If these girls had come up with another horror concept mv, their popularity would've skyrocketed..but the company has definitely some other plans in their mind😔
@@suler642 it’s different because they’re wearing jewelry from my culture which is only meant to be worn by people from a certain few countries (India, Pakistan, Bangladesh), plus correct me if i’m wrong but they’re also using stereotypical mocking as a choreography, and also using my culture as an aesthetic
@@suler642 also one of the girls is wearing a red bindi with white dots on top of her eyebrows which is a look traditionally worn by brides in Hindu wedding ceremonies and holds religious significance. I am so so disappointed
@@taetaeismylove9838 idk how but I think one who is not an indian shouldn't appreciate or use our costumes in any kinda aesthetic without knowing their real meaning. Even if you're Bengali and you don't think they are culture appropriating it but I think they are. Korean idol has always been doing these mockery things to other cultures. So they shouldn't wear anything that's related to our culture.
@@Monalisa-lf4iv Ehh, don't bother educating them. They've been aruging with a ton of people in other people's comments saying they aren't culture appropriating. Bullsh!t, in my opinion. Really sad to see Nature going down this way.
i have been silently supporting them ever since they debuted (allegro cantabile was a favorite of mine a couple years back), waited for almost 2 years for a comeback and we get this :/ n.CH Entertainment should've just bring back their cutesy concept or continued with the horror concept because people really loved their last comeback :(
don't you just love it when your culture is treated like a joke 😍😍 edit: don't even say they're spreading desi culture when it's not even theirs to spread in the first place.
I really hope Kpop stops this putting a show of other countries cultures as fun. No one's culture should be used as a prop and should not be disrespected.
I don't know if their company just hate them, or they just want to create controversy for more views and articles ....so sad, Nature is full of talented girls
@@percyjacksoncomingtodisney4453 They not angels but their def not at fault, the company's been mistreating them for a while. They're the the one who created this whole mess of an MV and blamed the girls for it. The girls revealed themselves that everything said in the mockumentary was directed by the production crew
Guys let's do something against it....guys respond ...let's do something against it . In Twitter let's start something ....we should react to it soon ...this should stop
the people in the comments?? if you are not desi you have no right to speak over us. if you are desi and you don't find this offensive then sure it's your opinion but you cannot stand for all of us, just because one person is okay with it doesn't mean the rest of us are. this is not 'appreciating the culture' because they are using stereotypical moves and misusing the chandan bindi so it is ca. i really hope the girls and the company will understand what they're doing is wrong
@@amritasingh3308 Then later during a Q and A it was revealed by the girls themselves that the things they said in the mockumentry were directed by the production crew
I clicked on it because of the thumbnail... She's wearing a Bindi. I'm an indian and in India Women wear Bindi not for aesthetic but for culture and religious purpose. It indicates their marriage (mostly), and them being the new Guardian of their husband's family. Bindi is highly respected in India and idk why nowadays there's an obsession over Bindi in K-pop.
That set is quite famous in Kpop industry: 1. Chungha PLAY 2. BUGABOO BUGABOO And now, 3. Nature Rica Btw that teaser is amazing it already stuck in my head
I was waiting for someone to make it clear (for me personally) whether its cultural appropriation or not. Because I'm Russian and, honestly, don't know much about other cultures, so I was wondering if it's just my misunderstanding or not. 😅What I'm trying to say is Thank you ) Also, I'm really sad too. I was waiting for them for so long. And what I've got is another concept change, some members are missing and cultural appropriation on top of that
@@vani50 they turned it into a whole aesthetic. They have literal traditional bengali wedding makeup on. They also turned bindi as an accessory. Just to remind you it is a traditional sign of marriage in Hindu and a lot of other religions do wear it too.
This is just a theory that I have, but what if the company had all this planned since the beginning? Last month Nature's insta account was apparently hacked but in the end it was just a strategy to promote Nature's new show where the members were seen preparing for their comeback, then 'Rica Rica' is announced and this cultural apropiation scandal begins, and of course the ones who are going to be hated and criticized are the members since they themselves produced this right? What if this was all just another publicity stunt and the company made that show to highlight that the members did everything, like, "look they did all of this so blame them, not us" but maybe the concept and aesthetic were already prepared in advance? We all already know how far kpop companies can go and N.ch looked pretty fishy the moment the insta account thing happened, also remember this is not the actual comeback but a pre-release, and this company lost their other group 'TOO' so now they are desperate for their only group 'Nature' to get some attention, and it's working, I mean look at the views, none of Nature's teasers had this many views and likes, and you know, evil promotion is still promotion.
Wait.... did TOO disband??? And yeah I had the same thought on this being a publicity stunt. If that really is the case, it's sad that they felt they had to resort to this.
First comeback with them only to see them doing CA by literally using traditional bengali bridal makeup for their music 💀 wtf are the girls and their company thinking edit: Also one of the members was wearing a mangalsutra which just added salt to the wound
omg what is this.. they were gone for more than a year, people thought they were disbanding and this is how they are coming back.. people are gonna tear them down😭😭 i feel so bad for the girls and the company should be ashamed of themselves
this song is literally mocking indian/desi culture 😐 yall come back after a year hiatus w this shit istg … to the members : educate yourself on cultural appropriation bc y’all r literally doing it 😭
Not an Indian but seriously KPOP IDOLS and their respective companies should atleast be educated about cultures and it is not appropriate to use it as an aesthetic. A lot of kpop idols are already called out because of the same matter. Does it really hard to respect a culture? Why not pick up some concepts that is not related to cultures? As I said above, I am not an Indian. I'm an Asian.
