WW2: The Battles Won & Lost That Decided The Outcome Of The Greatest Conflict In History | Timeline

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 май 2020
  • As the war in the Pacific escalates, the Japanese have already established a foothold in mainland China, Singapore and Indonesia. However, the Australians prepare an offensive to drive the Japanese back...
    It's like Netflix for history... Sign up to History Hit, the world's best history documentary service, at a huge discount using the code 'TIMELINE' ---ᐳ bit.ly/3a7ambu
    You can find more from us on:
    / timelinewh
    / timelinewh
    This channel is part of the History Hit Network. Any queries, please contact owned-enquiries@littledotstudios.com
    #ConvoyPQ17 #KokodaTrackCampaign #PacificWar

Комментарии • 879

  • @waltershumate5777
    @waltershumate5777 4 года назад +98

    Them Aussies and Kiwis live in a pretty hearty environment in the first place. This makes for a tougher populous than one might imagine.
    Good on your mates!

    • @doaftheloaf
      @doaftheloaf 4 года назад +8

      as long as they're not fighting emus.

    • @dovetonsturdee7033
      @dovetonsturdee7033 4 года назад +2

      @Slim Jim A few days ago there was a quiz show on British television called 'Pointless' The category was 'Australian Birds' It involved showing photographs of birds (feathered variety) and putting the name underneath with alternate letters missing. The first one was a long necked critter with the letters E-U underneath. Of 100 people asked, how many got I right? I assumed around 96.
      Actually, Fifty bloody five.

    • @scottessery100
      @scottessery100 4 года назад

      @@doaftheloaf lmfao.... those emus were bloody tough and won the war

    • @goldbug7127
      @goldbug7127 4 года назад +2

      You bet, mate, just like us frozen Canucks. btw, the word is 'harsh'. as in difficult, not 'hearty' as in sincere and warm or 'hardy' as in manly and brave.

    • @waltershumate5777
      @waltershumate5777 4 года назад +1

      @@goldbug7127 that's true.
      And you've got to know that they're good fun Neighbors when you can call their Canada geese by saying
      "Who wants beer, eh?".

  • @whateverjones5473
    @whateverjones5473 4 года назад +123

    Finland: "Mess with the best, die like the rest." Australia: Same.

    • @sarcasmo57
      @sarcasmo57 3 года назад +9

      I hope we can hold out during the next war. It is coming.

    • @pappachan7267
      @pappachan7267 3 года назад +5

      @@sarcasmo57 most likely the war against the ccp in the west Pacific

    • @jedilordlog8543
      @jedilordlog8543 3 года назад +7

      @@sarcasmo57 The government doesn't care about a war, out submarine fleet is understaffed and our surface fleet is way too small. China if just going to buy all our businesses until we practically ARE China... we need to find a new trading partner ASAP so we can stop China from bullying us!

    • @katedaphne4495
      @katedaphne4495 2 года назад +2

      Australia is pityful these days.

    • @Man-cv5ws
      @Man-cv5ws 2 года назад +1

      Your Australian government have turned commie it appears. Took your gun rights years back now they take your hall pass.

  • @chriskowalski7038
    @chriskowalski7038 2 года назад +61

    Finally l found a vid that describes how the weather affected the outcome of WW2 especially the cold Russian winters...

    • @user-ru9np7hu3w
      @user-ru9np7hu3w 2 года назад +2

      To prove what ...?

    • @ovadiadan
      @ovadiadan 2 года назад +3

      There are many books about it...
      EDIT: I'm halfway through this documentary and there's no mention of Russia yet 😂

    • @haroldgeorge4222
      @haroldgeorge4222 2 года назад

      Russian's we're ready for the brutal winter - Germans I'll prepared .

    • @warrennelson2089
      @warrennelson2089 2 года назад

      Reference Auelutian Islands.

  • @celticman1909
    @celticman1909 2 года назад +36

    The critical action at Thalia that checked Rommel and saved the Allied situation was to the credit of US General Irwin. An Artillery officer that had orders to proceed elsewhere, and by happenstance, encountered a beleaguered formation of British troops that had been severely mauled by German forces and had little hope of surviving another attack sure to come on the morrow. After consultation with British officers and realizing the enormity of the situation strategically for the Allies in theater, Irwin set aside his travel orders and on his own authority, deployed his Artillery resources so that when the German attack arrived, they were surprised by formidable shell fire battering their vanguard. Unable to respond in kind, the German was compelled to withdraw.
    General Irwin was typical of the competent, dependable, professional officer that did his duty and never sought out the limelight for personal glory. General Omar Bradley spoke approving of such officers as the ones he could count on and never got the press coverage and credit they deserved. I think Irwin served as military governor of Austria in the post war Allied occupation.

  • @nobullmag
    @nobullmag 3 года назад +61

    I have nothing but the TOTAL 100 % respect for our Aussie and NZ brothers. The sacrifices they mate: they achieved: they accomplished will be remembered ALL over the world. Thank you my friends. You will be remembered X

    • @saltyaussie7702
      @saltyaussie7702 2 года назад +2

      As a modern day Aussie veteran what actually breaks my heart, is the fact that Patton was assassinated for wanting to take the USSR. Once the German's & Japanese where defeated, Patton wanted to take out the commies. How things would be different today if Patton was allowed to continue with his campaign. Unfortunately it never happened & we're dealing with today's current situation because of it. Yet thankyou my friend.

    • @sneakyfeats2353
      @sneakyfeats2353 2 года назад +1

      @@saltyaussie7702 it would've gone very badly. Had hostilities broken out, the reds had the equipment, manpower and supplies to exterminate the allies in mainland europe. The only advantage the allies held was in long range bombers, which would be unable to reach the soviet industrial centers feeding war machines into the fight. We also had only 1 nuke remaining out of the 4 which were produced and Stalin had already infiltrated the Manhatten Project, enabling them to test their own weapon 4 years later.

    • @blockraven22
      @blockraven22 2 года назад

      @@saltyaussie7702 he wanted to use remaining Nazis to help fight the Russians. I don’t think that would’ve went well with the rest of the world.

