이세준님 표정이 아직 못 다 핀 꽃송이인데 어찌 저런 목소리 화음이 나올까 하는 표정 같으네요 아이돌 치고는 노래 또한 일취월장 늘어가는 것이 확실히 느껴지네요 산들군이야 불명에서 알아주누 보컬이 된지 오래고 신우군은 다시 보게 되었네요 어쩜 이리 맑고 곱고 기교도 없이 깨끗하게 부르는지 그저 신기 할 따름이네요 선배 가수들 사이에서도 인정을 했다니 말 다한것이나 매한가지네요
환상호흡이란 말이 이럴때 쓰이는것 같고... 산들군이야 워낙 불명에서 알아주는 실력이지만...신우군 오늘 모든 누나분들 마음 다 녹이신것 같습니다....노래듣는 선배가수분들이나 이미자님의 얼굴표정에서...오늘 노래에 대한 평은 다한것 같습니다... 너무 멋진무대였어요^^
B1A4 is really one of the idols who are not only hard working but you can see really great results. Their Immortal Song performances always gives us a new side of them. And the quality of their singing and the arrangements they are using fits them, so props Sandeul and CNU! You did a great job here! More B1A4 on IS2 please
CNU is soooo perfect. No wonder why he's my best bias not just in B1A4 but in my whole bias list. CNU is always my #1!!! This performance together with Sandeul is really amazing. I love listening to their Immortal Song performances since I can really see how good they are as performers... which obviously makes me love CNU more and more. Their voices blend together beautifully, no one is trying to overshadow the other. Teamwork is really there, they're very professional artists... ♥ 신우 너무 사랑해요 ♥ シンヌーとても大好き！あなたにできるすべてのことを捧げは。いつもの私の天使です。
That was simply angelic.. their voices go so well together! I honestly thought that CNU might be kind of overshadowed by Sandeul becuase he's been so powerful in some of his past performances, but this was beyond perfect!!!
I don't know what to say... This was so beautiful! I almost cried. They're incredibly talented. You can feel every emotion they express in the song. Indeed a true musician sings and listens with his heart and soul.
MARVELLOUS DUO,BEAUTIFUL, EXCELLENT SINGERS AND SONG ESPECIAL UNFORGETTABLES VOICES, THAT EMOTION THE SOUL THANK IS A GIFT, CONGRATULETION NOW AND FOREVER REMEMBERS,💝💝🌟🌟👏👏👏👏💐
In this competition, it doesn't really matter who wins. What matters is that they have touched so many people with their performance. Sandeul's voice is very stable and I'm always so relaxed listening to him. For some reason I always feel nervous whenever CNU does his solo. It always feels like he'll make a mistake but he always finishes perfectly! I think he's still working on the stability of his voice but hey, he sounds like Brian Mcknight right there! Proud BANA here!
Sandeul Oppa and Cnu Oppa's voice are so beautiful! I don't know about you guys but I can listen to this and I will fall asleep cause this song is calming! Jinyoung Oppa my bias saranghae! B1A4 OPPAS FIGHTING
Beautiful * . * I think Sandeul was born with this amazing voice, but Shinwoo has worked hard and improved a lot and now he's amazing too. We (BANAs) can be really proud of him!
This made me cry. Both Sandeul and CNU's voices left me shivering and crying. It didn't even matter that I didn't understand, it was just so beautiful and maybe even, haunting in a way. Sandeul and CNU have such powerful voices...though I was so afraid that Sandeul would overpower CNU's voice, but this performance had an immense amount of balance. These two should sing more often. #Sandeul #CNU #B1A4
Am I the only one who dreamt of this ballad performance from CNU and Sandeul. I almost or I actually cried upon hearing and watching this! ♥ TT-TT This is so amazing and wonderful.
i really miss Sandeul's high notes but at the same time i love when they harmonize like this too. Good job guys! If not for this show, i don't think i'll ever like b1a4
god, I love this. Perfect perf. Talented beautiful people. Ugh. This will stay in my head for a veeerryyyy long time. I hope they could be on IS2 more, and one day, just once, the whole of B1A4 comes, I wan my Channiee. But Sandeul alone is fine too. He's such an amazing singer. They are all amazing to me~~ #B1A4 #LONELY
I'm a proud bana of B1A4 especially in love with CNU. From the beginning he was talented, but he still worked hard to improve his voice. Love how humble he is, and I wish him succes. Besitos CNU me encanta tu nuevo look!!!!
