Thank you for all your support, and suggestions for new episodes. We want to make them all! Also check out the link to our store in the description, we have a limited edition Goliard University t-shirt available, as well as some other channel merch. classicsexplained.com/ And remember to listen to Carmina Burana this weekend as Carl Orff intended: very loudly!
Can you do Pastoral Symphony, Bolero, Bartered Bride, Barber of Seville, Pines of Rome, Kinderszenen, Four Seasons, Carnival of the Animals, but with different designs for each episodes other than Elgar, Gershwin, and Orf this time?
Thanks for this suggestion - four of these are actually currently in production! A fifth in production is by a composer of another one of them. Would appreciate some feedback on the animation of the last three and what your thoughts are on changing it? Always valuable for us to know what people like/dislike Thanks for your support :)
@@ClassicsExplained the animation for Gershwin should be like 1920s cartoons. Orf’s animation could be based on Dr. Seuss’ artwork. Saint Saens can be like the animation style of Disney Renaissance. The style of Vivaldi might look like Mary Blair’s art. Rachmaninoff’s style should’ve looked like Tim Burton styles (not stop motion). And the upcoming Bizet needs to look like Mucha Lucha.
I still remember the wash of horror I had when I read the (translated) lyrics of "The Roasting Swan." It was terrifying when you consider the last line is "I see teeth"
Cutest comment - thanks so much. Absolutely delighted to hear this. That means so much to us :) Please keep watching and supporting we are very grateful
@@puffadder92 Stokowski's is my favorite Carmina Burana recording. That Carnegie Hall concert is actually here on youtube as well! But the sound quality is a bit… strange. Stokowski was quite a pioneer in recording engineering stuff, so his Houston studio recording is has a much better balance. What I admire in his recording is the cohesiveness of the sequence of tempi. As for his reputation for being unpleasant to work with, I'm not quite sure how that came about. There are quite a few Stokowski in rehearsal videos here on YT, so I had a look at some of those. What I see is that he is EXTREMELY efficient. That implies of course that he picks small portions of works that are particularly tricky, That of course, is daunting if you are sitting there playing. Also I see him demanding total focus, not joking to chatting allowed. That also feels a bit… dictatorial. But then, to see it from the positive side, there is a lot of trust in the players in that attitude. I also came to understand that his unpleasantness was something of his later years. Did you aunt speak about him? Anyway, ol' Stokowski is quite a favorite of mine, not just for his Carmina Burana. His grip on meter and rhythm in particular I find quite fascinating. Thank you for bringing him up.
Pieces you can choose to make a video about: Erlkonig (Schubert) Gretchen am Spinnrade (Schubert) Beethoven symphonies Don Giovanni (Mozart) Tannhauser/Die Meistersinger de Nuremberg (Wagner) Lohengrin/Tristan & Isolde (Wagner) Salome (R. Strauss) There’s more but I will tell you later once you chose one P.S. love ur vids, Ben ❤ Classical flautist (SL)❤
This is massively appreciated, Sophie - can't thank you enough for your support and recommendations. So much I wish I could do (and I'd do all your suggestion if I had the time and money!) but I can tell you that one of them is currently in production ;)
I love the little Bewitched nose-wiggle you gave Venus around 6:20! This was such a great episode, I can't believe I've gone this long without actually looking up the story and text of Carmina Burana. I'm glad I learned it through your unique style of storytelling and not some boring written summary!
Thanks! Really appreciate that! Yeah - who wants to read some boring programme notes! Hope this is a funner way to learn! Keep listening and loving classical music :)
Fun fact: Orff didn't actually have his publishers destroy his previous publications. He admitted in his memoirs that he was being a bit overly dramatic when he told that story. ;-)
My local youth symphony woodwinds used to do this piece annually as part of our summer camp, when I was a teen. Definitely an exciting piece! Would love to know more of what it was about.
Quite a step up in the animation style and detail. The art style becoming more refined and more unique to the composer. The cut out puppet style when employed was a nice touch. As always the music research and clear explanations made it accessible to someone who only listens a bit to classical music. Really enjoy your channel.
I discovered this piece when I was 15. I even used it to conquer my girlfriend's heart at that time (how adequate!), and still today I can recite the complete lyrics by heart (I was studying some Latin and German at that time, so most of the words made sense to me, and that made them much easier to remember). My point being, I know this work very deeply, and yet I discovered new things, meanings, and facts about it. Congratulations for an astonishing job!
What a brilliant tale! Love that you had a feeling for the lyrics too. I sang it at school when I was about 17 or 18 and fell absolutely in love with it too. It's really primal and powerful - thanks for all the support :)
One of the first concerts my father took me to see. I was in awe at the music and lyrics, as the text and translation was being projected over the choir. My favorite piece ever to date!
I enjoy this series so much. I realize having done Rite of Spring the Firebird is unlikely to get a nod. I want to yell play Firebird when I visit symphony (instead of play Freebird at Rock concert😅).
I love the Firebird. Would love to do a video on it - one of those interesting pieces were Ravel is borrowing a lot from Rimsky in terms of orchestration but also doing some rhythmically fascinating stuff that is a precursor for what is to come. Keep tuned and thanks for your support :)))
I had only ever heard O Fortuna; the rest of the piece is great and I'm going to listen to the full work after this. Great video as always, always glad when a video can make me laugh and learn something. Thank you for your hard work!
Thanks so much! I love that you want to listen to the full piece. Like you, prior to singing this piece at school, I only knew O Fortuna. Then I discovered that it really is SO much more than that! Keep loving and learning about classical music and thanks for the support :)
I would really REALLY love to see you analyze Don Giovanni, it's my favourite Mozart Opera! Alternatively, I'd love to see you cover anything from Gilbert and Sullivan, especially Pirates of Penzance (a breakdown of all the references and jokes in "I am the Very Model of A Modern Major General" would be awesome). And since Halloween is coming, I'd also love Saint Saens' Danse Macabre, in the spirit of Spooktober.
What fascinating suggestions! We've done Magic Flute already (as much as I adore Don Giovanni) so perhaps G&S might be a cool left-field one. Regarding SS, keep tuned...! ;)
@@ClassicsExplained So, you're planning something for monsieur Camille? I wonder what could that be? If not Danse Macabre then maybe perhaps Le Carnival Des Animeaux? Or Organ Symphony? Either one would be awesome, and I can't wait to see your next video. Cheers!
