@@philipe1966I think they mean in addition to this version with the choir. And given how it can be more heard (imo), it gives a bigger impact to the already angelic sounding vocals
I think that it's because was a call from the other side, not a memory. the song is clearly a mother mourning the loss of her son, both a letter to and about her little boy, however that "Fall in!" is the call from the other side in what would have been the most calming thing that the boy would have known. A sense of "this is the place that I must be at." with this I think it's the last time that the boy sees his mother, through his spirit, before he moves on. but that's just what I get out of it
@@carminerose2116fall in is a military command for cadets to fall in place like a assembly line, in order to either train, drill, or prepare to go into war such of what happened to the son
@@carminerose2116yes, the fall in part is also in the song, but it's kinda rare for cover to add it, so it's a great addition and makes the atmosphere of this cover even more thematic
This is so good! While Kate Bush sings from the perspective of the mother, this feels like it's being sung by the pallbearers as they carry the coffin, I love it!
My baby brother left for the army just the other day. Whenever I hear this song, I cannot help but think about him. I never want there to come a day when I hear this song and cry. Please let there never be such a day.
Even as a grown man i cry hearing this song. I don't know, there will come a day when all of us can relate to this song. I hope that day doesn't came when we are alive.
Yes, this song is about a fallen soldier. Yet I cannot reject the self grieve over myself. I didn't come back the same guy I was. As if I died too in the army.
I didn't even know it was a command, i thought it was the sounds of soldiers dying. Maybe it's meant to sound like both? Anyways, I agree, it gave me chills too.
this version sounds like a father mourning his son, maybe even some guilt? Perhaps a father who made his son join the army like him, but ultimately regrets it Amazing work!
Oh this is beautiful! I was hoping to find a cover where the 'bfpo/mammy's hero' in the background was a bit more audible and this pulled it off so well
I can't help but think that this song can also be synonymous to some of us who didn't get to achieve our own dreams due to difficulties in our own lives 💔
That’s why this song drew me in. I’m saddened for all the lives taken so young fighting but also saddened because of the dreams I feel like I haven’t achieved or can’t achieve.
whenever I hear this song I begin to tear up. my father was in the military for 10 years, and thankfully he is still with us but to think what could've happened... this song makes me think about that. I finally started getting to a point where the original didn't make me tear up, but hearing this got me crying again
AND THE GUY YELLING FALL IN AND FALL OUT IN THE BACK AND THINKING ABOUT HOW THEY SOUND LIKE THEY'RE SINGING FROM A FELLOW SOLDIERS PERSPECTIVE ISNT HELPING
My brother had never joined the army, but my mom was in the army when she had heard that he had nearly died. She came all the way from her military base to visit him in the hospital and make the decision no parent ever should; whether to take him off life support or not. The entire time she was being criticized and blamed by my father. My brother’s death was kept somewhat private, so you’ll never find any obituaries of him. He never did make it to his 20s, and as his older sister, every year of my life is a milestone he’ll never reach. Rest in peace, Páddy.
I'm about to serve in the military. This song is so impactful for me because no matter how great America is, the military is still failing in supporting veterans. And its important to recognize the effects of war and how much is affects everyone. We can easily coin service as glorious and filled with bravery, but there is so much pain on both sides of the war. I recognize the many issues that lie in the military, but I am prompted even more to serve to advocate for veterans and actively work to resolve the many problems within it.
Praying for you! You are so right my brother served four year and two of his brother have passed, but from war or anything like that but both have “self exited” this country is so backwards! Our veterans deserve the world as well as our active soldiers. Thank you for your service and you will be in my prayers 🤍
Cette version choeur est splendide: elle est aussi belle , aussi riche que l'originale, je suis hébahie, bouche bée . Elle apporte aussi d'autres couleurs, c'est juste à tomber par terre tellement c'est beau, fidèle à l'original tout en le réinventant magnifiquement sans le trahir. Et le fait que cela soit chanté par un choeur d'hommes ajoute à mon émotion profonde. J'ai été stupéfaite par Kate Bush quand j'étais adolescente, dans les années 80, je suis tellement contente qu'aujourd'hui on se rende compte de son talent, de sa liberté créative, de son travail de musicienne accomplie sur tous les plans. En tant que musicienne, compositrice aventureuse, chanteuse à la voix inoubliable montant les octaves comme des sauts de cabris, l'air de rien. Osant tout. Avec exactement ce qu'il faut pour ne pas se trahir: faire ce qu'on veut et désire profondément. En totale sincérité avec soi-même, ce qui veut dire aussi refuser tout ce qu'on ne veut pas et se foutre de la notoriété. Merci Kate.