    • @fooo2241
      @fooo2241 2 года назад +1

      A great channel for learning more on the Aussie WW2 efforts and contributions - ruclips.net/video/pToxEa30KdU/видео.html

    • @dustinrobertson2965
      @dustinrobertson2965 2 года назад +1

      @@sneakyfeats2353 we would have had alot more allies than soviets

  • @williamwingo4740
    @williamwingo4740 2 года назад +437

    The two greatest generals in Russian history: General Hunger and General Winter.

    • @despinoladasilva
      @despinoladasilva 2 года назад +11

      Lol...

    • @robertleigh559
      @robertleigh559 2 года назад +32

      No. Actually it was Generals Mud and Winter!

    • @williamwingo4740
      @williamwingo4740 2 года назад +43

      @@despinoladasilva Maybe Hunger was still just a colonel.
      Added in edit: and of course, the United States had General Motors.

    • @JJ.-Jura_Jodel
      @JJ.-Jura_Jodel 2 года назад +4

      germans lost the war because soviets outsmart and outproduce them

    • @calebjay1wilson431
      @calebjay1wilson431 2 года назад +30

      Germany man for man probably had the Best military in the world man for man, but the Soviets had way more man power and tanks and economic resources to fight a long drawn out war. Germany expected to fight a quick and decisive war. Germany didn't have enough fuel and oil and didn't even have winter clothing in the first year of operation Barbarossa. Even after capturing millions of Russians in the first 6 months and completely dominating them, Germany failed to fight this long drawn out war. As a result operation Barbarossa was a failure.

  • @canuckguns
    @canuckguns Год назад +6

    бывшим советским солдатам, они так многим пожертвовали. Любовь из Канады.

    • @kudicid1234
      @kudicid1234 Год назад +1

      if only their leaders understood the price of life

  • @hemanag1020
    @hemanag1020 Год назад +20

    When i was in jail in the early 80s there were a group of books by an author called Sven Hassel. His books were about a military unit(German) which was made up of criminals, paroled from prison if they would go to the Russian front. The writing was so great with an ability to transport you into that world. I swear i found myself shivering a couple of times in my warm bed in my warm cell. The description of the cold, and the aspect of corpses or wounded being crushed under tracks were the things that were very chilling.

    • @SteveKarpali
      @SteveKarpali Год назад

      Bro, this is a great comment and im gonna look that book up now. Also, why were you in jail if you dont mind me asking?

    • @davepowell1661
      @davepowell1661 Год назад +1

      Prisoners pulled of the jail and chained to machine guns in pillboxes

    • @davepowell1661
      @davepowell1661 Год назад

      @@SteveKarpali Kiwi slang for luxury hotel room perhaps?

    • @animaltvi9515
      @animaltvi9515 Год назад +1

      Read most of that series great books they did make a film of wheels of terror. Was okay but the usually film based on a book.

    • @masr8875
      @masr8875 Год назад

      Are you referring to the Dirlewanger SS-brigade?

  • @RARDingo
    @RARDingo 4 года назад +272

    I would love to see you guys cover The Battle of Milne Bay.
    It was the first time that Japanese troops had been defeated in WW2.
    It was also the first time that Air, Sea & Land forces had been combined successfully in battle.
    To me, this is the most underrated acheivement of Australian forces in history.
    Keep up the good work!

    • @alt7488
      @alt7488 4 года назад +7

      even the videos i've seen on kododa gloss over milne bay

    • @somebloke3869
      @somebloke3869 4 года назад +3

      Former member of 25RQR?

    • @emmaherron5121
      @emmaherron5121 3 года назад +9

      Just so you know they don’t make these documentaries therefore they don’t decide what battles to cover.

    • @ThePiratemachine
      @ThePiratemachine 3 года назад +1

      @A C H But you didn't say combined....

    • @RARDingo
      @RARDingo 3 года назад +2

      @History Tank They were actually a mix of regulars & "chocos"

  • @thebridge5483
    @thebridge5483 2 года назад +138

    All my respects goes out to all the soldiers who fought during these world wars. They were man of mans.

    • @reptiliancyst878
      @reptiliancyst878 2 года назад +11

      Don’t forget the non combat engineers who kept the RED BULL
      EXPRESS ROLLING! My Grandpa was Ford mechanic thou he never killed the enemy he saved lives of our soldiers with his hands on repairing engines and maintenance. I’d give anything to have a couple hours now,
      just talking about the war, however, he died when I was 6 years old.

    • @Mustang1984
      @Mustang1984 2 года назад +2

      @@reptiliancyst878 Wasn't it the red ball express? Signified by the posters with a red ball on them showing the route?

    • @paleo704
      @paleo704 2 года назад +9

      @@Mustang1984 correct it was Red Ball. Redbull is a beverage

    • @andrem.thomas332
      @andrem.thomas332 2 года назад +3

      They were puppets like all soldiers are.

    • @paleo704
      @paleo704 2 года назад

      @@andrem.thomas332 like you are

  • @thomasaquinas2600
    @thomasaquinas2600 2 года назад +43

    The German drive on Moscow was more affected by Hitler's meddling than the weather. He ordered much of the panzers to stop driving east and turn about to seal the Kiev pocket. By the time they could return, it was too late. And, like Napoleon, it was not the cold that halted the army. In both cases the soldiers and horses suffered from the cold, but it was the rasputitsa (rain and mud) which made movement impossible. Both armies(French and German) actually welcomed the winter, which at least brought traversable roads. In the German case, the only detriment was when winter went from frosty to sub-zero cold...

    • @mathewm7136
      @mathewm7136 2 года назад +15

      eh, close but close enough to be accurate.
      -OKW's objective was to destroy the Russian army in the field within 8-10 weeks. Taking Moscow was never considered until Sep when plans were started for "Typhoon". The diversion of troops to Kiev was fully supported - and ORIGINALLY suggested - by OKW because they wanted to destroy the Russian army in exchange for captured territory. But because AH authorized it, he got the "holding the bag" blame.
      -It didn't just "Rain and Mud" on the German side of the front. The Russians, who were far less mechanized in '41 than Germany, suffered from it just as much.
      -In Sept, when the planning for "Typhoon" began, OKW Logistics told Army Group Center that they could have either adequate winter clothing for the onset of winter OR Fuel and Ammo for the upcoming push to Moscow. - not both. Army Group Center said "Ammo and Fuel as, with one last push, the war will be over."
      -Operation Typhoon's plan was NOT to capture Moscow, but encircle it. SO even then, Army Group Center NEVER intended to to physically capture it.
      So, if a blame is going to be laid, Army Group Centers overconfidence is at least equal to, if not greater, than any "meddling" done by AH.

