@@GarageStudio7 Mariah's whistles have a lot of texture, she is versatile. She can do it with strength and have it in an airy tone... here Mariah totally went for strength :))
@@francis3774 Very true, she's one of the very few vocalists who can manipulate numerous textures in that register. Plus she does that throughout her whole voice as well!
Jackie Maldonado I swear people try to compliment Ariana anytime they get a chance whistle notes isn’t supposed to be low Ariana even said she Doesn’t like her own whistle notes .
@@thetruth.7858 “whistle notes aren’t supposed to be low”. who told u that lmao -.- if it’s a harmony it can be low or high depending on the singers preferences / arrangement. and obv ari chose to do the lower whistle harmony here
@@India.R120 well a lot of people did for some reason? To me it was kinda obvious that it wasn’t gonna be the same ( cause that’s how harmonizing works but also because it would probably take a while for both of them to hit each note just as the other one did I know the track was pre recorded but still it would take a while ) , but then people started comparing the whistle notes so I’m confused ?
Lol Mariah only did this because Ariana fans basically pressured her too. She doesn’t like Ariana and just did this so people could stop saying they have beef. But at the end of the day I can see through it. Ariana and her fans bullied her way to be in a Mariah Carey song because secretly Ariana wants to be Mariah Carey so bad but she will never be.
Some Ari Stan’s saying “it’s harder to go lower then higher” which is a valid statement but if the context you put it in is that ari is more talented in whistle register your sadly mistaken
WOW!!!! Props to Ariana for taking the lower whistle harmony because it is extremely hard to whistle the lower you go!!! Whistling in the 5th octave is very difficult, but Ariana's 5th octave whistles were phenomenal!!! Both Mariah and Ariana were BEYOND INCREDIBLE
Lol Mariah only did this because Ariana fans basically pressured her too. She doesn’t like Ariana and just did this so people could stop saying they have beef. But at the end of the day I can see through it. Ariana and her fans bullied her way to be in a Mariah Carey song because secretly Ariana wants to be Mariah Carey so bad but she will never be.
@@DA24681 you don't know mariah, dude. You don't know how she think, you don't know what she think about ari, you don't KNOW HER so STOP talking like if you know what exactly mariah think. Thank u and don't be toxic pls.
@@ryane70 I meant we know ariana purposefully did the lower harmony- well, cause we're aware that it's supposed to be like that cause it's a harmony lol
@@ryane70 Babe, imagine being capable of notes around 6th Octave with such a soft tone and you call that HEAD VOICE? The notes are disconnected what are you talking about?
Wouldn't be amazing if we get to see a recording session of them including Jhud and doing those whistle. like Mariah-Ari convo while practicing the harmony. Hopefully Mariah will release some of it.
Yep it’s a tripple whistle / head note for the word “Santa” Mariah did both the higher harmony whistle for the word “Santa” as well as the middle main lead whistle, which was already the arrangement of the whistle harmony in the original song. In this new version, Ariana contributed by doing a lower harmony. If you isolate and seperate the three layers of vocals you can clearly and distinctively hear who’s doing what. Low head harmony done by Ariana Grande: G♯5, B♭5, C♯6 Middle main lead whistle done by Mariah Carey: C♯6, E♭6, F6 High whistle harmony also done by Mariah Carey: F6, F♯6, G♯6
Ariana's not using her head voice, she's rlly bringing her whistle register down which is pretty impressive. Also if u had trained musical ears you'd recognize the Last high harmony for the santa being ari's
aris notes r definitely high enough to be whistle register. also why do u have three notes for mariahs upper harmony if the only note she harmonized with was the last note on “ta” in the word “santa”? genuine question btw
I learned how to whistle from listening to Mariah . Your natural instincts is to whistle higher but to lower it is very hard. Mariah has done it very few times because it’s better to do the high whistle. I think she did it ending the climax of can’t let go live with MTV unplugged and another time. Overall, I’m glad they shared this moment together.
we all know that mariah is very much capable of hitting the highest of whistles, she even effortlessly hit an F#8! (video w/ a dolphin). I kind of wish Ariana hit the G#6 in reality because if Mariah allows that, that would be cool.
@@axelito6342 No it was an f#8 I checked with this app on my phone, also that video was adorable the dolphin was so surprised she could communicate with them lol.
it's so cool how ariana did the lower melody, because the lower the whistle note, the harder it is to get! you'd think that mariah would do the lower one because she's more experienced, but then when you think about it, this is a remix, so it makes sense why she did her original 2010 melody!!
