The Confederates considered it an insult to bury white officers in a mass grave with black troops, but Shaw's father said that's where his son belonged -- buried with his men. He considered it the highest honor.
“We would not have his body removed from where it lies surrounded by his brave and devoted soldiers....We can imagine no holier place than that in which he lies, among his brave and devoted followers, nor wish for him better company - what a body-guard he has!”
The North had segregated graveyards as well. Segregated everything. The distinctions between the North and South regarding "race relations" weren't drastic. Even freed or born free African Americans weren't afforded the rights and liberties of citizenship that white people took for granted.
@@The10thManRules When possible, the usual protocol was for the bodies of officers to be sent home for burial if the family requested it. Obviously, the Confederates didn't honor that protocol in this case, for the obvious reason.
The 1st Black Medal of Honor recipient was from the 54th Willian H Carney New Bedford, MA He saved the Regiments Colors during the attack on Fort Wagner was wounded 4 times when he got back before collapsing, he said, “Boys, the old flag never touched the ground!” he survived his wounds but it wasn't till May 23, 1900 that he was awarded the Medal and died in 1908 in a accident
@@mikebailey9566 yes born in VA enslaved and then around 14 yrs old made it too New Bedford, MA he enlisted in New Bedford with the local militia which was rolled into the 54th in March 1863 and he was in C co. and returned to New Bedford after the war
The real reason the Civil War saw so many dead is that the tactics was so far behind the technology. The Generals were still studying the Napoleonic Wars but the invention of the rifled musket had increased rifle range from 50-75 yards to 250-350 yards. This meant that the cavalry and infantry charges of those wars were effectively a thing of the past. Same exact lesson had to be learned in WW1 as well but now against machine guns and modern artillery.
Another contributing factor was that many Civil War battles had no strategic objectives, in the traditional sense. Capture this hill, cross the bridge, clear the cornfield etc... These things don't have much inherent value outside of the demands of the immediate confrontation you are involved in. Destruction of the enemy army was often THE strategic objective.
James Horner's score is so powerful, especially during the battle scenes. It adds to the emotion and hits hard at times. Rest in peace, sir. Thank you, Madison for this reaction video!
Wonderful, Madison, just wonderful. I was living in Seattle when this came out and saw it alone at a Sunday matinee. I remember walking out of the theater when it was over almost in shock, it was so powerful. On the way home I stopped at a music store to buy the soundtrack, and it is still one of my most favorite recordings. I moved to Boston a couple of years afterwards, and I had the joy of hearing The Harlem Boys Choir perform the score live. Incredible. Thank you for sharing this one with us. It is truly a special movie. Hope you feel much better soon!
If you still live in the Boston area can I assume you have seen the 54 bas relief Memorial on the edge of the Common Facing the State House (it is the backround the end credits roll over)? As an additional note of interest (last I knew) at least the state flag of the 54th colors (the white one) was on display in a place of honor in the first floor rotunda in said state house. I last saw it their shortly before 9/11 when one could just walk in during daytime business hours. I know it is more complicated accessing the state house now but I assume it is on the tours.
@@davidcorriveau8615 I moved from Boston to Chicago the week before 9/11, but I did see the memorial when I lived there. I went looking for it because of the movie! I didn't see the flag though. Bummer.
My great grandfather was wounded at Antietam, the opening battle, in the infamous cornfield. The bloodiest day in American history. He was from Wisconsin and was able to homestead in Iowa after the war, where I grew up.
The total casualty rate at Antietam: 22,747 - killed, wounded, captured/MIA. In one day. Hand salute for your great grandfather. Stand down, Soldier. Duty done.
I came into this movie with no expectations and was rewarded with not necessarily a war movie, but a movie of character and sacrifice. The music was perfect
@@howardadamkramer Denzel's initial single tear to showcase the emotional pain of the moment during the flogging scene was enough to win the award. Just so powerful. But then his speech at the end around the fire sealed the deal.
One of the greatest comments to a first watch I’ve seen- fantastic! I’m glad your old man recommended it to you, brilliant. As a black British veteran who saw this back in the cinema here back in the day this is one of my favourite ever movies and it should be compulsory viewing in your schools, especially in these dangerous, divisive days. Bravo 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
A beautiful, heartbreaking, inspiring film. Thank you for going on this journey. I recently was able to research my great-great-great-grandfather, Asher Fenton Taylor, who family lore said had served in the Civil War. Thanks to the Internet, I was able to determine he enlisted in the 82nd Indiana. He fought at Stones River, and served until August of 1863, when he died near Louisville, probably of disease. He left a young wife and an infant daughter (my great-great-grandmother). This war left indelible scars upon this country and its families. But I am proud to be Private Taylor's descendant.
There's also a PBS miniseries about the Civil War directed by Ken Burns with famous actors doing voice overs including Morgan Freeman. It used real photos and letters/journals detailing the war from beginning to post war. There are nine episodes each an hour long.
Another Civil War film worth watching is Gettysburg. General Lee, "General Pickett, reform your regiments." General Pickett, "General Lee sir, I have no regiments."
My Mother, a History teacher, showed me this film when I was just a kid. One of many great favors she was wise enough to do for me growing up. It had a big impact, and remains one of my favorite films. More people could stand to see this, and perhaps learn a thing or two. Thanks for the great reaction
Throughout the movie, the characters were given tough individual choices, which they'd never experienced before. But they all took the hard road and fought like heroes. To all our brothers and sisters in the forces ❤ Good luck with the book!!
Interesting Fact: Sgt. William Carney was a soldier in the 54th who was promoted to Sergeant for what he did at Fort Wagner and in 1900 he became the first black soldier to be given the Medal Of Honor for his actions there.
When the music kicks in and you get that epic wide shot of the 54th crawling up that sand hill, fighting with everything they have for every single inch. Can hardly take it.
Wonderful reaction, Madison. Your dad was right. I saw _Glory_ in theaters with my father when I was 16. As a Civil War buff, he provided a lot of context for me. Before _Glory_ , the only Hollywood film to portray the Civil War from the point of view of a Union solider was _The Red Badge of Courage_ in 1951. For decades going back to D.W. Griffith, the film industry romanticized the Confederacy and portrayed their struggle as noble and at times righteous. Hard to believe. _Glory_ was a turning point.
I always really enjoy the spiritual scene at the end not only because you can witness the transformation of Denzel Washington's character, but also because it must have been an interesting scene for him to perform, seeing as he is the son of a preacher man.
As far as Hollywood movies centered around actual historical events and people this is one of the more historically accurate movies I've seen. There are a few inaccuracies however and one of the biggest inaccuracies is probably this movie's most iconic scene. Shaw never had anyone of his men whipped. The flogging of soldiers in the US military as a punishment was banned in 1861. Shaw joined the army in 1861, so he would know that wasn't allowed anymore and the 54th didn't form until 1862. If he had done that, Shaw at the very least would've been dishonorably discharged from the army and his own father would've probably disowned him. Shaw's family were abolitionists and that was probably one of the reasons Shaw was asked to command the 54th because if anyone was going to treat the soldiers of the 54th the same as he would any other troops it would be Shaw.
The opening battle, Antietam, is the single bloodiest day in US history. There is a monument to Robert Shaw and the 54th in Boston. Unfortunately, it was damaged in the George Floyd/BLM riots. I can’t believe anyone who had seen this movie would desecrate this. It is a pretty wonderful monument, done by Saint-Gaudens. The history here is very accurate.
As someone from Boston I have heard nothing of this damage (I've literally walked by and seen none), if there was damaged it was deserved, we have not done enough to support African-Americans. So glad your morality supplants a statue above the suffering of millions. You obviously aren't an abolitionist, my family was, is, we had an ancestor, a volunteer, die after Fredericksburg. I would fight for the cause, and unlike most of the left I believe exorcising the right through violence an turmoil. No more kumbaya bs.
@@jackmessick2869 St Gaudens used the photos of men of 54th for their portraits. Their faces are as true as Shaw's. Yes, if anyone visits NH, his museum is a must see.
At one corner of Boston Common, on Beacon Street, is a memorial to Robert Shaw and the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment. Worth a visit if you're ever in the city.
North & South is wonderfully done. The only criticism I have of the production is the number of times they had to kill Alkianah Bent. The reunion group for the cast of North & South gets smaller all the time. We have lost Orie's Father, Orie Maine as well. (Patrick Swayze ) Rejulia (Christie Alley ) just last year and The Doctor, (David Ogden Stiers ) and Justin (David Caradine, who was type cast for the role.) But well worth watching.
This is a great film and ought to be required watching in high schools. I have perused quite others who have posted their reactions upon first watch. Yours, by far, reflects the most insight. Thank you.
