Tell the lady about the history of the Chinese admiral Zheng He’s seven voyages from 1405 to 1433. He commanded a huge fleet to sail from China to SE Asia and to East Africa. He traded tea, porcelain ware with the locals for spices on friendly terms. Later when the Dutch, Portuguese, Spaniards, British, and French came to Asia, they colonized, enslaved, plundered, and exploited the locals.
May the Grand Architect of this World punish the Europeans for their Brutality, thievery and debauchery... You are Right. All the Europeans did was, plunder, destroy and change the histories of the places they visited or colonized. now karma is back to bite where it hurts the most, their Ego. and that's why this host was soundly taught a good lesson in history and diplomacy as well as practical sophistication.
Well this podcast demonstrates very clearly the Standard and Quality of a Prof from Singapore Asian County and Prof from EU Poland, one talk about reality and another still living in a bubble 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Actually the Europeans are still speaking reality. You're not going to have a world where the United States is number two and the CCP is number one. I promise you that will not happen. Those df-41s Russian sarmots and minute mens will be flying everywhere before that ever happens.
Mahbubani is an amazing thinker and scholar, he has an amazing capacity to explain clearly and simple real controversial and hard to grap matters. It is always a pleasure to listen to him or read his books. Bonikovska had to challenge herself with the simplicity of the arguments as well as the friendly critics to things the Europeans like to make complicated, unaccessible often hiden in fear and taboo. She was irritated, not in a bad sence, but with herself, funny to watch. The elephant in the room, the one incredibly was avoided at all costs, like in a paralell reality where it just doesn't exists: Russia. Where is Russia? Russia made a strategic abrupt choice, already in 2020, to turn to Asia, and it was aware it will cut ties with Europe for many decades, unless western Europe learns. Mahbubani said it clearly, western Europe need to become more humble. Humbleness would definitely improve russia-eu relationship, but things are dark and war can even escalate to central and central eastern Europe. As things are now western Europe is building a wall in its eastern flank, that is so much to say, Europe is cutting ties with asia. As things are now in central eastern Europe they lost the access to Russia and its advantage to be near to Eurasia, meaning faster and cheaper transport costs to all parts of asia are gone. It will be no easy for Europe to make mea culpa.
I noticed the elephant in the room too. But, Mahbubani hinted at it by saying that "Europeans need to learn how to manage and get along with neighbouring great powers"
@@NoohCee You are blind to reality!! 80 % of Chinese territory is STOLEN!! Enough said about this evil dictatorship which destroys other cultures & civilizations just like how their western masters did!!
She is direct with her questions. But I applaud her for getting kishore on the show to answer her questions rather than a hawkish US person and also for giving time to hear the full answer without unnecessary interruptions.
It is unfortunate that too many like her are in academia in the EU. Virtual signaling and uncompromising moralizing behavior has become the core culture in western universities.
The "condescending attitude" is ubiquitous among the self identified "Academia" and loathing in the western world in general. But, You are right, at least she realizes that there is a Singapore. A US Congressman famously grilled the Singaporean CEO of TikTok why he is not a part of China. The congressman didn't know there is a Singapore nation and a China nation. Every one who "looks like Asian" is a secret agent of China. 🙄. No cure for Ignorance and Arrogance. Kishore is much more GRACIOUS than I would be.
Too eager to speak. Lacking patience or unwillingness to listen and internalise what Prof Kishore has explained. Too blinded. So blinded and foolish to think narrowly from perspective of a choice choosing between India and China when in fact Europe can choose both and more.
Obviusly they are still blinded by their self possessed superiority. Still halucinating about their past glory n conquest. Can't accept d. Fact that they r being used n manipulated by the US empire n preventing them to be independent in pursuing their own interests. Case in point the destruction of Nord stream pipelines n d intentional de industrialization of Europe.
This professor is wise, truthful and intelligent. Very knowledgeable and convincing basing on facts and truth! The interviewer's tough questions has been perfectly answered by the professor.
How is she lecturer at any University? Is this the best can Poland offer? And why is she so eagerly proud about her hate for China. She is closer to being radical than a lecturer. Glad Kishore lectured her properly. It's her choice if she take it or ignore it.
That host seem like a simple school girl schooled by a headmaster. She looked puzzled and confused by the lesson. On the other side, Mahbubani can be regard as a spokesman and representative for ASEAN with his energy and drive.
Proud Western Europe only knows they are free and independent but subconsciously or unconsciously acting just like a junior partner or vassal states of US's. And US is very pleased with Europe's behavior now.
It is astounding to see Madam Bonikowska's lack of knowledge about global affairs. This is what happens when Western-centric narratives populate Europeans' mindsets. And she is supposedly the president of International Relations and lecturer at the University of Warsaw-this is wretched.
@@donaldjoseph3903 Lol! But Hasan is the type to ambush guests. We are looking for a genuine conversation, not a lopsided one. We hope for Madam Bonikowska to be more engaged and probe more rather than ask the same core questions.
No, it's just your pro China and in the West we're not we never will be. So what you do is you take what Keisha says as fact as if because he says it will be. But the ones in power in the United States will not do that. They will not allow that. They even have a doctrine for called The wolfowitz doctrine. Nothing's going to change their trajectory of the United States no matter what.
