The sky'll crack open and God will reach his f*ing arm through. What a monumental album. When I was in hs, we'd do all the drugs and toss this album in the playstation. 😄 Good times.
It's ridiculous how this song has gotten me through so much. Helped with depression and gave me the focus to do the work to get to college. Personal win for me
NIN is very diverse. How many other bands play soft songs like La Mer or The Frail back to back with face melting metal? NIN has a very wide spectrum for a single band. They also innovate with the distribution of their content. Besides Radiohead and a handful of other bands who else is giving out all of their music for free? Instead of relasing a DVD they gave out 400 GB of professional quality video for fans to download via torrents. I'd call that innovative.
Indeed one of the many great moments on The Fragile. The part after the climax is also very good, with the piano and stuff. The atmosphere of this song is so strange. This song has the greatest intro and the greatest outro I ever heard in my life.
Me too, I lost somebody that I used to listen to, my first love, we were together for like 20 years. I remember when this album came out, better times I don’t like the times now it’s full of imposters and bad people!
Perfect - because NIN is a professional organization, he conducts the creation of his art professionally, his business professionally, hires other professionals serious about their art too, everything is professional. A lot of 'artists' cannot keep up this quality and dynamism for this long. Trent Reznor is a rare exception, and his conviction backs up everything he does. We are very fortunate in our generation to have an artist like Trent who gives so much of himself in his craft.
holy shit i cant believe they took a vid of this song,im front row at this show right infront of robin....i was only 15 at the time and this show is by far the most memorable show ive ever been to and there really is no band or show that can compare to the energy and emotion that trent and the band put inot a show...its been a year and a half since the show and im still in awe of this amazing front row experience..ill never forget this day,and i ge to relive it by watching this amazing vid
This song and this performance, in fact ALL of Trent's work is keeping me going through the bleak moments of life. Thank you, Trent, sincerely. You were here before her, and you'll be here long after she's gone.
one of the most exciting and exhilarating moments on the fragile.. the main keyboard melody is so fucking good that it rivals the downward spiral motif for me. insane to hear it done live.. anyone who thinks the fragile sucked should really watch this.
I don't know why but I just picture a meteor coming through the space and the sky as this song builds to its crash. As with everything Trent does, I love it!
Love these guys more everyday! It's crazy as I matured I appreciate the music and understand it so much more. I'm on a "Some what Damaged" kick also. 💪
@xsanchezz I partially agree, seen both NIN and U2 in Poland before, and despite a obvious difference in the sound of NIN and U2, both of the shows were incredible and the crowd had a great part on maintaining the awesome atmosphere of the gigs.
@Aesophere YES! God yes. Nine inch nails and atmosphere are the two greatest groups possibly to ever produce music. Shit changed my life. The Fragile and Lucy Ford are my two absolute favorite albums.
I know it sounds cliché, but NIN and especially 'The Fragile' saved me when i was down. And gave that drive to keep going. 'The way out is through' is that mantra and it saved many, i'm sure.
You're the best mr trent reznor. Keep doing what you're doing. Forever a fan, glo.
15 лет назад+1
live version is epic legendary breathtaking unbeatable !!! Luckily i saw this in İstanbul rock'n coke festival this year but UNFORTUNATELY he left the stage for some reason during this !!!!! :(((
After he yells they need that delay effect from the album. That kinda makes the song. And after the heavy part they need to go back to the soft "I will keep on". Amazing performance. One of my fave songs
I love pretty much everything by Trent but I've got to say this and a few other songs on The Fragile are some of the best songs he's ever written. This was a big turning point in his career and you can tell he has put so much into this album (which is possibly my favourite by NIN but being so long as it is, it definitely has some pretty low moments). I think he was a victim of his portrayal in his early career. Like Radiohead, NIN was a band that evolved beautifully.
I think I said this about a year ago, and several people asked "wtf"... the audience missed this... ... ... ... ... ... can you honestly tell me you would not be crawling on top of other people flailing with passion during this performance? if no, fine, great in fact... pay your toll and stand there like a tool. Maybe after years of standing idly on the side you'll see what it is to express such passion.
Trent Reznor. & Sean Daley Two Favorite Musicians. Two Best Lyricists Of Their Own Style In My Opinion. (Anyone Else Rock Some Nine Inch Nails And Bump Some Atmosphere?)
![NIN: "Last" live from on stage in Holmdel, NJ 6.06.09 [HD 1080p]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/jL7iGw5nm1k/mqdefault.jpg)
![NIN: "Last" live from on stage in Holmdel, NJ 6.06.09 [HD 1080p]](/img/tr.png)
“All I’ve undergone, I will keep on” man that line means so much to me
No matter what life does to us, we must keep on. I agree, The Fragile is my favorite NIN album.
These words are even more true and needed than ever.
2024 baby💪🏽
This what I say about my tattoos 😂
me too
"Underneath it all... we feel so small... the heavens fall... but still we crawl..." Man, does it ever feel like that for Mankind nowadays.
