NO @@eleonoretsareena1613. Tali song is classy and bad in many ways that will totally NQ. At least this one is a beautiful ballad that would qualify and get good results. You never know this could have won!
Well, there's some rumors of foul play involved since Tali has ties to the executive producer of the show and she very conveniently unanimously landslided the jury when she was not expected to. But oh well
In Sicht der Luxemburger seid ihr die einzigen die es nicht verstanden haben😅 Wir suchen gute Songs mit gutem Staging. Nicht eins von beiden sondern beides. Das hat Tali und deshalb hat sie es auch verdient
@@25jsw12 Du hast Recht, das Staging bei Drowning in the rain hätte auch von mir sein können, so langweilig war es. Aber das wäre zumindest das gewesen, was man problemlos in den nächsten 3 Monaten hätte angehen können. Nichtsdestotrotz freue ich mich über eure Rückkehr zum ESC und hoffe, dass es für Tali gut laufen wird in Malmö.
look, even though bridges got top 10, it got 8th i think in the semi, so i'm not entirely sure this would qualify, especially with the televote only semis.
one of the best songs this season just thrown away :( not only was krick robbed, but Elsie is robbed once again from having her music seen on the Eurovision stage
That is the think. I'm not only want her on esc, because she is talented I love her music. Also that more people will know her and see what a talent Elsie Bay is.
Rolly I completely agree. This is such a wasted opportunity. I love so much this song. Our last chance to bring Elsie's soul to Eurovision is sending Leona with Undream You
Greetings from Belarus. I sit with tears in my eyes. How could it be rejected? Sorry, but for me, winning is already this year. KRICK - thank you for the masterpiece.
Krick please come back and try again next year. I wanna see you on the ESC stage! Edit: She’s preparing a song to go to Luxembourg Song Contest 2025! We might see her in the Eurovision stage after all! 🤞🔥 Edit 2: Nvm the juries are tasteless
This will always be my winner and looking back on it, Yeah the staging is what killed it. Drowning in the Rain? Baby girl where’s the rain? Where’s the drowning? I missed the red from the lyric video.
Televote liked it more, she got at least 10 more points in original 8 and only lost by 1 in the super final. That still puts Tali at a bigger lead if you cancel them out.
Agree about the staging. She shouldn't have just stood there statically. She should've held the mic and moved around to add more dynamism, emotion and theatrics. Like it she wanted to keep it simple, she could've even just started in the back looking away or down and then as the song builds, look up and walk forward, and then at the climax either sing into the skies or crouch down in emotional agony and belt out her feelings. I think that kind of theatrics would have sold the performance even more. Just my two cents anyways.
This was my favorite going in, and it was the best live performance on the night - but I'm not mad about Tali advancing. Quite a few of the other songs were quite bad, and if one of them had advanced, I'd be furious.
How this masterpiece didn't win 😢 I was rooting for her since first listening of her song. I'm so disappointed because of results. The would br great at eurovision. Somebody wins selection, others win our hearts. Krick, we love you ❤
well it was also public's vote fault, the difference between first and second place was only of one point in the televote and it's understandable as everyone before the final was saying that either tali or krick were fine
Was a garbage format of voting similar to MGP Denmark of Superfinal of jury and public picking from 3. Should be based on all of them! I agree Jury has deaf ears and not listen to public reaction that wanted her.
This is the upset of this preselection season, the song with eurovision in every inch of its DNA. It could have strenghen this year's ESC so much, match the quality with Slimane's Mon Amour, i think we all hoped for the rest of the countries to send/choose their best after early announcement of sending Slimane, and Fighter was not the best option here. Krick totally should've won here.
@@mxfg1535 Yeah, almost every song had changes in the staging from national final to Eurovision. The national finals usually have a smaller budget, especially in small countries.
I listened to this music on a music app. Just randomly and I had no idea about who ever was the singer. This is a very spécial song and a great art of work in my honest opinion. So many feelings and different ideas mixed very well. But I have to admit it seems to be a difficult song for live performance. Would love to see this singer succeed.
