Hii here r the translations for all the Arabic text in this :) 2:54 - the book says "quantum theory" 3:54 - is a series of assorted AI-generated phrases all layered over each other so they can be a bit hard to discern, but of those phrases are the following: "Forgive me for all my sins In the real world In the Dream world In A dream Of becoming human again" "You can still be me The sky's colored in hope Though it's a shame, it's not my color" "You gotta leave now, you gotta stay now, or we'll kill today" "My body isn't strong enough for this now that it's reality" "Why did you do it" A little after that is just the phrase "I'm afraid" over and over And at the Tamari section at 4:01 it's the following phrases: "I hate you" "I deserved better" "Why did you make me like this?" "My lord, save them from themselves" "My lord, save them from me" Thank u ghost for this epic opportunity :)) I love tamari and his sister mariyam with my whole heart and i LOVED getting to work on and write for this project And I'm very excited for what else is to come :-))
I can imagine Mariyam deciding to follow her sibling in the other world and see at least 18 Tamaris eating cold pasta with nothing on it while 20 others play with Doors or destroy themselves
AUGH love the contrast between mariyam's lines being written in rhyming verse and tamari's lines being in the same rhymeless ai style as reckless battery burns..... the humantype and the machinetype. so good
Looking up what Salpêtrière is, it seems to refer to a teaching hospital for mental health/brain related problems in France, although it was originally a gunpowder factory
According to further research, it took in women of any status no matter who they were and branded them as hysterical. I've heard about this practice in Europe of women being called hysterical simple because of normal body functions - such as periods - or because they were "outcasts" either unwanted or acting beyond the "norm" of society at the time to a degree that lead to imprisonment. Often wrongly, as you'd guess. La Salpêtrière was basically a prison, and according to an article I found, in the September Massacres of 1792, due to anger, fear, and mob mentality, those who had the intention of freeing the imprisoned women ended up dragging them into the streets and... severely unaliving them. Fun fact - "Salpêtrière" is "saltpeter" in English, which is potassium nitrate - a common ingredient found in gunpowder. They literally named the hospital after the fact that it was a gunpowder factory before.
@@lueroso1540 For accuracy's sake : "salpêtre" is "salpeter". "Salpêtrière" is "the place where you store salpeter". but otherwise you're right =p I think the choice of salpêtrière as a word here is probably to use both meaning. Like, the fact that abuse and not acknowledging someone's agenticity (I was going to say humanity but it's not accurate heree so that's the best word I could find) ends up creating more problems than the ones you're trying to avoid and causing violent reactions, like litterally "sitting on a powder keg".
And now for one going the other way, what's up with the Seinfeld jokes? You start from somewhere you know and then you unlearn it? Why? How? What's the point here, @@Laezar1?
As metal breaks and bends and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends this is such a fucking banger
i played this song to me dad when we were testing my computer music, he described the song as 'karl marx's hell' as the mechanical sounds at the start made him think of some industrial factory where russian workers are being tortured or something. 'no wonder you're so angry all the time, this is what you listen to'. so i hereby rename this song karl marx's hell.
I love how all of Marriyam’s lines rhyme and all of Tamari’s don’t! Like tamari’s the “black sheep” of perfect robotics world and like broke away from their mom thing person…… Meanwhile Marriyam was like goin along with it and like didn’t listen to Tamari for a while (2:21 Tamari trying to show their sister his views by giving them an eye) and at the end they choose to listen to Tamari and like break away like a swaggy pog champ beast
at 3:37 it feels like Fayrouz is saying that, not Mariyam , "The core of my design"- Fayrouz realizing that the mistake wasnt in Tamari, but in herself, "Your eyes look down at mine"-Mariyam is dissapointed at Fayrouz and therefore looking down at her, not the other way around, "It never truly ends"- If tamari wasnt the mistake, Fayrouz is, meaning she will continue to make AIs that run away from her, over and over again. idk im too obsessed with this that i might be making things up but idk
4:33 THIS FACE!! If holds SO MANY thoughts behind it, here are my favorite examples "What cookies, haven't seen any....." "GOD you breath stinks" "I don't know who you are, and you clearly think I'm someone else, but I'm too anxious to tell you that so I'm just gonna pretend I know what's going on with you and your ex." "DID I FORGET SOMETHING!!!!!" "OH NO........"
tamari with their wings at 4:11 looks like the cover character from those who carried on with the placement of the mechanical like limbs and spikes from the head
In the desc of the unfinished pv video ghost said the universe is about a contagious disease that causes people to decompose alive and fall apart. I immediately thought of the line "ignore the rottenness, and see your beautiful bewildered face" maybe the unuverse take place ages after the events of those who carried on??
Something small that I noticed, is at 1:44 before the paper with the roschach test is torn, the bangs at the top are Miriyams. But as the paper is shred, the bangs quickly change to Tamari's before Tamari is revealed behind it. Not sure what this means, but I thought I should mention it here !!
Maybe cause the sister lady is all proper and doing things as intended, while tamari is ballin ballin, doin their thang. Really gettin out there. Making things happen. Payin bills and climbin hills. You know them. They're doin it. Robo robo. Done and done. Really gotcha there. Who needs psychology tests? The weird mumma (maybe not mumma) doc is makin robots. Who cares if the robots go coocoo? It SEEMS like, like one robot is coocoo enough. Even said, "You're paper... is... dumb" Other robot, well, is chill. But I hope they come to they're not-senses soon and start ballin like my cutie cutie patooty tamari
I was watching live and it was such an experience getting to share a braincell with all the other chatters at 1:55 and 4:33 going "TAMARI!!!" and "SISTER??? SIBLINGS???"
once again i have fallen into the "ghost and pals song" rabbit hole. step one: listening to the song. not my jam. step two: listens a second time from curiosity. becomes obsessed. step three: becomes my main song for months until ghost posts another song.
OH MY GOD YES! It happens to me where I listen to a song from either Ghost or Vane and aren't sure if I like it or not, so I listen to it again and then love it! So this is very relatable.
seriously! why does the fuck does this keep happening to me!! i listen to their songs, dont like it at first, listen to it again just to give it another chance, i cannot stop myself from listening to it over and over again until i get sick of it. every time!!!!
Did anyone else notice at 4:47 "TA-MO2" seems to be a reference to Tamari from Reckless Battery Burns. At the end of that song the file "ta-mo1.exe" is dragged into the desktop trash. And the mc has those same little antenna as Tamari. I wonder how they're connected. . . Edit, I forgot to mention how this song dislocated my whole spine in the best way possible :)
@@veryrealhuman5471 cuormor actually said that the design IN RBB was a simplified version of their design, and Tamari looks more like this version in their reference art iirc
@@HamHamIsDeadInside Based on this idea, it seems the 'ta-mo2 reconnection failed' scene is when Mariyam ran away to join Tamari, and Fayrouz probably wants them to come back. Yeah I think Tamari is the older sibling.
@@IHaveNoIdea5555 same except I'm now fistfighting myself about taking inspo from this song. Like I came into this thinking I'd get some oc vibes but I was not expecting the "therapist robot is considered a failure by their creators and is now on their own while their company tries to figure out WTF to do about it" flavor of vibes. IMAGINE MY SHOCK-
I love this so much! I love the return of Tamari, I love how the whole world is shown in colour when Mariyam finally finds them, I love that none of Tamari's lines rhyme and they all have the same quality as Reckless Battery Burns' lyrics. It gives off the idea that Tamari has become so enlightened by the experiments done on them that being near them exposes reality but at the same time Mariyam cannot understand what they are saying because they've changed far too much. And at the end, Mariyam grieves Tamari but I suppose agrees to follow in their footsteps? I love this continuation, I hadn't expected it.
