First Contact - Should we Reply?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 11 окт 2024
  • Subscribe - goo.gl/wpc2Q1
    SETI - The Early Years
    Perhaps life on Earth was the most impossible fluke, never to be repeated in the infinity of space. But on the balance of evidence one conclusion emerges. Conditions could’ve been the same on other planets billions of years before the birth of the Earth, which is a relative latecomer to the cosmic scene, and the Universe could be teaming with life far more advanced than our own.
    So what if we ever do receive a message? Whether this becomes the day the Earth stands still, or the day it goes into a flat spin, will depend on how well we are prepared to deal with it. And what about “them”, they’re certainly smart, but are they peaceful or aggressive - should we take the risk and answer back?

Комментарии • 117

  • @Piedone21
    @Piedone21 4 года назад +6

    If they are far more advanced, it doesn't matter if we reply or not. What they do to us it's out of our hands

  • @chaz000006
    @chaz000006 4 года назад +8

    The silence is deafening.

  • @SonyDjuana
    @SonyDjuana 4 года назад +5

    They probably contact us but we can't listen coz we are not in the same dimension as them.

  • @TaPharoah
    @TaPharoah 3 года назад +2

    2001??? Can we get an up to date video? 😒

  • @cobrasvt347
    @cobrasvt347 4 года назад +2

    8429.6 Mhz lol. When this was made that would have been considered an achievement. Today one can buy a transceiver on the internet to do 10 times that frequency. Technology as time goes by is hilarious at how fast it progresses.

  • @Shaden0040
    @Shaden0040 4 года назад +1

    Why do we assume they MUST be more advanced than we are? We have sent signnals directed at other star systems already, plus we've been broadcasting radio and TV signals since the 1890's. We cannot assume they are more advanced than we are. We can call out to distant stars light decades away from us, even hundreds of light years distant, and yet we can barely reach the heliopause of our solar system in travel over 1/3 of the time we've been broadcasting into space.

  • @paulfrain3670
    @paulfrain3670 4 года назад +3

    What happens when you point all that microwave power at a specific Target say something more local LOL

    • @StayMadNobodycares
      @StayMadNobodycares 4 года назад +1

      I think targeted radiation is a real thing the military has had for a good while now.

  • @Naek2763
    @Naek2763 4 года назад +6

    the ancient astronaut theorist suggest yes!

  • @Shaden0040
    @Shaden0040 4 года назад +3

    We're in it this far now, lets answer. It all depends on how close they are. anything over 500 years answer. anything closer reply cautiously.

  • @warhorse1956
    @warhorse1956 4 года назад +3

    Don't we have enough aliens here already?

  • @paulfrain3670
    @paulfrain3670 4 года назад +1

    I wonder ,it must be enormous amounts of energy those projects consume.

  • @Healitnow
    @Healitnow 3 года назад

    If they are contacting us instead of just sending out random signals it is too late not to answer since the very act of contacting us shows they already know we are here.

  • @gage1nate2
    @gage1nate2 4 года назад +3

    They’ll have to open up that Book of Enoch 🤔

  • @Zichronot
    @Zichronot 4 года назад +8

    This is 20 years old!

    • @jong2359
      @jong2359 4 года назад +4

      Some concepts never age.

    • @paulweisgerber7654
      @paulweisgerber7654 4 года назад +1

      Is age an indicator of value, Old Woman?
      (lol, I know what you’re saying. I’m 56, so I just thought I’d tease you a little!)

    • @Zichronot
      @Zichronot 4 года назад +1

      @@paulweisgerber7654 heh I listen to old stuff all the time .

    • @paulweisgerber7654
      @paulweisgerber7654 4 года назад

      The Old Woman
      Heh, me too. I talk to myself all the time! But then I tell myself not to listen, ‘cause that old guy doesn’t know what he’s talking about.
      By the time the fight is over, I’m ready for a nap! 😴🙃

    • @thomasdarby6084
      @thomasdarby6084 4 года назад

      My point, ditto.