Madison, From where I sit, you were properly wonderful in your reaction. I’ve seen this movie a number of times and I still go through the very same emotions. I am a big fan of movie soundtracks. Especially James Horner’s work. I still listen to CD’s and I have this soundtrack. It’s wonderful and one of my favorites. I’m glad to see and hear that you’re on the mend.
Out of high school, and seeing this film that brought to life names, events, and what life was like for these men, and society in general. With the score, acting, directing, etc., this was truly impactful. Thank you for the well-considered reaction. Get well, and soon.
Hey, Madison! This is my 12th favorite film of all time! There is a bas-relief bronze plaque in Boston Common commemorating Col. Robert Gould Shaw and the 54th. Denzel won his first Oscar for Best Supporting Actor when he shed that single tear! This is one of the best war movies ever made!
Madison, I joined your channel because you show surprising respect for the history behind some of these movies. If you get a chance the movie "Amistad" is as good of movie about the fight to end slavery.
The Memorial to Robert Gould Shaw and the Massachusetts Fifty-Fourth Regiment is a bronze relief sculpture by Augustus Saint-Gaudens opposite 24 Beacon Street, Boston (at the edge of the Boston Common). It depicts Colonel Robert Gould Shaw leading members of the 54th Regiment Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry as it marched down Beacon Street on May 28, 1863 to depart the city to fight in the South. The sculpture was unveiled on May 31, 1897 This is the first civic monument to pay homage to the heroism of African American soldiers. Peace out.
As was common at this time disease killed more soldiers than combat. In combat the battles were so brutal because the weapons were way ahead of the tactics. When guns first came into use they were smooth bored short ranged and inaccurate so armies had to line their men up and fire in volley to ensure hits. By the Civil War muskets and cannon were rifled and their projectiles were cone shaped so they were more accurate and had much longer range. Also cannon shells could explode so the damage they could do was savage. Unfortunately the tactics of lining up infantry to fire in volley were still in use and therefore got blown away. Also looking back at medical records of soldiers wounded in battle and reading personal letters written by soldiers it is now believed that the first cases of PTSD began to appear during this war. In this movie Shaw appeared to be suffering from it.
For many Americans this was real for our ancestors. A probable cousin died in that first battle, at Antietam. Had ancestors who served on both sides, very proud of all of them. Because they didn't die, I exist. Because of those who died, my country was worth fighting for.
Thank you for reacting to this movie! Glory is so special to me. I was in high school when this movie was made and my history class took a field trip to see it in the theater. After that my world changed. I became obsessed with learning all I could about the Civil War and the 54th and my interest lasted for years afterwards. While there are parts of fiction in this movie, a lot of it is historically accurate. I wish you had included the burning of Darien scene because that really did happen. Shaw really had no choice, and it was reported that the men of the 54th were very reluctant to burn that town. The attack on Fort Wagner is also very accurate. Love the score! I still think it's one of Horner's finest. He should've won an Oscar, but it didn't even get nominated that year! Powerful, beautiful music. I could go on & on about this film. If you're into commentaries, I highly recommend checking out the one for this film by director, Ed Zwick. He gives a great account of how the movie was made.
My Mentor in history was the one who did the research for this film. Dr. Douglas pocket took me under his wing as a young student at Spokane Falls Community College in Spokane Washington. He is by far the smartest person I have ever met. Dr. Puckett had 8 bachelor's degrees, a master's degree and a PhD in history. He saw something special in me, so at the 100 level at a community college he worked with me on how to research, how to write using primary and some secondary sources. A primary source would be a letter, a document, a bill, a secondary source would be an article or someone's words and thoughts on a primary individual. In eight years of college I never used anything below a secondary source. Because of him I have 4 degrees, bachelor's degrees in history, economics and government and a master's degree in history. The first class I took from him did not require a term paper at the end of the course. It was a 100 level class for new students. The subsequent for classes I took from him each required a term paper. I used all of my electives to take his classes. At the end of the final class, as he was entering the grades in his grade book for each student I asked him a question. I said did you start requiring term papers because of all the people complaining about your essay question? He said his pencil down, swivels around in his chair and looked up at me and said "No Russ, I started requiring term papers so that you would have a forum to express yourself in writing." It is the second greatest compliment I have ever received. The other was from my son. I don't feel like I ever properly thanked him for his leadership and mentorship of me. He is the reason I am a historian. Gettysburg is another accurate film, but knowing dr. Puckett was the one who did the research on the Massachusetts 54th Regiment tells me that this is one of the most accurate films ever written. I'm sure there are some examples of poetic license by Hollywood, but the use of the letters in the film including the fact that the Confederates buried him with the black soldiers thinking it was going to be embarrassing to his family when his family said he belonged with them there was no place he would rather be. I'm glad you enjoyed the film, one of the great things about Hollywood taking on historical topics is that it encourages people to learn and study history. This country needs to do more of that, we don't get history until college in America. History is not taught in high school, only jingoistic bullshit and fascist propaganda these days. I do recommend Gettysburg, Amistad, and Gangs of New York. As you mentioned 400,000 Union soldiers were killed and over 200,000 Confederate soldiers were killed during the Civil War. Gangs of New York takes place during the Civil War and it shows The Strife that was in the major Northern cities due to the disproportionate loss of soldiers. They don't harp on that topic, they just showed the Strife that was going on during the time. The best book I read regarding the Civil War was a dual biography about General Grant and General Lee, I can't remember which Soldier was listed first but it was Lee and Grant a dual biography or the other way around by an author named Smith. It is an extremely well done biography that starts during the Revolutionary War with the grandfathers. Lighthorse Harry Lee and I don't remember who Grant grandfather was. I read that book a very long time ago. You did an excellent job reviewing this film and paying close attention to detail. It is a hard movie to watch, you did a great job. Dr. Puckett would be proud of you.
When shaw was buried with his men it was meant to be a insult. When they asked his father if he wanted to retrieve his body for proper burial his father refused & said it was what his son would want a honer that he was buried with his men
Very surprised you hadn’t even HEARD of it, especially with that cast. I mean, this is the kind of movie they show in history class when the teacher has no other bright ideas to cover! Glad you mentioned the score too. It’s one for the few soundtracks I have bought. I even had James Horner’s autograph RIP.
I represent the Shaw family after living in their house on Staten Island and this history is about human transformation. The family wants their son to be remembered not by Colonel Shaw and the 54th Regiment but Colonel Shaw with the 54th Regiment!
And it is my understanding that after the war the government offered to dig up Robert Gould Shaw's body and return it to his family but his father turned them down saying he could think of no holier ground for him to lie than where he was. Wonderful reaction by the way. You expressed my sentiments exactly, for the film, for the performances and for the score.
In the context of the movie 2 things really stood out about the way Broderick portrayed Colonel Shaw. He requested help to train the Men in getting Sergeant Major Mulcahy his job wasn't to be liked it was to get them ready for Combat. The other was getting in the Ass of the QM he knew that his Soldier's needed the proper equipment to do the job. The devil is in the details but often it's the things that seem small are often the most important.
Two great scenes. Mulcahy wasn't being a racist; he was being a training instructor. Get 'em to hate you; that way they start bonding. One thing they can all agree on. Shaw posting Rawlins and the troops outside the QM's office, "I don't want to be bothered." Then Shaw's grin when he leaves, "Damn that felt good." Shaw became a true commander.
@@georgesykes394 Yeah. It's one of those things that can read a hellva lot better than it lives. No matter what you do, somebody, usually the wrong people, are going to be pissed off.
Thanks for the recommendation, Dad! I think my favorite scene is the one between Tripp and Shaw where Tripp declines to carry the standard. A short and eloquent encapsulation of what they were fighting for.
This is probably one of the best movies most people have never seen. I've watched it a dozen times and it gets me in my emotions every time. When you see what people had to suffer so that we could have our nation today. They say "Freedom is not Free", this is the price that was paid.
Ms. Madison, thank you for reacting to this masterpiece of cinema, I, like you am a student of history, I had the same reaction as you when I saw this for the first time, hope to see more reactions from you, wish we could discuss areas of history, and our personal interest in different era's, I mostly enjoy civil war time period and after the civil war, especially western expansion, and western history, I hope you will feel better soon....take care of yourself...👍👍👍👍👍
Thank you for making a review of this!!!---"GLORY" has always been one of my personal favorites ever since I was a kid and it inspired me to be a soldier today. I am 37 and serving with the 3/3 CR IRONHAWKS @ Fort Hood, Texas and I always love when someone new experiences this movie. Denzel won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor and it has become an American classic about the Union soldiers who gave their for FREEDOM AND UNION!!! Over 650,000 Americans died in that war (the largest number in all US history!!) and we shall never forget their sacrifice they made. Your crying is also a testament that you connected with the movie and loved the characters and even I get teary eyed sometimes watching it. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and post.