As Asians, we can agree that east Europeans are lost cause. Lmao. They getting braindrained by the western Europe while blaming China and Russia for everything they failed. Lol.
@@TacticalMayo So you're "tearing apart China" easily in your dream or what? Cuz, we hear hardly any bitching from China but whole lot of drama coming from the west and its vassal states. lol.
The western reporter is jaundiced in their view and really disrespectful and condescending about Asia and China. Well done, Professor, for speaking out.
She seems to insist on choosing sides. This is bizarre. Why can't she understand the very simple idea: be a friend to everyone. As Lincoln put it, with malice toward none; with charity for all...
@tannhaeuserx464, she can't see beyond "choosing sides" and "domination" because the US forced Poland and everyone else in Europe to choose sides and now has Europe under its heel. She can't break away from the notion that China won't do the same. She needs to read more about the history of China, Sun Tzu's The Art of War and Confucianism to realise that China is not the US or Europe. That is, China doesn't plunder, kill or steal from other countries.
That is the tragedy of Poland, having no idea of who they are and what is the best strategy for their long term interest. Polish researches are like this in almost all forums I watch!
Europeans should have more collaborative discussions with Asian countries as kishore suggests. That way they can see things from a different perspective and also learn how Asians solve problems.
@@patrickgzit won't because you're not going to have a peaceful acceptance of number two by the United States. You won't. I promise you. I'm an American. You really really, really really won't.
It seems that European leaders will only react when the problems are already manifesting. Such as at the moment, the closure of businesses due to the end of cheap energy, problems with refugees and migrants. They don't seem to be able to see potential problems before they become too big.
Because they don't plan long term and are unable to see beyond their big noses. The West think they are superior to others on the planet and that the status quo of Western dominations of the world will last forever and ever. They refused to believe the Asian century is already on the doorstep.
after read all the comments , clearly see how majority feel of the difference in thought and wisdom. Sadly to say that most of the western leaders still ignore the reality changing world. still "lock in their perception" no surprise what will happen not even close to 2050 as Prof. Kishore refer, it will significantly effect very sooner
Haha she was not smart enough to comprehend 😅 But fundamentally, Asians are not that expansionary and aggressive. So that's why it's hard for European to see why a big country wouldn't immediately take over all neighboring countries
@@TacticalMayoWhat do you lie? Has ASEAN members ever started a war against any Western Countries including the UK, France, Germany, Italy, Belgium, Spain and Portugal. Conversely, the above mentioned Countries were the colonists against Asia Countries.
China is the notable communist dictatorship that follows exactly the European Church's expansionary & imperialist policy in Asia & the world!! Their deep conflict with India, USA as well as Asean powers is PROOF enough!!
I'm American and for all my life I saw China as a threat until I started reading about war history. Americans can choose to live in ignorance or leave the ideological bubble and open their eyes to the world of many different and successful nations. The decline of education and literacy in the US is seriously frightening and allows the lobby controlled gov to manipulate our view of the world
You're still stuck in the delusion that somehow the United States will be number two and that's just how it is. I promise you that's not going to happen.
"Don't you see that it's a kind of domination..." - maybe it's a language thing, but sorry that's really condescending. Are you suggesting that Asians cannot see and interpret things with their own wisdom?
As an Indian I can tell you this much, there are no permanent friends or enemies. Also between partners you don't need to agree on everything. Take specific issues and deal with it case by case. Don't make stupid statements like we are enemies or friends. Just take each specific case and see if you like to partner on a specific issue or not. For the next issue start with clean slate
J'aime beaucoup l'analyse géopolitique de Kishore, il explique simplement ce que le reste du monde comprend, ce que la vielle Europe ne veut pas voir. Le monde a changé grâce en partie à cette Europe conquérante. Maintenant il faut accepter de concevoir un nouveau monde.
Now I understand why some Poles are hopeless when it comes to global geopolitics. And how some of their academia are stuck in the media narrative that distorts the reality of Asia and the inability the see another point of view in managing global affairs with multi-civilizational & multi-cultural attitudes that are significantly different but no less effective from the European civilizations. I salute Kishore for trying hard. But I think it might have all been lost.
it's best for every body if neither China or India dominates Asia，and ASEAN is devoted in keeping that delicate balance，and Europe should join the ASEAN countries in doing so. That's Mr. Mabuhani's key point and as a Chinese I think he's right.
ASEAN makes itself a platform of talks amongst those big players. And EU makes itself a battlefield between big players, both military and economically. EU needs independent policies to avoid this geographic disaster, not simply follow NATO or US. Understanding the global south better is the base of these independent policies. I think that's the message Kishore Mahbubani try to deliver.
But if you challenged the United States of America for their number one spot. It doesn't matter what Europe thinks Alfred or anyone because all it's going to take is what the reaction of the United States does. Cuz that's all it takes literally just them.
She doesn't seem to get it 🙄🙄🙄 Still stuck with the colonial mentality 🤦🏻♂️ One cringes at her questions. Thanks for giving her the lecture of her sheltered life KM.
This Lady exemplifies Western backward attitudes, stuck in zero sum thinking and unable to progress through mutual respect and cooperation for the benefit of all peoples, the whole planet. As a Swiss living in Asia, more and more often I feel ashamed and troubled about European cowardice and stupidity in the geopolitical context.
It's not stuck. They're telling you the US is going to stay top dog. It's not an option. It's either that or same thing that happened 100 years ago with Germany and Japan.
