-I swear Percy's skin was not that green on my Cintiq lol oh well I guess his skin is literally olive now- *OH ALSO ALSO!!!!* I'm doing my very first RUclips livestream this Sunday at around 1pm PST! I'm probably going to be taking requests, doing a Q + A, and working on Unfamiliar, so I hope you guys can come!
You should do the Outsiders I think you would really like doing it. (Even though there are a lot of characters in the book the movie does not do them justice) Also the description of the characters is in the very first couple of pages,
@@carolle9113 I meant that they they made him like a faun in the movies even tho he is supposed to be brave and kind hearted The movies showed him to be like a faun
Movie Annabeth: *flirty and acting so much like she has a crush* Book Annabeth: you drool in your sleep, seaweed brain, *literally doesn’t even hint at it till 3rd book*
Except, that's how kids are *always* depicted when showing someone they have a crush on them... It was better than the weird, forced handshake between Ron and Hermione in Chamber of Secrets...
They took Percy's loserness and made him cool. They took Annabeth's kick-butt attitude and made her useless. They took Grover's pining away at the hunters of Artemis and made him a pervert.
Nico first came in the Titans curse and luckily they didn’t make another movie because they would make him a bad character just like the rest of the movie characters
Holy fucking shit Rick Riordan roasted the shit out of them "If i was trying to sabotage this project, i couldnt have done a better job than this script"
Harry Potter movies: So let's be accurate to the books, consult and respect the author, have JK heavily involved, only cut when necessary Percy Jackson Movies: *We don't do that here*
My problem was that they ruined the character arks of everyone. Making the prophecy an evil soul instead of a hero's soul means Luke won't be redeemed, making Kronos not take over Luke's body takes away all of Annabeth's conflict, and cutting it down by 2 movies means no one gets an ark
Miles Life hope they do a remake i think its very possible. I think most people didnt mind how the characters looked its the supporting characters lack of development
Also abt grover they changed hi character (i feel like) the most. Just look at the lotus scene .i mean isnt this suposed to be for yung adults or 9-12 in our country?
Here’s what I think happened: Producers: Hey we need someone to play this 12 yr old boy 18 to 21 yr old guy walks in: hey I’d like to play Percy Jackson? The ONE producer who cares about the book: bro you’re an adul- 18 to 21 yr old guy squats down and says in a high pitched voice: I’m 12 what do you mean Other producers: cool you’re hired
Grover was one of the most adorable, sweet shy and cute character in the whole book, when I watched the first 30 min of the movie I slammed my laptop shut and cursed them to die in tartarus.
Grover in the movie: hero, brave,ladies man,popular Grover in the book: cries in the corner while Ananabeth is fighting with an Ares kid for picking on him
I mean, I really liked seeing a black disables guy being really charming (when he has the crutches -sorry don't know if it's a real word), it felt like good representation... if he had had a more active role tho.
@@sarasthoughts I didn't mind him being black, I actually though it was an improvement, but he isn't technically disabled. The crutches are to hide his goat legs, but on the bright side most demigods are dyslexic and have ADHD. it's the personality I had a problem with
I honestly love how each book picked up after the other one and seeing percy started to grow up and be comfortable using his power. It ones my favorite part, AND THEY REMOVED IT!! WHY?
@@Coffnist_Charm plus, the whole point is that he’d reach the age of 16 against all odds. He’d start a whole war when he reached 16, so they just completely ruined that
It’s a common thing done with movies, sadly. Like with the Giver, they only aged Jonas up so he could have a love arc with Fiona, which never happened in the book.
"Could you do a glamour and turn into something smaller?" "Such as what?" "I dunno. Something pocket-size and innocuous. A pen, maybe?" "A pen sword. That is the stupidest thing I've ever heard" THE SHADE LMAOOOOOOO
“I have feelings for you. I’m just not sure if they’re positive or negative yet.” Just Why? Why do that?? She’s literally only there as a romantic interest and a decade later it *still* pisses me off.
When I first saw Annabeth in the movie I was like: Oh, there comes Clarisse Books: She has blonde hair Movie: I'm sure that's no too important Books: Her eyes are grey Movie: The contacts are really expensive, we'll live without it Books: She has a deep tan Movie: Well, we haven't commited to any of the other stuff, so why commit to this? Books: She is muscular Movie: Nah, let's just make her have a classic movie star body. Also: Annabeth literally lost a fight to Percy, who has no training WHATSOVER after doing nothing but training for five years (well actually in the movies it has to be more, since the actress is like 20), and then she's all like: Oh, you're gonna need me on this quest, i have more experience and am a better fighter than you. Me: Yeah roight
I don't think that Hailey did this on purpose but- I appreciate the fact that on the neck up shot Annabeth's eyes look a lot like owl eyes. It's fitting because owls are a popular symbol for Athena, her mother
One Blue Duck! Same- Seaweed brain is an absolute necessity. Just do that at. Least. Once. It doesn’t have to be a big thing. Just have Annabeth walk up to Percy and say “Hey, Seaweed Brain.” That’s all I need. That’s it. But no.
I remember being the most angry about how the changed clarisse when I was younger, just because of how obviously “beautified” she was. She’s this wide shouldered, muscular, more “masculine” teenage girl. She’s scary and aggressive and a bully, not a super skinny, sexy, mean girl.
annabeth is like opposite hermione, instead of taking away all her imperfections and making her the perfect character they took away all her positive traits
i despise how they turned Annaberg, a good rep of a strong female role into a “uwu i’m just a love interest that’s super pretty and doesn’t do anything”
Books: - Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief - Percy Jackson and The Sea of Monsters - Percy Jackson and the Titan’s Curse - Percy Jackson and the Battle of the Labyrinth - Percy Jackson and the Last Olympian Movies: - Peter Johnson and the Sparky Stick - Peter Johnson and the Scary Puddle - Peter Johnson and the Huge Boi Spell - Peter Johnson and the Zigzag Fight - Peter Johnson and the Other Big Boi
Harry Potter at least had the excuse of their being so many characters in the books that get development, but in Percy Jackson and the olympians there's like 5-6 main characters you have to develop. Percy, Annabeth, Grover (not as much as the first two), Tyson, Nico, and Luke.
Book: Annabeth and Percy are both 12 years old. Annabeth has honey blonde hair and beautiful princess curls. She has gray eyes. Movie: Haha, we don't do that here.
Lavender: “There is a lack of black characters in fantasy stories...” Me, who is reading The Mark of Athena now: HAZEL! HAZEL! WE ARE BREAKING THE RULES WITH HAZEL!
The book: Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief. The movie: Peter Jhonson and the Sparkly Stick. The book: Percy Jackson and the Sea of Monsters. The movie: Peter Jhonson and the Bermuda Triangle
rick riordan : let’s write annabeth as an intelligent, useful, strong main character while still having subtle hints for her role as a love interest. screenplay writers : uh? pretty girl who percy likes. yes. perfect.
People think Romeo and Juliet are star crossed lovers? Move over, Percy’s dad and Annabeth’s mom hate each other so much that their kids usually don’t get along that well.
Movie Percy when he gets Riptide: A pen? But it's a sword? How does that happen? That isn't physically possible. A pen? A sword? Book Percy when he gets Riptide: lol gimme it
@@LunaIsMentallyDead I find a lot of both memes and other general fan depictions of Percy are a bit on the dumb jokester side then a smart but oblivious kid
Fans: **walk into production studio** guys you do know Annabeth's supposed to be blonde right? They describe her that way in the book. Producers: Wait... there was a book?
Honestly yeah. They should create enjoyable content with morals and themes that relate and correspond to the book, not movies that is just one out of millions of others left on the shelf for the rest of eternity (especially when that book is actually really freaking good. The crazy intense stuff starts more book 4, book 5 for anyone who is wondering. For the others, sit back and watch our character suffer and grow up into a lifestyle of betrayal, death, and insanity)
Yeah Uncle Rick should have! And btw I'm so glad that they didn't make HOO a movie or KC and MC because damn I dont know what I would do if they try to
@@clnne I low-key want PJO to be an animated TV show tbh. That way they don't have to worry about CGI and making things realistic and also producers aren't limited by the choice of actors in Hollywood.
I wanted to die after what they did to Annabeth. The reason her character looked like a stereotypical valley girl was to highlight how enemies could easily underestimate her much like Athena. Athena, her Mom, was underestimated in the Greek times because of her femininity and yet she is one of the most bad ass Greek goddesses of all time. In the movie, they were trying to make Annabeth "bad ass" by making her look less stereo typically girly, while at the same time, making her really boring.
