Survivor - Top 10 Players of All-Time

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 12 июн 2020
  • In this video, I talk about who I think are the 10 best players in the history of Survivor US along with a ridiculous amount of honorable mentions. I do plan on making more Survivor Top 10 player videos moving forward like a Top 10 Non-Winning Players and Top 10 One-Time Player videos.
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 1,1 тыс.

  • @user-kv8gf7zv9n
    @user-kv8gf7zv9n 3 года назад +104

    There is Michael Jordan. There is Tom Brady. There is Wayne Gretzky. And then there is Tony Vlachos

    • @lorettahoffman2751
      @lorettahoffman2751 2 года назад +4

      Boston rob is the jordan of survivor. HE TOOK THE JURY OUT OF THE EQUATION in all stars. And in the finale he made sure to let the jury know right before the votes were read when he proposed to amber. Either name they wrote down they all knew either way they were giving rob a million dollars. The 2 seasons he won were the most dominant displays of survivor ever. Tony's 1st season was great and season 40 was some slick maneuvering but there was alot of things he got lucky on. Rob didnt allow luck into either of his games he won he dominated ever aspect physical strategic and social.

    • @kobe3941
      @kobe3941 2 года назад

      @@lorettahoffman2751 rob barley won in his season, he only wins against Natalie and Philip yes he dominated the season but it was a completely dud of a cast.
      Tony won Cagayan easily from the final 7 on he can’t go home and wins against anyone on the season outside of spencer he then comes on winners at war and dominates the game easily from the merge on

    • @wills3210
      @wills3210 Год назад

      @@kobe3941 Tony loses to Spencer if they go to the final 2, and he probably loses to Trish and Tasha as well

    • @DRGOAT999
      @DRGOAT999 9 месяцев назад

      ​@wills3210 "IF". All that didn't happen because tony blindsided everyone 😂 he took control of his own game which make him the goat

    • @grantgoffin4774
      @grantgoffin4774 7 месяцев назад +2

      @@wills3210 So Tony still beats a lot of people who made the merge. Rob has only 1 winning Final 3 out of the whole merge on RI, and it was vs the two biggest goats in history, even bigger goats than Woo or Kass are.

  • @Eli-bm8om
    @Eli-bm8om 4 года назад +206

    I turn off the video when i don't see Jean Roberts the true best player :((

    • @vaporterra
      @vaporterra 4 года назад +30

      Genre Bear robbed goddess

    • @blazegod8490
      @blazegod8490 4 года назад +1

      thats fair

    • @riinalaakso4870
      @riinalaakso4870 4 года назад +8

      @@vaporterra GENRE BEAR i can't

    • @vaporterra
      @vaporterra 4 года назад +2

      Riina Laakso when I first saw someone call them that I actually snorted

    • @lorettahoffman2751
      @lorettahoffman2751 2 года назад

      He is almost singlehandidly puts china in my top 5 favorite season 😂😂

  • @lukebrennan3378
    @lukebrennan3378 4 года назад +214

    Cirie’s overview broke my heart. So robbed time and time again

    • @kennethreichelt
      @kennethreichelt 4 года назад +2

      1. Good social player. 2. Good strategic player. 3. Worst athletic player in history. Sandra is better. You need to be good at all three in order to win.
      Edit: usually need to be good at all three. Sandra is not.

    • @giulianoavella4978
      @giulianoavella4978 4 года назад +10

      @@kennethreichelt Are you just ignoring the fact that Sandra is one of the worst physical competitors of all time then?

    • @TheFuzziBear69
      @TheFuzziBear69 4 года назад

      @@kennethreichelt Yea, Sandra is an absolute challenge beast.

    • @TheFuzziBear69
      @TheFuzziBear69 4 года назад +3

      @@kennethreichelt 1. Sandra isn't that great socially (But is great in FTC) 2. Sandra isn't that great strategically (Never made a big move that worked) 3. I'll take Cirie in a challenge over Sandra because Cirie is good at puzzles.

    • @kennethreichelt
      @kennethreichelt 4 года назад +1

      @@giulianoavella4978 I see the flaw in my statement. Bottom line is that each jury is completely different and there's no set way to win survivor. I don't think Sandra deserved to win either of her games.

  • @ethan6483
    @ethan6483 Год назад +45

    Here’s the thing about Sandra in my opinion. She didn’t have a lot of control in her seasons, but she understands the kind of attitude you need to have when you’re not in control in order to gain the respect of a jury. Does that make sense?

    • @redguywins4802
      @redguywins4802 Год назад +8

      Sandra is definitely a top 10 player. This list loses a lot of credibility by not including her in the top 10. She was never in a good position but still managed to win because of jury control (which whether or not the video maker agrees with or not IS a part of the game.)

    • @thecamishere4344
      @thecamishere4344 Год назад +5

      @@redguywins4802 most definitely not. Clearly anybody who thinks she is didn't properly take the time to analyze her games. Not to mention she QUIT her very last season

    • @sssamui286
      @sssamui286 Год назад +2

      Yeah. Really the only of her games that I found impressive was the one in Game Changers which she was easily the best player there outside of Sarah.

    • @jewski6852
      @jewski6852 Год назад +3

      @@redguywins4802 Sandra has quit, has one of the worst moves of all time, and has only 2 total good moves in her career. She is about 20-25 ish

    • @owenpierce4874
      @owenpierce4874 Год назад +2

      I actually think the first 16 days of her 4 seasons and even Australian Survivor, her best seasons were the ones she was voted out in if you only look at her first 16 days. The only one that might would change would the WaW and HvH.

  • @vaporterra
    @vaporterra 4 года назад +93

    I agree with some of the other comments Earl should be in the top 10 ahead of Tommy

    • @connerewescott2447
      @connerewescott2447 4 года назад +2

      He is

    • @Arman-jx7cx
      @Arman-jx7cx 4 года назад +14

      I don’t know. Earl had much easier competition to play against. Tommy had to battle superfans that were loaded with idols. But Earl should definitely be higher

    • @vaporterra
      @vaporterra 4 года назад +3

      Arman Earl also didn’t know the show that well when he played Survivor so his ability to play as well as he did without the background of a Rob Cesternino type player is commendable too

    • @Arman-jx7cx
      @Arman-jx7cx 4 года назад +2

      vaporterra I agree. It’s very commendable, I do believe he should get a high spot, but I do think Tommy’s game was more impressive. And back to my point about the competition, all of his cast were also recruits, so he didn’t have any obstacle players.