  • @ivarslinis9273
    @ivarslinis9273 4 года назад

    Jared Diamond as always is on the point. And most probably right.

  • @SrI-fv9oe
    @SrI-fv9oe 4 года назад +2

    Humans mind changes everyday... I think they would probably reply

  • @manuelmanu128
    @manuelmanu128 4 года назад +4

    I say yes 👍
    Yes we should reply
    I'm waiting for reply
    I am so curious about the reply

  • @stoobydootoo4098
    @stoobydootoo4098 4 года назад +1

    'E really ees blaind! I just pulled ze funniest face, & he deedn't even smeerk.
    Après 'Murder by death'.

  • @RellshouldBsleep
    @RellshouldBsleep 4 года назад +1

    Yeah we should reply but not right away... don't want to seem desperate

  •  4 года назад +1

    There has been kind of a ladder of contacts, each step forward (up or down who knows) is shorter than the other. 1) In prehistory, 100 thousand years ago, when modern humans were achieved; 2) From sumerian to mayan, nearly 4000 years of continued contact; 3) Modern times, less than 100 years. Are we climbing up or down the ladder?

  • @stargazer7555
    @stargazer7555 4 года назад +1

    Flat Earthers would go crazy if this happend

  • @ronaldanderson2723
    @ronaldanderson2723 3 года назад

    2021 still waiting for answers

  • @Balthazare69
    @Balthazare69 4 года назад +1

    If aliens come on earth rn, they would just say... ooookkkk, we r made mistake, goodbye!!!

    • @madisoncarolina9848
      @madisoncarolina9848 4 года назад

      They will come 2024 to usher in the One world Government, #Project bluebeam

  • @benistingray6097
    @benistingray6097 4 года назад

    Of course we should, if they cant reach us they are no danger, if they can they are technological that far ahead of us that there is no benefit for them doing us harm.

  • @leafdude69420
    @leafdude69420 4 года назад +2

    Wait a minute, new life?

    • @stoobydootoo4098
      @stoobydootoo4098 4 года назад +3

      Depeche Mode's breakthrough single 1981.

    • @Harbalz
      @Harbalz 4 года назад

      @@stoobydootoo4098
      🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

    • @leafdude69420
      @leafdude69420 4 года назад

      @D_N yeah. But they didnt even made it fly, so it more of a fail ufo

  • @jeff_n1535
    @jeff_n1535 4 года назад +1

    Telepathically.

  • @christywoods9180
    @christywoods9180 4 года назад

    Yes,Of course We should and will,lol,And Already have many many many decades ago.Some are already here But When They come here and Disclose,The World will be shocked and Scared at first,but find out quickly they are quite friendly and kind and only peace here woth no nuclear weapons.

  • @hairullyt2999
    @hairullyt2999 4 года назад +1

    Why should i reply ?

  • @FSCforal
    @FSCforal Год назад

    we should not reply because the cost of calls are high, have you ever called australia??

  • @vinny142
    @vinny142 4 года назад

    SETI is interesting but a waste of time.
    We can only listen to a tiny fraction of the sky at a time so get any kind of remotely usefull coverage they listen only for a few seconds and them move on to the next bit of sky.
    This means that the transmitter must have been on at a *very* exact point in the past for the signal te reach earth right at the point that SETI happens to be listening to that bit of sky.
    If we have problems listning, then think about the transmitters, they have the opposite problem; trying to send a tera-watt signal to every bit of the sky, and they have to send something recognizable to all locations *AND* listen for a reply.
    this is why SETI does not listen for messages, they listen for machine-sounds, which is linked to the absurd notion that all alien life is so advanced that they can build machines that harness the power of an entire star, which is required to make the kind of electromagnetic noise that we might be able to hear here.
    Now comes the realitycheck: the only planet that we know to have life is earth, and of it's trillions of lifeforms only *ONE* species is sufficiently intelligent to develop radio. And we know that humans only got to exist because the dino's wher wiped out in a freak accident.
    Humans have only had technology for 100 years of its billions of years of existance. And most importantly: even with our limited intelligence are reducing power consumption, we are busy avoiding the need to harness a star's power. The *ONLY* life we know of is actively avoiding doing the thing that SETI expects aliens to be busy doing.
    And then there's the timeline; in order to receive a signal of any kind,it must have been transmitted exaclty long enough ago to meet earth when SETI is listening in that direction. If aliens finished their Dyson sphere 10 years earlier, we'll never hear it.
    If we do receive a signal,from 500 lightyears away, will they still be listening 1000 years later? And will we after another 500?
    There are more usefull ways of spending money than this.