Oh and for those who didn’t know the G#6 harmony was also in the original song back in 2010 but it was way behind in the layer ! Mariah here have done it again but put it more in the front . The harmony is a 4 layer-harmony! At the end Mariah is doing F6 and Ari C#6 like showcased here but each of them add a 2nd layer : Mariah G#6 and Ari F6 ! They are so talented wow
Mariah's whistles were sweet, peircing, airy and buttery while at the same time it sounds powerful, heavy and full. And Ariana shook me with that F5 whistle thats tooooo low.
Amazing, the talent, the teamwork, the love. No one outshined the other. Its more powerful than the best performer alone. Such magic.... proof that theres always room if you scoot over and share
@@1lambily419 it is rare and you must be very good! The whistle register isn’t even considered starting at A5 so you must be incredibly talented! Well done
Both ladies did well Ari did a great job for literally bringing whistles to the headvoice range area If you understand, going down is much harder than being up there when it comes to whistle notes And ofcourse Mariah's classic whistles
@@limpisisa.1664 whistle doesn’t start at a particular note, it’s just a specific register ! Male can go even in the upper 4th octaves in whistle register!
@@axelito6342 that is not true about the males. You may be able to make a whistle around E5 depending on the vowel you use. And even with that it's a falsetto not a whistle. Whistling has a particular sound. It's like saying that one can make a falsetto sound in the 2nd octave(around E2), which you can't. Vocal registers have their ranges. If you go above or below them, the sound you make changes.
To the arianators saying Ariana did the higher part, its a Mariah's song ffs, yall really think she'd let Ariana steal the spotlight on her OWN song? Mariah and her are on good terms but it's still Mariah's song, doesn't matter how close they are nowadays.
why y'all acting like y'all don't know, it's obvious even in the music video, the camera shows Ari face on that G#6, do u think they didn't do it on purpose?
@@rein2430 actually the G#6 actually sounds lighter in weight than Mariah's other whistles whereas it sounds like Ariana and is lighter like all her other whistles in and out of this song
@@rein2430 Do you know what Mariah's whistles even sound like? Don't comment if you don't know lol. Mariah's whistles are much thicker than what was heard from the top note. It was clearly Ariana and some people just can't accept it (most of these people being lambs who think Mariah always does the top notes).
Props to Mariah, she hit the Eb6 to F6 really making it sound like a G#6. I played it on my piano, and its so close to a G#6 but she does hit a F6 with super airy whistle giving it that G#6 effect.
@@tobiasbach9504 Then you'd know Mariah took the higher harmony, I mean the thickness of those whistles do not sound like Ariana's AT ALL. But I do think she did hit the G#6
You’re right the camera should only focus on Mariah because it’s Mariah’s song....the camera angle means nothing. Are you her vocal cords? Ari moves her jaw a lot Mariah doesn’t doesn’t mean she had the higher note.
@@User23553 I think the one who scored G # 6 was Ariana because Mariah’s wistles are different from hers, but Mariah’s also made G # 6 just as harmonized, as if it were a backvocal
Been waiting for you to isolate the Whistles... Lambs do know its Mimi who did the upper whistles.. Love them both. I'm missing the prolonged whistles towards the end of the original tract cuz they didn't include it.
@@chipmunkaraoke to materialize that we the LAMBS got to do something.. Make #OhSantaNumber1 . I remember her Disney performance of that encore whistle so heavenly..
@@swizzwizz12 who said anything about the 90's mariah. We all know no one could top that. We are talking about the recent mariah and recent ariana. The topic was who did the high note.
@@swizzwizz12 What did that have to do with anything? Your comment was so irrelevant here. What they said was that the last high whistle sounds like Ari. How is your comment relevant here?
I'm pretty sure many people in the comment section don't even know there was an original version over 10 years ago, where Mariah was doing every high and low note, having a pretty long riff at whistle register and whistling down to the 4th octave on that run. and btw, when not whistling, Mariah can easily hit down to C3 and even the 2nd octave. people here are just saying as if Mariah was having trouble with the lower notes and Ari handled it, are yall aware of the range of Mariah?