"if you wanna kill the world you should start by getting it backwards" is the rawest fucking lyric EVER and ive been thinking about it every day since this track came out like it goes so hard thank you for being a badass af artist ghost
@@ameladaptivedaydreamer949 No, this line was not AI-generated, all of the lyrics in this song were produced and written by GHOST themself. Reckless Battery Burns, the first song in the Qualia Automata series, is the only song the lyrics of which were BASED ON some results which GHOST got from an AI text generator (where, by the way, they put the lyrics of their own songs and some of their friends' songs with permission, the utilization of AI in this was completely ethical and with consent from all parties involved and did not involve any type of art theft).
"Dad, why is my sister named Rose?" "Because your mother loves roses." "Oh, thanks Dad" "No problem Solaria, Kevin / End-World Normopathy [Original Song Collaboration]"
i think the color changing is a metaphor for the main character leaving the head of the lab to find tamari. she leaves black and white behind to experience color for the first time! also, with the "to see the world again" it may be to go back before tamari was a lab experiment; as we see they're siblings! hope this makes some sense
When I saw the character in the thumbnail I was like "Hmm they look kinda familiar" and now I'm realizing that they actually appeared very briefly at the end of Reckless Battery Burns and I'm honestly surprised that I could remember that brief appearance
I remember when I saw mariyam at the end of reckless battery burns for the first time and I thought they were supposed to be the past version of tamari or something. I thought the story was that tamari got turned into a robot💀 anyways yeah, interesting
I’m probably reading too much into it but there’s a potential neat connection between the series title, mv, and a philosophical concept! In philosophy, a “qualia” is a property of the “conscious experience” of something. To set up a running metaphor, the wavelength of light reflecting off an apple is a physical property. Meanwhile, the “red” *you experience* as existing in front of you is a mental property. In other words, the qualia of red is “what it’s like” to see red for a person. So the title “qualia automata” could mean “the conscious experience of being an automata.” That’d fit really well with what this song seems to be about :D I used the example of a color in my explanation for a reason. Colors are really easy to see and define as conscious experiences, so they get used a lot in philosophical discussion. One such discussion is the thought experiment “Mary and the black in white room,” which challenges the view that all consciousness is purely physical. The scenario follows a hyper-competent woman named Mary who spends the first part of her life in a black and white room with no exposure to the color red. Inside that room, she learns *all* the physical information about light waves and the human brain. When she leaves the room for the first time and encounters red, humans assume she still learns something new: “what it is like to see red.” As she already possessed all the physical knowledge, the argument claims that something in this interaction must be non-physical. Just thought that was interesting, with the monochrome mv which abruptly switches to color. Idk if it was intentional, but it’s a cool connection nonetheless!
it was.. subconsciously intentional! im extremely familiar with theories in philosophy and quantum theory too. we named mariyam without thinking of that and i remembered it at some point while working on it this after i came up with the idea of the most of the pv being in b/w and was like like "haha im so unintentionally smart" and then forgot about it again until now
@@11vein pray tell how one can attain extreme familiarity in both philosophy _and_ quantum theory. like that's legit the coolest "useless knowledge" to just have lying around in your head.
LYRICS (i STILL enjoy writing these) the path you showed me how to walk was cold algorithmic dreams, a vessel of your soul through her eyes of perfect ambiguity we were born to keep the world in harmony and through the days we saw this place create normopathy that would collate the passages in detail on your palms a world enveloped proudly by your heart the gift of life would soon impart the tears were born from fires of a psalm a spark alight behind those eyes ensured damnation as a "failed attempt" enlightened windows to the mind were damaged still while your claws laid across your chest and now you're all alone fleeting words in pen, i tell the story of salpêtrière dissonant again, and shown disorganised, without a prayer cornered by a psyche in a world that never truly ends though you'll never die, you've found that all eyes are staring at your hands the core of my design you eyes look down at mine it never truly ends as metal breaks and bends the path you walk eternally is cold knowing clarity is out of our control i can't understand the way you seem to pray but reality's contorting at your say a new façade, a prophet's masquerade you recreated on your face those eyes designed and carried by your fate our hands embodied roles to automate to never feel, to never break the writing on the wall remains the same and yet you live between these states never belonging, in a futile daze but were the ethics appraised? now it's too late i fear you're lost in the holy gate the core of my design you eyes look down at mine it never truly ends as metal breaks and bends (and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks) as metal breaks (and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks) as metal breaks (and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks) as metal breaks (and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks) as metal breaks *listen, this is not a question* *i have tried and i have failed* *if you wanna kill the world* *you should start by getting it backwards* *i know that i can feel the* *pain in my heart* *and we've had to say goodbye to all illusions* *that are shattered and gone* *to see the world again* *and my sister just gives me that weird, surreal look* *to see the world again* to see the world again
Hi ghost! I just wanted to thank you so much for making this song. My limbs have detached and gained complete autonomy, now spinning around in circles to the beat of the music entirely on their own(they grow up so fast) and I lay motionless on the ground as nothing but a torso and head; I will probably be dead soon, as I cannot move. Thank you! In all seriousness, Thank you so much for this incredible song! Your content has improved so much and as somebody who’s been a fan of you since like 2015, it’s been an amazing ride to watch you grow and evolve as a content creator. Please keep up the great work!
I know a lot of people really love your older music, and I think a lot of that is due to nostalgia and the charm of that specific style, but I just have to say that I am IN LOVE with your new work. It's so apparent how much you've improved, especially in the quality of production. I actually recently made a close friend through your music, and we are both so invested in the story behind Qualia Automata!! I can (and often do) listen to your songs all day. Keep going, your work is fucking amazing!
i can already feel my organs shifting in excitement i'll let yall know how it goes after premier edit i am now a puddle on the floor im currently trying to be resuscitated
i'm the 100th like and yes i swear i'm a puddle on the ground as well but theres cracks in the floorboards so the dormies below me called the dentist.....
For some reason, when i heard Tamari/Kevin’s voice for the first time of listening to this song, i was as hyped as when you see a character from a movie you thought you’d never see again appear in the sequel of said movie 😭
I Can hear a hint of reckless battery burns in this song not just cuz temari is here if you know what im talking about then you know cuz tbh I can't describe the tune :( Either way absolutely amazing as always thank you ghost for blessing us with yet another banger
not tamari/mariyam related but honestly this is exactly the song id use to describe how anxiety feels for me. The noise, the melody, something in lyrics even
I’m going to post my personal theory after this, but i just wanted to say that this is amazing. GHOST, VANE, CARBON, and CRUORMOR all outdid themselves and I am so so happy. The work that was put into this is outstanding.
It feels like there is a parallell between Tamari, who has quite a devilish look with the horns and tail whereas Mariyam has a more angelic look in the end with the halo of cables and the robe. (Very in-depth, I know. Totally not something half of those watching caught the first time they watched this.)
