Guys we are only a few 100 from hitting 5k Subscribers which is insaaaaane 🤯 please if you could take 2 seconds to hit that subscribe button to show your support 🤘💜
Big fan of both, but I personally prefer Jinjer musically. Both vocalists are just at the top of their game…and I don’t love putting them up against each other. Love both vocalists, love both bands, but Jinjer is more interesting to me personally because of how much they experiment with genres. This was a fun reaction.
@@camlloyd3321 Same here. They even know each other and I've seen them like each others' IG posts. Oh, both have videos on Loudwire's "How __ learned to scream" series too.
@Jen G, you’re here too? Awesome! I agree my friend. I love both bands and I dislike pinning them up against one another. They both bring something unique in their own way. With that said though, I do prefer Tatiana’s vocals more and I love Eugene’s bass lines. But, I feel Spiritbox has slightly better song structure when it comes to writing. The change from verse to chorus in judgement and punishment didn’t flow well and seemed forced. Still love the song though. At the end of the day, both bands are good at what they do. I’m really happy that Spiritbox is getting more exposure and opportunities. I know how much it means to them. I’m just as happy for Jinjer.
They've both got different styles of screaming, and they are both talented clean singers in their own rights. I prefer Spiritbox's music overall but Tatiana's singing is on point all the time. Tatiana's cleans are oh so good in both recorded and live versions of Jinjer's songs. Jinjer it is for me.
Love the 2 of them, but I’m a Jinjer simp. Pisces is the song that brought everyone in, but the song that made me love them is Outlander. It’s a 2014 video with some older members in it and they have 2 guitars, instead of just Roman. The song is absolutely a banger
Make sure you do the version of Outlander uploaded by failure .color. Best version by a long shot. This is early Jinjer, back when they were a 5 piece band with an extra guitarist and a different drummer. Tatiana also has dreds.
Jinjer has reached terrifying levels of talent and have become one of the most important bands today. Jinjer gets my vote hands down no questions asked.
Nice reaction you two. I like Spirit Box, but I absolutely love Jinjer. So you already know where this is going LOL 😆😆 For me Courtney is a great singer and screamer/growler, but Tatiana is on a whole different level. Again this is just my preference, and when it comes to what you enjoy . musically, no one is wrong. Keep up the great reactions you two, and as always, stay Metal. 😊🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🎶🎶🎶🎶
The live in Melbourne version of this song is amazing.Tatiana working the stage and never misses a beat.Recommend their Pit of Consciousness live Kiev in their home country Ukraine an excellent quality performance.You won’t be disappointed 🤘🏼
Jinjer is pushing the metal genre into new and exciting places, so they would get my vote. Plus only Tatiana can make the word "deficiency" sound sexy.
Here comes the hate..... I feel if you take apart the vocals of both singers, Tatiana seems to have the advantage in the range for both cleans and growls. Tati uses a much wider range of styles within the music than I have seen from Courtney. I can't crack on Courtney, she's obviously an extremely talented vocalist, Tatiana is a bit more dynamic from what I've seen.
Spiritbox is good, but Tatiana's ability to sing like an angel and a demon, plus the great instrumentation of the band, puts Jinjer number one. And her cat is so cute. Have you heard of Brothers Of Metal, ironically half the time the lead singer is a female. They sing Norse mythology based metal songs. And their Monty Python style fighting I think would be right up your alley, as in lots of blood not lots of comedy.
Actually Tatiana inspired by the band Otep. Anyways both have their own style. Musically their are in many ways a heavy metal band but in their own style of genre. As a musician myself, I personnally preferJinjer because their music is a mixture of all. Their base music is technical progressive metal but intelligently they try to mix it with jazz, raggae, pop & even R&B & they do it in a good & stylish manner. Nobody can imagine a technical proggresive metal music with a complicated beats & tempo can smoothly co-exist with raggae in a song i.e Judgement & Punishment. That needs a lot of creativity, experience, skills, talent, a good chemistry among band members & of course hard work. Vocally they are both good with their own talent.
They are both great but Courtney's growls always sound the same to me whereas Tati has a wider range with her growls and singing because they have so many different styles in their music. Jinjer will always come first for me as a whole as a band. They are all masters in their own rights 😊😌
How about Tatiana singing Holy Roller, now that would be brutal! I actually dig both, it's two different vocal styles even though they're both " screaming" they're using two different techniques for their growling. Great reaction video idea! Hope you do more. Hope you'll react to anything from Twelve Foot Ninja!
@@BreakdownMediaYT I also suggest you react to: “I Speak Astronomy (Official)”; “Retrospection (Official)”; “Pit Of Consciousness (Live At Kiev); and “Wallflower (Official).”