She was my pick. But I am not mad about Tali. Quite a few of the other songs were just not it, so glad Luxembourg was able to pull through with something. Some constructive notes though: While I actually enjoyed this performance because musically it was lovely, I just wished she held the mic and moved around to show more emotions and theatrics. Like she could have started in the back looking away or down and then as the song builds, look up and walk forward and then at the climax either sing into the skies or crouch down in emotional agony and belt out her feelings. I think that kind of theatrics would have sold the performance even more than being mostly static. Just my two cents anyways.
Im BLOWN away by the pure beauty of this song. Everything matches. Its soo beautifull with the Grand legacy of the winning songs of Luxemburg in the past. This would have qualified on their bare feet and could be do very well in the Final. Im not confident with their chosen ESC 24 entry. All the best. Welcome back!!
I was gutted by this one not making it. At least I was able to buy the song. I feel like I have a curse in the national selections. The ones I like never make it.
Lástima que esta cancion no valla a eurovision sinceramente esta cancion tenia mas posibilidades de quedar en una buena posición e incluso ganar saludos desde México 🇲🇽🤝🇱🇺 🇱🇺Et ass schued dass dëst Lidd net an d'Eurovision geet, éierlech hat dëst Lidd eng besser Chance fir an enger gudder Positioun ze sinn an esouguer Gréiss aus Mexiko ze gewannen 🇲🇽🤝🇱🇺 🇬🇧It's a shame that this song doesn't go to Eurovision, sincerely this song had a better chance of being in a good position and even winning greetings from Mexico 🇲🇽🤝🇱🇺
Im really happy that Tali will go to Eurovision, but Kricks song, for me more powerful and will stun jury and public. Talis song is way more simple (as for me)
@@EclipseHighrollerif the jury can’t recognize which song was the best , it’s not Luxembourgs fault…taking an international jury is being impartial, the public was on her side though.
@@pianolo123and again, who decided one’s competition should have any bearing on what your country sends? International juries in national finals are so moronic. Of course they chose talk, cause they know talk is most likely a NQ and is it competition, whereas this would have gotten top 10 at a minimum. Luxembourg chose Krick. The competition chose tali. So effing stupid.
@@EclipseHighroller well if you already took part in a competition, there is something called impartiality, which is very important when you choose a jury. Luxembourg being a very small country, it’s suitable and correct to have an international jury. How can you know in advance which song they would choose?
Should've won. What an amazing track. I didn't know that the new bond movie was titled Drowning in the rain. Wonder when it comes out! My guess is Luxembourg doesn't want to host ESC.
I can't believe this song didn't win 🤦. Since we in Serbia have a strong national selection this year, I still don't know which one we will send, but be sure that after live performances we will know and will chose the best.
Am I the only one who thinks this song is lacking something? That the fact it lasts about 2'30'' not 3 mins just made this song too cut right before the climax? 🤔🤔
Shame about the styling, completely missed the mark there and takes away the impact of the song, but the song would be one of the best this year. Luxembourg made a mistake sending a generic pop song with a chorus that shoots you back decades. This should have won with a landslide
Может действительно не хватает зрелищности в номере, но это можно было доработать к основным этапам. Песня очень сильная и интересная. Люксембург мог бы вернуться с такой крутой песней, которая бы точно запомнилась. Вместо этого выбрали в итоге какой-то проходняк. Жаль
@@ang159el the winning song is the basic of the basic basic girlie songs that are forgotten on the next day :D i have no clue what you are thanking about
Great vocal and song. I think the visuals on stage let her down. I thought her outfit choice was odd. A white mullet dress whilst singing a dark song. There was also nothing happening on stage. Meanwhile Tali was allowed six dancers and pyro!
Welcome back 🥰 The song and performance are a bit old fashioned. We’re not in 1993 anymore 😜 Maybe they need a couple of years to assimilate to the modern Eurovision.
![Seungmin "그렇게, 천천히, 우리(As we are)" | [Stray Kids : SKZ-PLAYER]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/kAzmhLHePqU/mqdefault.jpg)
Luxembourg made a big mistake tonight. The potential here- could have been a winning comeback… 🇱🇺
YOU know CLEARLY that this song would NEVER win Eurovision because it's too classy for ESC.