it sounds like the ghosts of fallen soldiers, mourning the fate of themselves and their brothers in arms...it's beautiful in a deeply sad way. amazing cover of an amazing song
Why did I not see this even sooner? why is it just 89k views??? it should be more! I can't stop crying especially when the Drill Sergeant starts everything with "FALL IN!" and not to mention THEY HAVE POPPIES?? I couldn't possibly imagine the horrors that those young men experienced
Recently joined a church choir I can’t express how gorgeous the voices sound together it’s the most lifting feeling being part of this… Wow this performance is just giving me the shivers more than beautiful 😍
The cries of ghosts come from it, voices distorted beyond recognition harnessed to create songs, it is a very unique instrument and a favourite, fortunately my culture is very fond of them and I can enjoy them on a near daily. If you enjoy them as much I reccomend you listen to "Boere musiek", farmer's music from South Africa!
I listen to this more than the original, the background commands and yelling adds so much and it gives me chills to hear such harmony. Gonna convince my choir director to get us to sing this some time
This is one of those songs (and especially this version) that I turn my headphones up loud, lay on the floor and just exist in the same space as the song and it gives me chills every time
i was in choir during the pandemic, i remember having to sing through a mask very well. its not as difficult as you might think, but it is NOT easy! you have to fight to get air in AND get sound OUT. phenomenal sound
The drill sergeant is a really nice addition. This is definitely one that I come back to a lot.
It’s not an addition, the drill sergeant vocals are on the Kate Bush recording.
@@philipe1966I think they mean in addition to this version with the choir. And given how it can be more heard (imo), it gives a bigger impact to the already angelic sounding vocals
@@chaoticgaybirb2734I agree this is almost as magical as the OG ❤
The guys yelling in the back. I love it
Do you know which person was it? I cant find him, i'm really curious
@@Poimist I'm not entirely sure
@@KarlSchroeder-ei4rf i think he's in the most back row in the middle
It's was the man who is in front, who lead the hold team
@@deeploxgaming1332 Sounds more like a singer placed offstage somewhere.
Whenever I heard “Fall in!” My heart sank ever time… 😭🙏
I think that it's because was a call from the other side, not a memory.
the song is clearly a mother mourning the loss of her son, both a letter to and about her little boy, however that "Fall in!" is the call from the other side in what would have been the most calming thing that the boy would have known. A sense of "this is the place that I must be at." with this I think it's the last time that the boy sees his mother, through his spirit, before he moves on.
but that's just what I get out of it
Now that I realize what it means, me too ;-;
Time stamp?
The ''FALL IN!'' gives me the creeps every time i hear it
does it mean anything connected to the song or was it just the sound that creeped you out?
@@carminerose2116fall in is a military command for cadets to fall in place like a assembly line, in order to either train, drill, or prepare to go into war such of what happened to the son
@@carminerose2116yes, the fall in part is also in the song, but it's kinda rare for cover to add it, so it's a great addition and makes the atmosphere of this cover even more thematic
@@skytam9002"Fall into formation" & "Fall out of formation"
during the second chorus, instead of yelling fall in, he's yelling fall out! such a good detail. beautifully arranged, performed, and composed.
Amazing detail
And am I mishearing it or is he saying, "Fall... back!" at 3:08?
sim ❤
i also hear fall back which is even more haunting
This point of view sounds like instead of the mother grieving, it's the fellow soldiers
This is so good! While Kate Bush sings from the perspective of the mother, this feels like it's being sung by the pallbearers as they carry the coffin, I love it!