  • @chha6439
    @chha6439 4 года назад

    10 million a year would feed a lot of people that are struggling in life.I mean really struggling. Do you realize there are people that are starving. Still you have your head in the clouds. How do you sleep at night?.

  • @zethmox
    @zethmox 4 года назад

    We should reply "no phone who dis"?

  • @Koiler8
    @Koiler8 4 года назад +4

    To date 10% gave this a thumbs down. Less boneheads than I thought.

  • @oswaldoy1286
    @oswaldoy1286 2 года назад

    Aliens ready to send the message
    🌎💥🔫👽

  • @Critical_mtb
    @Critical_mtb 3 года назад

    Lmao 2021 and we got nothing yet lol

  • @ML-ey2yu
    @ML-ey2yu 4 года назад

    8.56 what is the tune called

  • @ElectricRhubarb
    @ElectricRhubarb 4 года назад +1

    " contact by 2004 ? What happened

    • @A_P
      @A_P 4 года назад +1

      Aliens didn’t pay their bills 👽

  • @mikeor-
    @mikeor- 4 года назад

    Then why have we not found any life elsewhere in the Universe?

    • @stoobydootoo4098
      @stoobydootoo4098 4 года назад

      Cosmic hide and seek?

    • @Harbalz
      @Harbalz 4 года назад

      N ever
      A
      S traight
      A nswer

    • @vinny142
      @vinny142 4 года назад

      Because we can only listen to a tiny part of the sky for a few seconds and if the aliens just happened to not send a message at exaclty the right time, we'll never hear it.

  • @paulfrain3670
    @paulfrain3670 4 года назад +1

    That's an extremely kind way of putting it LOL in other words taxpayer-funded

  • @LemonLadyRecords
    @LemonLadyRecords 4 года назад

    Jill Tarter, the Early Years.

  • @makeracistsafraidagain
    @makeracistsafraidagain 4 года назад +1

    We cannot live in fear of the unknown

  • @shaywilliams8076
    @shaywilliams8076 4 года назад

    Aliens know we are here.

  • @happynaruto7946
    @happynaruto7946 4 года назад +3

    Last

  • @craigking8758
    @craigking8758 4 года назад +1

    Alien lives matter 👽👽🤔🤔

  • @snorgonofborkkad
    @snorgonofborkkad 4 года назад +1

    It’s crazy how bloated and exaggerated this editing is. You could cut out 60% of this video and it would be a better edit.

  • @LeighJFP
    @LeighJFP 4 года назад +1

    Yes do the aliens will get pissed off of its let on *read*

  • @patrickbowers8359
    @patrickbowers8359 4 года назад

    DEEZ NUTS GOT UR LIFE

  • @rickvaldez4243
    @rickvaldez4243 2 года назад

    If the bible is not Gods history book, what is it, look to find the place called garden of eden. Were the first human not removed from eden. Read ot, you will understand your origin.

