the commentators dont always sit next to the scoreboard when they commentate and it is much harder for them to keep score than someone watching at home.
When the mistake happens, the Irish commentator is involved in a rather tired monologue about what constitutes a good coach. Neither of them is paying attention to the match. The scoreboard was incorrect anyway so how would that have helped?
Agreed, an apology goes a long way instead of sitting smirking parched up there on your high chair acting like Aga is over dramatising. 99% of players under these circumstances would of cursed the day away over this and Aga remained contained and civil. An apology was necessary. This umpire is now dead to me lol
And sorry, but it's so easy to apologize. Just look at the player, say I'm sorry in a sincere manner, and let the player (who was in the right!) move on and regain focus on the match. ANYONE could get a score wrong, not worth the ego trip.
She can't. They're not allowed to watch a replay either. She doesn't know she did a mistake. She only changed the score because the Barthel agreed with Radwanska.
I feel so sad for Radwanska. The problem is that these instances affect the mental focus of the player as well. It's like, "okay no one's really keeping a track of the points, now I have to do that as well". Darn that's sad.
@@limoncenzo Have you ever played tennis? It is easy to forget what has happened while playing intense rallies, and more importantly the order in which they occurred
@@limoncenzo Of course she didn't forget she lost two points. But its not her job, why is the chair umpire sitting there for? The player's sole focus is to concentrate on the game and not tracking the score.
It’s obvious the umpire was having a mental block about who was serving and the points. It happens to our brains sometimes. No one questioned it because we just assume the umpire won’t make a mistake.
@@piyushpriyadarshi2123 I’m hoping that they do, but in my opinion it’s too little too late. Some of these calls factor in to the results of the match as well as how the momentum swings for the players during the match. I think instant replays should come about due to the nature of a lot of these calls.
I don't think fines are the answer, but their performance should affect their future prospects. An umpire who repeatedly makes poor decisions should be penalised professionally (black mark etc.) and risk losing their licence. Also, 3 umpires, 2 human and one "AI" would allow for a majority vote for difficult decisions where they might disagree.
It's a terrible shame for WTA umpires, that twice in 1 month period Radwańska almost gets robbed by them and supervisor wins her points back. WTA has a long history against Radwańska, crowning Serena Williams Player of the year 2015 when Agnieszka had 54% of votes and Williams 27%, and stealing Radwańska's world no.1 with Azarenka's Rome 2012 cheat entry+withdrawal.
+MrKoval92 Hmm. I dont know where you get the info about WTA player of the year.But considering she didnt won a GS that year and never won any, I dont think she deserve the title.
@ MrKoval92 - I'm guessing based on your name that you're Polish. Truth should come before any patriotism. In 2015, Serena won 3 Grand Slams and advanced into the semis in the US Open. She also won in Miami and Cincinatti and had a semi in Indian Wells, Madrid and Toronto. Radvanska had a single semi in the Grand Slams and has even lost in the 1st round in Paris. Her wins in Tokyo and Tianjin were also Tier 2 events. The Hopman and the World Finals don't trump all other tournaments, even if they were won by your favourite player. Radvanska even fell out of the top 10 that year, how can you say that she was cheated out of the player of the year title?
Then the chair umpire acts like, ok, have it your way ... instead to apologize for making a couple of unbelievable mistakes. As for Barthel being "fair," fair would have been for her to acknowledge Aga won two points. If the decision would have went her way, she would have been ok with it, and that's not being fair.
triple wrong score announcements in one game! yes for 10 years of WTA following I saw that first time too and for such premier level both CU and event. impossible! I would fine Cicak for that match so she will no be sleeping on job anymore.
the only thing i remember similar is venus vs karolina sprem 2004 wimbledon..umpire accidentally gave an extra point to sprem in a tie break and no one noticed..sprem ended up winning that match too
Her opponent is not to blame. Probably as passionate about the game as Aga and simply she didnt know. but the umpire should be fine and suspended for number of matches for this incredible blunder (actually more blunders in one).
Radwanska was high class player, may be the best on tour, she wasn't powerful like Serena or other muscle type players but she played very smart games and won them, it was pleasure to watch her, smartest tennis I've seen ever.
Come on, thats just silly. Its a mistake, which she eventually corrected. Fines and suspensions should be only for biases or cheating and stuff like that.
+1 I also think should be at least a violation point for the umpire or a yellow card for not being focus on the game , common she still called a wrong point after all drama.