What are you talkin about I myself cried a few times through the movie. When Denzel Washington looking for boots, and he got whipped for attempted AWOL. That look on Denzel Washington's face. I had never heard of Denzel Washington before and I hated him through most of the movie because the way he was treating his fellow soldiers that had never been real slaves in the sense. But I finally got the movie on VHS and then DVD right now. This is one of the top movies that communicates True Hollywood style American history. But I accept it for fact.
@@davidcollver6155 Actually, the whipping scene never happened in real life. The punishment of flogging had finally been abolished in the army in 1861, at least two years before the time of the scene in the film (since recruiting for the 54th Massachusetts started in 1863).
@Robert Lucky abolished does not mean it didn't happen. You can outlaw anything, and someone will still do it. That's how outlaws are made. Enforcement is always difficult, and old habits die hard.
This film came out the year I graduated from High School, and I fell in love with it. In my Sophomore American History class at college we watched it in class and did several days lecturing and two different papers on it. 30 years later both of my children were shown this film their Sophomore years of High School. Rawlins' (Morgan Freeman) speech to Tripp (Denzel Washington) after he slaps him is the stuff of legend! Was sorry you didn't include it in the edit.
Understand that the high death rate in the Civil War wasn't exactly war casualty. Many died and the big battles reported deaths in the tens of thousands. However, what most died from was exposure and disease. Hygiene was still unheard of and wounds quickly became infected. There was much dysentery that spread through the ranks and who knows what other illnesses
"....who knows what other illnesses." Typhoid, small pox, TB, tetanus, flu, for starters. Germ theory was another decade away, virus were identified 1892. In short, disease accounted for 71% of the Union Army's casualty rate. It wasn't until WWI disease casualties started to drop, vaxxing was coming on line. 1917 the entire US armed forces was vaxx'ed for typhoid. By WWII it was down to .5%. Vaccinations work. So does better hygiene.
You're right. I did some research too and found out that this movie is pretty historical accurate. Off course it's dramatized for the audience. Great movie and really hit me hard.
There were quite a few artistic liberties taken. The bulk of the soldiers of the 54th Massachusetts regiment were not former slaves but born into free families. So most of them would have been more like Thomas.
Madison if you ever get to Boston there is a beautiful bronze relief honoring the 54th Massachusetts on the Beacon Street entrance to Boston Common and is one of my favorite things to show friends visiting Boston
That bronze relief is shown at the end of the film. Unfortunately some idiots vandalized it during the George Floyd riots. I believe it has since been repaired.
I Love the fact that you treat the Films, Actors, and Productions with the upmost respect. Unlike some other RUclips “Reactors.” Who tend to place themselves into Historical Events though Films, when they don’t have any idea of what History was like. Not, realizing that they they never even worked on a Production or let alone Served in the Military. While racking up views, and keeping the money! I try my best not to watch them because I believe someone shouldn’t make money from someone else’s work. But, you’re different. Thanks. And Yes, I’m a Veteran.
My girlfriend and I went to see this movie upon it's initial release at the theaters. We didn't know anything about it. Just saw it advertised 8n the newspaper and that it starred Denzel Washington and Morgan Freeman. Needless to say we were blown away. Your edit unfortunately cut out some crucial scenes, but it was still enjoyable to watch this video along with you. Keep up the good work.
I saw this movie when it first came out many years ago....I was 19. I truly love military movies and this is certainly one of the best that Ive ever seen, and that has ever been made Your reaction was truly heartfelt. Best of luck on your book.
'At the end of the film, Colonel Robert Gould Shaw's body is thrown into the mass grave with the black soldiers. Normally, officers were given formal burials, but the Confederacy had such contempt for the black regiment that the officers were thrown in with the regular soldiers, and no honors were rendered. After the war, Shaw's parents visited the site of Fort Wagner in South Carolina. When asked if they wished to have their son's body exhumed so they could take it home to Boston for burial, they declined. "We would not have his body removed from where it lies, surrounded by his brave and devoted soldiers," explained Shaw's father, Francis George Shaw. "We can imagine no holier place than that in which he lies, among his brave and devoted followers, nor wish for him better company. What a bodyguard he has!"'
There are about 5 movies that I will watch reactions to regardless of who is doing it and this movie is one of them. Thaniks for doing this one. And along the same line as this one you might want to also consider the Steven Speilberg masterpiece AMISTAD. It also stars Morgan Freeman along with Anthony Hopkins and Matthew McConnaughy. Does that also get your attention?
As Robert said he would do it and command the 54th. Wesley a simple farm boy was asked to be his 2nd. Without hesitation Wesley told Robert. "as you wish"
To my knowledge now, from looking it up (especially now with resources like the internet and wikipedia), although there were some liberties taken (apparently the pay boycott was instigated by Shaw and the officers in charge), all the major elements of the story are real. Some of the characters are either fictional, slightly altered, or like Cary Elwes's character, Major Forbes, were amalgamations of 2 or more real people. But the regiment, Shaw, and all the battles were pretty accurate.
Amazing masterpiece Glory starring by Matthew Broderick, Denzel Washington and Morgan Freeman. For this film Denzel Washington won an Oscar for best supporting actor. Thank you Madison great reaction👍👍👍
This movie is the rare exception for Hollywood, it really isn't historical fiction as you say, it is mostly history (80+% maybe 90ish) with just dashes of dramatic seasoning. This happened.
Dear Madison, I'm just now recovering from a month-long spell of illness, so I know how you feel. I too hope you feel better soon. You are so right about the noise firearms make. They are so loud that movies can never reproduce their true sound. I once loaded my .22 revolver with .22 short cartridges thinking that they would be "quiet" compared to .22 long rifle rounds. Even .22 shorts are painfully loud, and I never shoot without ear protection now.
When some veterans of D Day were invited to watch Saving Private Ryan, they said the only thing that wasn't true to life about the landing was the sound. They also said they knew it couldn't be.
Haven't even started watching your reaction to this. Just jumped in to say that I got super excited to see that you WERE reacting to it. Can't wait to see what you think.
I had the privilege to see this in the theatres upon release. I've seen many great movies in my day, but this is in the top ten. Two wishes I had while watching this reaction: better editing because some things were cut out or down that I felt should have been kept (I know about the time limit and studio rules) and the reaction itself. I thought there were scenes in which tears would have flowed but there was too much holding back. As an African American I dealt with the personalities of both Denzel's and Morgan's characters: the taunting, the preaching, the praying, the leadership, etc. I certainly can relate.
One of the best war films of all times. Your reaction, once again, was spot on in my opinion. Denzel Washington won a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his role. Morgan Freeman was also nominated for the same Oscar category but lost to Denzel… Beautiful movie and beautiful reaction as always. Good luck on your book. I hope it turns out to be a Bestseller😊👍🏼…
The fighting was brutal, and face to face. When I read the KILLER ANGLES, which was a Civil War book that won the Pulitzer Prize, it really brought the reality of the Civil war to me. I've read that book about 15 times, and have enjoyed it every time. This movie showed the same brutality of man on man. Great review on the movie, and I thought Matthew Broderick outdid himself in this role, as he was still considered a kid actor, at the time that he did this movie. Denzel and Morgan, were still considered "new" actors, and had not received the acclaim they now have.
The book is The Killer Angels by Michael Shaara and you are right. It is one of the finest depictions of the battle of Gettysburg I've ever read, and the book was the blueprint for the film "Gettysburg".
@@keithgoode6313 Yes. I can't remember when, but it was after the book, that Ken Burns did the PBS Documentary on the Civil War. It reminded me of the Book, with readings from soldier's letters throughout the series. I couldn't believe how well and beautiful some of the soldiers could write.
At 5 minutes.. the black man on the left is a free black man .. his name is Fredrick Douglas.. captain Shaw is played by Matthew Broderick ( aka ) ferris Bueller ….
You said it was Historical Fiction? This movie is Based on a True Story. Those were actual Letters from C Shaw. Glory is a 1989 American historical war drama film directed by Edward Zwick about the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment, one of the Union Army's earliest African-American regiments in the American Civil War. Robert Gould Shaw (October 10, 1837 - July 18, 1863) was an American officer in the Union Army during the American Civil War. Born into a prominent Boston abolitionist family, he accepted command of the first all-black regiment (the 54th Massachusetts) in the Northeast. Supporting the promised equal treatment for his troops, he encouraged the men to refuse their pay until it was equal to that of white troops' wage. He led his regiment at the Second Battle of Fort Wagner in July 1863. They attacked a beachhead near Charleston, South Carolina, and Shaw was shot and killed while leading his men to the parapet of the Confederate-held fort. Although the regiment was overwhelmed by firing from the defenses and driven back, suffering many casualties, Shaw's leadership and the regiment became legendary. They inspired hundreds of thousands more African Americans to enlist for the Union, helping to turn the tide of the war to its ultimate victory.