Thanks SO much for this - exactly the sort of comment we love because it encapsulates everything we want this channel to be! Keep enjoying our new releases :)
A very interesting piece, Carmina Burana. It certainly depicts a different take on... philosophy, yeah, that what's we're going to call it... from what's typically seen in music. For something completely different, I'd love to see a video that discusses Shostakovich's String Quartet #8. It's very bleak and pessimistic, but has a fascinating and similarly depressing story. Or, Shostakovich's Symphony #7; Its premier in the city of Leningrad occurred during the height of the siege during WWII. It is the only piece I know of where a premier was heralded by military action to ensure it would go uninterrupted.
Meanwhile, Dievs, tava zeme deg, a cantata by Latvian composer Lūcija Garūta, premiered in Rīga Cathedral during the 1944 Battle of Rīga. The recording even captures the sound of the battle.
Thanks so much for this! Some brilliant suggestions - and the Shostakovich symphony is an absolute classic for the reasons you explain. Got to find a way to somehow get it in! Keep up the support :)
@@johanneswerner1140 There's also an entire subtext, when the fourth son of Egino van Urach, the founder of the ducal line of Wurttemburg, cut loose as a suffragan bishop in the Rhineland Monasteries and Nunneries in the late 12th Century. Celibacy was a new doctrine, and not accepted here, so he had to be baled out by the Vatican, who found a use for his visceral hatred in the Albigensian Crusade, where he finished his Cousin Simon IV de Montfort's unfinished business.
Thanks SO much - really appreciate your support. There's many films I could make on Orff because the Schulwerk method is just fascinating. Perhaps we could address it in a side-video of me talking about it at the piano. Thanks for your support - and hope the kids are loving the Schulwerk method!
It's great! I sang it too at school - never forgot how unusual it was to sing in a piece like it after countless Mozarts and Bachs and the like. Was absolutely revelatory
Wonderful explanation of a fantastic piece. I remember singing this in my local symphony choir. My only knowledge was as "the one with the cool and scary piece that is used in lots of movies and commercials." Our conductor encouraged us to look into the stories and meanings in each piece and I was hooked! I truly enjoyed singing it so much more, understanding what each voice, character, and musical motif was!
4:58 I can’t find any reference to an “Ocasio” god of opportunity anywhere. Caerus is mentioned and is sometimes depicted as having only a forelock of hair. I read in one novel where a character mentioned “grabbing fortune by the forelock”. Another character later asked what was meant by that and was told that the goddess of fortune is depicted as having no hair on her head behind her ears. The first character replied “Doesn’t sound very attractive, does it?” 😊 Thanks for producing this, I really enjoyed it. Carmina Burana is one of my favorites!
I first heard Carmina Burana in middle school as our drama teacher used it as incidental music in our performance of the Hobbit. I loved it so much he made me a cassette after the show. I played it until the tape wore out and I tried to replace it. What I didn't realize is that it was the Ray Manzarak prog rock version and it was 20 years before I tracked that version down. 😂
Amazing! And I love the Manzarek connection! He did quite a few kooky versions of classical piece. If I weren’t doing classical music videos, I’d love to do Doors ones!
I should suggest you some pieces to make some more masterpieces of yours about: Night On Bald Mountain (Mussorgsky) Tale Of Tsar Saltan (Rimsky-Korsakov) Leningrad Symphony (Shostakovich) The Miraculous Mandarin (Bela Bartok) Alice In Wonderland (Unsuk Chin) Suicide In An Airplane (Leo Ornstein) Firebird/Petrushka (Stravinsky) Tosca/Turandot (Puccini) L'Orfee Aux Enfer (Offenbach) The Bat (Strauss) Danse Macabre (Saint-Saens/Liszt) To be continued... P. S. Waiting for your new masterpieces, Ben 💓
If you recommend the Leningrad Symphony, I recommend Dievs Tava Zeme Deg by the Latvian Lūcija Garūta. Another Latvian composer with an epic story would be Jānis Mediņš who began his opera Fire and Night in 1913, served in the Tsar's army, and after the Revolution, crossed Siberia and European Russia to return to an independent Latvia, carrying the massive score the entire way.
Thanks so much for your huge support and for these suggestions. A piece very closely linked to one of this (which quotes heavily from it) is soon to be released by us!
I absolutely LOVE this video. The animation is very well made and the way it's narrated and explained makes it so fun! I wish this had subtitles so i can show it to my non-english speaking friends.
I feel its best modern inclusion was in the score of the 1981 Boorman film "Excalibur". Since I was already a musician, it's what really sparked my interest to learn Latin as well.
Thanks so much for this lovely compliment! Keep up the support - and the Mahler suggestion is brilliant. I've toyed with the idea a lot and am seriously weighing up between two particular Mahler ones
I just want to announce that I just missed the job of a lifetime over a technicality, and all I could think of was of this video’s Fortuna patting my shoulder saying “best luck next time”
First of all, this channel’s work and dedication are surprising. Thank you for all these video masterpieces! My suggestion for a new video is Wagner’s „Der Ring des Nibelungen” and Shostakovich’s 7th Symphony. Greetings from Romania! 🇷🇴
my favorite piece! i sang with the university of michigan choir at carnegie hall in the prehistoric era; Rafael Fruhbeck de Burgos conducted . can’t wait to hear (and see 😊) what you’ve done with this piece! ❤
Absolutely enjoy your videos! Suggestions coming for pieces you could do videos around: Bach and his Brandenburg Concertos Mozart and his Piano Concertos No 20 & 21 Mozart’s Piano Sonata No 11 in A (the Rondo Alla Turca) and his Symphonies No 25, 40 and his famous symphony No 41. Perhaps selections from Handel’s Messiah. Mozart (his Sunny Symphony No 29), Piano quartet’s No 1 & 2 Schubert (Unfinished Symphony & his Trout Quintet) Can’t wait to see more of what you do in the future!
I played a portion of this work in concert band my senior year of high school, we performed 6 movements from it in concert band. I was sad I wasn’t the timpanist in it because I wasn’t first chair percussion, but I played the piano and chimes during the concert, and it was one of my most favorite works to play, definitely brought good memories from high school band. I’m glad I finally understand what is going on in all of the pieces in the work, thank you!
8:09 - 8:11 "This is Goliard approved Lust!" The following is a quote from an interview with Asmodeus, the literal embodiment of Lust: "As both a noble King in the Ars Goetia, and the Sin Demon of Lust, even doing something simple like mentioning the Goliards or even alluding to them makes me uncomfortable! I don't see Lust as something that should be forced upon! It's gross, it's illegal, and it makes me sick *past* my stomach!!" -Asmodeus, the Sin Demon of Lust.
