I'd love it. If anything (unpopular opinion) I'd love her to make a Rock/Punk oriented album. She should go back to her roots and really reinvent herself like she used to. I know she won't ever do it because most of our fan base is made by dance/pop lovers but I'm still hoping.
@Onika tanya I have heard her say in interviews she doesn’t like to repeat herself. As for your question. I’m not sure why you are asking me. I don’t know Madonna personally, so I’m not sure how you expect me to answer, unless you think I’m going to phone her and ask. But on the issue of nostalgia: how can you move forward in life if you are always living in the past?
jose jiron Porque es cool ser viejo ya que se ha ganado experiencia y sabiduría. Con suerte tú, yo y otros tanto también envejeceremos. De eso pocos se escapan. Estamos envejeciendo desde el día que nacimos. Y gracias por lo de Señor pero el único Señor es Dios. Los demás sólo somos seres humanos pasajeros en este mundo.
Damn, I love early Madonna, pre-first album...I mean I love every album but isn't it amazing how many genres and sounds she's covered and done so well. She was meant to be an artist. A musician. A revolutionary. I'd love to cover these songs and the Emmy ones. There all amazing.
seeing her at Danceteria in New York circa '83 it was obvious that she was a couple of years behind in terms of looks(neon bracelets, mesh tops, teased hair) and sound(the worst of ny dance-pop), but these early recordings are pretty incredible.
Well you know by then she hasn't picked up a guitar in over 15 years since her first solo album came. They have people who were monsters on guitar but if they haven't picked up an instrument in over 10 years they'll have to start back from basic. Take for instance, Vinny Vincent. He was a great guitar player and a huge shredder. He reappeared in the spotlight for the first time in 30 years. He started playing again but wasn't the same. All he did was play common chords that were about it.
I was impressed to find that Madonna did write a lot of her songs. I'm still not terribly impressed by the songs, but I thought they were written for her. I have a little more respect for her because of that. Not a lot, but some. I wouldn't really say that any of those songs stir up any more thought or emotion than any other pop song though, so I can't really go along with the idea that her having actually written some of those songs makes her an artist. Not saying she's not - just that none of those songs make her one.
@@matthewatwood8641 No respect? You don't have to like her music... but no respect? She is showgirl! Giving it her all... and yes she writes most her songs.... but she's smart enough to work with the best of the best, and she has a nose for talent and she trusts on her own tastes.... You can only but respect her.... just say you are not into her music, too commercial.... too whatever... I am not a fan... I like some of her music... And she irritates me quite often... But it is so difficult to do what she has done.... most artists would have made an album or two.... she kept on rolling, with energy, passion and emancipation ...
During the 80s, Madonna & Stephen Bray wrote and produced dozens of successes, while Bray continued in Breakfast Club, Madonna had left the band for a solo career. In the late 80s, The Breakfast Club got their own successes in the US charts with "Right On The Track", "Never Be The Same" & "Express Way To Your Heart". Shortly after, the band broke up and the 2nd album that had recorded with MCA was never published.
Tracks from the previously unreleased BC 2nd album recorded in 1988 have been leaking out gradually since 2016. The EP called "Percolate" has several catchy songs, including "Court of Love" and the textbook sophisti-pop "Can't Put My Finger On It". Listening to BC's punk origins, it is almost hard to believe it is the same core band members.
People that can't accept the mere fact that artists can sing when they're able to carry a tune and read music. She's also had quite solid vocal performances in her Pop career and she always sings live. This video is also the proof that she could sing since the beginning. There's this theory that if a singer doesn't hit notes a like Celine Dion isn't automatically a singer. I'm the first person that detests that bunch of Pop entertainers that can't sing a note and are wrongly passed off as singers, especially by the fans that are always in denial but you know, not being the best singer is one thing and being completely untalented is a total different matter.
I think that this is definitely more full-throated, ballsier singing than most of her pop career, at least the first track. Madonna, pre all that production, just making music. I'd be more than a casual listener of this alternate reality Madonna.
I don't say she can't sing, I just say she's not a great singer. I think a lot of people echo that sentiment. For some reason people go bananas over madonna, and assign her this icon status when she's just a cheesy pop star from the '80s.