The sky'll crack open and God will reach his f*ing arm through. What a monumental album. When I was in hs, we'd do all the drugs and toss this album in the playstation. 😄 Good times.
It's ridiculous how this song has gotten me through so much. Helped with depression and gave me the focus to do the work to get to college. Personal win for me
God bless man! Take care! We love you!
This song demonstrates the entire complexity that is TR and NIN. Might be my favorite track
This version is much more sonically enjoyable though. With the keys in the beginning and live drums, it really takes on a life of its own
it is my favorite track...
This has always been a song to me that wraps NIN into a single package.
It has nearly every element of anything he's ever done.
This is the best live performance of this track. Awesome
agreed
NIN is very diverse. How many other bands play soft songs like La Mer or The Frail back to back with face melting metal? NIN has a very wide spectrum for a single band.
They also innovate with the distribution of their content. Besides Radiohead and a handful of other bands who else is giving out all of their music for free?
Instead of relasing a DVD they gave out 400 GB of professional quality video for fans to download via torrents. I'd call that innovative.
The drummer at 3:19 is winning
NiN/Reznor is by far one of the greatest musical act's in my lifetime.
Goddamn I love this song. Robin Finck's vocals really stand out on this performance! Just plain awesome all around.
YES DUDE! I was thinking the exact same!!! 11 years later
Robin has such a strong unique voice, such a wonderful instrument for NIN shows
Indeed one of the many great moments on The Fragile. The part after the climax is also very good, with the piano and stuff. The atmosphere of this song is so strange. This song has the greatest intro and the greatest outro I ever heard in my life.
that album changed my life...
This track made me cry the first time I heard it.
Great story!
Me too, I lost somebody that I used to listen to, my first love, we were together for like 20 years. I remember when this album came out, better times I don’t like the times now it’s full of imposters and bad people!
Perfect - because NIN is a professional organization, he conducts the creation of his art professionally, his business professionally, hires other professionals serious about their art too, everything is professional. A lot of 'artists' cannot keep up this quality and dynamism for this long. Trent Reznor is a rare exception, and his conviction backs up everything he does. We are very fortunate in our generation to have an artist like Trent who gives so much of himself in his craft.
WOW Playing along to this I just realised this version is in dropped C instead of D. I like!
all i`ve undergone i will keep on
I can get lost in way out is through more than even most NIN songs, just close my eyes and feel the raindrops
I can get lost in The Fragile all the way through, i still feel like a teenager back in the year 2000 whenever I listen to this record.
holy shit i cant believe they took a vid of this song,im front row at this show right infront of robin....i was only 15 at the time and this show is by far the most memorable show ive ever been to and there really is no band or show that can compare to the energy and emotion that trent and the band put inot a show...its been a year and a half since the show and im still in awe of this amazing front row experience..ill never forget this day,and i ge to relive it by watching this amazing vid
Awesome man
I friggin' love how the guitar sounds in this video
can't believe this was almost 10 years ago. feels like almost yesterday they put this up.
I enjoy how NIN songs like this start out so contained and tense, then explode into a full rage.
This video deserves 10x the number of views that it has...
"Listening at a high volume for a long time may damage your hearing. Tap OK to allow the volume to be increased above safe levels."
Clicks OK.
NIN in a nutshell
I just went silly listening to this. Musicgasm.
I know exactly what you mean, brother. I just did too.
Holy shit, I have seen this song performed many times since 1999 but this is amazing.
Odor 66 I feel like this is the best performance of this song I’ve seen for sure
One of my favourite songs amazingly played.
This song and this performance, in fact ALL of Trent's work is keeping me going through the bleak moments of life. Thank you, Trent, sincerely.
You were here before her, and you'll be here long after she's gone.
This was the day/ show I met and hugged Trent! Best damn day of my life. 🖤
my god that's beautiful
OMG I did not know about this live version. This is just beautiful
i need this song now so much!
Magnificent 😢😍 I need to see this over and over. I'm obsessed
I just love Nine Inch Nails. Seeing them live in London was the best thing ever.
Possibly my favorite track from The Fragile.
So much power in this crescendo. My heart picks up EVERY time. I've listened to this countless times, and I'm still not jaded to it.
Perfect rainy weather song!
This is no doubt one of the baddest bands out there.. Trent make more albums ...My skin is begging you please...
It's raining and this song is ripping me apart. I love it.
Lo mejor de nin su capacidad de interpretar cualquiera de sus canciones en vivo y la frescura da cada una de sus versiones... me encanta
this song is just something from abother level from me. Every year i come back for this track and this live perfomance. Truly, the way out is through.
NineInchNails will forever have a spot on my playlist, till the very end of music its self.
one of the most exciting and exhilarating moments on the fragile..
the main keyboard melody is so fucking good that it rivals the downward spiral motif for me.
insane to hear it done live.. anyone who thinks the fragile sucked should really watch this.