Tatianna from Jinjer makes it look effortless. Courtney is great but looks like she has to struggle to get out the sounds. And Tatianna clean vocals are much better
Signs of a good couple, good video, and good reactions is that I do not care for the beast mode voice, but still really enjoyed the video!! I would say I rate Jinjer just because of the range of vocal talent.
I don't dislike Spiritbox, but Courtney's growls/screams have something about them that just grate on my nerves a bit. I love her clean singing, but it's just something in her voice that makes me go meh. Tatiana on the other hand I fucking adore. I love her growls, screams, cleans, everything. Musically I very much prefer Jinjer. I can listen to either of them but I smile when Jinjer is playing.
I don't like sweet barbie tone of Tatiana's voice. Her cleans sounds like small girl not adult woman. Courtney's clean voice has so much better colour. Not soo poppy-ariana-grande-shit style. Anyway I like both bands.
This was a very weird live from Spiritbox, I've never seen this. Looked like Cortney was really struggling to sing this and felt a big pressure. Shes usuallly not like this at all. But, ofc, no matter how much i like Spiritbox, Tatiana is GOAT!
wish tati would do more 1 takes and i agree with Maul rule of nines would have been a better comparison between songs because of vocal variety. Both super talented women with super talented bands behind them but I'm biased towards jinjer indefinitely.
As whole, Jinjer is a more talented band. Seemingly. If Spiritbox got a little more creative I might be more down with them. They are just too Djent, too Core, you know. They've got some good songs tho for sure and they can hit hard. But Jinjer is on another level period. And Tatiana's cleans are just much more refined mature and virtuoso than Courtney's. Growls and screams? We'll ... Tati has her there too, but Tati is better than 90 percent of the male growlers out there. I will say that Courtney is more brutal in delivery. She comes with it hard. I like that. She'll get better too, she's quite young relatively speaking. One is a Bad ass band and one is absolutely Great! Jinjer to me is the best band to come out since Gojira. Awesome tour that would be right? Spiritbox, Jinjer and Gojira?
Both are great, but Spiritbox for me is a bit more straightforward and predictable, Jinjer is much more complex music and Tatiana is much more versatile, next level from my personal preference.
I love both bands, I could not pick one over the other. I listen to Jinjer more because they have more songs that I can relate to. Spiritbox is still very new (they just released their first album in September 2021 and an EP in 2017,) I think they are just starting to experiment and find their sound. Both Courtney and Tatiana and their bands are amazingly talent at what they do.
They are both BAD ASS! It's funny how you looked at each other like wtf 😂 I believe they both cite Otep as one of their big motivation to sing like this. Otep was bad ass back in the day. Check her out! It's too hard to pick one or the other, so they can both be my future wives 😂🤘 They both have the pipes. I wish Courtney did a lot more really heavy stuff only, like this and Hurt You. I like that Tatiana does a lot heavier stuff and more of it🤘🤘🤘🤘
I love both bands very much. I love how new Spiritbox is and all the great music that will come over time. Jinjer however is just a well rounded and seasoned band. They have more experience with performing live all round Ukraine before peeking out to the rest of us to say hey lol so I really appreciate that. They don't have that "new band" feel if you get my meaning.
Great reaction You should've done the one take performence of Rule of Nines by Spiritbox because she does both in that song ( scream/ growl and the cleans ). 🤘
Good for you mate, I like Courtney as well but she is just not on Tatiana's level for me. As far as the songs go Spiritbox has some good songs but you kind of know what you are getting before you hear it. Whereas Jinjer is "Like a box of chocolates, you never know what you're gonna get". What you do know is that it's going to be really good !
Love them both but Spiritbox is my favorite musically. I don't feel like this is fair comparison at all. Tatiana had cleans while you showcased Courtney's screams only with Holy Roller.
I’ve seen both bands live, so I really can’t pick one over the other. I know Jinjer has a larger catalog, but i hope Spiritbox keeps putting out new material when they can. When I saw Spiritbox they were being supported by another like band on the side stage, Butcher Babies. Support like this is why I love metal so much, bands like to try and support each other. 🤘
Nice reaction! Love both these bands - I think you guys would really like Spiritbox’s 3 part series of live studio performances they did for SiriusXM. The 3 part song the Mara Effect especially.
I’m gonna be real. Courtney is a damn good screamer for a chick.. Tatiana is better than 99% of pro male screamers. Cleans are better from Tatiana as well. Then the band is far more technical and up my alley. Jinjer by a landslide
@@poinsettia12 way more versatile and dynamic. Her tone is a lot better and she uses her voice in a lot more ways. Just a prettier voice in general and applies it in a more musically creative way. She might not be operatically trained but she has a great set of pipes and a great musical sense.