  • @jmyd83
    @jmyd83 4 года назад

    Quickly Point it to the Moon 👽

  • @petepeterson4540
    @petepeterson4540 4 года назад

    never reply observe then when sure no threat reply

  • @aussiegardener1773
    @aussiegardener1773 4 года назад +1

    I think this a moot question ...... They are already here I believe .... 2 of my 3 sons have had alien encounters, 1 saw an alien and the other watch a space ship so huge at first the stars had just disappeared. I think it's either aliens or a slight discourse in the universe that allows us to see another dimension at times.
    👽

  • @direpetto
    @direpetto 4 года назад

    Extremely old documentary from the 70s or 80s

    • @StayMadNobodycares
      @StayMadNobodycares 4 года назад

      I like the old ones better although sometimes their facts are dated.

  • @alexm66
    @alexm66 4 года назад

    Why the British accent?

  • @dianaev4020
    @dianaev4020 4 года назад

    Seen ✔

  • @bakaemon4852
    @bakaemon4852 4 года назад +1

    E

  • @wtfamiactuallyright1823
    @wtfamiactuallyright1823 4 года назад

    Had a huge smile on my face watching this. Much needed, ty.

  • @billyboyce6249
    @billyboyce6249 4 года назад

    Bring chocolate

  • @goingdark5992
    @goingdark5992 3 года назад

    LMAO

  • @Harbalz
    @Harbalz 4 года назад

    The universe is a construct by INTELLIGENT DESIGN?

  •  4 года назад

    He is a lunatic

  • @ibelievegodexists4198
    @ibelievegodexists4198 4 года назад

    No such thing as aliens sorry

    • @ibelievegodexists4198
      @ibelievegodexists4198 3 года назад

      @@glennjpanting2081 lmao bruh aliens don’t exist and niether does God there’s no proof of niether an never will be but if you think aliens fuckin exist with ever seein them or having any type of proof then I suppose you must believe in a God lol

    • @ibelievegodexists4198
      @ibelievegodexists4198 3 года назад

      @@glennjpanting2081 so then.. you think there’s a chance that beings that you have never seen, no evidence or even slight evidence exist... but you don’t believe a God exists? How does that make any type of sense

    • @ibelievegodexists4198
      @ibelievegodexists4198 3 года назад

      @@glennjpanting2081 lol your runnin now? You didn’t even make a point lmao pussy

  • @Khizar_Ansari
    @Khizar_Ansari 4 года назад

    why do u make videos so dramatic ?

    • @Khizar_Ansari
      @Khizar_Ansari 4 года назад

      make it short and to the point

    • @jong2359
      @jong2359 4 года назад +1

      @@Khizar_Ansari We don't all have gnat-like attention spans.

    • @not_a_username
      @not_a_username 4 года назад

      @@Khizar_Ansari maybe because it's their channel and they can make videos anyway they want? 🤔

  • @Ashmoke
    @Ashmoke 3 года назад

    Ayy lmao

  • @HatRSol
    @HatRSol 4 года назад

    What a waste! Not surprised since it's caused creatures who'd do anything for ANYTHING BUT GOD approach. Believe in The one and Only Almighty Creator and you'll be successful, BECOME A MUSLIM.

    • @StayMadNobodycares
      @StayMadNobodycares 4 года назад +1

      How about......NO, How about that?

    • @HatRSol
      @HatRSol 4 года назад

      ​@@StayMadNobodycares Sure... No one can interfere with your choice, everyone chooses what he/she deserves.

    • @HatRSol
      @HatRSol 4 года назад

      @hans binder You'll find out your mistake on The Day of Judgement, when it'll be too late.

    • @HatRSol
      @HatRSol 3 года назад

      @@glennjpanting2081 Correct, Islam is THE ONLY SALVATION WAY, Christianity can claim whatever suits Christians, among which the earth is flat, the cosmos is 6000 years old and 1 equals 3. It is up to the sane person to distinguish the truth from the lies.
      I hope you're a sane person!

  • @nikithkumarvaidya2196
    @nikithkumarvaidya2196 4 года назад

    1 st comment

  • @Noneofyourfckingbusiness
    @Noneofyourfckingbusiness 4 года назад

    Already to late to ask this question 🙄

  • @Sukhoi2771
    @Sukhoi2771 4 года назад

    E