  • @birks2180
    @birks2180 4 года назад +81

    The edit in Micronesia is incredibly misleading. Making it seem like Parvati would have been the first boot, Cirie being the one to spearhead the Ozzy boot, etc. Cirie was firmly aligned with Parv from the get go and she was never going to be the first voted out. And in Heroes vs. Villains, Parvati didn't actually laugh at the heroes or mock them in any way. The only person to say this was Sandra and it was denied by multiple heroes. I think she is the player who had the toughest season to navigate as she had the biggest target coming into a season of all stars. We saw that the other tribe, who had 2 people that were her most loyal allies in a different season actively try to interfere with the OPPOSING tribe to get her voted out. That speaks volumes to how dangerous they thought she was. Then again in the merge episode, you see the Heroes totally isolate her to the point where Amanda has to hide the fact that she is talking to her. Parvati had no wiggle room at all that season and was FORCED to put all her eggs in Russell's basket. I don't think it's a knock against her that Russell used an idol on her. Russell is an incredibly selfish player and the fact that they were both able to convince Tyson (recent news has confirmed it was not just Russell's doing) to vote Parvati and she had a strong enough relationship with Russell is impressive. Not to mention, Parvati wouldn't actually leave over Russell anyways in a tie. Her and Sandra had a winners pact and she had way stronger relationships with Courtney and Coach. If not for the overabundance of twists in Cook Islands and the supposed "rigs", Parvati has a great shot at winning in a Final 3 (she certainly makes it there) and then again in Winners at War she gets one of the worst swap screws of all time. I think she's a very consistent player, and not exactly high variance like a lot of players (Tony).

    • @brenchengbrencheng4794
      @brenchengbrencheng4794 4 года назад +11

      Agreed! Also, I dont think Parvati got wayyyyy too much credit nor did she played a sloppy game in HvV. If we looked closely, Parvati was actually 'targetted' by almost everyone on that season. In one of their attempts to take her down, she was easily excluded from the Boston Rob's core alliance and during confessionals players kept reminding us clear, the tv viewers just how big of a threat level Parvati is and Jerri at one point said, she would love to find out how to bottle that 'natural charm' aura of hers due to her flirtatious and cunning personality without seeming manipulative and being obvious. The fact that they acknowledged her winning prowess in which she became the main leader of the deadliest alliance group in Survivor history at the time, the infamous black widow brigade where 5 members consisting of all females taking control over Micronesia and being praised very well, particularly in highlighting the women of their significant role and strength that eventually lead to several fun and epic blindsides of the season with the victims were mostly male. For the fans to enjoy watching her Survivor victory itself is absolutely incredible and just amazing to witness. However, that is totally in contrast to all of the other returning players in HvV. While Parvati leads the entire all-stars cast as to being the one with the most high profile name and her prolific reputation she builds in as a part of her winning status under the belt of her Survivor resume along with Tom Westman, JT Thomas and Boston Rob at the time, she directly became the public enemy no 1 because of her reputation and with the only two people willing to align with her, she was always being talked about very badly/intimidating when there are confessionals related to her persona inside or outside the game. Staying for a couple of days due to the tribe success in winning two straight tribal immunities allowed Parvati in finding herself enough room for a chance to breathe and nurture her game delicately. Day by day her gameplay kept flourishing ever since Tyson was taken down by Russell Hantz early during the game , which saw the downfall of the Boston Rob alliance and the risen power of a new dominance control possessed by the trio who were once in the minority. Parvati was having a tough time to ingratiate herself with almost 90% of her fellow players that season because most of the HvV players didnt want to have anything to do with her and a few of them like Tyson, JT, Candice(indirectly), Rupert and Amanda started to take into considerations some of the bold, risky moves they have chosen by themselves while acknowledging full understanding of the risk level of uncertainty in their decisions. The problem was not Parvati herself, it was the intimidating factor and the overall perception of breaking the Survivor rule by associating with Parvati or having a thought of working together with her will put any players in a bad position almost immediately. That's why the opposing players were very bitter and upset because they had lost the initial duel one by one against her continuously,starting from Tyson until Colby the last remaining heroes, which were all started from the opposing side rather than Queen P herself. Another extra example was Amanda, her tightest alliance in Micronesia got herself being busted once she told Parvati all her straight up lies to her face eventhough Parvati found out the truth after she correctly giving idols to fully control JT's elimination and what follows soon in the aftermath

    • @gregoryfuller9736
      @gregoryfuller9736 4 года назад +9

      Parvati was the first favorite to actually alliances with the fans as she was locked in at final two after Erick was eliminated as all three of the other women was taking paritvi to the end as both admana and cierie would’ve taken Parvati over the other one and if Natalie win out she also taking Parvati to end so In fact Parvati was never in danger at the merge.

    • @jaredfreeley8283
      @jaredfreeley8283 3 года назад +1

      After WaW I don’t think it’s fair to call tony high variance. He showed he’s super adaptable

    • @TheMurrmursonbottle
      @TheMurrmursonbottle 3 года назад +2

      Great points on Parv. She’s really really good at integrating herself and forming really strong bonds within her alliance. It’s hard to see just how screwed she was in Cook Islands with twists like the god idol and the bottle

    • @bigbuffguy9589
      @bigbuffguy9589 2 года назад

      No one has ever denied that Parvati mocked the heroes. Also, Parvati's decision to hide her idol from Russell is one of the dumbest moves in Survivor history and cost her the game. Sandra beat Parvati's ass straight up. Deal with it. Also, if you want to talk about twists, the only reason Parvati ever won was because of that BS final two in Micronesia.

  • @possum8894
    @possum8894 4 года назад +32

    if the greatest of all time Phillip Shepard isn't on this list I'm going to be upset

    • @kevfournier2998
      @kevfournier2998 3 года назад +1

      The thing is they carried him because of his asshole ways. He was character

    • @lorettahoffman2751
      @lorettahoffman2751 2 года назад +1

      Philip was one of the most entertaining characters in reality tv history

    • @GotKarp
      @GotKarp 2 года назад

      @@kevfournier2998 I firmly believe Phillip would have won Caramoan if Malcom didn’t do the crazy idol play.

    • @thecamishere4344
      @thecamishere4344 Год назад

      GOAT in entertainment maybe more than Coach but otherwise severely lacking game tact

  • @roland276
    @roland276 4 года назад +54

    the fact that tommy is above earl, tom, and yul baffles me

    • @Idkwhattoputheretbh558
      @Idkwhattoputheretbh558 4 года назад +1

      I know right

    • @Shoeperfreak31
      @Shoeperfreak31 4 года назад +4

      The fact that Tommy is on this list baffles me

    • @anrajsoni2596
      @anrajsoni2596 4 года назад +5

      Desmond Smith He says Todd only played once so he can’t make the list... but Tommy played once too? It’s recency bias :/ tbh

    • @cheesymonkey6221
      @cheesymonkey6221 4 года назад +1

      Yeah I agree that Earl and Tom should be above him but I still think Tommy is up there with the greats. Yul is hard to gauge how good he actually is because he had that stupidly overpowered idol in Cook Islands.