That is what "historical fiction" means. Some characters were fictional within a real historical act and interacting with real people. She said right at the beginning that the letter read aloud was an actual letter.
Such an awesome film. I saw this for the first time in American History class. Of course, I had no idea how many future acting greats were in it. Epic cast! If you are digging the historical content, Red Tails is another great one. Based on the Tuskegee Airmen.
The main character in Red Tails, Colonel Bullard is based on my great uncle... the first Black fighter pilot ever in WWI an American who fought for the French Air Force... Eugene J. Bullard; and Benjamin O. Davis, Jr. (later a general) of the Tuskegee Airmen from WWII. That movie is steeped in history. Lots of books about Eugene Bullard, who was later made into a Second Lieutenant of the Air Force... his plaque and story is at the Air Force museum. Generals Benjamin O. Davis, Sr. and Benjamin O. Davis, Jr. (father and son) are also well known as patriots in uniform.
Thank you my friend. Definitely check out the books on Bullard and Davis (father and son). They are great. My family have a lot of photos and copies of the books on Eugene Bullard. Thanks again. :)@@karlbecker8775
What a great reaction, Madison!! I'm happy you got to see this one. It's in my top 10 movies of all time. Wars are so often fought for reasons that aren't really worthy or justifiable. I always thought if ever there was a war movie that deserved to be called "Glory", this was it.
Beautifully horrific. A war fought with modern (for the time) weapons using tactics from the revolutionary war. The courage that it took to match into heavy weapons fire is amazing. It puts it into perspective from a timeline if you think that some of these men who fought were still alive into the late 40's and early 50's and saw WW1 and WW2.
I'm going to have to watch your reaction again because I kept forgetting I was supposed to be watching you. I kept being drawn in by the movie and the performances. And, like every time I watch it or a reaction to it, I spent half the time crying. I had never heard of this film before I saw it in the theater. My high school teacher was taking small groups of our class to the movies as a field trip, and my classmate picked this to watch because he was excited about seeing Denzel Washington. I had never heard of him either. I was completely blown away by Glory. I absolutely love it. I can't remember if you've seen/reacted to The Last Samurai, but Edward Zwick was the director for both. They are very different movies, but there are a lot of parallels as well. If you add in Legends Of The Fall, I'm not sure which Zwick movie has made me cry the most.
I was directly involved during this war! I survived that conflict and tried to stop the racial division that ensued as an aftermath! Our military solutions at that time were novel even though considered barbarous! Long live the USA!
Many of the African Americans who lived in the Wild West were veterans trying to find their own way and land because segregation was so bad in the East. They laid the ground work for things that would come after their lifetimes.
The Civil War was the first glimpse of what the horrors of World War I would show to the entire world. Antietam (the first Battle shown) is still the single bloodiest day in American History (23,000 + Casualties) in one day.
True, but not quite accurate. Total about 3,650 killed, 17,300 wounded, 1,770 missing/Captured for a total of around 22,720. By comparison, about 2,500 Americans died in the first 24 hours (D-Day) of the Normandy Invasion during WWII
This was one of the most historically accurate movies about history. Taken in very large part from the letters of Robert Shaw, and documents from the period. Much like the movie Waterloo, historians love it.
Our Civil War sometimes presaged WWI, the attack on Ft. Wagner was one. The siege of Vicksburg was another. This was an epic movie. Broderick was a bit of a stretch to take seriously, given his work earlier in the '80s, but this movie completely worked. Flogging soldiers & sailors was abolished in the west mostly in this era or shortly following.
One of the most interesting and poignant question I've ever heard was "When was the last slave freed in America?" Such a simple question but very illuminating. Slavery is truly at the center of the history of America. So much of what is America cannot be understood unless you put slavery at the center of it all. There's a great video essay by the channel 'Knowing' Better' called 'Neoslavery' that goes through this very topic. Highly recommended.
You know that there are archaeological records that show that slavery has existed for at least 10 thousand years, and that it was considered normal in all societies of the world, and although there were people who talked about abolishing slavery, no one took real action. The US Civil War was the moment when the movement to abolish exclatitude began.
@@ESPER_Power I'm not saying this to you out of impertinence but rather out of courtesy; read more books about the history of slavery, particularly about the transatlantic slave trade and the abolitionist movement because you clearly have a fractured view of historical events. Apart from that, I'm having trouble understanding the point of your reply. It reads like an apologetic for slavery or at the very least an attempt to defend or naturalise american slavery. Because I certainly did not imply that slavery was not something that occured elsewhere eons ago in other parts of the world. My comment was about the ways in which the transatlantic slave trade has informed american history politics economics and society. If you can't be bothered to read books about it or even look up the wikipedia page, atleast watch the video that I recommended.
@@makon89 I believe that the one that needs to read a history book is you. If by the transatlantic slave trade you mean the efforts made by the governments of Germany and England to end slavery in Africa, yes I know about that, I also know that it happened almost a decade after the US civil war and that England almost joined the confederate side for economic interests, but the war came to an end before that happened. I also know that the people of England stopped paying the costs of ending slavery in Africa on their taxes only 10 years ago. I also know of the movements that existed to put an end to slavery throughout the world but how they were unsuccessful. I also know that the ones who profited the most from the transatlantic slave trade were the African kings who sold their own people, I don't know if you know this, but there was a king in Africa (I don't remember his name) who came to have a fortune equivalent to Rockefeller's for invading his neighbors and selling out his people as slaves. My point is that after 10 thousand years of history, the end of slavery began at the end of the USA civil war. After that, all began to change.
00:40 Madison: "But today I am watching Glory... uh, to be completely transparent... honest with you guys I..." Me: Don't you dare say you have seen this movie before grrrr... Madison: "...had never even heard of this movie until a few days ago..." Me: Okay, that was a curveball you threw there, Madison. I like re-actors to go in total blind... never even heard of movie until a few days ago... brilliant!
The Confederates considered it an insult to bury white officers in a mass grave with black troops, but Shaw's father said that's where his son belonged -- buried with his men. He considered it the highest honor.
“We would not have his body removed from where it lies surrounded by his brave and devoted soldiers....We can imagine no holier place than that in which he lies, among his brave and devoted followers, nor wish for him better company - what a body-guard he has!”
Wow, I didn't know that. Respect.
The North had segregated graveyards as well. Segregated everything.
The distinctions between the North and South regarding "race relations" weren't drastic.
Even freed or born free African Americans weren't afforded the rights and liberties of citizenship that white people took for granted.
@@The10thManRules When possible, the usual protocol was for the bodies of officers to be sent home for burial if the family requested it. Obviously, the Confederates didn't honor that protocol in this case, for the obvious reason.
@@The10thManRules well said. History is written by the victors 🫠
The white soldier who yelled “Give ‘em hell, 54th!” as they marched to the beach was played by the screenwriter, Kevin Jarre.
OMG! Kirk in an alternate universe!
He was also the one starting the fight when they were doing manual labor.
@@JohnRodriguesPhotographer Yes, but I didn't want to demonetize Madison's page by repeating what he said then! 😊
The 1st Black Medal of Honor recipient was from the 54th Willian H Carney New Bedford, MA He saved the Regiments Colors during the attack on Fort Wagner was wounded 4 times when he got back before collapsing, he said, “Boys, the old flag never touched the ground!” he survived his wounds but it wasn't till May 23, 1900 that he was awarded the Medal and died in 1908 in a accident
I'm sorry but William H. Carney was born in my hometown of Norfolk, Virginia.
@@mikebailey9566 yes born in VA enslaved and then around 14 yrs old made it too New Bedford, MA he enlisted in New Bedford with the local militia which was rolled into the 54th in March 1863 and he was in C co. and returned to New Bedford after the war
The real reason the Civil War saw so many dead is that the tactics was so far behind the technology.
The Generals were still studying the Napoleonic Wars but the invention of the rifled musket had increased rifle range from 50-75 yards to 250-350 yards.
This meant that the cavalry and infantry charges of those wars were effectively a thing of the past.
Same exact lesson had to be learned in WW1 as well but now against machine guns and modern artillery.
Another contributing factor was that many Civil War battles had no strategic objectives, in the traditional sense. Capture this hill, cross the bridge, clear the cornfield etc... These things don't have much inherent value outside of the demands of the immediate confrontation you are involved in. Destruction of the enemy army was often THE strategic objective.
In my opinion this is the best movie Matthew Broderick has ever done.
Agreed for drama. I absolutely loved him in Biloxi Blues.
I also loved Project X with Helen Hunt
@@pmaximus5659 great flick no one ever talks about
James Horner's score is so powerful, especially during the battle scenes. It adds to the emotion and hits hard at times. Rest in peace, sir. Thank you, Madison for this reaction video!
