Is The Upgrade From Blu-Ray To 4K Blu-Ray Worth It?

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 дек 2024

Комментарии • 78

  • @jaydoubleu3419
    @jaydoubleu3419 11 дней назад +3

    I will keep. My blu rays thank you

  • @Franksmediaandreviews
    @Franksmediaandreviews 4 месяца назад +19

    For me personally, I think the upgrade from bluray is 4k is worth the price as long as you have the equipment to experience the difference. Especially on the audio end, which you touched upon. That makes a huge difference between bluray and 4k.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  4 месяца назад +4

      thanks for sharing! The right equipment is definitely important!

    • @davidmckee2898
      @davidmckee2898 4 месяца назад

      @Franksmediaandreviews One is , i've got the oppo 203 Player. And All of the over equipment are awarded winning. So what you are Saying is if you haven't got The top equipment You won't see the difference🤔

    • @frommatorav1
      @frommatorav1 15 дней назад

      @@davidmckee2898 You need to have a high end TV that displays HDR well to see the full benefits of 4k video wise. Having a very good soundbar or an AVR capable of Dolby True HD, Atmos and DTS X, with good speakers also enhances the movie watching experience.
      You have a great 4k player but it has to be connected to good equip to get the most out of it. It doesn't have to be top end, but TVs with great HDR is very important.
      I have an OLED TV, and watching the 4k HDR movies now is a remarkable experience and movies I've seen many times feel new to me.
      My sound system is only 5.1 but I have an upgraded AVR that is 4k 120Hz capable with DolbyVision, Dolby Atmos and DTS X capabilities, too. My speakers are only pretty good and my subwoofer isn't the loudest but it sounds a lot better than TV speakers. I also would like to add 2 height speakers, and the receiver will handle that easily, since it has 9 channels.

  • @mycool8357
    @mycool8357 4 месяца назад +6

    I have recently upgraded and bought myself a 4K blu ray player I already love my home theatre which does not decode Atmos and play `dts hd and dolly true hd but I’m my opinion for a standard size living room is more than enough in fact the system volume goes up to 100 and for a amazing experience I have on volume 15! I get that Atmos is great but so is Dts and true hd. I don’t see the point in upgrading to a Atmos system when I’m happy with the 5.1 system I already have.
    I have collected more than 3,000 standard blu ray and often pick up 2nd hand movies for as little as £2 on eBay or charity shops as since streaming everyone is getting rid of there collections. I have recently bought a few 4K movies and don’t get me wrong they are very impressive and the HDR on the disks is definitely an upgrade, however I still think standard blu ray is amazing, I still often get blown away by how great standard blu rays look and sound.
    I have done many comparisons as most 4K blu rays include both standard and 4K blu ray and I know this will be controversial but I have concluded that without side by side comparison it’s really hard to say the 4K is much better, both look amazing to my eyes with some 4K movies looking a bit too dark and less vibrant. I have enjoyed the HDR on a few and would say yes that is probably a better experience and then I remember I payed £25 for that disk and could have bought the standard version for a few pounds! The upgrade to price ratio does not work for me. I bought the Christopher Nolan 4K set of all his best movies that I already own! I was told his 4K movies are an amazing upgrade on 4K and yes they look great in many instances. I then decided to watch Tenet on standard as I don’t own this on 4K and again I was blown away at how great it looked.
    In conclusion I will not upgrade any more of the movies I already own on blu ray as there really is no point they look amazing anyway. I will however by a few 4K movies from time to time that I don’t already have as a treat but I expect that 90 percent of my purchases going forward will be standard blu ray. I really love the format and how cheap I can pick up 2nd hand movies. Maybe in a few years 4K blu ray will also be cheap as I remember in 2007 standard blu rays cost the same as 4K movies are now but until then I will continue to love the 1080p hd version.

