How To Make Wilderness Exploration FUN | 5e | TTRPG | D&D | Web DM
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 июн 2024
- This week, we're talking about how to make Wilderness Exploration REALLY FUN, why it's not fun enough in 5e right now, and what we're doing both in Weird Wastelands and at any table to make it better. Our Kickstarter for Worlds of Web DM: Weird Wastelands is LIVE NOW! Check it out here: www.kickstarter.com/projects/...
Time stamps:
0:00 Introduction
1:39 What’s wrong with wilderness exploration?
3:27 The “story” of wilderness survival
8:12 Resource Tracking - easing the burden of managing resources: time, food, water, shelter
16:55 Mechanics - simple procedures with clear stakes
GET MORE WEB DM! We've got a bonus podcast on / webdm that you can get every single week where we go into way more topics, answer your questions, and have way more benefits too. Become a Web DMN today!
#dnd #dungeonsanddragons #ttrpg
Facebook - bit.ly/2oGKLOg
Twitter - / webdmshow
Instagram - web_dm
Written & Hosted by Jim Davis and Jonathan Pruitt
Produced and Directed by Emma Lambert
Edited by Brandon Fraley
Web DM was created by Travis Boles, Jonathan Pruitt, and Jim Davis
Art by Ambrose H Hoilman ambrosehh.com/home.html
Music by John Branch -branchoutguitar.com
Web DM Theme by Kyle Newmaster - kylenewmaster.com 
Игры
Thank you so much for watching and for your support on Weird Wastelands, y'all! We LOVE the Web DM community! To learn more about the project, click here: www.kickstarter.com/projects/webdm/worlds-of-web-dm-weird-wastelands?ref=1getph
Would love to see some good cross community support! You guys should get in touch with fellow Dnd RUclipsr AJ Pickett who is also running a Kickstarter right now that would pair wonderfully with your book: Silicone maps, character sheets, and combat initiative trackers!
I'm eagerly awaiting its arrival.
It might just be screen glare, but Pruitt getting a faint purple tint on his glasses looks really rad actually 😎
Matches his shirt.
Literally doing DnD in an hour and the second part is a lot of wilderness, my phone notification popped up with this video, what kismet!
Have a great game!
For those unaware, "kismet" is a word of supposedly Turkish origin that means 'fate' or 'destiny' (at least if I understand Merriam-Webster correctly).
I think that Forbidden Lands did a really good job with creating ratings for supplies and making them matter for wilderness exploration and travel. Dungeon World's Perilous Wilds supplement also did something similar (though I haven't tried it myself yet). Five Torches Deep also does a good job of abstracting supplies, although they do so with supply points (that you can spend in the middle of exploration on things like rations, rope, etc.) rather than with a rating or a target number that you have to roll.
I love the resource rolling discussed in this vid! Absolutely using that. Helps make resources valuable and add realism without bogging the game down into Accounting 101.
Just popped in to feed the algorithm and say you guys are amazing!! I'll listen to the patron version later on.
Thank you so much Spencer!
They have absolutely top tier DnD advice. Web DM and Matt Coville are like the holy trinity of DM advice on RUclips, IMO.
@@greylithwolf Oh I completely agree, I only wish that Matt put out content as regularly as he used to.
Totally stoked for this Weird Wastelands book though! Bye Money 👋
I always have your episodes playing while I prep my sessions for good ideas. Keep rocking 🤘
Thanks Holden!
I can't count the number of times I've read a post or subthread online where the DM or player states they detest counting anything - not just food and water. Ammunition is hand-waved, encumbrance is ignored unless it's absurd, and even cost of living expenses are deemed "not fun." People say things like, "I'm not an accountant," or, "I play games to get away from worrying about that sort of thing," or, "Heroes don't run out of arrows." I find all those paths unsatisfying. Glossing over resource management removes a significant challenge of the game. Those who ignore it are missing out on a satisfying, rewarding aspect of the game that enhances play. I'm glad to hear there's a resource on the way to bring detail to this lost pillar of the game.
I've been running a DCC campaign, with travel rules borrowed from Oregon Trail.