Derek Stanyer I mean ok it’s a mistake, everyone makes mistakes but this mistake could have changed everything, it could have costed the loser of this match checks, ranking, the chance to win the title w/e You see Aga actually went to win this game and if she wouldn’t have noticed that the umpire would have stolen a game from her which most likely could have changed the result of this match in favor of Barthel. Again I agree that everyone makes mistakes but you can’t allow that to happen, atleast not without consequences. And really this is one hell of a bad umpire with a billion wrong and unfair calls in the past.
the most annoying thing about the ump, is that she's not even hearing radwanska out. she's in the wrong and admittedly confused, yet is still being stubborn and refusing to listen to what radwanska's complaint is. just let her explain what's wrong and then see what you can do to fix it. I can only imagine how frustrating this must've been for radwanska.
Yes Cicak made some mistakes but she listened to Radwanska, was open to a discussion and let the right thing occur, sometimes, the umpire is just too scared to admit they fucked up so they are not open to discussion. Thankfully in this case, the right thing happened. Love Agnieszka. Standing up for herself
I’m not sure what video you watched. She had no interest in admitting she might have made a mistake. If Radwanska didn’t refuse to back down and insist on talking to a supervisor then she would have lost the game. Even when the mistake was confirmed the umpire acted smugly.
"Barthel" (very fair)" - yeah, it is so "fair" to admit the mistake, once it was PROVEN, and not before that, even though you clearly know that you are cheating. FAIR play indeed...
What’s frustrating when watching on TV sometimes is that you don’t know who won the point and you have to listen to the umpire give the score. If the umpire gets it wrong than you don’t realize it.
Radwanska has a particular history with this tournament, i remember the other one against Nouni when she wanted to replay the point (althought she was right) and nouni said no.
No she challenged that the ball was out even though the ball declared to be in and turns out the ball was in so she lost the point. Doesn't matter if she was on the ball and even returned the ball.
I usually likes Cicak so much. That is very unusual. That's a serious and terrible mistake. Anyway, humans can make mistakes. Barthel "very fair"? Are you kidding me, right? When Radwanska asked her, Barthel just opened her arms and said she didn't know. Of course, when things were clear she HAD to admit Aga was right. Barthel COULDN'T discuss it. It was unfair saying (and smiling) she didn't know and later saying "she's right"
Skella17. Come on. You know the score especially as a server. She got passed on the very first point and hit a point way out. Then she played dumb and said she was confused. She knew it and should have said you know what Aga you did win two points you are correct. Instead she sat there waving her arms. Pathetic. You’re in denial.
sciappi74 agreed very Uncharacteristic of cicak To make so many consecutive errors. She must’ve really spaced out and maybe not had a Juicebox that morning LOL
Sure, but she was mixing it up, so she definitely wasn't keeping track of which was which. And what's more, the people putting the score on the board were just taking her word for it.
@@obliviouz Of course you are correct, but the exact same thing happened to Serena in the USO 2004 match with Jennifer Capriati. Serena returned the ball well within the sideline (with court showing between the ball and the line). The linesman signaled that the ball was in. The chair umpire did not overrule, but stated the score that assigned the point to Jennifer. Serena objected, but the chair refused to correct the call. This is why we have Hawkeye today.
This is just outrageous... it's one thing to make a mistake once, but to keep up with it for a whole game is just incredible. I honestly thought Cicak to be more professional than this. Also, why didn't anyone from supervising say anything before Aga made the call for the supervisor? Unbelievable.
Aga should have asked the lines person who made the call on the wide forehand if he/she remembered calling that point out. But I'm glad it was settled fairly. It would have been nice if the chair had said, "Sorry"....Remember when Venus lost a tiebreak at Wimbledon because the chair got the score wrong?
the opponent should know and have some integrity. i can understand the opponent maybe being confused during the game but afterwards she can mentally remember how what points were won and played.
I think these empires should get penalize for missing things like this. Because they never correct their mistake and act like they can never make wrong call complete bull shit. She knew she fucked up that’s she was not saying much.
Wow what a shame, what an arrogant umpire look when they were arguing even though she was absolutely wrong. She needs to get a sanction from the federation.