I'm still shocked the score didn't receive an Academy Award nomination. It did win the Grammy later on, however.
That guy looks too young to have been born in the mid-1800s.
Credit to the Harlem Boys Choir too.
@@CarolinaCharles777 It did win a Grammy though.
Wonderful, Madison, just wonderful. I was living in Seattle when this came out and saw it alone at a Sunday matinee. I remember walking out of the theater when it was over almost in shock, it was so powerful. On the way home I stopped at a music store to buy the soundtrack, and it is still one of my most favorite recordings. I moved to Boston a couple of years afterwards, and I had the joy of hearing The Harlem Boys Choir perform the score live. Incredible. Thank you for sharing this one with us. It is truly a special movie. Hope you feel much better soon!
If you still live in the Boston area can I assume you have seen the 54 bas relief Memorial on the edge of the Common Facing the State House (it is the backround the end credits roll over)? As an additional note of interest (last I knew) at least the state flag of the 54th colors (the white one) was on display in a place of honor in the first floor rotunda in said state house. I last saw it their shortly before 9/11 when one could just walk in during daytime business hours. I know it is more complicated accessing the state house now but I assume it is on the tours.
@@davidcorriveau8615 I moved from Boston to Chicago the week before 9/11, but I did see the memorial when I lived there. I went looking for it because of the movie! I didn't see the flag though. Bummer.
My great grandfather was wounded at Antietam, the opening battle, in the infamous cornfield. The bloodiest day in American history. He was from Wisconsin and was able to homestead in Iowa after the war, where I grew up.
The total casualty rate at Antietam: 22,747 - killed, wounded, captured/MIA. In one day.
Hand salute for your great grandfather. Stand down, Soldier. Duty done.
This is one of my top favorite films of all time. It hits all of the emotions just like "Shawshank Redemption" and "Green Mile". 📽❤️
Bob Gunton and Morgan Freeman are both in this film and in Shawshank.
Yes... am I BEING OBTUSE?!? Get busy living... or get busy dying...@@peteg475
I came into this movie with no expectations and was rewarded with not necessarily a war movie, but a movie of character and sacrifice. The music was perfect
Nominated for 5 Oscars.
Winning 3
Best Supporting Actor Denzal Washington
Best Cinematography
Best Sound.
I remember when I watched the Oscars that year I was thinking I liked Morgan Freeman better (although Denzel Washington was excellent).
@@howardadamkramer Denzel's initial single tear to showcase the emotional pain of the moment during the flogging scene was enough to win the award. Just so powerful. But then his speech at the end around the fire sealed the deal.
It’s a shame the score didn’t win.
One of the greatest comments to a first watch I’ve seen- fantastic! I’m glad your old man recommended it to you, brilliant. As a black British veteran who saw this back in the cinema here back in the day this is one of my favourite ever movies and it should be compulsory viewing in your schools, especially in these dangerous, divisive days. Bravo 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾
Thanks so much! Glad you enjoyed it🙏🏻
A beautiful, heartbreaking, inspiring film. Thank you for going on this journey.
I recently was able to research my great-great-great-grandfather, Asher Fenton Taylor, who family lore said had served in the Civil War. Thanks to the Internet, I was able to determine he enlisted in the 82nd Indiana. He fought at Stones River, and served until August of 1863, when he died near Louisville, probably of disease. He left a young wife and an infant daughter (my great-great-grandmother).
This war left indelible scars upon this country and its families. But I am proud to be Private Taylor's descendant.
There's also a PBS miniseries about the Civil War directed by Ken Burns with famous actors doing voice overs including Morgan Freeman. It used real photos and letters/journals detailing the war from beginning to post war. There are nine episodes each an hour long.
Another Civil War film worth watching is Gettysburg.
General Lee, "General Pickett, reform your regiments."
General Pickett, "General Lee sir, I have no regiments."
My Mother, a History teacher, showed me this film when I was just a kid. One of many great favors she was wise enough to do for me growing up. It had a big impact, and remains one of my favorite films. More people could stand to see this, and perhaps learn a thing or two. Thanks for the great reaction
Throughout the movie, the characters were given tough individual choices, which they'd never experienced before. But they all took the hard road and fought like heroes. To all our brothers and sisters in the forces ❤ Good luck with the book!!
I saw this in the theater. At the end, the theater was dead silent. Like stunned. Never before or since have I seen that.
This is the film where Denzel became Denzel for me. If that makes any sense.
@user-kx8ds6fk3q It was for me too. His performance blew me away.
Interesting Fact: Sgt. William Carney was a soldier in the 54th who was promoted to Sergeant for what he did at Fort Wagner and in 1900 he became the first black soldier to be given the Medal Of Honor for his actions there.
When the music kicks in and you get that epic wide shot of the 54th crawling up that sand hill, fighting with everything they have for every single inch. Can hardly take it.
Wonderful reaction, Madison. Your dad was right. I saw _Glory_ in theaters with my father when I was 16. As a Civil War buff, he provided a lot of context for me. Before _Glory_ , the only Hollywood film to portray the Civil War from the point of view of a Union solider was _The Red Badge of Courage_ in 1951. For decades going back to D.W. Griffith, the film industry romanticized the Confederacy and portrayed their struggle as noble and at times righteous. Hard to believe. _Glory_ was a turning point.
Yeah .. from "Give em hell 54th!" to the end, I'm an emotional wreck. Every time.
Frederick Douglas's son was a member of the 54th, and was killed at the assault on Ft Wagner
I always really enjoy the spiritual scene at the end not only because you can witness the transformation of Denzel Washington's character, but also because it must have been an interesting scene for him to perform, seeing as he is the son of a preacher man.
My favorite scene
As far as Hollywood movies centered around actual historical events and people this is one of the more historically accurate movies I've seen. There are a few inaccuracies however and one of the biggest inaccuracies is probably this movie's most iconic scene. Shaw never had anyone of his men whipped. The flogging of soldiers in the US military as a punishment was banned in 1861. Shaw joined the army in 1861, so he would know that wasn't allowed anymore and the 54th didn't form until 1862.
If he had done that, Shaw at the very least would've been dishonorably discharged from the army and his own father would've probably disowned him. Shaw's family were abolitionists and that was probably one of the reasons Shaw was asked to command the 54th because if anyone was going to treat the soldiers of the 54th the same as he would any other troops it would be Shaw.
The opening battle, Antietam, is the single bloodiest day in US history.
There is a monument to Robert Shaw and the 54th in Boston. Unfortunately, it was damaged in the George Floyd/BLM riots. I can’t believe anyone who had seen this movie would desecrate this. It is a pretty wonderful monument, done by Saint-Gaudens.
The history here is very accurate.
They cleaned/fixed it thankfully.
As someone from Boston I have heard nothing of this damage (I've literally walked by and seen none), if there was damaged it was deserved, we have not done enough to support African-Americans. So glad your morality supplants a statue above the suffering of millions. You obviously aren't an abolitionist, my family was, is, we had an ancestor, a volunteer, die after Fredericksburg. I would fight for the cause, and unlike most of the left I believe exorcising the right through violence an turmoil. No more kumbaya bs.
St Gaudens made a duplicate at his home, now a museum, in New Hampshire. It has been better maintained, and looks like new.
@@CaptainFSUextraordinarily based. genuinely super cool to have ancestors who fought for their oppressed peers.
@@jackmessick2869 St Gaudens used the photos of men of 54th for their portraits. Their faces are as true as Shaw's. Yes, if anyone visits NH, his museum is a must see.
At one corner of Boston Common, on Beacon Street, is a memorial to Robert Shaw and the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment. Worth a visit if you're ever in the city.
I would recommend the TV mini series "North and South"
It portrays the years leading up to the Civil War.
Two friends, one Southern, one Northern.
I’m actually watching that right now. Bent has become one of my top villains in cinema.
North & South is wonderfully done. The only criticism I have of the production is the number of times they had to kill Alkianah Bent. The reunion group for the cast of North & South gets smaller all the time. We have lost Orie's Father, Orie Maine as well. (Patrick Swayze ) Rejulia (Christie Alley ) just last year and The Doctor, (David Ogden Stiers ) and Justin (David Caradine, who was type cast for the role.) But well worth watching.
@@edwardimhoff3106 Bent is killed more than once?
This is a great film and ought to be required watching in high schools. I have perused quite others who have posted their reactions upon first watch. Yours, by far, reflects the most insight. Thank you.
Madison,
From where I sit, you were properly wonderful in your reaction. I’ve seen this movie a number of times and I still go through the very same emotions.
I am a big fan of movie soundtracks. Especially James Horner’s work. I still listen to CD’s and I have this soundtrack. It’s wonderful and one of my favorites. I’m glad to see and hear that you’re on the mend.