    • @zyzxx1762
      @zyzxx1762 2 года назад +4

      Germany had too many men & machines fighting or stationed in other places. Logistics, supply & manpower were all concerns the generals understood but were overlooked by the OKW. Overconfidence (due to racist beliefs) and underestimating the enemy were Germany's undoing.

    • @mhlangamlungisi5108
      @mhlangamlungisi5108 Год назад +3

      The advance should not have been done full stop . Germany had got used to easy victories ion western Europe and thought likewise in theEast and they were wrong They had left hundreds of Soviet troops in their rear who harrassed their supply lines and rendered the frontline in Moscow and other cities . 100000 men were left in Kiev alone and these were like a boil under the skin of the Germans. So the advance was artificial than real they cut through the enemy leaving him behind them which their supply left their supply line vulnerable

    • @DawnOfTheDead991
      @DawnOfTheDead991 Год назад +6

      It didn't matter, German logistics couldn't supply a large army in the Moscow region.

    • @lorijohnson1478
      @lorijohnson1478 Год назад +1

      Inadequate winter gear and supplies made for a slow death for many of those poor men

  • @No-timeforimbeciles
    @No-timeforimbeciles Год назад +9

    Very few people alive today can comprehend the fighting on the eastern front & the conditions they suffered, modern Warfare has no comparison!

    • @marcusagrippa8078
      @marcusagrippa8078 Год назад

      The German soldiers were not given winter gear due to the fact that they were supposed to conquer Russia in a few months , but the Russian soldiers were not trained to the level of the Germans, and literally would pick up the guns that their fallen comrade dropped when killed by the Germans because they didn’t have a gun before then.
      Americans(me) aren’t really told about the most brutal/ lives lost front being the eastern front.
      The bulk of fatalities(soldier wise) was in Russia and Ukraine… the amount of Germans and soviets killed in those short years is mind blowing.

    • @edwardballard5896
      @edwardballard5896 Год назад

      Ukraine

    • @No-timeforimbeciles
      @No-timeforimbeciles Год назад

      @@edwardballard5896 😂

  • @melvinmorrison4793
    @melvinmorrison4793 Год назад +4

    I'm aboriginal from Canada my father an all my uncles fought..one was killed in Belgium an two were wounded..my father was a sniper in the black watch..

  • @colinthompson3345
    @colinthompson3345 2 года назад +65

    The reality was more complex than this. Barbarossa failed for a number of reasons, the inability to adequately supply and maintain the Third Reichs combat forces, The inability of the Wermarcht to destroy the Red Army which was far larger and fought far harder than the Nazis predicted. Barbarossa was less of a plan and more of a product of optimistic wishful thinking.

    • @beltigussin81
      @beltigussin81 Год назад +2

      Hitler's "special operation"

    • @julianshepherd2038
      @julianshepherd2038 Год назад

      It failed because Hitlers racial and political theories were nonsense and logistics.

    • @marksauder9247
      @marksauder9247 Год назад

      3.5 million dead Germans vs. 27 million dead Russians

  • @Exotic3000
    @Exotic3000 2 года назад +8

    Australia 🇦🇺 is the greatest! They are reliable. They help the British when necessary. Then they help the USA 🇺🇸 WHEN needed. Australia is our best friend. Thanks from Canada 🇨🇦!

    • @caspian5964
      @caspian5964 Год назад

      Why did you do every flag except the Union Jack?

  • @feelinglikeandretti2970
    @feelinglikeandretti2970 Год назад +3

    What a absolutely fantastic documentary! I've watched basically everything there is on WW2 and somehow all of this was new information. Loved it

  • @sciencenate
    @sciencenate Год назад +3

    My favorite part was when the actors moved the X’s and O’s on the big map and pretended to be generals. Absolutely thrilling stuff

    • @davepowell1661
      @davepowell1661 Год назад

      Look harder, military strategy was being deliberately obfuscated lest the cameramen was aware of OXO tactical propaganda, the resulting confusion was indescribable apparently

  • @yami6499
    @yami6499 Год назад +6

    Timeline documentaries are so in depth and factual...probably the best

  • @deanseawa
    @deanseawa 3 года назад +20

    The title seems to have applied only to the first 5 minutes of this video. The rest had nothing to do with Australia.

  • @LibertarianPenticost
    @LibertarianPenticost 2 года назад +5

    Very professional documentation
    and displayed, very good work!

  • @kruxxed1339
    @kruxxed1339 3 года назад +12

    My great grandpa on my grandma's side served in the 54th battalion in WW1

  • @davidjohnson4298
    @davidjohnson4298 Год назад +2

    The suffering of both German and Russian was horrible

  • @akajakeyyale1897
    @akajakeyyale1897 2 года назад +2

    Man y’all really should do these more justice... The same old main stream stuff has been beat into the ground! Ppl deserve more

  • @rikijett310
    @rikijett310 Год назад +1

    Great video!!!! Very well done!!!! 👍👍

  • @whiterabit09
    @whiterabit09 4 года назад +134

    The first 5 mins was relevant.

    • @MendTheWorld
      @MendTheWorld 4 года назад +17

      so was the next 5 minutes, and the next 2 minutes after that.

    • @robertprigmore4774
      @robertprigmore4774 3 года назад +23

      Much like my 1st marriage marriage

    • @scottleft3672
      @scottleft3672 3 года назад +1

      Earth time says 11 min 54 seconds, the moon where you are is slowed by half, clearly.

    • @thelordgold
      @thelordgold 3 года назад +3

      As far as what Australia contributed towards winning the war, I think they were more than generous with time allotment.