I saw a video of the whistles on a loop for a minute earlier today and was like “I really wanna know who took which (higher/lower) harmony, and then this popped up lol
These arianators in the comments section have me in tears 😂 "The LOwEr haRmOnY is MorE dFFicuLt", well somebody has to take the lower harmony, so ariana took it, its not a conpetition, Mariah did the F6 and G#6 and ariana did the C#6, end of story
Props to Ariana for taking the lowest harmony because it is VERY hard to whistle the lower you go ! Both were ABOVE INCREDIBLE
It’s not hard, can you whistle ? Like in whistle register, I can, and I can go high and low too, but yeah it would be hard for those who are new
@@Justarttingz no like a low tone
@@yerrzy572 ik
@@Justarttingz it's hard in low whistle
I can't even sing whistles in 5th octave
Early!!! They slayed! First time Mariah harmonized whistles with someone in her career
She already did that with Paty Labelle
@@elenaleon749 i believe queen Patti was not in the same register
@@elenaleon749 Patty was belting G#5
@@ericklavrador5015 and Ariana is using head voice.
@@elenaleon749 I believe so.
So cool that you extracted their whistle notes.
It seems like they switched harmony parts in the end and Ariana sang the G#6.
It can be. Mariah's whistle notes are usually thicker than that.
@@ThiHills Exactly! Mariah's whistle notes are airy and ethereal but for some reason, still sound more powerful.
Sometimes it can be polyphonic
@@GarageStudio7 Mariah's whistles have a lot of texture, she is versatile. She can do it with strength and have it in an airy tone... here Mariah totally went for strength :))
@@francis3774 Very true, she's one of the very few vocalists who can manipulate numerous textures in that register. Plus she does that throughout her whole voice as well!
Actually the lower whistle is harder to do than the higher one
IT IS to have a whistle timbre in head voice ranges are so difficult!
@@pepsiriah1651 exactly because the vocal cords wanna go back in that head voice position so badly it takes immense control
I’m not sure about that lol they both did great, let’s leave it there.
Not for these two! Ariana is great at the lower ones and Mariah's current voice can sustain anything from A5-C7
Dark Soul yes!!!
it's refreshing to hear a 'low whistle' to be honest. lol
yeah sounds nice
How is it refreshing 💀
No
Jackie Maldonado I swear people try to compliment Ariana anytime they get a chance whistle notes isn’t supposed to be low Ariana even said she Doesn’t like her own whistle notes .
@@thetruth.7858 “whistle notes aren’t supposed to be low”. who told u that lmao -.- if it’s a harmony it can be low or high depending on the singers preferences / arrangement. and obv ari chose to do the lower whistle harmony here
Y'all do realize Mariah and Ariana whistles are different ON PURPOSE to make this harmony, right?
LMAO fr
I thought that was obvious-
That's how harmonizing work
Yes, that’s literally how harmonizing works…? I don’t think anyone thought this was an accident?
@@India.R120 well a lot of people did for some reason? To me it was kinda obvious that it wasn’t gonna be the same ( cause that’s how harmonizing works but also because it would probably take a while for both of them to hit each note just as the other one did I know the track was pre recorded but still it would take a while ) , but then people started comparing the whistle notes so I’m confused ?
They really made the world go wild with that harmonized whistle.
Everybody went crazy over that part! Why? Because we got what we wanted!
Mother Daughter creating a masterpiece 💕
Yes
Lol Mariah only did this because Ariana fans basically pressured her too. She doesn’t like Ariana and just did this so people could stop saying they have beef. But at the end of the day I can see through it. Ariana and her fans bullied her way to be in a Mariah Carey song because secretly Ariana wants to be Mariah Carey so bad but she will never be.
@@DA24681 ignorant
@@michaelsliders3421 not at all just can see through the bullsht but nice try
@@DA24681 Do you have proof of this? Maybe a link or a video or an article?
mariah and ari are both amazing in their whistle register why is there a war in the comments
Fr
Even after they collaborated, they still compare them. They whistled together so that these people will stop.
Because some people are toxic fans/stand
Some Ari Stan’s saying “it’s harder to go lower then higher” which is a valid statement but if the context you put it in is that ari is more talented in whistle register your sadly mistaken
Why is no one thanking the creator? This is the best filtered audio I’ve heard, nice job!
WOW!!!! Props to Ariana for taking the lower whistle harmony because it is extremely hard to whistle the lower you go!!! Whistling in the 5th octave is very difficult, but Ariana's 5th octave whistles were phenomenal!!! Both Mariah and Ariana were BEYOND INCREDIBLE
lmao not the comments trying to compare who’s better
like chill...ofc they’re not gonna do it exactly the same. 💀
It’s literally not how a harmony works. Harmony works by ppl taking a higher and lower register between them.