  • @georgeandreou695
    @georgeandreou695 4 месяца назад +8

    Yes they're expensive, but certain kinds of films look stunning in 4k and well worth the upgrade. I've upgraded to 4k for about 15 of my favourite films. Some of the best examples are Interstellar, Dunkirk, Blade Runner (the original), 2001 A Space Odyssey, The Prestige and The Shining. I agree you'll find lots of RUclipsrs raving about hundreds of 4k transfers, and it's commonly accepted that Jaws is one of the best. I personally don't see the point in watching that kind of film in 4k HDR, but certain films, particularly science fiction, can look fantastic. Not everyone will be bothered about image quality, and for the vast majority will be happy with blu rays, but for those who want to be blown away by the visuals I would say it's definitely worth it. Here in the UK you can pick up two for £30 at HMV, or buy used ones from CeX from between £6 and £12.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад

      Great points! Some movies are definitely better than others on 4K

    • @olliech33bo15
      @olliech33bo15 День назад

      I watched interstellar on 4k as a test. Didn't see any difference from the blue ray which looked amazing. If you have a good tv and player it will upscale anyway.

  • @shaolin95
    @shaolin95 4 месяца назад +6

    4k is great but the problem is a lot of people have subpar setups with small viewing angles so of course the resolution wont matter the

  • @benjaminphilp720
    @benjaminphilp720 4 месяца назад +2

    happy to jump from blu ray to 4k got a sony bravia 65 inch tv and i also have the jbl 9.1 home theatre sound bar and i have to say watching civil war on 4k took it tothe next level u can hear hellicopter flying above your head same with the plane it just like u were there with these people . best part it supported dolby atmos and dolby vision my 4 tv nearly 4 years now happy it doing i wont go back t blu ray or let alone dvd .

  • @caesar3311
    @caesar3311 4 месяца назад +6

    Only worth it for visually striking films; interstellar, alien, blade runner, Barry Lyndon (soon I hope) I’ve more often been underwhelmed than blown away. Rebel without a cause on BR was jaw dropping when I first saw it having had the DVD. The 4K ? Not so much

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад

      Those are some great examples of worthwhile 4K’s

  • @andrewattenboroughtwothumb4697
    @andrewattenboroughtwothumb4697 4 месяца назад +5

    Now that I own a 4K projector I think it’s worth the upgrade for most movies and recent releases in 4K

  • @earledward5763
    @earledward5763 4 месяца назад +1

    HDR stands for high dynamic range, so its primary advantage is greater shadow and highlight detail. The vibrancy of colors is at best a secondary advantage, which also varies from release to release.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад

      Yes. I think it makes a big difference on 4K releases

  • @Thundarr030
    @Thundarr030 4 месяца назад +1

    I love a lot of the cool collectors edition packaging that the boutique labels do for a lot of there 4k releases. Sometimes cool packaging is all it takes for me to upgrade or double dip on a movie

  • @calebsealey7361
    @calebsealey7361 4 месяца назад +1

    Thank you so much for the video I personally have not watched 4k yet. I am a Blu ray collector and actually got a 4k player for Christmas this past year just no 4k tv yet. I was wondering if the 4k discs were worth it and your video helped me learn more about it so thank you so much

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  4 месяца назад

      Thanks for sharing and I'm glad you found the video helpful. I always appreciate all of your kind comments.

  • @k-boxmotionpictures1337
    @k-boxmotionpictures1337 4 месяца назад +2

    If you select only the must haves like Lawrence of Arabia, original Blade Runner, 2001 A space… then 4K is good otherwise I prefer 4k streaming unless it’s of Dune or TG Maverick status where transfer is as good as the movie is. In recent years very few movies pushed me to get their 4k copies frankly speaking. I have 65” OLED & 5.1 sound so 4K streaming is equally fine.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад +1

      The only problem with streaming is the titles can be removed or edited anytime. Great examples though.

  • @slate49
    @slate49 5 месяцев назад +6

    I have a Sony Bravia tv and a Panasonic 4k player and WoW! Talk about a difference between the Blu and the 4k. In fact Panasonic’s upscale is insane-so blu’s look much closer to 4k than on other players. But I didnt see much difference until I purchased the Sony Bravia and Panasonic. On my previous tv LG and a Vizio, the pictures were fine on them but it wasn’t much for a theatrical experience at home. For 4k’s, you need the Tv and the right player to achieve that amazing picture. If a person doesn’t have the tv/player, then no need for the 4k disc.

