Nah man, nothing there was taken from any movie. That was all raw as it was live in person. A fan named Ron was handed the microphone and allowed to sing. This was the day before they headlined at Bonnaroo music festival in 2008. How do I know this? Because I was a few feet behind him as he was singing. This was a secret gig fan club members were emailed about a week before it happened and encouraged to enter a contest for a chance to win. 12 people won and were allowed to bring a guest. They had us meet at a park across the street before the show. All they told us was there would be a “surprise, of which would be a mystery, but you will not be disappointed.” As we stood there waiting, we were brainstorming what we thought the surprise might be. Someone joked “it might be a private show,” causing everyone to laugh.
this song is awesome!
one of the most underrated tallica songs!!!
just got the cd, the sound is awesome, would of loved to be at a intimate gig with metallica like that, cheers brilliant
they should play this song live in full this song is brilliant!!
come on metallica!!! we want that song in your shows!!!!!
the best metallica song!!!! sucks that they never do it live!!!
its just an awesome in an album with awesome songs.....
great song...power and groove
fans are singing to this song
@comonowicz for sure, cant wait for them to play it live, hopefully in their next gig in rock in rio, brazil 2011!
Holy shit, just 2 more days till they play it live... THEY BETTER FUCKING PLAY IT WHOLE!
@DustinFarleyTV
when you get the song/album off the livemetallica website it is played after For Whom The Bell Tolls
The crowd will go nuts when they finally play the full version
It was a couple of fans singing. James put his mic out for them.
Sickest song ever
Aaaalll we own! We oooooowe!
awesome riff on beginning of this vid
for sure man
wish i was there =(
I have a feeling, they WILL play all of this one day.... :)
check out "Metallica - Secret Show (June 12, 2008)" if you want to see the video
@DustinFarleyTV For some reason it shows up as the S&M version
@xurxo12 one of the best metallica's songs
sweeeet
aaaa wheres the video!?!?!?!
Why can't Metallica do the "Oh ee oh! Yo ho!" just like in the Album?! THAT PART WAS KILLER!
play the damn song live already
@hoplite246 probably cause thats not James hetfeild singing
0:39 - 0:43 - Drum solo, lol. Nice material by the way :D
It must have been slightly altered then; because it doesn't sound "exactly" the same.
the audience, in particular some people close to the camera
why aren't they playing the whole song?
i dont think they have played so much of that song :O
they never practice Frayed ends do they?
Do they think the song is cursed or something? Like what's the deal with playing it live just once, they like never do it.
It was done in 89, stopped half way through because its boring live.
***** Yes, today in Finland! First time ever….
because on the album thats not Metallica singing that part it was ripped straight from The Wizard of Oz
Nah man, nothing there was taken from any movie. That was all raw as it was live in person. A fan named Ron was handed the microphone and allowed to sing. This was the day before they headlined at Bonnaroo music festival in 2008. How do I know this? Because I was a few feet behind him as he was singing. This was a secret gig fan club members were emailed about a week before it happened and encouraged to enter a contest for a chance to win. 12 people won and were allowed to bring a guest. They had us meet at a park across the street before the show. All they told us was there would be a “surprise, of which would be a mystery, but you will not be disappointed.” As we stood there waiting, we were brainstorming what we thought the surprise might be. Someone joked “it might be a private show,” causing everyone to laugh.
@@Coolguy-es7mq what?
@braddudeguy o ok thnx
to tell ya the truth yes of course there were mistakes, they don't practice it :D But I noticed that the guitars sounded nice ! FTW xD
wat does sober mean
who is singing it ????
@OmGHiPPoS i truly hope so
2:51 Hetfield & Ulrich
wtf?? sing it yourself james, fucking awesome song!!!!
@cupcakkerobber pahahaha
swwet