@@tee4222 You mean Tatiana? First of all her cleans for me sound awful, like barbie doll. Secondly none of them can belt in high register which is soooo lame if we talk about real good metal singers. Both girls, Tatiana & Courtney don't have power in their cleans... not at all.
Both absolute magicians, I think musically I'm more frequently inclined to listen to Spiritbox but Tatiana and the rest of Jinjer's range of styles is more mood dependant (although they also have music for pretty much any mood).
Absolutely love both, there shouldn't be any riff in putting any of the two down over the other. I love that that they both have distinct differences that makes them so unique. Leads and melodic tunes are different for both. Leads for Spiritbox and those slight beat changes on the drums make a whole lot of difference that an average listener wouldn't pick up on. Jinjer is amazing...I mean why pick and choose when you can have them both
2 of my favourite bands! Tati is a vocal queen and Jinjers sound is so raw and unique, although to listen to overall I’d go Spiritbox; just their sound with the little electronic aspects and the ‘bounce’ their music has is sooo good! Plus Courtney’s clean voice has that deeper more haunting tone to it which I love. The vibe of their new song Sun Killer is everything I’m taking about haha
My vote is the dog and air fanning (classic) Tatiana is close 2nd, shes one of the most versatile singers in any genre. She can sing any style of Metal,also Rnb, Pop, Reggae, Punk, Jazz, Blues and no doubt chipmunks!! Her diction when growling is very clear unlike most growlers, she can also growl at different levels. Whats most impressive about Tatiana apart from been very humble, she's has had zero vocal lessons & doesnt need to warm up before performing. Let me thrown some shit your way... 2 Japanese female metal bands Nemophila (Dissesion) and Lovebites (Thunder Vengeance Live at Zap) one of the best openings to a concert.. Lovebites are well established but in Hiatus due to member leaving. Nemophila are a new band (2019) but labeled as super group, they will be big once touring resumes.
Courtney is a straightforward metal vocalist. She is very good at what she does, but place her in any genre and she couldn't do it. Tatiana is a jazz singer who also performs metal and pop. Place her in any genre other than metal and she would still be a star.
I definitely do not agree with this. Courtney's cleans can very much fit in a pop song or alternative/hard rock track. Both vocalists are great and talented but saying that Courtney is a straightforward metal vocalist is just totally false. Both can do harsh and clean vocals perfectly although I agree with almost everyone saying Tatiana has more dynamic range
I feel like I respect Tatiana and Jinjer more than I actually like them. If I'm being honest, day to day what would I listen to more often? It's Spiritbox.
Tatiana is easily one of the best vocalists performing right now as well as the talent of the rest of the band. One of the tightest bands when it comes to technicality and performance.
Well, I would like to throw a third competitor in the ring: Vintersea with their 'Slay at home' performance. It's kinda one take as well and Avienne's vocals play in the same league as these two ladies here.
Another great reaction 🙌🏻 IMO I enjoy both of this girls but I think, on a normal day, I will listen Jinjer before Spiritbox, but eventually I will end listening to Spiritbox... It's hard to choose just one xD So... Why not both? BTW! You should react to Trivium "The Phalanx" 🙌🏻😄 That would be great 👌🏻
Love both ladies! It would have been a better "comparison" if you chose a Spiritbox one vocal take that featured more of Courtney's range (like "Blessed Be"). But both women are extremely talented.
Build up, you say? Need to check out Wallflower by Jinjer. I would say Spiritbox. BUT to be fair, I love Tati as a singer and a songwriter. Jinjer as a band are their own genre honestly. I can listen to Spiritbox anytime. Jinjer I can as well, though I like to listen to them when I can give the music my full attention, especially the new record.
As far as music goes (all their music, not just these two songs) I'd say I enjoy Spiritbox more. I dont think they have a song I dont like. Whereas Jinjer, they have a few songs I dont care for. Then again Jinjer has been around longer so they have more music to judge. So maybe over time I'll find some Spiritbox songs I dont like. But as of right now, Spiritbox has better music overall. As for the skill of vocalists, I think it goes without saying that Tatiana of Jinjer is more talented. Dont get me wrong, Courtney is amazing too. But in terms of sheer skill, Tatiana just has a stronger, more powerful voice. If you watch a lot of their performances, you can tell the vocals don't wear Tatiana down like they do Courtney. Courtney takes more effort. Tatiana has stronger vocals in both cleans and growls but especially cleans. So in terms of which vocalist is better, I think its undoubtedly, objectively Tatiana.