    • @shmackatrotsky5394
      @shmackatrotsky5394 4 месяца назад

      I watch 4k blurays on a PS5 and a 5 year old TCL 55 inch tv (the 6 series, which was their flagship model). So, not the greatest setup, but I can definitely see a big difference bw reg blurays and 4k's. I will upgrade my setup at some point.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  4 месяца назад +1

      Thanks for sharing! The right tv does make a big difference!

    • @frommatorav1
      @frommatorav1 15 дней назад

      @@shmackatrotsky5394 A new TV will make a huge difference with HDR effects. I went from a Samsung 55" 4k LED TV from 2019 to a LG C1 65" OLED TV in 2022 and the difference was staggering. I mean the new TV is bigger and costs 4x as much but I don't regret paying the $1500 on that TV and I'm normally a frugal person.

  • @Onyxwatcher
    @Onyxwatcher 4 месяца назад +2

    Depends on the movie.

  • @Hicks-g1m
    @Hicks-g1m 4 месяца назад +2

    I can't tell the difference between 4k and blu-ray but I think it is worth it to upgrade whatever fits your taste

  • @LordDementus1987
    @LordDementus1987 Месяц назад

    No. The only difference I saw was in how bright the movie was because of HDR. I would question whether or not many older movies are actually 4K scans. The cost of going back and doing new scans from scratch is pretty expensive, plus redoing effects on top of that. Then the fact that most people will just stream rather than buy a disc. And the costs just don't justify it. Some big productions like Lawrence of Arabia obviously are native 4K scans. But that is a pretty big undertaking to do what they did, and expensive.
    Not only that, but top-of-the-line 1080p plasma TVs like Pioneer Kuro and Panasonic Viera, ended up still looking better than even the best OLED TVs. Sony and Panasonic are the only players left in the 4K Blu-ray player game and they can't seem to produce a player that works 100% reliably without skipping or freezing.

  • @simonfilmfan4899
    @simonfilmfan4899 4 месяца назад +5

    4K looks awful. They're too dark. Apparently that's the way they're supposed to look for authenticity. But I prefer brighter Blurays. They don't freeze up either.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад

      I think it really varies by release.

    • @frommatorav1
      @frommatorav1 15 дней назад

      There are a couple of movies and programs that were made too dark but most of the time the issue is with the HDR capability of the TV. Two years ago, I bought an OLED TV and the difference in picture quality, compared to my 3 year older 4k TV was night and day. Watching on the Samsung 55" 4k TV was night and the LG C1 OLED 65" TV was day. Everything was brighter and clearer and blacks were black instead of gray. Details in the shadows on the old TV were hazy and difficult too see but on the OLED were visible and clearer while still not being "bright".
      As far as freezing goes, the only disc I ever had a problem with, started working after cleaning it.

  • @JRCSalter
    @JRCSalter 4 месяца назад +3

    Upgrading for better quality isn't always a good decision. Most old television shows that were shot on video simply will not benefit from a 4K or even HD release. The amount of upscaling would just ruin the picture, and you're not going to see any more detail anyway. This is why I still buy DVDs. I've recently started buying some classic British comedies on DVD, and can see no benefit for Blu-ray. Though I am collecting the Doctor Who series on Blu-ray, despite the fact that it doesn't always benefit the picture unless they have the original film recordings; I just collect them because they are gorgeous sets, and it's my favourite show.
    As for 4K, I think very few properties really benefit from it. I feel this format is best suited for visually stunning media. I got the Mission: Impossible series on 4K, as well as Dune, and a smattering of other films. There's definitely a place for it, but I'm not going to replace my entire set with 4K; if I have a Blu-ray, I'm going to keep it, unless it's a special film to me.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад

      Do what works for you. Its great we have multiple formats to choose from. I personally always prefer bluray and 4K over dvd because larger tvs need higher resolution to look good in my opinion but modern bluray players can do well upscaling dvds also.