This IS GOOD! I knew Madonna was punk rocker at heart and the rage that it was in the late 70s. I hear Elvis Costello and B-52s in these songs. What an invaluable learning experience for her and yet it was good that she busted out on her own.
She's not even the handmaiden of Pop. Ever hear of Whitney Houston or Mariah carey? Madonna can't hold a candle to them or many other female pop stars. It's ridiculous to give Madonna all these accolades. She doesn't deserve it.
@4Tlccas It says I have ears & I can hear. Saying Madonna is in the league of any singer I mentioned is objectively false. Simple as that. It's not even opinion. Madonna can't do what they can do with her voice. Case closed. But go ahead & insult me some more, lol.
Holy shit I never thought madonna could sing. It turns out the "pop queen" was born to rock! Her vocals are amazing here! I love this more than her pop stuff! Rock on madonna!
I like Kurts answer, its quite respectful of Madonna, however he made an assumption about her ignoring the punk scene in NY. She was in a punk band "The Breakfast Club", both singing and playing drums.
I think he knew this but he was stating she chose to ignore it. She chose to focus on a different genre of music that's all. That's what he was pointing out.
This is one of the best recordings ever not exactly a fan of Madonna but a lot of respect for the Emmys and the breakfast club, imagine if she did a punk album now
The Love Express was one of her Emmy recordings, true. But these recordings here were done with the Breakfast Club, before she left to form the band Emmy & the Emmy's.
If you have some sort of musical ear you can clearly hear Madonna had already developed a distinctive and recognisable singing voice with a hint of pop even when this was recorded. It’s only logical she progressed and moved on quickly to more pop/funk oriented stuff after this. I’ve never been a big fan of Madonna, but it’s always interesting to hear how people started out. Thanks for the upload!
I'll argue with anybody that Gwen Stefani from No Doubt was heavily influenced. By Madonna from the look all the way down to the vocals especially on this song right here?
The first song is a great punk rock song. I also love the jangle Punk sound of the clean Rick guitar. Actually pretty original. And a sound that wouldn't be really hurt again till the late '80s and early 90s. From Riot girl bands. Madonna's always been just a little bit ahead of her time. These guys definitely have their own sound. I dig it.
@@fanatp0stpanka partly because madonna annoys me and partly because it's just fun to me, I like to argue. only talking to people who agree with you is like dancing with yourself.
IT's a shame this stuff will never have an official promotion and release, simply because the copyright owners will forever be having bitch fights over who owns what
That's exactly what I thought, I'm a huge Nirvana fan and a lot of their songs reminded me of them while I was watching the movie. Crazy, I think this band was ahead of their time and could have been huge
@@DaniCat99 I'll leave you guys guessing which bit from which song from this Madonna EP matched up with which bit from which nirvana song. Smell's Teen Spirit takes the intro from another band's song Australian Crawl - Daughters of the Northern Coast (the guitar and drum intro bit) ruclips.net/video/iYSN8z0x7m0/видео.html . Nirvana were on a Geffen subsidiarity DSG. Guns and Roses also on Geffen (as were Crawl) also stole music from Australian Crawl, a more substantial chunk from the Crawl song Unpublished Critics. The Nirvana thing you could write off as coincidence. Not the GNR rip. The guitar intro, the vocal line and the breakdown, are a facsimile. ruclips.net/video/oxqreCG0htQ/видео.html I still like GNR, but it kind of takes away the mystique when you know that they're not original enough to come up with all of their own stuff on their first album.
@Walter McDonald i don't know sorry. One of the easybeats guys, became a producer. But mainstreams Aussie music of that era was way out of my wheelhouse. From the moment i could interact with music, i was a music snob. heh.
Madonna - Love Express for America... Kylie Minoque - the Locomotion for Australia! Christian Anders - Train into Nirvana for Germany 🤣 Vanessa Paradise the Taxi for france 😋
Is this first song playing at the right speed? It seems slightly faster than normal, which makes her voice sound like Alvin and the chip monks, but super punk. I love all of this. It's so break through pre punk new wave.
![Emmy - No Time For Love [Studio Demo] (early Madonna)](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/XKgTUybIbG8/mqdefault.jpg)
Imagine Madonna performing a breakfast club medley in one of her tours... would be so cool.