If you want to do the male equivalent head to head try - one take vocals of - Will Ramos (Lorna Shore) - To the Hellfire and Justin Bonita (Tallah) - Overconfident.
I absolutely love both of these artists. Both are unique however Tatiana has just been doing this longer and has alot more clarity between the 2 takes. Listened to Courtney when she stepped in for iwrestledabearonce before forming Spiritbox and love her in her own band but this year they may take over the scene!
Both are epic and both are kicking ass professionally. Spiritbox was doing one-takes first, and I'm guessing that's why Tati did the one-take during lockdown to get some buzz out there since they couldn't tour and there weren't tons of bootlegs flooding youtube. Spiritbox doesn't tour as much so the one-take format is great for getting people a taste of Courney's live vocal chops. I suspect now that they have a label instead of mostly being indie they may have more pro-shot live videos once touring is more of a thing.
Guys we are only a few 100 from hitting 5k Subscribers which is insaaaaane 🤯 please if you could take 2 seconds to hit that subscribe button to show your support 🤘💜
Big fan of both, but I personally prefer Jinjer musically. Both vocalists are just at the top of their game…and I don’t love putting them up against each other. Love both vocalists, love both bands, but Jinjer is more interesting to me personally because of how much they experiment with genres. This was a fun reaction.
Thank you we appreciate it! 💜
I was going to write basically the same thing Jen said...so yeah what she said.
@@camlloyd3321 Same here. They even know each other and I've seen them like each others' IG posts. Oh, both have videos on Loudwire's "How __ learned to scream" series too.
Agreed on all counts.
@Jen G, you’re here too? Awesome! I agree my friend. I love both bands and I dislike pinning them up against one another. They both bring something unique in their own way. With that said though, I do prefer Tatiana’s vocals more and I love Eugene’s bass lines. But, I feel Spiritbox has slightly better song structure when it comes to writing. The change from verse to chorus in judgement and punishment didn’t flow well and seemed forced. Still love the song though. At the end of the day, both bands are good at what they do. I’m really happy that Spiritbox is getting more exposure and opportunities. I know how much it means to them. I’m just as happy for Jinjer.
Jinjer.
Jinjer! Jinjer!!!
They've both got different styles of screaming, and they are both talented clean singers in their own rights. I prefer Spiritbox's music overall but Tatiana's singing is on point all the time. Tatiana's cleans are oh so good in both recorded and live versions of Jinjer's songs. Jinjer it is for me.
100% 🤘
Love the 2 of them, but I’m a Jinjer simp. Pisces is the song that brought everyone in, but the song that made me love them is Outlander. It’s a 2014 video with some older members in it and they have 2 guitars, instead of just Roman. The song is absolutely a banger
Ooooo not heard it, added to the list 💜
Make sure you do the version of Outlander uploaded by failure .color. Best version by a long shot. This is early Jinjer, back when they were a 5 piece band with an extra guitarist and a different drummer. Tatiana also has dreds.
I don't belong to this RACE! NOR TO THIS PLANET... NOR TO THIS GALAXY!!!
Pisces brought in alot of fans but there was alot of Jinjer fans before that video. I heard Just Another awhile before the Pisces video blew up
🤘Jinjer🤘
Jinjer has reached terrifying levels of talent and have become one of the most important bands today. Jinjer gets my vote hands down no questions asked.
"terrifying levels of talent" is up there with "I hate it when a Jinjer song ends" and "that was as unexpected as my first child"
Nice reaction you two. I like Spirit Box, but I absolutely love Jinjer. So you already know where this is going LOL 😆😆 For me Courtney is a great singer and screamer/growler, but Tatiana is on a whole different level. Again this is just my preference, and when it comes to what you enjoy . musically, no one is wrong. Keep up the great reactions you two, and as always, stay Metal. 😊🤘🤘🤘🤘🤘🎶🎶🎶🎶
Excellent attitude and ALWAYS stay metal 🤘
If it was a contest - I would vote for Jinjer. Hands down.
Jinjer
I love both but Jinjer all the waaayyy!!
The live in Melbourne version of this song is amazing.Tatiana working the stage and never misses a beat.Recommend their Pit of Consciousness live Kiev in their home country Ukraine an excellent quality performance.You won’t be disappointed 🤘🏼
Thank you!
@@BreakdownMediaYT subscribed for Jinjer.Tatiana is a total badass on stage
Jinjer is pushing the metal genre into new and exciting places, so they would get my vote. Plus only Tatiana can make the word "deficiency" sound sexy.