  • @WARNING-1gv7ej2j
    @WARNING-1gv7ej2j Месяц назад +1

    No 4k blu ray only Regular blu ray with 1080p is the superior one and if you bring a 4K blu. Ray discs, Near my beloved home, including, 4k tv both the 4k tv and 4k blurays discs will be one ticket on the streets by the side walk However if it a 1080p blu-ray discs and 1080p tv it gets to stay Full hd Is the supreme forever.

  • @RetroreviewsPlus
    @RetroreviewsPlus 15 дней назад

    Never had blue ray , i stopped at dvd, not into wasting money. I can still enjoy a 🎥 🍿 on vhs. Build up your 4k collection then they'll come out with another format that's better than 4K you going to keep on throwing money away? I only like retro movies anyway so if I shop for a movie it's at Goodwill and I'll pay $0.50 for a VHS for $1 for a DVD. Got more important things to spend money on

  • @EthanAnania
    @EthanAnania 10 дней назад

    I am sticking to regular Blu-rays because 4K is super expensive.

  • @DefKiller90
    @DefKiller90 2 месяца назад +1

    For me its not about the quality i watch movie's for the content and storyline even if the movie has vhs quality i still watch it

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  2 месяца назад

      Nothing wrong with that

    • @frommatorav1
      @frommatorav1 15 дней назад

      For me, the movie is the most important part but I've watched movies in 4k that felt like a new experience. A great movie with a great 4k transfer is the best.
      I understand not wanting to upgrade all the movies you own to 4k.
      My only advice would be to get the better format if it's available when buying today. If you don't have a movie in bluray or 4k and it's available with 4k with a bluray, that is what I would buy. I only buy my favorite movies in 4k, or on bluray if it's a really good price. I won't get rid of my DVDs but I won't get any more to add to the collection. I'll stream movies I've never seen before, rather than blind buy.

  • @ryanb2607
    @ryanb2607 Месяц назад

    I think you didn't touch on one of the most important points - this is the final format for the vast majority of films. Unless it was filmed in 70mm or 8K, which only a small minority of films have been, there's nowhere else to go as far as video quality is concerned. There will never be any kind of mainstream 8K player and format because of how few films would be eligible for it.
    Many films will never come out in 4K even. Blu-ray is the final format for a good number. So Blu-Ray and 4K will likely stand the test of time - that's the real reason an upgrade is worth it, to me.

    • @LordDementus1987
      @LordDementus1987 Месяц назад

      On top of that, they would need to go back and redo everything from scratch in that resolution which is expensive and time-consuming. Plus how many people are going to buy the movie again? It just isn't worth the cost and I think this is why many films have not come out in 4K yet, even just digitally.

  • @dalethomas3277
    @dalethomas3277 4 месяца назад

    That’s one shiny shirt

  • @daveac
    @daveac 3 месяца назад +1

    All good advice to my mind - but would mention that if a viewer has had a collection of Blu-Rays for a number years and only recently has bought their first 4K TV - they will 'see' their Blu-rays looking better on that TV - as the latest 4K TVs have very good upscaling. It may also explain the point you made about the 'jump in quality' from Blu-ray to Ultra Blu-ray may not seeming as big a jump as from DVD to Blu-ray. As, unlikely I know, but if you had an HD TV playing the Blu-ray and to the side had a second 4K TV playing the same movie - but on Ultra HD disc - the difference would (on a good transfer disc) look considerably better. Lastly - Ultra Blu-ray on a 4K TV can take being 'blown up' to to being viewed on larger TV 70in plus! So the Blu-ray owner may have been happy watching blu-ray on a 55in TV - but less so on their brand new 77in TV a few years later Cheers!

  • @ThreechTHEdruid
    @ThreechTHEdruid Месяц назад

    only worth if can get all out of it if not not worth it

  • @Souls4Roca
    @Souls4Roca 4 месяца назад +3

    watch your Blueray on a PC with an HDR screen and an nvidia RTX 3000 or newer card and enable nvidia trueHDR, GG you just got the same image quality without rebuying your disks, oh, you can also upscale on the fly

    • @Bombasticbabygirl
      @Bombasticbabygirl 4 месяца назад

      lol PC?