Lol Mariah only did this because Ariana fans basically pressured her too. She doesn’t like Ariana and just did this so people could stop saying they have beef. But at the end of the day I can see through it. Ariana and her fans bullied her way to be in a Mariah Carey song because secretly Ariana wants to be Mariah Carey so bad but she will never be.
@@DA24681 this is an incredibly immature and stupid comment.
@@gwynethchloe no its not I see through the bllsht
@@DA24681 you don't know mariah, dude. You don't know how she think, you don't know what she think about ari, you don't KNOW HER so STOP talking like if you know what exactly mariah think. Thank u and don't be toxic pls.
before lambs run they mouth: ariana purposefully did lower whistle notes, cuz its a harmony. duh
I’m a lamb and i love ari! Of course they had to do it in this way to harmonize! And both were great!
And it just suits their voices honestly. Ariana has such a sultry RnB type voice, where Mariah leans more gospel. It would feel wrong any other way 😂
I think we're all aware that it's supposed to be a harmony
@@ryane70 I meant we know ariana purposefully did the lower harmony- well, cause we're aware that it's supposed to be like that cause it's a harmony lol
@@ryane70 Babe, imagine being capable of notes around 6th Octave with such a soft tone and you call that HEAD VOICE? The notes are disconnected what are you talking about?
You remain the undisputed queen of perfectly separating notes in songs 😭🙌❤️
Wouldn't be amazing if we get to see a recording session of them including Jhud and doing those whistle. like Mariah-Ari convo while practicing the harmony. Hopefully Mariah will release some of it.
love jhud but arixmariah and mariahxari fans have been WAITING for this and it FINALLY came true.
Yep it’s a tripple whistle / head note for the word “Santa”
Mariah did both the higher harmony whistle for the word “Santa” as well as the middle main lead whistle, which was already the arrangement of the whistle harmony in the original song. In this new version, Ariana contributed by doing a lower harmony.
If you isolate and seperate the three layers of vocals you can clearly and distinctively hear who’s doing what.
Low head harmony done by Ariana Grande: G♯5, B♭5, C♯6
Middle main lead whistle done by Mariah Carey: C♯6, E♭6, F6
High whistle harmony also done by Mariah Carey: F6, F♯6, G♯6
That feeling you get when someone articulates your opinion better than you is better than sex…
Ariana's not using her head voice, she's rlly bringing her whistle register down which is pretty impressive. Also if u had trained musical ears you'd recognize the Last high harmony for the santa being ari's
aris notes r definitely high enough to be whistle register. also why do u have three notes for mariahs upper harmony if the only note she harmonized with was the last note on “ta” in the word “santa”? genuine question btw
I learned how to whistle from listening to Mariah . Your natural instincts is to whistle higher but to lower it is very hard. Mariah has done it very few times because it’s better to do the high whistle. I think she did it ending the climax of can’t let go live with MTV unplugged and another time. Overall, I’m glad they shared this moment together.
I'm pretty sure Ariana took the higher harmony at "Santa" but this was nicely done! Props to Ariana for whistling down to an F5
She whistled down to a b5
@@risingstar9998 F5 as well
@@risingstar9998 tf no😂
@@risingstar9998 do u mean an A5 flat? hahah
@@lukas7307 shut up and leave me alone
Just listen to the original version you'll know that Mariah did the higher one.. btw I've been waiting for you to this vid and thank
we all know that mariah is very much capable of hitting the highest of whistles, she even effortlessly hit an F#8! (video w/ a dolphin). I kind of wish Ariana hit the G#6 in reality because if Mariah allows that, that would be cool.
@@chipmunkaraoke the video with the dolphin was a F#7 not a F#8 lmao !