@KARMA are you Indian? If you are then educated yourself about the culture and traditions and if you're not Indian then you need to shut your mouth :) Do you even know what the bindi means to Indian women? Bengali women wear it on their Wedding day and it's not an accessory that you can randomly put in your video
@KARMA have you heard paint the town by Loona? It has Indian beats that every bollywood movie has so it wasn't cultural appropriation cuz it didn't show anything offensive to our culture. The bindi and chandan these girls are wearing has a very big value And yes you aren't even Indian so you don't have any right to speak on this, go back to dancing
@@user-xy1hu5pv8q bruh what about Bollywood item songs they also wear bindi and all isn't that "cultural appropriation" and bindi is so common in India ok anybody wears it even if they are not married
this is clearly not an appreciation of desi culture, our people love it when people try out things from our culture, and genuinely show interest in it. This isn’t appreciation, it’s appropriation. Someone at this company decided to watch a few desi videos and decided to make a concept out of it. Let me give you an example to put it in perspective for whoever is still having difficulty comprehending this (and thats okay). It’s like someone from India, makes a music video with korean elements in it, makes an outfit from koreans traditional clothing, imitates a few korean traditional dance steps and there you go, they call it an aesthetic. Notice how offensive that is? If not offensive, it’s still culturally insensitive. We are so tired. And I think there’s another parallel to be drawn here, it’s even more problematic when someone picks out the parts of the culture that they personally like, and paint it as “appreciation” while they don’t acknowledge the history, and don’t respect other parts of the culture. Here’s an example, Korea loves cornrows. (What they call as raggae hair) but at the time are blatantly racist towards black people. (Before someone says not everyone, I know, I know. But most, enough to make it a problem.) People can’t pick and choose from a culture. Period. If you’re not an Indian, you have no rights to call out an Indian on being offended by this. If you’re an Indian, and this hurt you. I’m so sorry. If it doesn’t affect you, cool, sit down and don’t speak for other Indians. {plz shut up if ur not indian, thanks}
Pls fire whoever came up with this whole concept 😭💀 this is clearly not an appreciation of desi culture, our people love it when others try out things or show genuine interest in our culture. BUT this isn’t appreciation, it’s appropriation. Someone at this company decided to watch a few desi videos and decided to make a concept out of it. Let me give an example to put it in perspective for whoever is still having difficulty comprehending this (and thats okay). It’s like someone from India, makes a music video with korean elements in it, makes an outfit from korea's sacred traditional clothing, imitates a few korean traditional dance steps and there you go, they call it an aesthetic. (Imagine an Indian pop artist wearing a Hanbok with korean folk song going loud in the pre chorus) Notice how offensive that is? If not offensive, it’s still culturally insensitive. We are so tired. And I think there’s another parallel to be drawn here, it’s even more problematic when someone picks out parts of a culture, they personally like, and paint it as “appreciation” while they don’t acknowledge the history, and don’t respect other parts of the same culture. Here’s an example, Korea loves cornrows. (What they call as "raggae hair") but at the time are blatantly racist towards black people. (Before someone says not everyone, I know, I know. But most, enough to make it a problem.) People can’t pick and choose from a culture. Period. The whole argument of people should share cultures and celebrate each other's history is right, of course that's what made the world what it is today. But this isn't sharing a culture folks, this is mockery. You want to share cultures? Cool, learn about them, learn to respect them, take time to understand them, credit them, and appreciate them. If you're telling me wearing bindis on your forehead without knowing the actual meaning of it, just because they looked like "cute little aesthetic dots" is appreciation and sharing for you. My friend, I have some bad news for you. You failed your history class back in school. If you’re not an Indian, you have no rights to call out an Indian for being offended by this. If you’re an Indian, and this did hurt you. I’m so sorry. If it doesn’t affect you or you don't think it's offensive, you're allowed to make a judgement for yourself, cool, now sit down and don’t speak for other Indians. *Edit: there's a comment under this that carefully describes where the influences have been taken from, if you'd like to educate yourself, read it :)
It's like doing a bollywood item song in hanbok is it ok?no right pls when do they realise it. Even the dance moves ,the makeup pls everything is weird and kinda offensive and no one is blaming these girls for it they are just doing what there company is saying....there company should have proper info. Before trying any diff concept even Bollywood doesnt make it look weird and if ppl see anything offensive then they do raise the issue like happened with ghoomar song.
They themselves came up with it which absolutely makes it worse Also you said it perfectly. If non desis read this and still think we're overreacting, the n I dont even know
I'm Indian, I don't see any problem with it, can't y'all take a thing easily?? You did not even listen to the whole song and commenting.. and I think it has more latin vibes especially the background
@@yellow_rose5966 dude that's wht I'm saying if ppl feel smthng offensive then they call it out in bolly movies too OKAY and as an indian u cant just mock our culture like that. I'm indian firstt and dont judge by teaser what .the teaser it itself offensive .call any non kpop fan they can also tell it .wht is the need to use bindi ,chandan for aesthetics. They always produce music without getting enough information and we ignore it that's why they keep on doing itt .
It is surprising how there are still people who doesn't see what is wrong here... Es sorprendente como aún hay personas que no ven lo q está mal aquí...
i found out girls by them 2 days ago and got this in recommendation now.....i think this concept will cause them trouble for ca.... edit: they're definitely getting in trouble like adding chandan too ??!!!! you've gotta be kidding me
@@mischeuif you can see in the vdo that the girls are wearing bindi and kumkum on thier forehead which is an important thing in our hindu culture which here they are using it as aesthetic purposes..and these annoyingly hand gestures.. it just sucks man how they mock it..