I missed them so bad that i ended up watching their old videos,, its making me cry to death... like,,, look how much these babies have grown now.. i love themmmm
wow my ears have heard angels singing!!! solo beautiful there voices are so soft but strong love them....WaaaCNU why so handsome why!!!!!! He is OMG so handsome. I would like to hear his low but sweet voice in a lullaby. very dreamy. sanduek remind me of Sungmin both have the same of joy expresion and there eyes glow when they sing alone or in group and live the song.
Sandeul is amazing, goes without saying and I love him above all, but I think CNU is underrated vocally, he shows here that he has beautiful vocal ability... credit to CNU ❤️ Great performance x Thank you ❤️❤️❤️ xxx
I'm really proud of them, really!!! T.T I've been their fan since their debut day, and watching what they did all this while, made me so proud of them B1A4 FIGHTING!!!
That was beautiful!!! I want to cry because I am so proud of them. Really, they should sing together a duets more often. Cnu's soft voice against Sandeul's harsher one brings out...ahhhh...I can't describe it. I am just so proud!!!
I knew they would shine this bright, right from their debut day. They always work hard and have so much talents. B1A4 is the most heart-touching idol group for me, thanks to their efforts. Proud! :')
Oh my god, Amazing performance! Cnu and Sandeul's voice is a good match! and CNU working hard on his voice getting better and better since their debut... I'm so proud of our bear~♥
This performance cause my mouth to make unintelligible sounds cx I wish they would have lowered the instrumental in the middle of the song tho... it kind of overpowers their voices :/ Their voices are so amazing (together) I can't even
I almost cried. I could hear this over and over again, their voices are so powerful and beautiful. You, people, don't understand how happy this makes me feel, I'm so proud of of them. I LOVE THEM SO MUCH ♡
listening to it again... the beginning, they sound so desperate in a way... when the pace got faster, I could feel them soften a bit... but it still sounds like they're desperate... Their harmony is amazing too... (I keep imagining Baro rapping after the high note for some reason) the instrumental is so... dramatically perfect for this perf... just they sound like they're finally letting it go... like they sound smoother at the end... but still sad.... the ending is beautiful... -going sentimental again- #B1a4
![[HIT] 불후의 명곡2-산들(Sandeul) - 잊혀진 계절.20121117](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/p8zvm6Jjvpw/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HIT] 불후의 명곡2-산들(Sandeul) - 잊혀진 계절.20121117](/img/tr.png)
![Sandeul - Cosmos Flower Song | 산들 - 코스모스 피어있는 길 [Immortal Songs 2]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/054heAot_-w/mqdefault.jpg)
![[HOT] B1A4 - One candle, B1A4 - 촛불 하나, Yesterday 20140308](/img/1.gif)
이세준님 표정이 아직 못 다 핀 꽃송이인데
어찌 저런 목소리 화음이 나올까 하는 표정
같으네요
아이돌 치고는 노래 또한 일취월장 늘어가는
것이 확실히 느껴지네요
산들군이야 불명에서 알아주누 보컬이 된지
오래고 신우군은 다시 보게 되었네요
어쩜 이리 맑고 곱고 기교도 없이 깨끗하게
부르는지 그저 신기 할 따름이네요
선배 가수들 사이에서도 인정을 했다니
말 다한것이나 매한가지네요
화음 넘좋아요 원곡이 생각안날정도네요 어린나인데도 감성표현 정말 좋아요 신우 넘 멋지고 산들이 넘 귀여워요 한편의 드라마를 본듯하네요
신우 긴머리 넘넘 잘 어울려요 멋져요 어쩜 남자가 긴머리 잘 어울리는 사람 많지 않은데 신우 넘 넘 멋지다 멋져
지금 들어도 완벽한 조합입니다.영원히 기억할 거예요
산들이랑 신우 화음이 완전 짱입니다. 옛노래를 이렇게 감성풍부한 목소리로 부르니 너무 듣기 좋아요
지금 또 듣고 봐도 멋지네요 신우 완전 멋지다 산들 귀여워
신동우도 보석인데 제대하거 리얼 꽃길만 걷길...ㅠ
신우가 화음맞추는 부분 소름돋네요. 신우도 데뷔때보다 실력이 많이 는거같아요. 기교를 싹 빼니까 목소리도 예쁘고 섬세하고 정말 짱이에요bb
난 3년동안 바나하면서 신우가 저렇게 노래를 잘했다는걸 왜 여태까지 모른거지 옆에사람 신우인거보고 진짜 놀랐다 둘이 목소리도 너무 잘어울리고 진짜 둘다 잘부른다..