I've never read Percy jackson, I've only seen the movies, but I'm really into mythology and after I finished the first movie I was like "WHAT THE HELL HOW IS THAT GIRL THE DAUGHTER OF ATHENA WTF ATHENA IS THE MOST BADASS INTELLIGENT WISE DEITY IN THE OLYMPUS WHAT IS WRONG WITH THAT GIRL THEY *MUST* HAVE MADE A MISTAKE SHE CAN'T BE ATHENA'S DAUGHTER" and now I guess I was on point😂
My opinion: JUST BECAUSE YOU GIVE A GIRL A SWORD THAT DOESN’T MAKE HER INTERESTING! That’s how most movies portray “powerful” female protagonists and it pisses me off. I’m a girl and I find that more offensive then not having female protagonists because then people are like, “Stop complaining, female protagonists are normal now.” And I’m like “NO! THERE NOT! IM NOT JUST GONNA SIT HERE AND ACCEPT THE BARE MINUM!” (Oof, sorry for this dumb rant.)
So they turned a book for nerdy kids that featured interesting and complex characters into some primitive fratboy teenage flick. How many more movie adaptations will Hollywood ruin before it has enough money to choke on, srsly.
I’m very glad that Disney is supposed to be making a adaptation series with the cannon ages and that supposed to follow the cast as they grow up. Hopefully we’ll get to see it and possibly see characters we didn’t get to in the movies(specifically Nico and Leo).
@@sofiavarena1524 I'll cry if I see the movie version of Leo, because he's so cute and imagining him as a 30- year- old man is just haunting. PLUS Nico will probably end up looking like the actor they cast for Percy tbh
Phoebe Sachs IKR the hunger games movies were actually really good but some aspects didn’t fulfill me same with harry potter but percy jackson is ANOTHER THINF
I absolutely HATE how useless they made Annabeth, actually, most of the girls seem absolutely useless in every situation, yet Percy, a boy, who didn't know anything about his powers, BEATS Annabeth, someone who has been coming to the camp for YEARS. Idk about anyone else but that seems kinda sexist on the movie's behalf. edit: guys this comment is 2 years old and just restates something said in the video you've got to stop liking it-
I wonder if they watched the Harry Potter movies. Hermione was acted so well by Emma Watson. She even plays a good role in the movies. Annabeth on the other hand..... i'm not so sure.
Annabeth is probably the most resourceful and level-headded character in the book, but they completely chopped off all of her interesting traits and made her "strong generic female love interest girl" in the "movie" (Using the term movie very lightly)
She was also strong too and that coincides with being resourceful and level-headed? Why is general strength of character an issue to you for a female character? Especially when it's already accurate?
Multiple artist renditions in books and wikis: Grover is a wimpy, cinnamon roll, scrawny white kid Hollywood: did you mean a strapping, charismatic black dude?
Every other fandom: They only used 3/4 of the book none of the good details about the book were used. UGH Percy Jackson Fandom: *sobbing in the corner looking like Nico after Bianca died"
same thing!! i knew the movie first and then found out it was 'based' on a book series so i read them and my life has never been better than knowing the original plot of the book; i've had issues about the movie's plot since first watch it's just so weird and doesn't make any sense
As he's progressed, he's actually started dropping that as a fact xD He's been through way too much, he *deserves* this or that, but the gods need him again... "*sigh* I've got you, but you owe me big time."
• Wanna See My Shot Glass Collection • That was one of my favorite moments in the books. And the way he described how he was slowly losing control about the glass breaking in his mind was amazing. I’m sad that we don’t get to see a dark Percy anymore
the inaccuracies with annabeth in the movie pisses me off because it was so glaringly easy to make her blonde, i feel like they just didnt want to make a smart blonde character, it didnt even matter in the end because they made her absolutely useless in the movie, it just feels like they didn't want to make any of them interesting or complex like they were in the books, so the directors just fell on old tropes of, "useless woman," "cool badass protagonist," and "comic relief minority side character" for the main three
You know what really annoys me about the movies? Annabeth's reaction to learning about Luke's betrayal. In the books Annabeth and Luke have been friends for ages, Annabeth looks up to him and has a crush on him... and yet, in the movie she just calmy comes to the conclusion that he betrayed them and has absolutely no reaction to finding this out. It really annoys me
and in later books she continues to like admire him and even deny it in some cases. She still like holds onto the fact that Luke was one of her favorite people even when he kidnapped her and tried to kill her. She still denied that he was fully bad and it like actually hurts her that he turned out the way he did.
The only scene worth watching in the movies is this scene: Percy: **is on the roof of the Andromeda** Luke: .................What are you doing? Don't walk on my roof. Percy: (confused demigod noises)
what they did is unforgivable, even more so in the second CATASTROPHY of a movie for Sea of Monsters; the movies will be dissed until the end of time itself
YESSSS, I'm black and I hate what they did to Grover. Like they made him loud and obnoxious, like he only cared about girls and stuff which is SO WRONG book Grover is the exact opposite of movie Grover
@@illstealyourkneecaps694 I know! Like the movie people could’ve just changed his skin tone and kept his personality or changed his personality and kept his skin tone they didn’t have to make the movie even more stereotypical than it already is
@@princelyhairdos EXCACTLY, I'm fine with him being black but they took away what made Grover well, GROVER. He's not supposed to be all confident and stuff he's supposed to be shy and unassuming, that's why its so cool when he does something super brave
As a twelve-year-old, I did not pay that much attention to clothes. So I don't think Percy would, either, unless it is very distinctive (like the Camp Half-Blood shirt). I definitely appreciate how difficult it made it for you, though. A single, young POV makes things difficult to adequately describe unless it is super important or distinctive.
I just remember in one of the promotional interviews with the actors, they were asked about the blue food and all the actors looked really confused. That was the moment I knew this was not gonna be a faithful adaptation.
i find it interesting how they had no problem casting a black actor when they needed pop culture references, one liners, and comedic relief but, when they need the female love interest, the description of “tan skin” is nonexistent.
Books: Percy Jackson Annabeth Chase Grover Underwood Chiron Clarrise LaRue Movies: Peter Johnson Anniebell Run Grunter Overlog HorseDude Clarskinnies LalalalaPoo
I used to draw him a lot and never get him right, he's not that well described in the earlier books and I wasn't so good at art when I was 12... 😂 I can relate.
Leo described her as "scary blonde girl." Then Magnus described her as "if she was looking for me, I didn't want to be found. She was scary." Lol everyone thinks she's scary.
Just saying, but percy describes her when she's 12 and even then he saw she was intense. Leo sees her when she's 16 which is after she's been on a few quests, fought in a war, had to go through the whole luke thing, and had her boyfriend kidnapped. She grew into her scary appearance.
If Percy was like 16 in the books, I wouldn’t mind the casting, but they casted grown adults to play 12 year olds which is by far the dumbest casting choice I’ve ever seen.
In the movie, Annabeth seemed like a really snotty annoying person to me. In the books, she was someone I looked up to. And, I was also upset about what they did to her in the movies.
You know, I'm SO happy to see this comment, because my brother was (as still is) really into Percy Jackson books but I knew little about them, so when I watched this movie with my brother, I thought these were the actual characters, and I still haven't read Percy Jackson, but I am planning on it very soon because I am reading the Magnus Chase series at the moment, but I can just say I hated how they were portrayed in the movie and kind of made me not want to read the rest of the books, but now that I got descriptions of the actual characters, I am more than excited to read them!
And even Leo has charm at least, Grover in the movie was kinda....gross. Especially that Persephone scene, like she wasn’t even supposed to be in the movie at all??.? They just added that for laughs I guess? It wasn’t funny, just pedoish
I feel like a lot of people tend to forget that Grover was described as having his horns hide under his hair. So thank you for not making his horns visible.
LavenderTowne before reading Percy Jackson: I've never actually read the books so I have to learn more about it LavenderTowne after reading Percy Jackson: **kicks down door** whAT did thEY DO tO GROVER
Rick: *Makes Anabeth a Independent strong young-woman* Movies: *Makes her the damsel in distress and the helpless love interest* Me: WHAT DID YOU DO TO ANABETH!!!! HAVE YOU EVEN READ THE BOOKS!!! THEY EXIST! Movie: Percy Jackson books who??
One of the things that pisses me off the most about the movie adaptation of The Lighting Theif is the fact that they completely removed the section where Percy and the others find out his parentage and instead make it so that the information is already known to Chiron.