    • @giovannifitzgerald113
      @giovannifitzgerald113 4 месяца назад

      Do you still need an Intel cpu to run 4k blu ray disks? ...because it was blocked on amd cpus 🤔🕵

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад

      If you already have a pc gaming setup this could be a good option.

    • @Souls4Roca
      @Souls4Roca 3 месяца назад

      @@giovannifitzgerald113 intel right now is a fire hazard, also ryzen dominates the desktop and laptop market

    • @frommatorav1
      @frommatorav1 15 дней назад

      @@giovannifitzgerald113 You can watch 4k discs with AMD cpus, you just have to rip the disc first. Those Intel cpus that can natively play 4k blurays were short lived (only 8th and 9th gen I believe or 6th, 7th and 8th).
      Movie studios have made sure it's difficult to watch their movies on a PC or even on physical media in general.
      They made 4Ks unreadable with bluray drives, unless you revert the firmware to an older version. They don't want you to be able to watch on PC because they're trying to force everyone to streaming.
      They make DVD and Blurays region locked, which is anti-consumer.

  • @alexlanning712
    @alexlanning712 4 месяца назад +2

    4K helps "sell" the movie

  • @davidmckee2898
    @davidmckee2898 4 месяца назад +3

    Going from DVD to blu.Ray is a massive jump. From Blue ray to 4k Not so much. They say the picture is 4 times better Then hd No way Is it

    • @shaolin95
      @shaolin95 4 месяца назад

      😂😂😂 it is but if you have a small viewing angle then it won't matter

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  3 месяца назад +1

      Ya it doesn’t seem as drastic but it largely depends on your home theatre set up

  • @Scifi4life
    @Scifi4life 4 месяца назад +3

    I prefer standard blu ray.

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  4 месяца назад +3

      Thanks for sharing!

    • @2observe2comment
      @2observe2comment 4 месяца назад +1

      ​@@HomeVideoHangoutsYeah, PC. You know, those things that used to be used to actually get things done as opposed to a myriad of media consumption devices we were told are all we need. A decent-sized monitor and a PC processing muscle can really make for a great viewing experience.

  • @garyharper2943
    @garyharper2943 3 месяца назад

    Mostly, kept the Blu-ray of Aliens.

  • @jjphoenix4055
    @jjphoenix4055 3 месяца назад +1

    Nah, totally the opposite. HDR, HDR+10 and Dolby Vision are CRAP and look like CRAP unless you have a half million dollars home theater system. Blu ray is MUCH better and sturdy as a format than all the 4Ks in the world. Streaming 4K is even worst!

    • @LordDementus1987
      @LordDementus1987 Месяц назад

      At least to me, the colors look really washed out with 4KBD. I have some 4K streams in Vudu and I think they look much better. People keep calling my TV crap but my eyes don't lie. I don't really care for modern LED TVs either. I always thought plasmas looked better, even though they are not as bright and only full HD.

  • @djvalentin
    @djvalentin 5 месяцев назад +1

    First !!🎉

  • @wurmhat1501
    @wurmhat1501 5 месяцев назад +5

    4k is a joke. The players barely work and the cost is absurd. Most movies will never make even make it to the format. I can also get a blu ray player for $15. Just curious though, is there a blu rsy player that is considered the best thst you know of?

    • @jefffan171
      @jefffan171 5 месяцев назад +2

      OPPO BDP 105D used is one of if not the best Blu Ray player ever made

    • @SealedOrPorted
      @SealedOrPorted 4 месяца назад

      @@jefffan171 I concur

    • @HomeVideoHangouts
      @HomeVideoHangouts  4 месяца назад +4

      I have had a decent experience with Panasonic UB820 but i had to return it a couple times before getting a good one. I really enjoy the 4K releases for some movies but for some movies I don't see a need to upgrade from Blu-Ray or even dvd.

    • @shaolin95
      @shaolin95 4 месяца назад

      😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @simonfilmfan4899
      @simonfilmfan4899 4 месяца назад

      @@jefffan171 I have a Cambridge 650 it''s awesome. Upscales DVDs great as well.