Youre right. Its fun rewatching to see the clues. Like what you said. Or the fact Leo's character wasnt able to light his own smoke because they wouldnt give a lighter to a patient.
I read the book Shutter Island before I saw the movie, and I didn’t remember Chuck fumbling with his gun. Apparently, Scorsese added that part. I had the same reaction as you to that scene. I also thought he might be nervous with the guards being a bit menacing. Chuck being a doctor took me completely by surprise.
Strange thing about this movie.... I had a dream about this movie back in 2006 and remembered the entire thing and when it came out in 2010 I swore that I've seen it before and knew the ending before it was over.
I agree! I like movies that have multiple reasonable interpretations. It also takes a lot of guts to show a woman drinking a glass of water - without a glass of water! I missed that completely! That makes me wonder what else I missed.
He was going to expose the inhumane experiments that were going on there. Using their expertise to experiment on him, dosing him through cigarettes & pills, and setting up and carefully manipulating information and 'clues' for him pick up on. But that's the thing, crazy people are the perfect subjects. They talk and nobody listens.
I wonder how an escaped patient made her way to the cliffs without getting caught and how she managed to get into that space so very easily inside there .
It was not as if he was intended to watch over teddy.. It was all a scene in teddy's mind..it was all real in his mind and no one is covering up the truth in that world.
They probably got him in the ferry at the beginning to make the situation more believable to Teddy/Andrew, but he never actually got far from the island.
@@edwardburch7939 That one is explained in the novel by Dr. Cawley: since they already knew the contents of Laeddis' delusion, they waited until a storm was forecast to put their plan into play.
The Book is a lot more Open For interpretation as far as I remember. And I think with the Movie it’s the Same. The Music at the end is absolutely: Everything is clear now OR IS IT??
For me the best part of the movie is, I still cannot be sure if Andrew Lades is mad, or if the whole island is mad. Although intuitively I feel the hospital is genuine, emotionally I’d rather Andrew Lades is the only one normal… kinda sad
I thought the whole island might be up to no good (or possible mad, as you said). It just didn’t seem reasonable that a sane person could be driven insane by a few horrible tragedies experienced as an adult - even over the guilt at what he had done. I’ve never known a stable adult to suddenly lose touch with reality, and I think it only happens in fiction. I’ve known some VERY psychologically troubled people, but they aren’t THAT disconnected with reality. I HAVE met people who had psychological problems since early childhood, but only one who developed psychological problems as an adult (I barely knew him). In contrast, I’ve seen groups of people go along with unethical ideas - usually following a charismatic leader. So, the whole island being mad makes more sense to me too.
I know a girl who snapped and lost her mind. She went from a normal college student, wife, mother of a child .. to living homeless on the street - stalking people, stalking ME, would talk about nonsense and made up people . Insane to see, she didn’t just lose her job, she lost her mind and it seemed to happen after she gave birth. I also know my coworker had “lost” his mind and came back after years of meds and therapy - went from talking to angels and stalking people, going to mental hospitals etc to being a married man and living a stable life. I think it happens more than you think. I didn’t know any of these people till my 30’s
@@spe.z.artist i do feel that people , human beings, are mentally vulnerable. I was personally at the edge of cracking down… feel sorry for those that lost their minds, but at the same time I talk to myself to be strong … for another 30 years or so … for this short life time :)
Actually, almost true... Spoiler alert! It seems from the beginning, it's always other person who light his smoke, because since he's actually a patient there, the rule was that it's dangerous for a patient to bring a lighter or smoke on their own.
@@Sehon13UltdI havent Seen the Movie in Ages but I think I remembered that everything is up for your own Interpretation. As far as I remember there are Clues for every possibility Even more so in the Book. I wanted to Read That for years now, guess i‘ll do that soon.
There's literally tons of details that foreshadow the ending. For example all the Guards are strangely on edge when our heroes arrive on the island
Youre right. Its fun rewatching to see the clues. Like what you said. Or the fact Leo's character wasnt able to light his own smoke because they wouldnt give a lighter to a patient.
Half way through the movie you think you know why they're like this then your entire world gets flipped upside-down
Also that he never had a lighter with him and needed others to light his ciggs as a patient is not allowed to keep em
@@Replisticbut he had matches in the old military fort.
You mean victim
When I first watched the movie I had assumed Chuck struggling to remove his gun was that he was just inexperienced as a Martial. Great twist.
I read the book Shutter Island before I saw the movie, and I didn’t remember Chuck fumbling with his gun. Apparently, Scorsese added that part. I had the same reaction as you to that scene. I also thought he might be nervous with the guards being a bit menacing. Chuck being a doctor took me completely by surprise.
sames
Strange thing about this movie.... I had a dream about this movie back in 2006 and remembered the entire thing and when it came out in 2010 I swore that I've seen it before and knew the ending before it was over.
You smell that ?
I smell 🧢 🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢🧢
Sure you did. I SMELL BULLSHIT
@@Ligma..what
I had a similar experience with the first time I met a good friend of mine way back in second grade
"Did you know that the ending of this movie is the ending of the movie?" 🥴
🤯
Dekho simple hai yaa to director pagal hai yaa wo hame pagal bnana chahta hai😂🤣😂
This film is one of my favorites
Ngl, this movie was pretty good.
I agree! I like movies that have multiple reasonable interpretations. It also takes a lot of guts to show a woman drinking a glass of water - without a glass of water! I missed that completely! That makes me wonder what else I missed.