The Saint yup- Rebel Heart Tour. she always performs at least one song on the electric guitar since the Re-Invention tour in 2004
I'd love it. If anything (unpopular opinion) I'd love her to make a Rock/Punk oriented album. She should go back to her roots and really reinvent herself like she used to. I know she won't ever do it because most of our fan base is made by dance/pop lovers but I'm still hoping.
@@xxxTIN0xxx Madonna doesn’t do nostalgia
@Onika tanya I have heard her say in interviews she doesn’t like to repeat herself. As for your question. I’m not sure why you are asking me. I don’t know Madonna personally, so I’m not sure how you expect me to answer, unless you think I’m going to phone her and ask. But on the issue of nostalgia: how can you move forward in life if you are always living in the past?
@Onika tanya but if I’ve never met her, and clearly I’m not a mind reader HOW do you expect me to KNOW. Is a pretty stupid question to ask
A punk Madonna? Hell yes! I love it!
0:01 on the ground
1:35 shine a light
3:13 little boy
4:47 love express
Lia Petunia 0:01 is safe neighborhood
@@AlexeBriand2002 it s on the ground
Yasmina Belmelat no, it’s called Safe Neighborhood
@@AlexeBriand2002 demo is called "shit on the ground"
Yasmina Belmelat not according to the documentary Madonna and the Breakfast Club
0:01 Safe Neighbourhood (Shit On The Ground)
1:35 Shine A Light
3:13 Little Boy Lost
4:47 Love Express
Madonna Punk Rock. Me gusta este sonido más underground!
jose jiron Porque es cool ser viejo ya que se ha ganado experiencia y sabiduría. Con suerte tú, yo y otros tanto también envejeceremos. De eso pocos se escapan. Estamos envejeciendo desde el día que nacimos. Y gracias por lo de Señor pero el único Señor es Dios. Los demás sólo somos seres humanos pasajeros en este mundo.
+jose jiron Esa "vieja y fea" luce mejor que tu madre.
+TITUSPUNKER excelente respuesta!!
Damn, I love early Madonna, pre-first album...I mean I love every album but isn't it amazing how many genres and sounds she's covered and done so well. She was meant to be an artist. A musician. A revolutionary. I'd love to cover these songs and the Emmy ones. There all amazing.
seeing her at Danceteria in New York circa '83 it was obvious that she was a couple of years behind in terms of looks(neon bracelets, mesh tops, teased hair) and sound(the worst of ny dance-pop), but these early recordings are pretty incredible.
Reminds me that Belinda Carlisle was a TOTAL PUNK before she became pop. So was Madonna! Loving it!
The Go-Go’s started off punk but crossed over into pop punk. They hung around that crowd though.
What’s crazy is she knew how to play the guitar but in the late 90s she had a guitar teacher and made it sound like she hadn’t played before.
Well you know by then she hasn't picked up a guitar in over 15 years since her first solo album came. They have people who were monsters on guitar but if they haven't picked up an instrument in over 10 years they'll have to start back from basic. Take for instance, Vinny Vincent. He was a great guitar player and a huge shredder. He reappeared in the spotlight for the first time in 30 years. He started playing again but wasn't the same. All he did was play common chords that were about it.
This is amazing, how does this not have more legend status!? This is incredible, really enjoyed it.
Because it's not really that good.
Her voice sounds so cute
she a TRUE artist, most of these old songs were written entirely by her!!
If that's true she stopped being a true artist & hasn't been one since 1980. I doubt she wrote any of these songs anyway.
I was impressed to find that Madonna did write a lot of her songs. I'm still not terribly impressed by the songs, but I thought they were written for her. I have a little more respect for her because of that. Not a lot, but some. I wouldn't really say that any of those songs stir up any more thought or emotion than any other pop song though, so I can't really go along with the idea that her having actually written some of those songs makes her an artist. Not saying she's not - just that none of those songs make her one.
@@matthewatwood8641 no one cares
@@whitelightenergydads lol, two months later and people are still yelling at me.
