If you watch the whole clip he says my heart goes out to you and he does it by touching his heart and then gesturing my heart goes out to you. Wow I guess hate mongers like you only have hate in your life don't you?
You’re absolutely correct. In no way does this look like a duck, sounds like a duck, or swims like a duck. In NO WAY is it Nazism. You are correct. Just maybe a little confused or deranged.
The origin of this salute is the good ol’ USA. It’s called the Bellamy salute. Practiced in all U.S. classrooms by U.S. between 1878-1943 which is when congress abolished it and our students started using the hand over heart salute. Germany learned this salute from the U.S. because in the early 1900’s the U.S. was the eugenics capital of the world. America was ran by the Triple K’s society. Even Germany visited the U.S. before it wrote its Nuremberg laws. 28 U.S. states passed eugenics laws allowing for experimentation in its citizens. 600,000 women suffered (female genitalia mutilation) under these laws, and this includes W women who were not blonde haired and blue eyed. The leader of Germany at that time learned everything he implemented from this country. The Tuskegee experiment was also “legally” practiced under these American laws. Look it up.
How the heck could he *NOT KNOW*?!? That sort of salute, and giving the middle finger, are the *literally* two most notorious hand gestures in human history. If he flipped everybody off, would people say he was showing that every person was one finger of the hand of democracy?
@@mikehummel232name a single modern leader who did the same thing that wasn’t ripped out of context, kamala for example was pointing at a screen above her. bro is coping so hard 😂😂
It's constantly shown in Germany, but context matters. Is it for historical or news purposes, like here? Allowed. It's also allowed in an art context. Like, say, the Indiana Jones movies.
It's a shame that so many Democrats in other world leaders have done the same thing but he put his hand on his heart and he said at the same time my heart goes out to you and then gestures giving his heart out to the crowd watch the clip
Why hasn't Musk gone on CNN etc. and just say that this wasn't the meaning, he didn't think, is kinda dumb and is very sorry, because things like.this can't be accepted.
If you would watch the entire clip and listen to what he says he says my heart goes out to you and then puts his hand on his heart and gestures sending it out to everybody in the room or are you just that much of a hater?
Thanks DW, the bias in this "journalism" is insane. Taken completely out of context, with comparison photos at an angle to make them seem the same. Not only is it not a salute, it's someone trying to say their heart goes out to everyone. Shame on you DW.
The OG German salute is performed by tapping the left shoulder, followed by extending the right arm from the shoulder into the air with a straightened hand. The arm should be straight and pointed forward. Elons grabs his chest area and continues to deviate his arm to the right pretty dramatic and chaotic, without meaningful orchestration. There is no parallel between the German past and the current predicament in the US. The two situations involve very different historical, cultural, and political contexts. The scale and scope of Trump’s actions are fundamentally different from the extreme and violent nature of the German regime eighty years ago. Trump can certainly pose risks to democratic institutions, but these risks are very different from the explicit creation of an authoritarian regime bent on mass violence or genocide. Stop calling them fascist. What do you have to offer beyond your hollow and venomous resentment? How do you intend to sway the people who now have cast their votes for Trump cause to embrace a vision more aligned with _your_ preferences, while at the same time addressing their legitimate concerns in a manner that compels them to reconsider their allegiance, _despite_ them being a bunch of ****?? I bet you've never thought about that.
You're confusing fascism with N*zism. Trump and his followers do, regularly, espouse and enact literal fascism. There is absolutely overlap, but there are -many- fascists that aren't N*zi sympathizers
Specific way of salute is banned in Germany, and that's fine with Westerners, but banning semi naked women in Iran is a problem for Westerners. So, is Elon Musk this gesture to say "do not oppress people"?? 😂😅😂
Banning the salute of a regime that killed 6 million people in a mass genocide is something leftists do but having problems with a regime banning what clothes women can wear is? Those people are crazy!
It does look alot like a salute, I've been a elon fan for decades and wished he didn't do that, also he tends to think differently so time will reveal what his intentionl are, i curtain hope it's for the good of not only humans, but for us earth and beyond.
Look in his face and you know that it was deliberate.
Sure
The eyes chico
Twice....he did it twice
If you watch the whole clip he says my heart goes out to you and he does it by touching his heart and then gesturing my heart goes out to you.
Wow I guess hate mongers like you only have hate in your life don't you?
@@mikehummel232it must suck knowing there’s people like me who debunk your coping mechanism 😂😂
@@guywithyellowhat you actually believe your drivel
@@hotdog9262they all have delusion thinking the powers that be are destroying them. When it’s themselves
@@mikehummel232does the same in your job we see what happens 😂
If it looks like a duck, swims like a duck, and quacks like a duck, then it probably is a duck.
Correct
he is "throwing" his heart out to the audience. Dont conuse your WANTING to hate someone with them being a bad person.