I literally didn't even recognize the story when I watched the movie. or rather the other way around. Once I read the books I didn't realize I had actually seen the movie version before. They are so dissimilar it is not even funny.
Oh! I don’t forget the part with Hades! I love that part in the book on how Percy will get his helmet back and calls him uncle and it’s just AHHH! But NOOO! Not having that in the movie! Because Hades is a bad guy and his wife is the only good one! Also, Hades always keeps his promises in the book but in the movie they’re like NAHHH HES A DEVIOUS LITTLE B-TCH that will betray you. Completely OPPOSITE! And he also doesn’t want a war in the first place in the books, he doesn’t want more dead people in his kingdom. He only wants his helmet back, and that, ladies and gentlemen, is another reason to hate the movies!
Dull_Demon47 Dull_Demon47 I remember there was this video where the actors of the sea of monsters were looking at comments by fans and one of the fans mentioned about blue food and the actors were like “how is that even related to the movie” so yeah I’m pretty sure they had never read the books
@@emily-uo1et Theres a whole video of Rick being interviewed about this. They came to him, said they wanted to make a movie. He asked if he could have any say in how the movie would be done. They laughed at him and said no. But Rick still went for it because he thought it was the best way to get his book noticed, and it worked.
Ya and I was fuming mad about that and I don't get mad about movie characters done badly that often,I don't even notice half the times but annabeth and grover were done so badly
Oh gods she was horrible in the movie Like in the book I loved her she was so fierce but kind and just awesome And wen I first saw the movie I thought the supposed annabeth was clarisse in the first scene And wen we got to meet her I was like oh my gods what did they do to annabeth
@hades child I disagree, it's only confusing when the characters change ccompletely like the sorts of Percy Jackson. Recently they casted a black woman to play Hamlet and idk if you had the opportunity to see it, it's truly TRULY remarkable how her character is portrayed, I'll go as far as saying it is the best possible casting. Sometimes the source material needs some updating and I'll welcome all diversity, as long as the core of the story remains the same.
@hades child YOU can't do that because YOU are a real person, characters in another hand get updated all the time. For instance, A Star Is Born just got its third or fourth adaptation to cinema, but we all can understand that, while it is an updated rendition, the core of the story remained the same. Broadway has revivals all the time and as long as they take time to establish the characters, how is that possibly going to get confusing? The new Enjolras from Les Mis is black, but everything about him screams young revolutionary so no one is confused at all! The problem with Percy Jackson in particular is that while they did insert some diversity with the casting of Grover, his entire personality was butchered!
@hades child you sound very young so I'll just say this: art, literature, cinema... All of those things are in constant mutation. The way we, in our time, view characters like Darth Vader or Gandalf will change inevitably because of our time, but while our interpretations may change, the core of those characters as they were written should stay the same, don't you agree? The color of their skin doesn't have to change anything about the characters essence! A good script writer will be able to translate the original work to screen and tthere's that. The problem with Percy Jackson, once again, is that the characters weren't adapted properly. Grover can be black, Percy could be Asian and Annabeth could be middle eastern, as long as their personalities align with the ones from the book, why should it be confusing? It's only confusing in Percy Jackson because Grover was supposed to be a sweet flower child whereas the films kind of made him look like a jerk-y womanizer.
@hades child Sorry if I made you angry, but you said you didn't know Les Mis, which to me indicates that you haven't had the opportunity to read it in high school yet. I think you missed my point entirely. I'm simply saying a race change in a character doesn't change its essence at all. We are simply having a conversation, let's be mature about it.
Book Annabeth: Described as having tanned skin, stormy grey eyes and in a book scene where she is sitting with her siblings it's said "They all had athletic build and honey blond hair" Movie: Brown hair and green eyes, looks 20 years old
We all know why they destroyed Annabeth. They needed an eye candy damsel in distress to be Percy's love interest because Hollywood seems to think that girls can't be tough AND the love interest at the same time.
Nah, they were just shit adaptations. Hollywood has had great female leads for decades: Ellen Ripley, Sarah Connor, The Bride from Kill Bill, every Slasher Final Girl (Special props to Megan from Friday The 13th Part 6 and Nancy from Nightmare on Elm Street) and so on
![HOW HOWL WAS SUPPOSED TO LOOK... [book versus movie: Howl's Moving Castle]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/itQYOXDaLfc/mqdefault.jpg)
-I swear Percy's skin was not that green on my Cintiq lol oh well I guess his skin is literally olive now-
*OH ALSO ALSO!!!!* I'm doing my very first RUclips livestream this Sunday at around 1pm PST! I'm probably going to be taking requests, doing a Q + A, and working on Unfamiliar, so I hope you guys can come!
The description of Percy sounds like the description of Harry......black hair and green eyes
Green eyes not green skin girl
Lol it’s k I didn’t even notice till u mentioned
You should do the Outsiders I think you would really like doing it.
(Even though there are a lot of characters in the book the movie does not do them justice)
Also the description of the characters is in the very first couple of pages,
Percy is a zombie!!!!! Confirmed!!!! Not clickbait!!!
Books: **clearly describes Annabeth’s and Grover’s personality and appearance**
Movie: *lmao what*
Eh they don’t really describe Grovers appearance they just say he had dark brown curly hair
Science for life And stuff you’re probably right but I think this is more focused on annabeth, her appearance was a drastic change
Lemon ._. True true, they changed Annabeths appearance A LOT
@@scienceforlifeandstuff4590 i might be wrong but i think they also said he was pale
Did they even read the books?
First rule of the Percy Jackson fandom: Do not speak of the movies, they attract monsters.
correction, they ARE monsters.
This is accurate and now I’m tempted to go to a friend of mine, she’s Percy Jackson OBSESSED, and mention the movie. 🤣
@Bea's Bees Heck yeah.
What about the musical?
@@Actually_Autistic_ Yes. We are 100% allowed to talk about that one.
Book: *gives a detailed description of Annabeth, clearly stating her appearance*
Movie: Sorry what did you say?
Book: *d-did i stutter?*
"I SAID I'M A GUY WHO LOVES ADVENTURE!"
Don't forget the electronics rule
its like the uh, tiktok thingy? about the "what time is it?" "what?!" thingy if you know what im talkig about and aiming for....
Didn't help that they combined two characters into one. Lol
They ruined Grover, one of the nicest characters who's motivation through out the books is to get his searchers license so he can go clean the planet.
And n movies he was like
I am coming babay....
And he is not a satyr he is a freakin' faun.
@@asphaltman1819 no hes a satyr
@@carolle9113 I meant that they they made him like a faun in the movies even tho he is supposed to be brave and kind hearted
The movies showed him to be like a faun
@@asphaltman1819 oh yeah definitely
I havent read more than the second book-
And my parents won't be keen on doing so any time soon, so tell me, does percabeth become canon?
Movie Annabeth: *flirty and acting so much like she has a crush*
Book Annabeth: you drool in your sleep, seaweed brain, *literally doesn’t even hint at it till 3rd book*
Except, that's how kids are *always* depicted when showing someone they have a crush on them... It was better than the weird, forced handshake between Ron and Hermione in Chamber of Secrets...
Ken Livingston I’m gonna be honest I have no idea what part you are pointing out but ok
@@moonkitten0557 the ending of the movie
Ken Livingston ......uhh okay
@@moonkitten0557 so you didn't watch Chamber of Secrets. That's cool.
Annabeth in the movie : I have strong feelings for you~
Annabeth in the book : You drool when you sleep.
Amaeliss I prefer the book version lol
@@blackpinkluv9869 Same here lmao
@@amaeliss7827 never saw either but this seems wholesome
@@onettaviator5396 seriously you should read the books ! It's great ! :3
Shit, she refused to even admit her feelings until Percy did so lmao
They took Percy's loserness and made him cool.
They took Annabeth's kick-butt attitude and made her useless.
They took Grover's pining away at the hunters of Artemis and made him a pervert.
I KNOW that bugged me sooooo much
And they took Nico away completely
@@lucikka3674 NOT OUR DARK SPOOKY SON! I've only watched the first movie and couldn't force myself to watch any more.
Nico first came in the Titans curse and luckily they didn’t make another movie because they would make him a bad character just like the rest of the movie characters
@Rose Kennedy Heathers reference and Percy Jackson fan? The power of Peggy Schuyler is strong with this one
Holy fucking shit Rick Riordan roasted the shit out of them "If i was trying to sabotage this project, i couldnt have done a better job than this script"
LMAOO
LMAO IKR like you can totally tell he wrote the character of percy 😭😭
MAN HAS NO CHILL
@@WildSheWolf_ he has no integrity either since he sold the rights to them regardless of the script.