Out of high school, and seeing this film that brought to life names, events, and what life was like for these men, and society in general. With the score, acting, directing, etc., this was truly impactful.
Thank you for the well-considered reaction. Get well, and soon.
Hey, Madison! This is my 12th favorite film of all time!
There is a bas-relief bronze plaque in Boston Common commemorating Col. Robert Gould Shaw and the 54th.
Denzel won his first Oscar for Best Supporting Actor when he shed that single tear!
This is one of the best war movies ever made!
Madison, I joined your channel because you show surprising respect for the history behind some of these movies. If you get a chance the movie "Amistad" is as good of movie about the fight to end slavery.
Amistad was great. Love John Quincy Adams.
The Memorial to Robert Gould Shaw and the Massachusetts Fifty-Fourth Regiment is a bronze relief sculpture by Augustus Saint-Gaudens opposite 24 Beacon Street, Boston (at the edge of the Boston Common). It depicts Colonel Robert Gould Shaw leading members of the 54th Regiment Massachusetts Volunteer Infantry as it marched down Beacon Street on May 28, 1863 to depart the city to fight in the South. The sculpture was unveiled on May 31, 1897 This is the first civic monument to pay homage to the heroism of African American soldiers. Peace out.
Denzel won an Oscar for Best Supporting Actor for his role as Tripp.
As was common at this time disease killed more soldiers than combat. In combat the battles were so brutal because the weapons were way ahead of the tactics. When guns first came into use they were smooth bored short ranged and inaccurate so armies had to line their men up and fire in volley to ensure hits. By the Civil War muskets and cannon were rifled and their projectiles were cone shaped so they were more accurate and had much longer range. Also cannon shells could explode so the damage they could do was savage. Unfortunately the tactics of lining up infantry to fire in volley were still in use and therefore got blown away.
Also looking back at medical records of soldiers wounded in battle and reading personal letters written by soldiers it is now believed that the first cases of PTSD began to appear during this war. In this movie Shaw appeared to be suffering from it.
For many Americans this was real for our ancestors. A probable cousin died in that first battle, at Antietam. Had ancestors who served on both sides, very proud of all of them. Because they didn't die, I exist. Because of those who died, my country was worth fighting for.
Both Washington and Morgan are excellent in this movie … the best !!!
Thank you for reacting to this movie! Glory is so special to me. I was in high school when this movie was made and my history class took a field trip to see it in the theater. After that my world changed. I became obsessed with learning all I could about the Civil War and the 54th and my interest lasted for years afterwards.
While there are parts of fiction in this movie, a lot of it is historically accurate. I wish you had included the burning of Darien scene because that really did happen. Shaw really had no choice, and it was reported that the men of the 54th were very reluctant to burn that town. The attack on Fort Wagner is also very accurate.
Love the score! I still think it's one of Horner's finest. He should've won an Oscar, but it didn't even get nominated that year! Powerful, beautiful music.
I could go on & on about this film. If you're into commentaries, I highly recommend checking out the one for this film by director, Ed Zwick. He gives a great account of how the movie was made.
My Mentor in history was the one who did the research for this film. Dr. Douglas pocket took me under his wing as a young student at Spokane Falls Community College in Spokane Washington. He is by far the smartest person I have ever met.
Dr. Puckett had 8 bachelor's degrees, a master's degree and a PhD in history. He saw something special in me, so at the 100 level at a community college he worked with me on how to research, how to write using primary and some secondary sources. A primary source would be a letter, a document, a bill, a secondary source would be an article or someone's words and thoughts on a primary individual. In eight years of college I never used anything below a secondary source. Because of him I have 4 degrees, bachelor's degrees in history, economics and government and a master's degree in history.
The first class I took from him did not require a term paper at the end of the course. It was a 100 level class for new students. The subsequent for classes I took from him each required a term paper. I used all of my electives to take his classes. At the end of the final class, as he was entering the grades in his grade book for each student I asked him a question. I said did you start requiring term papers because of all the people complaining about your essay question? He said his pencil down, swivels around in his chair and looked up at me and said "No Russ, I started requiring term papers so that you would have a forum to express yourself in writing." It is the second greatest compliment I have ever received. The other was from my son.
I don't feel like I ever properly thanked him for his leadership and mentorship of me. He is the reason I am a historian.
Gettysburg is another accurate film, but knowing dr. Puckett was the one who did the research on the Massachusetts 54th Regiment tells me that this is one of the most accurate films ever written. I'm sure there are some examples of poetic license by Hollywood, but the use of the letters in the film including the fact that the Confederates buried him with the black soldiers thinking it was going to be embarrassing to his family when his family said he belonged with them there was no place he would rather be. I'm glad you enjoyed the film, one of the great things about Hollywood taking on historical topics is that it encourages people to learn and study history. This country needs to do more of that, we don't get history until college in America. History is not taught in high school, only jingoistic bullshit and fascist propaganda these days. I do recommend Gettysburg, Amistad, and Gangs of New York. As you mentioned 400,000 Union soldiers were killed and over 200,000 Confederate soldiers were killed during the Civil War. Gangs of New York takes place during the Civil War and it shows The Strife that was in the major Northern cities due to the disproportionate loss of soldiers. They don't harp on that topic, they just showed the Strife that was going on during the time. The best book I read regarding the Civil War was a dual biography about General Grant and General Lee, I can't remember which Soldier was listed first but it was Lee and Grant a dual biography or the other way around by an author named Smith. It is an extremely well done biography that starts during the Revolutionary War with the grandfathers. Lighthorse Harry Lee and I don't remember who Grant grandfather was. I read that book a very long time ago.
You did an excellent job reviewing this film and paying close attention to detail. It is a hard movie to watch, you did a great job. Dr. Puckett would be proud of you.
When shaw was buried with his men it was meant to be a insult. When they asked his father if he wanted to retrieve his body for proper burial his father refused & said it was what his son would want a honer that he was buried with his men
Very surprised you hadn’t even HEARD of it, especially with that cast. I mean, this is the kind of movie they show in history class when the teacher has no other bright ideas to cover! Glad you mentioned the score too. It’s one for the few soundtracks I have bought. I even had James Horner’s autograph RIP.
Most of today's teachers don't know this movie exist.
One of the best scores to ever grace a film. It impacts the movie in all the right places. The charge on the fort, I had goosebumps
I represent the Shaw family after living in their house on Staten Island and this history is about human transformation. The family wants their son to be remembered not by Colonel Shaw and the 54th Regiment but Colonel Shaw with the 54th Regiment!
And it is my understanding that after the war the government offered to dig up Robert Gould Shaw's body and return it to his family but his father turned them down saying he could think of no holier ground for him to lie than where he was.
Wonderful reaction by the way. You expressed my sentiments exactly, for the film, for the performances and for the score.
In the context of the movie 2 things really stood out about the way Broderick portrayed Colonel Shaw. He requested help to train the Men in getting Sergeant Major Mulcahy his job wasn't to be liked it was to get them ready for Combat. The other was getting in the Ass of the QM he knew that his Soldier's needed the proper equipment to do the job. The devil is in the details but often it's the things that seem small are often the most important.
Two great scenes. Mulcahy wasn't being a racist; he was being a training instructor. Get 'em to hate you; that way they start bonding. One thing they can all agree on. Shaw posting Rawlins and the troops outside the QM's office, "I don't want to be bothered." Then Shaw's grin when he leaves, "Damn that felt good." Shaw became a true commander.
@graceskerp I can't begin to fathom the responsibility of being a colonel in the infantry and not even 30 year's old!
@@georgesykes394 Yeah. It's one of those things that can read a hellva lot better than it lives. No matter what you do, somebody, usually the wrong people, are going to be pissed off.
Thanks for the recommendation, Dad! I think my favorite scene is the one between Tripp and Shaw where Tripp declines to carry the standard. A short and eloquent encapsulation of what they were fighting for.
This is probably one of the best movies most people have never seen. I've watched it a dozen times and it gets me in my emotions every time. When you see what people had to suffer so that we could have our nation today. They say "Freedom is not Free", this is the price that was paid.
Ms. Madison, thank you for reacting to this masterpiece of cinema, I, like you am a student of history, I had the same reaction as you when I saw this for the first time, hope to see more reactions from you, wish we could discuss areas of history, and our personal interest in different era's, I mostly enjoy civil war time period and after the civil war, especially western expansion, and western history, I hope you will feel better soon....take care of yourself...👍👍👍👍👍
Thank you for making a review of this!!!---"GLORY" has always been one of my personal favorites ever since I was a kid and it inspired me to be a soldier today. I am 37 and serving with the 3/3 CR IRONHAWKS @ Fort Hood, Texas and I always love when someone new experiences this movie. Denzel won the Academy Award for Best Supporting Actor and it has become an American classic about the Union soldiers who gave their for FREEDOM AND UNION!!! Over 650,000 Americans died in that war (the largest number in all US history!!) and we shall never forget their sacrifice they made. Your crying is also a testament that you connected with the movie and loved the characters and even I get teary eyed sometimes watching it. Thank you for sharing your thoughts and post.