Sim, torna tudo mais emocionante
YES
Yes!!
yessss omg
Yes, and I think this is confirmed by the line "four a men in uniform, to carry home my little solder"
My baby brother left for the army just the other day. Whenever I hear this song, I cannot help but think about him. I never want there to come a day when I hear this song and cry. Please let there never be such a day.
Prayers are sent out to him, your family, and his comrades 🙏
I hope he always return home safe. My blessings and prayers for him
Even as a grown man i cry hearing this song. I don't know, there will come a day when all of us can relate to this song. I hope that day doesn't came when we are alive.
Praying for you🤍 I’ll never forget the day my brother joined I was so proud. But terrified.
Yes, this song is about a fallen soldier.
Yet I cannot reject the self grieve over myself. I didn't come back the same guy I was.
As if I died too in the army.
I don’t know where you’re from, I don’t know what your role was, but thank you for your service.
It is right to grieve such a loss. Peace to you.
Крепись, иностранный брат, сожалею
You are more than a soldier, be at ease.
You got this. Its okay to grieve but maybe find a way to embrace and maybe share with others..
the chills im getting are crazy, especially with the "fall in!"
@@samararg4507 2:22 for example
I didn't even know it was a command, i thought it was the sounds of soldiers dying. Maybe it's meant to sound like both? Anyways, I agree, it gave me chills too.
What does fall out and fall in means??
@@Diaryofakhawabi Basically, "fall in" is a command for soldiers to get into formation. "Fall out" is a dismissal from formation
this version sounds like a father mourning his son, maybe even some guilt?
Perhaps a father who made his son join the army like him, but ultimately regrets it
Amazing work!
It’s by Kate bush and she wrote it in a perspective of a mother whose son died as a young soldier (he was in his teenage years)
@@Jazam.jarrrr I know that, genius.
That’s why I said “ this version “
@@Okanorawhy are you so angry 😭
@@katievx I literally just responded lmao?
@@Okanora “i know that, genius.” that’s an awful lot of aggression lmao
The first „fall in“ triggered such an intense reaction in me. Instant tears and goosebumps
Oh this is beautiful! I was hoping to find a cover where the 'bfpo/mammy's hero' in the background was a bit more audible and this pulled it off so well
what does bfpo mean?
British Forces Post Office - coming home in a box
CHILLS !!! Ah the screams in background made me shiver, I almost cry, what an awesome cover.
in love how a lot of people (including me) like to imagine these are the voices of the spirits from the fallen soldiers
is sad yet magical
I imagine these voices are voices of soldiers from different epochs: WWI, WWII, Vietnam, Folklands etc.
@@ДарьяГорякина-о7в i do indeed! :D
they're wearing masks and still sound so loud! it's impressive.
They sound muffled
I tried so hard not to cry. I failed
same..
Me as well 😢
tomorrow is memorial day, and this reminds me of the fallen soldiers who never got to see their mother, only in a wooden coffin
this feels like its sung by the spirits of the soldiers or the people carrying the coffin instead of the mother. absolutely beautiful
These guys sound muffled
The sergeant screaming fall in is so haunting, this reminds me of When the Tigers Broke Free or Bring the Boys Back Home by pink flyod
OMG REAL
I'm in tears at how amazing this is.
We're so glad you enjoyed it!
this needs 22M views, not 22K
I’m doing my best :) keep coming back
definiteoy. this is absolutely lovely
The video was posted 2 yrs ago, but thanks to the algorithm gods they’ve already gained 30k views in the weeks since you posted
It has 263k now
@@mime514this song became famous on tiktok so that may be why
I can't help but think that this song can also be synonymous to some of us who didn't get to achieve our own dreams due to difficulties in our own lives 💔
That’s why this song drew me in. I’m saddened for all the lives taken so young fighting but also saddened because of the dreams I feel like I haven’t achieved or can’t achieve.
And still sounding so good while wearing masks is insane
listening to this i cant help but think of all of the young people in gaza that will be martyred trying to protect their families.
Its happening in israel too both sides are suffering xx
@@Z0PHlA me when i lie ❤️
@@hotdoginthewind bro its true though altho its not bad as gaza israel is suffering too
@@Z0PHlA suffering from what exactly?
