@@wra7h He's opening and closing the hi hat with his left foot to keep time, as most drummers do, when doing the harmony vocals, so he's still "playing" them even if not hitting them at that point. Also it's quite tricky getting down those dynamics on the snare while also focusing on singing in tune.
@@bmac4there’s a backing track on the hats, lots of drummers use them to enhance their performance and there’s nothing wrong with it. His hats are played over the busier backing track.
@@wra7h yeah, it's easy to see that on the chorus. I was like: what, there are extra hi hat sounds here that he's not playing. Then I realized those are recorded. I don't really care, honestly. The guy is a monster anyway.
A couple of years ago i was in pretentious fanboy phase, i thought "NIN will never get a drummer as good as Josh Freese". I'm so glad i was wrong. This guy is a monster
Playing Drums, singing, and having perfect tempo with the samples ...freaking click track work its Fking insane, my absolute respect to this drum monster
it's hard to tell through all the noise but i'm pretty sure there was stuff missing during the drum solo, notably the toms and generally it felt like it was being played different. still good
@@DirkHoeppner The first part of the solo is just him playing, well, literally solo, no backing percussion, kinda why the groove sounds a bit "off" or different. It sounded odd to me too. When he stops the solo and comes back in with the guitars (that eeeeHHHH upward pitch bend), the backing perc is there and the groove he plays is just like the one on the record, that's probably what you're listening for and not hearing at first.
@@Zazzaro703 True enough. Or the guy from Dillinger Escape Plan (name escapes me, but he does a drum cover of "Come To Daddy" by Aphex Twin, which is basically the groove from this song on steroids). Chris something...
I have LOVED this song since it came out. Ten years later MTV is telling me that Reznor hates this song. Fifteen years later I learn that may not have been the full story. Awesome to see it performed live.
I really hope this is a classic Reznor tease of what will be a multi angle, full length concert, finally with the audio quality we’ve all been dreaming of for years!
I honestly can’t think of anyone that would be a better drummer for NIN than Ilan. Taking drum parts that were, for the most part, written and recorded on a computer and making them accurate as hell while still adding such a human warmth and groove is an astounding accomplishment. His videos explaining how to play drums are equally amazing. Huge talent. I hope Trent keeps him!
I was so fortunate to have been at their Red Rocks performance in 2018 when they performed it live for the very first time during the encore. I lost my shit completely. Waited 21 years to finally see it performed and they didnt' disappoint.
he's singing while playing drums FUCKING HOW. Edit: This is such an absolutely beautiful performance, The drums are probably my favorite part from the song.
The first person to sound as big as bonham. He has the girth and thickness that Bonham had, but is cleaner and more technically accomplished in many ways. Truly an underrated giant of rock drumming.
Holy crap man. 😳 thanks for uploading this! You are the best drummer NIN has ever had. And as a drummer myself, Freese is one of my favorite drummers. Seriously impressed.
Freese is incredible I’ll add just for sake. His absence from A Perfect Circle and their subsequent downfall of quality (imo) is really evident and quite frankly really a huge letdown
This is so fucking sick! Ilan is the raddest dude in drumming; he took what Trent said about it being impossible to play live and absolutely shattered expectations! I'm so upset I couldn't have witnessed this live myself.
I dream of seeing this song live so much. A few years ago I thought it wouldn't be ever possible. But with Ilan Rubin there's hope... I'm just waiting for the next concert in Poland.
lol the comments saying this is easy. Bro is clearly not struggling and he's also singing and doing this during the middle of a nine inch nails concert? Y'all are SILLY
After experiencing thirteen NIN shows and about four, maybe even five drummers in rotation, I swear... I swear. You, Sir Ilan, take the CAKE and THEN SOME. This is absolutely phenomenal, I'm freaking convinced. Fantastic performance! Seeing you perform this piece is like a realization manifested from a fever-dream, the ease of playing a song that was once claimed impossible with such jazz-inspired ferocity. BRAVO!!! 🤘🔥
I honestly don't know how many times I've watched this now. Such precision, professionalism and heart showcasing what separates players like you. This is the perfect balance of respect for the track with the added bonus of the song building to showcase the drumming monster you are. Pro level 110. Truly - thanks for sharing this.
