Not only is that part in girls where NingNing goes “real my WOO-OoO-oOo-orld” an amazing high note from her, it also requires a lot of vocal agility. The part where Winter just scream “Navis on the real my WOOOOOORLD!“ is comparatively much much easier. NN’s the main vocal for a reason.
No it doesn’t really require a lot of vocal agility tbh. It’s still harder than the real my world, but NingNing has way better agility than just that „real my world“ run.
Winter has some potential in supporting her head voice And i see she needs to work on her lows a lot Her mix register is quite impressive but she still needs to work on not to push her notes And about ning2 her lows Her light mix stops her to do more but i think she is improving And i wish for her upper register more material
It's hard to determine with both of them how much their techniques are coming from SM, BUT I think both Winter and NingNing need what the other has. If Winter can smooth out her belts and NingNing can project more powerfully, it would be nice to get another TaengSic.
Comparison doesn't make sense obviously Ningning is the best in everything, you should do Giselle and karina since they are basically on the same level or karina and winter since karina's lower register is better than winter
@@paledangels you've said it yourself it's outside her supported range aka she can't support it, everyone can hit it , I can hit it too, many can but supporting it is something completely different, that's what makes a better vocalist from another the supported ranges, Ningning can supported it easily winter can't, Ningning can support extremely well in the lower register actually she's the best in SM in this, she's better in the mixed register and upper rigester , and she's very good at belting, winter is below her in all of those and she's not consistent nor is she developed that's why her voice turns nasal just by hitting C5, she can't support it the higher register , simple, like Lily from NMIXX she can hit A7 but she can't support it so it's not included in her supported range simple
Being a main vocalist isn't just about high notes plus Winter projects better. Ningning gets all the harder stuff like runs. You people really need to get off of that already.
It's not just about high notes, it's about the execution and the delivery of the notes/lines, which Ningning excels than Winter. While I see a bit of favortism on Winter, but Ningning is objectively better at controlling her vocals.
@@brooke278 well winter deserved it and slayed it . I dont care of anything else😚 and in some points winter is better than ning but yall are not ready for this . Ning is not always the best in all parts / points🙄
Winter's G3 isn't supported, it's quite muffled. Ningning's Eb3 is very obviously low larynx lol. Winter's C5 and C#5 are both too tense and narrow. Ningning's D5 and Eb5 are too light and lack that grounded quality...there's tension going on as well but it's diluted by the overly heady mixing. You need to understand that not straining isn't the same as supporting. I wouldn't give Ningning's E5 and F#5 a pass either, it's way too light and almost falsetto-esque in quality.
@João Gabriel Rodrigues Souza The change in quality when she dipped into the Eb3 is very obvious actually, that's a very textbook example of low larynx with decent connection and projection. We're going to agree to disagree on this one.
Imo Winter belts carry more weight and have better coordination until B4, above that NingNing takes over. NingNing projection, tone production and connection are all better than Winter down to her lower register already from Bb3. Winter didnt rlly showcase a pure head voice, NingNing on the other hand did(even tho its pretty thin and has no live material)
Actually winter high notes are sometimes annoying in some songs like girls I think that ningning high notes was more natural I think that winter is really nasal sometimes it ended good like seulgi and sometimes fake like Rosie but I like all of them
![Gunna - one of wun [Official Video]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/w_JtBYqMgk8/mqdefault.jpg)
Ning ning is such a good main vocal!! She is soo versatile
Ningning lows are so good
Yes she is the best lows of 4 gen!
Her lower register is amazing
Most developed low register in the 4th gen
Not only is that part in girls where NingNing goes “real my WOO-OoO-oOo-orld” an amazing high note from her, it also requires a lot of vocal agility. The part where Winter just scream “Navis on the real my WOOOOOORLD!“ is comparatively much much easier. NN’s the main vocal for a reason.
No it doesn’t really require a lot of vocal agility tbh. It’s still harder than the real my world, but NingNing has way better agility than just that „real my world“ run.
it is more difficult to produce a clean sound for a long time without any trill 😔
Its not easy
@@JoelYie no ningning's part is still harder
Ningning Queen of vocal
Winter has some potential in supporting her head voice
And i see she needs to work on her lows a lot
Her mix register is quite impressive but she still needs to work on not to push her notes
And about ning2 her lows
Her light mix stops her to do more but i think she is improving
And i wish for her upper register more material
NingNing even sm give her main vocalist position，so why comparison this make no sense ！
It's hard to determine with both of them how much their techniques are coming from SM, BUT I think both Winter and NingNing need what the other has. If Winter can smooth out her belts and NingNing can project more powerfully, it would be nice to get another TaengSic.