@@matthewatwood8641 No respect? You don't have to like her music... but no respect? She is showgirl! Giving it her all... and yes she writes most her songs.... but she's smart enough to work with the best of the best, and she has a nose for talent and she trusts on her own tastes.... You can only but respect her.... just say you are not into her music, too commercial.... too whatever... I am not a fan... I like some of her music... And she irritates me quite often... But it is so difficult to do what she has done.... most artists would have made an album or two.... she kept on rolling, with energy, passion and emancipation ...
During the 80s, Madonna & Stephen Bray wrote and produced dozens of successes, while Bray continued in Breakfast Club, Madonna had left the band for a solo career.
In the late 80s, The Breakfast Club got their own successes in the US charts with "Right On The Track", "Never Be The Same" & "Express Way To Your Heart".
Shortly after, the band broke up and the 2nd album that had recorded with MCA was never published.
+Gina Sousa Branco Nice comment Gina!
Tracks from the previously unreleased BC 2nd album recorded in 1988 have been leaking out gradually since 2016. The EP called "Percolate" has several catchy songs, including "Court of Love" and the textbook sophisti-pop "Can't Put My Finger On It". Listening to BC's punk origins, it is almost hard to believe it is the same core band members.
Bootleg does exist of her 2nd
who says she cant sing she sounds good here good band
Do people say she can’t sing??
@@cheddarcheese7928 lol ALWAYS
People that can't accept the mere fact that artists can sing when they're able to carry a tune and read music. She's also had quite solid vocal performances in her Pop career and she always sings live. This video is also the proof that she could sing since the beginning. There's this theory that if a singer doesn't hit notes a like Celine Dion isn't automatically a singer. I'm the first person that detests that bunch of Pop entertainers that can't sing a note and are wrongly passed off as singers, especially by the fans that are always in denial but you know, not being the best singer is one thing and being completely untalented is a total different matter.
I think that this is definitely more full-throated, ballsier singing than most of her pop career, at least the first track. Madonna, pre all that production, just making music. I'd be more than a casual listener of this alternate reality Madonna.
I don't say she can't sing, I just say she's not a great singer. I think a lot of people echo that sentiment. For some reason people go bananas over madonna, and assign her this icon status when she's just a cheesy pop star from the '80s.
Madonna meets Blondie.
Debbie Harry was a major influence on her
Yeah, like the early-days stuff, fer sher.
This IS GOOD! I knew Madonna was punk rocker at heart and the rage that it was in the late 70s. I hear Elvis Costello and B-52s in these songs. What an invaluable learning experience for her and yet it was good that she busted out on her own.
Not Punk Rock, & Madonna was never a Punk.
she taught herself how to drum by listening to elvis costello records
dude this shit is actually dope has hell
Madonna had the talent and she been queen of pop later in her life
She's not even the handmaiden of Pop. Ever hear of Whitney Houston or Mariah carey? Madonna can't hold a candle to them or many other female pop stars. It's ridiculous to give Madonna all these accolades. She doesn't deserve it.
@4Tlccas It says I have ears & I can hear. Saying Madonna is in the league of any singer I mentioned is objectively false. Simple as that. It's not even opinion. Madonna can't do what they can do with her voice. Case closed. But go ahead & insult me some more, lol.
@4Tlccas They are far & away better singers than Madonna.
@4Tlccas Saying Madonna is a Punk is an insult to every Punk Rocker everywhere.
@4Tlccas Cindy Lauper.
This sounds very good! I like it! First time in my life I listen to it. And I was young in the 80´s
we were all young in the 80's silly goose!!!!!!!!
Ive heard all there songs these are just a few they have alot more😃still so cool !
Madonna and the Breakfast club documentary brought me here! Luv them both❤️
I never knew Madonna was in a group too I thought she was always been an solo artist
Two. After leaving The Breakfast Club, she founded Emmy & The Emmys.
Madonna is a Punk at heart- this proves it!
So good and it's actually from the late 70's!
she was in new York and London in the late 70's. so she was definitely there for that whole movement
She's very versatile
can't really pin her down
I don’t know about her being punk but she is definitely very talented!!!
@@johncohle8331 she wasn't in London. She was in Paris.
@@georgegeorgiev3946 ?
Wooow that's Madonna ... Pure punk rock! 🤘
Holy shit I never thought madonna could sing. It turns out the "pop queen" was born to rock! Her vocals are amazing here! I love this more than her pop stuff! Rock on madonna!