    • @rambo8550
      @rambo8550 3 года назад

      better social player than all 3, especially Yul, and can manage his threat level better than Tom and Yul

  • @Idkwhattoputheretbh558
    @Idkwhattoputheretbh558 4 года назад +108

    Time stamps
    HONORABLE MENTIONS
    0:52 Richard Hatch
    1:06 Tina Wesson
    1:28 Brian Heidk
    1:49 Rob Cesternino
    2:05 Queen Sandra Diaz Twine
    3:21 Johnny Fairplay
    3:37 Chris Daughtery
    3:51 Tom Westman
    4:45 Yul Kwon
    4:53 Todd Herzog
    5:05 Amanda Kimmel :(
    5:29 JT
    6:19 Tyson Apostal (I’m going to murder TheMernanianReview)
    7:10 Russel Hantz (There’s a flaw in this list)
    8:02 Cochran
    8:49 Denise Stapley
    9:14 Malcolm Freberg
    9:34 Natalie Anderson
    10:45 Michele Fitzgerald
    11:56 Aubrey Bracco
    12:27 Wendell Holland
    13:08 Domenick Abbate
    13:44 Nick Wilson
    ACTUAL LIST
    14:32 Number 10 Sophie Clarke
    17:23 Number 9 Earl Cole
    19:57 Number 8 Tommy Sheehan (I don’t know about that)
    21:59 Number 7 Boston Rob
    24:25 Number 6 Jeremy Collins
    27:17 Number 5 Cirie Fields
    31:34 Number 4 Parvati Shallow
    35:44 Number 3 Sarah Lacina (Hold on, How dare you put Sarah above Parvati)
    38:49 Number 2 Kim Spradlin
    41:34 Number 1 King Tony Vlachos
    This took way too long for a flawed list

    • @marcosortega3350
      @marcosortega3350 4 года назад +10

      I’m not the biggest fan of Parvati.

    • @chrisrysz7727
      @chrisrysz7727 4 года назад +1

      You forgot “king” tony

    • @philbox3productions
      @philbox3productions 4 года назад

      I actually like his top 3

    • @mikeundrscr
      @mikeundrscr 4 года назад +7

      GoatSimulator Vids&More ok so Tyson isn’t really top 10 honestly, HvV, took out himself, Tocantins, Got “Blindsided”. Russell Hantz also has TERRIBLE, and I mean TERRIBLE jury management. He did play a great game, but he had severe terrible Jury management and in Redemption Island his tribe threw a challenge to get him out. Australian Survivor, he plays very, poorly. If this is a “Top 10 Survivor Players” this is highly accurate, Tommy played a old school game with a game that’s advantage heavy, that’s impressive.

    • @sethrollins4230
      @sethrollins4230 4 года назад

      Earl, Tommy, Boston Rob, Jeremy and Kim don’t belong in top 10. They’re all honorable mentions but Earl player so long ago only ONE time, Tommy just isn’t in great player status this early, Boston Rob is probably the most overrated player ever and isn’t versatile in any way, Jeremy proved he couldn’t handle the strategic game in WAW and believed all the crap Tony told him unlike Michelle who saw through it, and Kim who proved she couldn’t play with good people in WAS. Kim cried the first day bcuz she didn’t position herself in any type of alliance, and waited too long to do anything.

  • @sturma314
    @sturma314 4 года назад +84

    I think Spencer Bledsoe should at least have been mentioned, as although he may be abrasive, he still was an incredible strategic mind, good at competitions and does well to survive even as the largest target on the bottom in Cagayan

    • @Sam-kp2ly
      @Sam-kp2ly 3 года назад +6

      Yes, would hate to play against spencer

    • @tylersoexclusive713
      @tylersoexclusive713 3 года назад +25

      Bro I stg in season 28 he had the shittest squad in all of survivor history (brains) and somehow he managed to carry them long enough to survive , just to have Kass flip when it was the stupidest move she could’ve made. His back was against the wall for 95% of the season and he managed to get to final 4 on probably the greatest cast of survivor ever. Dude is so underrated it’s unreal

    • @cusegirl5
      @cusegirl5 3 года назад +1

      Spencer the crybaby. No thanks.

    • @djsamfong
      @djsamfong 3 года назад +9

      @@cusegirl5 do you think jeremy deserved to win second chances? because jeremy sure cried A LOT

    • @kharihammon9784
      @kharihammon9784 2 года назад +2

      @@djsamfong over spencer? yes. tbh, i wouldn’t b upset if spencer won.

  • @markjackson6431
    @markjackson6431 4 года назад +36

    take a shot every time he says high variance

  • @jdsalz2505
    @jdsalz2505 4 года назад +27

    My 10 girls: Sophie, Parvati, Cirie, Sandra, Wentworth, Aubry, Kim, Amanda, Sarah, Natalie.
    My 10 boys: Tony, Rob, Jeremy, Russell, Ozzy, Tom, Cochran, Richard, Tyson, Yul

    • @tipsy4989
      @tipsy4989 4 года назад +5

      I feel like that’s good but for girls I would switch Sophie and parviti

    • @potatodog3363
      @potatodog3363 4 года назад +1

      Queenchele

    • @ethancostellostudent1698
      @ethancostellostudent1698 4 года назад

      Earl should be in top 19 guys

    • @MercRogers
      @MercRogers 3 года назад +2

      girls- kim, parvati, cirie, sarah, natalie
      boys- tony, rob, jeremy, chris d, ozzy

    • @noahanderson8255
      @noahanderson8255 3 года назад +1

      U forgot to put Tyson on girls

  • @jpbproductions3872
    @jpbproductions3872 4 года назад +126

    Now that you’ve done top 10 best survivor players, could u do top 10 worst survivor players?

    • @bradleyberdan5154
      @bradleyberdan5154 4 года назад +26

      Colton, Francesca, J’Tia.. just to name a few

    • @xander2cat
      @xander2cat 4 года назад +2

      lol yes

    • @brianregan5933
      @brianregan5933 4 года назад +22

      @@bradleyberdan5154 Wendy Jo! Wendy Jo! The true queen of survivor. And actually in all honesty, I don't think Francesca is the worst ever. She got supremely unlucky twice

    • @commentingperson9554
      @commentingperson9554 4 года назад +16

      @@bradleyberdan5154 I hate to say it, but Colton isn't actually a bad player in One World lol

    • @chrisrysz7727
      @chrisrysz7727 4 года назад +8

      Commenting Person agreed, he got what he wanted with the Bill and Monica votes

  • @harrdeeharr
    @harrdeeharr 4 года назад +121

    Glad to see someone give Tommy’s game respect. Just because everything else that season was awful shouldn’t discredit his dominant win. A true old-school style game in a new-school environment.

    • @lordoflaziness7775
      @lordoflaziness7775 4 года назад +17

      Janet would have won without the idol nullifier and Lauren if she made fire. On this list overrated and not enough evidence.

    • @TheKicksBoy
      @TheKicksBoy 4 года назад +3

      Tommy was garbage

    • @omaradil6541
      @omaradil6541 4 года назад +4

      He was just a social player ..and was lucky that Elain targeted Jason first and not him..then Elain and Karishma flipped on Missy and Elisabeth with no reason and saved him..then Dean saved him and spilled the beans at tribal and exposed the plan to vote him out putting the target on Nora and Elain...he was extremely lucky ..voting out Janet knowing that she had an idol and convincing Nora to take him to the final without making fire were his best moves besides the social game because those moves led to the elimination of the front runners of the season both Janet and Lauren...