You’re absolutely correct. In no way does this look like a duck, sounds like a duck, or swims like a duck. In NO WAY is it Nazism. You are correct. Just maybe a little confused or deranged.
Bingo.
@@YoubyMcRUclipsrFace
straight arm ✅
flat palm✅
above head✅
thumb bent inwards ✅
thats a certifiable... "german" salute.
You don't need to know the full history of the salute to know what it signifies, who it is associated with and why it's controversial.
The origin of this salute is the good ol’ USA. It’s called the Bellamy salute. Practiced in all U.S. classrooms by U.S. between 1878-1943 which is when congress abolished it and our students started using the hand over heart salute. Germany learned this salute from the U.S. because in the early 1900’s the U.S. was the eugenics capital of the world. America was ran by the Triple K’s society. Even Germany visited the U.S. before it wrote its Nuremberg laws. 28 U.S. states passed eugenics laws allowing for experimentation in its citizens. 600,000 women suffered (female genitalia mutilation) under these laws, and this includes W women who were not blonde haired and blue eyed. The leader of Germany at that time learned everything he implemented from this country. The Tuskegee experiment was also “legally” practiced under these American laws. Look it up.
He did it twice.
So what? He's a private African man. He can do what he wants.
How the heck could he *NOT KNOW*?!? That sort of salute, and giving the middle finger, are the *literally* two most notorious hand gestures in human history.
If he flipped everybody off, would people say he was showing that every person was one finger of the hand of democracy?
Just like so many Democrats and so many other world leaders that do that same thing you don't say a word do you.
@@mikehummel232name a single modern leader who did the same thing that wasn’t ripped out of context, kamala for example was pointing at a screen above her.
bro is coping so hard 😂😂
Good point.
He sure knew for sure
It’s just gaslighting. They know he knows what he did. Who you gonna believe, them or your own lyin’ eyes?
If it looks like a goose, smells like a goose, sounds like a goose, and steps like a goose… it’s probably a goose! 🤮
He’s not that based
Talking about yourself there are you?
@ not very bright, I guess, if that’s all you can respond with… are you 5yo? 🤔
People when a person raises their right arm: CONTROVERSIAL
He did it twice for clarification
“A GESTURE” ?????? If this was a strange hand gesture then Luigi was an Italian goodbye
ELQN 1S NAZ1
Elon is Nasty
He learns German.
😂😂😂 🚮
It is not normal to create brain chips
straight arm ✅
flat palm✅
above head✅
thumb bent inwards ✅
thats a certifiable... "german" salute.
Sideways?
Arm at an rotated angle
You can't be real
Yet pro Israel, so either way it doesn’t count.
@@Skystriker24 we like to call that cognitive dissonance and it does count, this is not a bingo card where one option does not matter.
Yeah, he’s a genius’ what a doofus
he was trying to gesture that hes throwing his heart out to syow love to the croud
the US used it during the 1940s for the pledge for a little while
i say bs to this, people just want to see what the want to see.
Yeah like how he told Germany to stop being guilty and stop practicing multi cultural ism that dilutes everything
I thought you can't show this in Germany, isn't it illegal?
Yes, it's forbidden.
Sure you can 'show' it. It's not forbidden to talk about. You just can't 'do' it. For a good reason...
Did you think it would get blurred or what?
We don't censor everything like the US but its forbidden to do the gesture.
It's constantly shown in Germany, but context matters. Is it for historical or news purposes, like here? Allowed. It's also allowed in an art context. Like, say, the Indiana Jones movies.
It's a shame that so many Democrats in other world leaders have done the same thing but he put his hand on his heart and he said at the same time my heart goes out to you and then gestures giving his heart out to the crowd watch the clip
All jokes aside I think everyone should prepare for the worst this was definitely a warning
Totally agree, this is getting out of hand and I think it's just the beginning.
Well, if it helps Canada's got plenty of room.
Lmao watch it be a slightly more right wing bill Clinton type presidency.
Chill out man.
Leftist fear mongering
yall are so dramatic 😂
Dr Strangelove
The salute Mussolini did was a bit different from the German one
So it was a roman gesture/greeting why did you word it like that, saying "it was never a common greeting" common or not that is its origin
Well also before the 1940's america also did it while singing the pledge of allegiance in school. It was called the bellamy salute.
get over your self's , just because you have a guilty conscious because of your past, that's your problem not ours.
I think New Zealand is looking mighty fine right about now
He is all business. Don't care about anything one. He went to Israel and supported their war.
They still do this salute in Mexico for Oath ceremony
This freaking guy!
We are so f'ing back 🗿
Might be why he turned to the side so it wouldn't look like that.
Oh if Biden did this…
Nah elon wilding 😭
True colors coming out now that he doesnt need to hide them because he is in power.
Americans forget that the pledge of allegiance started with a Romano salute.
This is a genuine question, not an insult: what is your point, sincerely?