I hope someone notices and speaks about it too but being from Desi culture, the cultural appropriation can't be unnoticed. I don't know why the companies don't educate them about these topics before using it. Desi culture isn't an aesthetic.
it’s the fact that the top comments are ignoring how wrong this is. some of you are even saying that it’s only makeup and it’s only outfits. wtf is wrong with yall?
@Martha Lopez I'm also extremely qualified to speak on my culture considering i have practiced bharanatymn for the past 10 years. Also me being a devote hindu who indulges in numerous cultural things like carnatic music, classical dance and temple works for said culture. My name is literally aaruthi
This is literally so raging for me- can't u see the cultural disrespect? for the misunderstanding : I'm talking about the "concept"(MY CULTURE IS NOT YOUR CONCEPT.) and the fact that people are anticipating for it instead telling than to stop as it is disrespectful and degrading.
@@kyooxoxo literally. The namaste, bindi, necklace (I'm not saying they shouldn't wear necklace but my grandma has those kinds of necklaces and considering the bindi and all we can easily say they tried to make it look Indian and all)
@@naegabyeonhae7061 they shouldn't wear indian jewelry and bengali chandan. They're being ignoraaaaaaant it's like they dgaf but they know what they're doing. They're grown up
Nature, im happy for y’all but plz listen to the Indian community if they’ve got something to say about your comeback. NCH, you listen too! To the Indian or ppl of that culture, you have every right to speak on it and no one else. They’re not allowed to have a say and/or invalidate you.
@@maryak4658 it’s just simple human decency. I don’t want to and should not disrespect other ppl just like I don’t want ppl to disrespect me. I’m sorry for this atrocity continuing to happen and I hope the kpop industry will stop and listen.
@@keira120 yes I know they participated but it's the way their company also allowed this to happen. Also it's not like the girls did EVERYTHING from the concept, to the song and make up.
Wtf I'm indian and im furious how casually they just appropriated our culture The bindi, bengali style makeup, namaste dance, the backtrack wtf Loona atleast did it respectively and credited our culture but they just came out with it thinking they did sth Cancel them I'm not tolerating this mockery of my culture
@@maryak4658 first of all, it's satire. the emojis are used IRONICALLY. second of all, yes they are cultural appropriating so i as a desi person have the whole right to hold them accountable.
@@aanzwiee haha I'm Muslim too but I'm Bengali and I assume she's the same! So we obviously understand this. It makes me upset that they're using Hindi Bengali culture as an aesthetic :(
wait isn't it look like bengali (indian) bridal make up? that chandan face art above the eyebrows with the bindi and indian jewellery? am i glitching or they really appeared in an indian bridal aesthetic?
So I heard the members themselves were creatively involved with the concept, song & styling. That just makes this situation even worse. Honestly i don't understand why the kpop industry is so attracted to appropriating other cultures. Korea itself has a very rich culture so why do these idols not use their own culture in the pop industry and show the intl fans the attraction of k-culture? But no they like to take stuff from the west or other asian countries who's cultures they have no knowledge over and use that in an ignorant way that makes it look like you're mocking it. Sighs
Actually they weren't, the company created this mv for more attention and just slapped the girls names on it. Poor girls got all the backlash as the company gained profit
@@Fred-sb8ed one of the girls said rika is Africa, so even if the Mv is by the company, some of the stuff that happened during this comeback was problematic, they have also mocked desi people before.
@@faeriiekoo That was said in the mockumentry which was directed by the production team. The girls aren't complete angels but they shouldn't be blamed for the creation of this mv or the cultural appropriation
Buddhism is very majorly practised in Korea and honestly, I think unless they actually wear something except for a bindi which transcends across South Asian countries-and the new borders dividing India and other countries is considerably new. However, I hope the lyrics aren’t problematic. They are already treading over a very dangerous boundary; and there’s a fine line between inspiration/ appreciation vs appropriation. I really wish they hadn’t taken up this concept though. People are going to be so enormously divided over this situation.
WOW!!! I'M SO EXCITED FOR THEIR COMEBACK. I've been missing them so much. It's just a teaser but it's already a bop. I hope people will recognize them more. Nature is a talented group y'all should stop sleeping in them.
this is obviously disrespectful. and obvious cultural appropriation. but i hope we can all remember that this is their MANAGEMENT'S fault, not the girls'.
Видеоклипы
![[MV] MOONBYUL(문별) _ LUNATIC](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/flhLfIK8nkw/mqdefault.jpg)
they edited out the bindi from the thunbnail ^^ they are listening
*we love our desi queens* 🥺
Yes we do 😩😩
Nature?more like prakiti
@@moonlightxlilac PLSSSSS
@@moonlightxlilac PRAKITI HELPPPP
the ca is this teaser is just enough
If these girls had come up with another horror concept mv, their popularity would've skyrocketed..but the company has definitely some other plans in their mind😔
This will get them a pak
@@Theminerboydiamonds literally Perfect All Kill... to their career
Imagine this being a group you love so much and then you wake up to their return being ca 😬
Wait people are saying that there’s CA in the teaser, but many other groups have had dances inspired by different cultures how is this different/g
@@suler642 it’s different because they’re wearing jewelry from my culture which is only meant to be worn by people from a certain few countries (India, Pakistan, Bangladesh), plus correct me if i’m wrong but they’re also using stereotypical mocking as a choreography, and also using my culture as an aesthetic
@@suler642 also one of the girls is wearing a red bindi with white dots on top of her eyebrows which is a look traditionally worn by brides in Hindu wedding ceremonies and holds religious significance. I am so so disappointed
@@delialastly58 correction BENGALI HINDU BRIDES
Exactly
they slayed the horror concept and then come out with this….
went from horror to ca 😟
Exactly 😐
ca is also scary i guess
@@seokrijn7916 exactly 😕
@@ritikaggarwal5558 STOP 😭
We were all rooting for you and you’re giving us this concept.,
It doesnt sound good :/
@@modderbad everything doesn’t look good lmao
@@richardmatthew7901 too
Exactly.