@@eleonoretsareena1613We’ll never know now…
NO @@eleonoretsareena1613. Tali song is classy and bad in many ways that will totally NQ. At least this one is a beautiful ballad that would qualify and get good results. You never know this could have won!
Yes!!
Oh Lord pls xDDD stop making Elsie Bay's dull songs famous
How was this not the jury winner. The strongest composition by a mile
Well, there's some rumors of foul play involved since Tali has ties to the executive producer of the show and she very conveniently unanimously landslided the jury when she was not expected to. But oh well
@@NoClueHonestlybejba action v2
Her live performance wasn't very good, need more practice to not sounding out of breath
Just a generic ballad, just like a millions appeared every NF season
Wrong PE.... its a shame...
For me had potencial for top 5-10 in malmo 100%
At least our German jury recognized the best song in the show.
Yes😢
In Sicht der Luxemburger seid ihr die einzigen die es nicht verstanden haben😅
Wir suchen gute Songs mit gutem Staging. Nicht eins von beiden sondern beides. Das hat Tali und deshalb hat sie es auch verdient
@@25jsw12 Tali‘s staging is better than Krick but the song is not strong enough :(
@@Hannahhuan32 The song is amazing in my opinion but I respect yours
@@25jsw12 Du hast Recht, das Staging bei Drowning in the rain hätte auch von mir sein können, so langweilig war es. Aber das wäre zumindest das gewesen, was man problemlos in den nächsten 3 Monaten hätte angehen können. Nichtsdestotrotz freue ich mich über eure Rückkehr zum ESC und hoffe, dass es für Tali gut laufen wird in Malmö.
one of the best "should have been" songs.
Feeling this is on the same wavelength of Alika's "Bridges", I'm definitely listening to this even if she not going to the ESC.
Youre right
Same here, and she would have gotten top 10 too.
look, even though bridges got top 10, it got 8th i think in the semi, so i'm not entirely sure this would qualify, especially with the televote only semis.
@@wibbliams between her amazing performance and it being Luxembourg i don’t see qualifying being an issue.
@@wibbliamsi think bridges got last in the semis
one of the best songs this season just thrown away :( not only was krick robbed, but Elsie is robbed once again from having her music seen on the Eurovision stage
That is the think. I'm not only want her on esc, because she is talented I love her music. Also that more people will know her and see what a talent Elsie Bay is.
Rolly I completely agree. This is such a wasted opportunity. I love so much this song. Our last chance to bring Elsie's soul to Eurovision is sending Leona with Undream You
@@enricopaoletti5650 It is not the last chance. She also submitted a song to the swiss selction.
For the ESC is it a bit too sad
For a bond movie perfect
A feature with Adele or sam Smith even BETTER
Don't worry she'll succeed
I can’t believe it. This should’ve been the jury winner. This was special
This was excellent! I'm surprised she lost. I hope they invite her in the future.
This would have been my personal favourite. An impactful ballad. I hope she'll try again next year. Love to Luxembourg from Ireland.
Well the German Jury was the only good one tonight.
It was obvious they would vote for Berlin in The Rain
@@cincinsworldvisionsongcont2399 oh yeah I saw that I was very confused
@@cincinsworldvisionsongcont2399 Sad that the Eurovision 2025 is not heading to Berlin 😅
@@RenéRapucalypse_Official yeah 😆
@@cincinsworldvisionsongcont2399 Will you do Worldvision By You?
Greetings from Belarus. I sit with tears in my eyes. How could it be rejected? Sorry, but for me, winning is already this year. KRICK - thank you for the masterpiece.
I am too!!!😢😢😮.
Krick please come back and try again next year. I wanna see you on the ESC stage!
Edit: She’s preparing a song to go to Luxembourg Song Contest 2025! We might see her in the Eurovision stage after all! 🤞🔥
Edit 2: Nvm the juries are tasteless
But elsie bay meeds to make her another song cause her songs are the best
This will always be my winner and looking back on it, Yeah the staging is what killed it. Drowning in the Rain? Baby girl where’s the rain? Where’s the drowning? I missed the red from the lyric video.