Running it has probably been the best TTRPG experience I've had.
If you want to introduce things like water, to your exploration. Remember GMs, it only cost 15 GP to buy a donkey, barrel, and packsaddle which will carry 40 gallons of water (10 days of water for 4 party members).
And the mule/donkey/horse? What about it¨s water? They drink more than humanoids.
@@laoxep get a second one if your going the full 10 days. Otherwise the barrel of water will cover you for the few days it takes to reach the next water source where you can refill it.
@@laoxep that is more or less the point. People complain about not having anything to spend gold on. Look back at older editions of the game and you quickly find that many groups spent their gold on caravans of npcs. Why trudge through the wilderness in an easily attacked 3 man group? It's so much easier to spend 1% of your profits from the last dungeon to hire 30 henchmen and townspeople to carry supplies, tend beasts of burden, look after the 12 guard dogs keeping watch at night, and carry torches on the way into the dungeon and treasure on the way out.
uhu and how would you that when you hit some narrow hunter's trail or other obstruction horses and donkey's can't go past? my players had to make decisions and abandon a lot of stuff along the way. so that donkey and barrel might be good in theory, but impractical when actually going out in the wilds. good luck climbing that mountain with a donkey. or the age old entering a dungeon. tying the horses and such to a tree. then when the heroes are in the dungeon for days... they come out and find the animals gone or killed and eaten.
@@GiblixStudio
Oh no, you mean the players might have to make tough tactical decisions sometimes? Sounds dreadful. Just line up the goblins for fireball, sigh from boredom, and move on to the next non-challenge.
The illusion of you being in the same room together is good enough that I feel deeply uncomfortable seeing you never make eye contact for even a moment.
Thank you for touching on Magic food
Goodness gracious, you guys get me so excited to DM every time. Love your work.
I totally agree that in high fantasy games like Pathfinder and 5E D&D it really is annoying that with a special ability or two and a 'ranger-spel" 90% of all wilderness challenges are just wiped of the table, especially when playing a ranger type character or maybe the opposite; a bunch of clueless city-slickers in the wild is an adventure in itself.To ditch that is ditching the very essence of adventure itself! It's all about the journey not the destination!😃 Just deal with exhaustion, hunger, cold, navigation, poisonous plants, crossing swollen rivers, scaling rock-faces, tracking, hunting, building shelters,fires and traps, using secret ranger and Druid signs and finally be a proper ranger and/or Elf and keep your party alive and teach your partymembers to travel light and not haul all that shit.Hell Dm give that massive pile of gold you'll have to carry through desert, mountains or jungle in a realistic way; it'll be the bread and butter for one of your best and most worthwhile adventures not in the least because everybody will be able to relate better and quickly be submersed in the greatest teacher humanity ever had ; MOTHER NATURE AKA THAT 💚GREEN HELL💚
I'm so beyond excited for this book, it seems like exactly what I've been looking for! The fact that it comes from WebDM is gravy! Thanks guys!
Man it would be sick to see some extra resources for alchemical builds, I love how xanathar had cool kits for tools and crafting potions and items. Wasteland or frontier based infusions would be dope. Love the idea of your techno wizard. Thaumaturgical spell casting in a magical wastelamd is always sick
Here’s what I love about this channel. You guys have stayed true to your approach for the last five years at the cost of a few subs. I’m sure you guys know all of the little click bait tricks but you don’t use them. You guys approach every topic very differently from most other RUclipsrs in that you stay with high level concepts instead digging into the crunch. Its a nice contrast from most other channels, although I enjoy some of those channels too. I’m really glad to still have you guys. Good luck on your Kickstarter-- I’m going to back it on payday
I'm running a game right now where I want wilderness exploration to be a major component and I found this very inspiring! Went ahead and snagged the book and the DM screen for Wild Wastelands as well! Big fan of your guys' stuff.
Oh man. I just got home from a long walk. Thanks guys!
This is great advice! Love these dudes' personality and outlook too, definitely subscribing for more.
You guys are great. I wish I could keep your ideas in my head when I'm rushing to keep up with my players at the table
I plan to use the guide for a arc in my Ebberon campaign in the mourn land. I'm excited.