I LOVE Cold Wind. Such a different sound.
She’s always had those influences and the rock attitude
They're all right, but amazing?
C'était vraiment pas mal du tout, pour un début...
Madonna était déjà très prometteuse, vraiment talentueuse.
wow I wish we had more of this side of Madonna
I like Kurts answer, its quite respectful of Madonna, however he made an assumption about her ignoring the punk scene in NY. She was in a punk band "The Breakfast Club", both singing and playing drums.
I think he knew this but he was stating she chose to ignore it. She chose to focus on a different genre of music that's all. That's what he was pointing out.
This video comes to mind when i heard kurt said that i was like “no she didnt!”
love it - a new respect for her
So Gwen Stefani before Gwen Stefani
Well Gwen has been very influenced by Madonna so it's not a surprise.
@@enriquesanchez9016 Yeah but in her looks, i dont think Gwen heared Madonna doing ska and punk
@@cleo5942 I think the pop sound of her solo albums was influenced by Madonna too, apart from the look.
@@enriquesanchez9016 yeah, i agree with that point
Gwen never played drums
It's a little punk, a little Velvet Underground, a little poppy, and a little New Wave.
This is one of the best recordings ever not exactly a fan of Madonna but a lot of respect for the Emmys and the breakfast club, imagine if she did a punk album now
I know all these tracks but Love Express, so brillliant x
I can only imagine what would have happened if she had gone this way with her music.
This songs actually were recorded when Madonna was a member of Emmy & the Emmy's.
The Love Express was one of her Emmy recordings, true. But these recordings here were done with the Breakfast Club, before she left to form the band Emmy & the Emmy's.
This is simply brilliant ! Can someone publish in real CD Album please !
Very interesting!80's Alternative rock!
Madonna Music I hate that word alternative to describe music.
The Police and the Beastie Boys started in punk, too..
Like all the goods bands in 80s
Duran Duran was another example also.
Steve Bray is playing drums, she's on guitar....
and Gary Burke on bass
Love her voice in the early, so melodic and girlish
I Love You Madonna No Matter what you do.. you just got better and better!
Rock Lobster
Happy Birthday Madonna!
The refrain/bridge sounds like a part of "Burning Up"
Maaan, she was a very solid drummer!!! 🤯👌⭐⭐⭐
Madonna is so damn talented
Love seeing this. I remember back in the 80's , people saying that this band ripped off the movie name. LOL to funny now. Thanks.
the band was started in nyc in 1979….the movie came out six years later in 1985…
@@heyoletsgo9 Kool. Thank You.
fast b52s love it...
Madonna ❤️
If you have some sort of musical ear you can clearly hear Madonna had already developed a distinctive and recognisable singing voice with a hint of pop even when this was recorded. It’s only logical she progressed and moved on quickly to more pop/funk oriented stuff after this. I’ve never been a big fan of Madonna, but it’s always interesting to hear how people started out. Thanks for the upload!
Love this
Germs meets Madonna. Someone just sent this to me in a message. Not my favorite thing ever, but cool artifact for sure
I hear a hint of Violent Femmes in that song. KOOL!
I'll argue with anybody that Gwen Stefani from No Doubt was heavily influenced. By Madonna from the look all the way down to the vocals especially on this song right here?
In Don't Speak video she's dressed like her in Live to Tell, she has always admitted that Madonna was her inspiration
The first song is a great punk rock song. I also love the jangle Punk sound of the clean Rick guitar. Actually pretty original. And a sound that wouldn't be really hurt again till the late '80s and early 90s. From Riot girl bands. Madonna's always been just a little bit ahead of her time. These guys definitely have their own sound. I dig it.
You're so full of it. There's nothing original about any of it.
@@matthewatwood8641dude you've been bitching about the woman in every comment on this video holy shit we get it you don't like it why bother
@@fanatp0stpanka partly because madonna annoys me and partly because it's just fun to me, I like to argue. only talking to people who agree with you is like dancing with yourself.
I love this music.
