Tracie literally sounds like she does on the CD. True talent. Props to Nicole though, she really held her own in a song sung by one of the greatest Broadway performers in the world.
I am a HUGE Idina Mendel fan and while I do agree that no one can do this song like Idina, Nicole's vocals were definitely stellar in this song and production of RENT. She played the part of Maureen very well. I give credit were credit is do and as a vocalist myself I know these songs are not the easiest to sing. Take me or leave me can be especially challenging and Nicole delivered. GET IT GIRL!
Some performers have trouble balancing acting and singing, focusing too much on the singing with sub-par acting or vice versa. But, damn, Tracie nails it every time
I love Idina, don't get me wrong, but I feel like Nicole really got the whole "I've always been hot & flirty" thing down, also TRACIE MY GOD WORDS CANNOT AND DO NOT EXPRESS THAT TALENT
Not my favorite Maureen, but damn, she can sing the hell out of this song. I really wasn't expecting aynthing from her, but I was wrong. Way to go Scherzinger!
Tracie wasn't in the original cast. She was in the movie, the final cast and this. However, she IS Joanne. No one else will ever play the role as well as she does
Obviously Tracie and Idina have better chemistry as they've had more time together and have known one another for a long time now. But Nicole, Tracie and everyone else involved in this production only had 1 week to rehearse everything - which is why there were still minor glitches during the 3 days they performed at the Hollywood Bowl. If they were given more time together to practice, I believe the chemistry would've been there.
Plus Tracie already knew the part well - while Nicole had to learn it all in a short period of time and that year she was still doing Dancing With The Stars and filming for Men In Black 3 and finishing her solo album at the same time so you can't really compare her to Idina who's had more experience and time with the role of Maureen.
wow! there just isnt any words to describe how amazing tracie thoms and nicole scherzinger are. if i said this was amazing, that would be an understatement.(y)
Nicole singing like this and doing Phantom of the Opera and Cats makes me wonder why she wasted any of her time doing generic pop crap with the Pussycats Dolls. Anyone could have done what she did with that group, but she's clearly better than people think.
Woowwwww i think Nicole she is awesome..!!! Great moves,superb voice..!!! I am going crazy when she says about the tiger in the cage,cause she climbes on the table as a real one..!!! ;) What can i say about Tracey....I just love her..!!
nicole's voice is amazing but i wasnt thrilled by her acting, her caracter just wasnt romantically conected to the other woman who was singing with her
That's the hottest Maureen I've ever seen. And her voice? Gives Idina a run for her money, singing wise. Unfortunately her acting outside of the song wasn't much to write home about.
jaquen1977 you should see her do Maureen's performance piece. She freaking nails it. I think the problem here is with the staging/direction. The actors are too far apart. These characters need to be up in each other's face so you can feel the real love you/hate you tension.
Tracie literally sounds like she does on the CD. True talent.
Props to Nicole though, she really held her own in a song sung by one of the greatest Broadway performers in the world.
If your referring to Idina Menzel, your completely correct!!
lol of course I'm referring to Idina... she was the original Maureen
dirttowater Idina is the benchmark that every Maureen will be measured against.
I realize everyone's talking about Idina and Nicole, but can we take a minute to appreciate Tracie! Ugh always SO good!
prob cause with tracie there's nothing to debate (ie. she's good.) :P
There's no one better than Tracie in this role.
+Kisha H I love Idina better too though.
I've seen a number of different versions of Rent, and Tracie is the best Joanne ever.
I came here for Tracie. ❤️
I am a HUGE Idina Mendel fan and while I do agree that no one can do this song like Idina, Nicole's vocals were definitely stellar in this song and production of RENT. She played the part of Maureen very well. I give credit were credit is do and as a vocalist myself I know these songs are not the easiest to sing. Take me or leave me can be especially challenging and Nicole delivered. GET IT GIRL!
Some performers have trouble balancing acting and singing, focusing too much on the singing with sub-par acting or vice versa. But, damn, Tracie nails it every time
Nicole Scherzinger is so freakin underrated, ugh, gosh. I love when she does things like this, always makes people sit up and take notice.