@@minnie-fu3bh constant rockets and missiles being sent from Lebanon, Palestine, iran, just accept the fact that both sides are suffering dawg
I am in tears, this is so beautiful
whenever I hear this song I begin to tear up. my father was in the military for 10 years, and thankfully he is still with us but to think what could've happened... this song makes me think about that. I finally started getting to a point where the original didn't make me tear up, but hearing this got me crying again
AND THE GUY YELLING FALL IN AND FALL OUT IN THE BACK AND THINKING ABOUT HOW THEY SOUND LIKE THEY'RE SINGING FROM A FELLOW SOLDIERS PERSPECTIVE ISNT HELPING
I love Kate Bush and I have always enjoyed this song, this rendition did it justice and some, brought tear to my eye.
I'm not crying, no, my eyes are just dehydrated 💦👁️💦💦👁️💦
My brother had never joined the army, but my mom was in the army when she had heard that he had nearly died. She came all the way from her military base to visit him in the hospital and make the decision no parent ever should; whether to take him off life support or not. The entire time she was being criticized and blamed by my father. My brother’s death was kept somewhat private, so you’ll never find any obituaries of him. He never did make it to his 20s, and as his older sister, every year of my life is a milestone he’ll never reach. Rest in peace, Páddy.
i dont know what it is but men singing this makes it so much more impactful. young singing with old...how enchanting
I'm about to serve in the military. This song is so impactful for me because no matter how great America is, the military is still failing in supporting veterans. And its important to recognize the effects of war and how much is affects everyone. We can easily coin service as glorious and filled with bravery, but there is so much pain on both sides of the war. I recognize the many issues that lie in the military, but I am prompted even more to serve to advocate for veterans and actively work to resolve the many problems within it.
good luck comrade
Good luck and wishes, hope that all goes well.
An early salute to you 🫡
Praying for you! You are so right my brother served four year and two of his brother have passed, but from war or anything like that but both have “self exited” this country is so backwards! Our veterans deserve the world as well as our active soldiers. Thank you for your service and you will be in my prayers 🤍
crying, i love army dreamers so much. So upset that this is so underrated.
Cette version choeur est splendide: elle est aussi belle , aussi riche que l'originale, je suis hébahie, bouche bée . Elle apporte aussi d'autres couleurs, c'est juste à tomber par terre tellement c'est beau, fidèle à l'original tout en le réinventant magnifiquement sans le trahir.
Et le fait que cela soit chanté par un choeur d'hommes ajoute à mon émotion profonde. J'ai été stupéfaite par Kate Bush quand j'étais adolescente, dans les années 80, je suis tellement contente qu'aujourd'hui on se rende compte de son talent, de sa liberté créative, de son travail de musicienne accomplie sur tous les plans. En tant que musicienne, compositrice aventureuse, chanteuse à la voix inoubliable montant les octaves comme des sauts de cabris, l'air de rien. Osant tout. Avec exactement ce qu'il faut pour ne pas se trahir: faire ce qu'on veut et désire profondément. En totale sincérité avec soi-même, ce qui veut dire aussi refuser tout ce qu'on ne veut pas et se foutre de la notoriété. Merci Kate.
I'm gonna cry, I love it so much
Stunningly beautiful, and crushingly heartbreaking.
Tear inducing, and so pertinent.
THIS NEED MORE ATTENTION, LIKE COME ON RUclips MASTERPIECE RIGHT HERE! DON'T U SEE IT?... GOOD JOB GUYS, YOU GUYS MAKE ME CRY SO HARD THANK YOU!
love the orignal powefull message but wow i love this version as much
it sounds like the ghosts of fallen soldiers, mourning the fate of themselves and their brothers in arms...it's beautiful in a deeply sad way. amazing cover of an amazing song
I’m genuinely so glad this was recommended to me oh my goodness
Why did I not see this even sooner? why is it just 89k views??? it should be more! I can't stop crying especially when the Drill Sergeant starts everything with "FALL IN!" and not to mention THEY HAVE POPPIES??