Extremely accurate 🤣
dont forget "Skittish"!
Here comes the hate..... I feel if you take apart the vocals of both singers, Tatiana seems to have the advantage in the range for both cleans and growls. Tati uses a much wider range of styles within the music than I have seen from Courtney. I can't crack on Courtney, she's obviously an extremely talented vocalist, Tatiana is a bit more dynamic from what I've seen.
No need for any hate, you have a valid opinion 🤘
Spiritbox is good, but Tatiana's ability to sing like an angel and a demon, plus the great instrumentation of the band, puts Jinjer number one. And her cat is so cute. Have you heard of Brothers Of Metal, ironically half the time the lead singer is a female. They sing Norse mythology based metal songs. And their Monty Python style fighting I think would be right up your alley, as in lots of blood not lots of comedy.
The cat was the main deciding point not gonna lie 🤣
The cat is called Mr. Pepino and it belongs to Tatiana's boyfriend/husband (I don't know which anymore), not her. ; )
@@module79l28 That's too bad. Oh well it's still cute, whosever it is.
The low growl of Tati are insane
Actually Tatiana inspired by the band Otep. Anyways both have their own style. Musically their are in many ways a heavy metal band but in their own style of genre. As a musician myself, I personnally preferJinjer because their music is a mixture of all. Their base music is technical progressive metal but intelligently they try to mix it with jazz, raggae, pop & even R&B & they do it in a good & stylish manner. Nobody can imagine a technical proggresive metal music with a complicated beats & tempo can smoothly co-exist with raggae in a song i.e Judgement & Punishment. That needs a lot of creativity, experience, skills, talent, a good chemistry among band members & of course hard work. Vocally they are both good with their own talent.
Love them both, but I’m in the Tatiana camp if I have to choose 🤘🤘🤘
Respect both their talents 🙏
Tati is a Ukranian boss lady powerhouse QUEEN
And the Winner is.. Tatiana.. 😅 🇺🇦 😎 🤯... Reakt to oldscool jinjer outlander 2014 failor color!!
We will! Subscribe to be notified when we do 🔥
If you like the buildup and switch-ups, try Jinjer's new video 'Wallflower'.
Yes never thought it, but this is has actually gone in my Top 5 Jinjer songs. And Bonus, the Children sing along when we hear it in the car
They are both great but Courtney's growls always sound the same to me whereas Tati has a wider range with her growls and singing because they have so many different styles in their music. Jinjer will always come first for me as a whole as a band. They are all masters in their own rights 😊😌
jinjer is in the league of its own....untouchable
Tati hands down. Too much talent and versatility. Though I do love the Spiritbox ambience.
lol
How about Tatiana singing Holy Roller, now that would be brutal! I actually dig both, it's two different vocal styles even though they're both " screaming" they're using two different techniques for their growling. Great reaction video idea! Hope you do more. Hope you'll react to anything from Twelve Foot Ninja!
Great reaction :) you should try "Teacher Teacher" the official video from Jinjer. It's my favorite song and i bet my ass you'll love it!
That is certainly going to be added to the list, thank you
Jinjer all day
Tati..... 100%
Good choice 🔥
lol easily jinjer........better cleans, better growls, better screams, better musicianship.......and i like spiritbox lol.
For the next reaction JINJER - Perennial (Live at Wacken Open Air 2019) pleasss...
And also Perennial from Spiritbox !
It’s in the list 💜
@@BreakdownMediaYT I also suggest you react to: “I Speak Astronomy (Official)”; “Retrospection (Official)”; “Pit Of Consciousness (Live At Kiev); and “Wallflower (Official).”
Tatianna from Jinjer makes it look effortless. Courtney is great but looks like she has to struggle to get out the sounds. And Tatianna clean vocals are much better
Tatiana in her heavy vocal is far easier to understand what she is saying.
Signs of a good couple, good video, and good reactions is that I do not care for the beast mode voice, but still really enjoyed the video!! I would say I rate Jinjer just because of the range of vocal talent.
Haha thank you Zodiac 💜
Tati has so much more control and diction.
All hail Queen TaTi!!
I don't dislike Spiritbox, but Courtney's growls/screams have something about them that just grate on my nerves a bit. I love her clean singing, but it's just something in her voice that makes me go meh. Tatiana on the other hand I fucking adore. I love her growls, screams, cleans, everything. Musically I very much prefer Jinjer. I can listen to either of them but I smile when Jinjer is playing.
Exactly my thought. You took the words out of my mouth 😀🤘
I don't like sweet barbie tone of Tatiana's voice. Her cleans sounds like small girl not adult woman. Courtney's clean voice has so much better colour. Not soo poppy-ariana-grande-shit style.