@@TacticalMayo Lmao, the f**k you and west gonna do? Start nuclear war? Their f*scist asses got humbled in Ukraine. Now they trying to get out of this never ending war desperately. Lol.
Amazing Kishore. Amazing insight. Equally ‘amazing’ is the dumbness, arrogance, condescending attitude of so many westerners, especially those holding important positions, as represented in this madam, who only seem to be able to project themselves instead of trying to understand other cultures.
The fact in your mind that you think we would give up everything that comes with being number one is delusional beyond anything I have ever read someone right. You're not taking a crown from our hands. You'll have to pry it out of our radioactive palms.
Lessons in pragmatism and humility is long due. Also the notion of human rights seems to be the prerogative of the usual privileged in the minds of those who have it and used to this mindset. Others are simply not encouraged to improve their situation. Even frequently not allowed!
Oh so what you're saying is for them to accept? Well sir, I promise you that will never happen. That's not even an option ever I mean ever as long as the Earth exists.
It's bitterly ironic how the West made such a song and dance for decades about tearing down the Iron Curtain and The Wall and yet its spent the decades since that was achieved trying to put up new ones
Interesting! 1- poland to-my-opinion struggling for self-determination (half excepting and half rejecting EU) 2- singapore a powerful global player in term of finance - ruled by a chinese speaking elite (indigene people seemed to be marginalized, but perhaps they are benefitting well?) 3- africa still in the trap of neocolonializm (some radial leaders trying to escape by force - wish them good-luck!) 4- world facing war-desaster (global institution like UN failing to handle Israel-apardheid and US-imperialism - similar to failure of
Korea (South and North) not to be unestimated. Their tech is stellar: better than China, in my opinion. If the chaebol corruption is kept in check and they don't try to dilute standards by working with shoddy partners in other parts of Asia, they'd lead the tech scene. Vietnam is fierce. South-East Asia is definitely a bridge between East and West. Nepal where I am from have lots of young people who've studied and lived abroad--we don't have tech and industry but we have soft power. Plus ability to coexist between China and India. An important skill ("we know how to handle the giants") which Singapore has mastered with great finesse. Japan aging but still who else can hit Mach 10?
Just look at Germany economy today .. What happened now and Why it has become to be in this sad state economically. . Which was once upon a time the 4th largest economy in the world and largest in Europe .. Germany would be wise to look after its own National interests and its Citizens
The host is either completely ignorant of what's going on outside OECD and very narrow minded, or is really great actress - playing naive person, who hears all these facts for the first time
The American investmens are strategic, with the goal to build American bases around China. They are less interessted in the people in South East Asia. Containing Russia and China seems the only inteterest of American polititians.
Wanita ini ngotot karena singapore kaya makmur karena AS dan barat , ngotot pilih china ato india pikiran ngadu domba , wanita ini tidak ingin china tumbuh besar .
US is dropping to #2. and we all know the jealous wife will never tolerate a probable rival mistress #3 in her orbit. Wife is not afraid of the husband, just as the US is not afraid of China; they are afraid any bloc (EU/India) that will challenge/replace her #2 position. My advise to ASEAN is never to challenge US #2 position (#4 should be safe), and that China #1 must help consolidate his wife's position beyond any doubt.
Why did the host not be honest and declare from the start that she believes China is bad period and ask Kishore for confirmation instead of dancing around the edge? I doubt it if she actually knows where China is other than what she has been propaganda fed daily by her own and other western press.
Is she a Prosecutor interrogates suspect? She has shown no respect at all to more senior and more experiences Prof. K. Mahbubani. Please don't show her face again in this channel.
The lady seems to listen too much to western narrativ and propaganda we most of us in Europe are blocking. Being more humble towards Asia as the professor mentioned, would save Europe from going down with USA on one side - and Ukraine on the other. A sinking ship… 😪
🩶US / America calls it "Liberation" instead of "Invasion". That was what US call it in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Somalia and the list goes on... Why the double standard? Confused... Please enlighten. Genuine question... Instances of the United States "liberated" or overthrowing, or attempting to overthrow, a foreign government since the Second World War. (* indicates successful ouster of a government) China 1949 to early 1960s Albania 1949-53 East Germany 1950s Iran 1953 * Guatemala 1954 * Costa Rica mid-1950s Syria 1956-7 Egypt 1957 Indonesia 1957-8 British Guiana 1953-64 * Iraq 1963 * North Vietnam 1945-73 Cambodia 1955-70 * Laos 1958 *, 1959 *, 1960 * Ecuador 1960-63 * Congo 1960 * France 1965 Brazil 1962-64 * Dominican Republic 1963 * Cuba 1959 to present Bolivia 1964 * Indonesia 1965 * Ghana 1966 * Chile 1964-73 * Greece 1967 * Costa Rica 1970-71 Bolivia 1971 * Australia 1973-75 * Angola 1975, 1980s Zaire 1975 Portugal 1974-76 * Jamaica 1976-80 * Seychelles 1979-81 Chad 1981-82 * Grenada 1983 * South Yemen 1982-84 Suriname 1982-84 Fiji 1987 * Libya 1980s Nicaragua 1981-90 * Panama 1989 * Bulgaria 1990 * Albania 1991 * Iraq 1991 Afghanistan 1980s * Somalia 1993 Yugoslavia 1999-2000 * Ecuador 2000 * Afghanistan 2001 * Venezuela 2002 * Iraq 2003 * Haiti 2004 * Somalia 2007 to present Honduras 2009 * Libya 2011 * Syria 2012 Ukraine 2014 * 2014 - 2022 - 9 countries yet to verify. Pakistan 2022 * Haiti 2022 * Niger 2023 Bolivia 2024
This lady is utterly confused and cant even seem to understand what Kishore is saying. Hard to imagine she has a PhD; and teaches IR. I would be concerned for any student that she teaches or was in her classes - need to get a refund on those useless degrees.