If you don't cry at the end of this movie you're not human.
What are you talkin about I myself cried a few times through the movie. When Denzel Washington looking for boots, and he got whipped for attempted AWOL. That look on Denzel Washington's face. I had never heard of Denzel Washington before and I hated him through most of the movie because the way he was treating his fellow soldiers that had never been real slaves in the sense. But I finally got the movie on VHS and then DVD right now. This is one of the top movies that communicates True Hollywood style American history. But I accept it for fact.
Or if you are human but don't cry at the end, you're dead inside lmao
@@davidcollver6155 Actually, the whipping scene never happened in real life. The punishment of flogging had finally been abolished in the army in 1861, at least two years before the time of the scene in the film (since recruiting for the 54th Massachusetts started in 1863).
If you don't cry at the end of this movie, you're probably an emotionally stable human being...
There, fixed it for ya!
@Robert Lucky abolished does not mean it didn't happen. You can outlaw anything, and someone will still do it. That's how outlaws are made. Enforcement is always difficult, and old habits die hard.
This film came out the year I graduated from High School, and I fell in love with it. In my Sophomore American History class at college we watched it in class and did several days lecturing and two different papers on it. 30 years later both of my children were shown this film their Sophomore years of High School. Rawlins' (Morgan Freeman) speech to Tripp (Denzel Washington) after he slaps him is the stuff of legend! Was sorry you didn't include it in the edit.
Rawlins was born to be a Sergeant Major.
Understand that the high death rate in the Civil War wasn't exactly war casualty. Many died and the big battles reported deaths in the tens of thousands. However, what most died from was exposure and disease. Hygiene was still unheard of and wounds quickly became infected. There was much dysentery that spread through the ranks and who knows what other illnesses
"....who knows what other illnesses." Typhoid, small pox, TB, tetanus, flu, for starters. Germ theory was another decade away, virus were identified 1892. In short, disease accounted for 71% of the Union Army's casualty rate. It wasn't until WWI disease casualties started to drop, vaxxing was coming on line. 1917 the entire US armed forces was vaxx'ed for typhoid. By WWII it was down to .5%. Vaccinations work. So does better hygiene.
This is dead on accurate. The screenwriter was a historian and got every little detail he could right. He wrote Tombstone as well.
You're right. I did some research too and found out that this movie is pretty historical accurate. Off course it's dramatized for the audience. Great movie and really hit me hard.
Actually it is NOT very accurate. All you have to do is do some research and you will find out.
There were quite a few artistic liberties taken. The bulk of the soldiers of the 54th Massachusetts regiment were not former slaves but born into free families. So most of them would have been more like Thomas.
@@ronb8500 What parts for example?
GLORY is one of my top 5 favorite films all time. Great reaction!
Madison if you ever get to Boston there is a beautiful bronze relief honoring the 54th Massachusetts on the Beacon Street entrance to Boston Common and is one of my favorite things to show friends visiting Boston
That bronze relief is shown at the end of the film. Unfortunately some idiots vandalized it during the George Floyd riots. I believe it has since been repaired.
Great reaction to a great movie. Many people don't realize that Glory was written by the same screenwriter as Tombstone, the late Kevin Jarre.
I Love the fact that you treat the Films, Actors, and Productions with the upmost respect. Unlike some other RUclips “Reactors.” Who tend to place themselves into Historical Events though Films, when they don’t have any idea of what History was like. Not, realizing that they they never even worked on a Production or let alone Served in the Military. While racking up views, and keeping the money! I try my best not to watch them because I believe someone shouldn’t make money from someone else’s work. But, you’re different. Thanks. And Yes, I’m a Veteran.
Such a powerful movie. And the score is absolute perfection.
My girlfriend and I went to see this movie upon it's initial release at the theaters. We didn't know anything about it. Just saw it advertised 8n the newspaper and that it starred Denzel Washington and Morgan Freeman. Needless to say we were blown away. Your edit unfortunately cut out some crucial scenes, but it was still enjoyable to watch this video along with you. Keep up the good work.
I saw this movie when it first came out many years ago....I was 19. I truly love military movies and this is certainly one of the best that Ive ever seen, and that has ever been made Your reaction was truly heartfelt. Best of luck on your book.
Great reaction video. And you’re right the estimate is around 620,000 men killed in action with 360,000 American soldiers lost.
And we're men, ain't we...
That stands out to me. It's like the first time he had the thought.
Enjoyed the reaction.
'At the end of the film, Colonel Robert Gould Shaw's body is thrown into the mass grave with the black soldiers. Normally, officers were given formal burials, but the Confederacy had such contempt for the black regiment that the officers were thrown in with the regular soldiers, and no honors were rendered. After the war, Shaw's parents visited the site of Fort Wagner in South Carolina. When asked if they wished to have their son's body exhumed so they could take it home to Boston for burial, they declined. "We would not have his body removed from where it lies, surrounded by his brave and devoted soldiers," explained Shaw's father, Francis George Shaw. "We can imagine no holier place than that in which he lies, among his brave and devoted followers, nor wish for him better company. What a bodyguard he has!"'
Colonel Shaw would have agreed. He wouldn't leave his men, even in death.
There are about 5 movies that I will watch reactions to regardless of who is doing it and this movie is one of them. Thaniks for doing this one. And along the same line as this one you might want to also consider the Steven Speilberg masterpiece AMISTAD. It also stars Morgan Freeman along with Anthony Hopkins and Matthew McConnaughy. Does that also get your attention?
As Robert said he would do it and command the 54th. Wesley a simple farm boy was asked to be his 2nd. Without hesitation Wesley told Robert. "as you wish"
To my knowledge now, from looking it up (especially now with resources like the internet and wikipedia), although there were some liberties taken (apparently the pay boycott was instigated by Shaw and the officers in charge), all the major elements of the story are real. Some of the characters are either fictional, slightly altered, or like Cary Elwes's character, Major Forbes, were amalgamations of 2 or more real people. But the regiment, Shaw, and all the battles were pretty accurate.
Amazing masterpiece Glory starring by Matthew Broderick, Denzel Washington and Morgan Freeman. For this film Denzel Washington won an Oscar for best supporting actor. Thank you Madison great reaction👍👍👍
I have seen this movie about 20 times and the final 20 mins always makes me cry.
This movie is the rare exception for Hollywood, it really isn't historical fiction as you say, it is mostly history (80+% maybe 90ish) with just dashes of dramatic seasoning. This happened.
Dear Madison, I'm just now recovering from a month-long spell of illness, so I know how you feel. I too hope you feel better soon. You are so right about the noise firearms make. They are so loud that movies can never reproduce their true sound. I once loaded my .22 revolver with .22 short cartridges thinking that they would be "quiet" compared to .22 long rifle rounds. Even .22 shorts are painfully loud, and I never shoot without ear protection now.
When some veterans of D Day were invited to watch Saving Private Ryan, they said the only thing that wasn't true to life about the landing was the sound. They also said they knew it couldn't be.
Haven't even started watching your reaction to this. Just jumped in to say that I got super excited to see that you WERE reacting to it. Can't wait to see what you think.
I had the privilege to see this in the theatres upon release. I've seen many great movies in my day, but this is in the top ten. Two wishes I had while watching this reaction: better editing because some things were cut out or down that I felt should have been kept (I know about the time limit and studio rules) and the reaction itself. I thought there were scenes in which tears would have flowed but there was too much holding back. As an African American I dealt with the personalities of both Denzel's and Morgan's characters: the taunting, the preaching, the praying, the leadership, etc. I certainly can relate.
One of the best war films of all times.
Your reaction, once again, was spot on in my opinion. Denzel Washington won a Best Supporting Actor Oscar for his role. Morgan Freeman was also nominated for the same Oscar category but lost to Denzel…
Beautiful movie and beautiful reaction as always.
Good luck on your book. I hope it turns out to be a Bestseller😊👍🏼…
The fighting was brutal, and face to face. When I read the KILLER ANGLES, which was a Civil War book that won the Pulitzer Prize, it really brought the reality of the Civil war to me. I've read that book about 15 times, and have enjoyed it every time. This movie showed the same brutality of man on man.
Great review on the movie, and I thought Matthew Broderick outdid himself in this role, as he was still considered a kid actor, at the time that he did this movie. Denzel and Morgan, were still considered "new" actors, and had not received the acclaim they now have.
The book is The Killer Angels by Michael Shaara and you are right. It is one of the finest depictions of the battle of Gettysburg I've ever read, and the book was the blueprint for the film "Gettysburg".