@@livanbard he deserved to be mad tho
Harry Potter movies: So let's be accurate to the books, consult and respect the author, have JK heavily involved, only cut when necessary
Percy Jackson Movies: *We don't do that here*
Honestly, adaption wise the hp movies are only good in comparison
Whats disappointing is both Harry Potter and Percy Jackson had the same director
@@BlazeDupree1525 wait seriously?
@@pissypantskenzie Chris Columbus
Death Note Movie: WHAT ANIME??? THIS IS WHITE. AMERICAN MADE. WE AREN'T WEEBS.
They made annabeth DUMB. She had no character because they took her whole Architect thing away. THATS my problem.
My problem was that they ruined the character arks of everyone. Making the prophecy an evil soul instead of a hero's soul means Luke won't be redeemed, making Kronos not take over Luke's body takes away all of Annabeth's conflict, and cutting it down by 2 movies means no one gets an ark
Miles Life hope they do a remake i think its very possible. I think most people didnt mind how the characters looked its the supporting characters lack of development
book annabeth: *kills a whole monster*
movie annabeth: *trips* "PERCY HELP ME!"
Also abt grover they changed hi character (i feel like) the most. Just look at the lotus scene .i mean isnt this suposed to be for yung adults or 9-12 in our country?
@@slurp3194 yea they r actually disneyplus is making a series based on the book and i think and rly hope they do it right not like century fox did
Here’s what I think happened:
Producers: Hey we need someone to play this 12 yr old boy
18 to 21 yr old guy walks in: hey I’d like to play Percy Jackson?
The ONE producer who cares about the book: bro you’re an adul-
18 to 21 yr old guy squats down and says in a high pitched voice: I’m 12 what do you mean
Other producers: cool you’re hired
😂
🤣🤣🤣
I pictured the high pitched voice as Micky Mouse's voice
@@eugeneimnotgonnatellyoumyl5513 me too
I wheezed to oblivion 😭😂
Grover was one of the most adorable, sweet shy and cute character in the whole book, when I watched the first 30 min of the movie I slammed my laptop shut and cursed them to die in tartarus.
They better or I will shove them in myself
and i will summon hades to inflict emotional pain upom them, first.
@@cometlolly 💀💀💀💀💀💀 goofy ahh boi
So relatable 💀
Murder
Chiron: You can’t use cell phones; they’ll attract monsters
Also Chiron: Let’s make the shirts BRIGHT ORANGE
Monsters might be color blind. You don't know! :P
Tania Liao This Comment right here, I love it
Oof
Tania Liao That’s Mr. D
And the phones amplify “smell” of half bloods
Grover in the movie: hero, brave,ladies man,popular
Grover in the book: cries in the corner while Ananabeth is fighting with an Ares kid for picking on him
But at the same time, in the movie he seems to be so useless
What did they do my poor goat boi
Accurate!
I mean, I really liked seeing a black disables guy being really charming (when he has the crutches -sorry don't know if it's a real word), it felt like good representation... if he had had a more active role tho.
@@sarasthoughts I didn't mind him being black, I actually though it was an improvement, but he isn't technically disabled. The crutches are to hide his goat legs, but on the bright side most demigods are dyslexic and have ADHD. it's the personality I had a problem with
Book: Annabeth with blonde hair and grey eyes.
Movie: WHAT THE F-
When she first appeared I actually thought she was Clarisse
@@milenasarkowicz3080,lol
I would like to order a movie that is Exactly what the book says
@@milenasarkowicz3080
Me too, her fierceness also made me believe that
@@milenasarkowicz3080 When i saw the cover of The Sea of Monsters movie, I thought TYSON was Clarisse. TYSON.
Fun fact: Percy being aged up is not only unnecessary but literally ruins the whole plot of the books
You CD?
I honestly love how each book picked up after the other one and seeing percy started to grow up and be comfortable using his power. It ones my favorite part, AND THEY REMOVED IT!! WHY?
@@Coffnist_Charm plus, the whole point is that he’d reach the age of 16 against all odds. He’d start a whole war when he reached 16, so they just completely ruined that
Also he's supposed to be dead because demigods usually die young without a lot of training.
It’s a common thing done with movies, sadly. Like with the Giver, they only aged Jonas up so he could have a love arc with Fiona, which never happened in the book.
“I wish he would have described Percy like he described Riptide”
As Jack says, ‘Blades over babes’
*N I C E*
I love the internet
"Could you do a glamour and turn into something smaller?"
"Such as what?"
"I dunno. Something pocket-size and innocuous. A pen, maybe?"
"A pen sword. That is the stupidest thing I've ever heard"
THE SHADE LMAOOOOOOO
AH YES finally somebody mentions magnus chase and the gods of asgard
Magnus Chase babyyyyyy
Movie: *I'M IN LOVE WITH YOU AFTER ONE FIGHT!* 🤮
Book: *"You drool when you sleep."*
lmao she also had a big fat crush on luke
@GGR Makes yes ! 🤣🤣
mark's eyelash in book 5 she said she saw Luke more as a brother.
“I have feelings for you. I’m just not sure if they’re positive or negative yet.”
Just
Why?
Why do that?? She’s literally only there as a romantic interest and a decade later it *still* pisses me off.
Adrienne Kaio in Mark of Athena she said she had a crush on him, he was her first love, from her perspective
When I first saw Annabeth in the movie I was like: Oh, there comes Clarisse
Books: She has blonde hair
Movie: I'm sure that's no too important
Books: Her eyes are grey
Movie: The contacts are really expensive, we'll live without it
Books: She has a deep tan
Movie: Well, we haven't commited to any of the other stuff, so why commit to this?
Books: She is muscular
Movie: Nah, let's just make her have a classic movie star body.
Also: Annabeth literally lost a fight to Percy, who has no training WHATSOVER after doing nothing but training for five years (well actually in the movies it has to be more, since the actress is like 20), and then she's all like: Oh, you're gonna need me on this quest, i have more experience and am a better fighter than you.
Me: Yeah roight
I always thought clairasse was a little broader
I swore to god I thought she was coming to punch him
Movie: nah that's Annabelle
Me: wtf
Deadass i thought that too
Halfway through the movie im thinkin wheres annabeth
Same
Same lol
I don't think that Hailey did this on purpose but- I appreciate the fact that on the neck up shot Annabeth's eyes look a lot like owl eyes. It's fitting because owls are a popular symbol for Athena, her mother
can I just say...."I guess they thought she didn't need a backstory" is throwing SO much shade
It is and I'm here for it
o-owo seven
“She’s always been cute but now I’m starting to think she’s seriously beautiful”
Percy talking about Annabeth the last Olympian
SPOILER ALERT: they end up togther
@@whitebat8957 yea they kiss two times in the end of the last olympian
I really want to read the rest of the other series
White Bat theres literally a whole book in the HOO series thats practically Percabeth 3000
Thank you, I think we all needed that line to give us hope to continue living after watching this video.
PJO books: *annabeth as a supportive female character who plays an important role in the books*
PJO movie: *lmAOOO*
Henny got dragged thru hell and back for this?!
I know right!! But Annabeth is Not as tan as the drawing
@@zir0804 true the book didn't describe it well apparently she doesn't have one at all
Dude it’s like they got information from Wikipedia... got the pictures from there too
Annabeth in movie: you need me percy
Me: ArE yOu SuRe AbOuT tHaT?
“She(Annabeth) just gets described a lot”
Me: ahh young love, even then Percabeth was amazing
THERE’S EVEN TENSION IN THE NEW SHOW
@@poseidons_child.how has the show been going? Better I hope?
the fact that Annabeth never called Percy "Seaweed Brain" was disturbing to me
I wanted to hide under my blanket and cry.
One Blue Duck! Same-
Seaweed brain is an absolute necessity. Just do that at. Least. Once. It doesn’t have to be a big thing. Just have Annabeth walk up to Percy and say “Hey, Seaweed Brain.” That’s all I need. That’s it.
But no.
... in the Peter Johnson series you mean like the movies LOL XD
The movie: she never said that! He he.
PJ movies: *I'm sorry, what? Oh well.*
I remember being the most angry about how the changed clarisse when I was younger, just because of how obviously “beautified” she was. She’s this wide shouldered, muscular, more “masculine” teenage girl. She’s scary and aggressive and a bully, not a super skinny, sexy, mean girl.
The second description fits Drew more than Clarisse.
Clarise is weird, because she should've be looked kinda fat
Leah MacElhiney what??