Half of the comments don't see uwts wrong-
Cultural appropriation ain't cute. I don't understand why it's so hard for them to get that
They went from horror concept queens to cultural appropriation queens we love to see the glow down !
lol 😭
Indian here. The mockery is real
@@Monalisa-lf4iv bengali here I dont see them mocking my culture
@@taetaeismylove9838 idk how but I think one who is not an indian shouldn't appreciate or use our costumes in any kinda aesthetic without knowing their real meaning. Even if you're Bengali and you don't think they are culture appropriating it but I think they are. Korean idol has always been doing these mockery things to other cultures. So they shouldn't wear anything that's related to our culture.
@@Monalisa-lf4iv Ehh, don't bother educating them. They've been aruging with a ton of people in other people's comments saying they aren't culture appropriating. Bullsh!t, in my opinion. Really sad to see Nature going down this way.
We stan our desi queens 😍🥰🤩🤪‼️
what's up with the non indians/non bengalis saying it's not CA? last time i checked, outsiders don't get to gatekeep OUR culture and heritage.
Ikrr!!
frrrrr i saw so many non indians
cant believe we waited so long for y’all to come up with this😭
i have been silently supporting them ever since they debuted (allegro cantabile was a favorite of mine a couple years back), waited for almost 2 years for a comeback and we get this :/ n.CH Entertainment should've just bring back their cutesy concept or continued with the horror concept because people really loved their last comeback :(
Sadly 'Girls' flopped in Korea :(
i was rooting for u, we were ALL rooting for u 💀
But they did dirty to us :')
don't you just love it when your culture is treated like a joke 😍😍
edit: don't even say they're spreading desi culture when it's not even theirs to spread in the first place.
im so sorry bestie its so fcked up :(
exactly and who though this was a good idea.
Ikr :-!
I'm sorry, but why is this bad? I don't really know, isn't it better that Indian culture is spreading through kpop music? I don't understand :(
@@benjiAAP it’s mockery of desi culture. instead of appreciating the culture they’re clearly mocking it and using it as an aesthetic plus a concept..
HELP THE BINDIS
as an indian idc but idk about others-
what happened to the horror concept I loved Girls and its still in my playlist😭
nah cuz theyr old songs are good but this..
Oh no.... They're done for 🥲
omg i LOVE culture inappropriation...as if we couldnt hv enough of the curry song:")
right idk why ppl are hyping this up when it’s extremely offensive .. THE BINDI??
I really hope Kpop stops this putting a show of other countries cultures as fun. No one's culture should be used as a prop and should not be disrespected.
Exactly even I was thinking the same thing
Exactly
DONT YOU JUST LOVE TO SEE YOUR CULTURE GET APPROPRIATEED & GET USED AS AN AESTHETIC!!😍😍😍😍 Like girls come on its 2022
Stfu it's a disrespect!!!
@@rudranighosh2265 it's sarcasm -genius-
Quit whining. Man, I hate how even the silly parts of American culture have spread around the world.
I don't know if their company just hate them, or they just want to create controversy for more views and articles ....so sad, Nature is full of talented girls
They helped produce this so it’s not just their company.
@@scoupslawyer the company gave them this concept
@@Bambabababambam ?? but the girls worked on it as well. hold them accountable too ur idols are not angels lmao
Only a few people are whining about.
@@percyjacksoncomingtodisney4453 They not angels but their def not at fault, the company's been mistreating them for a while. They're the the one who created this whole mess of an MV and blamed the girls for it. The girls revealed themselves that everything said in the mockumentary was directed by the production crew
As an Indian..
Hope..
It *doesn't* gets under *Culture inappropriation tag..*
it will
I think it will
This will I can already say this after seeing the makeup on that black haired girl from the thumbnail
As a Indian that bindi ain't it.
Yeahhhh I am gonna be so conflicted cuz from this teaser its gonna be a bop, but will also be hella problematic 😬😬
yall just gonna ignore the CA in this video?
Desi K-pop fans can NEVER get a break... We're in 2022 I know all these idols know about our culture but still use it as damn aesthetic.
Ikr
EXACTLY
*company
Yes.
Guys let's do something against it....guys respond ...let's do something against it . In Twitter let's start something ....we should react to it soon ...this should stop
the choreographer really came up with this and thought it was okay-
From what I read they (the members) helped on the choreo...
Even the bindi , the CA bruhhh I'm done with kpop groups playing around with ca as aesthetics.
It is ok.
@@hannieshingibbangi quit whining
@@souljaboyisbad it’s not
is it that hard to not appropriate a culture for a successful comeback
true , they dont learn lessons from their senior idols being called out for the same stuff.
FRRR
IKRR
Bcz they dont have anything else to get into notice
Literally man like 75%of the comments here don't even know what's happening
Now imagine this as a teaser of some most popular girl groups. The CA controversy would be so big and the girls would get so much hate.
