past"
@@lloydkim3990 the person who got bullied was Garam. Eunseo took pictures of her friend and spread them online.
Kim garam's so beautiful, unique, brave, strong, don't give up Kim Garam, I will always support you 💪💪💖👑
Kim garam her voice was so satisfying, but hearing that hybe kicked her made me sad
Garam had a friend *eun soo*(i mean bully) who spreaded fake rumours about her to destroy her life of becoming idol (*eun soo* admitted that she spreaded fake rumours) And now garam is getting bullied at school😭😭😔😭
EDIT: if you are a hater of garam dont reply me
She's all I remember when I sing this song. Her absence stings.
지금까지 고생했어요 ㅜㅜ 항상 사랑하고 응원해요 ^^
is seriously ? Then they tell her to get off the stage, to kick her out of the company and then they tell her: "We love you, I'm waiting for your debut" HOW HYPOCRITE KOREANS ARE (of course, not all but mostly) in the 21st century but you just the same time doesn't pass them
Yesterday I read on my own national internet news: There is an idol company in South Korea that deliberately manipulated the country to hate and frame Garam...
My one and only bias in Lessarafim.I miss her
논란만 아니었어도 내가 엄청 좋아했을텐데 얼굴은 예뻐가지고ㅠㅠ