It seems that the colour changing from monotone to similar to RBB at the end of the song is the sister following Tamari instead of their creator/mentor, who had previously ran away or rebelled and was portrayed to the sister as a "failure" of the project they were created for
happy 1 year to this song :') this series means so much to me, so thank you to the team for making it possible! it's been fun theorizing and piecing stuff together as the story progresses - I hope that after the finale people will appreciate the characters and the message as much as I do! ❤
somthing about the art changeing from black and white, mostly just line art, and very angular, to full color and vibrint chaotic backrounds right when Mariyam runs away, just yes
notice how at 3:37 when Mariyam sings here you can hear a little bit of Tamari's vocals as well in the background to emphasize how similar the two truly are here. fun shit
One small thing that I noticed (after who knows how many listens of this song holy shit its good), is that the choir that plays during the intro and in the first chorus is almost "glitched" in a way, with it cutting, stuttering, repeating. However, when the same chorus plays at the end, after Tamari and Mariyam re-unite, when we see Fayrouz slumped against the wall in a defeated manner, the choir doesn't cut out. It doesn't stutter. There is no "glitch" to it. This carries through until the end of the song. I don't know what to make of this, if there's any possible meaning, but once you notice it, it is very... Eerie. Almost feels like something that was once incomplete has been completed; something previously broken has been fixed. However, with how dark the instrumental and song overall seem to be... Perhaps this completion was never meant to be. I'm both scared and extremely excited for the next entry into this series ':> Addendum: I've now also noticed that the instrumental when the siblings re-unite completely changes, keeping the similar dirty/glitchy bass, yes, but the other instrumentation is *lower*. Do I hear a bell? Something about it feels church-like; which I think pairs well with Tamari's metal wings, and how Mariyam becomes an almost "angelic automaton" at the end, but it has me thinking... did Tamari become a god of some sort? Reading the story summaries on the Qualia Automata caard, I think so. At least in one way. I continue to be both scared and excited for the next entry :')
Just noticed EWN 4:32 And my sister just gives me that weird, surreal look. RBB 4:42 Ignore the rottenness, and see your beautiful, bewildered face! (specifically at 4:45, you can see fayroux, then mariyam)
Absolutely screamed at the shot where everything is suddenly in color holy shit This entire video is such a work of art and the funky sounds rattle my braincells quite nicely
i feel like this song is based on mary the color scientist basically the series is called qualia automata, and what qualia means from what i could gather was human sensations and perceptions that cannot be explained, but have to be experienced so what mary the color scientist was was a theory saying that if you locked mary in a colorless room, and only explained to her what colors are, she would never have the qualia, or experience, of the colors. i feel like this is connected to the song because of how the mv starts out black and white and how the characters name is mariyam also, the mary color scientist theory was used as a way to prove that life isnt mental and made up by our brains but it is physical (i dont feel this connects to this song but maybe the next one) also sorry if i got any details wrong
I love how the melody gets more aggressive whenever Tamari is speaking or in a scene. I adore this song so much, and it’s just before my Tamari plush arrives to boot! Speaking of Tamari plush, this may be sudden but would there be any other Ghost or Vane Lily merch in the near future?? I will patiently wait for the day I can forfeit my organs for yet another silly
So uh, in case anyone was wondering what the story of Salpêtrière was. The Salpêtrière was originally a gunpowder factory, but in 1656 at the direction of Louis XIV, it was converted into a hospice for the poor women of Paris as part of the General Hospital of Paris. This main hospice was for women who were learning disabled, mentally ill or epileptic, as well as poor. In 1657 it was incorporated with the hospice of the Pitié designed specifically for beggars' children and orphans. In 1684 a women's prison was added to the site with a total capacity of 300 convicted prostitutes. It provided wretched living conditions for its inmates. On the eve of the Revolution, Pitié-Salpêtrière Hospice had become the world's largest hospice, with a capacity of 10,000 "patients" and over 300 prisoners. Until the French Revolution, the Salpêtrière had no medical function: the sick were sent to the Hôtel-Dieu hospital (via Wikipedia). There is a lot more to this, but this is the basics that I thought were either interesting or possibly??? relevant.
_Highly_ relevant. Especially with *he* says towards the end, right...? "Start by getting _it_ backwards." ...read backwards, the story goes from *highly successful hospice care,* to *women's health,* to the *powder factory.* _...if you wanna k--l the world..._
Got in a fight with someone in a psych ward over this song because they were calling it "satanic"... 10/10 would recommend experience. (UPDATE: I won I kicked that kid's ass LAWL-)
Thank you, GHOST, honestly thank you for having this song up. It helped distract myself from something horrible unfolding tonight as I type. Warning: suicide My little cousin that lives like a town away just tried in her backyard by hanging and my mom left our house in a frenzy, leaving my brother in my care, he's 16 but special needs and I'm 21 with an apartment upstairs so she's able to dump him here and run to my aunts house that's like 40 mins away with her bf driving. I'm... I'm a mess I won't lie and I won't care if anyone says I lie or I'm making it up, I really wish I was, I wish I was. I apologize in advance for anything I say in this comment, I'm just a mess from all of this right now, she and her sisters are like the sisters me and my brother never had, the girly type that would do your hair and gossip but also play in the backyard with mud and bows with arrows and cool things, there's three, the oldest, the middle, and the youngest, 15, 14, 13, respectedly. The 14 year old is the one that went and tried. I don't want to bring religion into this but as a pentecostal Christian, I prayed for a miracle tonight. I prayed with my bf and brother beside me in prayer. So thank you, GHOST, for this song. It brings an idea of some of these impossible and harsh emotions right now. I'm also sorry if this makes a landmark on your song or you get traction because of this comment, I wish not for many people to know this sorrow. I don't even want to know it right now, I doubt I'll get any sleep, but I made sure my brother had some valerian root so he doesn't worry as much during rest time. I'm sorry for rambling. Thank you for being one of the Vocaloid producers that I've grown fond of and grown comfort in. It really means a lot in times like these.
I'm sorry, i hope talking about it helped a little. A few days ago my boyfriend wanted to do it but thankfully i talked him out of it and now everything is ok
I continue to want to hug Tamari. Unfortunately I suspect they probably wouldn't appreciate someone doing that, but. They definitely deserve whatever equivalent they would appreciate.
I love how the way Ghost incorperates Arabic into the music videos is like how I incorperate the half bug-half owl creatures into the bodies of my cousins 🥰
I love the parts of reckless battery burns in the background, and also the way Solaria sounds. Like, she really sounds androgynous in this one, and I absolutely love this. Also, normopathy is now one of my favorite words to say, along with panopticon, glockenspiel, and onomatopoeia. edit:am I the only one who hears trollolloll in the background?
![Yuma, Stardust, Asterian, Kevin / SCAPEG♾AT [Original Song]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/vqe2WMZYYvQ/mqdefault.jpg)
![Yuma, Stardust, Asterian, Kevin / SCAPEG♾AT [Original Song]](/img/tr.png)
![Dex / Honey I'm Home [Original Song]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/xHffjNbWmig/mqdefault.jpg)
Hii here r the translations for all the Arabic text in this :)
2:54 - the book says "quantum theory"
3:54 - is a series of assorted AI-generated phrases all layered over each other so they can be a bit hard to discern, but of those phrases are the following:
"Forgive me for all my sins
In the real world
In the
Dream world
In
A dream
Of becoming human again"
"You can still be me
The sky's colored in hope
Though it's a shame, it's not my color"
"You gotta leave now, you gotta stay now, or we'll kill today"
"My body isn't strong enough for this now that it's reality"
"Why did you do it"
A little after that is just the phrase
"I'm afraid" over and over
And at the Tamari section at 4:01 it's the following phrases:
"I hate you"
"I deserved better"
"Why did you make me like this?"
"My lord, save them from themselves"
"My lord, save them from me"
Thank u ghost for this epic opportunity :)) I love tamari and his sister mariyam with my whole heart and i LOVED getting to work on and write for this project
And I'm very excited for what else is to come :-))
THANK YOU CARBON MONOXIDE
PLEASE STOP MAKING ME WANT TO TAKE ARABIC CLASSES I CAN'T EVEN AFFORD THEM
This needs to be higher in the comments list
OMG THANKSSSSSSSS
fellow arabian person. Thx
The GHOST fandom: Were you killed?