She will always be the winner of our hearts🥹
I will never forgive juries
Televote liked it more, she got at least 10 more points in original 8 and only lost by 1 in the super final. That still puts Tali at a bigger lead if you cancel them out.
She should’ve done smth more intriguing with the stage cause the song is 10/10. I will still listen to this song for some time 😌
Agree about the staging. She shouldn't have just stood there statically. She should've held the mic and moved around to add more dynamism, emotion and theatrics.
Like it she wanted to keep it simple, she could've even just started in the back looking away or down and then as the song builds, look up and walk forward, and then at the climax either sing into the skies or crouch down in emotional agony and belt out her feelings. I think that kind of theatrics would have sold the performance even more. Just my two cents anyways.
Difficult to sing such a tricky song song if you move around. Perfect for me.
This was my favorite going in, and it was the best live performance on the night - but I'm not mad about Tali advancing. Quite a few of the other songs were quite bad, and if one of them had advanced, I'd be furious.
Based comment.
As you can tell the songwriter is Elsie Bay sounds like her songs. I loved it should have won
I have never heard a better song eurovision 2024 winner for me.
The REAL WINNER 😍
Luxembourg this year could have won Eurovision…😢❤
How this masterpiece didn't win 😢 I was rooting for her since first listening of her song. I'm so disappointed because of results. The would br great at eurovision. Somebody wins selection, others win our hearts. Krick, we love you ❤
Came here to watch this beautiful performance instead watching that girl perform live (rn at this moment) during the final
I was so sure this would win but once again the jury decided otherwise.
well it was also public's vote fault, the difference between first and second place was only of one point in the televote and it's understandable as everyone before the final was saying that either tali or krick were fine
@@newlightent2Tali also won the televote in original 8 with more than a ten point lead
Was a garbage format of voting similar to MGP Denmark of Superfinal of jury and public picking from 3. Should be based on all of them! I agree Jury has deaf ears and not listen to public reaction that wanted her.
Cette chanson aurait du aller à l'eurovision
This is the upset of this preselection season, the song with eurovision in every inch of its DNA. It could have strenghen this year's ESC so much, match the quality with Slimane's Mon Amour, i think we all hoped for the rest of the countries to send/choose their best after early announcement of sending Slimane, and Fighter was not the best option here. Krick totally should've won here.
Well said
Luxembourg….. this could have won Eurovision.
Be fr😭
Not the whole contest but at least the juries. 😢
Needed better staging
@@mxfg1535 Yeah, almost every song had changes in the staging from national final to Eurovision. The national finals usually have a smaller budget, especially in small countries.
So sad that krick didnt win. But she is the real winner in our hearts ❤️❤️
KRICK HAS TO TRIED AGAIN NEXT YEAR! she is amazing. the lyrics, the song, the melody, THE everything...
Nice, classic, well performed. Well done, 2nd place deserved ❤
What a crime i hate the jury
Дуже сподобалась ця пісня.
Зараз часто її слухаю.
Жаль,що не вона перемогла.
How didn’t this win?? This could have win the whole Eurovision contest this year!!! Huge mistake
I am actual so mad and I will forever be sour about the results
JUSTICE FOR KRICK!
Krick is the wionner of my heart, If we cant see her on ESC, mabe on the next James Bond. 😍😍😍😍😍
7 months later... how did this masterpiece not win?
The best song i ve heard by far how can't this be the final choice for Luxembourg??????
I listened to this music on a music app. Just randomly and I had no idea about who ever was the singer.
This is a very spécial song and a great art of work in my honest opinion. So many feelings and different ideas mixed very well.
But I have to admit it seems to be a difficult song for live performance. Would love to see this singer succeed.
This should’ve been the choice
She was my pick. But I am not mad about Tali. Quite a few of the other songs were just not it, so glad Luxembourg was able to pull through with something. Some constructive notes though:
While I actually enjoyed this performance because musically it was lovely, I just wished she held the mic and moved around to show more emotions and theatrics. Like she could have started in the back looking away or down and then as the song builds, look up and walk forward and then at the climax either sing into the skies or crouch down in emotional agony and belt out her feelings. I think that kind of theatrics would have sold the performance even more than being mostly static. Just my two cents anyways.