Her qualification equate to Permanent Head Damaged PHD. She lack the intellectual capacity of Kishore Geopolitics knowledge. Majulah Singapura Kishore Mahbubani.😅😅😅😅😅
@@TacticalMayo China will eventually be 2x size of US economy if they can get their per capita to only half of US. China will be more powerful than US, imperial Japan, Nazi germany and Soviet Union combined. At least in terms of output
Tell the lady about the history of the Chinese admiral Zheng He’s seven voyages from 1405 to 1433. He commanded a huge fleet to sail from China to SE Asia and to East Africa. He traded tea, porcelain ware with the locals for spices on friendly terms. Later when the Dutch, Portuguese, Spaniards, British, and French came to Asia, they colonized, enslaved, plundered, and exploited the locals.
May the Grand Architect of this World punish the Europeans for their Brutality, thievery and debauchery...
You are Right. All the Europeans did was, plunder, destroy and change the histories of the places they visited or colonized. now karma is back to bite where it hurts the most, their Ego. and that's why this host was soundly taught a good lesson in history and diplomacy as well as practical sophistication.
@@R.G.9795 Why should we educate her for her lack of preparation in her work? Mean she is incompetent and lack interest, only for jobwise.
Well this podcast demonstrates very clearly the Standard and Quality of a Prof from Singapore Asian County and Prof from EU Poland, one talk about reality and another still living in a bubble 🤣🤣🤣🤣
Actually the Europeans are still speaking reality. You're not going to have a world where the United States is number two and the CCP is number one. I promise you that will not happen. Those df-41s Russian sarmots and minute mens will be flying everywhere before that ever happens.
No. They were living under the rock for the last 20 years or longer
Mahbubani is an amazing thinker and scholar, he has an amazing capacity to explain clearly and simple real controversial and hard to grap matters. It is always a pleasure to listen to him or read his books. Bonikovska had to challenge herself with the simplicity of the arguments as well as the friendly critics to things the Europeans like to make complicated, unaccessible often hiden in fear and taboo. She was irritated, not in a bad sence, but with herself, funny to watch. The elephant in the room, the one incredibly was avoided at all costs, like in a paralell reality where it just doesn't exists: Russia. Where is Russia? Russia made a strategic abrupt choice, already in 2020, to turn to Asia, and it was aware it will cut ties with Europe for many decades, unless western Europe learns. Mahbubani said it clearly, western Europe need to become more humble. Humbleness would definitely improve russia-eu relationship, but things are dark and war can even escalate to central and central eastern Europe. As things are now western Europe is building a wall in its eastern flank, that is so much to say, Europe is cutting ties with asia. As things are now in central eastern Europe they lost the access to Russia and its advantage to be near to Eurasia, meaning faster and cheaper transport costs to all parts of asia are gone. It will be no easy for Europe to make mea culpa.
I noticed the elephant in the room too. But, Mahbubani hinted at it by saying that "Europeans need to learn how to manage and get along with neighbouring great powers"
True!! BUT... Kishore is unnecessarily TOO SOFT on China/#CCP & it's crimes against humanity!!
Very intelligent professor. I am American living in Thailand 40 years. He's 100 percent right
The host has been taught a lesson in history, diplomacy and pragmatism by Kishore.
She comes across not only ignorant but has an European supremacist attitude, sorry lady, you’ve been living under a rock 😂
Does this ignorant woman not realise South East Asian is a big ethnically Chinese?! Kishore is so patient, teaching her a history lesson!
Kishore is definitely a smart & intelligent man but he is also definitely biased or paid to favor Chinese dictatorship & Asean!!
@@rka-truthalwayswins5127 you are no better than the host. So sad.
@@NoohCee You are blind to reality!! 80 % of Chinese territory is STOLEN!! Enough said about this evil dictatorship which destroys other cultures & civilizations just like how their western masters did!!
This lady seems to look down on China as most westerners .
She is direct with her questions. But I applaud her for getting kishore on the show to answer her questions rather than a hawkish US person and also for giving time to hear the full answer without unnecessary interruptions.
It is unfortunate that too many like her are in academia in the EU. Virtual signaling and uncompromising moralizing behavior has become the core culture in western universities.
The "condescending attitude" is ubiquitous among the self identified "Academia" and loathing in the western world in general.
But, You are right, at least she realizes that there is a Singapore.
A US Congressman famously grilled the Singaporean CEO of TikTok why he is not a part of China. The congressman didn't know there is a Singapore nation and a China nation. Every one who "looks like Asian" is a secret agent of China. 🙄.
No cure for Ignorance and Arrogance.
Kishore is much more GRACIOUS than I would be.