Finck has an amazing voice
holy shit, this song live actually happened?? *-*
All I undergone
I will keep on
Underneath it all
We feel so small
The heavens fall
But still we crawl
Trent messed up the lyrics if u noticed
@@mjdia2543 I did just now. lol Ouch.
The indomitable human spirit
I was there, incredible bro!
@ibstrd being in a NIN concert is paying all your attention and senses to the guys on stage, the inertia keeps you motionless :)
This must be one of my favorite nin songs, I'm glad they play it live it.
Amazing song, my heart almost stopped when I saw it live. Damn you NIN for stopping touring!
Oh my F'ing GOD - I LOVE this song! Epic Indeed! So good live with that scorching white light at the climax! SO GOOD!
Awesome.. I was at this show.. :)
I did the vip donation for this one..
It was an amazing show..
I don't know why but I just picture a meteor coming through the space and the sky as this song builds to its crash. As with everything Trent does, I love it!
holy shit. I always loved that song and now... now it's better.
Love these guys more everyday! It's crazy as I matured I appreciate the music and understand it so much more. I'm on a "Some what Damaged" kick also. 💪
Welcome! So so much to explore in the NIN catalog and that's without tapping into trents amazing movie scores
Thank you Robyn for the back-up vocals
love this track, especially the intro
@xsanchezz I partially agree, seen both NIN and U2 in Poland before, and despite a obvious difference in the sound of NIN and U2, both of the shows were incredible and the crowd had a great part on maintaining the awesome atmosphere of the gigs.
@Aesophere YES! God yes. Nine inch nails and atmosphere are the two greatest groups possibly to ever produce music. Shit changed my life. The Fragile and Lucy Ford are my two absolute favorite albums.
best live show I've ever been to...
He made it... :)
It cant get better than this
i would have never even dreamed of them playing this song what an incredible video(nintour2010)
Never seen/heard this live with the whispered part, but it makes me happy because I have that as a tattoo.
Amazing song!!!!!
I could listen to this live everyday
The mantra of a man that struggles with wanting to be alive: "All I've undergone, I will keep on".
I know it sounds cliché, but NIN and especially 'The Fragile' saved me when i was down. And gave that drive to keep going. 'The way out is through' is that mantra and it saved many, i'm sure.
Why does it feel like The Fragile is the most weirdly optimistic album from NIN's discography???
Because the album was about trying to pull yourself together, only for it to unravel
This sounds so f*cking good it’s ridiculous
You're the best mr trent reznor. Keep doing what you're doing. Forever a fan, glo.
live version is epic legendary breathtaking unbeatable !!! Luckily i saw this in İstanbul rock'n coke festival this year but UNFORTUNATELY he left the stage for some reason during this !!!!! :(((
After he yells they need that delay effect from the album. That kinda makes the song. And after the heavy part they need to go back to the soft "I will keep on".
Amazing performance. One of my fave songs
Yup i saw the amazing fan made video of this song just blows your minds away ;)
God almighty it's amazing to think you've created such an amazingly talented human being;)
HOLY FUCK! perfect, even after all these years...
one of the best bands ever
awesome quality!!!
beautiful
Beyond Godlikeeee
the original version of this song literally broke my heart when i heard it the first time.
@DaveFallows Thanks man! Yeah, we guessed it was a '97 but wern't sure.
NIN my fav band always will be!!!
The greatest ever
of the best songs
I love pretty much everything by Trent but I've got to say this and a few other songs on The Fragile are some of the best songs he's ever written. This was a big turning point in his career and you can tell he has put so much into this album (which is possibly my favourite by NIN but being so long as it is, it definitely has some pretty low moments). I think he was a victim of his portrayal in his early career. Like Radiohead, NIN was a band that evolved beautifully.
Just been favorited
The Fragile is fucking timeless
that Fragile era Gibson.. good god
such an amazing concert, i was there
I think I said this about a year ago, and several people asked "wtf"... the audience missed this... ... ... ... ... ... can you honestly tell me you would not be crawling on top of other people flailing with passion during this performance? if no, fine, great in fact... pay your toll and stand there like a tool. Maybe after years of standing idly on the side you'll see what it is to express such passion.
Freaking amazing.
The truth runs deep.
Amazing!
Regards from chili you are the best.....
Trent Reznor.
&
Sean Daley
Two Favorite Musicians.
Two Best Lyricists Of Their Own Style In My Opinion.
(Anyone Else Rock Some Nine Inch Nails And Bump Some Atmosphere?)
Dude robins backing vocals 🥵
@zkrunner117 my thoughts exactly, I did like of all TR's recent stuff but The Fragile has a 'special place' in my heart
those were awesome
image is great !!
nice, one of the remaining Fragile guitars.... Def my fave album..
The FRagile is the inspiration for my Screeenplayyy... >:)