Most popular groups tbh cuz nct has been dragged too
If kpop girls are not going to go full bollywood with these things then they should just leave it to the desi girls...
the people in the comments?? if you are not desi you have no right to speak over us. if you are desi and you don't find this offensive then sure it's your opinion but you cannot stand for all of us, just because one person is okay with it doesn't mean the rest of us are. this is not 'appreciating the culture' because they are using stereotypical moves and misusing the chandan bindi so it is ca. i really hope the girls and the company will understand what they're doing is wrong
^^^^
DON'T DEFEND THE COMPANY, they know they'll get controversial and it def for clout
It was the girls ideas and production so not only company but girls too should hold accountable
@@sanhwacat4397 how u know its theires
@@sanhwacat4397 it wasnt their ideas, they were given this concept and choreographed parts of the choreo u can see it in the mockumentary
@@Bambabababambam um yes it is they said it themselves
@@amritasingh3308 Then later during a Q and A it was revealed by the girls themselves that the things they said in the mockumentry were directed by the production crew
I clicked on it because of the thumbnail... She's wearing a Bindi. I'm an indian and in India Women wear Bindi not for aesthetic but for culture and religious purpose. It indicates their marriage (mostly), and them being the new Guardian of their husband's family. Bindi is highly respected in India and idk why nowadays there's an obsession over Bindi in K-pop.
One of them is also wearing bengali bridal makeup
@@partypartyyeah4694 uhh... Messed up
me too :(
Ya me too
the ones making the cultural appropriation comment should do something then, cheers
Yasss CA queens😍
Omg!! Culturally appropriating!! My fav thing everrrrr!
stan ignorance!!! SLAYY !!!!
That set is quite famous in Kpop industry:
1. Chungha PLAY
2. BUGABOO BUGABOO
And now,
3. Nature Rica
Btw that teaser is amazing it already stuck in my head
I think tri be also rum a dum
Tri.be rub a dum too
Tri.be Rub-a-dum too
@@Se7enK. but I think the set in rub a dum is slightly different 🤔
I think dumdi dumdi too
my indian didis 😋🥰🙈
Lmaooo
HELP 😭
HHELPPP
DYING 😭😭
😭..
Nature I didn't expect this from you..
I waited a year for a comeback just to see them appropriate my culture 😟
I was waiting for someone to make it clear (for me personally) whether its cultural appropriation or not. Because I'm Russian and, honestly, don't know much about other cultures, so I was wondering if it's just my misunderstanding or not. 😅What I'm trying to say is Thank you )
Also, I'm really sad too. I was waiting for them for so long. And what I've got is another concept change, some members are missing and cultural appropriation on top of that
@@vani50 You should go learn what is cultural appropriation
@@vani50 are you desi/indian? if not you can't say if it's mocking or not only they can so kindly stfu
@@vani50 they turned it into a whole aesthetic. They have literal traditional bengali wedding makeup on.
They also turned bindi as an accessory.
Just to remind you it is a traditional sign of marriage in Hindu and a lot of other religions do wear it too.
Same
This is just a theory that I have, but what if the company had all this planned since the beginning? Last month Nature's insta account was apparently hacked but in the end it was just a strategy to promote Nature's new show where the members were seen preparing for their comeback, then 'Rica Rica' is announced and this cultural apropiation scandal begins, and of course the ones who are going to be hated and criticized are the members since they themselves produced this right? What if this was all just another publicity stunt and the company made that show to highlight that the members did everything, like, "look they did all of this so blame them, not us" but maybe the concept and aesthetic were already prepared in advance? We all already know how far kpop companies can go and N.ch looked pretty fishy the moment the insta account thing happened, also remember this is not the actual comeback but a pre-release, and this company lost their other group 'TOO' so now they are desperate for their only group 'Nature' to get some attention, and it's working, I mean look at the views, none of Nature's teasers had this many views and likes, and you know, evil promotion is still promotion.
i agreeeeeeee bad attention is still attention
Wait.... did TOO disband??? And yeah I had the same thought on this being a publicity stunt. If that really is the case, it's sad that they felt they had to resort to this.
@@heykaylc23 No, but they left this company and re-debuted as TO1
They're Koreans. They probably don't know silly western ideas.
First comeback with them only to see them doing CA by literally using traditional bengali bridal makeup for their music 💀 wtf are the girls and their company thinking
edit: Also one of the members was wearing a mangalsutra which just added salt to the wound
they are coming back with a CA comeback 🤩🤩💀
@@onceatiny5738 are u blind? they're actually wearing bindis and that's not CA for u?💀
@@onceatiny5738 then what is it
@@onceatiny5738 if you don't see this as a CA, you don't know what CA is.
@@user_blacktea Jennie got hate for wearing Bindi. These girls deserve hate too. Right?
@@m11nt lol I'm not saying we should hate the girls 💀💀
is the company tryna gain them popularity by controversies- please no wtf💀
omg what is this.. they were gone for more than a year, people thought they were disbanding and this is how they are coming back.. people are gonna tear them down😭😭 i feel so bad for the girls and the company should be ashamed of themselves
When they get a PAK from this song then what
What are you whining about...Jesus christ. The Indians complaining don't represent all Indians.
this song is literally mocking indian/desi culture 😐 yall come back after a year hiatus w this shit istg … to the members : educate yourself on cultural appropriation bc y’all r literally doing it 😭
Ah yesss , someone said RAciSt rAcist🤡🤡🤡
desicore 😍
Stop appropriating desi cultures this is specifically bengali bridal eye makeup
잘됐으면 좋겠어서 보러온건데 안 망하고 싶은 거 맞음...? 내 미감이 이상한 거라고 믿고싶다. 파이팅..
ㄹㅇ ㅠㅠ 여기 소속사는 감이 너무 없는듯….
요즘 트렌드는 아닌데 kpop 홍수에서는 차라리 이런게 먹히지 않을까 싶네요.
빤한컨셉이 아니여서 좋긴한데
이게 먹힐까... 약간 크레용팝 같은 느낌이...
트로트쪽으로 가려나
NATURE is back!!!