Too eager to speak. Lacking patience or unwillingness to listen and internalise what Prof Kishore has explained. Too blinded. So blinded and foolish to think narrowly from perspective of a choice choosing between India and China when in fact Europe can choose both and more.
As she should because RUclips is Western, it's American.🇺🇸 Never forget that.
Kishore Mahbubani never disappoints 😂😂😂😂😂
He's one of the BEST ❤️ and WELL INFORMED speakers on INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS!
I feel the deep frustration of Kishore trying to explain the world to a European, even worst to a Polish.
Obviusly they are still blinded by their self possessed superiority. Still halucinating about their past glory n conquest. Can't accept d. Fact that they r being used n manipulated by the US empire n preventing them to be independent in pursuing their own interests. Case in point the destruction of Nord stream pipelines n d intentional de industrialization of Europe.
Kishore, a voice of reason... a brilliant human 👏
Unite not divide!
This professor is wise, truthful and intelligent. Very knowledgeable and convincing basing on facts and truth! The interviewer's tough questions has been perfectly answered by the professor.
This is diplomacy at its highest- especially dealing with the un-enlightened.
How is she lecturer at any University? Is this the best can Poland offer? And why is she so eagerly proud about her hate for China. She is closer to being radical than a lecturer. Glad Kishore lectured her properly. It's her choice if she take it or ignore it.
They even hate d Russians more who r closer to them than Asians.
That host seem like a simple school girl schooled by a headmaster. She looked puzzled and confused by the lesson. On the other side, Mahbubani can be regard as a spokesman and representative for ASEAN with his energy and drive.
The western mind block.
@@Way827 Western wooden block. They thought they are very smart but actually they are the opposite.
Proud Western Europe only knows they are free and independent but subconsciously or unconsciously acting just like a junior partner or vassal states of US's. And US is very pleased with Europe's behavior now.
She isn't western European at all!! She like all east European countries are former slaves of the soviet communist block!!
He is giving this woman a lesson.
Absolutely not because in the west nothing's going to change how we see it. Nothing will.
The best professor,author. We like to listen to him whenever he start to talk. Always speak with sense.
It is astounding to see Madam Bonikowska's lack of knowledge about global affairs. This is what happens when Western-centric narratives populate Europeans' mindsets. And she is supposedly the president of International Relations and lecturer at the University of Warsaw-this is wretched.
Western Ignorance and Arrogance on full display. 🙄.
I mean if you're leftist pro China shill you would say that but whatever.
@@gingermintrose from her other videos I presume that center is a one person cabinet.
She's too kind and nice. If Kishore meets Al Jazeera's Mehdi Hasan, Kishore will be knock out..
@@donaldjoseph3903 Lol! But Hasan is the type to ambush guests. We are looking for a genuine conversation, not a lopsided one. We hope for Madam Bonikowska to be more engaged and probe more rather than ask the same core questions.
Is this the quality of university prof in Poland?
Im surperised, i did not expect that low.
No, it's just your pro China and in the West we're not we never will be. So what you do is you take what Keisha says as fact as if because he says it will be. But the ones in power in the United States will not do that. They will not allow that. They even have a doctrine for called The wolfowitz doctrine. Nothing's going to change their trajectory of the United States no matter what.
Now we, Asian, understand why East European can’t get along with Russia😂
As Asians, we can agree that east Europeans are lost cause. Lmao. They getting braindrained by the western Europe while blaming China and Russia for everything they failed. Lol.
Totally agree. They will pay for their stupidity and evil.
She tried really hard to tear apart china and ASEAN
It's not trying when it comes to China that's easy.
@@TacticalMayosaid some Cia shill
@@WonderfulFreshwaterLake no, I'm not. I don't like them either. Nope, none of them. I don't like not one of them.
@@TacticalMayo So you're "tearing apart China" easily in your dream or what? Cuz, we hear hardly any bitching from China but whole lot of drama coming from the west and its vassal states. lol.
@@TacticalMayoNice try, we know you are.
Now you see the standard of phd in Europe. Why are people still persuing higher education in Europe?
Western education leads to Ignorance and Arrogance. She is example of western Academia 🙄.
The western reporter is jaundiced in their view and really disrespectful and condescending about Asia and China. Well done, Professor, for speaking out.
Yes we are and we will be that way military as well.
Y@@TacticalMayo you're schtick is so transparent...lol
@@TacticalMayo You ain't gonna do shit, lil bro. Your navi fleet got clapped by Houthis and ran away from the Red Sea, you should worry about that.
She seems to insist on choosing sides. This is bizarre. Why can't she understand the very simple idea: be a friend to everyone. As Lincoln put it, with malice toward none; with charity for all...
Oh you have no choice. Everyone will have to. The United States will make sure of it.
@tannhaeuserx464, she can't see beyond "choosing sides" and "domination" because the US forced Poland and everyone else in Europe to choose sides and now has Europe under its heel. She can't break away from the notion that China won't do the same. She needs to read more about the history of China, Sun Tzu's The Art of War and Confucianism to realise that China is not the US or Europe. That is, China doesn't plunder, kill or steal from other countries.
That is the tragedy of Poland, having no idea of who they are and what is the best strategy for their long term interest. Polish researches are like this in almost all forums I watch!
Great! Thank you again for a very informative engagement with Prof Kishore M. - EJT Tirona, Philippines.