Tamari: Sadly, yes
*but I lived*
So glad they got better
I lived bitch
ICE AGE REFERENCE OMG
Reminds me how Neuro Sama talked about "she's still dead", like someone could stop being dead
*sadly yes I died, BUT I LIVED*
Tamari being like "Quit your job, join my emo band" is killing me. But also this song fucks so severely
I'd quit my life to join Tamari's emo band ngl
This is my favorite comment
All I can imagine is Tamari going "WHERE ARE YOOUUU... AND I'M SO SORRY 😩"
@@kitten-cloudy1557Tamari be like "She left me roses by the stairs-"
@@jakke6691 Same
I can imagine Mariyam deciding to follow her sibling in the other world and see at least 18 Tamaris eating cold pasta with nothing on it while 20 others play with Doors or destroy themselves
*_y e s_*
And one of the tamaris is just like 'HEY WANT SOME PASTA!?!?'
And the first thing she hears is " OH FZCK YOU FIGURE " from one of them
Mmmmm the cold pasta
Seems like they dont know how to make a chicken casserol
@@HamHamIsDeadInside what
AUGH love the contrast between mariyam's lines being written in rhyming verse and tamari's lines being in the same rhymeless ai style as reckless battery burns..... the humantype and the machinetype. so good
@@invisilibrarian ye they use ghost songs in some of their playlists. very epico
FOR. REAL. AH
OH I DIDN’T REALISE THAT!! thank you for making note of it!!!!!
FOR REAL
I KNOW RIGHT... one of my favorite tropes ngl
Looking up what Salpêtrière is, it seems to refer to a teaching hospital for mental health/brain related problems in France, although it was originally a gunpowder factory
As a French person, I didn’t know, thanks
According to further research, it took in women of any status no matter who they were and branded them as hysterical. I've heard about this practice in Europe of women being called hysterical simple because of normal body functions - such as periods - or because they were "outcasts" either unwanted or acting beyond the "norm" of society at the time to a degree that lead to imprisonment. Often wrongly, as you'd guess. La Salpêtrière was basically a prison, and according to an article I found, in the September Massacres of 1792, due to anger, fear, and mob mentality, those who had the intention of freeing the imprisoned women ended up dragging them into the streets and... severely unaliving them.
Fun fact - "Salpêtrière" is "saltpeter" in English, which is potassium nitrate - a common ingredient found in gunpowder. They literally named the hospital after the fact that it was a gunpowder factory before.
@@lueroso1540 For accuracy's sake : "salpêtre" is "salpeter". "Salpêtrière" is "the place where you store salpeter". but otherwise you're right =p
I think the choice of salpêtrière as a word here is probably to use both meaning. Like, the fact that abuse and not acknowledging someone's agenticity (I was going to say humanity but it's not accurate heree so that's the best word I could find) ends up creating more problems than the ones you're trying to avoid and causing violent reactions, like litterally "sitting on a powder keg".
@@lueroso1540 well. The histrionic side of history is not that well understood, is it?
And now for one going the other way, what's up with the Seinfeld jokes? You start from somewhere you know and then you unlearn it? Why? How? What's the point here, @@Laezar1?
"And my sister just gives me that weird surreal look" has the same energy as "what the FUCK are you talking about"
" -Jessie- Tamari what the fuck are you talking about?!"
@@chiscore SAME
The way she looks at me is hilarious
TAMARI WHAT THE FUCK IS YOU TALKING ABOUT
@@Spxxns_i tamar💀
They really hit us with a Tamari sibling
@@Ta-m01the name of one of the characters the person with multiple eyes in reckless battery burns AND in this song
They were in reckless battery burns
@@utatanepikoV5 Yeah just recalled seeing her in the one frame near the end of reckless completely slipped my mind
@@utatanepikoV5 wait she was??? 😱 Edit: yeah I just checked back and now I remember, it's been 8 months LMAO
@@KeizerScourge huh wondered who that was
I see that Tamari’s following the GHOST character pipeline that is becoming a heavily-detailed god. Good for them good for them.
I think the double vision from too many eyes actually doesn't work that much
@@principleshipcoleoid8095but it looks cool and intimidating so fuck it we ball
@@klondikegardens6570fr
@@klondikegardens6570 yep.
As metal breaks and bends and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends it breaks and bends this is such a fucking banger
I'm having a stroke reading that.
@@Mcdonagihowcanihelpu understandable
best part
r/ihadastroke
@@alandoyle1077 good point
i played this song to me dad when we were testing my computer music, he described the song as 'karl marx's hell' as the mechanical sounds at the start made him think of some industrial factory where russian workers are being tortured or something. 'no wonder you're so angry all the time, this is what you listen to'. so i hereby rename this song karl marx's hell.
Lmao
Nah with all the chants and shit, I call it what the guardmen hear before the extemantus, it’s like they are praying to not die
Your dad is a genius!
Also, this comment made me realize that this song and Rainbow Factory have a somewhat similar vibe. Karl Marx's hell indeed.
Привет
@@sahaafa9082 👋
I already imagine how I will listen this song the whole day tomorrow
Literally me
smae vdaabngs
ok now i found out that this is my new stress relief song 🐮
so real aster
real
I can feel myself already memorizing this song lyrics
I love how all of Marriyam’s lines rhyme and all of Tamari’s don’t!
Like tamari’s the “black sheep” of perfect robotics world and like broke away from their mom thing person…… Meanwhile Marriyam was like goin along with it and like didn’t listen to Tamari for a while (2:21 Tamari trying to show their sister his views by giving them an eye) and at the end they choose to listen to Tamari and like break away like a swaggy pog champ beast
I love this theory!!
Wait tamaris a robot
@@aries.floofy5167 yes??😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭 look at the robotic pieces and the machine in the vid
@@invisilibrarian oh well I’m talking about in reckless battery burns
@@aries.floofy5167 AW SHI- man that makes sense😭 bro got that artificial human swag can’t tell what species they r
at 3:37 it feels like Fayrouz is saying that, not Mariyam , "The core of my design"- Fayrouz realizing that the mistake wasnt in Tamari, but in herself, "Your eyes look down at mine"-Mariyam is dissapointed at Fayrouz and therefore looking down at her, not the other way around, "It never truly ends"- If tamari wasnt the mistake, Fayrouz is, meaning she will continue to make AIs that run away from her, over and over again. idk im too obsessed with this that i might be making things up but idk
YES !!!!! EXACTLY !!!!!
This is such an interesting observation becauss in "Lamentations" Mariyam says "Your eyes look up at mine" so your comment might actually be true
I thought at this part Mariyam escaped Dr. Fayrouz
yes that too but thoeries@@itsclae
It's those darn power dynamics again.
Superiority from/as 'creator,' while the 'inferiority' goes unchecked.
I thought “that guy kinda looks like Tamari” and then two seconds later Tamari showed up.
My jaw was on the floor the entire time, good job Ghost
Same lmao
@@sleeplesswhipdcreme_nosleep Gimme the timestamp please I can't find it
@@sleeplesswhipdcreme_nosleep THANK YOU SO MUCH
Hyperdontia reference in the original comment?
@@sleeplesswhipdcreme_nosleep you’re correct, the scientist lady was also there. I know this from memory of course because I love these songs
This song makes me want to do exactly 73 backflips
the Four pfp adds to the chaos
The fact your pfp is Four makes this comment that much better
But honestly same
I wanna do exactly 73 backflips
@@koishikomeiji1387 yooo a fellow osc member in the wild 🤸🤸🤸
@@itzpixlz8001 *another wild OSC member appears!*
FOUR
Mariyam: When can I see my sibling?
Fayrouz: uhhh... About that....
Tamari: HEY BINWASHERS WANNA JOIN ME IN THE METAVERSE
4:33
THIS FACE!!