Tx for the show, guys.
Excited for this my dudes.
Ah this explains why you mentioned Lone Survivor's Guide to Bushcraft. You guys were making your own survivor book!
I immediately backed this. I love your ideas and am eager to see them in print!
Thank you!
Glad to say not only was I able to back your Kickstarter buuuut ...
I'm also starting two new campaigns just finished the map and I'm dropping the hex grid on top today.
As always gentlemen your timing is impeccable and I wish you good luck on all your future endeavors.
I missed watching you guys. Always so interesting and informative. I love 5E.
When you talked about Goodberries and magical food, it reminded of the Potion Miscibililty (sp?) table from 1e AD&D and how drinking multiple potions could have some unpredictable and extreme effects. I love your way of thinking about it. Going to back your kickstarter now. March 2022 can't come soon enough.
Early birds where u aaaat
We're here!
We are here!
Here 🖐
Good idea to put out this video. Definitely convinced me to back the kickstarter.
I'm geeked for this book !
I have developed a little system that the groups consumption of rations is determined by a 1d4 die. I also had three "paces" the group can travel in. "Slow" gives -1 to the 1d4 consumption die. "Normal" gives no modifiers and "Fast" gives +1 in friendly terrain and +2 in tough terrain.
Tied together with the Scout role that has the "Forage" ability and the Cook role with the "Cooking" ability that also has their outcomes determined by die with modifiers, I think its abstract enough with some randomness that keeps the pacing going but they still have to worry about rationing without becoming an accountant.
I can't wait for the release of this book guys! It sounds like it will be great for my own game
My group revamped foraging and some problematic spells (goodberry, create food and water, etc.) and we now have much more fun with exploration!
Hey Jim and Pruitt, I've commented on this before, but I'm currently running a wilderness exploration hex crawl and your videos have been instrumental. What you describe about players becoming deeply attached to their characters in these types of campaigns rings so true, at least for us. Our last session's conflict was nothing more than having to cross a river, but it was 300 ft wide and they're only level 3s... it ended up being quite the challenge and they really had to pull together. Looking forward to your book, keep up the great work!
Great feedback, thank you! Glad you're having the same experience as we have, it's incredible when it fires on all cylinders
Good stuff! looking forward to the book nice job with an abstraction that compacts a normally overlooked aspect of fantasy roleplay.
I need to punch up on my wilderness exploration, so this video is a godsend. Also, I can't believe how well the Kickstarter is doing! You guys are great.
Thank you Rene! Glad to help
Very excited by this video. I definitely want to run some hexploration asap.
One point about the eagles and LOTR, the Eye of Sauron was in place for a reason. One doesn't just soar into Mordor.
Also, all the lands were crumbling and about to tear each other and themselves apart. If Eagle Rush worked, which it probably wouldn't have, the world's still broken and heading to a dozen wars.
Super excited for your book!!
Thank you!
God I am so thrilled to hear more about the project - every time I hear more I get more enthralled in having it and you expansion on exploration rules
You should check out Forbidden Lands. Its seems like its the source for a lot of the rules that are being referenced. I've implemented a lot of the lessons learned from FL and other Year Zero Engine games by Free League in lots of other RPGs
@@sandpaper I just got FL like a day before this vid dropped (just watching now) and for a sec I thought I was hearing a FL review. lol I backed early because I like the idea of supporting WDM but I doubt I'll use the book. Will just play FL(which I am loving!) and not deal with 5e bloat.
"I don't want to remove even more from the game". Ahh. So true!
I love the idea to just view the spells from a different angle. Introduce complications to those spells.
Btw: I modified my resting rules a bit and they seem to put a reign on some of those spells too.
1: Short-Rests are about 10-15 minutes long.
2: I use the slow healing rules from the DMG. So you use hit dice on your long rests to heal.
3: On a long rest you only get back half your spell slots and hit dice (rounded down).
3a: Exception are Warlock spells and features like breath weapon etc.
3b: I might introduce a option to convert Inspiration into a single hit dice (not sure about vice versa).
