Kanye has rapped on beats like CARNIVAL - Black Skinhead, All Day, & even Power all have production that feature maximalist, anthemic vocal chants. Kanye’s production is different bro, easily the GOAT
Problematic is more impressive and interesting song then burn but it’s raw while burn is shortened perfection. So valid but I’m with Lu about liking problematic more personally
wow, king so far is my fav off the album. not going to let others ruin it 4 me tho if anything its better as it would be more of the lowkey songs to listen to
Am i the only one who doesn’t get the Carnival obsession? Like it’s not a horrible song or anything, but it’d be near the bottom of my list for this album. The Carti feature is good I just can’t get over the chanting for some reason. Maybe it’ll grow on me 🤷♂️
@@hikikomoriiii-y1w mo bamba is a LIL different than Carnival IMO. At least mo bamba had a good flow and a vibe, for some reason Carnival missed the mark for me. It seemed like Ye was trying too hard with the chanting sample and multiple features. Felt like he threw a bunch of arrows at the board and missed the bullseye. Album was still overall pretty fire tho
I don't even get the obsession with this album in general. Production is stellar as usual, but it has the worse lyrics out of any Ye album. Nothing is as clever as Ye thinks it is in his head.. Ty does his best to make this a real project but there are too many weak bars as a whole to even justify a bracket video.
1st Round: carnival > fuk sumn back to me > vultures burn > king problematic > stars talking < keys to my life paperwork > hoodrat beg forgiveness > good (don’t die) paid < do it 2nd round: carnival > back to me burn < problematic keys to my life < paperwork beg forgiveness > do it 3rd round: carnival > problematic paperwork < beg forgiveness FINALS: carnival > beg forgiveness 🤑🤑🤑
Tried to do a top 5 but end up with 10. These songs on repeat for me. 1. Carnival 2. Do it 3. Back to me 4. Fuk Sumn 5. Paid 6. Vultures 7. Talking 8. Stars 9. King 10. Paperwork
I don't know why Paperwork is not as hyped as other songs off this record. The beat and sample alone are some of the most creative stuff in Ye's catalogue
Carnival wasn’t even close to the song u hear on the album back when vultures was released as a single. There was no Milan choir. Kanyes verse wasn’t too great . Thankful they didn’t drop that as the lead single
_ROUND 1_ - Carnival > Fuk Sumn - Back To Me > Vultures - Burn > King - Stars < Problematic [Very close tho] - Talking > Keys To My Life - Paperwork > Hoodrat - Beg Forgiveness < Good(Don't die) - Paid < Do It - *Winners:* - Carnival vs Back To Me - Burn vs Problematic - Talking vs Paperwork - Good(Don't die) vs Do It - _ROUND 2_ - Carnival > Back To Me - Burn < Problematic - Talking < Paperwork - Good(Don't die) > Do It - *Winners:* - Carnival vs Problematic - Paperwork vs Good(Don't die) _ROUND 3_ - Carnival < Problematic - Paperwork < Good(Don't die) - *Winners for final:* Problematic vs Good(Don't die) Winner: porblematic
I guess Jon Denton & I are the only ones who actually enjoy HoodRat. Kinda surprised I agree with every other take you guys have, but HoodRat in the car on blast is hard af man. Idk
imo album should’ve ended on that “fuckin ridiculous” callback bar off problematic… that shit woudlve been a perfect way to cap off such a different type of album from kanye by calling back to one of his most iconic bars from one of his best songs.
