@@eddyjacx5622 she can.. she hit one in the savage encore and she did in this video too what 😂 she was taught in china and her mother and grandmother are professional singers too. I’m kpop strong loud piercing belts are the style and she did it in savage perfectly but she wont do them regularly bc that’s not how people sing in china
@@eddyjacx5622 you can tell ningning is a professional singer not a kpop singer by the way her high notes and light and her lows and extremely developed
@@Kimnabi123 Extremely developed lows? Not at all. They're fine for a modern kpop singer but it's nothing special. Uji, Eunji, Wendy, Hyolyn can all beat her there, and those aren't even the strongest chest voices in pop music by a long shot lol. Her high notes aren't bad per se, but they aren't strong either. Even someone like Lily has a palpably better developed belting technique, and Lily can't be compared to the true chesty belters either lol. Good belts aren't "piercing," they've full and open, and NN's best are still way too light to be described with those adjectives. It's quite a bit less impressive than higher A-AAs like Kei or Swan.
so her supported range must be G3-C5/C#5(D5)-E5/F5?? Anyways, im happy that NingNing is being able to upgrade her vocal everyday since her SMRookie days
@ilovebeomgyu3947 I agree with the head voice part, but giving her G3 ~ C5 is kind of too harsh. She has sung many supported F#3s since debut and even before when she was younger. Her consistency on C#5 is arguable, and it actually doesn't make any difference, but she barely has any bad attempts. Even though the quality is different in comparison to her C5s, I'd personally say it's fair to give her C5/C#5.
@@queenning28 it isn't intense as Wendy version of this song. She used heady mix a whole C5-F#5 & sound very tense Ningning used headvoice coordination, very light at that, not even full headvoice. There is a sustain D5 she dodged by using headvoice too 3:12 soft headvoice
That is headvoice coordination, Ningning's E5 & F5 heady mix is quite tight & intense Her F5 is even thinner than normal headvoice like this ruclips.net/video/61n3tPBjjmU/видео.html I agree Ningning's Eb5 is not overly tight or throaty
@@aevokall I don't think so. she does have decent development even until D5/Eb5 ish but her problem was never about her support it's within her approach.
aespa vocal tiers: 1. ningning C+ (not B- since she doesn’t have resonance qualities) 2. winter C (she’s been improving and even supported a C#5) 3. giselle D+ (she’s now consistent with Bb4 but still shallow) 4. karina D+ (she’s not fully consistent with Bb4 [A4/Bb4])
![Something Like That [Cover by. Ningning] Romanization Lyrics & English Translation](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/GvnHgeitYb8/mqdefault.jpg)
![Something Like That [Cover by. Ningning] Romanization Lyrics & English Translation](/img/tr.png)
her mix is so light i didnt even realize how high she was going most of the time
because she has good technique. she doesn’t force strong belts
@@Kimnabi123She can't do strong belts, at all. Avoiding them isn't a technical skill as much as it is lack of development.
@@eddyjacx5622 she can.. she hit one in the savage encore and she did in this video too what 😂 she was taught in china and her mother and grandmother are professional singers too. I’m kpop strong loud piercing belts are the style and she did it in savage perfectly but she wont do them regularly bc that’s not how people sing in china
@@eddyjacx5622 you can tell ningning is a professional singer not a kpop singer by the way her high notes and light and her lows and extremely developed
@@Kimnabi123 Extremely developed lows? Not at all. They're fine for a modern kpop singer but it's nothing special. Uji, Eunji, Wendy, Hyolyn can all beat her there, and those aren't even the strongest chest voices in pop music by a long shot lol. Her high notes aren't bad per se, but they aren't strong either. Even someone like Lily has a palpably better developed belting technique, and Lily can't be compared to the true chesty belters either lol. Good belts aren't "piercing," they've full and open, and NN's best are still way too light to be described with those adjectives. It's quite a bit less impressive than higher A-AAs like Kei or Swan.