    • @rajorajo7429
      @rajorajo7429 4 года назад +6

      @@omaradil6541 He was not lucky with Jason being targeted, his social game and threat management saved him there. Same thing with the Missy vote. Missy was playing a great, but overly dominant game that showed her as a massive threat, while Tommy hid at the right times. Again, same thing with Dean. These people aren't saving Tommy because he's "Lucky," they're saving him because they like him, he's hiding his dominance and putting it on someone else, and everyone thinks they're in good with Tommy. If anything, he gets unlucky when Dan is removed (Don't get me wrong, he absolutely should have been removed. He's terrible). And I think he definitely beats Janet at the end. I wouldn't be surprised if he beats Lauren at the end as well, but both definitely had strong cases and would really come down to their FTC performances. If Lauren wins the fire-making challenge, I think Jack, Elaine, Janet, and Dean are locked votes for Tommy, and Jamaal would probably be leaning towards Tommy as well. I don't think Lauren has any "locked" votes, but she could win the unsure people over. Lauren would need all of the other votes to win. Definitely possible, and she gets 5 and it's a tie, I do think Noura votes for Lauren, so that is a knock on his game. However, she is probably gone at 6 if Dan is still there.

    • @redclyde730
      @redclyde730 4 года назад +5

      I completely agree with Tommy being a good winner, and inside reports say that he actually could’ve won against anyone in the cast. Plus, if the Dan didn’t get disqualified or whatever, Janet goes at 6, and then Noura, and Lauren go at 5 and 4, which gives him a clear win over Dan and Dean, who he had a final two with

  • @OnceUponAnIsland
    @OnceUponAnIsland 4 года назад +53

    How is Sandra not in the top 10? She won twice. Only two players can say they have done that.

    • @picafavo3466
      @picafavo3466 4 года назад +7

      Once Upon An Island ya, but she shouldn’t have won HvV

    • @bradleygrace7783
      @bradleygrace7783 4 года назад +6

      Absolutely, Sandra not being on the list makes the entire list almost pointless.

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 4 года назад +19

      Survivor is about 2 things.
      1. Get to the end.
      2. Make the jury happier with you than with who you are sitting next to.
      That is everything. How you do it is up to you. Sandra did it twice in her first two times playing.

    • @freakyfridays135
      @freakyfridays135 4 года назад +12

      Because it's not just about two seasons. It's extrapolating who would do well in many random circumstances. You can't just look at the end results and say who is best when the sample size is so small.

    • @picafavo3466
      @picafavo3466 4 года назад

      Once Upon An Island true, but making the jury mad, is called bullshit. You shouldn’t be mad just because someone took you out. Russell and Parv played 5 times the game Sandra did

  • @ethand7647
    @ethand7647 4 года назад +47

    Parvati is the best player to ever play this game. She always gets far and I would bet if she had a better swap in Winners At War she makes it to around the final 8 which is still impressive

    • @enriquemarshaii
      @enriquemarshaii 2 года назад +8

      100% agree I think she deserved that Heroes Vs. Villains win (I LOVE Sandra but she didn’t deserve it over Parvati) !!! Incredibly impressive player.

    • @CalloPasta
      @CalloPasta 2 года назад +3

      It's not really that impressive. Some pretty low standards and strange appreciation of talent to prop up and give such acclamation to someone for being "good" or finding success in this game show lol

    • @Brayzon
      @Brayzon Год назад +3

      Parvati and Rob are the two best IMO both screwed by the tribe swap in WaW but Parv should of won Heroes vs Villain's forsure. And Rob besides his first season always was in control even Heroes vs Villains he got just screwed by Tyson being the dumbest ever

    • @wills3210
      @wills3210 Год назад +2

      I would normally agree but her Cook Islands and Winners at War games make me hesitant to put her at 1

    • @itzwakk335
      @itzwakk335 10 месяцев назад

      parvati played a bad social game, and strategically was outmanuevered by russell at every turn@@enriquemarshaii

  • @alexandercousins2186
    @alexandercousins2186 4 года назад +98

    Tommy at 8? Over Tom Westman and Yul, let alone others?

    • @jj9487
      @jj9487 4 года назад +2

      Ikr. Tom shouldve been top 10

    • @TheKicksBoy
      @TheKicksBoy 4 года назад +10

      Tommy is a bottom tier winner not sure what happened with that ranking

    • @alzero120z
      @alzero120z 4 года назад +5

      Yea yul is handsdown a better player

    • @giulianoavella4978
      @giulianoavella4978 4 года назад +12

      @@TheKicksBoy I don't see how you could view him as bottom tier.

    • @rajorajo7429
      @rajorajo7429 4 года назад +14

      Tommy played one of the most Dominant social games without ever making himself a massive threat. I would put him over Tom for sure. Yul is my personal favorite survivor ever, so it's hard for me to give an unbiased answer, but I can certainly see an argument to be made between the two

  • @Ndumieso
    @Ndumieso 4 года назад +102

    Russell’s showing in Australian Survivor was probably his worst😫

    • @JMaster9877
      @JMaster9877 4 года назад +8

      I dont count that

    • @joeyralston3773
      @joeyralston3773 4 года назад +11

      At least he says that if he came back he would play a lot differently

    • @vaporterra
      @vaporterra 4 года назад +21

      JMaster98 Most fans count it, it’s a legitimate series and the last two Australian winners were good players too

    • @JMaster9877
      @JMaster9877 4 года назад +3

      @@vaporterra I dont count it towards Russell's resume. To me I dont consider it playing 4 times

    • @Claaarize
      @Claaarize 4 года назад +6

      Goes to show he didn’t learn anything from losing three times. 😂

  • @archer_bt3442
    @archer_bt3442 4 года назад +29

    This comment section is the most salty I’ve ever seen on a video related to survivor, like seriously half of these people can’t handle this dudes opinion on certain players lol.

    • @vaporterra
      @vaporterra 4 года назад +1

      Welcome to RUclips, people are allowed to disagree and critique

    • @karson779
      @karson779 3 года назад

      It's as if the commenters don't listen to his criteria for the best players lol

    • @bigbuffguy9589
      @bigbuffguy9589 2 года назад

      Eh, he has some pretty trash opinions to be fair.

  • @brianbortz
    @brianbortz 4 года назад +16

    parv: 6th place first season, 1st second season, 2nd third season
    sarah: merge boot first season, 1st second season, 4th third season
    parv: won more challenges and made larger moves in her entire survivor career
    sarah: made a solid speech and flipped on a lot of people
    and you STILL have parv under sarah... i think sarah is an amazing player but definitely not above parv.
    he also acts like having a target on their back is and avoiding it is a bad thing. in my opinion if you are supposed to be the first boot and you manage to work around it AND get deep in the game, that should give you more credit, not less.