I couldn't possibly imagine the horrors that those young men experienced
I love hearing other versions of this song, and this has to be one of my favorites. The details
get that flag out of your profile
This is my fav performance of this piece. I’m crying
I don’t think I’ve ever truly experienced goosebumps from a song holy crap
excellent job!! i have goosebumps :-)
Oh, is it inside a cathedral ?? so perfect!!
I've never cried from the beauty of a song before. This arrangement is perfect
my husband and I both cried by the end. he's a veteran and even in "peacetime" it takes a toll
A breathtaking interpretation
I have an out of body experience when I listen to this
My eyes are full..so beautiful. Well done all.
My eyes are full, so beautiful, you just know Kate would love this. Thank you!
I’m a nerd so I always picture clone troopers when I listen
its horrible how many children die serving in war. called adults but still a child.
Overwhelming sadness; the implications behind this song. There are truly no winners in war.
I hope Kate has seen this. Beautiful.
Kate will love it.
Thank you!
if this doesn’t play at my funeral, i don’t wanna go
I love this so much, its like.. its speaking to me, ive been listening to "army dreamers but better" and hearing just the choir is lovely
A singular tear ran down my face
All the words of this song, seen and thought about, it just hits hard
This made me cry.
I'm going to make this 1m views by putting this on repeat, this is BEAUTIFUL; I'm not crying, you are
Recently joined a church choir I can’t express how gorgeous the voices sound together it’s the most lifting feeling being part of this…
Wow this performance is just giving me the shivers more than beautiful 😍
I'm getting chills and tear up... The screaming sounds sad and terrified
This reminds me of the horrible situation in Gaza right now. They are in my prayers 🍉❤️
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸
Insanely beautiful arrangement, the accordion adds something almost ghostly or otherworldly.
The cries of ghosts come from it, voices distorted beyond recognition harnessed to create songs, it is a very unique instrument and a favourite, fortunately my culture is very fond of them and I can enjoy them on a near daily. If you enjoy them as much I reccomend you listen to "Boere musiek", farmer's music from South Africa!
Terrifyingly amazing
Beautiful and powerful performance and a powerful message.
listening to this a few times, ngl, makes me wish you could do a full cover of the album this song comes from
Beautifully sung. Have a dad who is ex army.
Fall in just feels so surreal
AND TO THE GUY BEHIND AND SCREAMING "FALL IN AND FALL OUT" I LOVE U SO MUCH
I listen to this more than the original, the background commands and yelling adds so much and it gives me chills to hear such harmony. Gonna convince my choir director to get us to sing this some time
Astonishing 🤩
absolute chills it makes it 100x more tragic to hear
Прекрасно! Готова слушать вечно.. из голоса, гитара, рояль., акардеон.. прекрасно!!
This is one of those songs (and especially this version) that I turn my headphones up loud, lay on the floor and just exist in the same space as the song and it gives me chills every time
i need this on spotify rn
So no one cried at this beautiful magnificent performance I DIDDDDD
Это прекрасно и заставляет меня плакать! Спасибо!
Love this rendition
the amount of times i have watched this video is insane
Just Class!
i was in choir during the pandemic, i remember having to sing through a mask very well. its not as difficult as you might think, but it is NOT easy! you have to fight to get air in AND get sound OUT. phenomenal sound
I NEED THIS ON SPOTIFY UTS AMAZING AND SO HAUNTINGLY BEAUTIFUL
Wow excelent cover!! :O
I’ve listened to this song 4 days in a row so far… I can’t get enough….😓🤷♀️
This needs more views
This was gorgeous
The world is on fire this just puts a paused to it for me.
Arkadaki çığlık kadar beni etkileyen bir şey yok
so this is what heaven sounds like
Literal chills wow.
This deserves more recognition, it's just chilling. Great job!!!
Полностью согласен, они сделали хорошую работу
I adore this version so much. Hope it’s getting more views.
this feels more RPG fantasy like than most fantasy songs
this cover is so ethereal omg
this is beautiful, sends chills down my spine
Nossa magnífico, não tenho palavras pra descrever como ficou lindo!