If holds SO MANY thoughts behind it, here are my favorite examples
"What cookies, haven't seen any....."
"GOD you breath stinks"
"I don't know who you are, and you clearly think I'm someone else, but I'm too anxious to tell you that so I'm just gonna pretend I know what's going on with you and your ex."
"DID I FORGET SOMETHING!!!!!"
"OH NO........"
*Everyone who was a Binwasher: okay mate sure lol*
@@Eldritch_Esther when you hear your mom pulling in but you havent took the chicken out of the freezer yet
Yes
I DONT KNOW WHY BUT I KEEP READING TAMARIS LINE HERE IN BILL CIPHERS VOICE AFSGSGAF
tamari with their wings at 4:11 looks like the cover character from those who carried on with the placement of the mechanical like limbs and spikes from the head
I SAW THAT TOO LIKE- SIMILAR UNIVERSE/CONCEPT??? brain going brrrrrrrreeeeeeerrrrrrreeeeerrrr
Fr
THATS WHAT I THOUGHT!!!!!
WAIT YOURE SO RIGHT
In the desc of the unfinished pv video ghost said the universe is about a contagious disease that causes people to decompose alive and fall apart. I immediately thought of the line "ignore the rottenness, and see your beautiful bewildered face" maybe the unuverse take place ages after the events of those who carried on??
Cant believe this all happened just because ghost and vane were joking around with an ai at first 💀
This AI has started something beyond extraordinary
And now it's my favorite song other than deathbody
Truly a Ghost and Vane moment
you have a nice profile picture
@@kim-dokja_ thank you :)
Something small that I noticed, is at 1:44 before the paper with the roschach test is torn, the bangs at the top are Miriyams. But as the paper is shred, the bangs quickly change to Tamari's before Tamari is revealed behind it. Not sure what this means, but I thought I should mention it here !!
While Mariyam try to answer the test as intended
Tamari found that the answer was violence and breaking laws
@@blackkitsune6840 i like this
Maybe cause the sister lady is all proper and doing things as intended, while tamari is ballin ballin, doin their thang. Really gettin out there. Making things happen. Payin bills and climbin hills. You know them. They're doin it. Robo robo. Done and done. Really gotcha there. Who needs psychology tests? The weird mumma (maybe not mumma) doc is makin robots. Who cares if the robots go coocoo? It SEEMS like, like one robot is coocoo enough. Even said, "You're paper... is... dumb"
Other robot, well, is chill. But I hope they come to they're not-senses soon and start ballin like my cutie cutie patooty tamari
@@headphoneshq6032 I love this comment so much
Tamari is such baller
@@headphoneshq6032 i tried to read this outloid w a stright face and couldnt XD
I don’t need therapy I need to be pronounced like Mariyam says Salpêtriére (2:05)
That part always makes me happy for some reason
REAL
I was watching live and it was such an experience getting to share a braincell with all the other chatters at 1:55 and 4:33 going "TAMARI!!!" and "SISTER??? SIBLINGS???"
the amount of TAMARI in the chat was unreal
for some reason my brain wondered 'are they the same person' for a sec and somewhere in thatchat i said something about it 💀
This comment is too funny
don’t forget everyone spamming “TRANS TAMARI???” when we saw miriam
Considering the references on Reckless Battery Burns
I'm convinced this is just Tamari inviting Mariyam to discover the internet
The first thing that happens after the song ends is tamari making a cover of welcome to the internet
@@chocolate_pizza Welcome to the internet. Have a look around.
@@TheMind129Anything that brain of yours can think of can be found
@@TheMind129Anything that brain of yours can think of can be found.
@@TheMind129 anything that brain of yours can think of can be found
once again i have fallen into the "ghost and pals song" rabbit hole.
step one: listening to the song. not my jam.
step two: listens a second time from curiosity. becomes obsessed.
step three: becomes my main song for months until ghost posts another song.
SAME
OH MY GOD YES! It happens to me where I listen to a song from either Ghost or Vane and aren't sure if I like it or not, so I listen to it again and then love it! So this is very relatable.
THIS IS ME FIRST I DIDN'T LIKE THIS SONG BUT THEN I BECOME OBSESSED WITH IT AND ITS THE ONLY SONG I'VE BEEN LISTENING TO FOR MONTHS NOW
seriously! why does the fuck does this keep happening to me!! i listen to their songs, dont like it at first, listen to it again just to give it another chance, i cannot stop myself from listening to it over and over again until i get sick of it. every time!!!!
ME
This slaps harder than the solid iron claws
Are you being violently beaten by tamari
@@joenigglepickle yes
It makes it easier to ignore the rottenness
It's more beautiful than the bewildered face
@@arthyem21320 Amazing response 😂
The way I SCREAMED when I saw Tamari appear! Great to see that comeback from Reckless Battery Burns!
Omg same literally thought it was a coincidence they looked so similar at first!
omg same i fucking jumped. the video was kinda giving me tamari vibes but i was not expecting that
Not just that but some parts of the music from that song are hidden in this one
SAME I SO NEARLY SCREAMED REALLY LOUDLY NEXT TO MY MUM
I LEGIT SCREAMED “TAMARI IS BACK!” AT THE TOP OF MY LUNGS WHEN I SAW THEM I WAS SO HAPPY
I legit gasped when tamari appeared, it's so cool to see ghost getting back into making song series.
I nearly screamed when I saw them 😭
@@gumimissilelauncher I cried lmao
1:56 the girl has a human sized Tamari plush ig good for her
Loved the part where Tamari said "it's Tamaring Time" and the Tamarred all over the place
WE TAMAR
i tamar 💀
@@kirbyenthusiastnumber2 i omor...
@@rrukoko real
@@rrukoko 😈
the pronunciation of Salpêtrière is gently massaging my lungs 🤤
same
same
same
JELP ME
That line fucks so hard. It lives rent free in my brain, knocking things over like a cat.
Did anyone else notice at 4:47 "TA-MO2" seems to be a reference to Tamari from Reckless Battery Burns. At the end of that song the file "ta-mo1.exe" is dragged into the desktop trash. And the mc has those same little antenna as Tamari. I wonder how they're connected.
.
.
Edit, I forgot to mention how this song dislocated my whole spine in the best way possible :)
tamari in this song also looks quite drastically different (much more mechanical, 2 new eyes, more horns on their head)
@@veryrealhuman5471 Ah, thanks, I just did the obligatory read-through of Ghost's comment section and yes, it IS Tamari!
If Tamari's real name is TA-M01 (test andriod model 01), and Mariyam is TA-M02 (test andriod model 02)... Does that mean Tamari is the older sibling?
@@veryrealhuman5471 cuormor actually said that the design IN RBB was a simplified version of their design, and Tamari looks more like this version in their reference art iirc
@@HamHamIsDeadInside Based on this idea, it seems the 'ta-mo2 reconnection failed' scene is when Mariyam ran away to join Tamari, and Fayrouz probably wants them to come back. Yeah I think Tamari is the older sibling.
Normopathy - The pathological pursuit of conformity and societal acceptance at the expense of individuality.
i am [intrigued]
Welp that’s all my trauma summed up into one word :>
Have an oc that matches this term unimaginably well and now I love this song even more
@@IHaveNoIdea5555 Same
@@IHaveNoIdea5555 same except I'm now fistfighting myself about taking inspo from this song. Like I came into this thinking I'd get some oc vibes but I was not expecting the "therapist robot is considered a failure by their creators and is now on their own while their company tries to figure out WTF to do about it" flavor of vibes. IMAGINE MY SHOCK-
It bends and breaks, it bends and breaks, it bends and breaks, it bends and breaks...