Europeans should have more collaborative discussions with Asian countries as kishore suggests. That way they can see things from a different perspective and also learn how Asians solve problems.
this evolution of the mindset will take generations
What you want is for them to walk away from the US. That's not an option ever.
@@patrickgzit won't because you're not going to have a peaceful acceptance of number two by the United States. You won't. I promise you. I'm an American. You really really, really really won't.
Respect!!! Respect!!!! Respect!!!!
It seems that European leaders will only react when the problems are already manifesting. Such as at the moment, the closure of businesses due to the end of cheap energy, problems with refugees and migrants. They don't seem to be able to see potential problems before they become too big.
Because they don't plan long term and are unable to see beyond their big noses. The West think they are superior to others on the planet and that the status quo of Western dominations of the world will last forever and ever. They refused to believe the Asian century is already on the doorstep.
RUclips deleted my innocuous reply to your comment. I do not know by what criteria they are unhappy with the comments I made.
@@raymondtay9442 This is hypocrisy of American style of freedom of speech!!
after read all the comments , clearly see how majority feel of the difference in thought and wisdom. Sadly to say that most of the western leaders still ignore the reality changing world. still "lock in their perception" no surprise what will happen not even close to 2050 as Prof. Kishore refer, it will significantly effect very sooner
Shit, you mean?
Eurocentric view has to change and it’s not bowing to US and adopting their view.
Haha she was not smart enough to comprehend 😅
But fundamentally, Asians are not that expansionary and aggressive. So that's why it's hard for European to see why a big country wouldn't immediately take over all neighboring countries
That's a lie
@@TacticalMayoWhat do you lie?
Has ASEAN members ever started a war against any Western Countries including the UK, France, Germany, Italy, Belgium, Spain and Portugal.
Conversely, the above mentioned Countries were the colonists against Asia Countries.
@@TacticalMayo 无知
China is the notable communist dictatorship that follows exactly the European Church's expansionary & imperialist policy in Asia & the world!! Their deep conflict with India, USA as well as Asean powers is PROOF enough!!
I'm American and for all my life I saw China as a threat until I started reading about war history. Americans can choose to live in ignorance or leave the ideological bubble and open their eyes to the world of many different and successful nations. The decline of education and literacy in the US is seriously frightening and allows the lobby controlled gov to manipulate our view of the world
china is not like germany or russia that occupied poland and other nations. china has lived in peace with most neighbours for thousands of years.
BS!! India, Vietnam, Philippines,....??!!!
STOP LYING!! 80% China, of today is STOLEN Territory!!
Asian very welcome Europe. Hopefully Europe think of himself and ensuring world peace and thrive.
She's stuck in the delusion of seeing Jonnie Foreigner as bad, just because they are foreign.
You're still stuck in the delusion that somehow the United States will be number two and that's just how it is. I promise you that's not going to happen.
"Don't you see that it's a kind of domination..." - maybe it's a language thing, but sorry that's really condescending. Are you suggesting that Asians cannot see and interpret things with their own wisdom?
If Asean's trade with China increases, that means Asean is being dominated by China??? She needs to look up the meaning of the word 'trade'.
Wow. This is a clear case of what we call “street smart” n “book smart”!!
As an Indian I can tell you this much, there are no permanent friends or enemies. Also between partners you don't need to agree on everything. Take specific issues and deal with it case by case. Don't make stupid statements like we are enemies or friends. Just take each specific case and see if you like to partner on a specific issue or not. For the next issue start with clean slate
J'aime beaucoup l'analyse géopolitique de Kishore, il explique simplement ce que le reste du monde comprend, ce que la vielle Europe ne veut pas voir. Le monde a changé grâce en partie à cette Europe conquérante. Maintenant il faut accepter de concevoir un nouveau monde.
Wow. How long was this woman living under the rock ? Seem like the last time she came out was 20 years ago.
Now I understand why some Poles are hopeless when it comes to global geopolitics. And how some of their academia are stuck in the media narrative that distorts the reality of Asia and the inability the see another point of view in managing global affairs with multi-civilizational & multi-cultural attitudes that are significantly different but no less effective from the European civilizations. I salute Kishore for trying hard. But I think it might have all been lost.
We like this professor, he can explain very well China history.
She wants to drive a wedge between India and China and completely ignore ASEAN. Divide and conquer.
G7 is sunset nation whereas BRICs is sunrise nations.. that's best one
Proud to be asean and Asian 🎉🎉
That arrogant woman justly and humbly got schooled about pragmatic attitude 😂
Are you ready for the party?
@@TacticalMayoGo see a shrink.
@@NoohCee I hope you like fallout 4 ☢️
Professor Kishore Mahubani great scholar 21 century,he try present very realistic geopolitical and economic reality.
Total different mentality!!!!
it's best for every body if neither China or India dominates Asia，and ASEAN is devoted in keeping that delicate balance，and Europe should join the ASEAN countries in doing so. That's Mr. Mabuhani's key point and as a Chinese I think he's right.
ASEAN makes itself a platform of talks amongst those big players. And EU makes itself a battlefield between big players, both military and economically. EU needs independent policies to avoid this geographic disaster, not simply follow NATO or US. Understanding the global south better is the base of these independent policies.
I think that's the message Kishore Mahbubani try to deliver.
Very well put! Spot on.