B1a4 has mad vocals. I'm so proud to be a bana
+YuriDiculous me too
와우.. 산들군이 잘하는건 진작부터 알고있었지만 신우군도 잘하네요 목소리 너무좋아요 둘의 화음.. 아름답다는 생각이 듭니다 앞으로도 좋은무대 보여주세요~
환상호흡이란 말이 이럴때 쓰이는것 같고...
산들군이야 워낙 불명에서 알아주는 실력이지만...신우군 오늘 모든 누나분들 마음 다 녹이신것 같습니다....노래듣는 선배가수분들이나 이미자님의 얼굴표정에서...오늘 노래에 대한 평은 다한것 같습니다...
너무 멋진무대였어요^^
사랑스러워...... 이때 너희 20대 초반으로 어린 나이였는데 어린나이에 어떻게 이런 분위기에 노래를 잘 소화해서 부를 수가 있지.. 대단해 아가들
신우군도 숨겨진 보석이었군요.. 좀만더 다듬는다면 더훌륭한 보컬이될듯! 음색이 어쩜저리도 맑은지.. 산들군과 신우군의 노래에 마음이 편안해졌네요 정말듣기좋아요 둘의 화음은 제가본 아이돌가수중 단연 최고라해도 과언이 아니리라 생각될정도네요ㅎ 무한반복중!
B1A4 is really one of the idols who are not only hard working but you can see really great results. Their Immortal Song performances always gives us a new side of them. And the quality of their singing and the arrangements they are using fits them, so props Sandeul and CNU! You did a great job here! More B1A4 on IS2 please
yes. i agree with u :) IS2 always make them to show their hidden talent. proud noona here ^_^
이렇게 사랑스런 화음♡♡
서로 정말 잘 알고 믿으니까 나오것 같다
CNU is soooo perfect. No wonder why he's my best bias not just in B1A4 but in my whole bias list. CNU is always my #1!!! This performance together with Sandeul is really amazing. I love listening to their Immortal Song performances since I can really see how good they are as performers... which obviously makes me love CNU more and more. Their voices blend together beautifully, no one is trying to overshadow the other. Teamwork is really there, they're very professional artists... ♥ 신우 너무 사랑해요 ♥ シンヌーとても大好き！あなたにできるすべてのことを捧げは。いつもの私の天使です。
agree
좋읍니다,,,,, 이 조합,,,@^^@
B1A4 노래왜이렇게잘합니까? 진짜잘해요!
산들랑 CNU 최고이에요!
Those harmonies are so beautiful I think my brain is melting out of my ears
신우오빠 노래 진짜 잘한다 ♡♡♡♡ 😍
화음이 너무 예뻐요 진짜 둘다 너무 잘해요 ㅠㅠ
That was simply angelic.. their voices go so well together! I honestly thought that CNU might be kind of overshadowed by Sandeul becuase he's been so powerful in some of his past performances, but this was beyond perfect!!!
agree
I don't know what to say... This was so beautiful! I almost cried. They're incredibly talented. You can feel every emotion they express in the song. Indeed a true musician sings and listens with his heart and soul.
god cnus voice makes me want to cry like a baby!!!! D:
CNU's voice in the beginning and ending had my heart hurting it's so beautiful TTuTT
me as well
Beyond perfect harmony. Not so surprised since B1A4 always in harmony whenever singing, even not their songs 😘💕👍
아우 신우 목소리 너무 좋다..🖤
Sandeul always amazes me with his perfomances and his voice
Both of them are the ones that sing better in B1A4. They can all sing good but Sandeul and Cnu have the most powerful voices in the group.
Both have such beautiful voices!:)
Agreed!!
I disagree that CNU has a powerful voice but I agree they can sing
ohmygudde He can do high notes though....