This marks year 30 for me listening to/watching/enjoying NIN. For me it's always been about the layers; how The Perfect Drug would just be ok, without the backing vocals, but how rich it really is once you have that layer in place. Holy shit. Whatever they are paying Rubin they should double, triple, whatever it takes. Great capture... thank you Mr. Rubin.
Saw them Boston Calling night 2, they didn't play this one and I wanted to hear it so bad, the set was amazing and Ilan was fantastic. I saw NIN with Josh Freese on drums back in 09, that was also an incredible set. Ilan and Josh are both masters behind the kit.
You are not fucking kidding!!! Goosebumps the whole time watching/;listening to that! Third time through and I feel I would never get tired of this. Yeah, just fucking awesome!
Having Ilan and his kit up front is so fitting. He deserves to be on display for the audience to enjoy. Not only is he an amazing drummer, but he performs with style and emotion that is beautiful to watch. Great choice in the stage layout to feature him.
I remember meeting you at a meet and greet during the "NIN FAN CLUB" when it was around at Madison Garden and I'm pretty sure at the Virgin Mega Store. I asked you to sign the album and say "I'm better than Josh" and you smiled and shook my hand. You lived up to all of my expectations bro.
I have heard this song, millions of times....and NIN has never disappointed me in their live shows. What a fantastic performance... the nostalgia is a trip. Thank you.
I never thought I’d see NIN play this song live until I had the privilege to see you guys in Cleveland this year, what an amazing night 🤩 I saw you and Robin in the airport the next day but since Robin was wearing mask I thought it would be rude to ask for a picture, thank you very much for an unforgettable night 🙂
Holy shit that was AMAZING!!!! I loved Vrenna, he was just so quintessentially NIN ya know, but Ilan is just on another level. IMO one of he best drumers alive!
Amazing. I would call this the greatest drum solo ever, but it is a song (which the drummer is also singing--because I guess the drums weren't hard enough). Really, I can't heap enough praise on this performance. Thanks for sharing.
WHY ??!? Why did I saw this ??? It was like .... seing the perfect drug that makes you stunded, speechless... and addict !!!! Mister Rubin, I bow my head down ....
There are some bootlegs available with the IEM mix. I'm not sure if Ilan has his own specific mix but the IEM bootlegs have all the audio cues and click tracks which the crowd don't hear.
Thank you for sharing, not only the pristine sound mix, but also a steady, clear video of you drumming. It's just a masterclass in your skill, style, and I appreciate seeing this very much. One of my favorite songs, brought to life perfectly by this group of musicians.
Aaahhhhhhhh, saw the boys again on this '22 tour in Portland at Edgefield amphitheater........ Perfect! I could Not keep my eyes off of Ian's drumming! He is a Beast on the set
I was at Edgefield also. It was so good that when I got back to the motel I got online & got a ticket & hotel for Bend 2 days later. That show was even better! Way things are going it might've been my last rock & roll roadtrip. At least I went out on a high note.
_Text book example of a SOLID DRUMMER. Every stroke is with purpose and confident in the knowledge of what you’re playing and why. I dig the open handed tech as well. Kit sounds amazing, and the drumming is great to watch, which cannot be said for many drummers._
I was at Raleigh, got to see this at the first stop of the tour. Just blown away is an understatement. When we got back from the show and I started talking about this on Reddit with others who went to the show and they said you did the keyboard at the end too I couldn't believe it. At the show we saw you get up from the drums and we were like yeah that was a walk-off mic drop moment and figured you were back getting a much needed drink or something. Couldn't see anything through all the smoke.