    • @thebois2190
      @thebois2190 3 года назад +1

      @@thelordgold * laughs in the rats of Tobruk*

  • @ThePiratemachine
    @ThePiratemachine 3 года назад +14

    I was very interested in The Kokoda Trail information as Dad was in New Guinea for three years and never said anything so I am grateful for your providing information. It was new to me that the Australians were successful reasonably quickly. Thanks again - and for the Finnish history. Not much is known of these two area as far as I know and you have done something to remedy that.

    • @dianneblack4395
      @dianneblack4395 3 года назад +1

      Its the Kokada track not trail

    • @MJTAUTOMOTIVE
      @MJTAUTOMOTIVE 3 года назад +1

      @@dianneblack4395 . It is recognized by the PNG Government and the Australian war memorial as the Kokoda Trail.

    • @montecarlo1651
      @montecarlo1651 3 года назад

      @@MJTAUTOMOTIVE Actually, preferred official usage is Track and it was originally only known as Track. Trial is an Americanisation creeping into the language and should be resisted, not least for the veterans sake (the yanks had a habit of claiming everything for themselves - let's at least keep the Kokoda story our own by retaining the correct name).

    • @nickdanger3802
      @nickdanger3802 3 года назад

      @@montecarlo1651 "Kokoda Trail" and "Kokoda Track" have been used interchangeably since the Second World War and the former was adopted by the Battles Nomenclature Committee as the official British Commonwealth battle honour in October 1957.
      Kokoda Trail Campaign
      www.awm.gov.au/collection/E84663

    • @montecarlo1651
      @montecarlo1651 3 года назад

      @@nickdanger3802 Thanks for bringing this to my attention, certainly the first I have heard of it. I don't have a reference but I thought I heard the AWM was promoting Track as correct usage, by the link you provided, seems either my memory fails me or I'm straight up wrong. I appreciate your adding the link.

  • @billmason2785
    @billmason2785 2 года назад +21

    America is very thankful for our Australian allies and acknowledge your sacrifice in WW2 👍🌏🇦🇺

    • @gregfrench1254
      @gregfrench1254 2 года назад +1

      Unity of all human beings. If your not into that, there's your sign! Lol

    • @anon2427
      @anon2427 Год назад

      @@gregfrench1254 no

  • @MisteriosGloriosos922
    @MisteriosGloriosos922 2 года назад +1

    *Thanks for your informative video, Have a great time and be safe!*

  • @zulubeatz1
    @zulubeatz1 4 года назад +41

    The Finns & The Aussies. Tough, tough soldiers. Just as the Japanese are not all Jungle experts not all Russians can fight in the snow it seems.Credit has to go to the Finns for only fighting to regain lost territory and not getting in to deep with the Nazis. Clever move.

    • @JungerWeisserMann
      @JungerWeisserMann 2 года назад +1

      Watch "Europa The Last Battle", "In The Name Of Zion" and "The Greatest Story Never Told" on bitchute if reality interests you.

    • @ci6516
      @ci6516 2 года назад +4

      @Oscar Pinto from those who won like always. If you want to write history , win

  • @jonathanbennetts2632
    @jonathanbennetts2632 2 года назад +3

    my grandfather's brother died in on the Thai Burma railway. I put a flower on his headstone in Kanchanaburi Thailand last year. I am 52 now. But I know where my blood lies.

  • @hollow_9476
    @hollow_9476 Год назад +1

    38:00 i wonder if anyone dived in that area and explored it for the ships that sunk 🤔

  • @klayofthemystics
    @klayofthemystics 4 года назад +16

    I was watching, then stepped out of the room, came back in and for some reason the Finish, Soviets and Germans were in the snow

  • @NITWIT856
    @NITWIT856 Год назад +5

    Some tough men. My heart goes out to what these children had to endure. Because they were children

  • @zulubeatz1
    @zulubeatz1 4 года назад +105

    What an interesting film. These are often historically neglected campaigns so its great to see something like this. not revisionist sensationalist rehashes of the usual big battles. It makes me want to look further into the Finnish - Russian war & also research the Australian & New Zealand contribution to the Allied victory.

    • @minnowpd
      @minnowpd 3 года назад +4

      Aye, the lesser known campaigns were real enough for those who served. The Finns? they made the soviets suffer on the Raate Road.

    • @tonylove4800
      @tonylove4800 3 года назад +1

      The British and French etc (I am a Kiwi and we declared war before Britain - if you count the time difference) declared war because Germany invaded Poland. Fair enough. They then did nothing and Poland was a slave state for the next 50 years. The British also did nothing when Stalin invaded Finland. I guess they knew they would need the Soviets. After Finland's treatment by Stalin, why didn't they help the Nazis out at Leningrad? The course of human history could be very different (not better, just different).

    • @thomasstevens8095
      @thomasstevens8095 3 года назад

      @@tonylove4800 ANZACS are too strong brother, people may not recognise our contribution in Africa and Kokoda but it sure was important to us!!!

    • @academyofnaturaljustice8939
      @academyofnaturaljustice8939 3 года назад +2

      If you want the truth about WW2, you can only find it by studying Stalin?
      AIF 2/15 battalion from Queensland Australia were the first to defeat the Germans in land battle at Tobruk.
      The Aussies were also the first to defeat the Japanese in land battle at Milne bay PNG.
      My uncle Tommy RIP fought there.

    • @thomasstevens8095
      @thomasstevens8095 3 года назад +3

      Ripped Hoff, yes Australians are some of the best soldiers as they have a high kill per death ratio and are very tough

  • @minionviking1532
    @minionviking1532 Год назад +3

    Love the fact these are battles I've never really heard of or was taught about in school many moons ago...
    There was more than the battle of Britain and D-Day...school syllabus' are seriously lacking. I doubt it has changed...would be interesting to find out what they include these days

  • @Snipeyou1
    @Snipeyou1 2 года назад +3

    Thank you for pushing these documentaries out!

  • @matthewzablocki5310
    @matthewzablocki5310 2 года назад +6

    The Shogun of Japan said this to the Emperor, "I can only promise 6 months of victory". We need to win the war within that time frame cause after that, idk whats gonna happen". 6 months later was pearl harbor.
    The shogun went back to the emperor and said this about the u.s. "We have made a grave mistake" "I think we have awoken a sleeping giant".