Nicole KILLS this... she's such an underrated performer
Jesus, Tracie is absolute perfection
I love Idina, don't get me wrong, but I feel like Nicole really got the whole "I've always been hot & flirty" thing down, also TRACIE MY GOD WORDS CANNOT AND DO NOT EXPRESS THAT TALENT
Jesus Christ can she ever sing. Say what you want about her acting that voice is unreal. Flawless.
Tracie Thoms was born for this role. God, I love her!!
Tracie Thoms is the ONLY joanne😍😍
She sure is!
I think that every time I've seen rent it's been her
agreed. i love that she is always in everything for RENT
maya papaya She really is. The ONLY Joanne
This was amazing from both girls, but this was one of the most breathtaking vocals I've heard from Tracie Thoms
I love Idina as Maureen, but I love Nicole's take on the role too. Amazing.
tracie thoms will always be joanne in my mind
Whoa!!! Nicole's voice fits so well with this song along with Tracie's!! XD This is amazing how well the two sounded. Their voices were so powerful!
I think we can all agree that no matter who is Maureen and so far on youtube there's been Idina, Nicole and Eden, Tracie is Queen Joanna
Nicole would've made a PERFECT MIMI!!!
Samantha Vaughan talk about art imitating life!
Tracie Thoms is so great.
Not my favorite Maureen, but damn, she can sing the hell out of this song. I really wasn't expecting aynthing from her, but I was wrong. Way to go Scherzinger!
Their chemistry is actually so on point. One of the best scenes in this production!
holy shit that was incredible. a stadium-shattering performance if there ever was one
Nicole is a great singer wow
They both DEFINITELY did that.
Nicole: Lack of acting skills, but her voice WOW, impressive. Took to another level.
One moment while I sigh happily over THE Tracie Thoms of original Rent
Tracie wasn't in the original cast. She was in the movie, the final cast and this. However, she IS Joanne. No one else will ever play the role as well as she does
I will always want the Idina and Tracie duo!
Obviously Tracie and Idina have better chemistry as they've had more time together and have known one another for a long time now. But Nicole, Tracie and everyone else involved in this production only had 1 week to rehearse everything - which is why there were still minor glitches during the 3 days they performed at the Hollywood Bowl. If they were given more time together to practice, I believe the chemistry would've been there.
Wow, I've been youtubing as many versions of this as I can find. Vocally this is no.1 so far.......Amazing.....Being there would have been too much.
Nicole was unbelievable and so amazing!
I love Tracie! She always brings a smile to my face when she plays Joanne
Nicole can sing everything!! she's the best:)
Plus Tracie already knew the part well - while Nicole had to learn it all in a short period of time and that year she was still doing Dancing With The Stars and filming for Men In Black 3 and finishing her solo album at the same time so you can't really compare her to Idina who's had more experience and time with the role of Maureen.
Nicole's vocals were FIERCE in this.
Best version I've heard
I know that most singers can actually sing. People always say that everyone's using autotune but obviously there has to be some talent there.
That was wonderful. Just....I never knew Nicole played Maureen....Im going to go cry tears of joy now -sniffle- Just wonderful
this version was so awesome
Tracie sounds amazing here!
First time I've ever seen this version and it was SO GOOD!!
Fantastic rendition of the song.
Um, everyone does realize that Nicole just belted an F in this, right? Fucking. Amazing.
These two are gold.
"Kiss Pookie" gets me everytime hahaha
wow! there just isnt any words to describe how amazing tracie thoms and nicole scherzinger are. if i said this was amazing, that would be an understatement.(y)
I love it how Nicole tries to not overpower Tracy's voice.
I have always luved this song and now I love it more!!!!
That actually may be the best Take Me or Leave Me I've seen to date.
tracie is the best joanne you can get not only is she's in millions of different rent shows but she was amazing in the movie
no auto-tune. pure talent. Me Likee.