The Queen of Pop
Madonna on drums! never knew that before
IT's a shame this stuff will never have an official promotion and release, simply because the copyright owners will forever be having bitch fights over who owns what
Holy crap, this is like No Doubt in the early days with Gwen Stefani
haha, that was exactly what I was going to write
@@auroraborealis6398 Wow I wrote this on another video from her "Emmy & the Emmy's band"...Glad I'm not alone on this!!
one of the million women that Madonna influenced directly is Gwen
Love this!
awesome thanks so much!!!
punk rock at its best
Respect. Kind of impressive to hear that she sang AND played the drums.
Wooo she had soul ❤️🎵
This is just brilliant !!!
Blondie and Madonna would've been up there competing if they would've been at CBGB'S at the same time
blondie would've ripped her to shreds
fucking GOOOOOOD
Surprize, surprize... Never heard of that Song!
Weird, Madonna wrote a nirvana song.
dleetr which song?
That's exactly what I thought, I'm a huge Nirvana fan and a lot of their songs reminded me of them while I was watching the movie. Crazy, I think this band was ahead of their time and could have been huge
@@DaniCat99 I'll leave you guys guessing which bit from which song from this Madonna EP matched up with which bit from which nirvana song. Smell's Teen Spirit takes the intro from another band's song Australian Crawl - Daughters of the Northern Coast (the guitar and drum intro bit) ruclips.net/video/iYSN8z0x7m0/видео.html . Nirvana were on a Geffen subsidiarity DSG. Guns and Roses also on Geffen (as were Crawl) also stole music from Australian Crawl, a more substantial chunk from the Crawl song Unpublished Critics. The Nirvana thing you could write off as coincidence. Not the GNR rip. The guitar intro, the vocal line and the breakdown, are a facsimile. ruclips.net/video/oxqreCG0htQ/видео.html I still like GNR, but it kind of takes away the mystique when you know that they're not original enough to come up with all of their own stuff on their first album.
@Walter McDonald i don't know sorry. One of the easybeats guys, became a producer. But mainstreams Aussie music of that era was way out of my wheelhouse. From the moment i could interact with music, i was a music snob. heh.
awesome
Kurt Cobain brought me here
I’m so happy to read this 🧡
@4Tlccas are you literally gatekeeping? Lmao. Whatever dude, we can like whatever the fuck we want to
@@itsjustvincey7309 fr
What's the connexion?
He was always right. Welcome❤
if you want something, you have to work for it
THIS GOES SO HARD
Somebody knows, where can I download this cd record in Cd or Mp3?. Thank.
This is why Beastie Boys opened for her on the Virgin Tour
muy buenoo ..madonna punk
Madonna invented grunge .
this sounds as the first album of The B52s
1:00 i see where "Burning up" came from
Exactly! You see the evolution right here! Its fascinating.
Almost the melody of the middle eight of Burning Up... :)
I also hear the Cure guitar style, and her deeper voice on the first song sounds like Open Your Heart
Its great to hear this! I like it!
🥁🥁 Madonna play the drumms 🤩
"So rare its on youtube"
yes hon, thats how information works
...and we all should be glad...still...😀
Yeah you were lucky someone found, downloaded & posted for your ass to complain about . 🙄
Amazing 🌟
Madonna - Love Express for America... Kylie Minoque - the Locomotion for Australia! Christian Anders - Train into Nirvana for Germany 🤣 Vanessa Paradise the Taxi for france 😋
Já demonstrava afinação e talento!!!!
Perfeitaaa né. Amo a voz dela
Wow ! I didn't know that , it's actually good .
like Madonna meets Joy Division and Cure alone in the dark park..hah
The first song reminds me of Burning Up.
Rebellion Madonna 💪🏽
this is actually the first time I really really like madonna
LOL
I still do
I hear sublime,it's really cool actually!
Pau Wegman how sad
Wayyyheyeah
Well, this was a nice surprise
WHOAMAHGAWD
Love this I want one
Some parts of this song reminded me Burning Up
Is this first song playing at the right speed? It seems slightly faster than normal, which makes her voice sound like Alvin and the chip monks, but super punk. I love all of this. It's so break through pre punk new wave.
LOVE!)))
Sounds a little between No Doubt and Arctic Monkeys
Ooo this sounds good.
first song s got a few melodic lines of "burning up"
great