People are human and make mistakes, obviously it was not intentional. It’s a bit disturbing that one of the game’s best umps made such a big mistake though. I think the great thing here is that in the end, it was corrected just in time. This would have been soooooo emotionally frustrating for Aga and the shocking thing to me is she has had two matches in a row with a horrible mistake that upset her but was ultimately corrected. You can go a whole career and not have these things happen so it’s unfirtunate luck. Some may say it was hard because Mona thought the game was over but as a player she would have known she only won 3 points. Aga’s winner was clear and as Aga said, Mona lost a second point when she hit a ball a meter out. It’s just my opinion but I think Mona knew the game was still in play but she quickly went to her chair when the score was called and just pretended she was confused. That’s not entirely sportsmanlike either.
It looked like more than one mistake, and even the announcers did not recognize nor the officials sitting behind the umpire. I think Barthel knew about the mistake but said nothing. Aga or her team should have spoken up sooner.
Makes you wonder what the hell that chair umpire has been doing during that game. Texting on her phone or something. You go girl, Radwanska for fighting back hard at that stupid umpire. You earned my respect there.
Cicak looked very bored or thoughtful until it happened. I do not think she should judge this day. Something must have happened in her private life and that is why she was absent. That's why she made a mistake, but it was not intentional.
The worst thing is that seh keeps saying "I remember..." No, woman, you don't remember at all and anyway you should have the humility to simply verify instead of questioning.
I know people make mistakes but it's very frustrating to leave the fate of your career on mistakes like these. Errors like this should not be left behind just by the umpire but anyone that's part of the WTA Staff to get an instant correction. I'm no Tennis Pro nor do I know the rules and regulation of ATP and WTA but rookie efforts like this should be a team effort. At the same time what makes a portion of tennis exciting is drama on the court sadly. IMO.
I was literally there watching during the mistake and that we knew what's wrong and how we want to shout to the umpire it's incorrect but waiting for someone in a formal manner to raise the issue to the umpire. Good that Radwanska was brave enough to raise her question... and when Barthel was asked, she was washing her hands over the issue... We want to shout #replay and let's see the real story... And actually, after that mistake, there was another mistake again during that match....
Wow, I’ve been an umpire before and it’s not easy. But geez. I wasn’t before, but I’m a Radwanska fan now, her Sitting Down Groundstrokes not withstanding. Barthel should have admitted it.
I watched a ladies match at the -99 US open. Capriati was one of the players and got upset with the umpire, who was female. "Are you here?" Capriati shouted.
Shame on EVERYONE at this match! The officials, the players, the coaches, the commentators, and the crowd. SOMEONE should have said something's wrong. And the official knew something was wrong because she corrected herself on the 2nd point, then went on to make more mistakes later.
its amazing to watch badminton and tennis where umpires make blunders which can easily be corrected by replays which are readily available but still they stick to their archaic methods
The opponent knew damn well the score was wrong and simply said nothing when the issue was raised. That is not the way tennis players are supposed to conduct themselves.
Amazing. Nobody in the whole stadium except Radwanska's team noticed the error, including all the officials and commentators. Umpire needs to go on to doing something else. Something that doesn't require concentration.
Logical reaction for a mistake. Do you think anybody that gets a ticket for speeding or doesn't come to a full stop at a stop sign should have their license revoked for eternity? See the stupidity?
They said Barthel was fair not complaining when the score was corrected. She was NOT fair, because she must have known about her two mistakes in that game. She just kept her mouth shut waiting what would be next.
Its true, chair umpires rarely overrule these days, instead relying on Hawkeye and the Challenge System. In a match like this, if she's not keeping score, she's basically paid to daydream in a chair.
Even the players weren't paying attention. It's up to the player to notice the mistake and tell the umpire as soon aa a point is called wrongly. After the game it's too late IMO. It was a very embarrassing performance by the umpire and the commentators. Radwanska should have noticed earlier and not continue playinv while her point was given to the opponent though.
My Music actually she’s been umpiring for a looonngggg time. She’s actually one of the most experience ones out there and gets chosen to umpire a lot of semis and finals at grand slams
Спорт
Embarrassing performance by the commentators as well, not at all paying attention to the match, just babbling away.
the commentators dont always sit next to the scoreboard when they commentate and it is much harder for them to keep score than someone watching at home.
When the mistake happens, the Irish commentator is involved in a rather tired monologue about what constitutes a good coach. Neither of them is paying attention to the match. The scoreboard was incorrect anyway so how would that have helped?
Allen Lye But at the first point, when they hear 15-0 as opposed to 0-15, they should have taken note of it.
you are right ! the game should always come first not banter
Exactly. Maybe if that female commentator would have taken a breath and STFU for a second, they would have realized it.
so many officials and nobody pays attention to the game
Nor did Aga
Can you blame anyone?