Now the PCs have to be a bit more mindful about spell use. Create Food & Water, Good-berries etc. are now way more expensive.
Maybe if they eat to much good-berries still - they have to save or lose a hit die for that day.
I am very interested in the resource die mechanic. Sounds really promising.
Let’s go! More one shots to write for beach trips!
Woot!
AHHHHH I NEED THIS BOOK IN MY LIFE!
I'm always craving more content for this
Backed this so hard. This seems right up my alley, and not in the Blackadder sense. Now the only problem is how the hell do I stay patient for 8 friggin' months?
Thank you for your support!
I know riiight
This is awesome! I've got an idea for several campaigns that could benefit from these ideas!!!
Love the Consumable Resource dice mechanic. Will be adding that to my games in the future
@23:45 it's what plants crave
I'm so hyped for this book
The lack of really straightforward and simple wilderness rules, and the fact that exploration is a pillar of the game that some classes can just ignore, is in my opinion the great flaw of an otherwise pretty good version of DnD. Glad to see you all have addressed it
You know what the weirdest thing is, in the playtest there was really straightforward survival rules all in the same location. Furthermore, it has examples of how survival in a campaign would be run. I don’t have a clue why they wouldn’t include these rules in the DMG because their work had already been done!
@@Exisist5151 It could have been a matter of space. They may have cut it out out of concern for keeping the page count to a certain number and the text flow/structure straight.
@@Draeckon Maybe, but still, it’s much more worth it to me and I’m pretty sure most other consumers of the DMG, for it to have the full set of rules rather than pieces of it, even if it might break the flow a bit.
Backed...and oh, if only I could have this NOW! Even just the sweet, sweet flask.
This video really speaks to me as I've been playing both Pathfinder Kingmaker and Assassin's Creed Odyssey where wilderness exploration is an important part of the games
Okay so I just went to your site to look at the book and I want to say that like what I see and I'm considering picking up a copy for myself. I'm especially excited for the wilderness adventure portion, which is something the community really needs. I'm not going to lie when I saw the orc casting a spell I thought she was using a guitar as a casting focus. That might not end up in the book, but the energy is there. I’m already thinking about how to do a magic based mad max fury road campaign.
Something on exploring, as I've done that in my youth. Are you exploring in an area that has been explorer before? Or going from one place to another that people already had gone before. We are a social species, and we require the survival of more people to keep our species alive. That's how we survive, and we keep doing so, specially in a setting like D&D, we would share knowledge of such things for free, it's both our nature and instinct for surviving. Now, if they are going into an unexplored area, then the safety thing to do with rations is to take either a lot more or turn back once half the rations have disappeared and there is no way to acquire food in the wild.
I explored caves, explored mountains and forests, swamps, deserts and so on. It was a fun activity back then, there are rules for safety though even back then since it was just me, my siblings and my mother.
I love a gritty game with survival mode so looking forward to seeing your book for this
Excellent video as always guys
Thank you
You should check out Forbidden Lands. Its seems like its the source for a lot of the rules that are being referenced. I've implemented a lot of the lessons learned from FL and other Year Zero Engine games by Free League in lots of other RPGs
In the spirit of making wilderness fun. I enjoy equipment management, but i dislike the 5e system for it. i often exchange weight management for a slot system. You freely carry a belt with a main and off-hand sheath, 20/20 ammo pouch (or quiver), a 30/30 component pouch, a 5/5 water skin for short rest hit dice, a 1/1 ration pocket for long rests, and a tool kit satchel (tools can be replaced with larger items such as hunting trap, 10' retractable pole, or door ram, etc.)
Additionally, your STR score x2 is your carry weight slots. backpacks and mounts and carts significantly add to the carry slot number for the party, but you risk losing it all if you go into a vertically challenging terrain without a game plan to lift a pack mule 50 feet up a rock wall (make block & tackle great again lol) also, make rangers great again, so they can navigate your pushcart full of mined copper ore thru the cave and out again. but i digress.
i give out loot like crazy, but they all have random die slot mechanics for the sizes they take up in carry weight. When there is an hour worth of travel between each section of a "dungeon" (to far to backtrack) and too much to carry, players have to fomo to leave something behind to pick up something new. which mean they may drop some extra torches or rope to grab more loot. Not even myself as the DM knows what its value yet, as the dice decide this as well. they are often caked in mud, fossilized, or rusted (very nondescript)
When the party long rests, what I do is "perceived" value. the higher you roll, the better % chances you have of having something of great worth. make a roll to identify the item, then note that number next to the item. if you fail the percentile roll it is still mundanely valued for gp equal to the amount of your roll.