her D5 sounds good
Beautiful voice Ningning ❤
You have so much material to analyze nowadays 🤗 happy to see updates
She really has good vocal runs kinda rare in kpop
닝닝 보컬 최고네 ❤
느기으드즈지ㅡㄴᆞㄷㅈ습으
그시드
I understand nothing y'all are talking about in the comments, im just here for Ningnings heavenly voice lmao
me too😂 all those notes, letters and numbers are making me dizzy😂😂😂
so her supported range must be G3-C5/C#5(D5)-E5/F5?? Anyways, im happy that NingNing is being able to upgrade her vocal everyday since her SMRookie days
Her low is F#3/G3
G3-C5. her hv is so inconsisitent in doesnt even count atp
@ilovebeomgyu3947 I agree with the head voice part, but giving her G3 ~ C5 is kind of too harsh. She has sung many supported F#3s since debut and even before when she was younger. Her consistency on C#5 is arguable, and it actually doesn't make any difference, but she barely has any bad attempts. Even though the quality is different in comparison to her C5s, I'd personally say it's fair to give her C5/C#5.
@@ilovebeomgyu3947you have the audacity to comment on vocals when u have momo as ur pfp. i have to laugh 😆
F5 is clearly a heady mix
Her F5 headvoice is even thinner than fuller headvoice from another vocalist like this
ruclips.net/video/61n3tPBjjmU/видео.html
I feel like this channel just doesn't recognize the existence of "heady mix". They just consider it to be "head voice" for some reasons.
@@queenning28 it isn't intense as Wendy version of this song. She used heady mix a whole C5-F#5 & sound very tense
Ningning used headvoice coordination, very light at that, not even full headvoice. There is a sustain D5 she dodged by using headvoice too
3:12 soft headvoice
She's B- 😊
more like still C+
@@el.c.8858 No she is a Low Above average vocalist, so her tier is B-
I mean she is low B-
@@imthebest11881She is a low Average to Above Average.
@@eddyjacx5622 no she is Low Above average
@@pruitv2 Based on what, exactly?
The F5/F#5 are mixed voice.
Also her Eb5 1:17 doesn't sound strained but maybe it's just me 😅
That is headvoice coordination, Ningning's E5 & F5 heady mix is quite tight & intense
Her F5 is even thinner than normal headvoice like this
ruclips.net/video/61n3tPBjjmU/видео.html
I agree Ningning's Eb5 is not overly tight or throaty
it definitely isnt head voice- you can hear the chest
@@loafytofu1525 i don't hear any chest voice or the intensity of mix voice. Research Bada vocal range to watch F5 mix voice
Will you analyze the MTMW recording behind? I feel there might be some new stuff especially for rap line
the video'll be coming in a couple of minutes
@@aevokallthanks!
damn you're FAST
00:50
Is she is solid B- ?
not solid but She is in Low Above Average tier
@@aevokall ok thanks
@@aevokall can we guarantee that in they next comeback she can be completely solid B-?
@@aevokall I don't think so. she does have decent development even until D5/Eb5 ish but her problem was never about her support it's within her approach.
@@winwinzolution so, it's mean she's still in C+?
aespa vocal tiers:
1. ningning C+ (not B- since she doesn’t have resonance qualities)
2. winter C (she’s been improving and even supported a C#5)
3. giselle D+ (she’s now consistent with Bb4 but still shallow)
4. karina D+ (she’s not fully consistent with Bb4 [A4/Bb4])
giselle is still shallow.
@@selenesaint yes, thank you for correcting me
Is she using falsetto?
yeah, a lot in this performance
She's upgrade?
She has developments on D5
@@aevokall she's up to B-?
@@pramuditoprabowo2439 yes
@@pramuditoprabowo2439 is B- above average? What’s proficient?
@@chimilicitypjm459 she's just B-, she's already reach that
Is she AA?
Yes
Not at all.
She is low AA
Sumpah..., gua kira jenny blackpink
Jennie? JAJAJAJAJAJA
Bffr rn