I was first exposed to this work in my tweens when my father, a public school instrumental educator, bought an album, the particulars of which I can't remember. I had a musically inclined ear from infancy (so I've been told) and was struck immediately with the primal quality of the music; the feeling that it was both ancient and modern at the same time. The music lured me in to reading the liner notes and following the translated poetry and even though I was too young to *really* get it, I got it to the extent I could. I'll have to do some digging and see if somehow I ended up with that LP. I haven't listened to the whole thing in ages. Thanks for a great summation.
Carmina burana is my most valued memory of my beginnings in classical music taste, as I always seek videos explaining its melancholic message. I’m so glad to know I’ve found such in this video, along with the funniest visuals ever ❤️❤
My most direct introduction to the O Fortuna section was the 'salsa cookies' meme from like 10 years ago, and I've since added the entire Carmina Burana piece to my work playlist. I absolutely love it, and I really enjoy your presentation of the meaning behind the work. After watching this video, I am again reminded that people do not change. On a side note, I am dying that the falsetto section is supposed to be from the perspective of the swan lol what a great piece
Saw this piece done by the Cincinati Symphony Orchestra years ago. As it happenened i had broken my foot earlier that day. I recall not only temporarily forgeting my pain but but being nearly brought to tears. That was actually the very first (but not last) time thst had happened.
Carmina Burana means "Songs from Beuren" because the book containing these songs was found in Benediktbeuren Abbey. They were, however, written down either in Styria or in Brixen in Tyrol by a monk who knew no or very little German himself for the handwriting shows Italian characteristics and the Middle High German has strange mistakes.
Yep! We wish we could have explained this in more detail - and it certainly wasn't lost on us. We felt to delve into the linguisitc points may have taken away from the flow of this film. But it is certainly something I would consider addressing in more depth in a spin-off video at the piano. Thanks for the comment :)
This video showed up in my recommendations and yes I like classical music, so I watched it. I enjoyed it so much I subscribed, now I'm going back to the beginning to watch the videos in series.
I'm a pianist so naturally adore playing Chopin. There is so much to choose from though...the Ballades aren't a bad place to start though! Thanks so much for the support :)
In addition to the great suggestions for videos, consider, Darius Milhaud’s Scaramouche and his Saudades Do Brazil. There high levels of polytonality in Saudades.❤❤
I associated O Fortuna with the movie Excalibur till I sang it in a choir. This video gives a more comprehensive summary than our conductor did. Incidentally, after-parties following a performance of Carmina Burana tend to go off with a bang...
@@minnieyuyantung I would say Stravinsky 's Les Noces is a more direct and obvious influence. listen to the Magma albums Wurdah Itah and Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh.
Like a number of the commenters here I first heard O Fortuna as part of the Excalibur movie in the 1970's but great piece of music won't be denied and loved the work since. However! I never understood the story - I am NOT one for dry performance notes. Thank you so much for your concise and clear explanation of the story. I have just relistened to the oratorio but with a much clearer understanding.
In the segment "Chramer, gip die varwe mir", I hear sleigh bells. They also appear in Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's German Dance no. 3 "Sleigh Ride", Emile Waldteufel's Skaters Waltz, Frederick Delius' WInter Night, Richard Eilenberg's Petersburg Sleigh Ride, at the begining of Gustav Mahler's Fourth Symphony, Leroy Anderson's Sleigh Ride, Serge Prokofiev's Troika from Lieutenant Kije, Angela Morley's Snow RIde, and Philip Lane's Sleighbell Serenade.
Also Pastoral Symphony by Beethoven, Bolero, by Ravel, Bartered Bride by Smetana, Barber of Seville by Rossini, Roman Trilogy by Respighi, Carnival of the Animals by Saint Saens, Lark Ascending by Williams, Kinderszenen by Schumann, Pearl Fishers by Bizet, La Boheme by Puccini, Rigoletto by Verdi, Song of the Night by Mahler, and Tales from the Vienna forest by Strauss!
Another made-of-awesome video! Excellent review and great details & presentation. Moar pLz! My first exposure to Carmina Burana was John Boorman's Excalibur, which was a perfect match of screen and classical. I would argue that movie kicked off the popular use of O Fortuna on the big and small screens.
There's a choreography for this piece, authored by Ernst Uthoff, co-founder of the Chilean National Ballet (dependant of the University of Chile, the country's state university). You can watch excerpts of it searching in RUclips by "Carmina Burana 2010 Estacion Mapocho." I sang in the choir years before (Symphonic Choir of the University of Chile), we sang the whole thing by heart - and mostly in darkness. 😁
As a musician, I've had a ... fateful experience with Carmina Burana. It started in High School, when I was playing with my Youth Orchestra, I was invited to perform Carmina to cover for another musician in a large amatuer orchestra. Unfortunately the performance was to be the night before my final school exams and parents, teachers and even trumpet tutor would pressure me into not accepting the position. I'd spend the next week blasting recordings of Carmina on the daily at home like a rebellious teen. "There will be plenty of opportunities to perform Carmina I'm sure" they said. Tempting fate. I moved to another state to go to University and about 3 months after my move, I was invited again to perform Carmina. In my former state. I accepted, advising that I might have to miss a specific rehearsal, but would be there for the main rehearsals. It would require some expensive 10 hour drives from university to home (or 1 hour flights), but my university schedule could be squished around to avoid Mondays most of the time, and they had 4 Monday rehearsals followed by a Saturday. I was in for a penny, in for a pound and ready for some sleep-deprived Tuesdays at uni and a few questionable 10 hour drives starting at 10pm into a 9am class the next day. Till they found out I actually wasn't living in state, and they cancelled me (while I was in Sydney ready for the first rehearsal the next day). Apparently their rules meant we all had to be in-state musicians or something. Finally, I managed to join a large community Orchestra and perform with them a few times before they were ready to do a Carmina. I was invited, confirmed, and ready to go, and our Performance was scheduled for August of 2020. Covid-19 lockdowns cancelled every performance venue in the state for 6 months starting in June. running 3 out of 3 for cancelled Carmina's.
Aaargh not the trumpet tutor... this hurts. Smh. What is it with the glorified exams. Music is good for brain. Not so sure about binge studying on the night before.
Mindblowing storytelling! Knew most of this from when I sung in university choir, but pictures give it life, 10/10 (and also matches Orff's intent as far as I understand) When singing though, I never imagined the baritone character in a sweaty wifebeater...