Ghost is really out here feeding us with so many amazing songs one after another
It's so good, no?
@@AkuAku_66 yes it is THAT good! The visuals are also sooo sooooo stunning
@@SamSam-sg2xt TAMARI IS A BOY , HE HAVE A SISTER , A SISTER , I CAN'T BELIVE THIS FACT
@@AkuAku_66 ITS SO SICK HE HAS A WHOLE SISTER WOAH?!?!?!?! and she is ABSOLUTELY GORGEOUS?!?!?!?
@@SamSam-sg2xt it's so amazing... I can't sleep this night...
I love this so much! I love the return of Tamari, I love how the whole world is shown in colour when Mariyam finally finds them, I love that none of Tamari's lines rhyme and they all have the same quality as Reckless Battery Burns' lyrics. It gives off the idea that Tamari has become so enlightened by the experiments done on them that being near them exposes reality but at the same time Mariyam cannot understand what they are saying because they've changed far too much. And at the end, Mariyam grieves Tamari but I suppose agrees to follow in their footsteps? I love this continuation, I hadn't expected it.
"if you wanna kill the world you should start by getting it backwards" is the rawest fucking lyric EVER and ive been thinking about it every day since this track came out like it goes so hard thank you for being a badass af artist ghost
Y'knoe it's ai generated right? Don't lose yourself in a single line of lyrics
@ameladaptivedaydreamer949 dont care + goes hard + enjoying
@@ameladaptivedaydreamer949 No, this line was not AI-generated, all of the lyrics in this song were produced and written by GHOST themself. Reckless Battery Burns, the first song in the Qualia Automata series, is the only song the lyrics of which were BASED ON some results which GHOST got from an AI text generator (where, by the way, they put the lyrics of their own songs and some of their friends' songs with permission, the utilization of AI in this was completely ethical and with consent from all parties involved and did not involve any type of art theft).
@@dinoheartnerd2265"...but were the ethics appraised?" 🥴
I see it as telling them to off themselves lmao@@ameladaptivedaydreamer949
"Dad, why is my sister named Rose?"
"Because your mother loves roses."
"Oh, thanks Dad"
"No problem Solaria, Kevin / End-World Normopathy [Original Song Collaboration]"
Lmao that would be so true if i were a parent
fr
didnt understand it fully because my brain runs on a single braincell eating noodles, but now i do :D
now i have the urge to name some kids tamari and mariyam, but i don't want to be dr fayrouz😒
someone said this about chattering lack of common sense aswell lol
i dont know why
but when tamari appeared i screamed so loud i hurt my throat
overall amazing song i love that tamari makes another appearance.
FURTHER FOR THY SAKE! OPEN MY MOUTH AN SCREAM ALONG WITH MEEEE
@@undertale-perseverance Tamari is shaped like a friend.
@@undertale-perseverance tamari : exist
Ghost fans :
@@siorganism ITS OUR LORD AND SAVIOR TAMARI, PRAY TO THEM, LOVE THEM, FRIEND THEM
that's how I feel when i see the silly little friend shaped Tamari
Me too!! I was so happy I love tamari smmm
i think the color changing is a metaphor for the main character leaving the head of the lab to find tamari. she leaves black and white behind to experience color for the first time!
also, with the "to see the world again" it may be to go back before tamari was a lab experiment; as we see they're siblings!
hope this makes some sense
@@Ta-m01 im happy someone agrees with me! i like looking at how things can be metaphors for something hahaha
When I saw the character in the thumbnail I was like "Hmm they look kinda familiar" and now I'm realizing that they actually appeared very briefly at the end of Reckless Battery Burns and I'm honestly surprised that I could remember that brief appearance
YesYES
Help I don’t even remember that and I watched it the other day 😭
fayrouz (scientist lady) appears before her as well!!
I NOTICED THAT TOO!!
I remember when I saw mariyam at the end of reckless battery burns for the first time and I thought they were supposed to be the past version of tamari or something. I thought the story was that tamari got turned into a robot💀 anyways yeah, interesting
I’m probably reading too much into it but there’s a potential neat connection between the series title, mv, and a philosophical concept!
In philosophy, a “qualia” is a property of the “conscious experience” of something. To set up a running metaphor, the wavelength of light reflecting off an apple is a physical property. Meanwhile, the “red” *you experience* as existing in front of you is a mental property. In other words, the qualia of red is “what it’s like” to see red for a person. So the title “qualia automata” could mean “the conscious experience of being an automata.” That’d fit really well with what this song seems to be about :D
I used the example of a color in my explanation for a reason. Colors are really easy to see and define as conscious experiences, so they get used a lot in philosophical discussion. One such discussion is the thought experiment “Mary and the black in white room,” which challenges the view that all consciousness is purely physical. The scenario follows a hyper-competent woman named Mary who spends the first part of her life in a black and white room with no exposure to the color red. Inside that room, she learns *all* the physical information about light waves and the human brain. When she leaves the room for the first time and encounters red, humans assume she still learns something new: “what it is like to see red.” As she already possessed all the physical knowledge, the argument claims that something in this interaction must be non-physical.
Just thought that was interesting, with the monochrome mv which abruptly switches to color. Idk if it was intentional, but it’s a cool connection nonetheless!
it was.. subconsciously intentional! im extremely familiar with theories in philosophy and quantum theory too. we named mariyam without thinking of that and i remembered it at some point while working on it this after i came up with the idea of the most of the pv being in b/w and was like like "haha im so unintentionally smart" and then forgot about it again until now
@CRUORMOR that’s so cool!!!
@@11vein pray tell how one can attain extreme familiarity in both philosophy _and_ quantum theory. like that's legit the coolest "useless knowledge" to just have lying around in your head.
second to memorizing every metal gear revengance song by heart of course
Holy CRAP that one was one hell of an eye-opener. THANKS FOR THAT WALL OF TEXT MY 3RD EYE HAS BEEN OPENED THIS IS SO COOL
3:11 what a fine friend, I hope they don't recklessly burn batteries.
LYRICS
(i STILL enjoy writing these)
the path you showed me how to walk was cold
algorithmic dreams, a vessel of your soul
through her eyes of perfect ambiguity
we were born to keep the world in harmony
and through the days we saw this place create
normopathy that would collate
the passages in detail on your palms
a world enveloped proudly by your heart
the gift of life would soon impart
the tears were born from fires of a psalm
a spark alight behind those eyes
ensured damnation as a "failed attempt"
enlightened windows to the mind were damaged still
while your claws laid across your chest
and now you're all alone
fleeting words in pen, i tell the story of salpêtrière
dissonant again, and shown disorganised, without a prayer
cornered by a psyche in a world that never truly ends
though you'll never die, you've found that
all eyes are staring at your hands
the core of my design
you eyes look down at mine
it never truly ends
as metal breaks and bends
the path you walk eternally is cold
knowing clarity is out of our control
i can't understand the way you seem to pray
but reality's contorting at your say
a new façade, a prophet's masquerade
you recreated on your face
those eyes designed and carried by your fate
our hands embodied roles to automate
to never feel, to never break
the writing on the wall remains the same
and yet you live between these states
never belonging, in a futile daze
but were the ethics appraised?
now it's too late
i fear you're lost in the holy gate
the core of my design
you eyes look down at mine
it never truly ends
as metal breaks and bends
(and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks)
as metal breaks
(and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks)
as metal breaks
(and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks)
as metal breaks
(and metal breaks and metal breaks and metal breaks)
as metal breaks
*listen, this is not a question*
*i have tried and i have failed*
*if you wanna kill the world*
*you should start by getting it backwards*
*i know that i can feel the*
*pain in my heart*
*and we've had to say goodbye to all illusions*
*that are shattered and gone*
*to see the world again*
*and my sister just gives me that weird, surreal look*
*to see the world again*
to see the world again
Thank youuu
Commenting so this goes to the top because my reptile brain needs words in a clear format
THANK YOU???