@@axelito6342 queen mariah didn’t know what note she was hitting pls
Yea and Ari did low tune which is harder
@@axelito6342 No it was an f#8 I checked with this app on my phone, also that video was adorable the dolphin was so surprised she could communicate with them lol.
it's so cool how ariana did the lower melody, because the lower the whistle note, the harder it is to get! you'd think that mariah would do the lower one because she's more experienced, but then when you think about it, this is a remix, so it makes sense why she did her original 2010 melody!!
i feel like Ariana’s harmony was an octave higher than she sang it, BUT STILL AMAZING
how tf did she sing a c#7 when she can't even hit a decent b6? the delusion
@@pambinobequeno5062she literally hit e7 what r you on
talented, brilliant, incredible, amazing, show stopping, spectacular, never the same, totally unique, completely not ever been done before
But Beyonce has one of the best of all time 🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴🥴
I don't think people get the concept of harmonies based on the comments lmao
Oh and for those who didn’t know the G#6 harmony was also in the original song back in 2010 but it was way behind in the layer ! Mariah here have done it again but put it more in the front . The harmony is a 4 layer-harmony! At the end Mariah is doing F6 and Ari C#6 like showcased here but each of them add a 2nd layer : Mariah G#6 and Ari F6 ! They are so talented wow
Mariah's whistles were sweet, peircing, airy and buttery while at the same time it sounds powerful, heavy and full. And Ariana shook me with that F5 whistle thats tooooo low.
This channel always comes out with quality contents and i'm loving it
Ariana Grande + Mariah Carey =
Perfect harmonization like angels
I’m more concerned about the lack of support on streaming where are all the fans man?!?!?!
Amazing, the talent, the teamwork, the love. No one outshined the other. Its more powerful than the best performer alone. Such magic.... proof that theres always room if you scoot over and share
I can’t believe that you can do that!😱😱
The edit of the notes!!
How can you separate that??!😱😱
Its unbelievably amazing!!😱😱
That lower whistle was actually bordering a whistle and head voice.
Quite true! Whistles usually don’t go below D6 so singers who can do whistles C6 and below are very talented
Ariana has a beautiful head voice and seems to have a lot of ease with it. I believe it.
@@binnarae2950 It's actually not rare to whsitle a little lower than C6
While doing whistle warm-ups, I usually whistle around A5 - B♭5
@@1lambily419 it is rare and you must be very good! The whistle register isn’t even considered starting at A5 so you must be incredibly talented! Well done
All this time I thought Ari was doing the higher whistle 🤦🏻♂️😔
i think the G#6 is still Ari
she does the higher part when they say santa
ARI DOES IT
Yea that’s Mariah.
@@sanai6723 that’s Mariah
Both ladies did well
Ari did a great job for literally bringing whistles to the headvoice range area
If you understand, going down is much harder than being up there when it comes to whistle notes
And ofcourse Mariah's classic whistles
thanks for extracting the whistles! you’re the best
It’s honestly beautiful that they came together . Sis got to sing w/ her idol 😏✨
Lol it sounds so different when they're isolated! But when you put them together it's like an echoing vibration 🤣
purr mariah eating up the higher harmony
Okay, but it’s pretty cool how the last two notes from Mariah are polyphonic, and she’s actually whistling two notes at once!
Actually the g#6 was Ariana
@@multiversetriology its not lol the g#6 is from the original version of the song its mariah singing it
I was waiting for you to do this 😍
Ariana took the higher whistle at the end and did a G#6
That was Mariah ( the G#6 was also present in the original song in 2010 and the tone doesn’t sound at all like Ariana’s)
Im just shocked that Ariana did the lower whistle of which I thought vice versa hahha and as I listened to this extracted video, I still cant believe
Thank you for creating this! So cool.
ill be waiting for another collab😌💅🏽
The question is how is Ari whistling in the fifth octave?
lots of focus and coordination
Due to the vowel she is using and pure whistling starts from I think G5 or A5. Plus it's basically a high falsetto
@@limpisisa.1664 whistle doesn’t start at a particular note, it’s just a specific register ! Male can go even in the upper 4th octaves in whistle register!
@@axelito6342 that is not true about the males. You may be able to make a whistle around E5 depending on the vowel you use. And even with that it's a falsetto not a whistle. Whistling has a particular sound.
It's like saying that one can make a falsetto sound in the 2nd octave(around E2), which you can't. Vocal registers have their ranges. If you go above or below them, the sound you make changes.
@@limpisisa.1664 false, whistle don't start at a certain range. mariah has unintentionally whistled a D5 before.
To the arianators saying Ariana did the higher part, its a Mariah's song ffs, yall really think she'd let Ariana steal the spotlight on her OWN song? Mariah and her are on good terms but it's still Mariah's song, doesn't matter how close they are nowadays.
it literally was ariana tho. you can literally hear it and see how different it is from mariah as first whistle.
why y'all acting like y'all don't know, it's obvious even in the music video, the camera shows Ari face on that G#6, do u think they didn't do it on purpose?