Wow! Your videos are getting better and better! It's obvious a whole lot of work goes into each one and so they can only come out every once in a while but it's always such a treat when I see a video by you come up in the suggestions! Learning is easy when it's fun!
Stravinsky revised Petrushka in 1947 (10 years after Carmina Burana's Premiere). Earlier he had debued his Les Noces in 1923 with Choreography by Bronislava Nijinska.
Another wonderful job! From the animation to the analyze, everything is so well made. :D May I give you a suggestion? I would love to see a video about The Cunning Little Vixen by Leoš Janáček. ^^
Excellent work! Love the animations and storytelling! I am a little disappointed that the only inclusion of Nazi influence here is a bit misleading, though. The Nazi party were staunchly against modern music and wanted to hearken back to the sounds of Mozart and Beethoven to sell the idea of German superiority, to the point that they banned many composers' works and intentionally propagandized this one for its more classical and populist sound. I've even heard that at some points of the war, its message of giving into carnal lust was leaned into, as a way for the party to convince more people to have babies which would ensure they would have an army for decades to come. That last bit was more speculative from my professor at the time, but he gave some solid supporting evidence.
Thanks for your compliments and the interesting points raised in your message. I should say that I was planning on addressing these issues in a bit more depth in the video but didn't want to dwell on Orff's "Nazi problem" and also thought it might better be addressed in a spin-off video of me talking about the point at the piano. Great food for thought and definitely one I'm considering producing a short on. Lest we forget - this is the most famous piece to come out of Nazi Germany... Thanks for your support :)
Thank you for all your support, and suggestions for new episodes. We want to make them all! Also check out the link to our store in the description, we have a limited edition Goliard University t-shirt available, as well as some other channel merch. classicsexplained.com/ And remember to listen to Carmina Burana this weekend as Carl Orff intended: very loudly!
Can you do Pastoral Symphony, Bolero, Bartered Bride, Barber of Seville, Pines of Rome, Kinderszenen, Four Seasons, Carnival of the Animals, but with different designs for each episodes other than Elgar, Gershwin, and Orf this time?
Thanks for this suggestion - four of these are actually currently in production! A fifth in production is by a composer of another one of them.
Would appreciate some feedback on the animation of the last three and what your thoughts are on changing it? Always valuable for us to know what people like/dislike
Thanks for your support :)
Something *I* would really like to see is Night on Bald Mountain by Modest Mussorgsky.
@@ClassicsExplained the animation for Gershwin should be like 1920s cartoons. Orf’s animation could be based on Dr. Seuss’ artwork. Saint Saens can be like the animation style of Disney Renaissance. The style of Vivaldi might look like Mary Blair’s art. Rachmaninoff’s style should’ve looked like Tim Burton styles (not stop motion). And the upcoming Bizet needs to look like Mucha Lucha.
Learning about the swan being the falsetto voice when thinking it was some sort of metaphor for lustful temptation genuinely made me laugh
ha! It's a fascinating one
So, in a way, it was an actual swan song. I'll see myself out. 😅
I still remember the wash of horror I had when I read the (translated) lyrics of "The Roasting Swan." It was terrifying when you consider the last line is "I see teeth"
@@hagerty1952 Heh heh heh... "Dentes frendentes video!"
@@fleeb - Yep.
I'm stoked. I've been binge watching this series with my 4 year old daughter.
That is really cute :D
Rather racy for a 4 Yr old, no?
Cutest comment - thanks so much. Absolutely delighted to hear this. That means so much to us :) Please keep watching and supporting we are very grateful
You might want to censor out some parts for your daughter....
@@ClassicsExplained are you gonna use different designs this time?
A most excellent choice! My late aunt sang this at Carnegie Hall under Stokowski, an absolute legend.
WOW!!!!
That is so exciting - to say she's sung under Stokowski!
Would love to have been a fly on the wall at rehearsals
Lol just a fly on the wall right? Wouldn't really want to work for him...
@@puffadder92 Stokowski's is my favorite Carmina Burana recording. That Carnegie Hall concert is actually here on youtube as well! But the sound quality is a bit… strange. Stokowski was quite a pioneer in recording engineering stuff, so his Houston studio recording is has a much better balance. What I admire in his recording is the cohesiveness of the sequence of tempi.
As for his reputation for being unpleasant to work with, I'm not quite sure how that came about. There are quite a few Stokowski in rehearsal videos here on YT, so I had a look at some of those. What I see is that he is EXTREMELY efficient. That implies of course that he picks small portions of works that are particularly tricky, That of course, is daunting if you are sitting there playing. Also I see him demanding total focus, not joking to chatting allowed. That also feels a bit… dictatorial. But then, to see it from the positive side, there is a lot of trust in the players in that attitude. I also came to understand that his unpleasantness was something of his later years. Did you aunt speak about him?
Anyway, ol' Stokowski is quite a favorite of mine, not just for his Carmina Burana. His grip on meter and rhythm in particular I find quite fascinating. Thank you for bringing him up.
Pieces you can choose to make a video about:
Erlkonig (Schubert)
Gretchen am Spinnrade (Schubert)
Beethoven symphonies
Don Giovanni (Mozart)
Tannhauser/Die Meistersinger de Nuremberg (Wagner)
Lohengrin/Tristan & Isolde (Wagner)
Salome (R. Strauss)
There’s more but I will tell you later once you chose one
P.S. love ur vids, Ben ❤
Classical flautist (SL)❤
Add rachmaninoff piano concerto 2 too,
Add the Antar Symphony! And Balakirev's "Tamara!"
A couple of additional suggestions:
Les Preludes (Liszt)
Concerto for Orchestra (Bartok)
@@Lucius1958 And for a research challenge, Sergei Lyapunov's "Hashish!"
This is massively appreciated, Sophie - can't thank you enough for your support and recommendations.
So much I wish I could do (and I'd do all your suggestion if I had the time and money!) but I can tell you that one of them is currently in production ;)
I love the little Bewitched nose-wiggle you gave Venus around 6:20! This was such a great episode, I can't believe I've gone this long without actually looking up the story and text of Carmina Burana. I'm glad I learned it through your unique style of storytelling and not some boring written summary!
Thanks! Really appreciate that! Yeah - who wants to read some boring programme notes! Hope this is a funner way to learn! Keep listening and loving classical music :)
I possess a German bilingual copy of the Latin poems from the original anthology.