@@Frip36 that's right i mean they're out there all day doing it... my mind would wander.. unless i was the fucking umpire...lol
Huge respect to the umpire for apologizing, oh wait... She didn't...
We didn't see the whole thing. I am sure something was said on the changeover.
Women...
@@topneorej insecure little boys...
She’s a woman
@@RossBayCult yeah I wasn't talking about the umpire
By the end, I wouldn't have been surprised if the chair said "35-28".
Dj13e36 hahahaha
70-68 ;)
Actual lol
ahahahah good one :D :D
hahahahah
The umpire should have apologised.
Agreed, an apology goes a long way instead of sitting smirking parched up there on your high chair acting like Aga is over dramatising. 99% of players under these circumstances would of cursed the day away over this and Aga remained contained and civil. An apology was necessary. This umpire is now dead to me lol
And sorry, but it's so easy to apologize. Just look at the player, say I'm sorry in a sincere manner, and let the player (who was in the right!) move on and regain focus on the match. ANYONE could get a score wrong, not worth the ego trip.
She should be fined!!
She can't. They're not allowed to watch a replay either. She doesn't know she did a mistake. She only changed the score because the Barthel agreed with Radwanska.
I remember a chair umpire apologised Roger
literally no one was paying attention to this match... umpire, commentators, supervisors, players.. only radwanska's coach was actually following
In the moment people can be sort of manipulated and just go along with the leader who is the umpire in this case.
Not even the players...
I feel so sad for Radwanska. The problem is that these instances affect the mental focus of the player as well. It's like, "okay no one's really keeping a track of the points, now I have to do that as well". Darn that's sad.
She had to know she lost twice. You don't forget that you put one out and couldn't get the other one.
And not just Radwanska, Barthel too. To think oh I won the game then have to come back and play a game. Thats tough adjustment
@@limoncenzo Have you ever played tennis? It is easy to forget what has happened while playing intense rallies, and more importantly the order in which they occurred
@@limoncenzo Of course she didn't forget she lost two points. But its not her job, why is the chair umpire sitting there for? The player's sole focus is to concentrate on the game and not tracking the score.
wtf? the players are responsible for knowing the score
After all that she says 30-40 🤣🤣🤣🤣 OMG
chunks lol
Hash browns I know man it was hilarious 😁
It’s obvious the umpire was having a mental block about who was serving and the points. It happens to our brains sometimes. No one questioned it because we just assume the umpire won’t make a mistake.
The umpire was trolling Aga 🤣
Phil McEvoy True. What a job! One mistake and u get massacred. Plus u r supposed to seem sure always which is close to a lie.
These officials need to start getting fines for their major mistakes. They need to start being held accountable.
You really think once the mistake is recognised by the governing body that the officials dont get penalized
@@piyushpriyadarshi2123 I’m hoping that they do, but in my opinion it’s too little too late. Some of these calls factor in to the results of the match as well as how the momentum swings for the players during the match. I think instant replays should come about due to the nature of a lot of these calls.
Let's kill them while we're at it
I don't think fines are the answer, but their performance should affect their future prospects.
An umpire who repeatedly makes poor decisions should be penalised professionally (black mark etc.) and risk losing their licence.
Also, 3 umpires, 2 human and one "AI" would allow for a majority vote for difficult decisions where they might disagree.
fired, not fined
Here we go again. It's sad that someone like Aga have to stand up for justice twice in such a short time.
It's a terrible shame for WTA umpires, that twice in 1 month period Radwańska almost gets robbed by them and supervisor wins her points back. WTA has a long history against Radwańska, crowning Serena Williams Player of the year 2015 when Agnieszka had 54% of votes and Williams 27%, and stealing Radwańska's world no.1 with Azarenka's Rome 2012 cheat entry+withdrawal.
+MrKoval92 Hmm. I dont know where you get the info about WTA player of the year.But considering she didnt won a GS that year and never won any, I dont think she deserve the title.
@ MrKoval92 - I'm guessing based on your name that you're Polish. Truth should come before any patriotism. In 2015, Serena won 3 Grand Slams and advanced into the semis in the US Open. She also won in Miami and Cincinatti and had a semi in Indian Wells, Madrid and Toronto.
Radvanska had a single semi in the Grand Slams and has even lost in the 1st round in Paris. Her wins in Tokyo and Tianjin were also Tier 2 events. The Hopman and the World Finals don't trump all other tournaments, even if they were won by your favourite player. Radvanska even fell out of the top 10 that year, how can you say that she was cheated out of the player of the year title?