Thank you chain
Help I also wrote the lyrics but it got no attention
Except you wrote the whole as metal breaks and bends part I got lazy lmao
Hi ghost! I just wanted to thank you so much for making this song. My limbs have detached and gained complete autonomy, now spinning around in circles to the beat of the music entirely on their own(they grow up so fast) and I lay motionless on the ground as nothing but a torso and head; I will probably be dead soon, as I cannot move. Thank you!
In all seriousness, Thank you so much for this incredible song! Your content has improved so much and as somebody who’s been a fan of you since like 2015, it’s been an amazing ride to watch you grow and evolve as a content creator. Please keep up the great work!
god, i know right? i remember way back when my limbs did that too, it feels so long ago! haha, *i have no clue how i am typing.*
@@Ta-m01 ghost and pals does it
I know a lot of people really love your older music, and I think a lot of that is due to nostalgia and the charm of that specific style, but I just have to say that I am IN LOVE with your new work. It's so apparent how much you've improved, especially in the quality of production. I actually recently made a close friend through your music, and we are both so invested in the story behind Qualia Automata!! I can (and often do) listen to your songs all day. Keep going, your work is fucking amazing!
😭 i edited the comment but then i put it back and it made ghost unlike it automatically
@@alexolivers9476yeah that happens😔
I cannot convey how much I love that gospel of distorted screams.
GHOST really be pumping out absolute BOPS lately. masterpieces if you will
Oops, all bangers!
i can already feel my organs shifting in excitement i'll let yall know how it goes after premier
edit i am now a puddle on the floor im currently trying to be resuscitated
ME TOO
REal
THIS. ME TOO BUDDY
WHAT
i'm the 100th like and yes i swear i'm a puddle on the ground as well but theres cracks in the floorboards so the dormies below me called the dentist.....
You're quite active for someone who's decomposing, Ghost. Well done 👏 👏👏👏👏
@@ShowdollP maybe end of the world composing?
de(composing)
You can just pick up your arms and legs
0:40 My face when I'm drawing and my pen is literally on the paper the someone asks me "Omg did you draw that?"
Real like yeah I obviously drew something 😭
Real
How did i just realize that Mariyam's rhyming is more human like and Tamari's is more ai generated?
FAYROUZ.
i read the ‘FAYROUZ’ in edward from arcade craniacs’ voice btw
mariyam is more human like and tamari is more ai
You know you’re a ghost and pals fan when tamari appears on screen and you jolt so hard out of pure excitement that you puke lungs
For some reason, when i heard Tamari/Kevin’s voice for the first time of listening to this song, i was as hyped as when you see a character from a movie you thought you’d never see again appear in the sequel of said movie 😭
I Can hear a hint of reckless battery burns in this song not just cuz temari is here if you know what im talking about then you know cuz tbh I can't describe the tune :( Either way absolutely amazing as always thank you ghost for blessing us with yet another banger
2:10 ???
@@joenigglepickle that and also a the part where the pitch rises
4:42
The distorted kettle noise my beloved
another user mentioned the bass-line seems to be the same between the two songs
I loved watching chat going crazy when tamari called mariyam “sister”
not tamari/mariyam related but honestly this is exactly the song id use to describe how anxiety feels for me. The noise, the melody, something in lyrics even
I’m going to post my personal theory after this, but i just wanted to say that this is amazing. GHOST, VANE, CARBON, and CRUORMOR all outdid themselves and I am so so happy. The work that was put into this is outstanding.
goddamn tamari must be getting some incredibly fast wifi with all those damn antennas
God I love how these newer Vocaloids sound, it makes the old-school fan in me happy
synth v is the new vocaloid
THIS IS ABSOLUTELY AMAZING! it's nice to see Tamari bonding with their family by playing wii Sports!
WII SPORTS >>>>>>
Let's wait until they choose to play "Wii are resorting to violence" instead
It feels like there is a parallell between Tamari, who has quite a devilish look with the horns and tail whereas Mariyam has a more angelic look in the end with the halo of cables and the robe. (Very in-depth, I know. Totally not something half of those watching caught the first time they watched this.)
you say that but i genuinely never made that connection until now
@@mothgirl0512 I guess I just got worried that I was being annoying by pointing it out... The comparison could also just be superstition.
0:24 one of the best beat drops in Ghost history
Yes
Yes #2
Hard agree
RIGHT?!
It seems that the colour changing from monotone to similar to RBB at the end of the song is the sister following Tamari instead of their creator/mentor, who had previously ran away or rebelled and was portrayed to the sister as a "failure" of the project they were created for
happy 1 year to this song :') this series means so much to me, so thank you to the team for making it possible! it's been fun theorizing and piecing stuff together as the story progresses - I hope that after the finale people will appreciate the characters and the message as much as I do! ❤
somthing about the art changeing from black and white, mostly just line art, and very angular, to full color and vibrint chaotic backrounds right when Mariyam runs away, just yes
ghost fans r eating well this year. im so happy you (and everyone involved) share your songs with us!!
notice how at 3:37 when Mariyam sings here you can hear a little bit of Tamari's vocals as well in the background to emphasize how similar the two truly are here. fun shit
"If you wanna kill the world you should start by getting it backwards"
Alright
ti
oh no
You've doomed us all
*it has been done*
*You have no idea what you just did*
OH. OH NO.
One small thing that I noticed (after who knows how many listens of this song holy shit its good), is that the choir that plays during the intro and in the first chorus is almost "glitched" in a way, with it cutting, stuttering, repeating. However, when the same chorus plays at the end, after Tamari and Mariyam re-unite, when we see Fayrouz slumped against the wall in a defeated manner, the choir doesn't cut out. It doesn't stutter. There is no "glitch" to it. This carries through until the end of the song.
I don't know what to make of this, if there's any possible meaning, but once you notice it, it is very... Eerie. Almost feels like something that was once incomplete has been completed; something previously broken has been fixed. However, with how dark the instrumental and song overall seem to be... Perhaps this completion was never meant to be.
I'm both scared and extremely excited for the next entry into this series ':>
Addendum:
I've now also noticed that the instrumental when the siblings re-unite completely changes, keeping the similar dirty/glitchy bass, yes, but the other instrumentation is *lower*. Do I hear a bell? Something about it feels church-like; which I think pairs well with Tamari's metal wings, and how Mariyam becomes an almost "angelic automaton" at the end, but it has me thinking... did Tamari become a god of some sort? Reading the story summaries on the Qualia Automata caard, I think so. At least in one way.
I continue to be both scared and excited for the next entry :')
The fact that tamari still adding eyes to their body
needs more eyes
needs more eyes
needs more eyes
needs more eyes
Needs more eyes
Tbh i cant get over how amazing ghosts artstlye is. really suits their music too (nevermind cruormor did the art. cruormor has a very cool artstyle!!)
cruormor did the art for this video!
@@ghostandpals oh cool! their art is awesome, ill go check them out :)
@@ghostandpals omg do they have a patreon?
@@mirlachan i dont currently!! when i start working on some more personal projects and stuff i might open one
@@11vein Your art is so very pretty!
Ok this one is God Tier. music, theme, illustrations, animation, and how it ties into reckless battery burns are fantastic. I adore it so much!
already ready to loop this for the next 6 days
REAL
Tamari really went "Hey bitches im back" and started singing a verse he made up on the spot
i have no idea why but i am addicted to the way solaria is tuned when saying salpetriere.