They just like removed Clarisse entirely from the first movie
Do u know that Clarise end name is like Brazil thingy
annabeth is like opposite hermione, instead of taking away all her imperfections and making her the perfect character they took away all her positive traits
I 100% agree. It’s just horrible in my opinion.
So basically like Ron?
@@eurywoulahan7412 yes.
Ron and Percy are the opposite they gave all of Annabeth‘s good stuff to Percy and took all of Ron ‘s good stuff and gave it to Hermione
URGH I KNOW! I’m a big hp fan, and let me tell you. THEY MASSACRED RON AND GINNY 😭😭😭😭
i despise how they turned Annaberg, a good rep of a strong female role into a “uwu i’m just a love interest that’s super pretty and doesn’t do anything”
"Annaberg"
No but yeah I agree
Same it's so annoying
Books:
- Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief
- Percy Jackson and The Sea of Monsters
- Percy Jackson and the Titan’s Curse
- Percy Jackson and the Battle of the Labyrinth
- Percy Jackson and the Last Olympian
Movies:
- Peter Johnson and the Sparky Stick
- Peter Johnson and the Scary Puddle
- Peter Johnson and the Huge Boi Spell
- Peter Johnson and the Zigzag Fight
- Peter Johnson and the Other Big Boi
sourkiwichair marceline Well actually, the last olympian is Hestia so it would be “Peter Johnson and the Thicc Grill” but whatever.
I love you. Not in a weird way tho
huge boi eye-
I'm going to C R Y at Peter Johnson and the Zigzag Fight why is that so funny-
sᴄᴀʀʏ ᴘᴜᴅᴅʟᴇ
HP fans: the movie ruined book Ginny 😞 (which is true)
Percy Jackson fans: hold my ambrosia
TRUTH
So true
I am both
Harry Potter at least had the excuse of their being so many characters in the books that get development, but in Percy Jackson and the olympians there's like 5-6 main characters you have to develop. Percy, Annabeth, Grover (not as much as the first two), Tyson, Nico, and Luke.
@@anonymousanonymity2815 Man they didn't even get to *introduce* Nico!
If anyone tried to do a book report on The Lightning Theif, but tried to skimp out and just watch the movie, they obviously failed that project.
@Napoleon Bonaparte lmao yesss😂
That was me... After the big F, i read the book to find out it was very small
I did a book report on the book and watched the movie after. I wish I didn't watch the movie.
@@embersun. same
Lindsay T. I know! At least it helps the teachers see who’s cheating.
9:46 "I guess they thought that she didn't need a backstory."
Wow damn, if that roast was any hotter, it would be burning inside the Flame of Olympus
*dam
"Damn" is the correct spelling for the curse. A "dam" is the structure that holds back water.
@@Rachel-fi4sc I’m disappointed in you 😔/j
@@PrezReni045 I feel like that's a reference I don't understand here.
@@Rachel-fi4sc there is, you missed the best joke in the entire book series
Friendly reminder that Apollo, a god, called Annabeth "the scary one"
We support a girl that can scare gods.
@@Breve-might-be-here yeah we do
+Support
We stan
Apollo is honestly a mood-
Annabeth: * Exists in high detail *
Movie: "* smiles and blinks * "Hm? You say something?"
Book: Annabeth and Percy are both 12 years old. Annabeth has honey blonde hair and beautiful princess curls. She has gray eyes.
Movie: Haha, we don't do that here.
yeah when i finished the book i was so excited to watch the movie but when i figured out in the movie they were teens i got really confused
@ArtisticxAriii no, they were both 11
@ArtisticxAriii no its says there both 12
@ArtisticxAriii oh, my bad!! I was thinking of a different character from a different book series. Sorry!!
Mena Toda Book: Grover
Movie: Who? We don't do that here.
Lavender: “There is a lack of black characters in fantasy stories...”
Me, who is reading The Mark of Athena now: HAZEL! HAZEL! WE ARE BREAKING THE RULES WITH HAZEL!
what about Beckendorf ;-;
@@randompersonwithinternet1001 He’s pretty minor…
@@notshelley its still sad
@@randompersonwithinternet1001 Oh sorry…
Yo reading the Mark of Athena?My deepest condolances
The book: Percy Jackson and the Lightning Thief.
The movie: Peter Jhonson and the Sparkly Stick.
The book: Percy Jackson and the Sea of Monsters.
The movie: Peter Jhonson and the Bermuda Triangle
I'M DYING OF LAUGHTER O MAH GOD
u bought me with the sparkly stick
this is just amazing
*HEH*
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂WHEEZE
rick riordan : let’s write annabeth as an intelligent, useful, strong main character while still having subtle hints for her role as a love interest.
screenplay writers : uh? pretty girl who percy likes. yes. perfect.
9IRLS But Annabeth is also a main character
m.a _illustrations u have a point there oops
ill change it
Volt Prime lol
@@vp3841 its just so SAD that is how the world is -.- this is why i never watch movies. people arent realistic
Volt Prime lmaooo
“She gets described a lot”
Yeah cuz percy is always checking out Annabeth
True
Facts
I choked
People think Romeo and Juliet are star crossed lovers? Move over, Percy’s dad and Annabeth’s mom hate each other so much that their kids usually don’t get along that well.
Love this
Movie Percy when he gets Riptide: A pen? But it's a sword? How does that happen? That isn't physically possible. A pen? A sword?
Book Percy when he gets Riptide: lol gimme it
Cannon Percy is nit smart enough for saying that kind of stuff
@@LunaIsMentallyDead he smart, but completely oblivious
@@sammysmith6437 i know,k was just joking lol - v - /no offense
@@LunaIsMentallyDead it's chill
@@LunaIsMentallyDead I find a lot of both memes and other general fan depictions of Percy are a bit on the dumb jokester side then a smart but oblivious kid
The funny thing about the woman who plays Annabeth is that she’s blond in every other project she’s done, so they dyed her hair dark FOR THE MOVIE.😂
Whyyyyyyyyy
I swear Disney+ needs to at least make her blonde, otherwise they are gonna get steamrolled by all of the PJO fans...
Jajajajajajajajaja
THEY PURPOSELY RUINED ANNABETH!!
Fans: **walk into production studio** guys you do know Annabeth's supposed to be blonde right? They describe her that way in the book.
Producers: Wait... there was a book?
When the author has to tell the producers they suck at their jobs.
Lol
Honestly yeah. They should create enjoyable content with morals and themes that relate and correspond to the book, not movies that is just one out of millions of others left on the shelf for the rest of eternity (especially when that book is actually really freaking good. The crazy intense stuff starts more book 4, book 5 for anyone who is wondering. For the others, sit back and watch our character suffer and grow up into a lifestyle of betrayal, death, and insanity)
Yeah Uncle Rick should have! And btw I'm so glad that they didn't make HOO a movie or KC and MC because damn I dont know what I would do if they try to
@@clnne I low-key want PJO to be an animated TV show tbh. That way they don't have to worry about CGI and making things realistic and also producers aren't limited by the choice of actors in Hollywood.
ikr
Book Annabeth is actually THE useful character. She's the one who gets the most done, Percy is an agent of chaos and Grover is a tag-along
THAT'S VERYY ACCURATE I mean that girl completely on her own Won the _Athena Parthenos_ which is like ONE of her achievements so far-
Ikr! She was my favorite character. I expected a lot more of these movies
@@aynain1810 ikr! She's so smart and capable in the books, but in the movies she's basically a side character.
@@camillacameron6604 well Rick says he doesn't want anything to do with the movies so .. i m not mad. There exists no pj movje
@@camljun well hello aren't you passive and agressive. If you get the point, get on with yo damn life
"I don't need to be the Oracle of Delphi to foresee what will happen. You will lose the fans of the series 100%" DAAAAAMN, I'M GONNA USE THAT ONE DAY
dam*
@@randompersonwithinternet1001 no, it's spelled "Damn"
@@jeremyrigdon7875 but- but- hoover dam ;-;
@@randompersonwithinternet1001 that's a different kind of Dam, that blocks water
@@jeremyrigdon7875 have you read The Titan's Curse?
I wanted to die after what they did to Annabeth. The reason her character looked like a stereotypical valley girl was to highlight how enemies could easily underestimate her much like Athena. Athena, her Mom, was underestimated in the Greek times because of her femininity and yet she is one of the most bad ass Greek goddesses of all time. In the movie, they were trying to make Annabeth "bad ass" by making her look less stereo typically girly, while at the same time, making her really boring.