  • @jamesplease1980
    @jamesplease1980 4 года назад +28

    Kokoda is actually a really gripping story and I feel this didn't do justice. better than being ignored. Interestingly though, latest research showed the Japanese made a last stand at eora creek but got smashed by the 2/3rd battalion. Later general hori made "corrections" and backdated the paperwork to hide the Japanese retreat.

    • @davidearea242
      @davidearea242 4 года назад +2

      jamesplease1980 - Must be standard practice. The history they teach at schools regarding WW2 contains plenty of 'corrections' as well.

    • @ThePiratemachine
      @ThePiratemachine 3 года назад +1

      THE BATTLE OF AUSTRALIA equivalent THE BATTLE OF BRITAIN

    • @alganhar1
      @alganhar1 3 года назад +4

      To be fair, it did little justice to ANY of the operations described in the video! Virtually no one in the UK knows anything of the fighting that 14th Army went through for example. Despite the unit designations there were a lot of British troops there, African and Indian Army Brigades were generally made up of two African or Indian Battalions, and a British Battalion. As a result at least a third of the troops fighting in those actions were British (though many would attempt to say otherwise).

  • @charliekezza
    @charliekezza 4 года назад +34

    Lest we forget!

    • @jaredprince4772
      @jaredprince4772 3 года назад +1

      One of my coworkers has a shirt that says, "Lest we don't forget." I asked him how substantial was the discount?

  • @trohland1001
    @trohland1001 4 года назад +106

    I was mostly interested in the Australian point of view and their specific involvement in the war. However, the topic of the video title only lasts for the first 5 minutes of the video and then moves on to describe multiple world powers and war theaters... stupid.

    • @rileygardner4336
      @rileygardner4336 4 года назад +9

      Agreed

    • @troys9222
      @troys9222 4 года назад +19

      Yeah, it's like someone found the video somewhere not knowing what it was, then watched the first few minutes of the video when deciding what to call it. I was looking forward to an entire hour dedicated to a lesser known part of the war as well.

    • @rascallyrabbit8548
      @rascallyrabbit8548 4 года назад +6

      i enjoyed what i got for free

    • @Bobbyjonesyrrr
      @Bobbyjonesyrrr 3 года назад +3

      Some context not established in this video is the fact that the majority of Australia's main forces were stuck in North Africa and Europe, defending various fronts. The Australians were always weary of the Japanese and were nervous about contributing so much to Europe under British assurances that Singapore would hold.... No one predicted the Japanese to push through South East Asia relatively uncontested and so quickly. When Singapore fell Australia went into full panic mode. Most of the forces left in Australia were reservists, conscripted and injured/retired/veterans. The unique defensible position of the Australian continent led the American's to base their main Pacific operations command in Brisbane and the Australian Government, given their vulnerable position, gave over command of the remaining Australian groups to General MacArthur.

    • @jaystreet46
      @jaystreet46 3 года назад +1

      😭😭

  • @chrisjohnson2771
    @chrisjohnson2771 2 года назад

    Great video

  • @charlesmiller3114
    @charlesmiller3114 2 года назад +2

    Great video. Too bad it had nothing to do with the title.

  • @goldentaco4970
    @goldentaco4970 Год назад

    Yes! My favorite Timelines. The ones that don't began with the dude in the plane trying to sell the documentary website.

  • @WilliamJasonSherwood
    @WilliamJasonSherwood 4 года назад +24

    Should have posted this a few days earlier -- 25 of April is ANZAC Day (Australian & New Zealand's biggest military celebration/remembrance).

    • @johayes7529
      @johayes7529 4 года назад +4

      Why bother a 10 minute half arsed account of that campaign isn't worth putting up on ANZAC DAY! It's not a celebration either, it's a day to remember your fallen mates!

    • @paulbaker9277
      @paulbaker9277 4 года назад +1

      Beside, they be at each others throats , that is why they teach them to fight together, in between times.

    • @theone-swta
      @theone-swta 3 года назад

      @@paulbaker9277 That is not true.

    • @ThePiratemachine
      @ThePiratemachine 3 года назад +1

      @@johayes7529 You wouldn't have even ten minutes if Australian troops hadn't stopped them and given their lives for you to express yourself, but I like your last sentiment.

  • @loupiscanis9449
    @loupiscanis9449 4 года назад +1

    Thank you

  • @Dulcimertunes
    @Dulcimertunes Год назад +1

    This title only applies to a small part of this video but it’s still a great history lesson

  • @KateLicker
    @KateLicker 4 года назад +7

    it was getting a bit warm and sweaty on Kokoda for our battalions, so we thought we'd transfer them to Finland.

  • @jonwingfieldhill6143
    @jonwingfieldhill6143 2 года назад +28

    One of the reasons Germany lost the war was whilst virtually every other power was engaged in the doctrine of total war and had switched their economy to a war economy. Germany concentrated their economy to production of household goods and maintenance of living standards and used resources from captured countries to prop up their economy but as soon as they started losing access to those resources they couldn't afford to maintain the war. Everything they gained came from shrewd political manoeuvres and concentrated overwhelming force but when they slowed down and dispersed their forces to hold territory they couldn't hold against numerically superior forces.

    • @samcolt1079
      @samcolt1079 Год назад

      THEY LOST BECAUSE THE WORLD COULD SEE THAT THEY WERE DISGUSTING SCUM AND HAD TO BE STOMPED IN TO THE GROUND KNOW MATTER WHAT. THANK THE LORD FOR SAVING THE WORLD FROM THEM. ITS TO BAD SO MANY NAZIS GOT AWAY.

    • @michaelwackers6475
      @michaelwackers6475 Год назад

      TOTAL BS! Germany of all powers was not engaged in total war? MY FOOT! Ever heard the infamous Goebbels speech?

    • @Frank-jg4tq
      @Frank-jg4tq 11 месяцев назад

      This is a really good summary

  • @TheAnthoula14
    @TheAnthoula14 4 года назад +11

    I enjoy this series for the history, but I got to admit it, I almost enjoy the two guys glaring at each other across the board almost as much.

    • @bgswansonlocc
      @bgswansonlocc 2 года назад

      It was very humorous to me as well

  • @unclescipio3136
    @unclescipio3136 Год назад +2

    The only thing worse than having to fight in terrain like that is having to fight flipping Aussies in terrain like that.