Just noticed
EWN 4:32 And my sister just gives me that weird, surreal look.
RBB 4:42 Ignore the rottenness, and see your beautiful, bewildered face! (specifically at 4:45, you can see fayroux, then mariyam)
Absolutely screamed at the shot where everything is suddenly in color holy shit
This entire video is such a work of art and the funky sounds rattle my braincells quite nicely
Its in words!
i feel like this song is based on mary the color scientist
basically the series is called qualia automata, and what qualia means from what i could gather was human sensations and perceptions that cannot be explained, but have to be experienced
so what mary the color scientist was was a theory saying that if you locked mary in a colorless room, and only explained to her what colors are, she would never have the qualia, or experience, of the colors. i feel like this is connected to the song because of how the mv starts out black and white and how the characters name is mariyam
also, the mary color scientist theory was used as a way to prove that life isnt mental and made up by our brains but it is physical (i dont feel this connects to this song but maybe the next one)
also sorry if i got any details wrong
WE GETTIN OUT THE WORMHOLE WITH THIS ONE 🗣️🗣️🗣️‼️‼️🔥
Боже, это прекрасно!! Я очень рада, песня очень понравилась, я очень благодарна всем кто работал над этой песней!!!
я ждал что в конце тамари плюш тупо будет чёрно белый лол
@@kirieshkinsq235 да да да я тоже
Хочется узнать побольше лора о вселенной этой песни и RBB. Блин, я их обожаю.
@@San4ous.mp2mk можешь рассказать всё что знаешь об этом?
I love how the melody gets more aggressive whenever Tamari is speaking or in a scene. I adore this song so much, and it’s just before my Tamari plush arrives to boot! Speaking of Tamari plush, this may be sudden but would there be any other Ghost or Vane Lily merch in the near future?? I will patiently wait for the day I can forfeit my organs for yet another silly
So uh, in case anyone was wondering what the story of Salpêtrière was.
The Salpêtrière was originally a gunpowder factory, but in 1656 at the direction of Louis XIV, it was converted into a hospice for the poor women of Paris as part of the General Hospital of Paris. This main hospice was for women who were learning disabled, mentally ill or epileptic, as well as poor. In 1657 it was incorporated with the hospice of the Pitié designed specifically for beggars' children and orphans. In 1684 a women's prison was added to the site with a total capacity of 300 convicted prostitutes. It provided wretched living conditions for its inmates. On the eve of the Revolution, Pitié-Salpêtrière Hospice had become the world's largest hospice, with a capacity of 10,000 "patients" and over 300 prisoners. Until the French Revolution, the Salpêtrière had no medical function: the sick were sent to the Hôtel-Dieu hospital (via Wikipedia).
There is a lot more to this, but this is the basics that I thought were either interesting or possibly??? relevant.
_Highly_ relevant.
Especially with *he* says towards the end, right...? "Start by getting _it_ backwards."
...read backwards, the story goes from *highly successful hospice care,* to *women's health,* to the *powder factory.*
_...if you wanna k--l the world..._
Got in a fight with someone in a psych ward over this song because they were calling it "satanic"... 10/10 would recommend experience. (UPDATE: I won I kicked that kid's ass LAWL-)
Does this work with other GHOST songs
@@I_E_O_T_Chopefully
@@I_E_O_T_Cprobably, especially with songs like Chelovek and Perfect Nothing
@@rinatepaste9218 don’t forget Honey I’m Home
@@lux_isSELF-iSH oh yeah that one too
No clue what the hell is going on, but thank you Ghost, very cool
In general, two siblings reunited and escaped their abusive mother.
Thank you, GHOST, honestly thank you for having this song up. It helped distract myself from something horrible unfolding tonight as I type.
Warning: suicide
My little cousin that lives like a town away just tried in her backyard by hanging and my mom left our house in a frenzy, leaving my brother in my care, he's 16 but special needs and I'm 21 with an apartment upstairs so she's able to dump him here and run to my aunts house that's like 40 mins away with her bf driving.
I'm... I'm a mess I won't lie and I won't care if anyone says I lie or I'm making it up, I really wish I was, I wish I was. I apologize in advance for anything I say in this comment, I'm just a mess from all of this right now, she and her sisters are like the sisters me and my brother never had, the girly type that would do your hair and gossip but also play in the backyard with mud and bows with arrows and cool things, there's three, the oldest, the middle, and the youngest, 15, 14, 13, respectedly.
The 14 year old is the one that went and tried. I don't want to bring religion into this but as a pentecostal Christian, I prayed for a miracle tonight. I prayed with my bf and brother beside me in prayer.
So thank you, GHOST, for this song. It brings an idea of some of these impossible and harsh emotions right now. I'm also sorry if this makes a landmark on your song or you get traction because of this comment, I wish not for many people to know this sorrow. I don't even want to know it right now, I doubt I'll get any sleep, but I made sure my brother had some valerian root so he doesn't worry as much during rest time.
I'm sorry for rambling. Thank you for being one of the Vocaloid producers that I've grown fond of and grown comfort in. It really means a lot in times like these.
I'm sorry, i hope talking about it helped a little.
A few days ago my boyfriend wanted to do it but thankfully i talked him out of it and now everything is ok
@@Ta-m01 thank you, it was awful
Making another comment to say that Tamari and Mariyam are literally:
Epic Rap Battles of History: ADHD vs. Autism
What happens if you have both?
@@cryptorborgjulien902death
@@cryptorborgjulien902that's when you check out Ghost-P's 'pathological facade' to borrow 'latent aripiprazole.'
Fayrouz abuses you
The animation reminds me of a mix between "honey im home" and "reckless battery burns"
YESS
watched this with my tamari plush and it floated away and fucking exploded rest in peace
your balls are going to explode at 2:45 am on april 22nd.
I find that GHOST’s songs always take a few replays to really appreciate …. And MAN this one is gonna be a BANGER!!
Finally, a plush to achieve the magical feat of being human.
This song makes me want to add wires to my grilled cheese.
Fair enough tbh
Forbidden string cheese
Garnish with a few triple A batteries
@@the.thing. I might get battery burns though. And that would be quite reckless of me.
@@Spxxns_ Twirler's with a twist
I continue to want to hug Tamari. Unfortunately I suspect they probably wouldn't appreciate someone doing that, but. They definitely deserve whatever equivalent they would appreciate.
Tamari plushie
I would like to point out Mariyam’s outfit is the same on the mannequin in Reckless Battery Burn’s MV at 3:36!
This song absolutely made my eyeballs jiggle and my gender become squiggly I love it
Oh 😃
What the hell
Was not expecting the Tamari jumpscare but it’s VERY MUCH APPRECIATED
EVERYONE IS TALKING ABOUT SALPÊTRIÈRE BUT HOLY SHIT THE AMBIGUITY AT THE BEGINNING THE PRONUNCIATION MAKES ME FEEL SO :D
Y'all did it with tamari now do it with Mariyam, make her into a plushy NOW
this person predicted the future
You predicted the future SoySause_tamari
I love how the way Ghost incorperates Arabic into the music videos is like how I incorperate the half bug-half owl creatures into the bodies of my cousins 🥰
Omg same!
@@novinovi- Yes finally someone else does it too 😍
0:27
My ass being the therapist friend and letting anyone vent to me despite also needing someone to vent to, frfr.
frfr
I love the parts of reckless battery burns in the background, and also the way Solaria sounds. Like, she really sounds androgynous in this one, and I absolutely love this. Also, normopathy is now one of my favorite words to say, along with panopticon, glockenspiel, and onomatopoeia.
edit:am I the only one who hears trollolloll in the background?
@@Ta-m01 I agree
I’m happy to be alive rn with all these songs coming out