I've never read Percy jackson, I've only seen the movies, but I'm really into mythology and after I finished the first movie I was like "WHAT THE HELL HOW IS THAT GIRL THE DAUGHTER OF ATHENA WTF ATHENA IS THE MOST BADASS INTELLIGENT WISE DEITY IN THE OLYMPUS WHAT IS WRONG WITH THAT GIRL THEY *MUST* HAVE MADE A MISTAKE SHE CAN'T BE ATHENA'S DAUGHTER" and now I guess I was on point😂
it was even mentioned she felt oppressed or something about being blonde in HOO
I KNOW! It really sucks like you don’t have to make them exactly how they are described but at least make them like their character.
Ikrrrrr maybe it's also because every Californian girl tho-
My opinion: JUST BECAUSE YOU GIVE A GIRL A SWORD THAT DOESN’T MAKE HER INTERESTING! That’s how most movies portray “powerful” female protagonists and it pisses me off. I’m a girl and I find that more offensive then not having female protagonists because then people are like, “Stop complaining, female protagonists are normal now.” And I’m like “NO! THERE NOT! IM NOT JUST GONNA SIT HERE AND ACCEPT THE BARE MINUM!” (Oof, sorry for this dumb rant.)
First rule of the Percy Jackson series fandom: *We don’t talk about the movies.*
You are correct but it had to be done. She fixed them
Ithinkflutterawesome should i watch the movies tho? Ive read the first ”season” of Pj books and also the next ”season” with Jason and piper you know
@@sivstalull9041 If you want to see how much it sucked, then go ahead, but for the sake of your sanity, follow what Uncle Rick would tell you: don't.
Red Faldas Im gonna do it, just so My friend Who read and watched can rant to me😂
So they turned a book for nerdy kids that featured interesting and complex characters into some primitive fratboy teenage flick. How many more movie adaptations will Hollywood ruin before it has enough money to choke on, srsly.
Other authors: Her dark crimson coat fluttered in the wind, her jet black skirt finishing just under her knees.
Rick Riordan: she wasn't naked
Hey, at least we know Charon wore Italian suits
And hasn’t gotten a raise in a couple thousand years
les get Charon a raise or imma sue
@@victreebeloverlord1185 chiron
Yeah I'm with ya, poor Charon has to deal with all these people and he can't even buy his fancy shmancy suits
I’m very glad that Disney is supposed to be making a adaptation series with the cannon ages and that supposed to follow the cast as they grow up. Hopefully we’ll get to see it and possibly see characters we didn’t get to in the movies(specifically Nico and Leo).
The world will go absolutely crazy whenever we see Nico or Leo
@@sofiavarena1524 ye. And so will i
@@sofiavarena1524 I'll cry if I see the movie version of Leo, because he's so cute and imagining him as a 30- year- old man is just haunting. PLUS Nico will probably end up looking like the actor they cast for Percy tbh
THEY DIDN'T PUT NICO IN THE MOVIES, SOMEONE GIVE ME RIPTIDE!
the hunger games fans: they removed madge from the films!
harry potter fans: they ruined ginny!
percy jackson fans: hold my ambrosia
But I’m in all three fandoms!! And I’m mad about all three!! But tbh Annabeth is definitely portrayed the worst of the three
Phoebe Sachs IKR the hunger games movies were actually really good but some aspects didn’t fulfill me same with harry potter but percy jackson is ANOTHER THINF
@@frogbysachs7559 their Annabeth was honestly so sexist.
And harry potter fans complain that ginny was runied cuz of her personality.
Try reading the Cirque Du Freak books and then watching the movie... travesty... this movie adaptation is golden by comparison.
I absolutely HATE how useless they made Annabeth, actually, most of the girls seem absolutely useless in every situation, yet Percy, a boy, who didn't know anything about his powers, BEATS Annabeth, someone who has been coming to the camp for YEARS. Idk about anyone else but that seems kinda sexist on the movie's behalf.
edit: guys this comment is 2 years old and just restates something said in the video you've got to stop liking it-
They could have at least had them do the water thing.
I wonder if they watched the Harry Potter movies. Hermione was acted so well by Emma Watson. She even plays a good role in the movies. Annabeth on the other hand.....
i'm not so sure.
Not to even mention the fact that in the book, that was meant to be Annebeth and Percy on the same team
Yeah 😠
I though Annabeth was Clarisse- 😔
Annabeth is probably the most resourceful and level-headded character in the book, but they completely chopped off all of her interesting traits and made her "strong generic female love interest girl" in the "movie" (Using the term movie very lightly)
legit they did that in the giver to fiona in the movie >_
soyest boy ya, not to mention that they RE CREATED THE WHOLE FIRST MOVIE!!!! THE STORY LINE WASNT EVEN THE SAME!!!!!!!!
She was also strong too and that coincides with being resourceful and level-headed? Why is general strength of character an issue to you for a female character? Especially when it's already accurate?
Right?!....
Multiple artist renditions in books and wikis: Grover is a wimpy, cinnamon roll, scrawny white kid
Hollywood: did you mean a strapping, charismatic black dude?
mkgjgf charismatic is not the word i would use for movie grover
Book: Clarisse bullies Percy
Movie: I have never met Clarisse in my life
actually, clarisse is in the second. and they reference things that havent happened yet.
And then she magically appears in the second movie 🙄
she is in the movie
Book: Literally she’s about to murder him and he blows up the bathroom
Movie: Clarise who?
When I was younger I actually thought Anabeth in the first movie was Clarisse and I was very confused about where Anabeth was
Every other fandom: They only used 3/4 of the book none of the good details about the book were used. UGH
Percy Jackson Fandom: *sobbing in the corner looking like Nico after Bianca died"
RIP Bianca.
DON'T SPOILLLLLLLLLLLLL
@@sunnystars1280 she died but is doing fine lately
*tOO SOON*
Rip Bianca :(
Harry Potter movie creators: *Try their hardest*
Percy Jackson movie creators: *“Aight, Ima head out”*
Lol XD
I actually found out that the Harry Potter director is the same director that made Percy Jackson
@@camsherm *shrug* I don't know
When the writer works on the movie (Harry Potter) vs when the author doesn't (Perry Johnson).
@@hunt3rxtr3me81 Exaxtly! Authors should pay attention to what's happening with the moviesa
Rando: I thought the Percy Jackson movie was pretty good
Everyone who's read the books: so you have chosen death
I actually used to like the movie
But then I read the book
And then I cringed so hard when I realized the truth.
Do you think God stays in heaven because he's scared of what he's created?
Same, I first watch the movie and thought it was okay, and I the books... Nah fam
Fionna Sherri me too
same thing!! i knew the movie first and then found out it was 'based' on a book series so i read them and my life has never been better than knowing the original plot of the book; i've had issues about the movie's plot since first watch it's just so weird and doesn't make any sense
Me too. I was really little when I saw the movie. The book made me do a one eighty
"I didn't see him as a jokester mainly because he was pretty much suffering through out the books"
THANK YOU, HE'S BEEN THROUGH SO MUCH
As he's progressed, he's actually started dropping that as a fact xD He's been through way too much, he *deserves* this or that, but the gods need him again... "*sigh* I've got you, but you owe me big time."
@@JanMaynz Yeah, like in the House Of Hades, he kinda loses control for a moment because, he "wanted to see just how much misery Misery could take"
• Wanna See My Shot Glass Collection • That was one of my favorite moments in the books. And the way he described how he was slowly losing control about the glass breaking in his mind was amazing. I’m sad that we don’t get to see a dark Percy anymore
@@okmillyy ME TOO, I really wish we could have seen more of it. I would have loved it, it's a real shame
yea he mainly used comedy as a cooping mechanism
Producers: *reading* “My name is Percy Jackson.” SWEET! Guess we got enough information to make a movie!
Me: *deep breath* n o
it surely seems like thats what they did
They didn't even read his age lol
i dont think they even read anything tbh
Nah mate, they probably just looked at the cover, title, asked somebody about like, 2 characters, and made the Peter Johnson franchise.
@@SamiStrawberryPie omg XD
the inaccuracies with annabeth in the movie pisses me off because it was so glaringly easy to make her blonde, i feel like they just didnt want to make a smart blonde character, it didnt even matter in the end because they made her absolutely useless in the movie, it just feels like they didn't want to make any of them interesting or complex like they were in the books, so the directors just fell on old tropes of, "useless woman," "cool badass protagonist," and "comic relief minority side character" for the main three
And they avoided making every muscular person muscular-
@@L1lyW0mpW0mp And they managed to make the one character in the main three who was repeatedly described as "scrawny" muscular 😭
@@mochaismilk exactly
And in the second movie Clarisse just pops out of FRICKING NOWHERE
You know what really annoys me about the movies? Annabeth's reaction to learning about Luke's betrayal. In the books Annabeth and Luke have been friends for ages, Annabeth looks up to him and has a crush on him... and yet, in the movie she just calmy comes to the conclusion that he betrayed them and has absolutely no reaction to finding this out. It really annoys me
OMG FR THO 💀
Like I expected her to be like "NO LUKE HOW COULD YOU"
instead she was like "Oh yeah I knew that."