The nose wiggle was from Bewitched, not I Dream of Jeannie.
@@Xerxes2005 Oh shoot, you're right! I'm gonna correct my comment, thanks for calling that out. 😅
At 10 mins, as I’m feeling for the swan being killed & roasted, the swan singing gets me giggling 😁& laughing 😂. Wow!
Another absolute masterpiece! Orff did pretty well too.
ha! Thanks so much! Loving the support :)
Fun fact: Orff didn't actually have his publishers destroy his previous publications. He admitted in his memoirs that he was being a bit overly dramatic when he told that story. ;-)
I love your videos!! And I would also love to see a "Night On Bald Mountain" video!! 😆😆
Great suggestion! And that recommendation has been made by a few people so definitely a contender! Thanks for the support :)
My local youth symphony woodwinds used to do this piece annually as part of our summer camp, when I was a teen. Definitely an exciting piece! Would love to know more of what it was about.
Quite a step up in the animation style and detail. The art style becoming more refined and more unique to the composer. The cut out puppet style when employed was a nice touch. As always the music research and clear explanations made it accessible to someone who only listens a bit to classical music. Really enjoy your channel.
Thank you very much for this feedback - greatly appreciated and well-observed. We are really trying to step things up now
Thank you so much
I discovered this piece when I was 15. I even used it to conquer my girlfriend's heart at that time (how adequate!), and still today I can recite the complete lyrics by heart (I was studying some Latin and German at that time, so most of the words made sense to me, and that made them much easier to remember). My point being, I know this work very deeply, and yet I discovered new things, meanings, and facts about it. Congratulations for an astonishing job!
What a brilliant tale! Love that you had a feeling for the lyrics too. I sang it at school when I was about 17 or 18 and fell absolutely in love with it too. It's really primal and powerful - thanks for all the support :)
I love this piece! I sang it with my university choir this June, it was so much fun.
Isn't is fab to sing in - I did the same many years back at school and never forgot the experience
One of the first concerts my father took me to see. I was in awe at the music and lyrics, as the text and translation was being projected over the choir.
My favorite piece ever to date!
Brilliant - thanks so much for sharing this ! :))
I enjoy this series so much. I realize having done Rite of Spring the Firebird is unlikely to get a nod. I want to yell play Firebird when I visit symphony (instead of play Freebird at Rock concert😅).
I LOVE THE FIREBIRD. I hope he might do a video on it.
I love the Firebird. Would love to do a video on it - one of those interesting pieces were Ravel is borrowing a lot from Rimsky in terms of orchestration but also doing some rhythmically fascinating stuff that is a precursor for what is to come. Keep tuned and thanks for your support :)))
@@ClassicsExplained Another vote here for Firebird!!
Another piece of art, 👏
Thank you :)
I had only ever heard O Fortuna; the rest of the piece is great and I'm going to listen to the full work after this.
Great video as always, always glad when a video can make me laugh and learn something. Thank you for your hard work!
Thanks so much! I love that you want to listen to the full piece. Like you, prior to singing this piece at school, I only knew O Fortuna. Then I discovered that it really is SO much more than that! Keep loving and learning about classical music and thanks for the support :)
The men's chorus in the "In Taberna" section can be a real show-stopper!
Recently attended a performance staged as an opera. Astoundingly powerful music and visuals
Isn't it just! Singing in it is even better!
This kind of high quality content on classical music is what we need!! Very well done video essay
Thanks so much! Exactly what we're aiming for - just hope it doesn't get a bit too niche for the algorithm!
Discovered this piece in the Excalibur movie
Terrific choice! We played this with our whole school orchestra & choir back in the 1970's. Then recognized it in Excalibur later. 😀
I would really REALLY love to see you analyze Don Giovanni, it's my favourite Mozart Opera! Alternatively, I'd love to see you cover anything from Gilbert and Sullivan, especially Pirates of Penzance (a breakdown of all the references and jokes in "I am the Very Model of A Modern Major General" would be awesome). And since Halloween is coming, I'd also love Saint Saens' Danse Macabre, in the spirit of Spooktober.
What fascinating suggestions! We've done Magic Flute already (as much as I adore Don Giovanni) so perhaps G&S might be a cool left-field one. Regarding SS, keep tuned...! ;)
@@ClassicsExplained So, you're planning something for monsieur Camille? I wonder what could that be? If not Danse Macabre then maybe perhaps Le Carnival Des Animeaux? Or Organ Symphony? Either one would be awesome, and I can't wait to see your next video. Cheers!
@@jarekwrzosek2048 Not just planning...it's more or less ready! Looking forward to sharing soon :)
@@ClassicsExplained YES! Also in the meantime I've got another video Idea for you: Vivaldi's Four Seasons!
Thank you! Can't wait to re listen Carmina Burana twice afterwards
YES!!!
Exactly what I love to hear! Listen to the Eugen Jochum one that we credit - personally endorsed by Orff
These videos are absolutely sublime.
Accessible to classical music newcomers, but also very entertaining and informative for more advanced listeners!
Thanks SO much for this - exactly the sort of comment we love because it encapsulates everything we want this channel to be! Keep enjoying our new releases :)
@@ClassicsExplained I’m so happy you’re back to uploading!
A very interesting piece, Carmina Burana. It certainly depicts a different take on... philosophy, yeah, that what's we're going to call it... from what's typically seen in music.
For something completely different, I'd love to see a video that discusses Shostakovich's String Quartet #8. It's very bleak and pessimistic, but has a fascinating and similarly depressing story.
Or, Shostakovich's Symphony #7; Its premier in the city of Leningrad occurred during the height of the siege during WWII. It is the only piece I know of where a premier was heralded by military action to ensure it would go uninterrupted.
Meanwhile, Dievs, tava zeme deg, a cantata by Latvian composer Lūcija Garūta, premiered in Rīga Cathedral during the 1944 Battle of Rīga. The recording even captures the sound of the battle.
Thanks so much for this!
Some brilliant suggestions - and the Shostakovich symphony is an absolute classic for the reasons you explain. Got to find a way to somehow get it in!
Keep up the support :)
did I see cameo appearance of Elgar in this episode🤣 This is brilliantly animated btw!
Well-spotted and thank you :)
The poems had been separated from their original music, which has since been found. It's amazing how close Orff got.
Yup, the C.B. is a brilliant collecting. Love it!
Bacche bene venies... (especially the line about why you should not drink water...)