The camera angle doesnt mean anything
Ur crazy lmao....
The whistle even sounds like Mariah dummy
@@rein2430 actually the G#6 actually sounds lighter in weight than Mariah's other whistles whereas it sounds like Ariana and is lighter like all her other whistles in and out of this song
@@rein2430 Do you know what Mariah's whistles even sound like? Don't comment if you don't know lol. Mariah's whistles are much thicker than what was heard from the top note. It was clearly Ariana and some people just can't accept it (most of these people being lambs who think Mariah always does the top notes).
Props to Mariah, she hit the Eb6 to F6 really making it sound like a G#6. I played it on my piano, and its so close to a G#6 but she does hit a F6 with super airy whistle giving it that G#6 effect.
Mariah slay queen goddess! Love you too Ari princess!
She did not just hit eb5 with whistle ur kidding? She’s a real vocal beast
She did! 😌
Who? Both of them didn't do any Eb5s whistles in here
Extremely clean 👏👏
Beautiful
Mariah Carey: 0:04
Ariana Grande: 0:15
BOTH: 0:25
Its a 35 second vid lmao, we can watch the whole thing
When two legends combine
But people still pit them against each other
IT so beatiful!!
Great breakdown! Thank you
“ITs ActUaLly HArdEr tO WHisTle iN LoWEr” Literally no one is taking credit away from Ari, y’all are delusional.
Who said anyone was we telling straight facts try it😭💀
@@everythingFLO__ its easy for me lmao
Lol that's falsetto not a whistle then
@@hisashiburimobilelegends9502 you can whistle in falsetto, but eh idrc which wa sharder or not both were great
\
@@Mercinater whistle is not falsetto.. but they're both amazing 😁
Plot twist: Ariana is actually singing the higher part and Mariah the lower one...
how do you know
@@mervebeste6021 Absolute pitch.
@@tobiasbach9504 Tf that has got to do w anything lol? just say you're an arianator and go
@@alt3170 Not only! I'm also a fan of Mariah's. Which makes it very clear who sings what
@@tobiasbach9504 Then you'd know Mariah took the higher harmony, I mean the thickness of those whistles do not sound like Ariana's AT ALL.
But I do think she did hit the G#6
Thanks, this is useful! 🥰
Meanwhile Jennifer Hudson: 💃💃
Best comment
That high "santa note was Ariana's. It sounds completely different from Mariah's.
True
Fr tho,last whistle was ariana's whistle part not Mariah
It really wasnt 😂 mariah can control her whistle to make it sound balanced, it was hers
@@jonathan_8100 i have heard bunch of Mariah's and Ariana's whistle,i can detect their whistle notes well...wht did he say is right
@@anpanmlbb the person who made the vid said it was mariah who did the F6 and G#6 and ariana did the C#6, idk what your talking abt
Mariah:
0:04 -> 0:12
Ariana:
0:15 -> 0:23
Both:
0:25
Thank me later
FINALLY!! . . . THANKS!
Good thing u hav this video so that I could harmonize this with my cousin
Ariana hit G#6 at the "SANTA" part...
Okay but why on G # 6 in "Santa" did the camera focus on the Ariana and she made an expression of how she was making a super high note? 🤔
Ariana might have actually sang the higher harmony on the “Santa”
lol this is funny
You’re right the camera should only focus on Mariah because it’s Mariah’s song....the camera angle means nothing. Are you her vocal cords? Ari moves her jaw a lot Mariah doesn’t doesn’t mean she had the higher note.
@@User23553 I think the one who scored G # 6 was Ariana because Mariah’s wistles are different from hers, but Mariah’s also made G # 6 just as harmonized, as if it were a backvocal
yep that g#6 was sung by ari
They’re both awesome
Wow bravo to ariana for the lower harmony that is HARD
yall enooooough !!!! Mariah Carey have 5 - 6 - 7 + octave vocal rage !!!! LoL plz dont fight over this !! haha
Mariah is a 5 and Ari is a 4 nothing huge
@@millsypooh thats pretty huge
Oh Mariah ❤️
The mosquito in my room at 3AM:
That's officially it. They've won singing, nothing can beat this.