@@pihoo9966 k, sjw
The outfit looks like MOMOLAND Yummy yumm love OT7 Version ahahah
pihoo U obviously are not educated on ca. At all. Or kpop in general. Even if it was ca they have no control over anything they put out. But go off ig
Hey you:) Glad you have a good taste in music.
@@Formoftherapy. A bit, yeah😂
The make up the jewellery gives indian vibe😍😍😍
Not an Indian but seriously KPOP IDOLS and their respective companies should atleast be educated about cultures and it is not appropriate to use it as an aesthetic. A lot of kpop idols are already called out because of the same matter. Does it really hard to respect a culture? Why not pick up some concepts that is not related to cultures?
As I said above, I am not an Indian. I'm an Asian.
Seriously, just stick to the horror concept or literally ANY other concept! CA is a serious matter, it isn't hard at all to just ignore it!
@KARMA are you Indian? If you are then educated yourself about the culture and traditions and if you're not Indian then you need to shut your mouth :)
Do you even know what the bindi means to Indian women? Bengali women wear it on their Wedding day and it's not an accessory that you can randomly put in your video
@KARMA have you heard paint the town by Loona? It has Indian beats that every bollywood movie has so it wasn't cultural appropriation cuz it didn't show anything offensive to our culture. The bindi and chandan these girls are wearing has a very big value
And yes you aren't even Indian so you don't have any right to speak on this, go back to dancing
@@user-xy1hu5pv8q bruh what about Bollywood item songs they also wear bindi and all isn't that "cultural appropriation" and bindi is so common in India ok anybody wears it even if they are not married
this is clearly not an appreciation of desi culture, our people love it when people try out things from our culture, and genuinely show interest in it. This isn’t appreciation, it’s appropriation. Someone at this company decided to watch a few desi videos and decided to make a concept out of it. Let me give you an example to put it in perspective for whoever is still having difficulty comprehending this (and thats okay). It’s like someone from India, makes a music video with korean elements in it, makes an outfit from koreans traditional clothing, imitates a few korean traditional dance steps and there you go, they call it an aesthetic. Notice how offensive that is? If not offensive, it’s still culturally insensitive. We are so tired.
And I think there’s another parallel to be drawn here, it’s even more problematic when someone picks out the parts of the culture that they personally like, and paint it as “appreciation” while they don’t acknowledge the history, and don’t respect other parts of the culture. Here’s an example, Korea loves cornrows. (What they call as raggae hair) but at the time are blatantly racist towards black people. (Before someone says not everyone, I know, I know. But most, enough to make it a problem.)
People can’t pick and choose from a culture. Period.
If you’re not an Indian, you have no rights to call out an Indian on being offended by this.
If you’re an Indian, and this hurt you. I’m so sorry.
If it doesn’t affect you, cool, sit down and don’t speak for other Indians. {plz shut up if ur not indian, thanks}
i'm honestly scared for this girls...
WTF THE BINDIS-????????
no pls this is so wrong, this is a clear example of cultural appropriation, i can't believe their company considered the idea to make this concept
loona mocked the indian culture with PTT. hypocrite!
@@nwjns_lesserafim_gidle they didn’t mock babe… they literally PUT AND SAID THAT THEY WERE INSPIRED BY BOLLYWOOD MUSIC… INSPIREDDDDDDDDD
@@nwjns_lesserafim_gidle hypocrite lol
Thts called culture appreciation 😊😊
The girls had a voice in this comeback so it’s not just the company to blame.
@@nwjns_lesserafim_gidle Lol who said i stan loona?
Pls fire whoever came up with this whole concept 😭💀 this is clearly not an appreciation of desi culture, our people love it when others try out things or show genuine interest in our culture. BUT this isn’t appreciation, it’s appropriation. Someone at this company decided to watch a few desi videos and decided to make a concept out of it. Let me give an example to put it in perspective for whoever is still having difficulty comprehending this (and thats okay). It’s like someone from India, makes a music video with korean elements in it, makes an outfit from korea's sacred traditional clothing, imitates a few korean traditional dance steps and there you go, they call it an aesthetic. (Imagine an Indian pop artist wearing a Hanbok with korean folk song going loud in the pre chorus) Notice how offensive that is? If not offensive, it’s still culturally insensitive. We are so tired.
And I think there’s another parallel to be drawn here, it’s even more problematic when someone picks out parts of a culture, they personally like, and paint it as “appreciation” while they don’t acknowledge the history, and don’t respect other parts of the same culture. Here’s an example, Korea loves cornrows. (What they call as "raggae hair") but at the time are blatantly racist towards black people. (Before someone says not everyone, I know, I know. But most, enough to make it a problem.)
People can’t pick and choose from a culture. Period.
The whole argument of people should share cultures and celebrate each other's history is right, of course that's what made the world what it is today. But this isn't sharing a culture folks, this is mockery. You want to share cultures? Cool, learn about them, learn to respect them, take time to understand them, credit them, and appreciate them. If you're telling me wearing bindis on your forehead without knowing the actual meaning of it, just because they looked like "cute little aesthetic dots" is appreciation and sharing for you. My friend, I have some bad news for you. You failed your history class back in school.
If you’re not an Indian, you have no rights to call out an Indian for being offended by this.
If you’re an Indian, and this did hurt you. I’m so sorry.
If it doesn’t affect you or you don't think it's offensive, you're allowed to make a judgement for yourself, cool, now sit down and don’t speak for other Indians.
*Edit: there's a comment under this that carefully describes where the influences have been taken from, if you'd like to educate yourself, read it :)
period someone had to say it
It's like doing a bollywood item song in hanbok is it ok?no right pls when do they realise it. Even the dance moves ,the makeup pls everything is weird and kinda offensive and no one is blaming these girls for it they are just doing what there company is saying....there company should have proper info. Before trying any diff concept even Bollywood doesnt make it look weird and if ppl see anything offensive then they do raise the issue like happened with ghoomar song.