My picks: Sweet 16: F*K SUMN > CARNIVAL VULTURES > BACK TO ME KING > BURN STARS > PROBLEMATIC KEYS TO MY LIFE > TALKING HOODRAT > PAPERWORK GOOD (DON’T D*E) > BEG FORGIVENESS PAID > DO IT Elite 8: VULTURES > F*K SUMN STARS > KING KEYS TO MY LIFE > HOODRAT PAID > GOOD (DON’T D*E) Final 4: VULTURES > STARS KEYS TO MY LIFE > PAID Championship: KEYS TO MY LIFE > VULTURES
if you listen to the leaked fuk sumn it's such a badass song with such a good kanye part. But then he puts the song on the album completely destroyed. I just dont understand. And that is just one of endless examples.
paid over do it is absolutely insane
Kanye has rapped on beats like CARNIVAL - Black Skinhead, All Day, & even Power all have production that feature maximalist, anthemic vocal chants. Kanye’s production is different bro, easily the GOAT
Also heaven and hell and selah
@@PEGGY18MAFIA chakraslover911: ok so, selah had no beat at the time the last freestyle was recorded, it was only a bass and adlibs
Yeah I don’t get the Carnival glazing. The feature’s great but I can’t fall in love with the sample
facts Charlie heat
kendrick exsists
King is slept on fr. Feels like fight music
paid over do it?? thats kinda wild cuz imo do it is top 3 in the album
Underrated
do it over paid is fuckin atrocious lol
Do it is my favorite song on the album
@@haus119I think it's the best song on the album
stars got me floating
Problematic is more impressive and interesting song then burn but it’s raw while burn is shortened perfection. So valid but I’m with Lu about liking problematic more personally
good dont die in the first round is crazy
Burn is the best song
This dude did not just say that King should have been kept off.
I agree with Lu
It’s Ye’s victory lap to close the album. Goes hard
Beat is bonkers if you’re talking boom bap style rap beat could be best on the album
Burn has to be one of my favorite ye songs currently, feels like his old work
the only channel giving me vultures content
My top 5
1.Burn
2.Carnival
3.Stars
4. King
5. Vultures
if stars had more YE bars, it could be the best of the album
Problematic is so good
carnival is so overrated, got damn I hate Playboy Carti and Mumble Rap in General
@@e.l.b6435like it or not it’s a good track it’s popular for a reason
wow, king so far is my fav off the album. not going to let others ruin it 4 me tho if anything its better as it would be more of the lowkey songs to listen to
I know man. I love King. Im surprised people don’t mess with that more
It's a sweet song. Surprised they didn't like it
The mixing is awful. When I first heard it I genuinely thought I was listening to some older version of the album
Am i the only one who love loves HOODRAT?? Idk i just love tgat song. Top 3 of the album for sure
I agree, it is mixed badly but I love the production and I think the melodies are so good
the hook is incredible, the way kanye enters in each verse is amazing. such an underrated song, one day they'll understand :(
Am i the only one who doesn’t get the Carnival obsession?
Like it’s not a horrible song or anything, but it’d be near the bottom of my list for this album. The Carti feature is good I just can’t get over the chanting for some reason. Maybe it’ll grow on me 🤷♂️
Nope 🤷♂️ I don’t get any of the hype, I like problematic & that’s about it, Carnival is literally just mo bamba
@@hikikomoriiii-y1w mo bamba is a LIL different than Carnival IMO. At least mo bamba had a good flow and a vibe, for some reason Carnival missed the mark for me. It seemed like Ye was trying too hard with the chanting sample and multiple features. Felt like he threw a bunch of arrows at the board and missed the bullseye.
Album was still overall pretty fire tho
I don't even get the obsession with this album in general. Production is stellar as usual, but it has the worse lyrics out of any Ye album. Nothing is as clever as Ye thinks it is in his head.. Ty does his best to make this a real project but there are too many weak bars as a whole to even justify a bracket video.
Without Playboy Carti The Track Would be Better in my opinion. I don`t have a Taste for Mumble Rap
Beg forgiveness is 🐐
I love you guys’ videos! You guys should do a vid on Leaked Songs Vs AI Songs
fire idea
I really hope that Kanye's verse on Paid grows on people, In my opinion Kanye's verse goes crazy on that beat.
Back to me is a Kanye classic
Beg Forgiveness is my fav song.