He probably did it on purpose since he did it TWICE
Let's be real we all did the n a zi salute
so many bots in the comments
Wrong.
Sticks and stones will break your bones but hand gestures should never hurt you.
Normalize roman salute✋
Cookie Lyons did that first “To the Empire!” 😁
he is the richest man on the planet we should be happy he’s still wearing pants
My such a slanderous attitude
The level of ignorance 😂😂😂😂
This is heart
Persona non grata
Any read that book “Mars Project”?
For all the people offended by this, I just want to say my heart goes out to you. Thank you.
Elon Musk pledged allegiance to Germany. That's not good.
He openly supports germany's far right/nationalist party AfD and interviewed their leader... who's basically a female Ernst Röhm
@ why? was Ernst Röhm a lesbian?
Go over to Ukraine and you can see plenty.
In the West that is. East no so much anymore.
Oh u r ne normalizing it nw.
Why hasn't Musk gone on CNN etc. and just say that this wasn't the meaning, he didn't think, is kinda dumb and is very sorry, because things like.this can't be accepted.
Because he is not sorry😂
Yeah, why oh why would that be controversial in Germany? Edolf just showed his real face.
You would obviously know.
Once a crazy always a crazy.
Even if you support him, this was asinine. It’s like an homage to genocide.
If you would watch the entire clip and listen to what he says he says my heart goes out to you and then puts his hand on his heart and gestures sending it out to everybody in the room or are you just that much of a hater?
And then he goes to Germany and supports the naI party wake up sleepy
Oh my god I am so flabbergasted what
Now explain the swastika history😮
Do the research yourself. Or can you read ?
There are a lot of crazy people in the world!
Are you one of them ?
this guy has always been a tool
He knew
😂❤
to me it looks like all the old video people are holding hand forward while Elons hand is to the side?
Go look at pictures and you'll see some far wide ones.
AOC did it too. Musk called her out.
I used to defend him but that was OBVIOUS.
Then you obviously didn't watch the entire clip or even listen to it because it's obvious you're quite blind
He is clearly "throwing" his heart out to the audience.
Seriously, a moving side by side comparison instead of carefully chosen freeze frames show how different these motions were.
Now show pics of all the leftist American celebrities and politicians doing the exact same arm gesture like they showed on Gutfeld!
Have you ever in your life confirmed the accuracy of your sources? Gutfeld is notorious for blatant misinformation, objectively full out lies.
Thanks DW, the bias in this "journalism" is insane. Taken completely out of context, with comparison photos at an angle to make them seem the same. Not only is it not a salute, it's someone trying to say their heart goes out to everyone. Shame on you DW.
You know what’s worse? They’re funded by the German government.
Have you ever read 1984, by chance? Because your doublethink is showing.
@sineadfigiel5946 Thanks for the engagement! Yes I've read 1984. Hope you're having a great day.
@ psychological projection from you.
how about, you dont end with and question thats opens up other explanations then the obvious? why?
journalism needs to learn this lesson.
The OG German salute is performed by tapping the left shoulder, followed by extending the right arm from the shoulder into the air with a straightened hand. The arm should be straight and pointed forward.
Elons grabs his chest area and continues to deviate his arm to the right pretty dramatic and chaotic, without meaningful orchestration.
There is no parallel between the German past and the current predicament in the US. The two situations involve very different historical, cultural, and political contexts.
The scale and scope of Trump’s actions are fundamentally different from the extreme and violent nature of the German regime eighty years ago.
Trump can certainly pose risks to democratic institutions, but these risks are very different from the explicit creation of an authoritarian regime bent on mass violence or genocide.
Stop calling them fascist. What do you have to offer beyond your hollow and venomous resentment?
How do you intend to sway the people who now have cast their votes for Trump cause to embrace a vision more aligned with _your_ preferences, while at the same time addressing their legitimate concerns in a manner that compels them to reconsider their allegiance, _despite_ them being a bunch of ****??
I bet you've never thought about that.
You're confusing fascism with N*zism. Trump and his followers do, regularly, espouse and enact literal fascism. There is absolutely overlap, but there are -many- fascists that aren't N*zi sympathizers
Specific way of salute is banned in Germany, and that's fine with Westerners, but banning semi naked women in Iran is a problem for Westerners. So, is Elon Musk this gesture to say "do not oppress people"?? 😂😅😂
Banning the salute of a regime that killed 6 million people in a mass genocide is something leftists do but having problems with a regime banning what clothes women can wear is? Those people are crazy!
Elon did increase the viewership of every channel
It does look alot like a salute, I've been a elon fan for decades and wished he didn't do that, also he tends to think differently so time will reveal what his intentionl are, i curtain hope it's for the good of not only humans, but for us earth and beyond.
But how can you neglect to consider this action in the context of his hateful rhetoric and vocal support for the AfD?
And then by Musk in 2025....
Oh u r ne normalizing it nw.