Anyway I like both bands.
@@poinsettia12 for me its the other way around. love the variety of Tatis clean voice and her Growls is just of another dimension
@@frankhermansen243 Because you are a man so you like sweet poppy female voice. It's all connected with sexuality😝
@@poinsettia12 the other way Around... like I dont think Tatis voice is poppy. figure the rest out 😁
Tatiana alllllll the way
Freakn AMAZING 👏 👏 👏
This was a very weird live from Spiritbox, I've never seen this. Looked like Cortney was really struggling to sing this and felt a big pressure. Shes usuallly not like this at all. But, ofc, no matter how much i like Spiritbox, Tatiana is GOAT!
wish tati would do more 1 takes and i agree with Maul rule of nines would have been a better comparison between songs because of vocal variety. Both super talented women with super talented bands behind them but I'm biased towards jinjer indefinitely.
I would LOVE more Tati 1 takes 🔥
Tatiana best of the best 👍🤘
🤘🤘🤘
Taitana is a goddess,jinjer handsdown..
🔥
Check out Jinjer - Vortex or Home Back if you want to hear Tatiana go deep.
Also, Retrospection- Live in Melbourne is outstanding
Love both bands but it’s Jinjer for me 🤘🏽
🤘🔥
Jiner is the 🐐
Spiritbox is amazing, but Jinjer is hands down on another level…imo. Jinjer FTW!!! Great reaction btw! 🍻
Yes Jinjer ftw & thank you 💜
I really feel like the comparison is unnecessary
@@leviathan3630 Perhaps so…there’s not a right or wrong answer, merely preference 🍻
you NEED to check out "Perennial live at Wacken"..Tati is such a showman..suuuper talented band, and yet, she STILL shines
Love them both, but Tatiana is in a League of her own. No one can touch her vocals
Agreed
Colour of her clean voice sucks.
@@poinsettia12 you’re allowed to be wrong, it’s ok.
@@cdesha Problems with other people taste?:D
There is no (antagonistic) competition, they are both BRUTAL QUEENS!
HOO!! 🐺🔥🤘🏾
Jinjer 100%
Good choice 👍
Jinjer, always Jinjer
As whole, Jinjer is a more talented band. Seemingly. If Spiritbox got a little more creative I might be more down with them. They are just too Djent, too Core, you know. They've got some good songs tho for sure and they can hit hard. But Jinjer is on another level period. And Tatiana's cleans are just much more refined mature and virtuoso than Courtney's. Growls and screams? We'll ... Tati has her there too, but Tati is better than 90 percent of the male growlers out there. I will say that Courtney is more brutal in delivery. She comes with it hard. I like that. She'll get better too, she's quite young relatively speaking. One is a Bad ass band and one is absolutely Great! Jinjer to me is the best band to come out since Gojira. Awesome tour that would be right? Spiritbox, Jinjer and Gojira?
Both are great, but Spiritbox for me is a bit more straightforward and predictable, Jinjer is much more complex music and Tatiana is much more versatile, next level from my personal preference.
I found this 2 bands in this weekend, amazing the vocal/gutural ... the mara effect - Spiritbox and Pit Of Consciousness - JINJER really cool
I love both bands, I could not pick one over the other. I listen to Jinjer more because they have more songs that I can relate to. Spiritbox is still very new (they just released their first album in September 2021 and an EP in 2017,) I think they are just starting to experiment and find their sound. Both Courtney and Tatiana and their bands are amazingly talent at what they do.
They are both BAD ASS! It's funny how you looked at each other like wtf 😂 I believe they both cite Otep as one of their big motivation to sing like this. Otep was bad ass back in the day. Check her out!
It's too hard to pick one or the other, so they can both be my future wives 😂🤘 They both have the pipes. I wish Courtney did a lot more really heavy stuff only, like this and Hurt You. I like that Tatiana does a lot heavier stuff and more of it🤘🤘🤘🤘
They are both fucking bad asses 🔥
You 2 are so cute - just bing watched a few of your reactions
Wow, thank you for the support we really appreciate it 💜
Jinjer and Tati all day
Big fan of both, no need for competition
So are we, but what’s wrong with friendly competition if you can appreciate both?
jinjer
Good choice 👍
Jinjer all the way 🤘🏻
Fuck yeah 🔥
JINJER >>>>>>>> all the bands
Raggae-Metal? See Skindred - "nobody" Its an absolute classic
Never heard that suggestion could be interesting 🔥 👀
Tatiana just sings so well it's hard not to pick her , if you judge just the screams it'd be closer but as a total package she's different
She is a beast 🔥
I love both bands very much. I love how new Spiritbox is and all the great music that will come over time. Jinjer however is just a well rounded and seasoned band. They have more experience with performing live all round Ukraine before peeking out to the rest of us to say hey lol so I really appreciate that. They don't have that "new band" feel if you get my meaning.
