this song has so many complexities going on both the lead and background vocals. it really isn't most fans' favorite, but having it vocally analyzed really makes one appreciate the song more. thank you so much for the effort in doing this!
Congrats on finishing the Vocal Analysis for another album! Can't wait for LD. So far, before this final song the order among vocal line is: Tae, Jess, Seo, Tif, Sun. I think that's gonna be the final top 5 order too. If TaengSic didn't sing one note in this song, they'd still be no 1 and 2.
@ywc9644 Right, off course. I heard male voice in the song. Make this song is so deep. It's snsd best song. Love Jessica's adlibs. Who is he? I thought it was Leeteuk or Ryeowook
It's grear that you do SNSD VA again🥰 but ummm.... 'Middle Harmony' doesn't exist. When there's three or more vocal pitches than the mid is what we call melody.
yeah but I noted it was middle harmony just to separate with the low/high harmony, such as in the chorus Jessica sang the melody and a harmony, it may make some people misunderstand about which harmony Jessica sang - the low harmony (bgs) or high harmony (Seohyun) :v
By far is the best song by Girls' Generation.
I love how they are singing this song fully from their hearts.
And I love Jessica's power in this.
this song has so many complexities going on both the lead and background vocals. it really isn't most fans' favorite, but having it vocally analyzed really makes one appreciate the song more. thank you so much for the effort in doing this!
Thank you ❤️ it’s so much harder since they put a lot of harmony in the song which is really not easy to be heard :v
It's one of my favs from them
That's called harmony, sir
Ahhh I was working on this too but it was so hard to filter out the low volume background vocals! Glad you did it ❤
thank youuu ❤️
Can someone do the HaHaHa song? Every LD I see says Yoona doesn't have a line, but I think I hear her once and I'm curious.
This song has some of my favorite GG ad-libs. Looking forward to the line distribution❤️
Congrats on finishing the Vocal Analysis for another album! Can't wait for LD.
So far, before this final song the order among vocal line is: Tae, Jess, Seo, Tif, Sun. I think that's gonna be the final top 5 order too. If TaengSic didn't sing one note in this song, they'd still be no 1 and 2.
SEOHYUN did a goodjob in this Song ❤❤❤
Yoona's lower harmony at the end slayed me.
love it
❤❤
Dang Sooyoung and Hyoyeon really doesn't sing at all in this song
Not much in any other songs I think. Everyone have a role.
The male background vocals probably their own edited to low pitched. Or is it? Maybe one of the boys from Suju.
this song(album)'s producer maybe sing the background vocal...because there were video of him singing the demos of 2 songs for them.
@ywc9644 Right, off course. I heard male voice in the song. Make this song is so deep. It's snsd best song. Love Jessica's adlibs.
Who is he? I thought it was Leeteuk or Ryeowook
It's grear that you do SNSD VA again🥰 but ummm.... 'Middle Harmony' doesn't exist. When there's three or more vocal pitches than the mid is what we call melody.
yeah but I noted it was middle harmony just to separate with the low/high harmony, such as in the chorus Jessica sang the melody and a harmony, it may make some people misunderstand about which harmony Jessica sang - the low harmony (bgs) or high harmony (Seohyun) :v
The middle note in a harmony is not always the melody though.
@@thedoradora I guess you could put it like that.