Видеоклипы
Trent : I don’t think we can ever play this song live and make it sound right.
Ilan: hold my water Trent…
more like... "hold my drums while i'm at the piano mate!" hehe ;-)
@@moliver_xxii hahaha!
Ilan is so fucking talented!
WHILE singing backup and stepping away to fill in on piano...
*whiskey* lol
Auditioning for NIN:
"Can you play fast beats?"
"I guess, yeah."
"Okay, but can you do falsetto backing vox?!"
And keyboard!
@@DirtiestDMusicsounds as Louis Cole😆
It is insane that the drummer is playing those beats while singing so well. Mind blown. So much practice and professionalism to get to this level.
hes not playing the hi hat
What the hell do you mean he’s not playing the hi hat??!!!
@@wra7h He's opening and closing the hi hat with his left foot to keep time, as most drummers do, when doing the harmony vocals, so he's still "playing" them even if not hitting them at that point. Also it's quite tricky getting down those dynamics on the snare while also focusing on singing in tune.
@@bmac4there’s a backing track on the hats, lots of drummers use them to enhance their performance and there’s nothing wrong with it. His hats are played over the busier backing track.
@@wra7h yeah, it's easy to see that on the chorus. I was like: what, there are extra hi hat sounds here that he's not playing. Then I realized those are recorded. I don't really care, honestly. The guy is a monster anyway.
This is just further proof that we need a live (4K)Blu-ray with the current line-up.
Ok, boomer.
@@douchymcdouche169 keep saying that shit when you cry when all of your digital content is gone boy.
@@thevoid99 Go back to your cave.
@@douchymcdouche169 you're on a NIN video. You're the damn boomer. @Eyerobot you're right would be perfect
@@shawnlegrand9945 Great logic bro! Hey kids, if you're watching 2022 concerts on youtube - you're old!
A couple of years ago i was in pretentious fanboy phase, i thought "NIN will never get a drummer as good as Josh Freese". I'm so glad i was wrong. This guy is a monster
check out delta empire drum cover of this song
And then does a casual back up vocal
Josh did not fit in NIN.. this guy is perfect. buttt also so was Aaron
You forgot Chris Vrenna.He was awesome
@@sandansaiyan5675 he was the best. He's a teacher now
Playing Drums, singing, and having perfect tempo with the samples ...freaking click track work its Fking insane, my absolute respect to this drum monster
Then jumps to keyboard lol
You took a song Trent called "impossible" for over 20 years and made it look effortless. You are a drum god. Never stop.
it's hard to tell through all the noise but i'm pretty sure there was stuff missing during the drum solo, notably the toms and generally it felt like it was being played different. still good
@@DirkHoeppner The first part of the solo is just him playing, well, literally solo, no backing percussion, kinda why the groove sounds a bit "off" or different. It sounded odd to me too. When he stops the solo and comes back in with the guitars (that eeeeHHHH upward pitch bend), the backing perc is there and the groove he plays is just like the one on the record, that's probably what you're listening for and not hearing at first.
I have seen metal drummer take this song next level. It is hardly "impossible" to play in a single cut or live.
Nothing against Rubin, but there is no way Josh Freese couldn’t play this live had they wanted to.
@@Zazzaro703 True enough. Or the guy from Dillinger Escape Plan (name escapes me, but he does a drum cover of "Come To Daddy" by Aphex Twin, which is basically the groove from this song on steroids). Chris something...
That solo is solid cardio training 😮
💯
While singing all the backups!
my heart rate went up just watching it
lol drummer takes the whole song so good
Im right now doing 😂
Dude straight fucked those drums up then slow walks to the keyboard like that solo was nothing. Absolute beast!!!!🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥🔥☠️☠️☠️💣💣💣💣
I have LOVED this song since it came out. Ten years later MTV is telling me that Reznor hates this song. Fifteen years later I learn that may not have been the full story. Awesome to see it performed live.