Great reaction
You should've done the one take performence of Rule of Nines by Spiritbox because she does both in that song ( scream/ growl and the cleans ). 🤘
We would but we have already reacted to it on our channel!
@@BreakdownMediaYT Oops. Sorry , i forgot 🖤
The winner is all of us!!!!
Courtney's awesome, but Tatiana's the queen. Spiritbox is cool, but Jinjer rules.
Common theme atm!
Jinjer, duh
Jinjer....Always Jinjer 🤘
Fuck yeah 🤘
Tati and the boys are a force to be reckon with in this industry for sure!
Love them both. Different styles.
Exactly, we appreciate both 🤘
they got a full band one take songs for a radio.. i think you guys would enjoy it
Can’t wait to watch! 🔥
Jinjer.... not even close
Good for you mate, I like Courtney as well but she is just not on Tatiana's level for me. As far as the songs go Spiritbox has some good songs but you kind of know what you are getting before you hear it. Whereas Jinjer is "Like a box of chocolates, you never know what you're gonna get". What you do know is that it's going to be really good !
100% agree
Love them both but Spiritbox is my favorite musically. I don't feel like this is fair comparison at all. Tatiana had cleans while you showcased Courtney's screams only with Holy Roller.
jinjer by far
I’ve seen both bands live, so I really can’t pick one over the other. I know Jinjer has a larger catalog, but i hope Spiritbox keeps putting out new material when they can. When I saw Spiritbox they were being supported by another like band on the side stage, Butcher Babies. Support like this is why I love metal so much, bands like to try and support each other. 🤘
Exactly and we can only hope that our reaction videos help people discover such amazing bands!
Nice reaction! Love both these bands - I think you guys would really like Spiritbox’s 3 part series of live studio performances they did for SiriusXM. The 3 part song the Mara Effect especially.
We have Pt.1 on our list so keep your eyes peeled and sub to know when its live!
@@BreakdownMediaYT Spiritbox - The Mara Effect live at Silverside Sound, that will blow your minds!! would love to see a reaction to that :)
My heart and mind is with Tatiana, even though I love Courtney's vocals so much.
Spiritbox is good. But I vote for Tatiana, more range,more interesting.
I’m gonna be real. Courtney is a damn good screamer for a chick.. Tatiana is better than 99% of pro male screamers. Cleans are better from Tatiana as well. Then the band is far more technical and up my alley. Jinjer by a landslide
True!
Cleans are better in which way? Let's start with the fact none of them are good clean vocalist:D they are both in medium levels of skills.
@@poinsettia12 way more versatile and dynamic. Her tone is a lot better and she uses her voice in a lot more ways. Just a prettier voice in general and applies it in a more musically creative way. She might not be operatically trained but she has a great set of pipes and a great musical sense.
@@tee4222 You mean Tatiana? First of all her cleans for me sound awful, like barbie doll. Secondly none of them can belt in high register which is soooo lame if we talk about real good metal singers. Both girls, Tatiana & Courtney don't have power in their cleans... not at all.
Both absolute magicians, I think musically I'm more frequently inclined to listen to Spiritbox but Tatiana and the rest of Jinjer's range of styles is more mood dependant (although they also have music for pretty much any mood).
Very true!
Absolutely love both, there shouldn't be any riff in putting any of the two down over the other. I love that that they both have distinct differences that makes them so unique. Leads and melodic tunes are different for both. Leads for Spiritbox and those slight beat changes on the drums make a whole lot of difference that an average listener wouldn't pick up on. Jinjer is amazing...I mean why pick and choose when you can have them both
We love them both, but nothing wrong with friendly competition right?
2 of my favourite bands! Tati is a vocal queen and Jinjers sound is so raw and unique, although to listen to overall I’d go Spiritbox; just their sound with the little electronic aspects and the ‘bounce’ their music has is sooo good! Plus Courtney’s clean voice has that deeper more haunting tone to it which I love. The vibe of their new song Sun Killer is everything I’m taking about haha
My vote is the dog and air fanning (classic) Tatiana is close 2nd, shes one of the most versatile singers in any genre. She can sing any style of Metal,also Rnb, Pop, Reggae, Punk, Jazz, Blues and no doubt chipmunks!! Her diction when growling is very clear unlike most growlers, she can also growl at different levels. Whats most impressive about Tatiana apart from been very humble, she's has had zero vocal lessons & doesnt need to warm up before performing.