    • @lorettahoffman2751
      @lorettahoffman2751 2 года назад +1

      Rob and parvati are the king and queen of the game. Both were the best triple threats. Physical strategic and social games were on point in all 3 categories. Mistakes made by their alliance members cost them in every season they didnt make it to the end. (Tyson voting himself out, penner being a flipper even though he knew he was flipping to the bottom of a 5 person alliance) they made fewer mistakes than anyone to ever play and they played more than anyone

    • @jesuisencoler
      @jesuisencoler 2 года назад

      @@lorettahoffman2751 it's more Tony and Parvati beacause Tony won twice

  • @yourlocalpenguin662
    @yourlocalpenguin662 4 года назад +22

    For me:
    10. Todd
    9. Earl
    8. Rob
    7. Jeremy
    6. Cirie
    5. Sandra
    4. Parvati
    3. Kim
    2. Sarah
    1. Prolly Chicken idk

    • @chickenchicken9072
      @chickenchicken9072 4 года назад +6

      Aw thank you :D

    • @MaccaForever
      @MaccaForever 4 года назад +4

      DAMN!

    • @tipsy4989
      @tipsy4989 4 года назад

      Kim is honestly overrated I think the only reason she controlled her original season was because the hole cast was goats and I think her WAW really summed her game up

    • @markjackson6431
      @markjackson6431 4 года назад +1

      Aqua Leaf you clearly haven’t watched her deep dive with Cesternino. nobody wanted to work with her because of her threat level. the fact that she made it to the merge is impressive ESPECIALLY with the target she had. Kimbot literally said she did everything in her power to make it seem like she could be trusted. making errors for everyone to be like hey guys you can work with me. when you know this, it’s understandable. and you wouldn’t be making a bullshit comment like you just did.
      that’s the problem with you fans, you don’t even listen to interviews and or read em and you just make up false narratives that you believe it’s true when it’s not

    • @chickenchicken9072
      @chickenchicken9072 4 года назад

      Mark Jackson YES👏

  • @EpiicxTurtles
    @EpiicxTurtles 3 года назад +6

    Sandra in Pearl Islands: *one jury vote off of the first ever perfect game, ties the record for most jury votes at the time*
    This guy: "Sandra played two of the worst winning games ever"

    • @Sam-kp2ly
      @Sam-kp2ly 3 года назад

      Truly this list subtly betrays that this guy would not do well playing the game

    • @maryjasper3369
      @maryjasper3369 3 года назад

      her game in hvv wasn't strong at all, but idk why he's so critical of her pi game

    • @rambo8550
      @rambo8550 3 года назад

      Because that one fact doesn't automatically make it a good game. the amount of jury votes doesn't define the quality of a winner. If that were the Case, Adam klein is a better winner than Sandra because he got all the votes, right?

    • @rambo8550
      @rambo8550 3 года назад

      @@maryjasper3369 cuz she didn't really have any idea what was going on while Fairplay and Burton owned most of the merge (except f5). If you think about it, it's really similar to Hvv. Her ally gets taken out early jury phase, then tries to take out the good strategic player but just can't because she's not a good enough player, but this time Lil is able to do it for her.

  • @georgehook3885
    @georgehook3885 3 года назад

    this is such a good, thorough, thoughtful list

  • @musicdude4776
    @musicdude4776 4 года назад +1

    i was waiting for this forever

  • @nelsonhamilton8262
    @nelsonhamilton8262 4 года назад +30

    Sandra won twice...I don’t care how she did it...that’s at least instant top 5. I think Rob said it best in winners at war: If ya won ya won.

    • @warmgooeycookie5609
      @warmgooeycookie5609 3 года назад +6

      People underestimate her ability to read the room... the “anyone but me” strategy that she uses only works when you’re savvy enough to ensure it’s anyone but you...
      Sure she’s bad at challenges, but not putting her in the top 10 is honestly kind of crazy.
      She’s a good liar, she’s socially aware, people generally like her, she doesn’t get paranoid and overthink things, people want to bring her deep into the game with them, she’s not seen as a huge threat, she is smart enough to see the real threats... She didn’t win twice based on luck.
      Additionally, Russell has to be a part of the conversation... he’s great but can’t win... why?? FOR ALL THE REASONS SANDRA DOES WIN.

    • @jaredfreeley8283
      @jaredfreeley8283 3 года назад +4

      The reason she gets to the end and wins usually isn’t because of her is what he’s trying to say. Russel drags her there in HvV and she literally wanted to take him out. She’s lucky she failed to Bc if she did she would’ve lost

    • @iddiolgames
      @iddiolgames 2 года назад +1

      Complete disagreement heres everyone on my list betweeen Sandra and the top 10 Malcolm,Spencer,Kelly,David,Brian,Nick,Rob C, Earl,Tommy,Amanda,Johnny F, and more

  • @anrajsoni2596
    @anrajsoni2596 4 года назад +32

    I mean... luck is always involved in Survivor though. It always is, you know? Sandra should be there because she showed that you don’t need to be a strategic prowess- I just don’t think you can discredit Sandra’s wins because she won in a cast with returning players who aren’t winners, unlike Tony. You know? She’s the Queen 👑. Think about it- had Kass won the Final Immunity Challenge in Cagayan (and she was off by 2 seconds), Tony wouldn’t be a two-time winner. He was superrrr lucky

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 4 года назад +9

      Sandra should definitely be in the top 10.

    • @devinthesupersmosher
      @devinthesupersmosher 4 года назад

      Winning a challenge that isnt luck based doesnt make you lucky for winning it and yes luck is a big part of winning survivor but that doesnt luck should be credited the very definition of luck makes succeeding in it a non skillful act that shouldn't be looked highly upon

    • @devinthesupersmosher
      @devinthesupersmosher 4 года назад

      @@OnceUponAnIsland why

    • @lukereistle4786
      @lukereistle4786 4 года назад +1

      Or if Woo didn’t stay loyal and took the somewhat goat Kass instead of Tony, then Tony would not have won

    • @devinthesupersmosher
      @devinthesupersmosher 4 года назад +1

      @@lukereistle4786 woo did they cause of tony so it's all credited to Tony

  • @jacoblangguth5125
    @jacoblangguth5125 4 года назад +26

    1. Zane Knight 2. Francesca Hogi 3. Phillip Sheppard

    • @airtempest8945
      @airtempest8945 4 года назад +3

      Nah. Number 1 is Wendy Jo 100%. She is the queen of every survivor season.

    • @jacoblangguth5125
      @jacoblangguth5125 4 года назад

      Air tempest #WendyJowasrobbed

    • @airtempest8945
      @airtempest8945 4 года назад

      @@jacoblangguth5125 Queen Wendy Jo for Survivor Legends. We all know she'll dominate the game 'cause people want to be her friend, and they like to be her friend. Then she'll backstab everyone she needs to, and be the mastermind we truly know she is.