Hot take, stars is top 3
2nd best rated song on aoty
it’s a really fun listen and it’s a beautiful intro
1st Round:
carnival > fuk sumn
back to me > vultures
burn > king
problematic > stars
talking < keys to my life
paperwork > hoodrat
beg forgiveness > good (don’t die)
paid < do it
2nd round:
carnival > back to me
burn < problematic
keys to my life < paperwork
beg forgiveness > do it
3rd round:
carnival > problematic
paperwork < beg forgiveness
FINALS:
carnival > beg forgiveness 🤑🤑🤑
Ant: (Losing argument)
Also Ant: “So in the car”
Burn as the winner is a massive W, that's my choice aswell
King is so good tho🥺🥺🥺🥺
After everything is said hannnnn
He is still the king
Tried to do a top 5 but end up with 10. These songs on repeat for me.
1. Carnival
2. Do it
3. Back to me
4. Fuk Sumn
5. Paid
6. Vultures
7. Talking
8. Stars
9. King
10. Paperwork
Dont like burn?
Nah Burn's gotta be top five. Unless you just forgot it existed?
no problematic or burn is crazy
where's Burn
Good don’t die is underrated
bruh, how many videos you gonn make on vultures💀
Vultures =
33% Yeezus
33% Donda
33%TLOP
1% 808's and Heartbreaks
that 1 percent is good (dont die)
Paperwork clears keys to my life and it’s not even close
i don’t get what ant is saying with paid having much more interesting production than do it. that beat switch on do it was insane
Good(don’t die) is no longer available on Amazon Music???!!!
I thought as much. Great track so hopefully gets resolved!!
I don't know why Paperwork is not as hyped as other songs off this record. The beat and sample alone are some of the most creative stuff in Ye's catalogue
Can you do a bracket when all the vultures have dropped!
a nfr bracket with no need for anger management classes 😮
nfr podcast x fortnite collab comiing soon!
For me the number 1 song is Carnival and the 2nd is Beg Forgiveness
You guys have a great show. My only thing is why aren't you guys speaking on the album being tooken down from apple music?
My top 5 in order:
1. Burn
2. Good(Don’t Die)
3. Back to Me
4. Beg Forgiveness
5. Stars
no problematic is crazy, Problematic is literally top1. Its on completly other level than anything on the whole album
Its so sad that ye removed the Best Song "Good" from the album
Do it over paid 100%
Also painful to see Stars not make it past round1 but going against Problematic is... Problematic...
Carnival wasn’t even close to the song u hear on the album back when vultures was released as a single. There was no Milan choir. Kanyes verse wasn’t too great . Thankful they didn’t drop that as the lead single
The “go go go head so good she honor roll” chants sound so awkward . It sounds like a sloshed English football stadium.
Congratulations, you got the point of the song!
Do It lost to Paid??? That's crazy. Paid is cool but Do It is a whole other level - I almost feel like Do It is a mix of Burn with Carnival.
It’s crazy how I agree with their takes on overall albums but completely disagree with their takes on individual songs. Idek how it’s possible.
BURN is definitely the best song. Only flaw is Kanye didn't have a 2nd verse
I like king a lot
If Diablo/WorkDone is on Vultures 2 it will top everything.
The left side of the bracket was way more stacked than the right side
_ROUND 1_
- Carnival > Fuk Sumn - Back To Me > Vultures - Burn > King - Stars < Problematic [Very close tho] - Talking > Keys To My Life - Paperwork > Hoodrat - Beg Forgiveness < Good(Don't die) - Paid < Do It -
*Winners:* - Carnival vs Back To Me - Burn vs Problematic - Talking vs Paperwork - Good(Don't die) vs Do It -
_ROUND 2_
- Carnival > Back To Me - Burn < Problematic - Talking < Paperwork - Good(Don't die) > Do It -
*Winners:* - Carnival vs Problematic - Paperwork vs Good(Don't die)
_ROUND 3_
- Carnival < Problematic - Paperwork < Good(Don't die) -
*Winners for final:* Problematic vs Good(Don't die)
Winner: porblematic
Fuk Sumn clears carnival and vultures clears back to me
@@BACKDOORBROWNIE710 those are really valid picks, but all of them wouldn't win anyway
paid is underrated as hell
I guess Jon Denton & I are the only ones who actually enjoy HoodRat. Kinda surprised I agree with every other take you guys have, but HoodRat in the car on blast is hard af man. Idk
hoodrat goes hard its top 3 for me
They pulled the album who cares about a song bracket.