Been waiting for you to isolate the Whistles... Lambs do know its Mimi who did the upper whistles.. Love them both. I'm missing the prolonged whistles towards the end of the original tract cuz they didn't include it.
I actually thought the repetitive whistle that fades at the end in the original was kinda annoying.
@@Number-ek1hf errr.. sorry to hear that but I LOVE IT!
i wish mariah will do that original ending/encore whistle when she performs it live w/ ari and jhud.
@@chipmunkaraoke to materialize that we the LAMBS got to do something.. Make #OhSantaNumber1 . I remember her Disney performance of that encore whistle so heavenly..
sis actually ari hit the G#6
Yasssss harmonize
Only queen is the miss Mariah Carey ❤❤❤
In the original song Mariah sings both whistle in the “santa” word (polyphonic or harmonized). So maybe it’s from Mariah again.
Hahahaha
aham
Yup
hhhaaaa real funny
so are u trying to say Ariana didn’t sing it 🤣
They both make me so happy! I love them both! My singing heroes 😍
Same🥰 two queens!👑
I tried to cover this gorgeous song with whistle notes! It would mean a lot to me if you gave a listen to it 😆
@@TheCosmicNote yes of course! Please post the link and I will listen and like it :) I am sure it is great!
people who say this is bad are OBVIOUSLY delusional this is literally the most amazing and catchy thing in a Christmas song ever
Well blended
I'm sorry please do not attack me but I think ari did the high part. 😭😭
Me too, if you watch closely to the video. It looks like it’s ariana’s plus notes matches her whistles from her latest album 🤭
I like Ariana, she has an amazing voice but the 90s Mariah would have blown our minds out. I love Mariah and Ariana both though
@@swizzwizz12 who said anything about the 90's mariah. We all know no one could top that. We are talking about the recent mariah and recent ariana. The topic was who did the high note.
Ari didn't hit G#6 the whistle was harmonized:
C#6= Ari
F6= Mc
C#6+F6= G#6
@@swizzwizz12
What did that have to do with anything? Your comment was so irrelevant here. What they said was that the last high whistle sounds like Ari. How is your comment relevant here?
The Giant Mariah, Goddaughter of Legendary Patti LaBelle! So Beautiful!
lol
✨”The Whistle Queens”✨
Wow mariah. 👌🏻
não tem ninguém nesse youtube que mixa vozes melhor que tu kkkk só vc conseguiu separar as vozes delas com exatidão
I'm pretty sure many people in the comment section don't even know there was an original version over 10 years ago, where Mariah was doing every high and low note, having a pretty long riff at whistle register and whistling down to the 4th octave on that run. and btw, when not whistling, Mariah can easily hit down to C3 and even the 2nd octave. people here are just saying as if Mariah was having trouble with the lower notes and Ari handled it, are yall aware of the range of Mariah?
That whistle riff in the original version still gives me goosebumps, it's so fast!!
Arianators ofc does not know the range of Mariah.
You nailed it!
So good thank u @
Thats mum & doter right there..🥰
ariana has got a lot of strengh in her vocals
The whistle is easy but
BUT THE BEAUTYYYYYY💞💞💞
This part had me out of my chair running
that F#6 makes me feel nostalgic
I hope you can isolate the 3 voices on 'santa'!
How do u seperate them lile this o g
I saw a video of the whistles on a loop for a minute earlier today and was like “I really wanna know who took which (higher/lower) harmony, and then this popped up lol
This is crazy😁😁
woah..all this time i thought that G#6 was Ariana😍it was the queen MC
For mariah is easier to whistle cuz of her airy natural voice , ari's are learned however incredible
Honestly, there’s no real way of knowing who did the G#6
These arianators in the comments section have me in tears 😂 "The LOwEr haRmOnY is MorE dFFicuLt", well somebody has to take the lower harmony, so ariana took it, its not a conpetition, Mariah did the F6 and G#6 and ariana did the C#6, end of story
Si te callas?
@@alvaroramos4619 no, callate tu
I wanna see maraiah whistles in a lower tone
actually Mariah did the F6, but not the G#6, the person that made this made a msitake fjdjnfjajfj
@@ismael5912 yeah, cuz your the one that separated the vocals, just accept it goddam, it doesnt frkn matter
Queens 🔥🔥🔥
love ariana and mariah
Caramba. E eu que achava que Ariana era quem tivesse feito o Whistle mais alto. ❤️👏🏻 Rainha soberana dos apitos.