"Family Luke, you promised" SOBBING
and in later books she continues to like admire him and even deny it in some cases. She still like holds onto the fact that Luke was one of her favorite people even when he kidnapped her and tried to kill her. She still denied that he was fully bad and it like actually hurts her that he turned out the way he did.
Producers be like: There was a book?
Alycia Rodman underrated comment
Might as well be best friends with the people that did the atla live action
@@lunacheesecake5148 omg that's so true
Lol
Luna Bear Don’t say that name. If you must refer to it, use the proper name. Shit
"Even the fittest kids wont have bulging muscles"
Literally every 14 year old jojo character: *HMMMMM*
Yare yare
Jojo characters: *OBSERVE*
THUNDER CROSS SPLIT ATTACK!!!
*Ah yes, here in My hero academia we to, have weirdly fit kids*
Looks at Goten and Trunks
can I just say when she erased percy’s original pose to him having his hand on his hip I literally started saying MATERIAL GWORL-
The only scene worth watching in the movies is this scene:
Percy: **is on the roof of the Andromeda**
Luke: .................What are you doing? Don't walk on my roof.
Percy: (confused demigod noises)
Where can I find the scene?
@@nehb1332 sea of monsters
@@fueledbypaintwater Okay
H a h a h a h a- i havent dared watched the movies :)
@@purplebelo-xs8io oh my gods this makes me hate the movies even more
I love that we're still dissing the movie nine years later XD
That's how much we despise it
It’s not only the Percy Jackson fandom the does it
*In the background*
HARRYDIDYOUPUTYOURNAMEINTHEGOBLETOFFIYAH!!
@@Potterhead-wg7vz oh God... Yeah that's still a thing🙄
what they did is unforgivable, even more so in the second CATASTROPHY of a movie for Sea of Monsters; the movies will be dissed until the end of time itself
Hayley Wilson screw off it has NOT been 9 years. Oh my gods that’s too much lol
They made Grover black and then said “ok let’s give him every racist stereotype ever” in the movie like 👁 👄 👁
I hate the black stereotypes, your skin colour does not direct your actions.
@@aimalisapro123 I know right! So frickin annoying
YESSSS, I'm black and I hate what they did to Grover. Like they made him loud and obnoxious, like he only cared about girls and stuff which is SO WRONG book Grover is the exact opposite of movie Grover
@@illstealyourkneecaps694 I know! Like the movie people could’ve just changed his skin tone and kept his personality or changed his personality and kept his skin tone they didn’t have to make the movie even more stereotypical than it already is
@@princelyhairdos EXCACTLY, I'm fine with him being black but they took away what made Grover well, GROVER. He's not supposed to be all confident and stuff he's supposed to be shy and unassuming, that's why its so cool when he does something super brave
As a twelve-year-old, I did not pay that much attention to clothes. So I don't think Percy would, either, unless it is very distinctive (like the Camp Half-Blood shirt).
I definitely appreciate how difficult it made it for you, though. A single, young POV makes things difficult to adequately describe unless it is super important or distinctive.
I just remember in one of the promotional interviews with the actors, they were asked about the blue food and all the actors looked really confused.
That was the moment I knew this was not gonna be a faithful adaptation.
Rip blue food
Bet they didnt even read the book
Poor Percy
Percy Jackson-blue food = a guy
who doesn't like his life
And the dude who plays Percy himself, said that Percy had nothing to do with blue food, like- bruh-
They were like "well thats random" and I literally screamed
Rick: it’s simple really! She has B.L.O.N.D.E hair
Movies: She has what?
Rick:.... did you read the book..?
Movies: The what?
Zero_Dream Maker Anyone who hasn't read the books has a dam problem
... what's a book?
Kavya Whyte You see I haven’t read the books, but I’m perfectly healthy so.....
Z3R0Z Have you watched the movies?
@@ahqq- it's a dam joke.
You did annabeth eyes so good. She looks like a owl which is fitting.
Exactlyy what I was thinking 😩👌
:U
Percy:a guinea pig. Nico: a corn plant. Thalia: a tree.
Frank: an iguana
@@Angelo-uw9eopiper: *kaleidoscope*
@@girlleavemealone--oh my gosh YES XDD also Will: a lightbulb
i find it interesting how they had no problem casting a black actor when they needed pop culture references, one liners, and comedic relief but, when they need the female love interest, the description of “tan skin” is nonexistent.
Books:
Percy Jackson
Annabeth Chase
Grover Underwood
Chiron
Clarrise LaRue
Movies:
Peter Johnson
Anniebell Run
Grunter Overlog
HorseDude
Clarskinnies LalalalaPoo
@@fatmattbellamy7052
Mooshroom Annebeth: Anne girl
Lol
Lol
Hehe...
You drawing Percy like 15 times before settling on something is a mood
I used to draw him a lot and never get him right, he's not that well described in the earlier books and I wasn't so good at art when I was 12... 😂 I can relate.
Extremely relatable
"Percy is usually described with having a mischevous smirk"
PERCY WALKS IN WITH A MISCHEVOUS GRIN
The thunder and rain makes sense, considering who his father is.
THUNDERRRR! You telling this story, or am I?
😏
Leo described her as "scary blonde girl." Then Magnus described her as "if she was looking for me, I didn't want to be found. She was scary."
Lol everyone thinks she's scary.
Oh my gosh yesss🤣💯💯
you spelt mongo cheese wrong
ARAMIS NOEL-HEMMING yes
Except for Percy 😏
Just saying, but percy describes her when she's 12 and even then he saw she was intense. Leo sees her when she's 16 which is after she's been on a few quests, fought in a war, had to go through the whole luke thing, and had her boyfriend kidnapped. She grew into her scary appearance.
99%-the movie sucks
1%-Percy is green
I’m so flippen happy that Disney Plus is making a series that Rick Riordan is actually gonna be involved with
:o
THANK GODDDD
They are!? Hell yes I’m definitely watching that🤩
I would so prefer a cartoon tho tbh
excited for it to begin
If Percy was like 16 in the books, I wouldn’t mind the casting, but they casted grown adults to play 12 year olds which is by far the dumbest casting choice I’ve ever seen.
Annabeth’s appearance: *exists
Movie: (sips tea) *pardon?*
Tamaki Amajiki!!! A fellow My Hero Academia fan!!
𝘀𝗶𝗽 𝘀𝗶𝗽
@@doesnt yay!
@@doesnt 𝖘𝖎𝖕
@@doesnt SIP SIP
In the movie, Annabeth seemed like a really snotty annoying person to me. In the books, she was someone I looked up to. And, I was also upset about what they did to her in the movies.
Yes!!
Ikr!! Annabeth had soo much more potential and character than what the movies portrayed. I feel sorry for anyone who watched the movies first.
You know, I'm SO happy to see this comment, because my brother was (as still is) really into Percy Jackson books but I knew little about them, so when I watched this movie with my brother, I thought these were the actual characters, and I still haven't read Percy Jackson, but I am planning on it very soon because I am reading the Magnus Chase series at the moment, but I can just say I hated how they were portrayed in the movie and kind of made me not want to read the rest of the books, but now that I got descriptions of the actual characters, I am more than excited to read them!
Alright, who was it? who ruined the likes and made it 667?
XDD
Also, thank y’all for 668 likes!! That’s crazy!!
lavender: ...when grover was portrayed as a ladies man...
me : sINCE WHEN DID LEO GET HERE
I'm glad they didn't make HOO movies, I don't want anything happening to my son :'(
I hope Disney+ will make a HoO adaptation, because I want to see who they cast as Leo
@@irati848 yes... but my favorite character is Nico
And even Leo has charm at least, Grover in the movie was kinda....gross. Especially that Persephone scene, like she wasn’t even supposed to be in the movie at all??.? They just added that for laughs I guess? It wasn’t funny, just pedoish
Imagine if they got there hands on Nico they'd probably make him blond or something
I feel like a lot of people tend to forget that Grover was described as having his horns hide under his hair. So thank you for not making his horns visible.