Then the chair umpire acts like, ok, have it your way ... instead to apologize for making a couple of unbelievable mistakes. As for Barthel being "fair," fair would have been for her to acknowledge Aga won two points. If the decision would have went her way, she would have been ok with it, and that's not being fair.
Instant replay would have settled this in a manner of seconds.
it seemed the video recording is not available instantly to the umpires. not a very organised tour may be.
this is unreal, in half a century i have never seen anything like it
triple wrong score announcements in one game! yes for 10 years of WTA following I saw that first time too
and for such premier level both CU and event. impossible! I would fine Cicak for that match so she will no be sleeping on job anymore.
the only thing i remember similar is venus vs karolina sprem 2004 wimbledon..umpire accidentally gave an extra point to sprem in a tie break and no one noticed..sprem ended up winning that match too
exactly !! it's almost weird it doesn't happen more often..
Normal mistake. They have to switch every game. Bad to make this mistake at pro level but as a human I understand
because they all have display to look at.
it's infuriating to see the commentators talk away, the umpire not doing her job, and radwanska's opponent not stepping up to admit the mistakes
Her opponent is not to blame. Probably as passionate about the game as Aga and simply she didnt know. but the umpire should be fine and suspended for number of matches for this incredible blunder (actually more blunders in one).
This is why women get paid less.
Cuilin Liu I wouldn’t blame Barthel though cos she could also have been confused by the umpire’s score call
@ LOL HAHAHAHA
Cuilin Lui you're an idiot! how do you expect the opponent to notice when Radwanska didn't notice!!
Bravo for Aga for standing her ground!
TV people should provide backup. Wow that was bad umpiring. Asleep at the switch!
Yes, you’re actually right. Resume that game. Twelfty ten.
This really cracked me up 😂😂😂
Twelfty? I think you mean onety-two.
I guess the Commentator was talking about how good the pizza they sell at that particular restaurant.
Radwanska was high class player, may be the best on tour, she wasn't powerful like Serena or other muscle type players but she played very smart games and won them, it was pleasure to watch her, smartest tennis I've seen ever.
Well this is what happens when you have Ellen Degeneres referee such a big match instead of a qualified umpire
Enrique
I was scrolling in the comment section to see who would say she looks like Ellen. The umpire is very pathetic!!! She should be fined.
Walk of shame could do.
@none
Never*
woman's*
job.*
@@miniena7774 , u r a eedyot.
Minien ar yu dum;
Novak would say: FOCUS
It must be stressful for judges to know that a televised record shows their mistakes.
except that they wont be punished for shit, so why should they do the right thing if they know they wont be punished
After all that, she says "30-40"! Mama Mia!
With so much technology available, can't the tournament referees do a real time correction by calling the umpire on the walkie-talkie?
Probably the referees were sleeping too like most of the organisers 😂 hopeless morons.
The commentators too were lost in their own world
with so much technology, why is there even a need for an umpire at all?
@@streamdoll7420 Ya actually why they need umpire there ??
nope, bc they are drunk, like the linesmen/ump
They recruit blind supervisors who sit there and see nothing...
This is very embarrassing for the umpire. She should be fined and suspended.
Come on, thats just silly. Its a mistake, which she eventually corrected. Fines and suspensions should be only for biases or cheating and stuff like that.
The umpire made repeated mistakes. I agree with Light Bearer.
+1 I also think should be at least a violation point for the umpire or a yellow card for not being focus on the game , common she still called a wrong point after all drama.
Derek Stanyer I mean ok it’s a mistake, everyone makes mistakes but this mistake could have changed everything, it could have costed the loser of this match checks, ranking, the chance to win the title w/e
You see Aga actually went to win this game and if she wouldn’t have noticed that the umpire would have stolen a game from her which most likely could have changed the result of this match in favor of Barthel.
Again I agree that everyone makes mistakes but you can’t allow that to happen, atleast not without consequences. And really this is one hell of a bad umpire with a billion wrong and unfair calls in the past.
@@derekstanyer its the fact that she had a smug look on her face and didn't even apologise
the most annoying thing about the ump, is that she's not even hearing radwanska out. she's in the wrong and admittedly confused, yet is still being stubborn and refusing to listen to what radwanska's complaint is. just let her explain what's wrong and then see what you can do to fix it. I can only imagine how frustrating this must've been for radwanska.