Yeah that's true
OMG! I was like "Where is this ANGELIC VOICE come from? Oh! it's SANDEUL & CNU" .. No wonder.. Such a GREAT VOICE.. Really a GOOD SINGER 👍❤️ #B1A4 ❤️
MARVELLOUS DUO,BEAUTIFUL, EXCELLENT SINGERS AND SONG ESPECIAL UNFORGETTABLES VOICES, THAT EMOTION THE SOUL THANK IS A GIFT, CONGRATULETION NOW AND FOREVER REMEMBERS,💝💝🌟🌟👏👏👏👏💐
In this competition, it doesn't really matter who wins. What matters is that they have touched so many people with their performance. Sandeul's voice is very stable and I'm always so relaxed listening to him. For some reason I always feel nervous whenever CNU does his solo. It always feels like he'll make a mistake but he always finishes perfectly! I think he's still working on the stability of his voice but hey, he sounds like Brian Mcknight right there! Proud BANA here!
omGod yesss love cnu's voice so soft
내가 산에 갈때마다 들었던 영상 오랜만에 보니 감회가 새롭네요
Great duet 💚 Beautiful vocals. You can see the audience responses to their voices 🥰
신우는 마이크를 입술에 눌러서 노래하는 경향이 있어서 소리가 뭉개지게 들림. 둘이 잘불렀다.
Sandeul Oppa and Cnu Oppa's voice are so beautiful! I don't know about you guys but I can listen to this and I will fall asleep cause this song is calming! Jinyoung Oppa my bias saranghae! B1A4 OPPAS FIGHTING
Beautiful * . *
I think Sandeul was born with this amazing voice, but Shinwoo has worked hard and improved a lot and now he's amazing too. We (BANAs) can be really proud of him!
one of my favourite immortal songs performances especially when they sing together at the end so beautiful :')
아..화음 너무 좋았음..
OMG!!!!!! It's just OMG!!! how come such a young boy can interpret the emotion of this song so well!!
This made me cry. Both Sandeul and CNU's voices left me shivering and crying. It didn't even matter that I didn't understand, it was just so beautiful and maybe even, haunting in a way. Sandeul and CNU have such powerful voices...though I was so afraid that Sandeul would overpower CNU's voice, but this performance had an immense amount of balance. These two should sing more often.
#Sandeul #CNU #B1A4
Wow Sandeul and Cnu voices go well together
It gave me chills 😭♥️♥️♥️
Am I the only one who dreamt of this ballad performance from CNU and Sandeul. I almost or I actually cried upon hearing and watching this! ♥ TT-TT This is so amazing and wonderful.
신우의재발견. 멋있다!
Two different voice and style
But in this duet it's really perfect.
B1A4 best kpop group!!
신우.산들목소르 짱♥♥감미롭다 ㅋㅋ
This is beautiful. Sanduel's and CNu's voices go so well together.
B1A4 짱! 진짜대박이다!
빠른 업뎃 감사드려요!!! B1A4 짱짱!!!! 노래 넘 좋아요~~~ 저 어려운 노래를 이렇게 안정적으로 불러내다니!! 짱짱!!!! >ㅅ
it's amazing how well they sing together :')
piola (?
와우♡♡♡
감동 감동 감동
최고다♡♡♡
i really miss Sandeul's high notes but at the same time i love when they harmonize like this too. Good job guys!
If not for this show, i don't think i'll ever like b1a4
sandeul.....beautiful voice
god, I love this. Perfect perf. Talented beautiful people. Ugh. This will stay in my head for a veeerryyyy long time.
I hope they could be on IS2 more, and one day, just once, the whole of B1A4 comes, I wan my Channiee. But Sandeul alone is fine too. He's such an amazing singer. They are all amazing to me~~ #B1A4 #LONELY
신들 너무 잘하네요
THEY HARMONIZE SO WELL!!!
I'm a proud bana of B1A4 especially in love with CNU. From the beginning he was talented, but he still worked hard to improve his voice. Love how humble he is, and I wish him succes. Besitos CNU me encanta tu nuevo look!!!!