@@johanneswerner1140 There's also an entire subtext, when the fourth son of Egino van Urach, the founder of the ducal line of Wurttemburg, cut loose as a suffragan bishop in the Rhineland Monasteries and Nunneries in the late 12th Century. Celibacy was a new doctrine, and not accepted here, so he had to be baled out by the Vatican, who found a use for his visceral hatred in the Albigensian Crusade, where he finished his Cousin Simon IV de Montfort's unfinished business.
My family went to see this piece live yesterday, and I showed them this video as a crash course!
Incredibly clever and as usual, a stellar job. I use the Orff Schulwerk methodology in May Music teaching. Orff Rocks!
Thanks SO much - really appreciate your support. There's many films I could make on Orff because the Schulwerk method is just fascinating. Perhaps we could address it in a side-video of me talking about it at the piano. Thanks for your support - and hope the kids are loving the Schulwerk method!
Oh, I love this piece! The last time I sang this was when I was in a children's choir, and we sang with a college choir and full orchestra.
It's great! I sang it too at school - never forgot how unusual it was to sing in a piece like it after countless Mozarts and Bachs and the like. Was absolutely revelatory
Finally I found an explanation step by step of my favorite cantata ❤ thanks a lot for this amazing work
Wonderful explanation of a fantastic piece. I remember singing this in my local symphony choir. My only knowledge was as "the one with the cool and scary piece that is used in lots of movies and commercials." Our conductor encouraged us to look into the stories and meanings in each piece and I was hooked! I truly enjoyed singing it so much more, understanding what each voice, character, and musical motif was!
THANK YOU!!! I watch these over and over, and a new one is a delight!
What a LOVELY comment - thanks so much. Many more to come :)
4:58 I can’t find any reference to an “Ocasio” god of opportunity anywhere. Caerus is mentioned and is sometimes depicted as having only a forelock of hair. I read in one novel where a character mentioned “grabbing fortune by the forelock”. Another character later asked what was meant by that and was told that the goddess of fortune is depicted as having no hair on her head behind her ears. The first character replied “Doesn’t sound very attractive, does it?” 😊
Thanks for producing this, I really enjoyed it. Carmina Burana is one of my favorites!
I think the poem is not referring to a character named Occasio, but rather a personification of opportunity.
on wikipedia: Occasio or Tempus is roman equivalent of Caerus
I first heard Carmina Burana in middle school as our drama teacher used it as incidental music in our performance of the Hobbit. I loved it so much he made me a cassette after the show. I played it until the tape wore out and I tried to replace it. What I didn't realize is that it was the Ray Manzarak prog rock version and it was 20 years before I tracked that version down. 😂
Amazing! And I love the Manzarek connection! He did quite a few kooky versions of classical piece. If I weren’t doing classical music videos, I’d love to do Doors ones!
I should suggest you some pieces to make some more masterpieces of yours about:
Night On Bald Mountain (Mussorgsky)
Tale Of Tsar Saltan (Rimsky-Korsakov)
Leningrad Symphony (Shostakovich)
The Miraculous Mandarin (Bela Bartok)
Alice In Wonderland (Unsuk Chin)
Suicide In An Airplane (Leo Ornstein)
Firebird/Petrushka (Stravinsky)
Tosca/Turandot (Puccini)
L'Orfee Aux Enfer (Offenbach)
The Bat (Strauss)
Danse Macabre (Saint-Saens/Liszt)
To be continued...
P. S. Waiting for your new masterpieces, Ben 💓
If you recommend the Leningrad Symphony, I recommend Dievs Tava Zeme Deg by the Latvian Lūcija Garūta. Another Latvian composer with an epic story would be Jānis Mediņš who began his opera Fire and Night in 1913, served in the Tsar's army, and after the Revolution, crossed Siberia and European Russia to return to an independent Latvia, carrying the massive score the entire way.
Thanks so much for your huge support and for these suggestions. A piece very closely linked to one of this (which quotes heavily from it) is soon to be released by us!
Absolutely fascinating!
Woww I didn't know Latvian classical music at all :(( my guilt :( I should listen this, thanks :)
I absolutely LOVE this video. The animation is very well made and the way it's narrated and explained makes it so fun! I wish this had subtitles so i can show it to my non-english speaking friends.
As someone who only knew the o fortuna part prior to watching, I can say that this is the exact opposite of what I expected it to be about
I feel its best modern inclusion was in the score of the 1981 Boorman film "Excalibur". Since I was already a musician, it's what really sparked my interest to learn Latin as well.
Very deep and exciting music, the instruments literally speak along with singers. Love it
Thanks so much - and for the support :)
Fantastic video and a well thoughtful series ❤ When chance is brought up I’d loooove to see a video about a Mahler symphony :))))
Thanks so much for this lovely compliment! Keep up the support - and the Mahler suggestion is brilliant. I've toyed with the idea a lot and am seriously weighing up between two particular Mahler ones
I would also like a discusion on Menotti- Amahl and the Night Visitors.
yes
I just noticed the guy catching fire as he rides into the sunset at 7:05! 😂
Did you notice that Paris looks like Hercules?
I just want to announce that I just missed the job of a lifetime over a technicality, and all I could think of was of this video’s Fortuna patting my shoulder saying “best luck next time”
I sang this my freshman year of college. It never got performed because it was 2020. Ended up learning the Orff method of music education instead
First of all, this channel’s work and dedication are surprising. Thank you for all these video masterpieces! My suggestion for a new video is Wagner’s „Der Ring des Nibelungen” and Shostakovich’s 7th Symphony. Greetings from Romania! 🇷🇴
Classics explained already made der ring de nibelingen
@@lisys511 Sorry, i just saw the video after i posted this comment. ☺️
Another hit!
Thanks so much for your support!
my favorite piece! i sang with the university of michigan choir at carnegie hall in the prehistoric era; Rafael Fruhbeck de Burgos conducted . can’t wait to hear (and see 😊) what you’ve done with this piece! ❤
I had an aunt sing this at Carnegie under Stokowski
WOW! Must have been amazing to sing this under him! :)
You are awesome, once again you make a video about a piece that it’s going to be played this season on our local venue(Teatro colon, Buenos Aires)
This is one of the few channels where I'll periodically check back to see if I missed any uploads just in case you snuck past my notifications lol
LOVE this supportive comment - keep up the morale boost!
Absolutely enjoy your videos!