    • @rambo8550
      @rambo8550 4 года назад +2

      Where's queen Na0nka? King Colton? Fix this list please!!!

    • @TrevAndy08
      @TrevAndy08 4 года назад +2

      It’s francesqua

  • @stayinalive92
    @stayinalive92 4 года назад +43

    Wentworth deserved an honorable mention! Strong underdog game in Cambodia and then a fairly decent showing in EOE (arguably her best performance) until a close ally decided to target her and in the process ruin their own game.

    • @ryanpacatte6054
      @ryanpacatte6054 4 года назад +2

      Yah give someone and honorable mention who placed 14th on their first try😂

    • @stayinalive92
      @stayinalive92 4 года назад +3

      Ryan Pacatte Her other showings speak for themselves 🤷‍♂️

    • @ryanpacatte6054
      @ryanpacatte6054 4 года назад

      ivrdolj1 no they don’t. Second chances she wasnt a threat to anyone coming in unlike others. It’s so hard to judge returnee seasons. She wasn’t anything impressive in EOE either. So even if you give her credit for playing one good game out of three I think most people who play survivor could do good once

    • @stayinalive92
      @stayinalive92 4 года назад +3

      Ryan Pacatte I’m giving her credit for playing two strong games out of three, which is fairly impressive imo. You’re free to disagree

    • @ryanpacatte6054
      @ryanpacatte6054 4 года назад

      ivrdolj1 I do

  • @jackwolff5428
    @jackwolff5428 4 года назад +23

    Shocked to not see tommy on the honorable mentions, even more shocked to see him be put number 8 but it does make sense.

    • @MrDainEbro
      @MrDainEbro 4 года назад +5

      recency bias

    • @a.a6382
      @a.a6382 4 года назад

      Mr Dain Ebro right

    • @alzero120z
      @alzero120z 4 года назад +1

      @@MrDainEbro or smoking crack

  • @jacoblangguth5125
    @jacoblangguth5125 4 года назад +25

    I do feel like Sandras Heroes villains win wasn’t all luck. She didn’t need to dominate or need to get out Russell. Simply opposing Russell was setting her up to win, because if she goes to the end with him, the heroes vote for her because they don’t like Russell and she becomes the non-Russell option, if she makes it to the end with heroes, she may get some villain votes. Also her move to get out coach really is underrated

    • @picafavo3466
      @picafavo3466 4 года назад +3

      the only thing about Sandra is, her entire game was getting Russell out, and never even came close to do it.

    • @ryleycarroll9486
      @ryleycarroll9486 4 года назад +1

      Let’s say pavity wins and she and jerry wants to vote russel out, do you think she will put him in fire against jerry so she can still sit next to him

    • @picafavo3466
      @picafavo3466 4 года назад

      Ryley Carroll they didn’t go to fire back then

    • @ryleycarroll9486
      @ryleycarroll9486 4 года назад

      Top 10 Sports I mean Parvati and jerry votes for Russell, russel somehow knows and the only way for him to get to the end if himself and Sandra votes for jerry than Russell will go against jerry

    • @picafavo3466
      @picafavo3466 4 года назад

      Ryley Carroll what?

  • @zachariahwilson4201
    @zachariahwilson4201 4 года назад

    I've been waiting for this video l

  • @AaronLad
    @AaronLad 4 года назад

    What a great top 10 as always

  • @KIRBIXthecameraGUY
    @KIRBIXthecameraGUY 4 года назад +10

    Regardless of how you play survivor, winning twice puts you in the top 10. Yeah Sandra gets "lucky" in Pearl Islands, doesn't "dominate" HvV, but the goal of Survivor is getting enough jury votes to win. If you can do that twice that makes you one of the best players.

    • @timurtheking
      @timurtheking 4 года назад

      not really. winning twice doesnt make you as a player, in the best of the best, especially cuz her games have proved she is shit at strategy: Game changers & WaW.

    • @brettkot5309
      @brettkot5309 4 года назад

      Timuru in GC she got swap screwed tho

    • @fatseal9999
      @fatseal9999 4 года назад +1

      I agree. Even though she didn’t have that great of a game in her wins and has no strategic mind, I still think winning twice automatically give you a spot in the top ten. I would’ve put her at somewhere 10-8

    • @fatseal9999
      @fatseal9999 4 года назад

      Wild Card Watson But Sandra has no clue that was what was going on. It was pure coincidence that happened

  • @TheColby7947
    @TheColby7947 4 года назад +16

    Tony has always been my favorite

    • @valtterihakkarainen4149
      @valtterihakkarainen4149 3 года назад

      Same

    • @coconut6748
      @coconut6748 3 года назад +2

      Same, i love his strategies, especially when woo took him in the finals who should've took Kass with him.

  • @liamduffy4589
    @liamduffy4589 4 года назад

    Finally!!!! Yayyyyy!!! Thank u

  • @elbows-knees2413
    @elbows-knees2413 4 года назад +28

    I Love Tommy but I can’t believe I’m living in a world where he’s above Natalie Anderson lol

  • @joseyarur2369
    @joseyarur2369 4 года назад +23

    My top
    Honorable mentions: Tina, Ethan, Vecepia, Brian, Rob C, Chris D, Danni, Amanda, JT, Malcolm, Denise, Cochran, Tyson, Spencer, Michele, Domenick, Wendell, Nick.
    15. Tommy
    14. Russell
    13. Yul
    12. Cirie
    11. Sophie
    10. Tom
    9. Natalie
    8. Rob
    7. Sandra
    6. Earl
    5. Sarah
    4. Jeremy
    3. Parvati
    2. Kim
    1. Tony

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 4 года назад +9

      Vecepia overcame 7-2 at the jury phase. She is the true underdog.

    • @joseyarur2369
      @joseyarur2369 4 года назад +5

      Once Upon An Island just as underrated as your channel

    • @OnceUponAnIsland
      @OnceUponAnIsland 4 года назад +4

      @@joseyarur2369 Lol good one. Thank you very much.

    • @escminnesota5543
      @escminnesota5543 4 года назад

      THANK YOUUUU! Vee is so underrated shes for sure a top 20 player for me.

  • @TrevAndy08
    @TrevAndy08 4 года назад +20

    My list: Honorable Mentions: Hatch, Tina, Colby, Ethan, Brian, Cesternino, Amber(I guess) Stephanie, Tom, Danni, yul, Penner, Yau-Man, Earl, James, Amanda, Todd, Chicken, Erik Reichenback, JT, Coach, King Fabio, Phillip Shepard, Cokran, Denise, Malcolm, Brandon Hantz😂, Ciera, Hayden, Sarah, Spencer,
    Wentworth, Natalie, Joe, Michele, Aubrey, Adam, Ben, Chrissy, Domenick, Wendell, Nick (Yeah IK I have too many honorable mentions. Deal with it.)
    Real List
    10. Sophie
    9. Sandra
    8. Tyson
    7. Russell
    6. Jeremy
    5. Cirie
    4. Kim
    3. Rob
    2. Parvati
    1. Tony 👑

    • @quinster6502
      @quinster6502 3 года назад +1

      Chicken? Phillip? Brandon? Terrible players

    • @jollfamily4379
      @jollfamily4379 3 года назад +1

      Quinster Chicken is queen 👑

    • @jesuisencoler
      @jesuisencoler 2 года назад

      @@quinster6502 DAMN

  • @carter4616
    @carter4616 4 года назад +51

    Kelly wentworth, not even a honourable mention😭

    • @ansonpang
      @ansonpang 4 года назад +6

      she hasn't been to any FTC and she played three times?