  • @rogersledz6793
    @rogersledz6793 Год назад

    Thank you so much for uploading this video. It is helping me get through the pandemic!

  • @janspup6232
    @janspup6232 2 года назад +3

    Which is worse??? Hot and humid jungle or sub zero frozen wasteland, they're both brutal.

  • @laopang91362
    @laopang91362 2 года назад +11

    Winter was equally brutal to both sides. But the defenders were more determined than the aggressors.

    • @shmetienne
      @shmetienne 2 года назад +6

      also home advantage/growing up in that environment, like you said definitely terrible for both sides the russians were more molded to it

    • @williamwingo4740
      @williamwingo4740 Год назад +5

      The Russians also had better cold-weather equipment: overcoats, etc. Also, their tanks. planes, vehicles, etc. were simpler and better designed for harsh conditions.

  • @caractacusbrittania7442
    @caractacusbrittania7442 2 года назад +4

    Title is incorrect,
    Russian autumn stopped the advance, roads became two feet deep of thick glutenous mud,
    Vehicles, tanks, trucks, supply lorries, none could move.
    When the first winter frost and snow appeared, the roads hardened, the
    Vehicles could move again, even though it was difficult to unfreeze equipment.

  • @noone-td8rc
    @noone-td8rc Год назад

    👌👍good video

  • @MH-nc5jd
    @MH-nc5jd 3 года назад +25

    Guerilla forces have proven to be a key to beat much superior militarys... Home field advantage and the will to fight for literally forever seems to wear down most invaders.. the inavders usually have some dumb idea that they can do it quickly and everyone will surrender.. so many times the latter has that proven idiotic to say the least...

  • @eddiemerc1986
    @eddiemerc1986 2 года назад +13

    Anyone with a little background on history would wonder why the wermacht was stucked in the Soviet Union too long until winter showed up. Barbarossa, even though was delayed for weeks, was planned to last for a month and a half giving the nazis almost 2 months to spare before winter season. The only possible explaination is the Wermacht never quite realized the timeframe they calculated to conquer the soviets was too optimistic. About winter and the catastrophic results, well, an 8 year old scholar would know that.

    • @unirod23
      @unirod23 Год назад +2

      The Wermacht sure was a strong fighting force.
      But so was the british Heir Force and the US American Naywi.
      Hope this doesn't come across to harsh but it's spelled "Wehrmacht". Roughly translates to "Counterforce".

  • @ilokivi
    @ilokivi Год назад +1

    Finland's border with the USSR shown at 13:02 is not that which existed at the outbreak of the Winter War (Talvisota) in November 1939, but that which was decided on after the end of the Continuation War (Jatkosota) in September 1944. The Mannerheim VKT defence line existed on the Karelian isthmus, between Ladoga (Laatokanjárvi) and the Gulf of Finland.

  • @The_Daily_Tomato
    @The_Daily_Tomato 4 года назад +16

    Good video but this simply must be said.
    The title of the video is extremely misleading.
    I clicked this expecting this to be only about Australia's fight against the Japanese Empire, instead it's a mixture of everything, most having nothing to do with Australia.

    • @jaredprince4772
      @jaredprince4772 3 года назад +1

      Yeah, I passed it on to my girlfriend to improve her recipe for meatloaf. Her meatloaf is much better now thanks to this video.

    • @ovadiadan
      @ovadiadan 2 года назад

      @@jaredprince4772 lmao

    • @ovadiadan
      @ovadiadan 2 года назад

      Strongly agree. The funny thing is it doesn't even make sense to make the title about Russian Winters. Something just seems off...

    • @The_Daily_Tomato
      @The_Daily_Tomato 2 года назад

      @@ovadiadan They seemed to have changed the title since I was here last 🙃

  • @lcifermorningstar191
    @lcifermorningstar191 2 года назад +1

    Love history ❤️

  • @phrayzar
    @phrayzar 3 года назад +7

    Very nicely made series, partially spoilt by the two dudes eyeing each other up over the board game.

    • @jaredprince4772
      @jaredprince4772 3 года назад +4

      Their apparent budding romance was either to arouse interest or remind us of the horrors of war. I'm not sure which.

  • @domingodeanda233
    @domingodeanda233 2 года назад +1

    Damn!! That was pretty damn good

  • @littleredhen3354
    @littleredhen3354 2 года назад +1

    I love that the Australian military uniforms included shorts👍

  • @uvutshila3821
    @uvutshila3821 2 года назад

    The war-strategizing guys in the cutaways did it 4 me.

  • @pranavr9783
    @pranavr9783 4 года назад +11

    I like the video of Australia vs Japan is there possibility of having Gurkha involvement in war. I know it a very large topic. Something perhaps as asking for every Britain war from 200 year. I am really interested for there involvement from anglo Gurkha war. Anglo Afghan war. WW1. And WW2 . Falkland etc. They are army that even the enemy admire for there bravery and determination. And currently serving part of britan!. Indian's and Nepali Army. Also Sultan of Borneo has a unit as well. I hope you can enlighten us with there history. I know few thing about them but I know there is alot to learn. 🙏

    • @wekapeka3493
      @wekapeka3493 4 года назад +3

      The Gurkha are renowned for their discipline, honour, tenacity, training, bravery etc.......... and every other positive adjective that could be used to describe a superlative military unit.

  • @scottessery100
    @scottessery100 4 года назад +4

    7:55 strewth... F *** me dead that looks like a sav holiday hike mate.

  • @Spiritfba
    @Spiritfba 2 года назад

    Those Fins were pretty badass.

  • @Guide1089
    @Guide1089 3 года назад

    Very good video, but the number of ads break up the continuity of the program.

  • @ritamedina-molina8550
    @ritamedina-molina8550 Год назад +1

    Extremely interesting...I never knew the australians are such tough brave fighters

  • @mitchellhedden1978
    @mitchellhedden1978 Год назад +1

    The guy in the thumbnail must be going grocery shopping.

  • @wernesgruder1
    @wernesgruder1 4 года назад +14

    Australia went into WW2 with a really bad army and came out with a really good one.