I’m still able to listen to it
imo album should’ve ended on that “fuckin ridiculous” callback bar off problematic… that shit woudlve been a perfect way to cap off such a different type of album from kanye by calling back to one of his most iconic bars from one of his best songs.
Either Problematic or Beg Forgiveness are #1 imo
Nooo do it, is so good😭
Paperwork one of the most underrated songs on the album
It won’t let me play the album anymore😢😢
they almost forgot about ty dolla sign being in the album
I hate the intro/hook on carnival
RIP vultures on apple music
@adrianxab That’s why I downloaded it to my library
Thank god, let's be honest here
Donda should be his final album, that's a way better of a send off
Listening to this whole album I think picking carnival isn’t the song that offers the most. It wouldn’t feel right for that to be the best song
Vultures (song) goes hard. Idk why it’s not a top pick imo. Sure maybe not as artistically on point as the rest, but it’s a banger song nonetheless
Disagreed with almost everything you guys said but entertaining content none the less
Unreleased “Do It” wayy better than released version
King is low key one of my fav on the album
Hi!
Luke, as a viewer, I'd appreciate it if you could interrupt Ant a little bit less. Sometimes I cannot hear what he says. Shoutout to both of you.
King is fire imo
Vultures Havoc edition is one of the best. Way better than the original vultures
carti on fuk sumn >>> carti on carnival
guys, please do a 36 song bracket with eminem songs, think it would be dope
I wish burn was a bit longer
Problematic over stars is WILD
My picks:
Sweet 16:
F*K SUMN > CARNIVAL
VULTURES > BACK TO ME
KING > BURN
STARS > PROBLEMATIC
KEYS TO MY LIFE > TALKING
HOODRAT > PAPERWORK
GOOD (DON’T D*E) > BEG FORGIVENESS
PAID > DO IT
Elite 8:
VULTURES > F*K SUMN
STARS > KING
KEYS TO MY LIFE > HOODRAT
PAID > GOOD (DON’T D*E)
Final 4:
VULTURES > STARS
KEYS TO MY LIFE > PAID
Championship:
KEYS TO MY LIFE > VULTURES
Gotta be back to me that Freddie verse is no joke
Kanye ruined that song so bad that Gibbs verse dosent even save it
dude said "beautiful big titty butt naked just dont fall off the sky you know" too many times like it was hella annoying
stars>problematic imo. always loved that sound from ye
fuk sumn is the best song
Why doesn't ppl like King, it's amazing
Beg forgiveness is okay but I promise you the fans right now aren’t bumping it that much and it’s not what the album will be remembered for lol
Do it is way better than paid. I honestly don’t like paid it’s so boring + shitty ye verse
Good(don’t die) got removed from apple music
Great album
Do it is soo underrated…
My top 5
Beg forgiveness
Problematic
Carnival
Do it
Back to me
Beg Forgiveness is ASS
Keys to my life is so boring and forgettable
Paperwork is Goated
King is not mid at all
Vultures is an actual good song
L take
So many tracks
Best album for now!
back to me >>>>>>
Burn is a perfect song, too bad it's so short
Naaaa paid over do it is wild. Paid is in my bottom 3
if you listen to the leaked fuk sumn it's such a badass song with such a good kanye part. But then he puts the song on the album completely destroyed. I just dont understand. And that is just one of endless examples.
W bracket, actually agreed with the whole bracket for once
do it stayed being slept on its all good tho
goddamn Lu & Ant are milking tf out of this but I love it 💀
Carnival praise in the moment 🤣
Burn is best because it sounds like old kanye, the best kanye
BEG FORGIVENESS #1 and it’s not even close fr
People hyped up Carnival like it was this classic Kanye song but that shit is ass wtf are yall talking about
what is the gun one in every states
KING & STARS got set up 😭 both did NOT deserve a first round exit (y’all SLEEP on KING 💤)
They rlly milking this album🤣🤣🤣