I missed them so bad that i ended up watching their old videos,, its making me cry to death... like,,, look how much these babies have grown now.. i love themmmm
wow my ears have heard angels singing!!! solo beautiful there voices are so soft but strong love them....WaaaCNU why so handsome why!!!!!! He is OMG so handsome. I would like to hear his low but sweet voice in a lullaby. very dreamy.
sanduek remind me of Sungmin both have the same of joy expresion and there eyes glow when they sing alone or in group and live the song.
신우 노래잘하네
This makes me tear up everytime... I love them
Sandeul is amazing, goes without saying and I love him above all, but I think CNU is underrated vocally, he shows here that he has beautiful vocal ability... credit to CNU ❤️ Great performance x Thank you ❤️❤️❤️ xxx
신우오빠랑 산들오빠랑 멋있어
ShinDeul's voice is so soothing
I'm really proud of them, really!!! T.T
I've been their fan since their debut day, and watching what they did all this while, made me so proud of them
B1A4 FIGHTING!!!
이 노래 조회수가 믿기지가 않네. 난 가끔 들으러 오는데.
Musical-liked👍🏼 full of story ar!! Love their voices so much❤️
Oh my goodness! That was beautiful! They started and ended together perfectly!
😍😍💗💗 what a beautiful voice 👏👏👏👏👏
That was beautiful!!! I want to cry because I am so proud of them. Really, they should sing together a duets more often. Cnu's soft voice against Sandeul's harsher one brings out...ahhhh...I can't describe it. I am just so proud!!!
still watching #teamshindeul ..amazing voices of B1A4
I never think they can sing as well as this untill saw immoral song. They really talent and sing with all their heart.
DanThanh P.N have you watched all their immortal songs? omgosh loveet so much
I knew they would shine this bright, right from their debut day. They always work hard and have so much talents. B1A4 is the most heart-touching idol group for me, thanks to their efforts. Proud! :')
ㅎ 돌아섰다가 다시 돌아옵니다 떠날 수 없어서 이뻐요 신우
Oh my god, Amazing performance! Cnu and Sandeul's voice is a good match!
and CNU working hard on his voice getting better and better since their debut... I'm so proud of our bear~♥
This is beautiful
진짜 멋지다!!자랑스럽다 비원에이포!!!♥♥♥♥
산들오빠 대단하다 왕주왕전에 나오다니!♥
This performance cause my mouth to make unintelligible sounds cx
I wish they would have lowered the instrumental in the middle of the song tho... it kind of overpowers their voices :/
Their voices are so amazing (together) I can't even
I almost cried. I could hear this over and over again, their voices are so powerful and beautiful. You, people, don't understand how happy this makes me feel, I'm so proud of of them. I LOVE THEM SO MUCH ♡
자랑스럽다 내가수 B1A4♡
달리 무슨 말이 필요한가. 좋다 그냥. 신우는 목소리도 좋고 표현력도 좋은데, 군데 군데 약간 발음이 부정확한게 아쉽네. 이런거보면 산들이가 확실히 노래를 잘 하는구나....
오늘도 혼자서 들으러 왔다...
gave me chills!! i loved how they made this duet magical!
:O this one is so beautiful. CNU voice killing me
떠날 수 없네요 이뻐요 정말 이뻐요
이때 이세준님이 노래해석을 해주셔서ㅜㅜㅠㅠㅜ더감동💕
This performance was AMAZING!! I keep watching it.. It's too good! I love B1A4
Cnu voice, is so soft...:')
makes my heart beating fashter...
I love their voice ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
Beautiful performance.
listening to it again...
the beginning, they sound so desperate in a way... when the pace got faster, I could feel them soften a bit... but it still sounds like they're desperate...
Their harmony is amazing too... (I keep imagining Baro rapping after the high note for some reason)
the instrumental is so... dramatically perfect for this perf... just they sound like they're finally letting it go... like they sound smoother at the end... but still sad.... the ending is beautiful...
-going sentimental again- #B1a4
Merci a vous 2! CNU et Sandeul mille mercis pour cette merveilleuse chanson, tellement emouvante et chantee avec une telle sensibilite.
MERCI ❤
Amazing voice
Wow.. that was amazing ! Their vocals... daebak..
This is absolutely beautiful!!
캬~>///
OMG that was beyond perfect proud to be a bana
love you sandeul oppa
What more can I say? It's PERFECT.!