Yes Cicak made some mistakes but she listened to Radwanska, was open to a discussion and let the right thing occur, sometimes, the umpire is just too scared to admit they fucked up so they are not open to discussion. Thankfully in this case, the right thing happened. Love Agnieszka. Standing up for herself
She has ONE JOB. If she can't even count, what good is she?
I’m not sure what video you watched. She had no interest in admitting she might have made a mistake. If Radwanska didn’t refuse to back down and insist on talking to a supervisor then she would have lost the game. Even when the mistake was confirmed the umpire acted smugly.
A fine example of terrible umpiring
"Barthel" (very fair)" - yeah, it is so "fair" to admit the mistake, once it was PROVEN, and not before that, even though you clearly know that you are cheating. FAIR play indeed...
What’s frustrating when watching on TV sometimes is that you don’t know who won the point and you have to listen to the umpire give the score. If the umpire gets it wrong than you don’t realize it.
Radwanska has a particular history with this tournament, i remember the other one against Nouni when she wanted to replay the point (althought she was right) and nouni said no.
If you are remembering the radwanska safarova match, Nouni was totally right there
at.kafasi.212 Hell no Radwanska played the point even if the ball was in, the point should have been replayed Nouni gave it to Safarova.
No she challenged that the ball was out even though the ball declared to be in and turns out the ball was in so she lost the point. Doesn't matter if she was on the ball and even returned the ball.
nouni was right on that occasion because the rules are actually screwed up on situations like this
wtf r u talking about, WTA has released official statement confirming Aga was right and apologizing to her
Barthel surely knew what was going on, how could she not know..
This is unacceptable to Aga!
Yeah she uh... took care of it ... Thank you for your support
I usually likes Cicak so much. That is very unusual. That's a serious and terrible mistake. Anyway, humans can make mistakes.
Barthel "very fair"? Are you kidding me, right? When Radwanska asked her, Barthel just opened her arms and said she didn't know. Of course, when things were clear she HAD to admit Aga was right. Barthel COULDN'T discuss it. It was unfair saying (and smiling) she didn't know and later saying "she's right"
Totally agree with everything you said.
Skella17. Come on. You know the score especially as a server. She got passed on the very first point and hit a point way out. Then she played dumb and said she was confused. She knew it and should have said you know what Aga you did win two points you are correct. Instead she sat there waving her arms. Pathetic. You’re in denial.
sciappi74 agreed very Uncharacteristic of cicak To make so many consecutive errors. She must’ve really spaced out and maybe not had a Juicebox that morning LOL
Ya. But most people wouldnt even admit it. She at least changed her mind at the last minute.
She told the umpire she asked her coach and he said Radwanska was right.
The umpire seemed to forget that the score is ALWAYS given as server/ receiver. or 40/30. I thought at first she did not know which player was which.
Sure, but she was mixing it up, so she definitely wasn't keeping track of which was which. And what's more, the people putting the score on the board were just taking her word for it.
You don't even need to know who's who - you can see who's serving. Umpire was just braindead.
@@obliviouz
Of course you are correct, but the exact same thing happened to Serena in the USO 2004 match with Jennifer Capriati.
Serena returned the ball well within the sideline (with court showing between the ball and the line). The linesman signaled that the ball was in. The chair umpire did not overrule, but stated the score that assigned the point to Jennifer. Serena objected, but the chair refused to correct the call. This is why we have Hawkeye today.
Weirdest thing is that no one realised that the score was wrong until somebody told Radwanska after the game.
Quite a few I’m guessing were thinking “oh that’s the game” and went along with with what the umpire said not being sure.
This is just outrageous... it's one thing to make a mistake once, but to keep up with it for a whole game is just incredible. I honestly thought Cicak to be more professional than this. Also, why didn't anyone from supervising say anything before Aga made the call for the supervisor? Unbelievable.
bc they, like everyone else, didnt bother to watch the match
Aga should have asked the lines person who made the call on the wide forehand if he/she remembered calling that point out. But I'm glad it was settled fairly. It would have been nice if the chair had said, "Sorry"....Remember when Venus lost a tiebreak at Wimbledon because the chair got the score wrong?
Wow the umpire went from this to the Wimbledon final chair! (Who decides the umpires lol)
the opponent should know and have some integrity. i can understand the opponent maybe being confused during the game but afterwards she can mentally remember how what points were won and played.
Ya man unless she's life a goldfish, 3:21 what the . . .