But if you challenged the United States of America for their number one spot. It doesn't matter what Europe thinks Alfred or anyone because all it's going to take is what the reaction of the United States does. Cuz that's all it takes literally just them.
She doesn't seem to get it 🙄🙄🙄
Still stuck with the colonial mentality 🤦🏻♂️
One cringes at her questions.
Thanks for giving her the lecture of her sheltered life KM.
Kishore 👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻
This Lady exemplifies Western backward attitudes, stuck in zero sum thinking and unable to progress through mutual respect and cooperation for the benefit of all peoples, the whole planet.
As a Swiss living in Asia, more and more often I feel ashamed and troubled about European cowardice and stupidity in the geopolitical context.
It's not stuck. They're telling you the US is going to stay top dog. It's not an option. It's either that or same thing that happened 100 years ago with Germany and Japan.
@@TacticalMayo Lmao, the f**k you and west gonna do? Start nuclear war? Their f*scist asses got humbled in Ukraine. Now they trying to get out of this never ending war desperately. Lol.
@@TacticalMayolol pay back the debt you owe us the Chinese ok
Kishore is too modest not to mention US's bulk of invest in Asia is in SINGAPORE.
The wise man of Asia is telling Europe to grow up! 😂
😂😅Lee Kuan Yew..before he pass on..was asked.
Who is the best European leader ? His answer " Putin "😂😅
EU countries has a lot to learn from Asia. For the past half a century Asia has learnt a lot from the west and it's time for the reverse
Amazing Kishore. Amazing insight. Equally ‘amazing’ is the dumbness, arrogance, condescending attitude of so many westerners, especially those holding important positions, as represented in this madam, who only seem to be able to project themselves instead of trying to understand other cultures.
The fact in your mind that you think we would give up everything that comes with being number one is delusional beyond anything I have ever read someone right. You're not taking a crown from our hands. You'll have to pry it out of our radioactive palms.
Her ignorance of Asia is astounding for a professor.
Lessons in pragmatism and humility is long due. Also the notion of human rights seems to be the prerogative of the usual privileged in the minds of those who have it and used to this mindset. Others are simply not encouraged to improve their situation. Even frequently not allowed!
Oh so what you're saying is for them to accept? Well sir, I promise you that will never happen. That's not even an option ever I mean ever as long as the Earth exists.
It's bitterly ironic how the West made such a song and dance for decades about tearing down the Iron Curtain and The Wall and yet its spent the decades since that was achieved trying to put up new ones
Goldman Sachs.....see Prof got to quote this fella otherwise this woman won't believe. 😂😂😂😂😂
You think that matters to those in power in the United States?
Dr. Kishore has the Maturity and Patience of Buddha, Allah, a saint, . . .
Nonsense
@@TacticalMayo is your comments
Buddha/Saints are great but what is Allah??!!
i wil not surprise if in the future europe turn into new "afrika" while afrika and asia shoaring to the top
As a professor, With her ignorance about asia, we all ordinary youtubers can also be professor like her
Cannot blame her..30 years of western propaganda...she grew up inside the American bubble...😅😊😂
He is not teaching but telling about the facts
The host asked good questions but was very opinionated about China and ASEAN. Enlightened to hear the guest's responses.
Nice to see the brilliant European lady teach and school the short little brown Asian man.
I live in Europe but I barely make my living, I am working in noble profession and I am inventor too.
I have been plundered.
😢Excellent Conversation 💔
Interesting!
1- poland to-my-opinion struggling for self-determination (half excepting and half rejecting EU)
2- singapore a powerful global player in term of finance - ruled by a chinese speaking elite (indigene people seemed to be marginalized, but perhaps they are benefitting well?)
3- africa still in the trap of neocolonializm (some radial leaders trying to escape by force - wish them good-luck!)
4- world facing war-desaster (global institution like UN failing to handle Israel-apardheid and US-imperialism - similar to failure of
Collapse of Fiat currency is exponentially proportional to paucity of purchase of West's debt.
We do business with both China and India.
India is 30 years behind China
More like 70 years. Sorry but I don't see india doing what chines has done. No way. The gap for the moment too big and the education level too widen
Excellent.
Goodness sakes ASEAN has been dealing with far richer US and Europe. We had to also work around domination there.
Euros are so full of it😂
Korea (South and North) not to be unestimated. Their tech is stellar: better than China, in my opinion. If the chaebol corruption is kept in check and they don't try to dilute standards by working with shoddy partners in other parts of Asia, they'd lead the tech scene.
Vietnam is fierce. South-East Asia is definitely a bridge between East and West.
Nepal where I am from have lots of young people who've studied and lived abroad--we don't have tech and industry but we have soft power. Plus ability to coexist between China and India. An important skill ("we know how to handle the giants") which Singapore has mastered with great finesse.
Japan aging but still who else can hit Mach 10?
You cannot have intelligent conversation with one of old world mentality.
👌👌👌👍👍👍👏👏👏
Just look at Germany economy today .. What happened now and Why it has become to be in this sad state economically. . Which was once upon a time the 4th largest economy in the world and largest in Europe .. Germany would be wise to look after its own National interests and its Citizens
Pose should be more worried about the situation with Russian. Don't think they will survive if the Russians got too angry
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
The host is either completely ignorant of what's going on outside OECD and very narrow minded, or is really great actress - playing naive person, who hears all these facts for the first time
Typical political expert in Eastern Europe.