    • @carter4616
      @carter4616 4 года назад +2

      Anson Pang I just expected her to be a honourable mention considering the others listed

    • @Justin-lr8tq
      @Justin-lr8tq 4 года назад +5

      Anson Pang Cirie played 4 and didn’t make it and she’s amazing

    • @spdprawcereal7181
      @spdprawcereal7181 4 года назад +6

      Tbh she's kinda overrated. I haven't seen EoE, but in her first season and in Cambodia, she only did one good move (from what ik and remember)

  • @philbox3productions
    @philbox3productions 4 года назад +2

    I think you nailed the 1st, 2nd, and 3rd place players I'd have them as my top 3

  • @hoopswithjo4591
    @hoopswithjo4591 4 года назад +28

    Not even an honorable mention for Ozzy

    • @micahanderson6219
      @micahanderson6219 4 года назад +4

      nope😋✨

    • @coolwahl
      @coolwahl 4 года назад +5

      No and it should stay that way

    • @vickigroesbeck1104
      @vickigroesbeck1104 4 года назад +9

      Ozzy and Rupert both are fan favorites with objectively limited skill sets. They tend to do well in the early game, but have no real strategy or ability to adapt as the game changes around them. IMO, both are highly over-rated just because they are fun to watch on TV.

  • @jasoncastello5693
    @jasoncastello5693 4 года назад +14

    I’ll admit that I was genuinely surprised by Tommy’s inclusion on the list. I think he’s a great player too, but it typically takes me a couple of months to fully analyze a new players game. I think Sandra should be on the list (solely for her being a two time winner), but other than that, I think this list is pretty accurate.

  • @happybeavr
    @happybeavr 2 года назад

    I love your list, thank you

  • @KendalljazzYT
    @KendalljazzYT 4 года назад

    Ok time to watch this entire thing!

  • @evanxgaming5454
    @evanxgaming5454 3 года назад +9

    Boston Robs had great showings at pretty much every season, in Marquesas, was pretty dominant, a pre merge robbed, then lost in all stars due to a bitter jury, got robbed in pre merge of HvV due to Tyson messing up, Won RI, and had a meh gameplay on WAW, being decent on EoE, and tried to be controlling in his boot episode, but it didn’t work. Overall, he’s still a top 10 player

    • @samorlando6586
      @samorlando6586 3 года назад +2

      Thank you and he didn’t have any chance in WaW anyway. Had a good chance of winning HvV if Tyson didn’t mess him up and would’ve won all stars if shii ann didn’t falsely think amber was the mastermind

    • @johnbattle7518
      @johnbattle7518 2 года назад +1

      Boston Rob unofficially won AllStars even his wife admitted she rode his coat tails

  • @liamduffy4589
    @liamduffy4589 4 года назад +6

    You should do your Top 10 Characters of all time!!!

  • @suppacoo7268
    @suppacoo7268 4 года назад +22

    Of course Tony is #1! Suprised to see Kim at #2, but not dissappointed. She played genuinely smart both times and can adapt very well.

    • @suppacoo7268
      @suppacoo7268 4 года назад

      @@Bhuges801 I skipped to see if Tony was #1, which he was UwU. And when skipping to see #1 I also saw #3 & 2. Im watching the full video rn tho.

    • @TheKicksBoy
      @TheKicksBoy 4 года назад +1

      Pleas explain to me how she played well the 2nd time...I must’ve been watching a different show

    • @bc1173
      @bc1173 4 года назад +2

      @@TheKicksBoy she played very poorly in winners at war, people who know the game understand this.

    • @devondonato4609
      @devondonato4609 3 года назад

      @@bc1173 I thought she played amazing at winners at war if I’m going to compare her to everybody else that season. People forget everybody that season played awful. Even then I think Kim played great, she was only at he bottom for having a pregame alliance but she held power at the swap and was in a great position to win if she gets Jeremy out

    • @bigbuffguy9589
      @bigbuffguy9589 2 года назад

      Kim's game in One World is the most overrated strategic game ever. It was an excellent physical game and a good social game, but she made a ton of strategic mistakes that didn't cost her because the competition was weak.

  • @julescenteno
    @julescenteno 4 года назад +5

    Top 10 moves for both Survivor and Big Brother. I'd love to see your input on both of those topics!

  • @vaughnarmour612
    @vaughnarmour612 4 года назад +29

    So Ethan wasn’t even an honorable mention?

  • @mateovendrell3250
    @mateovendrell3250 4 года назад +18

    Thank you so much for not putting Sandra on this list. I’m serious thank you so much

  • @JVKSportshouse
    @JVKSportshouse 9 дней назад +1

    This is what it really is:
    1-Boston Rob
    2-Tony Vlachos
    3-Parvati Shallow
    4-Sandra Diaz Twin
    5-Cirie Fields
    6-Russell Hantz
    7-Sarah Lacina
    8-Kim Spradlin
    9-Jeremy Collins
    10-Richard Hatch
    Honorable Mentions:
    Ozzy Lutsh
    Tom Westman
    Jt Thomas
    Tyson Apostol

  • @RankopediaHarvey
    @RankopediaHarvey 4 года назад +3

    Can I ask a question? Not holding this against your list, BUT when you start talking about Richard Hatch and Tina Wesson's games not adapting well to modern Survivor, does that mean for modern winners of Survivor you will also gauge how their game would translate to earlier seasons of Survivor?

    • @dennismonk9559
      @dennismonk9559 Год назад

      they both came back (tina a few times) and performed poorly. Tina showed in s27 specifically she wasn't suited to modern survivor

    • @idkwhatsgoingon4584
      @idkwhatsgoingon4584 Месяц назад

      ​@@dennismonk9559 both of the came back as the only winner on their starting tribe, and had the biggest target on their back, and didn't have idols or anything, so they had no chance.

    • @dennismonk9559
      @dennismonk9559 Месяц назад

      ​@@idkwhatsgoingon4584 sure that was true for Tina in survivor all stars but it certainly wasn't true in season 27, she was carried because she wasn't a threat, no cared about her past. she didn't play well. ANd Hatch got past that point in all stars, he just failed because he did the same thing he did in 1 and didn't adjust at all.