Choose one:
Perception + weight= % chance of being highly valuable to a merchant.
Arcana + weight = % chance of being enchanted
History+ weight= % chance of being valued by a specialist/collector who might trade up with rare items.
Investigation + weight = % chance of being something very useful. particularly something clutch to the mission.
Religion + weight = % chance of yielding a blessing, bane, or augury.
Nature + weight = % chance of gaining experience or boon
I've been dying for this video
I picked up rime of the frost maiden a while ago but I was still a bit lost for how to run the exploration in the setting. I think this book could be a big help.
I like the idea of a hybrid approach. Leave trivial things as meaningless (food and ammo). Set aside time in the adventuring day for minor foraging and fishing, arrow and bolt making. Let there be a chance for food to spoil or a quiver to accidentally dump out, and the consequences of that.
I see ammo as almost punishment for a ranged character as you don’t really ever run out of longsword. Some of that can be attributed to the comparative safety inherent with attacking from a distance.
Looking forward to the finished product. I have to say that there a lot of quality of life features that are way to easy for the players to get ahold of in D&D. One of my biggest pet peeves is anything that lets players fast travel of bypass areas with ease. Another one is all of the magical huts and whatnot that let players rest without the burden of having to worry about getting attacked during the night. Though this has not been so much of an issue in this campaign, my last one it was. Honestly, there will be various things that will simply not be making it into my next game. It just kills great opportunities within the game.
One method to limit some of the ease of use and fast travel stuff is to just alter the thematics and descriptions then have your players roleplay through the changes you made.
For example, Goodberry. Don't change anything about the mechanics of the spell or limit/ban the use of it. They can cast goodberry all they want. But like Jim said in this and a few other recent videos, magic food is the worst thing you can put in your body. So every time their teeth piece the skin of a goodberry tell your players they feel like they're being waterboarded with lemonade.
It also helps to play the adrenaline shot scene from Pulp Fiction and tell them "Yeah, that's what it looks like whenever you cast revivify, or use magic, potions, or goodberry to get back up while making death saves."
I become increasingly more interested in your vision for the game.
Been wanting to run an exploration/survival game for so long. Really excited to see this is going to be in the book
You should check out Forbidden Lands. Its seems like its the source for a lot of the rules that are being referenced. I've implemented a lot of the lessons learned from FL and other Year Zero Engine games by Free League in lots of other RPGs
All fantastic, I just wish it were out sooner because I need these rules now xD
I can't wait for your book. Survival is a sorely missed part in woc content.
Thank you!
Love your videos...definitely the most insightful and thoughtful among your peers. This is aside from the main topic of this video, but I just wanted to throw in a different perspective concerning ammunition. Yes it's dumb for a PC to carry hundreds of arrows, but I would question how a PC could find that many arrows. It is actually difficult to make arrows by hand that fire correctly. I think the DM has the freedom within 5e to make ammunition harder to come by...scarce, expensive, and only from an NPC fletcher or a PC with Woodworking tool proficiency (which is what XGtE suggests, 5 each day, only if the materials are available).
For a long time I've loved the idea of abstracting resources such as rations, torches, ammunition, etc. with decreasing resource dice. It simplifies the bookkeeping but doesn't completely remove it.
22:00 is good stuff.
for more veteran tables, the burden should be a part of the journey.
one thing I do is require generalized "components" to cast a spell but are consumed. Similar to how sourcery was explained in the witcher series. something must give and something must take. this makes monster hunting a more meaningful journey. Spell focus merely negate cast fail chance, but anything with component feature must have something to consume. Base 3 components down into a +1 component to make higher spell attk and save DC, or kill a high CR monster to collect high +1 or +2 compenents.