They themselves came up with it which absolutely makes it worse
Also you said it perfectly. If non desis read this and still think we're overreacting, the n I dont even know
I'm Indian, I don't see any problem with it, can't y'all take a thing easily?? You did not even listen to the whole song and commenting.. and I think it has more latin vibes especially the background
@@yellow_rose5966 dude that's wht I'm saying if ppl feel smthng offensive then they call it out in bolly movies too OKAY and as an indian u cant just mock our culture like that. I'm indian firstt and dont judge by teaser what .the teaser it itself offensive .call any non kpop fan they can also tell it .wht is the need to use bindi ,chandan for aesthetics. They always produce music without getting enough information and we ignore it that's why they keep on doing itt .
why they gotta use the desi culture as an aesthetic man😭😭 this is coming from a desi btw 😺
yesss lets go another mockery of our culture woohoo 🥰🥰 kpop the land of CA
IKR they are obsessed with us 😻😻
Watching them first time ..... They are good
It is surprising how there are still people who doesn't see what is wrong here...
Es sorprendente como aún hay personas que no ven lo q está mal aquí...
Exactly.. people gone blind or something?
EXACTLY
and what exactly is wrong??
Exactly! I love how people are trying to gloss over what is blatantly wrong here
@@JJWhy Idk, probably doing ca with the choreogrpahy, using bindis and using a culture as an aesthetic?
i found out girls by them 2 days ago and got this in recommendation now.....i think this concept will cause them trouble for ca....
edit: they're definitely getting in trouble like adding chandan too ??!!!! you've gotta be kidding me
whoever let nature make this teaser is truly praying on their downfall
this is why they’re a nugu group
I was about to stan-
Haha
Wow, we will be having a comeback after a year hiatus 😭
@@KimJanet-ze5sq Que wea
@@KimJanet-ze5sq deja de molestar aquí con tu spam !!!
now you will be having a disbandment
@@zzzonline where
@@RyansGameplay201 they have literally cultural appropriation this time of desi
They deserve better
They were in on the concept and everything so we can’t defend the members either..
so you're telling me this is the same group who released the song 'I'm so pretty'??? WTF YAZZZZ
im sooooo excited for this official mv
I tought they were gonna comeback with another song like "Girls" but lets see.
Same here.
same
Nature WILL NOT stick to the same concept TWICE
@@AgustinaRD5 yes i Just didnt expect such a drastic change i am still positive even tho it might be disliked because of the cultural stuff.
This is just a pre-release
WE LOVE OUR CULTURE BEING USED AS A JOKE, LET'S GO, NATURE🤩🤩😍
Yess its too much now🙄
wait what did they do? pls explain
@@mischeuif you can see in the vdo that the girls are wearing bindi and kumkum on thier forehead which is an important thing in our hindu culture which here they are using it as aesthetic purposes..and these annoyingly hand gestures.. it just sucks man how they mock it..
EXACTLY.
Yess
K-pop will never leave Desis 🚶♀️
a bop is fkg coming
I hope someone notices and speaks about it too but being from Desi culture, the cultural appropriation can't be unnoticed. I don't know why the companies don't educate them about these topics before using it. Desi culture isn't an aesthetic.
I dunno man. It doesn't really matter to me.
it’s the fact that the top comments are ignoring how wrong this is. some of you are even saying that it’s only makeup and it’s only outfits. wtf is wrong with yall?
And we are thinking what wrong with you 😂
@@studydeepezly6303 yeah because ur clearly delusional 😂
@@studydeepezly6303 ur embarrassing
I’m proud to say that I never known who they are or Stan them 😍
yall know you can take inspiration from south asian culture without mocking it.
@Martha Lopez clearly you aren’t south Asian so how would you know when my culture is being appropriated :)
@Martha Lopez I'm also extremely qualified to speak on my culture considering i have practiced bharanatymn for the past 10 years. Also me being a devote hindu who indulges in numerous cultural things like carnatic music, classical dance and temple works for said culture. My name is literally aaruthi
Every member of NATURE is incredibly talented and soon the whole world will know it
R.I.P Reply section above ahahahah
This is literally so raging for me- can't u see the cultural disrespect?
for the misunderstanding : I'm talking about the "concept"(MY CULTURE IS NOT YOUR CONCEPT.) and the fact that people are anticipating for it instead telling than to stop as it is disrespectful and degrading.
Yeah for culture appropriating desi culture.
@@kyooxoxo literally. The namaste, bindi, necklace (I'm not saying they shouldn't wear necklace but my grandma has those kinds of necklaces and considering the bindi and all we can easily say they tried to make it look Indian and all)
@@naegabyeonhae7061 they shouldn't wear indian jewelry and bengali chandan. They're being ignoraaaaaaant it's like they dgaf but they know what they're doing. They're grown up
This is going to haunt them forever, the amount of hate they’re going to get soon lol 😂
it's interesting. rica rica is a type of chili sauce in my place and it's yummy i love it
if cultural appropriation is k-pop had a teaser, this would be it.
Omg my Bengali queens coming to slay 🥺🥺🥺😍😍😍🥰🥰
Nature, im happy for y’all but plz listen to the Indian community if they’ve got something to say about your comeback. NCH, you listen too! To the Indian or ppl of that culture, you have every right to speak on it and no one else. They’re not allowed to have a say and/or invalidate you.