Let me thrown some shit your way... 2 Japanese female metal bands Nemophila (Dissesion) and Lovebites (Thunder Vengeance Live at Zap) one of the best openings to a concert.. Lovebites are well established but in Hiatus due to member leaving. Nemophila are a new band (2019) but labeled as super group, they will be big once touring resumes.
Dog fanning ftw 🙏🤘
Courtney is a straightforward metal vocalist. She is very good at what she does, but place her in any genre and she couldn't do it.
Tatiana is a jazz singer who also performs metal and pop. Place her in any genre other than metal and she would still be a star.
I do agree with that tbf!
I definitely do not agree with this. Courtney's cleans can very much fit in a pop song or alternative/hard rock track. Both vocalists are great and talented but saying that Courtney is a straightforward metal vocalist is just totally false. Both can do harsh and clean vocals perfectly although I agree with almost everyone saying Tatiana has more dynamic range
I think Courtney can do well in symphonic.
I feel like I respect Tatiana and Jinjer more than I actually like them. If I'm being honest, day to day what would I listen to more often? It's Spiritbox.
I like the honesty!
Tatiana is easily one of the best vocalists performing right now as well as the talent of the rest of the band. One of the tightest bands when it comes to technicality and performance.
Well, I would like to throw a third competitor in the ring: Vintersea with their 'Slay at home' performance.
It's kinda one take as well and Avienne's vocals play in the same league as these two ladies here.
We may have already recorded a Vintersea video and we are waiting to post it 👀 make sure you’re subbed so you see when it’s live 🔥
Awesome reaction.. btw both Jinjer and Spiritbox have a song called Perennial.. please do a double feature of those!
Ooooo good idea, we like it!
Another great reaction 🙌🏻 IMO I enjoy both of this girls but I think, on a normal day, I will listen Jinjer before Spiritbox, but eventually I will end listening to Spiritbox... It's hard to choose just one xD So... Why not both?
BTW! You should react to Trivium "The Phalanx" 🙌🏻😄 That would be great 👌🏻
Thank you so much 🙏
Love both ladies! It would have been a better "comparison" if you chose a Spiritbox one vocal take that featured more of Courtney's range (like "Blessed Be"). But both women are extremely talented.
We both agree 🔥
Build up, you say? Need to check out Wallflower by Jinjer. I would say Spiritbox. BUT to be fair, I love Tati as a singer and a songwriter. Jinjer as a band are their own genre honestly. I can listen to Spiritbox anytime. Jinjer I can as well, though I like to listen to them when I can give the music my full attention, especially the new record.
As far as music goes (all their music, not just these two songs) I'd say I enjoy Spiritbox more. I dont think they have a song I dont like. Whereas Jinjer, they have a few songs I dont care for. Then again Jinjer has been around longer so they have more music to judge. So maybe over time I'll find some Spiritbox songs I dont like. But as of right now, Spiritbox has better music overall.
As for the skill of vocalists, I think it goes without saying that Tatiana of Jinjer is more talented. Dont get me wrong, Courtney is amazing too. But in terms of sheer skill, Tatiana just has a stronger, more powerful voice. If you watch a lot of their performances, you can tell the vocals don't wear Tatiana down like they do Courtney. Courtney takes more effort. Tatiana has stronger vocals in both cleans and growls but especially cleans. So in terms of which vocalist is better, I think its undoubtedly, objectively Tatiana.
If you want to do the male equivalent head to head try - one take vocals of - Will Ramos (Lorna Shore) - To the Hellfire and Justin Bonita (Tallah) - Overconfident.
We have already reacted to Lorna Shore, head over to our channel if you want to see the reaction
I absolutely love both of these artists. Both are unique however Tatiana has just been doing this longer and has alot more clarity between the 2 takes. Listened to Courtney when she stepped in for iwrestledabearonce before forming Spiritbox and love her in her own band but this year they may take over the scene!
I like Spiritbox’s overall sound much more, and I love Jinjer, but Tati’s vocals are top notch.
Both are epic and both are kicking ass professionally. Spiritbox was doing one-takes first, and I'm guessing that's why Tati did the one-take during lockdown to get some buzz out there since they couldn't tour and there weren't tons of bootlegs flooding youtube. Spiritbox doesn't tour as much so the one-take format is great for getting people a taste of Courney's live vocal chops. I suspect now that they have a label instead of mostly being indie they may have more pro-shot live videos once touring is more of a thing.
The one take ideas are truly genius, some of our favourite content to react to
Fan of both 🤘🤘