    • @wekapeka3493
      @wekapeka3493 4 года назад +4

      That’s a thought and it’s probably true for all (was going to say Commonwealth) allied forces. This was the result of fighting an enemy who had been secretly planning for it for a decade. We must heed the lessons of the past!

    • @Maxyshadow
      @Maxyshadow 4 года назад +5

      There was nothing bad about the performance of the Australian divisions in the middle east.

    • @richardperezcamacho4810
      @richardperezcamacho4810 4 года назад

      03

    • @eliasjarjoura445
      @eliasjarjoura445 3 года назад

      @@Maxyshadow far east you mean

    • @johnnyneverletmedown53
      @johnnyneverletmedown53 3 года назад +1

      @@eliasjarjoura445 No, Max means middle east where Rommel couldn't beat them.

  • @mubaarigruush7358
    @mubaarigruush7358 2 года назад +25

    The russian winter is not why Russia won over the Germans. That might have been a minor effect in the war but not the sole reason. The Germans were defeated by the heroic people of Russia. It was blood and sweat that defeated the Germans.

    • @vgrepairs
      @vgrepairs 2 года назад +2

      Agreed.

    • @tonyromano6220
      @tonyromano6220 2 года назад +9

      Winter absolutely stopped the Germans in 41.
      And mud…..

    • @vgrepairs
      @vgrepairs 2 года назад +2

      @@tonyromano6220 winter pushed the germans all the way back to Berlin?

    • @jamesgreene4811
      @jamesgreene4811 2 года назад +1

      Keep telling yourself that and you might just believe it as for russia defeating Germany yea along with America England and it's empire France Canada Australia and on and on and yea the weather in russia stopped the German army at the gates of Moscow Fact

    • @cambs0181
      @cambs0181 Год назад +1

      Heroic people of the USSR!

  • @sonofthesoutherncross1836
    @sonofthesoutherncross1836 3 года назад +14

    Lest we forget … courage mate ship and pride … god bless Australia 🇦🇺

  • @yurigabrilovich2190
    @yurigabrilovich2190 Год назад +1

    Winters dont win wars Superior bravery heroism and valor wins wars plus superior weapons tactics and fighting for your motherland In Zhukov they had the best general

  • @Anonymouscommentor99
    @Anonymouscommentor99 Год назад

    The futuristic tabletop prop is ridiculous. Done with this one. Yoog

  • @scottleft3672
    @scottleft3672 4 года назад +5

    2:10 "Our Boys" marching past Town Hall and south down George st, sadly 34 thousand never returned....RIP.

    • @uyraellsensenmann8931
      @uyraellsensenmann8931 4 года назад +3

      "They shall not grow old, as we who are left grow old,
      Age shall not weary them, nor the years condemn,
      At the going down of the Sun, and in the morning, we will remember them:
      We WILL Remember Them."
      ---Laurence Binyon.
      To My Aussie ANZAC Cousins, Eternal Respect !
      Kind and Respectful Regards, Uyraell, NZ.

    • @scottleft3672
      @scottleft3672 4 года назад +1

      @@uyraellsensenmann8931 Sadly we get all the kudos, Kiwis were better than us by and large....only just, lol.

  • @NathanChisholm041
    @NathanChisholm041 4 года назад +7

    Proud Aussie right here!!

    • @06458637
      @06458637 4 года назад +1

      Same here, ausie,ausie, ow,ow,ow

    • @ThePiratemachine
      @ThePiratemachine 3 года назад

      Errol Flynn Rod Taylor!!!

    • @dianneblack4395
      @dianneblack4395 3 года назад +2

      @Baby Sama 48 Australian and proud of it by an exNational servicmen.

    • @anthonyeaton5153
      @anthonyeaton5153 3 года назад +1

      Proud Brit here.

    • @NathanChisholm041
      @NathanChisholm041 3 года назад

      @@dianneblack4395 Ex 16th light horse reg Perth WA here...

  • @-AxisA-
    @-AxisA- Год назад +4

    I thought this whole video would be about the Nazis vs Soviets, but seeing my countrymen defending our homeland against the Soviets in white gear and skis, so properly fitted to the Finnish winter put a smile on face😄 I always say to people that complain about cold weather what my father told me when I was young "There's no such thing as too cold weather. Just too little clothes."
    Edit: The guy speaks about "Motti" tactic, which is basically querilla warfare. Like he said Motti means a pile of wood, speficially a cubic meter of wood, so it means piling the little wood logs one by one to a huge pile, so that was basically what the Finnish super light ski forces were doing to the enemy. Chipping at them little by little. Hitting and retreating super fast.

    • @calebjay1wilson431
      @calebjay1wilson431 Год назад +1

      The Finns are warriors man. I'm from Texas my dna is mostly Scottish, Scandinavian and German with 2% Finnish. They smashed the Russians

  • @zeussy1377
    @zeussy1377 2 года назад +5

    ‘The key to taking over Russia is getting to Moscow before winter.’
    Napoleon would disagree

  • @johnelliott7375
    @johnelliott7375 Год назад +2

    The German army in Africa at this time was wore out, lack of supplies, support, weaponry and materials ensured that the fresh 300,000 troops didn't have a chance and eventually was captured being surrounded at Tunis.

  • @JerzyFeliksKlein
    @JerzyFeliksKlein 4 года назад +20

    Quite disappointing to be honest, a complete mash up of random battles with no link between them.

    • @hodaka1000
      @hodaka1000 4 года назад +2

      .....and not much to do with Australia or Japan

    • @ThePiratemachine
      @ThePiratemachine 3 года назад

      Can't see that. Thought it was good. Try adapting.

  • @tommybrown9534
    @tommybrown9534 2 года назад +1

    Even their military dressed like Steve Irwin..guy's a legend!! 🤷‍♂️

  • @johnelliott7375
    @johnelliott7375 Год назад +1

    The main supply and effort was being used and needed on the Eastern front.

  • @jasonfrew2394
    @jasonfrew2394 Год назад

    Nobody ever seems to remember bringing warm winter boots.

  • @MorphingReality
    @MorphingReality Год назад

    Wasn't expecting the dibs usage

  • @haleysharp1247
    @haleysharp1247 Год назад

    The 2 guys playing checkers is a bit funny. It's like visualizing a passive aggressive argument.