Desi* not just indian
@@ishbel08 I apologize and thank you for letting me know
I'm from Pakistan but totally understand and thank you
@@maryak4658 it’s just simple human decency. I don’t want to and should not disrespect other ppl just like I don’t want ppl to disrespect me. I’m sorry for this atrocity continuing to happen and I hope the kpop industry will stop and listen.
Plenty of Indian people don't care.
it's literally 2022 and the kpop industry still hasn't learned that they shouldn't be using ca for attention
Fr
Oh they're asking for it at this point 😭😭😭
the girls are finally having a comeback and this is happens??? whoever did the choreo and their stylist definitely hate the girls
they did it themselves, theres a mockumentary on youtube of them doing everything
@@keira120 yes I know they participated but it's the way their company also allowed this to happen. Also it's not like the girls did EVERYTHING from the concept, to the song and make up.
@@keira120 im sure they helped but I doubt they did everything but who knows if they genuinely knew what was wrong or not
its a self-made project they did it themselves.
Wait, crazy difference between twitter and YT... people are roasting them for Indian cultural appropriation there, but not here...? Strange
u look at the recent comments, a lot of us are mad....
@@kpop__whistler7734 yeah i did see that, but the top comments are all positive...
Wtf
I'm indian and im furious how casually they just appropriated our culture
The bindi, bengali style makeup, namaste dance, the backtrack wtf
Loona atleast did it respectively and credited our culture but they just came out with it thinking they did sth
Cancel them I'm not tolerating this mockery of my culture
"Cancel them" LMAOO
YES CULTURAL APPROPRIATION LETS GO🎉🎉😍🙏🏻
**no need to invalidate my opinion with what u think unless u are actually a Desi person. specially a hindu:]**
you need help.
@@maryak4658 it's satire
It's the top comment yas
@@maryak4658 first of all, it's satire. the emojis are used IRONICALLY. second of all, yes they are cultural appropriating so i as a desi person have the whole right to hold them accountable.
The music, the makeup, the jewelry everything looks Indian. I really hope they don't mess it up much 😔
I DONT LIKE THEM WEARING A BINDI AS AN AESTHETIC THAT TOO RED ONE IM UPSET
@@aanzwiee Same. It pisses me off.
@@aminahussain8690 I assume you're a Muslim, but you're still understanding the problem, ty cutie
@@aanzwiee haha I'm Muslim too but I'm Bengali and I assume she's the same! So we obviously understand this. It makes me upset that they're using Hindi Bengali culture as an aesthetic :(
@@tahiti1264 yeah like educating them won't be enough now literally this happens too often and they're grown up
wait isn't it look like bengali (indian) bridal make up?
that chandan face art above the eyebrows with the bindi and indian jewellery? am i glitching or they really appeared in an indian bridal aesthetic?
Yeah it's bengali bridal makeup. They mixed up bengali and indian culture together into an aesthetic. Smh
Yea it is 😐
OUR BROWN QUEENS !!!
So I heard the members themselves were creatively involved with the concept, song & styling. That just makes this situation even worse. Honestly i don't understand why the kpop industry is so attracted to appropriating other cultures. Korea itself has a very rich culture so why do these idols not use their own culture in the pop industry and show the intl fans the attraction of k-culture? But no they like to take stuff from the west or other asian countries who's cultures they have no knowledge over and use that in an ignorant way that makes it look like you're mocking it. Sighs
literally who gaf
@@taytay7414 ur mom
Actually they weren't, the company created this mv for more attention and just slapped the girls names on it. Poor girls got all the backlash as the company gained profit
@@Fred-sb8ed one of the girls said rika is Africa, so even if the Mv is by the company, some of the stuff that happened during this comeback was problematic, they have also mocked desi people before.
@@faeriiekoo That was said in the mockumentry which was directed by the production team. The girls aren't complete angels but they shouldn't be blamed for the creation of this mv or the cultural appropriation
so the girls are wearing bindis. that is the only reason I clicked on this video, to see if they are appropriating and my fears coming true it seems.
Same
Same
It isnt religious tho and ofc in kpop everyone jumps for every little thing... While in western world they embrace culture with it
drama
@@gosponante2199 its insensitive
Buddhism is very majorly practised in Korea and honestly, I think unless they actually wear something except for a bindi which transcends across South Asian countries-and the new borders dividing India and other countries is considerably new. However, I hope the lyrics aren’t problematic. They are already treading over a very dangerous boundary; and there’s a fine line between inspiration/ appreciation vs appropriation.
I really wish they hadn’t taken up this concept though. People are going to be so enormously divided over this situation.
This gives me big T-ARA Yayaya vibes and I love that! I’m so excited for this comeback, I hope they do well!
Yessss waiting for NATURE
Another day of some kpop group Approriatiing our culture imagine how tired we are at this point.
WE WE'RE ROOTING FOR YOU WE WE'RE ALL ROOTING FOR YOU HOW DARE YOU
WOW!!! I'M SO EXCITED FOR THEIR COMEBACK. I've been missing them so much. It's just a teaser but it's already a bop. I hope people will recognize them more. Nature is a talented group y'all should stop sleeping in them.
ive never been this excited
Not a bindi omg.. they're gonna get so much hate 😭
Not just any bindi💀 the bridal type seeing from the thumbnail
@@goreizz ikr😭
this is obviously disrespectful.
and obvious cultural appropriation.
but i hope we can all remember that this is their MANAGEMENT'S fault, not the girls'.
the girls helped produce the song / dance, dont defend them.
They helped produce this, it’s tjeir fault as well
@@vivi-eq6ip i wasn't aware of this! thank you for bringing this to light.
@@scoupslawyer i wasn't aware thank you for letting me know!!
I'm getting loona paint the town vibes, this is gonna be lit 🔥
hmmm, are you all thinking what I’m thinking?