I really hope this is a classic Reznor tease of what will be a multi angle, full length concert, finally with the audio quality we’ve all been dreaming of for years!
Don’t hold your breath I think people are still waiting for 5 other tour footage releases, in any case a lot of the fan footage does pretty well
Even as I can see him doing it, I still almost can’t believe it. Superhuman.
Saw them perform this in Bend 2022 and I was frozen stiff in amazement.
I honestly can’t think of anyone that would be a better drummer for NIN than Ilan. Taking drum parts that were, for the most part, written and recorded on a computer and making them accurate as hell while still adding such a human warmth and groove is an astounding accomplishment. His videos explaining how to play drums are equally amazing. Huge talent. I hope Trent keeps him!
Lards Ulrich has entered the chat
Reznor has always been able to find incredibly talented musicians to perform with especially on drums and Ilan is no exception.
02:45 🤯
The Perfect Drum Solo
I’ve waited my entire life to see this song performer live. This lived up to everything. Thank you.
I was so fortunate to have been at their Red Rocks performance in 2018 when they performed it live for the very first time during the encore. I lost my shit completely. Waited 21 years to finally see it performed and they didnt' disappoint.
Any time Ilan touches the kit, it's a rock drumming masterclass. What a gift to be in the same timeline as this man.
I truly had no idea NiN still went _this_ hard wowowow been out of the loop for a *hot* minute❗
The Perfect Drummer
This made my day. As a drummer, as a rock fan, and even as just a person going about their day. Thanks for making this and sharing it!
This audio quality is fkn sick
he's singing
while playing drums
FUCKING HOW.
Edit: This is such an absolutely beautiful performance, The drums are probably my favorite part from the song.
Huge recommendations to listen Louis Cole as well.He's playing breakbeat with drums and sings
Even Ringo Starr could sing and drum at the same time.
The first person to sound as big as bonham. He has the girth and thickness that Bonham had, but is cleaner and more technically accomplished in many ways. Truly an underrated giant of rock drumming.
"... and then the drummer stands up and starts playing the keyboard"
100%!!! 5 stars on Rock Band!!! Seriously it's insane how spot on it is, HOF level performance! Insane!
Holy crap man. 😳 thanks for uploading this! You are the best drummer NIN has ever had. And as a drummer myself, Freese is one of my favorite drummers. Seriously impressed.
Freese is incredible I’ll add just for sake. His absence from A Perfect Circle and their subsequent downfall of quality (imo) is really evident and quite frankly really a huge letdown
My favorite part is that after he did this magical drug solo, he then got up to play the keyboard. This man is an angel.
I'd sell my soul for that snare sound
^^^^👆
Looks like the snare is triggered and mic'd so might be a mix of both the sampled snare and live audio, either way, phwoar!!!
The entire kit is hooked up to a million filters and effects as far as I know.
Sample and live. Gated and distorted verbed and choked +real snare for the clean thump.
@@matthijshanninkI don't think so.
This is so fucking sick! Ilan is the raddest dude in drumming; he took what Trent said about it being impossible to play live and absolutely shattered expectations! I'm so upset I couldn't have witnessed this live myself.
I dream of seeing this song live so much. A few years ago I thought it wouldn't be ever possible. But with Ilan Rubin there's hope... I'm just waiting for the next concert in Poland.
It’s everything you’ve ever wanted. I saw it two nights at Red Rocks and even the second time I had chills and smiles.
Yeah, they made it a staple this last tour, something wonderful to witness in Louisville
Despite all my appreciation for Josh Freese - this is just absolutely awesome 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻
The mixing on this live is insane
lol the comments saying this is easy. Bro is clearly not struggling and he's also singing and doing this during the middle of a nine inch nails concert?
Y'all are SILLY
Already one of the greatest drummers of all time! Saw NIN at Brixton Academy in 2022 and I was just blown away by IIan’s playing the whole show.