You‘re right but I felt like most of the performances were quite static. Nevertheless this was my absolute favorite.
I'm sure this could've been the winner of the finale
This would have won eurovision 2024 very strong and beautiful song...could have been a BOND SONG....LOVE FROM Ireland 🇮🇪 ❤
This would not in a million years have won. This would have been a possible NQ
@@Girafenare you talking about Fighter or are you crazy?
Wow! Such a wonderful song!
This is the real winner for Luxembourg! 🏆
Im BLOWN away by the pure beauty of this song. Everything matches.
Its soo beautifull with the Grand legacy of the winning songs of Luxemburg in the past.
This would have qualified on their bare feet and could be do very well in the Final.
Im not confident with their chosen ESC 24 entry.
All the best.
Welcome back!!
Foi a única música que gostei !!! Tocou meu coração!! ❤
I was gutted by this one not making it. At least I was able to buy the song. I feel like I have a curse in the national selections. The ones I like never make it.
I lost two of my darlings this week 😢
Same…..
Gimlo knows the pain :^(
Same i wanted Krick & Ailsha so bad 😢
@@greenshock97 me too! And i feel so disappointed not, I'm afraid the rest of my favourites will end at 2nd place
Loved her performance !
Luxembourg missed out on qualifying for the final
Luxembourg are still 100% qualifying, but most likely not a top 10 finish anymore 😢
@@cheerioboiesc2194 We‘ll see the rest of the songs first
@@cheerioboiesc2194 That's what they said about Georgia last year, or Ireland in 2022, the competition is very strong, This song was for the finals
Luxembourg will be 100% qualifying for the final no matter what song they sent, because of the hype of their return
@@erinnadia0409 not so sure as they are in the first semi final - which is a bloodbath!
Sublime dommge pour vous davoir fait un autre choix vpus zuriez ete parmi les favoris
Lástima que esta cancion no valla a eurovision sinceramente esta cancion tenia mas posibilidades de quedar en una buena posición e incluso ganar saludos desde México 🇲🇽🤝🇱🇺
🇱🇺Et ass schued dass dëst Lidd net an d'Eurovision geet, éierlech hat dëst Lidd eng besser Chance fir an enger gudder Positioun ze sinn an esouguer Gréiss aus Mexiko ze gewannen 🇲🇽🤝🇱🇺
🇬🇧It's a shame that this song doesn't go to Eurovision, sincerely this song had a better chance of being in a good position and even winning greetings from Mexico 🇲🇽🤝🇱🇺
shouldve been the female ballad of 2024
Im really happy that Tali will go to Eurovision, but Kricks song, for me more powerful and will stun jury and public. Talis song is way more simple (as for me)
How they could choose Tali instead of this masterpiece😢
First utter robbery of the season is already in January...
This was too good for Eurovision, there's no other way it didn't win
My favourite, more unique than the Winnersong.
I was hoping so much this would be the song to represent Luxembourg in ESC. Would've definitely gotten my 12 points
Luxembourg admitted they didn’t want to be taken seriously or win by not sending this masterpiece.
It wasn’t Luxembourg…the jury was international.
@@pianolo123and who’s rules allow for the jury in the Luxembourg final?
@@EclipseHighrollerif the jury can’t recognize which song was the best , it’s not Luxembourgs fault…taking an international jury is being impartial, the public was on her side though.
@@pianolo123and again, who decided one’s competition should have any bearing on what your country sends? International juries in national finals are so moronic. Of course they chose talk, cause they know talk is most likely a NQ and is it competition, whereas this would have gotten top 10 at a minimum.
Luxembourg chose Krick. The competition chose tali.
So effing stupid.
@@EclipseHighroller well if you already took part in a competition, there is something called impartiality, which is very important when you choose a jury. Luxembourg being a very small country, it’s suitable and correct to have an international jury.
How can you know in advance which song they would choose?
Much better than Tali….
Should've won. What an amazing track. I didn't know that the new bond movie was titled Drowning in the rain. Wonder when it comes out!