"For sure we could sneak around these trash mob goblins, it's not worth our time, but we could use the easy kills for some goblins toenails, since my component pouch is getting low. and we can sell the rest to the local alchemist, or, i might can brew a poison with it, or make a scroll of stinking cloud."
See? the burden provides motive. it makes the story pace out that much easier when players are focused on being optimized verses being brave to push on. In this way, you don't need to write countless plot beats. The necessity to survive will make for a good narrative as you work your way towards a singular easy to remember and highly motivated plot beat.
Thanks.
so pumped cant w8
Keep it up fellas
One of those arrows that "missed" you was stopped by you quiver damaging it an allowing half you arrows to spill out.
I really dig the resource abstraction die mechanic concept. Particularly with ammo it smoothes the disconnect with feeling like you ought to carry inordinate amounts of ammo. In game terms it makes sense but narratively speaking who would even imagine they might need 200+ arrows between excursions
I carry more than that many rounds when I am in country fighting for America... Why does that number sound weird to you???
@@jasminebebe3455 200 bullets vs. 200 arrows? idk how to answer your question, it just seems unusual to imagine a fantasy adventurer expecting they might need that many at a stretch. I'm not saying it's unprecedented in real life though.
@@DougVehovec Not saying you would have them all on your person but possibly in a pack or a horse or a cart.
Just started reading wheel of time and wow do they really sell you on the character building of travel. My first big fantasy book and yeah they spend a lot more time moving and experiencing adventure on the road than much else.
Backed the KS today, mostly due to curiosity about the new Psion class and because I'm a complete RPG book freak.
I give rangers Advantage on Survival rolls for navigating and foraging, instead of automatic success.
I straight up give them expertise in their favored terrain.
I let Rangers keep deft explorer from Tasha's, but favored foe/enemy are replaced with favored mana. I took the 5 colors of mana from magic the gathering, plus colorless, and let rangers pick one color at 1, 6, and 14.
Creature types, races, backgrounds, classes, and terrain types are all mapped to one of the 6 color options. Players deal an extra 1d6 on 1 or 2 attacks a turn if the color identity of the creature they hit matches one of their colors. They also get one or two languages common to their color, and advantage on all Dex, Int, and Wis checks made in terrains of their color or while dealing with creatures/cultures tied to their color.
To give credit where it is due, the usage die concept is from an osr game called The Black Hack
i made cards, with 12 encounters on them, taking up front and back. labelled for dif types of terrain, then made a card with 12 behaver's. such as hunting, resting, fighting, running etc. combining them to make quite a few dif out comes. and i am making more, so i roll which card i am going to use then. roll on the card then roll the behaviour. Then i am working on my own way of doing the Trailblazer, scout, quartermaster and warden. with degrees of success ranging from, you travel normal time, to asking the players to tell me what is here, such as land marks or maybe dungeons. Yeah, i have fallen in love with the hex crawl, combined with 'normal' storytelling. forbidden lands was my gate way drug for it :)
I had a player play an abhorrent mind sorcerer and take the navigation feat. On one hand, we lost the ability to get lost…but on the other hand, each time we navigate I have an in game reason to move ahead a bit as well as give them a chance to narrate how they lead the party through the uncharted areas.
People usually play 5E as if the world between zones of interest is not a zone of interest. It impoverishes the game so much. I myself use the rule 1-2. For every single (story relevant) encounter in a specific location (city/village/fort/lair...) there are 2 related encounters "on the road". Distribution of the story throughout the world, really makes the world alive.
I got it alongside Helianas.
There are so many class features / options / skills that never really get used if you skip the journey. No matter the game system. Clerics create food and water / purify water , ranger abilities etc….
The travel / survival aspect is important. It makes reaching that small settlement and a good nights rest at the inn a reward in itself.
The resource tracking streamlining is important though to make it a mini-game.
Resource die is a really great concept... I'll be buying a pdf of the book for sure, but damn could I use the details of that system right now! Would just love to drop 5-10$ for a pdf of just that bit.... right now.