Theres ALOT of foreshadow in the movies, first time watching was shocking, second time watching will be like....ohhhhh
I thought he was the cop and they just drugged him and in the end it was just him giving in to the drugs
He was going to expose the inhumane experiments that were going on there. Using their expertise to experiment on him, dosing him through cigarettes & pills, and setting up and carefully manipulating information and 'clues' for him pick up on.
But that's the thing, crazy people are the perfect subjects. They talk and nobody listens.
I wonder how an escaped patient made her way to the cliffs without getting caught and how she managed to get into that space so very easily inside there .
If youre thinking of Rachel Solano, i think it was all inside Tedy's mind
Did you know the spoiler for this movie? Lemme tell you...
Yeah for a movie that's been out for 13 years
If you haven’t watched a movie that’s been out for more than a decade, than that’s on you 😂😂
Don’t know who this short is for lol. If you watched the movie that is very obvious, if you didn’t watch the movie now it’s been spoiled
It was not as if he was intended to watch over teddy.. It was all a scene in teddy's mind..it was all real in his mind and no one is covering up the truth in that world.
This is something I've been always wondering, was he really out of the island and came back there on the fery?? Or was it just his imagination??
What about the storm?
They probably got him in the ferry at the beginning to make the situation more believable to Teddy/Andrew, but he never actually got far from the island.
@@edwardburch7939 That one is explained in the novel by Dr. Cawley: since they already knew the contents of Laeddis' delusion, they waited until a storm was forecast to put their plan into play.
@@TheJFGB93 Ohhh wow, that's really smart.. Thank you for the explanation!!
Its a masterpiece
I highly recommend that people read the book as the book is one thousand percent better than the movie.
The Book is a lot more Open For interpretation as far as I remember. And I think with the Movie it’s the Same. The Music at the end is absolutely: Everything is clear now OR IS IT??
favorite movie
He was a Marshall at some point, and he was also on the military. I don’t think this should’ve been too hard for him
Other guy
Chuck/Dr. Sheehan (Mark Ruffallo's character) was the one who fumbled with the holster.
Also, did anyone spot the cameo from the guy who played buffalo bill in SOTL?
It's not a cameo, it's a substantial speaking role.
Ted Levine has 109 acting credits to his name, he's not just "guy who played Buffalo Bill".
I did not see the ending coming at all and to this day is my pick for number 1 twist in a movie.
Watch
Triangle
Prisoners
A perfect getaway
Predestination
Project Almanac
Mind hunters
Gone girl
I honestly hated this movie when I first watched it. Then when I finally understood the ending it became one of my favorites
To get the full story watch it minimum 3 times. The first time I was taking the side of Andrews-Teddys narrative
I noticed that detail the second time I saw the movie..
He would have experience, he was military and a cop before his break. This is grasping a bit..
The other guy
@@Horsemanpigcan you be anymore vague than that to the guy who doesn't understand? Why not just tell clearly that "Chuck was not a marshal"
Yes, everyone fucking knows this.
Movie with most cigarettes smoked..
Duh
Is this the only one you noticed?
Um actually, it is still difficult for Law Enforcement officers. The holsters are designed to stay attached to your clothing
Its not difficult at all. Im not law enforcement or had nearly the training theyve had and i can remove mine very easily and fast.
Yes I did.
Wrong
When you are white
For me the best part of the movie is, I still cannot be sure if Andrew Lades is mad, or if the whole island is mad.
Although intuitively I feel the hospital is genuine, emotionally I’d rather Andrew Lades is the only one normal… kinda sad
I thought the whole island might be up to no good (or possible mad, as you said). It just didn’t seem reasonable that a sane person could be driven insane by a few horrible tragedies experienced as an adult - even over the guilt at what he had done. I’ve never known a stable adult to suddenly lose touch with reality, and I think it only happens in fiction. I’ve known some VERY psychologically troubled people, but they aren’t THAT disconnected with reality.
I HAVE met people who had psychological problems since early childhood, but only one who developed psychological problems as an adult (I barely knew him). In contrast, I’ve seen groups of people go along with unethical ideas - usually following a charismatic leader. So, the whole island being mad makes more sense to me too.
I know a girl who snapped and lost her mind. She went from a normal college student, wife, mother of a child .. to living homeless on the street - stalking people, stalking ME, would talk about nonsense and made up people . Insane to see, she didn’t just lose her job, she lost her mind and it seemed to happen after she gave birth. I also know my coworker had “lost” his mind and came back after years of meds and therapy - went from talking to angels and stalking people, going to mental hospitals etc to being a married man and living a stable life. I think it happens more than you think. I didn’t know any of these people till my 30’s
@@spe.z.artist i do feel that people , human beings, are mentally vulnerable. I was personally at the edge of cracking down… feel sorry for those that lost their minds, but at the same time I talk to myself to be strong … for another 30 years or so … for this short life time :)
He also didn’t have his smokes on him. No smoker is going to an island without remembering his smokes.
Source: me.
They'd bring a carton
@@SauceOnChickenBall facts
Actually, almost true...
Spoiler alert!
It seems from the beginning, it's always other person who light his smoke, because since he's actually a patient there, the rule was that it's dangerous for a patient to bring a lighter or smoke on their own.
In the initial scene on the boat he says he can't find his smokes and he and chuck wonder if someone on the boat stole them.
I new what the movie was about within 10 minutes
So is the twist that the guys insane? But then why’d they give him a gun
It’s a toy gun, you’d know that if you watched the movie
@@Sehon13UltdI havent Seen the Movie in Ages but I think I remembered that everything is up for your own Interpretation. As far as I remember there are Clues for every possibility Even more so in the Book. I wanted to Read That for years now, guess i‘ll do that soon.
Fantastic movie