Suggestions coming for pieces you could do videos around: Bach and his Brandenburg Concertos
Mozart and his Piano Concertos No 20 & 21
Mozart’s Piano Sonata No 11 in A (the Rondo Alla Turca) and his Symphonies No 25, 40 and his famous symphony No 41.
Perhaps selections from Handel’s Messiah.
Mozart (his Sunny Symphony No 29), Piano quartet’s No 1 & 2
Schubert (Unfinished Symphony & his Trout Quintet)
Can’t wait to see more of what you do in the future!
Thanks SO much for this and your suggestions and your support - we will deffo keep them coming :)
I played a portion of this work in concert band my senior year of high school, we performed 6 movements from it in concert band. I was sad I wasn’t the timpanist in it because I wasn’t first chair percussion, but I played the piano and chimes during the concert, and it was one of my most favorite works to play, definitely brought good memories from high school band. I’m glad I finally understand what is going on in all of the pieces in the work, thank you!
So pleased it brought back those wonderful memories - one day you will be the timpanist I hope! :)
8:09 - 8:11
"This is Goliard approved Lust!"
The following is a quote from an interview with Asmodeus, the literal embodiment of Lust:
"As both a noble King in the Ars Goetia, and the Sin Demon of Lust, even doing something simple like mentioning the Goliards or even alluding to them makes me uncomfortable! I don't see Lust as something that should be forced upon! It's gross, it's illegal, and it makes me sick *past* my stomach!!"
-Asmodeus, the Sin Demon of Lust.
I was first exposed to this work in my tweens when my father, a public school instrumental educator, bought an album, the particulars of which I can't remember. I had a musically inclined ear from infancy (so I've been told) and was struck immediately with the primal quality of the music; the feeling that it was both ancient and modern at the same time. The music lured me in to reading the liner notes and following the translated poetry and even though I was too young to *really* get it, I got it to the extent I could. I'll have to do some digging and see if somehow I ended up with that LP. I haven't listened to the whole thing in ages. Thanks for a great summation.
These videos are mind blowing!
Thanks so much! Many more on their way :)
Great to see you again! I can't wait for future episodes!
Thanks so much for the support - looking to bringing out the next few soon! :)
Carmina burana is my most valued memory of my beginnings in classical music taste, as I always seek videos explaining its melancholic message. I’m so glad to know I’ve found such in this video, along with the funniest visuals ever ❤️❤
Wonderful comment - many thanks for sharing and watching :)
I proformed this in a big thing and now i love this song
I want this to get more recommended by the algorithm, so here is this comment
The algorithm wants you to listen to Beyonds or Lizzo.
Sadly!
But thank you so much for this and your support!
Wait a minute, was that George Gershwin entering the tavern (11:16)?
And Paul Whiteman
and is that... *gasp* SIR EDWARD ELGAR?!
Well spotted - we were hoping some keen eyes would play along with the in-joke
My most direct introduction to the O Fortuna section was the 'salsa cookies' meme from like 10 years ago, and I've since added the entire Carmina Burana piece to my work playlist. I absolutely love it, and I really enjoy your presentation of the meaning behind the work. After watching this video, I am again reminded that people do not change. On a side note, I am dying that the falsetto section is supposed to be from the perspective of the swan lol what a great piece
Orff was briefly mentioning the Homer and Virgil's acounts of Trojan War which was depicted at the begining of Berlioz' Les Troyens.
Superb! Excellent overview.......👍
11:17 Gershwin is one of the boys 😎
Well-spotted ;)
An excellent video!
Thank you!
I love carmina burana
YOU'RE BACK!!!!!
We are indeed! And not too long for release of next film either! Thanks for the support :)
Saw this piece done by the Cincinati Symphony Orchestra years ago. As it happenened i had broken my foot earlier that day. I recall not only temporarily forgeting my pain but but being nearly brought to tears. That was actually the very first (but not last) time thst had happened.
Wonderful comment - thank you for watching :)
Carmina Burana means "Songs from Beuren" because the book containing these songs was found in Benediktbeuren Abbey. They were, however, written down either in Styria or in Brixen in Tyrol by a monk who knew no or very little German himself for the handwriting shows Italian characteristics and the Middle High German has strange mistakes.
Yep! We wish we could have explained this in more detail - and it certainly wasn't lost on us. We felt to delve into the linguisitc points may have taken away from the flow of this film. But it is certainly something I would consider addressing in more depth in a spin-off video at the piano. Thanks for the comment :)
@@ClassicsExplained Still you mistranslated. It's not "Songs from Bavaria".
Brilliant video of my favourite piece of classical music. Well done and thank you!
This video showed up in my recommendations and yes I like classical music, so I watched it. I enjoyed it so much I subscribed, now I'm going back to the beginning to watch the videos in series.
I don’t know how this could happen, but I really want Chopin on this channel. I know his isn’t program music but a Ballade maybe?
I'm a pianist so naturally adore playing Chopin. There is so much to choose from though...the Ballades aren't a bad place to start though! Thanks so much for the support :)
@@ClassicsExplained my favourite Chopin's program music is Raindrop Prelude ;)
Carmina Burana is also the music that inspired "One Winged Angel". Except for "Sephiroth", all the lyrics are nicked from the poems Orff used.
In addition to the great suggestions for videos, consider, Darius Milhaud’s Scaramouche and his Saudades Do Brazil. There high levels of polytonality in Saudades.❤❤
Please do the William Tell Overture next
Great suggestion! Thanks for watching
Carmina burana really is a masterpiece and one of my favourite pieces ever (even tho it's packed with sin)
Back in 1982 I was in the UMass Lowell marching band and our off the line piece was Music from Carmina Burana opening with O Fortuna.
I associated O Fortuna with the movie Excalibur till I sang it in a choir. This video gives a more comprehensive summary than our conductor did. Incidentally, after-parties following a performance of Carmina Burana tend to go off with a bang...
NO WAYYY. I just found out that prog group Magma was heavily inspired by O Fortuna so I did a Wikipedia dive on this piece. Can't wait to learn more!
which skng is inspired by O Fortuna?
Amazing how many bands it inspired :)
@@minnieyuyantung I would say Stravinsky 's Les Noces is a more direct and obvious influence. listen to the Magma albums Wurdah Itah and Mekanik Destruktiw Kommandoh.
Like a number of the commenters here I first heard O Fortuna as part of the Excalibur movie in the 1970's but great piece of music won't be denied and loved the work since.
However! I never understood the story - I am NOT one for dry performance notes.
Thank you so much for your concise and clear explanation of the story. I have just relistened to the oratorio but with a much clearer understanding.