After experiencing thirteen NIN shows and about four, maybe even five drummers in rotation, I swear... I swear. You, Sir Ilan, take the CAKE and THEN SOME. This is absolutely phenomenal, I'm freaking convinced. Fantastic performance! Seeing you perform this piece is like a realization manifested from a fever-dream, the ease of playing a song that was once claimed impossible with such jazz-inspired ferocity. BRAVO!!! 🤘🔥
Ilan coming through with the fan service. Thank you!!
Playing drums at this level and singing ... so gnarly!
Holy shit that drummer is a beast. I never thought I'd see them play this live.
This dude just embodies rock n roll energy.
..God damn. This is the one song I've never got to hear them play live. It's on my bucket list now that they have a drummer who can play it.
I honestly don't know how many times I've watched this now. Such precision, professionalism and heart showcasing what separates players like you. This is the perfect balance of respect for the track with the added bonus of the song building to showcase the drumming monster you are. Pro level 110. Truly - thanks for sharing this.
They need to release the concert as a live album. Please!
The BEST NIN song. Bar none
And he is singing on top of that crazy beat!
Simply amazing!
This marks year 30 for me listening to/watching/enjoying NIN. For me it's always been about the layers; how The Perfect Drug would just be ok, without the backing vocals, but how rich it really is once you have that layer in place. Holy shit. Whatever they are paying Rubin they should double, triple, whatever it takes. Great capture... thank you Mr. Rubin.
Saw them Boston Calling night 2, they didn't play this one and I wanted to hear it so bad, the set was amazing and Ilan was fantastic. I saw NIN with Josh Freese on drums back in 09, that was also an incredible set. Ilan and Josh are both masters behind the kit.
That breakdown was fucking incredible. I was waiting for you to miss the triple kicks in the 2nd half but you killed it. i could watch it 1,000 times.
You are not fucking kidding!!! Goosebumps the whole time watching/;listening to that! Third time through and I feel I would never get tired of this.
Yeah, just fucking awesome!
@@parasite-b9604 There's a video somewhere that does a side-by-side of the studio version and this. Unbelievable!
@@Metal_God thanks very much for that info. I'll have to find that!
Happy New Year's for tomorrow.
This needs to go viral
Having Ilan and his kit up front is so fitting. He deserves to be on display for the audience to enjoy. Not only is he an amazing drummer, but he performs with style and emotion that is beautiful to watch. Great choice in the stage layout to feature him.
You know shits about to go down when Ilan moves the mic out of the way.
I thought no one would ever have the precision and energy Josh Freese has in the gig world.... and then Ilan Rubin showed up.
You want the perfect drum, the perfect drum!
I remember meeting you at a meet and greet during the "NIN FAN CLUB" when it was around at Madison Garden and I'm pretty sure at the Virgin Mega Store. I asked you to sign the album and say "I'm better than Josh" and you smiled and shook my hand. You lived up to all of my expectations bro.
INSANE.
This is what Trent needed in the late 80's. This dude is everything
Quickly becoming not only my favorite NIN drummer, but my favorite, period. Thanks for posting these.
I never thought anyone would top Josh Freese.
I was wrong.
Fucking beast. Been watching this guy since he was a kid.
I have heard this song, millions of times....and NIN has never disappointed me in their live shows. What a fantastic performance... the nostalgia is a trip. Thank you.
This is some insane drumming!
I never thought I’d see NIN play this song live until I had the privilege to see you guys in Cleveland this year, what an amazing night 🤩 I saw you and Robin in the airport the next day but since Robin was wearing mask I thought it would be rude to ask for a picture, thank you very much for an unforgettable night 🙂
He nailed it.
Ilan Rubin did it!!
Ilan Rubin has more control over his left hand than I have over my life.
I’m glad I got to see him use almost every bit of kit he’s got. Awesome.
This deserves so much more views, stunning drum work.
I feel like he deserved a huge steak dinner after this?