Okay I did not know nicole could sing/perform like this!!!
Nicole did better than I thought she would but I'm still in love with Tracie Thoms :)
Girl I got chills..
The perfect combination for this song will always be Tracie Thoms and Idina Menzel.
THAT'S the real Joanne! She is just amazing!
Perfect job Nicole!
Nicole Scherzinger is so underrated.
omg its tracie!!!!!! thats awesome they have her as Joanne, and its interesting seeing Nicole doing broadway! but this part was made for her!
Hmm...Pleasantly surprised by Nicole's performance. No words for Tracie... She is just incredible!
Best song in the whole movie!!!
TRACIE THOMS is AMAZING!!!
oh my god she's my new favorite maureen.
StripesofShay same here the only for me is Nicole scherzinger
thanks for posting!!! you had great seats and your so lucky you got to see them perform!! im so jealous!!! :(
I love Tracie so much!!
What an excellent performance :)
Tracy really had the advantage going into this though cuz she did the movie AND played Joann on Broadway as well lol But Nicole is amazing too!
best performance in the production
Nicole singing like this and doing Phantom of the Opera and Cats makes me wonder why she wasted any of her time doing generic pop crap with the Pussycats Dolls. Anyone could have done what she did with that group, but she's clearly better than people think.
Noone can do it better than Idina, but Nicole did a pretty good job ^^'
GO for it girl!
damn Nicole is phenomenal!
acting wasn't great on Nicole's part. But her voice was GREAT.
Nicole is just fantastic. im totally speechless....
Great performance... though there will never be a replacement for Idina, I'm thoroughly impressed with Nicole!
nicole should really do more musical theatre! she's amazing at this and at phantom of the opera and evita.
Pleasantly surprised by Nicole's singing ability. She did very well.
Nicole's voice is amazing...
Tracie Thoms kills this song every.single.time. SHE IS Joanne.
AGREED! I can't see anyone else playing her!
Guys. is that the lead singer of the Pussycat dolls, or am I crazy?
+Candy Wiklun yes it is
+Candy Wiklun yes! its nicole scherzinger
Holy crap that was fantastic! Idina may still be my favorite Maureen, but that was wayyyyyyy too amazing.
Tracie is the best Joanne!
she is great both of them are great
Woowwwww i think Nicole she is awesome..!!! Great moves,superb voice..!!! I am going crazy when she says about the tiger in the cage,cause she climbes on the table as a real one..!!! ;) What can i say about Tracey....I just love her..!!
nicole's voice is amazing but i wasnt thrilled by her acting, her caracter just wasnt romantically conected to the other woman who was singing with her
I like Nicole's take, on the Maureen character. While I'm a huge Idina fan, I think Nicole did a damn good job.
WHAT?! Nicole...I. am. impressed.
I like the one with NPH and David Burtka, that's my favorite version! :D
Perfect just like the oringinal!
That's the hottest Maureen I've ever seen. And her voice? Gives Idina a run for her money, singing wise. Unfortunately her acting outside of the song wasn't much to write home about.
jaquen1977 you should see her do Maureen's performance piece. She freaking nails it.
I think the problem here is with the staging/direction. The actors are too far apart.
These characters need to be up in each other's face so you can feel the real love you/hate you tension.
Tracie:D
Hello Tracie Thoms...damn.
really enjoying your videos! can't wait to see your next uploads
wow, I had my doubts about Nicole, but she OWNS this song
holy crap this amazing.
So good.
THIS is Maureen.
nicole sounds AMAZING....when she's not singing her own songs. brilliant performance.
I like Nicole as Maureen but it doesn't seem the same without Idina as Maureen! Idina just does it perfectly
That's because Idina was the actress who got to determine Maureen's personality.
That's because Idina was the actress who got to determine Maureen's personality.
Nicole Nicole Nicole...why aren't you doing more of THIS/??
that was epic.
definitely. movie and theater can't be compared as far as vocals are concerned.
aww love nicole
PHENOMENAL