Did the guy at 2:00 say "we will have a top seat as an equal member of The EU?" The mind boggles. Which layer of the EU was he alluding too? On a side note. He looks like an old friend of mine, bit dim.
Welsh independence, just to then go and join the EU. Screw loose... we all need independence from Westminster. As not only Welsh but eng, Scot, n.ire suffer as well
Coming from a small European country ler me tell you that every smaller european nation sees EU membership as something that reinforces our sovereignty and independence. Smaller european nations have always been pushed around by the big powers. Conferences were almost always held by the big States with the smaller ones outside the room being told about their decisions after with no power whatsoever do change that decision. In the EU we are in the room. We can influence and often block those decisions or at the very least arrange for compensation or mitigation of decisions that harm us. Wales and Scotland would be in the same position, instead of just doing what the English tell them to do.
The thing I find amazing is these nationalists who want to leave the UK union where they say they get told what they can and can’t do in that union and then want to join the European Union where they will get told what they can and can’t do if they wanted to be TOTALLY independent then I would get it but not what they want I personally think it’s naïvety
4:16 '' *Wales voted to leave the E.U in 2016 as did the United Kingdom* " Nope , Scotland voted to remain ,Northern Ireland voted to remain - it was England and Wales only that voted to leave.
@@jjwasp1413 But this is my point - due to the fact that Scotland is part of the UK - it's being dragged out of the EU against its will - the SNP enjoyed a huge surge in support for Scottish independence immediately post Brexit. The UK is dying on the vine : Scotland *will* vote for independence within the next five years - demographics strongly suggest that Northern Ireland will join the Republic of Ireland within the next 20/30 years ; as for Wales ? Politically , Wales is in the same position as Scotland was a decade ago . Cherish your prescious Union - it won't last much longer.....
Cwm Pennant Sheepdogs Yeah your language which has only been revived in the last 50 years. Your basically saying the ‘true welsh people’ voted for remain which is just racist and biased. Wales voted leave the figures prove it, so jog on.
Cwm Pennant Sheepdogs Your argument is weak. I’m sure 200 years ago there was a lot more Cornish speakers ffs. And how is the ‘English looting’ welsh land any different from the influx of Eastern European migrants as a result of being in the EU; I don’t have a problem with it but your contradicting an argument you’d put out. And it’s a fact the welsh language has only been revived in the last 50 years look at the statistics .. it wasn’t even till recently the language had to be taught at schools... the language is irrelevant to the Brexit fiasco just accept Wales voted leave a correlation between welsh speakers and the vote is irrelevant.
@K J Your stupid. You have a labour government in the welsh parliament. Heard of devolution? You control most of the powers for your own country : education, transport I could go on, stop moaning and educate yourself
@K J your honestly the most stupid person I’ve ever came across on this app. You clearly don’t keep up with much politics and it’s showing so it’s better you keep your uneducated mouth shut. As you know the Welsh Labour devolved government has many powers, and as you know again the country of Wales voted for Brexit. The welsh voted for brexit :) . Voting for Brexit and the Conservatives wanting it is irrelevant. Labour politicians did too. You seem in denial about the facts, let me remind you again Wales voted Brexit and Has it’s own devolved powers and is happy apart of the U.K. :) xxx
The English have no right to oppress the Welsh or the Scots and dominate their affairs! Yugoslavia was established on much more equal and fair terms than the UK and the situations are not fully comparable
@@McHobotheBobo you know Scotland has free universities and the north of England. Suffers because of Scotland as Westminster spends most of there money on Scotland
Thankfully, this is a minority movement, and many are unaware of the extreme political heritage of the movement. For as long as there are extreme far-right Welsh nationalists, there will never be Welsh independence. We will vote against it, including more moderate and reasonable Welsh people.
@@joshp5842 are they? Obviously, you don't understand what nationalism means. There is no such thing as "left wing" nationalism - if there were, then we could say the Nazis were left-wing! DOH!
@@joshp5842 This is NOT the USA! Wales in not and will never be a republic. In the 60s, nationalists would burn down English homes. That's not socialism. Today, nationalists are spraying over English text on road signs - that's not socialist. NO such thing as a socialist nationalism - that I guarantee you. ALL nationalism is, or tends to be right-wing - whether you like it or not. Funny, since the decline of the Welsh language has occurred during the height of Welsh nationalism. Yet, no one seems to realize the correlation.
@@10hourslooney25 Not a Republic like the USA. More like Ireland. The 60s was FWA, they weren't socialist, correct, but their bombings with the MAC were due to the drowning of Capel Celyn and the investiture. The Meibion Glyndŵr burnt down holiday homes in the 70s-90s, but that wasn't to do with freedom fighting, that was in response to the still ongoing housing crisis. The majority of people that want Welsh independence are socialist republicans, or at least left wing. It's a fact.
Scotaland is anyway going next month wales and Northern Ireland will continue
Olive I hope so
AHAHA, I would love to see that
Yes !! Go Wales !!
Did the guy at 2:00 say "we will have a top seat as an equal member of The EU?" The mind boggles. Which layer of the EU was he alluding too? On a side note. He looks like an old friend of mine, bit dim.
@@joshrees3413 A lot of spelling mistakes for somebody who attends university.
@@joshrees3413 What are you studying?
Annibyniaeth 🏴🏴
Cymru am byth
Your keyboard is broken.