It wasn't controversial btw.It was clear umpire terriple mistake.
I think these empires should get penalize for missing things like this. Because they never correct their mistake and act like they can never make wrong call complete bull shit. She knew she fucked up that’s she was not saying much.
Ya always like a boss on the high ground . . . frustrating 🤣😏🙄
5:45 imagine the umpire would say "Game set and match Barthel" after this point of Radwanska 😂😂
I'm so dumb, this whole time, I thought that some person named "noone" had been recognizing the umpire's mistake.
lfmao
Wow what a shame, what an arrogant umpire look when they were arguing even though she was absolutely wrong. She needs to get a sanction from the federation.
Nobady except Bartel, realized the mistake nor Radwanska. Somebody warned her about the error.
This umpire also took a point from Hsieh Su-wei while actually Sabalenka who stopped playing by raising her finger to challenge the service.
In Malay, cicak means lizard
ha ha yesss
tu yang pelik diorang sebut2 pasal cicak hehe
In Armenian it means chilly pepper :D
Luqman Nulhakim da gak org malaysia tgk wta tennis,,,nice
in her own language (croatian/serbian) Čičak means Velcro ;)
It was not controversial. It was very clear. Go Aga !!!
And barthel knew it from the first moment....
i don't think so
She knew it, it was obvious when she said im honestly so confused
Umpire had a look of "Oh, you may get this point but trust me, I will get it back"
People are human and make mistakes, obviously it was not intentional. It’s a bit disturbing that one of the game’s best umps made such a big mistake though. I think the great thing here is that in the end, it was corrected just in time. This would have been soooooo emotionally frustrating for Aga and the shocking thing to me is she has had two matches in a row with a horrible mistake that upset her but was ultimately corrected. You can go a whole career and not have these things happen so it’s unfirtunate luck. Some may say it was hard because Mona thought the game was over but as a player she would have known she only won 3 points. Aga’s winner was clear and as Aga said, Mona lost a second point when she hit a ball a meter out. It’s just my opinion but I think Mona knew the game was still in play but she quickly went to her chair when the score was called and just pretended she was confused. That’s not entirely sportsmanlike either.
It looked like more than one mistake, and even the announcers did not recognize nor the officials sitting behind the umpire. I think Barthel knew about the mistake but said nothing. Aga or her team should have spoken up sooner.
Shut up the fucking ass, fuck you
dude
NOBODY found out, not even the players?!
that's how shitty and uninteresting WTA is
peachy - why are you here watching WTA videos if the WTA is so shitty and uninteresting?
to see what's the drama about by the title of the video, IDIOT
Imagine if this was Serana Williams 🤣🤣
[OCB] she’d kill the umpire
Serena would have caught the mistake at 15-0
Lololol
She would have set the stadium on fire!
P-R-E-P-O-S-T-E-R-O-U-S! Had this been a match with any of the Top 5 players, male or female, the umpire would have been immediately dismissed lol
Makes you wonder what the hell that chair umpire has been doing during that game. Texting on her phone or something.
You go girl, Radwanska for fighting back hard at that stupid umpire. You earned my respect there.
Cicak looked very bored or thoughtful until it happened. I do not think she should judge this day. Something must have happened in her private life and that is why she was absent. That's why she made a mistake, but it was not intentional.
This umpire should have been fired
"Can u call the supervisoorr" i just love Aga Radwanska english slang. Lol.
The worst thing is that seh keeps saying "I remember..."
No, woman, you don't remember at all and anyway you should have the humility to simply verify instead of questioning.
WTF are the dudes w/ the giant cameras doing????!!!! JUST WATCH A REPLAY!!!!
I know people make mistakes but it's very frustrating to leave the fate of your career on mistakes like these. Errors like this should not be left behind just by the umpire but anyone that's part of the WTA Staff to get an instant correction. I'm no Tennis Pro nor do I know the rules and regulation of ATP and WTA but rookie efforts like this should be a team effort. At the same time what makes a portion of tennis exciting is drama on the court sadly. IMO.
fate of a career? its like 3 points.
drunk much?
@@jiogcyihsugyiocjfdoivhphvw6821 you must not play tennis. if radwanska breaked it would've almost guaranteed her the match.
Holy shit, is there not a process for asking the TV folks to quickly review?
I was literally there watching during the mistake and that we knew what's wrong and how we want to shout to the umpire it's incorrect but waiting for someone in a formal manner to raise the issue to the umpire. Good that Radwanska was brave enough to raise her question... and when Barthel was asked, she was washing her hands over the issue... We want to shout #replay and let's see the real story... And actually, after that mistake, there was another mistake again during that match....