  • @johnfraumano3334
    @johnfraumano3334 4 года назад +3

    Good bit on the Kokoda Track. Pity it got so cold so quickly. What's the point of having two guys eyeing each other off over a board that has no resemblance to a real map? They look like a couple of plonkers.

  • @theodoresmith5272
    @theodoresmith5272 3 года назад +5

    The best of Aussie troops were in Egypt. Britain wouldn't return them. The troops that fought in the battle described were old home guard. After the British failed to return the troops, australia has worked with the Americans that helped keep Japan from cutting off Australia.

    • @peteranson4021
      @peteranson4021 3 года назад +2

      Actually not correct. The 39th Battalion that met the Japanese at Kokoda were militia but they became a highly successful force. Two other militia battalions failed against the Japanese. The 39th were reinforced at Isurava by the 2/14th Battalion, part of the 7th Division that had returned from the Middle East. Further reinforcements arrived in the 2/16th Battalion and later the 2/25th. All of these battalions had fighting experience, but not in the jungle. By the time the Japanese had reached the limit of their advance, these three battalions (I think about 2500 men) were so depleted by death, wounding or illness that they could only muster around 150 fit men who became "Chaforce" and were part of the force that defeated the Japanese at Gona. My father-in-law was in the 2/14th and Chaforce.

    • @dovetonsturdee7033
      @dovetonsturdee7033 3 года назад

      The 9th Division remained in North Africa, but the 6th & 7th returned in early 1942. In exchange for retaining the 9th, the British undertook to expand the RAAF to 73 squadrons, and the US to send additional US troops to Australia. The 9th Division returned to Australia in January 1943.

    • @ronjohnson1658
      @ronjohnson1658 3 года назад +1

      Certainly not old home guard - they were young conscripts rounded up off the streets of Sydney and Melbourne and they held and then gave a fighting retreat to the Japanese until reinforced when they counterattacked and annihilated the Japanese at Buna Gona.

    • @montecarlo1651
      @montecarlo1651 3 года назад +1

      @@ronjohnson1658 Correct, nothing like a Home Guard. They were conscripted for limited service in Australia and the nearby islands. The AIF on the other hand was a wholly volunteer service. There was a lot of movement from the CMF to the AIF during the war too as men elected to transfer, ie: volunteer.

  • @TheBrianFlanagan
    @TheBrianFlanagan 3 года назад +2

    “Operation Morning Wind” sounds like me in bed after a night of whiskey and hot dogs. 🌭😂

    • @MH-fb5kr
      @MH-fb5kr 2 года назад

      Chili dogs…

  • @skyislands8887
    @skyislands8887 3 года назад +6

    Research "Z force" and "Coast Watchers". These men are the pivotal reason behind many of these allied (Australian / NZ / British and US) successes. Living behind enemy lines for weeks to even years, supported by local populations, in some cases completely independent - living hand in mouth. They preformed every thing from 'strategic' assignments (incl. killings) / guided naval or aerial bombing , report enemy troop / shipping / air movements, guided landing allied troops. Behind the enemy and ahead of the allies all the way to Japan.
    I had the pleasure of meeting 2 original Z force men, humble and unassuming, yet their endurance and incredible contribution to the war effort has little public awareness. Many were educated men, proficient in linguistics, entomologists, accountants, cattle men, engineers...…
    Officially in WW2 they 'did not exist', a highly trained elite that even friendlies feared and respected, let alone the opposing forces. UK / Nazi's had Commandos, US has the likes of green berets Australia had Z force, a world first in concept, truly next level solders, the forbears of many subsequent special forces training regimes around the world.
    Lest we Forget

    • @davidwall2919
      @davidwall2919 3 года назад +1

      Do you know anything about M specials? More secret than Z force but same command about 30 men directly under Macarthur, Australian, NZ, UK and Dutch. You might have seen the picture of M Special Unit Sergeant Leonard Siffleet being executed by the japanese in the last days of WW2 ..Bushido.

  • @1986fritzthecat
    @1986fritzthecat 3 года назад +7

    I quite like maps as visual aides, however the random guys emphatically moving around the tokens was laughable

  • @RoadTripzz14
    @RoadTripzz14 2 года назад +3

    Couple of points here: The Russians killed more German soldiers than any other nation. It was cold, snowy and challenging for BOTH sides. It’s like saying the English Channel halted the German advance. It kinda did but that is a glaring disservice to magnificent English bravery.

  • @SEEMAX-2012
    @SEEMAX-2012 Год назад

    nice

  • @vratislavspacek776
    @vratislavspacek776 Год назад

    Ty dokumenty já můžu sou super

  • @MendTheWorld
    @MendTheWorld 4 года назад +4

    I appreciate their usage of original black and white film footage. Colorized video really annoys me.

    • @MendTheWorld
      @MendTheWorld 2 года назад

      @@blakemortellaro I find your comment annoying. 🤬

  • @blinkblink1969
    @blinkblink1969 Год назад

    Please show the Battle of Schrute Farm next please.

  • @briantayler1230
    @briantayler1230 4 года назад +4

    Gidday from Australia, I do wonder why these documentaries must have "Tiger" and "Panther" tanks racing to Moscow in 1941, 2 to 3 years before they existed. Is there no time relevant film archives available?

    • @KateLicker
      @KateLicker 4 года назад +1

      it's not the only ballsed-up archive footage in the docus here...right at the start, RAAF A20s are shown in the air as the Japanese first land in NG..
      you see this kind of thing on all network channel docus, why they are unable to have the archive film selections edited/vetted by someone who has some idea wtf they are looking at, I don't know..there are 11YOs making plastic model airplanes who would have enough knowledge to know better..
      how many times have we seen USN SBDs and TBMs attacking Pearl Harbor??

  • @terrancedactielle5460
    @terrancedactielle5460 3 года назад +2

    This needs more adverts please...........

  • @1Daphdong
    @1Daphdong 3 года назад +2

    The First Aussies that faced the Japanese were, in fact, Militia. Not regular soldiers..They were told that they faced about a thousand Japanese..Of course it was much, much more.

  • @FrostRare
    @FrostRare 2 года назад

    What tabletop wargame are those guys playing it looks fun