GOD tier drumming. Ilian is a beast
This was EPIC, totally worth the wait...I´ve got to see them live again and witness this masterpiece live
A shade of Bowie and some of Copeland's fills in here. Kickass version! You're the drumming beast, man!
Simply amazing, I could listen to that dude play drums for hours.
Holy shit that was AMAZING!!!! I loved Vrenna, he was just so quintessentially NIN ya know, but Ilan is just on another level. IMO one of he best drumers alive!
Amazing. I would call this the greatest drum solo ever, but it is a song (which the drummer is also singing--because I guess the drums weren't hard enough).
Really, I can't heap enough praise on this performance. Thanks for sharing.
WHY ??!? Why did I saw this ??? It was like .... seing the perfect drug that makes you stunded, speechless... and addict !!!!
Mister Rubin, I bow my head down ....
....next Halloween I wanna be this monster.....dang bro, killed it....
Would love to hear what's in your ears when playing this live! Always interested in what other drummers have in their monitor mix
There are some bootlegs available with the IEM mix. I'm not sure if Ilan has his own specific mix but the IEM bootlegs have all the audio cues and click tracks which the crowd don't hear.
One of my favorite drum solos ever. The second part of the solo at 3:24 was probably some of the best drumming I've seen thus far. Way to go.
My jaw went through the floor and into the center of the Earth! A new rock god is born!
Thank you for sharing, not only the pristine sound mix, but also a steady, clear video of you drumming. It's just a masterclass in your skill, style, and I appreciate seeing this very much. One of my favorite songs, brought to life perfectly by this group of musicians.
dont stop uploading these, fantastic insight.
Oh snap! Always wanted to hear this live! The drum part is fing nuts!
So now I am revisiting this drum cam as well as Danny Carreys Pneuma on weekly basis
Aaahhhhhhhh, saw the boys again on this '22 tour in Portland at Edgefield amphitheater........ Perfect!
I could Not keep my eyes off of Ian's drumming! He is a Beast on the set
I was at Edgefield also. It was so good that when I got back to the motel I got online & got a ticket & hotel for Bend 2 days later. That show was even better! Way things are going it might've been my last rock & roll roadtrip. At least I went out on a high note.
I'm glad to see this song performed live. I'm amazed by your skills. Great drumming and great performance by the band. 💪
_Text book example of a SOLID DRUMMER. Every stroke is with purpose and confident in the knowledge of what you’re playing and why. I dig the open handed tech as well. Kit sounds amazing, and the drumming is great to watch, which cannot be said for many drummers._
I remember when I discover the Lost Highways soundtrack back then. The couple of songs of NIN and Bowie blew me away.
Proper musician.
Sensational 👏🏼
Incredible !!! Drum'n bass live !
Holy mother of god dude. Amazing.
This dude just ran a marathon. Respect.
I was at Raleigh, got to see this at the first stop of the tour. Just blown away is an understatement. When we got back from the show and I started talking about this on Reddit with others who went to the show and they said you did the keyboard at the end too I couldn't believe it. At the show we saw you get up from the drums and we were like yeah that was a walk-off mic drop moment and figured you were back getting a much needed drink or something. Couldn't see anything through all the smoke.
Best live band I’ve seen. Godlike.
When I was young they said Eric Clapton and Lemmy were god.
Ilan Rubin is the new god.
Man best touring band for the last 5 or so years. Ya killed it every show I saw in 18’ saw the Friday and Sunday shows In NOLA @ Saenger.
Don't know how you played so amazingly with all that smoke! Well done! Never thought I'd see a live version of this song.
Then he’s like let play this piano and sing back up!!! Hellooo?! It’s nuts
the GOAT. Without question
That snare sound is nothing sort of a very busy day at a live artillery range. Sweet Jesus. Glad I found this guy, what a beast.
Best version of this already toptier song
This man is an animal! I love him!
Does the audience even know what they witnessed?
Some do
The drummer killed it. Trent is lucky to have him.