@@keithgoode6313 Yes. I can't remember when, but it was after the book, that Ken Burns did the PBS Documentary on the Civil War. It reminded me of the Book, with readings from soldier's letters throughout the series. I couldn't believe how well and beautiful some of the soldiers could write.
At 5 minutes.. the black man on the left is a free black man .. his name is Fredrick Douglas..
captain Shaw is played by Matthew Broderick ( aka ) ferris Bueller ….
You said it was Historical Fiction? This movie is Based on a True Story. Those were actual Letters from C Shaw. Glory is a 1989 American historical war drama film directed by Edward Zwick about the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment, one of the Union Army's earliest African-American regiments in the American Civil War. Robert Gould Shaw (October 10, 1837 - July 18, 1863) was an American officer in the Union Army during the American Civil War. Born into a prominent Boston abolitionist family, he accepted command of the first all-black regiment (the 54th Massachusetts) in the Northeast. Supporting the promised equal treatment for his troops, he encouraged the men to refuse their pay until it was equal to that of white troops' wage.
He led his regiment at the Second Battle of Fort Wagner in July 1863. They attacked a beachhead near Charleston, South Carolina, and Shaw was shot and killed while leading his men to the parapet of the Confederate-held fort. Although the regiment was overwhelmed by firing from the defenses and driven back, suffering many casualties, Shaw's leadership and the regiment became legendary. They inspired hundreds of thousands more African Americans to enlist for the Union, helping to turn the tide of the war to its ultimate victory.
That is what "historical fiction" means. Some characters were fictional within a real historical act and interacting with real people. She said right at the beginning that the letter read aloud was an actual letter.
@@thorguff TY I was just filling in the blanks
Such an awesome film. I saw this for the first time in American History class. Of course, I had no idea how many future acting greats were in it. Epic cast!
If you are digging the historical content, Red Tails is another great one. Based on the Tuskegee Airmen.
The main character in Red Tails, Colonel Bullard is based on my great uncle... the first Black fighter pilot ever in WWI an American who fought for the French Air Force... Eugene J. Bullard; and Benjamin O. Davis, Jr. (later a general) of the Tuskegee Airmen from WWII. That movie is steeped in history. Lots of books about Eugene Bullard, who was later made into a Second Lieutenant of the Air Force... his plaque and story is at the Air Force museum. Generals Benjamin O. Davis, Sr. and Benjamin O. Davis, Jr. (father and son) are also well known as patriots in uniform.
@@Smenkhaare That's amazing! Thank you for sharing. You have plenty to be proud of!
Thank you my friend. Definitely check out the books on Bullard and Davis (father and son). They are great. My family have a lot of photos and copies of the books on Eugene Bullard. Thanks again. :)@@karlbecker8775
What a great reaction, Madison!! I'm happy you got to see this one. It's in my top 10 movies of all time. Wars are so often fought for reasons that aren't really worthy or justifiable. I always thought if ever there was a war movie that deserved to be called "Glory", this was it.
Beautifully horrific. A war fought with modern (for the time) weapons using tactics from the revolutionary war. The courage that it took to match into heavy weapons fire is amazing. It puts it into perspective from a timeline if you think that some of these men who fought were still alive into the late 40's and early 50's and saw WW1 and WW2.
I've avoided watching this movie for a second time because it's so heart rending. Just about managed to stay with it this time. Great reaction. 😐
RIP Andre Braugher (Thomas) 12/11/2023 🙏 ❤️ 💐
Your dad rocks! Great reaction. It is a powerful movie with powerful performances throughout.
I'm going to have to watch your reaction again because I kept forgetting I was supposed to be watching you. I kept being drawn in by the movie and the performances. And, like every time I watch it or a reaction to it, I spent half the time crying. I had never heard of this film before I saw it in the theater. My high school teacher was taking small groups of our class to the movies as a field trip, and my classmate picked this to watch because he was excited about seeing Denzel Washington. I had never heard of him either. I was completely blown away by Glory. I absolutely love it. I can't remember if you've seen/reacted to The Last Samurai, but Edward Zwick was the director for both. They are very different movies, but there are a lot of parallels as well. If you add in Legends Of The Fall, I'm not sure which Zwick movie has made me cry the most.
I was directly involved during this war! I survived that conflict and tried to stop the racial division that ensued as an aftermath! Our military solutions at that time were novel even though considered barbarous! Long live the USA!
A 1986 movie with Jeremy Iron and Rovert DeNiro... The Mission.
Now you watched the movie check out Thomas Sowell (a Black man) "Facts about slavery never mentioned in school".
Many of the African Americans who lived in the Wild West were veterans trying to find their own way and land because segregation was so bad in the East. They laid the ground work for things that would come after their lifetimes.
I'll never forget the first time I saw this in the theater when I was 12 years old.
The Civil War was the first glimpse of what the horrors of World War I would show to the entire world. Antietam (the first Battle shown) is still the single bloodiest day in American History (23,000 + Casualties) in one day.
True, but not quite accurate. Total about 3,650 killed, 17,300 wounded, 1,770 missing/Captured for a total of around 22,720.
By comparison, about 2,500 Americans died in the first 24 hours (D-Day) of the Normandy Invasion during WWII
@@seannovack3834 Yeah, I worded it wrong. I meant 23,000 including casualties. It's still far more than D-Day.
Been a top 2-3 movie of all-time for me from the 1st time I saw it in Junior High.
finally a video with a genuine reaction and not fakes reactions.
This was one of the most historically accurate movies about history. Taken in very large part from the letters of Robert Shaw, and documents from the period. Much like the movie Waterloo, historians love it.
Our Civil War sometimes presaged WWI, the attack on Ft. Wagner was one. The siege of Vicksburg was another. This was an epic movie. Broderick was a bit of a stretch to take seriously, given his work earlier in the '80s, but this movie completely worked. Flogging soldiers & sailors was abolished in the west mostly in this era or shortly following.
Glory should have won best picture the year it was nominated. This movie has really aged well.
I think I was 16 or 17 when I first saw this film, and I was inconsolable afterward, just sobbing and sobbing. This film is gut-wrenching.
makes me cry a minimum of three times everytime I watch it.
One of the most interesting and poignant question I've ever heard was "When was the last slave freed in America?" Such a simple question but very illuminating. Slavery is truly at the center of the history of America. So much of what is America cannot be understood unless you put slavery at the center of it all. There's a great video essay by the channel 'Knowing' Better' called 'Neoslavery' that goes through this very topic. Highly recommended.
You know that there are archaeological records that show that slavery has existed for at least 10 thousand years, and that it was considered normal in all societies of the world, and although there were people who talked about abolishing slavery, no one took real action. The US Civil War was the moment when the movement to abolish exclatitude began.
@@ESPER_Power I'm not saying this to you out of impertinence but rather out of courtesy; read more books about the history of slavery, particularly about the transatlantic slave trade and the abolitionist movement because you clearly have a fractured view of historical events. Apart from that, I'm having trouble understanding the point of your reply. It reads like an apologetic for slavery or at the very least an attempt to defend or naturalise american slavery. Because I certainly did not imply that slavery was not something that occured elsewhere eons ago in other parts of the world. My comment was about the ways in which the transatlantic slave trade has informed american history politics economics and society. If you can't be bothered to read books about it or even look up the wikipedia page, atleast watch the video that I recommended.
@@makon89 I believe that the one that needs to read a history book is you.
If by the transatlantic slave trade you mean the efforts made by the governments of Germany and England to end slavery in Africa, yes I know about that, I also know that it happened almost a decade after the US civil war and that England almost joined the confederate side for economic interests, but the war came to an end before that happened.
I also know that the people of England stopped paying the costs of ending slavery in Africa on their taxes only 10 years ago.
I also know of the movements that existed to put an end to slavery throughout the world but how they were unsuccessful.
I also know that the ones who profited the most from the transatlantic slave trade were the African kings who sold their own people, I don't know if you know this, but there was a king in Africa (I don't remember his name) who came to have a fortune equivalent to Rockefeller's for invading his neighbors and selling out his people as slaves.
My point is that after 10 thousand years of history, the end of slavery began at the end of the USA civil war. After that, all began to change.
@@ESPER_Power You put a wall of text with nonsense, so I'll point you to my previous comment.
@@makon89 Funny I would say the same about you and by the way if you do not believe what I said you are free to look for the information yourselve.
I think I went to see this 5 times when it was released. Such a powerful film.
00:40 Madison: "But today I am watching Glory... uh, to be completely transparent... honest with you guys I..."
Me: Don't you dare say you have seen this movie before grrrr...
Madison: "...had never even heard of this movie until a few days ago..."
Me: Okay, that was a curveball you threw there, Madison. I like re-actors to go in total blind... never even heard of movie until a few days ago... brilliant!