Great man talk great.
The American investmens are strategic, with the goal to build American bases around China. They are less interessted in the people in South East Asia. Containing Russia and China seems the only inteterest of American polititians.
Thank you to esteemed seniors for sharing.
Wanita ini ngotot karena singapore kaya makmur karena AS dan barat , ngotot pilih china ato india pikiran ngadu domba , wanita ini tidak ingin china tumbuh besar .
No we don't want them to grow big. We won't let them grow bigger than us. For you, you want it like that for us Americans Western we won't allow it
US is dropping to #2. and we all know the jealous wife will never tolerate a probable rival mistress #3 in her orbit. Wife is not afraid of the husband, just as the US is not afraid of China; they are afraid any bloc (EU/India) that will challenge/replace her #2 position. My advise to ASEAN is never to challenge US #2 position (#4 should be safe), and that China #1 must help consolidate his wife's position beyond any doubt.
This is beyond her understanding!
😮😮
Remember China & India were Superpowers in the past for centuries!
They deleted comment criticizing them. What a hypocrite ?
Lady freaking out cause her story is old and outdated
Why did the host not be honest and declare from the start that she believes China is bad period and ask Kishore for confirmation instead of dancing around the edge?
I doubt it if she actually knows where China is other than what she has been propaganda fed daily by her own and other western press.
Albania should join BRICS.
Is she a Prosecutor interrogates suspect? She has shown no respect at all to more senior and more experiences Prof. K. Mahbubani. Please don't show her face again in this channel.
This is a United States social media platform. If you people don't like it, make your own.
@@TacticalMayo And the f*ck you gonna do if we talk shit about your breed on your own platform while shitting on it?
The poles got a little bit richer and start to behave like those western power. Too young and too naive
The lady seems to listen too much to western narrativ and propaganda we most of us in Europe are blocking. Being more humble towards Asia as the professor mentioned, would save Europe from going down with USA on one side - and Ukraine on the other. A sinking ship… 😪
🩶US / America calls it "Liberation" instead of "Invasion". That was what US call it in Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Syria, Yemen, Somalia and the list goes on... Why the double standard? Confused... Please enlighten. Genuine question...
Instances of the United States "liberated" or overthrowing, or attempting to overthrow, a foreign government since the Second World War. (* indicates successful ouster of a government)
China 1949 to early 1960s
Albania 1949-53
East Germany 1950s
Iran 1953 *
Guatemala 1954 *
Costa Rica mid-1950s
Syria 1956-7
Egypt 1957
Indonesia 1957-8
British Guiana 1953-64 *
Iraq 1963 *
North Vietnam 1945-73
Cambodia 1955-70 *
Laos 1958 *, 1959 *, 1960 *
Ecuador 1960-63 *
Congo 1960 *
France 1965
Brazil 1962-64 *
Dominican Republic 1963 *
Cuba 1959 to present
Bolivia 1964 *
Indonesia 1965 *
Ghana 1966 *
Chile 1964-73 *
Greece 1967 *
Costa Rica 1970-71
Bolivia 1971 *
Australia 1973-75 *
Angola 1975, 1980s
Zaire 1975
Portugal 1974-76 *
Jamaica 1976-80 *
Seychelles 1979-81
Chad 1981-82 *
Grenada 1983 *
South Yemen 1982-84
Suriname 1982-84
Fiji 1987 *
Libya 1980s
Nicaragua 1981-90 *
Panama 1989 *
Bulgaria 1990 *
Albania 1991 *
Iraq 1991
Afghanistan 1980s *
Somalia 1993
Yugoslavia 1999-2000 *
Ecuador 2000 *
Afghanistan 2001 *
Venezuela 2002 *
Iraq 2003 *
Haiti 2004 *
Somalia 2007 to present
Honduras 2009 *
Libya 2011 *
Syria 2012
Ukraine 2014 *
2014 - 2022 - 9 countries yet to verify.
Pakistan 2022 *
Haiti 2022 *
Niger 2023
Bolivia 2024
If it wasn't for the fact that you're $0.50 bot, someone would care.
@@TacticalMayo Your breed is funny when it projects itself. Lmao.
@@MGZetta Judging by that user's name (TacticalMayo )and English level, probably Japanese, good dog~
I downloaded 3.2M copies.
This lady is utterly confused and cant even seem to understand what Kishore is saying. Hard to imagine she has a PhD; and teaches IR. I would be concerned for any student that she teaches or was in her classes - need to get a refund on those useless degrees.
It's not that it's the fact that it will not be accepted. You will get the same thing you got a hundred years ago with Japan and Germany.
Her qualification equate to Permanent Head Damaged PHD. She lack the intellectual capacity of Kishore Geopolitics knowledge. Majulah Singapura Kishore Mahbubani.😅😅😅😅😅
@@TacticalMayo China will eventually be 2x size of US economy if they can get their per capita to only half of US. China will be more powerful than US, imperial Japan, Nazi germany and Soviet Union combined. At least in terms of output
@@endeend1 yeah sure. Sure, keep telling yourself that, whatever you say 🤣
@@endeend1 I hope you like fallout 4 ☢️
But both of you forgetting that economy after US has great portion from military materials and goods weapons manufactures
Russia solved the china India puzzle