This is one of my all time favorites, first heard it in the old movie Excalibur. It always gets my blood pumping.
It's great!
In the segment "Chramer, gip die varwe mir", I hear sleigh bells. They also appear in Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart's German Dance no. 3 "Sleigh Ride", Emile Waldteufel's Skaters Waltz, Frederick Delius' WInter Night, Richard Eilenberg's Petersburg Sleigh Ride, at the begining of Gustav Mahler's Fourth Symphony, Leroy Anderson's Sleigh Ride, Serge Prokofiev's Troika from Lieutenant Kije, Angela Morley's Snow RIde, and Philip Lane's Sleighbell Serenade.
I would also want a discussion on the Christmas Pastorales of Corelli, Torelli, Locateli, Manfredini, etc.
Thanks for all these super suggestions :)
OMG, what an amazing video!
What about the Four Seasons by Antonio Vivaldi?
Also Pastoral Symphony by Beethoven, Bolero, by Ravel, Bartered Bride by Smetana, Barber of Seville by Rossini, Roman Trilogy by Respighi, Carnival of the Animals by Saint Saens, Lark Ascending by Williams, Kinderszenen by Schumann, Pearl Fishers by Bizet, La Boheme by Puccini, Rigoletto by Verdi, Song of the Night by Mahler, and Tales from the Vienna forest by Strauss!
Coming VERY soon ;)
3 of these in production (with one of them being the next one) and the composer of one of them coming up soon :)
Another made-of-awesome video! Excellent review and great details & presentation. Moar pLz!
My first exposure to Carmina Burana was John Boorman's Excalibur, which was a perfect match of screen and classical. I would argue that movie kicked off the popular use of O Fortuna on the big and small screens.
Great point! And thanks for the compliments :)
Excalibur brought me here.
The Once and Future King Rides Again..!
Venus also appears in Respighi's Triptych to Botticelli from 1927.
after singing this with my boy coir with was on our top 5 concerts we did!!! Our favorit part was the famous;OH OH OHHHH TOTUS FLOREO
There's a choreography for this piece, authored by Ernst Uthoff, co-founder of the Chilean National Ballet (dependant of the University of Chile, the country's state university). You can watch excerpts of it searching in RUclips by "Carmina Burana 2010 Estacion Mapocho."
I sang in the choir years before (Symphonic Choir of the University of Chile), we sang the whole thing by heart - and mostly in darkness. 😁
As a musician, I've had a ... fateful experience with Carmina Burana. It started in High School, when I was playing with my Youth Orchestra, I was invited to perform Carmina to cover for another musician in a large amatuer orchestra. Unfortunately the performance was to be the night before my final school exams and parents, teachers and even trumpet tutor would pressure me into not accepting the position. I'd spend the next week blasting recordings of Carmina on the daily at home like a rebellious teen. "There will be plenty of opportunities to perform Carmina I'm sure" they said. Tempting fate.
I moved to another state to go to University and about 3 months after my move, I was invited again to perform Carmina. In my former state. I accepted, advising that I might have to miss a specific rehearsal, but would be there for the main rehearsals. It would require some expensive 10 hour drives from university to home (or 1 hour flights), but my university schedule could be squished around to avoid Mondays most of the time, and they had 4 Monday rehearsals followed by a Saturday. I was in for a penny, in for a pound and ready for some sleep-deprived Tuesdays at uni and a few questionable 10 hour drives starting at 10pm into a 9am class the next day. Till they found out I actually wasn't living in state, and they cancelled me (while I was in Sydney ready for the first rehearsal the next day). Apparently their rules meant we all had to be in-state musicians or something. Finally, I managed to join a large community Orchestra and perform with them a few times before they were ready to do a Carmina. I was invited, confirmed, and ready to go, and our Performance was scheduled for August of 2020. Covid-19 lockdowns cancelled every performance venue in the state for 6 months starting in June. running 3 out of 3 for cancelled Carmina's.
Great :) thanks for sharing!
Aaargh not the trumpet tutor... this hurts. Smh.
What is it with the glorified exams. Music is good for brain. Not so sure about binge studying on the night before.
5:29 I-CAN'T-EAT-RICE!
Mindblowing storytelling! Knew most of this from when I sung in university choir, but pictures give it life, 10/10 (and also matches Orff's intent as far as I understand)
When singing though, I never imagined the baritone character in a sweaty wifebeater...
ha! Thanks
Wow! Your videos are getting better and better! It's obvious a whole lot of work goes into each one and so they can only come out every once in a while but it's always such a treat when I see a video by you come up in the suggestions! Learning is easy when it's fun!
Awesome! I love it! What a great video! I’ve sung it but this video taught me a ton!!! Thanks!
Stravinsky revised Petrushka in 1947 (10 years after Carmina Burana's Premiere). Earlier he had debued his Les Noces in 1923 with Choreography by Bronislava Nijinska.
Another wonderful job! From the animation to the analyze, everything is so well made. :D
May I give you a suggestion? I would love to see a video about The Cunning Little Vixen by Leoš Janáček. ^^
Thanks so much for this compliment - and the fantastic suggestion :)
you deserve a million more suibs
Love this! Thanks so much for your support. That would be the dream - to get people as excited about classical music as we are
Consider a discussion on Lyadov's Tone Poems Baba Yaga, The Enchanted Lake, and Kikimora.
"From the Apocalypse" is a great hint of what could have been if Lyadov had composed the ballet for Diaghilev in 1909 instead of Stravinsky.
Excellent work! Love the animations and storytelling! I am a little disappointed that the only inclusion of Nazi influence here is a bit misleading, though. The Nazi party were staunchly against modern music and wanted to hearken back to the sounds of Mozart and Beethoven to sell the idea of German superiority, to the point that they banned many composers' works and intentionally propagandized this one for its more classical and populist sound. I've even heard that at some points of the war, its message of giving into carnal lust was leaned into, as a way for the party to convince more people to have babies which would ensure they would have an army for decades to come. That last bit was more speculative from my professor at the time, but he gave some solid supporting evidence.
Thanks for your compliments and the interesting points raised in your message. I should say that I was planning on addressing these issues in a bit more depth in the video but didn't want to dwell on Orff's "Nazi problem" and also thought it might better be addressed in a spin-off video of me talking about the point at the piano. Great food for thought and definitely one I'm considering producing a short on. Lest we forget - this is the most famous piece to come out of Nazi Germany...
Thanks for your support :)
Brilliant!!