Coooool
Music at 0:34?
Also I will say I usually don't buy non-official books, but with what you guys have said about this so far I will have to make an exception to that.
Thanks for your support! As for the song, it's from a licensing library. Pretty sure it's called retro sci Fi or something like that
Having to travel and suffer occasionally doing so can even give credence to character bad attitudes or the approach they will take to solving problems after getting to town
How do you recreate the serendipity of stumbling across something you weren't expecting to find?
I never use fast travel even when it's an option in video games anymore. The only exception is in instances where it's the only option; I remember in Ocarina of Time there's a puzzle where adult Link goes to a place and learns the song to warp to that place, and then he has to go back in time so child Link can play the warp song because otherwise the place is inaccessible in the past.
if you guys have ever played outbreak undead, what you described for dice for supplies sounds similar to their system
The guys have not but Emma has and it's fun!! Can think of a few other games with that kind of system as well, it's clean and it works.
I think Breath of the Wild would serve as a good example of how to make exploration just as fun, if not more so, as completing main quest. Obviously it's not a one to one example since BotW is a video game instead of a TTRPG but I think many of the principles still apply.
Here to be learn! Whatcha got this week? 😁
Backed, hoping that some of these mechanics can easily slip over to other systems (Cypher, TinyD6, Dungeon World, etc.).
Definitely should be!
I was not super excited for this book at first. It just seemed to be about a setting I wasn't interested in running. These mechanics have piqued my interest. Not sure if I'll support the Kickstart yet, but I'll definitely take a closer look by the time it goes to print.
I have very similar issues with exploration and arrow like resources. These are brilliant fixes and wizards should pay you to include them in a future book.
What about weapon condition for long journeys.
Something like a hit die for your equipment that you can use on a rest for basic maintenance. Each time you use the "repair" you can drop the die level by 1(d10 to d8 to d6...) You wouldn't so much worry about sudden breakage as you would dread watching your equipment slowly deteriorate.
could you do a video on lizardfolk?
They very lightly touched on lizardfolk in their dragonborn video, but I'd be genuinely interested in a longer RP and world building video on all the scaly races and any potential ties they have to the primordial elder dragons that may or may not have ruled any given setting in "The before times. In the long long ago."
I like goodberry. But I also like the idea of limiting it by making it so your character only wants to eat a goodberry as a last resort. You eat them to fend off starvation or when you're down and making death saves so the ranger puts one berry between your teeth and presses your jaw closed.
So far my best idea is to say that goodberry does everything the spell says, but as soon as their teeth pierce the skin of the berry your character feels like they're being water boarded with lemonade.
Your player sacrificed a slot that they could have used for damage or utility so you then punish them twice over... got it.
This makes no sense, the same amount of energy needed to feed the party for a day is the same as that needed to boil water to make them each a cup of tea, once.
Caster's have the ability to warp reality, cure the dying, unleash napalm hell, summon high explosives from thin air, animate the dead, precision bend light, but can't make a tasty sammich?
Okay so apparently I was the only one paying attention to the part of the video where Jim talked about limiting magic food consumption becuase it's literally the worst thing you can put in your body in every myth, fable, and fairytale where magic food comes up.
I get that it's hard to pay attention and you guys might not have noticed that this video is talking about very specific homebrew rules to add chellenges back into the exploration pillar of the game. But if you're just here to nitpick over limited use houserules while ignoring the context and content of the video you can kindly piss off.
Edit: also, how exactly is turning Goodberry into an easy route to recreating the adrenalin shot scene from Pulp Fiction "punishing the players?" I never even mentioned changing the mechanics of the spell. Just the thematic effects that should be roleplayed through.
My god! The system me and my friends have been developing makes frequent use of a usage die system! Im never been more happy and so gutted at the same time that someone beat me to the punch.
Not implemented in the exact same way it seems but certainly interesting how like-minded people come up with similar solutions to problems.
Also Land of the Freak and Weird Wastelands ! Mad
Opportunity cost is still a cost! Yes, a spell can take care of it, but you lose out on another spell.
This sounds like the Forbidden Lands resource system.