Welsh independence, just to then go and join the EU. Screw loose... we all need independence from Westminster. As not only Welsh but eng, Scot, n.ire suffer as well
Coming from a small European country ler me tell you that every smaller european nation sees EU membership as something that reinforces our sovereignty and independence. Smaller european nations have always been pushed around by the big powers. Conferences were almost always held by the big States with the smaller ones outside the room being told about their decisions after with no power whatsoever do change that decision. In the EU we are in the room. We can influence and often block those decisions or at the very least arrange for compensation or mitigation of decisions that harm us. Wales and Scotland would be in the same position, instead of just doing what the English tell them to do.
Ireland is doing just fine
The thing I find amazing is these nationalists who want to leave the UK union where they say they get told what they can and can’t do in that union and then want to join the European Union where they will get told what they can and can’t do if they wanted to be TOTALLY independent then I would get it but not what they want I personally think it’s naïvety
4:16 '' *Wales voted to leave the E.U in 2016 as did the United Kingdom* "
Nope , Scotland voted to remain ,Northern Ireland voted to remain - it was England and Wales only that voted to leave.
the uk did vote to leave are you stupid
@@jjwasp1413 the UK isn't a nation - but ( excluding Northern Ireland ) *Nations*
@@cymro6537The UK as a whole voted to leave
@@jjwasp1413 But this is my point - due to the fact that Scotland is part of the UK - it's being dragged out of the EU against its will - the SNP enjoyed a huge surge in support for Scottish independence immediately post Brexit.
The UK is dying on the vine : Scotland *will* vote for independence within the next five years - demographics strongly suggest that Northern Ireland will join the Republic of Ireland within the next 20/30 years ; as for Wales ? Politically , Wales is in the same position as Scotland was a decade ago .
Cherish your prescious Union - it won't last much longer.....
@@cymro6537 ok
I used to be called by my English name Dick Hard but now I prefer the ancient Welsh version of my name! Sugna fi nawr!
His arguments are weak. He should remember that Wales voted for brexit.
Anthony Mitchell The polls say otherwise :)
Cwm Pennant Sheepdogs Yeah your language which has only been revived in the last 50 years. Your basically saying the ‘true welsh people’ voted for remain which is just racist and biased. Wales voted leave the figures prove it, so jog on.
Cwm Pennant Sheepdogs Your argument is weak. I’m sure 200 years ago there was a lot more Cornish speakers ffs. And how is the ‘English looting’ welsh land any different from the influx of Eastern European migrants as a result of being in the EU; I don’t have a problem with it but your contradicting an argument you’d put out.
And it’s a fact the welsh language has only been revived in the last 50 years look at the statistics .. it wasn’t even till recently the language had to be taught at schools... the language is irrelevant to the Brexit fiasco just accept Wales voted leave a correlation between welsh speakers and the vote is irrelevant.
@K J Your stupid. You have a labour government in the welsh parliament. Heard of devolution? You control most of the powers for your own country : education, transport I could go on, stop moaning and educate yourself
@K J your honestly the most stupid person I’ve ever came across on this app. You clearly don’t keep up with much politics and it’s showing so it’s better you keep your uneducated mouth shut. As you know the Welsh Labour devolved government has many powers, and as you know again the country of Wales voted for Brexit. The welsh voted for brexit :) . Voting for Brexit and the Conservatives wanting it is irrelevant. Labour politicians did too. You seem in denial about the facts, let me remind you again Wales voted Brexit and Has it’s own devolved powers and is happy apart of the U.K. :) xxx
Edward I longshanks will rise from his grave and subjugate these rebellious welsh.Dont even think of independence😂😂 JK
Nice report love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩🇧🇩
The Welsh independence but still what money off Westminster
United forever 🏴🏴🏴🇬🇧
Most annying age is ~20yo. They put heir noses every where but know nothing.
There was me thinking you could only find traitors north of the border !
Are you Serbian because they have experience is this Yugoslavia
@@Lewis-rq3of , Yes I’m a British born Serb that’s why I can see parallels between the break of of Yugoslavia & the attempt to break up the UK
The English have no right to oppress the Welsh or the Scots and dominate their affairs! Yugoslavia was established on much more equal and fair terms than the UK and the situations are not fully comparable
@@McHobotheBobo , How exactly are the English oppressing the Welsh ?
@@McHobotheBobo you know Scotland has free universities and the north of England. Suffers because of Scotland as Westminster spends most of there money on Scotland
Thankfully, this is a minority movement, and many are unaware of the extreme political heritage of the movement.
For as long as there are extreme far-right Welsh nationalists, there will never be Welsh independence.
We will vote against it, including more moderate and reasonable Welsh people.
The majority of Welsh 'nationalists' are left wing.
@@joshp5842 are they? Obviously, you don't understand what nationalism means. There is no such thing as "left wing" nationalism - if there were, then we could say the Nazis were left-wing! DOH!
@@10hourslooney25 the majority of Welsh 'nationalists' are socialist republicans. Wales is not a right wing country.
@@joshp5842 This is NOT the USA! Wales in not and will never be a republic. In the 60s, nationalists would burn down English homes. That's not socialism. Today, nationalists are spraying over English text on road signs - that's not socialist. NO such thing as a socialist nationalism - that I guarantee you. ALL nationalism is, or tends to be right-wing - whether you like it or not. Funny, since the decline of the Welsh language has occurred during the height of Welsh nationalism. Yet, no one seems to realize the correlation.
@@10hourslooney25 Not a Republic like the USA. More like Ireland. The 60s was FWA, they weren't socialist, correct, but their bombings with the MAC were due to the drowning of Capel Celyn and the investiture. The Meibion Glyndŵr burnt down holiday homes in the 70s-90s, but that wasn't to do with freedom fighting, that was in response to the still ongoing housing crisis. The majority of people that want Welsh independence are socialist republicans, or at least left wing. It's a fact.
Need to remain in the United Kingdom.