LavenderTowne before reading Percy Jackson: I've never actually read the books so I have to learn more about it
LavenderTowne after reading Percy Jackson: **kicks down door** whAT did thEY DO tO GROVER
Yep, hardcore fan girl here, I LOVED that reaction.
15:58
me:
*juniper will kill him.*
That is me
GroVEr Is THE HOLY SON AND SAVIOUR AND THE SWEET ENVIOURMENTELIST CINNAMON ROLL HOW DARE THEY CHANGE HIM!1!!11
Well it’s quite simple...they kinda ruined him
Rick: *Makes Anabeth a Independent strong young-woman*
Movies: *Makes her the damsel in distress and the helpless love interest*
Me: WHAT DID YOU DO TO ANABETH!!!! HAVE YOU EVEN READ THE BOOKS!!! THEY EXIST!
Movie: Percy Jackson books who??
Which is really disappointing because Annabeth is my hero :(
What Percy Jackson movies? Oh, you mean the Potato Janitor movies?
In a movie interview, someone said ‘do you like blue food?’ And the actors were like ‘wut. What does that have to with Percy Jackson?!’
@@lucikka3674 That made me sooooo *_triggered._*
@@eebertdeebert Wow. Potato Janitor...I should use that more often.
One of the things that pisses me off the most about the movie adaptation of The Lighting Theif is the fact that they completely removed the section where Percy and the others find out his parentage and instead make it so that the information is already known to Chiron.
oh yeah, not to mention they removed the main antagonist from the plot, Ares
Also how the gods look completely different....
I literally didn't even recognize the story when I watched the movie. or rather the other way around. Once I read the books I didn't realize I had actually seen the movie version before. They are so dissimilar it is not even funny.
Oh! I don’t forget the part with Hades! I love that part in the book on how Percy will get his helmet back and calls him uncle and it’s just AHHH! But NOOO! Not having that in the movie! Because Hades is a bad guy and his wife is the only good one! Also, Hades always keeps his promises in the book but in the movie they’re like NAHHH HES A DEVIOUS LITTLE B-TCH that will betray you. Completely OPPOSITE! And he also doesn’t want a war in the first place in the books, he doesn’t want more dead people in his kingdom. He only wants his helmet back, and that, ladies and gentlemen, is another reason to hate the movies!
LIKE SRSLY!!!
Me : wow I love Grover he’s such a cinnamon roll 🥰
Movie : nope
WHAT HAVE THEY DONE TO HIM? I LITREALLY ALMOST LEFT MY CLASSROOM AFTER THAT FEDORA DANCE SCENE 😭
Rick: I want you to make a Percy Jackson movie.
Director: A _what_ movie?
Rick: Percy Jackson? You’ve read that, right?
Director: **panics** Yes…
The thing is, I'm pretty sure the actors read the books too.
The weirdest thing is that it’s Chris Columbus! The guy who directed the first Harry Potter movies! He should have been great.
Dull_Demon47 Dull_Demon47 I remember there was this video where the actors of the sea of monsters were looking at comments by fans and one of the fans mentioned about blue food and the actors were like “how is that even related to the movie” so yeah I’m pretty sure they had never read the books
No, Rick didn’t ask and they didn’t ask Rick.
@@emily-uo1et Theres a whole video of Rick being interviewed about this. They came to him, said they wanted to make a movie. He asked if he could have any say in how the movie would be done. They laughed at him and said no. But Rick still went for it because he thought it was the best way to get his book noticed, and it worked.
I love this so much. SO MUCH. the saltiness, the sass, the art, I love it all. thank you for fixing my poor babies.
YESSSSS THANK YOU!!
YAZZZZ
fellow elise!
elise magers wow hi!!!
there are never any other Elise's I've only ever known of 5 and that's it
They made Annabeth into just the helpless love interest just to attract more people. :(
Ya and I was fuming mad about that and I don't get mad about movie characters done badly that often,I don't even notice half the times but annabeth and grover were done so badly
And even percy had some important elements missing
The movie makers probably made her an aphrodite child
Oh gods she was horrible in the movie
Like in the book I loved her she was so fierce but kind and just awesome
And wen I first saw the movie I thought the supposed annabeth was clarisse in the first scene
And wen we got to meet her I was like oh my gods what did they do to annabeth
I was SO MAD that she barely had battle scenes.
Billy what have you done?!
“I like crappy movie adaptations”
*shoot em again.*
"They pretty much ruined her."
TRUTH.
Loki Odinson I thought you died, faked it again?
Yes, I did. Surprise...
@@aizawhat1377 OMG! You're alive! I knew IT! I love you! You are my husbend forever!♥️♥️♥️♥️
I was pissed they got rid of the baseball cap
Loki odinson we all know thor is the adopted one
I didn't mind glover being black, I just wished they kept this personality
Ana não faria I agree grover is fibe no matter hiw he looks just as long as it matches his (book) personality.
@hades child I disagree, it's only confusing when the characters change ccompletely like the sorts of Percy Jackson. Recently they casted a black woman to play Hamlet and idk if you had the opportunity to see it, it's truly TRULY remarkable how her character is portrayed, I'll go as far as saying it is the best possible casting.
Sometimes the source material needs some updating and I'll welcome all diversity, as long as the core of the story remains the same.
@hades child YOU can't do that because YOU are a real person, characters in another hand get updated all the time.
For instance, A Star Is Born just got its third or fourth adaptation to cinema, but we all can understand that, while it is an updated rendition, the core of the story remained the same. Broadway has revivals all the time and as long as they take time to establish the characters, how is that possibly going to get confusing? The new Enjolras from Les Mis is black, but everything about him screams young revolutionary so no one is confused at all!
The problem with Percy Jackson in particular is that while they did insert some diversity with the casting of Grover, his entire personality was butchered!
@hades child you sound very young so I'll just say this: art, literature, cinema... All of those things are in constant mutation. The way we, in our time, view characters like Darth Vader or Gandalf will change inevitably because of our time, but while our interpretations may change, the core of those characters as they were written should stay the same, don't you agree? The color of their skin doesn't have to change anything about the characters essence! A good script writer will be able to translate the original work to screen and tthere's that.
The problem with Percy Jackson, once again, is that the characters weren't adapted properly. Grover can be black, Percy could be Asian and Annabeth could be middle eastern, as long as their personalities align with the ones from the book, why should it be confusing? It's only confusing in Percy Jackson because Grover was supposed to be a sweet flower child whereas the films kind of made him look like a jerk-y womanizer.
@hades child Sorry if I made you angry, but you said you didn't know Les Mis, which to me indicates that you haven't had the opportunity to read it in high school yet.
I think you missed my point entirely. I'm simply saying a race change in a character doesn't change its essence at all.
We are simply having a conversation, let's be mature about it.
Movie ginny: they ruined me completely! I am the worst character and everything about me sucks! No one is worse than I am!
Movie annabeth: hold my cap
Literally anyone in the PJO movies except Percy and maybe Luke:
*Hold my Blue cherry coke*
Movie Annabeth: Hold my cap, oh wait, I DON'T HAVE ONE !!
_what cap?_
I hated luke in the movies, he is one of my favourites in the book
What cap am i trying to hold. Remember you dont have one.
“I was like ‘…I have a few suggestions…’ and then I pulled out like twenty pages.”
Book Annabeth: Described as having tanned skin, stormy grey eyes and in a book scene where she is sitting with her siblings it's said "They all had athletic build and honey blond hair"
Movie: Brown hair and green eyes, looks 20 years old
They're 18 in the movies.
6:41 just really punctuates your point
We all know why they destroyed Annabeth.
They needed an eye candy damsel in distress to be Percy's love interest because Hollywood seems to think that girls can't be tough AND the love interest at the same time.
You realise no one beat her but Percy right?
that wasn't the point
Hanako's Dream Forest you‘re sure about That? Hollywood is Full of sjw‘s, Creating overpowered female Characters 🤷🏻♂️
@@motmi2356 that's probably them trying to remedy the underpowered female characters. Not by making them good characters, just overpowered
Nah, they were just shit adaptations. Hollywood has had great female leads for decades: Ellen Ripley, Sarah Connor, The Bride from Kill Bill, every Slasher Final Girl (Special props to Megan from Friday The 13th Part 6 and Nancy from Nightmare on Elm Street) and so on
Let’s be honest the Percy jackson movie was a disgrace to the series
What movie? The movie you're talking about. Doesn't. Exist.
@@appletonfamily3520 lol
Mhm
@Kitty Cool *perry johanson
@@ogaboga6496 Prairie Jamaica