The players should be able to ask for a new umpire if this happens
Goes to show no one is there for the tennis.
Wow, I’ve been an umpire before and it’s not easy. But geez. I wasn’t before, but I’m a Radwanska fan now, her Sitting Down Groundstrokes not withstanding. Barthel should have admitted it.
Barthel probably realized she lost 2 points and figured the score had to be incorrect haha
I watched a ladies match at the -99 US open. Capriati was one of the players and got upset with the umpire, who was female. "Are you here?" Capriati shouted.
Shame on EVERYONE at this match! The officials, the players, the coaches, the commentators, and the crowd. SOMEONE should have said something's wrong. And the official knew something was wrong because she corrected herself on the 2nd point, then went on to make more mistakes later.
How I miss Agnieszka Radwanska on court 😍
its amazing to watch badminton and tennis where umpires make blunders which can easily be corrected by replays which are readily available but still they stick to their archaic methods
The opponent knew damn well the score was wrong and simply said nothing when the issue was raised. That is not the way tennis players are supposed to conduct themselves.
Yes for the hundred times...Aga was fucking RIGHT !! none of these spv nor the umpire team took noticed about it..
Barthel knew from very beginning that Radwanska is right but wasn't fair enough to admit it, rather wanted to pretend she doesn't know.
I dunno. It’s not her job to pay attention to the score. You don’t expect this to ever happen and that’s why nobody caught on.
I'm sure there were people who recognized the score was wrong but were too afraid to say anything.
Barthel new it was wrong
Amazing. Nobody in the whole stadium except Radwanska's team noticed the error, including all the officials and commentators. Umpire needs to go on to doing something else. Something that doesn't require concentration.
If u also in the stadium,I doubt u will notice it too
Can u watch all of it for 2 hours and still notice it?
I will fall asleep
Go Aga!
I sometimes feel sad for the referees when players shout at them for a mistake but gotta say never seen a ref admit mistake
Such egos
Like a couple of others have said: strange none of the commentators even noticed!
They were too busy yabbering...
This happens when a seasoned chair umpire treats a match like this as low key...
The umpire should be fired right away. He made three mistakes, which are impossible to cancel out.
She*
Commentator is a joke and the umpire should be fine and ban from any tennis games
Logical reaction for a mistake. Do you think anybody that gets a ticket for speeding or doesn't come to a full stop at a stop sign should have their license revoked for eternity? See the stupidity?
Imagine an umpire like this refering a game with Troicki. Not sure he/she comes back home
They said Barthel was fair not complaining when the score was corrected.
She was NOT fair, because she must have known about her two mistakes in that game. She just kept her mouth shut waiting what would be next.
ITS THEIR ONLY JOB! AMAZING
A lot more to it than that, bunghole
The umpire had ONE job. So incompetent!
Its true, chair umpires rarely overrule these days, instead relying on Hawkeye and the Challenge System. In a match like this, if she's not keeping score, she's basically paid to daydream in a chair.
And now she's the umpire of Wimbledon men's final:))
Of course, we gonna have to balance the gender game
Even the players weren't paying attention. It's up to the player to notice the mistake and tell the umpire as soon aa a point is called wrongly. After the game it's too late IMO. It was a very embarrassing performance by the umpire and the commentators. Radwanska should have noticed earlier and not continue playinv while her point was given to the opponent though.
I totally agree
Cédrik Thibert they are trying to play the game 😂😂
Worst umpire ever!!!
Honestly the worst commentators in English that I've ever had the displeasure of witnessing lol
What a joke.... officials, commentators and crowd didn't pick up on it..!!
She should've said:
"I'm the Sunate!"
This smells of corruption.
Terrible.
This umpire seems to make too many mistakes.
Cmon Barthel. You know you missed that forehand wide....smh
That woman is on her first time making this job??he doesn't understand anything !!!! go home !!!
My Music actually she’s been umpiring for a looonngggg time. She’s actually one of the most experience ones out there and gets chosen to umpire a lot of semis and finals at grand slams
How can Ellen DeGeneres umpire a tennis match? She's a talk show host.
At this level it’s impossible that pro-players didn’t know what the score was.
This umpire made a couple of mistakes in Montreal semi against Sloane, two calls overruled by her, then challenged by Sloane and she was wrong on both