My guess is Luxembourg doesn't want to host ESC.
Luxemburg muss die Entscheidung rückgängig machen. So ein tolles Lied muss zum ESC!
this was the best by far, i'm so sad
Something is missing from the performance i think, it dosent have the same effekt as the studio
The staging is missing. Having her standing there static is not effective or epic.
sadly, it's the singer... heartbroken to say it but Krick ain't Elsa.
This could’ve won the entire competition. If this was sent it would’ve been my #2 😥🥲🥲🥲❤️❤️❤️
❤❤❤12 points ❤❤❤ the Netherlands
this would've been the GREAT LUXEMBOURG COME BACK
If this song went to ESC, Luxembourg would have a chance to win for the 6th time!
WOW !!
I can't believe this song didn't win 🤦. Since we in Serbia have a strong national selection this year, I still don't know which one we will send, but be sure that after live performances we will know and will chose the best.
THIS SHOULD HAVE WON, THAT'S A MASTERPIECE
I want her to come back and represent Luxembourg in Basel.
Real winner
How did that happened? They had one chance with that song literally.
Drowning In The Rain is unquestionably the stronger song, however the horrible staging and lighting ruined its chances😢
What the hell were Luxembourg thinking this is flawless and you would have been my winner had you sent Krick to Malmo!!!
Guys how this strong song didn't make it?!
This was so much better than Tali.
Should have won
Am I the only one who thinks this song is lacking something? That the fact it lasts about 2'30'' not 3 mins just made this song too cut right before the climax? 🤔🤔
Omg!!! She is so talented and charismatic!!!! ❤❤❤❤❤
OMG its sooooo beautiful and amazing. Hope she will win/ with love from Ukraine
She has lost already???? 😂
@@mxfg1535
These jurys must all have COVID, because this was art and they have no taste.
except Germany, who got the vaccine, thankfully.
It was the Televoting's fault. Jury's points were only 1 less than the first place
This would have been so good on the malmo stage im crying
Luxemburgo no quiere ganar eurovisiòn.Esta canciòn era Top 5 en Malmö😢
Shame about the styling, completely missed the mark there and takes away the impact of the song, but the song would be one of the best this year. Luxembourg made a mistake sending a generic pop song with a chorus that shoots you back decades. This should have won with a landslide
Vibe Estonia 2023
No
It‘s different vibe
Может действительно не хватает зрелищности в номере, но это можно было доработать к основным этапам. Песня очень сильная и интересная. Люксембург мог бы вернуться с такой крутой песней, которая бы точно запомнилась. Вместо этого выбрали в итоге какой-то проходняк. Жаль
This year would have been so much better with this and Angel’s Share from Czech were in the Eurovision.
Sorry for the caps lock.. HOW DID THIS NOT WIIIIIIIIIIN?!?!?!? !!!!
Can we please get rid of jurys during NF at least?
this wasn’t luxembourg fault tho… tali got most 12 points from the juries and krick won the televote….
those juries were creepy af :D none ever heard of them :) giving 12 points sitting on the sofa :D
She won the televote by 1 point, Tali still deserved it
@@ang159el wish we could be that Tali or whatever is her name wont qualify :D
@@ang159el the winning song is the basic of the basic basic girlie songs that are forgotten on the next day :D i have no clue what you are thanking about
@@costi_scnah it is different and great. I live the mixing of languages and singing
Great vocal and song. I think the visuals on stage let her down. I thought her outfit choice was odd. A white mullet dress whilst singing a dark song. There was also nothing happening on stage. Meanwhile Tali was allowed six dancers and pyro!
Damn why couldn’t she just win 😭
Rip. James Bondish anthem. More Jamez Bondish than the actual winner
Welcome back 🥰 The song and performance are a bit old fashioned. We’re not in 1993 anymore 😜 Maybe they need a couple of years to assimilate to the modern Eurovision.
As Always The Jurys Ruin EVERYTHING
The quality of the contest was great n all but I’m gonna need a 10 year lecture on how this did not win
Luxembourg 🇱🇺 big big mistake this was a Eurovision Song Contest 🎵 Winner .
Winner ..