Anyone with clear ears knows that Ningning is the best not just in aespa but in the entire 4th generation
Ningning high and low notes is just wow ❤️🔥❤️🔥
Comparison doesn't make sense obviously Ningning is the best in everything, you should do Giselle and karina since they are basically on the same level or karina and winter since karina's lower register is better than winter
Just a video with purpose of showing their recently updated supported notes. I made a video Karina vs Giselle before and now it is the maknaes' turn
Not everything. Ningning ruined the Cochella stage and her live performance is bad many times
Both is MY Queens 👑👑
Winters C#5s dont sound supported
winter has better C5 in black mamba than step back tbh, sounded too tight and tense to me
That'sbecause she can't support C5 yet simple
@@eulalia3468 she can, it's just outside her usual supported range
@@paledangels what you've said is exactly what I've said , she can't support C5
@@eulalia3468 but she can..???? it's just once or twice she's not at all consistent with it but she CAN
@@paledangels you've said it yourself it's outside her supported range aka she can't support it, everyone can hit it , I can hit it too, many can but supporting it is something completely different, that's what makes a better vocalist from another the supported ranges, Ningning can supported it easily winter can't, Ningning can support extremely well in the lower register actually she's the best in SM in this, she's better in the mixed register and upper rigester , and she's very good at belting, winter is below her in all of those and she's not consistent nor is she developed that's why her voice turns nasal just by hitting C5, she can't support it the higher register , simple, like Lily from NMIXX she can hit A7 but she can't support it so it's not included in her supported range simple
yet sm still gives winter more high notes than ningning
Being a main vocalist isn't just about high notes plus Winter projects better. Ningning gets all the harder stuff like runs. You people really need to get off of that already.
They still need to give the high notes to Ningning, winter's high notes hurt ears...
Cuz she nailed it and she deserved it 👑😚❤️
It's not just about high notes, it's about the execution and the delivery of the notes/lines, which Ningning excels than Winter. While I see a bit of favortism on Winter, but Ningning is objectively better at controlling her vocals.
@@brooke278 well winter deserved it and slayed it . I dont care of anything else😚 and in some points winter is better than ning but yall are not ready for this . Ning is not always the best in all parts / points🙄
Ningning firever💜
Why NingNing vs Winter? Why not Karina vs Winter? NingNing is stronger than Winter in every vocal expect
Just a video with purpose of showing their recently updated supported notes. I made a video Karina vs Giselle before and now it is the maknaes' turn
Winter is stronger than Karina in all register too
@@reenfocus4493 I got to say Karina has better lower register
@@aevokall Yeah, I forgot she is pretty consistent in G#3/A3, still winter is overall stronger vocalist than karina.
Because they are the main vocal and lead vocal in aespa i think?
F3 với E3 của bé Win gần như tàng hình luôn 😅
Can I ask you to do ningning vs lily. I want to know more about thier voices plus thier range, thanks for the good video
I don't listen to Lily cause following aespa just takes all my time, I have to say I barely know anything vocally about the other girls except aespa
low:ning
belt/mix:lily
headvoice:lily
@@vyeagra420 also agility ningning
@@missprettyvioletaj6220 not rlly
@@missprettyvioletaj6220 you wish, Technique = Lily
Winter's G3 isn't supported, it's quite muffled. Ningning's Eb3 is very obviously low larynx lol.
Winter's C5 and C#5 are both too tense and narrow. Ningning's D5 and Eb5 are too light and lack that grounded quality...there's tension going on as well but it's diluted by the overly heady mixing. You need to understand that not straining isn't the same as supporting.
I wouldn't give Ningning's E5 and F#5 a pass either, it's way too light and almost falsetto-esque in quality.
@João Gabriel Rodrigues Souza The change in quality when she dipped into the Eb3 is very obvious actually, that's a very textbook example of low larynx with decent connection and projection. We're going to agree to disagree on this one.
nah that Eb3 sounds good,plus a sop has to lower her larynx for a note low as Eb3
@@vyeagra420they start to low at G3, you are right
Why don't you put ningNings predebut clip Run to here then you will know who is winner
Gosto da voz da Ningning
Imo Winter belts carry more weight and have better coordination until B4, above that NingNing takes over.
NingNing projection, tone production and connection are all better than Winter down to her lower register already from Bb3.
Winter didnt rlly showcase a pure head voice, NingNing on the other hand did(even tho its pretty thin and has no live material)
Old que ning né mores
Actually winter high notes are sometimes annoying in some songs like girls I think that ningning high notes was more natural I think that winter is really nasal sometimes it ended good like seulgi and sometimes fake like Rosie but I like all of them
the intro 😭
0:57 isn’t that G3 low larynx?
she just used more chest voice than the airy style she usually uses. I do not hear any tension or muffled sound with that G3
Winter 🎉
Any improvement from kamp la ??
unfortunately not
Winter belts in 4th octave >>>
Ningning better but I like theres something about the way winters voice sounds that I like more
How low can winter support?
(G#3)A3/B3 is I think her consistent one
Bb3 consistently and G#3 at her best.
She is consistent with A3s and quite a lot of G#3s but still airy, G3 is her lowest supported notes
Winter's vocals is my favorite>>>>>>>
Ning Ning vocals my favourite and that's why she's main vocalist 🥰❤️
@@Fishy_flops. i dont care . Let me praise my fave
@@dareenabuhmeidan2286 I don't care too let me praise my fave 🥰👑❤️
@@Fishy_flops. u can praise your fave in your own comment not in my OWN COMMENT 🙃
NINGNING❤
Winter is the best ❤ i love her voice more ❤
I still prefer winter's voice over ningning tbh 🤷♀️
Winter is my type 💙❄️
Winter >>>>>>
that B4 from ningning did not sound good,throaty
it wasn't well placed but it wasn't throaty at all
@@hiaz4974 It really was.