    • @idkwhatsgoingon4584
      @idkwhatsgoingon4584 Месяц назад

      @@dennismonk9559 I was talking about All Star's, which is why I also mentioned Hatch

  • @ethancostellostudent1698
    @ethancostellostudent1698 4 года назад +4

    I agree with most of this other than Sandras placement. Sure she didn’t play a flashy game but you can’t deny her skill

  • @abihayes8587
    @abihayes8587 4 года назад +6

    wow leaving sandra off of this list is wild to me. her first two games do involve plenty of luck, but every single survivor game involves a certain degree of luck. people are so quick to underrate utr players despite the fact that it’s one of the most effective survivor strategies.
    she obviously has flaws, but i just fundamentally disagree with the idea that more control = a better game

    • @spammail06
      @spammail06 4 года назад +1

      They all need some amount of luck based on the things they can't control like the tribe swaps, twists, weather, injuries and all that. With that being the case every single thing you don't control then also becomes even more luck you need. That means that you don't get credit for it. It just happened out of your control. On the flip side, if something happens because you controlled it then you do get credit for it. You made that happen. Sandra's wins were like 90% out of her control which is crazy. I don't see how anything like that can ever happen again and I hope it doesn't.

  • @justinallen925
    @justinallen925 4 года назад +6

    I made my top 50 recently:
    1. Kim
    2. Boston Rob
    3. Parv
    4. Tony
    5. Jeremy
    6. Sandra
    7. Cirie
    8. Russell H.
    9. Yul
    10. Sarah
    11. Tom
    12. Tyson
    13. Cochran
    14. Earl
    15. Todd
    16. Hatch
    17. Brian H.
    18. Rob C.
    19. JT
    20. Wendell
    21. Dom
    22. Wentworth
    23. Natalie Anderson
    24. Danni
    25. Ethan
    26. Tina
    27. Tommy
    28. Denise
    29. Nick
    30. Aubry
    31. Amanda
    32. Adam
    33. David
    34. Chris D.
    35. Fairplay
    36. Yau-man
    37. Malcolm
    38. Spencer
    39. Mike Holloway
    40. Fichbach
    41. Sophie
    42. Lauren B.
    43. Devens
    44. Rafe
    45. Michele
    46. Aras
    47. Natalie White
    48. Amber
    49. Vecepia
    50. Ben

    • @marcosortega3350
      @marcosortega3350 4 года назад

      Did you actually put Jeremy above Sandra?!

    • @shanekilmartin9771
      @shanekilmartin9771 4 года назад

      Sandra is so overrated and natalie white would be in my bottom 50 players lol

    • @kinge3508
      @kinge3508 4 года назад

      Rick Devens made the list so I agree

    • @maryjasper3369
      @maryjasper3369 4 года назад

      @@shanekilmartin9771 hi russell!

    • @shanekilmartin9771
      @shanekilmartin9771 4 года назад

      @@maryjasper3369 its true

  • @MoneyPlaysEveryDay
    @MoneyPlaysEveryDay 4 года назад +2

    Yessss I was waiting!!!

    • @officialthreegang
      @officialthreegang 4 года назад

      welp, I tried delaying it.

    • @user-zm7sy3bu1k
      @user-zm7sy3bu1k 4 года назад

      yeah we know, you were being so annoying about it

    • @officialthreegang
      @officialthreegang 4 года назад

      @@user-zm7sy3bu1k Awwwww, how sweet. The Neiman Channel got his mommy to insult me, how pathetic!

    • @user-zm7sy3bu1k
      @user-zm7sy3bu1k 4 года назад

      @@officialthreegang no i wasnt replying to you i was replying to the neiman channel lol

    • @officialthreegang
      @officialthreegang 4 года назад

      @@user-zm7sy3bu1k woops, sorry I thought you were one of his minions LOL.

  • @savantfnbr5014
    @savantfnbr5014 3 года назад +3

    Tony's first game is the only game Ive ever watched lol, then I looked up best players and was like, I saw a good season lol.

  • @bennymcshea2448
    @bennymcshea2448 4 года назад +39

    this list is cap

    • @marcosortega3350
      @marcosortega3350 3 года назад

      Except for SANDRA NOT BEING ON THE LIST!

    • @user-yi9hz3or2t
      @user-yi9hz3or2t 3 года назад

      @@marcosortega3350 shes the worst winner ever idk how she won twice

  • @Smokey-25
    @Smokey-25 4 года назад

    A good video idea is ranking all jury speeches might take a while but it will be a good watch

  • @bradymosberger6271
    @bradymosberger6271 4 года назад

    amazing list

  • @tyreeneshane.
    @tyreeneshane. 4 года назад +23

    Lmao, Parvati is definitely above Sarah. And Tommy at 8? Already? That season happened like last year, has that really cemented him as a top 10 player OF ALL TIME?
    Also, I love Jerri Manthey sksksk

    • @parkzy2920
      @parkzy2920 4 года назад +4

      Tommy really didn't have any faults except not predicting Dan would go overboard with touching at final 6 if you can even fault him for that.

    • @jaredfreeley8283
      @jaredfreeley8283 3 года назад

      It’s based on how good they are at the game not their place in survivor history so the fact that he played once doesn’t rly matter

    • @tyreeneshane.
      @tyreeneshane. 3 года назад

      @@jaredfreeley8283 Gege

    • @jaredfreeley8283
      @jaredfreeley8283 3 года назад

      @@tyreeneshane. ?

    • @lorettahoffman2751
      @lorettahoffman2751 2 года назад

      Yea the Tommy fans perplex me. If coasting by and taking zero risks is top notch game playing then the goats that get drug to the end are the best players ever

  • @aidanmillow566
    @aidanmillow566 3 года назад +3

    I think it's hilarious the difference in BLM's portrayal of Sandra and JT's give away and idol move. The former is "A completely dumb move, one of the worst moves done by a winner" and the later "inherently isn't a bad move, there is some merit to it, it just doesn't work out for him." I would argue that both are bad moves but JT's is way worse. Sandra gives an idol (that was about to expire) to a player she knows is at the bottom in exchange for fire tokens hoping to get loyalty, tokens and eliminate a threat at the risk of being vulnerable at that tribal. It blows up on her because Denise a) had an idol already and b) thought taking out Sandra was better for her game than either of the guys (if either of those things doesn't hold then the move would probably work out). JT gives an idol to someone whose he has no knowledge of under the assumption that he's at the bottom hoping to get loyalty (from someone who was cast as a villain) and eliminate a threat at the risk of someone else having an idol and him not. It blows up on him later because he completely misread the situation on the other tribe. Ultimately JT was giving up more with less information than Sandra.

    • @bigbuffguy9589
      @bigbuffguy9589 2 года назад +1

      Yeah, Sandra didn't account for Denise making a boneheaded move and voting out the one person who wanted to work with her. Denise doesn't get enough heat for her stupidity on this move. Sandra still shouldn't have taken that risk, but it wasn't _that_ bad. I would argue that Parvati hiding her idol from Russell was infinitely more stupid, as there was no reason to do it other than to satisfy her ego, and it led directly to Russell voting out Danielle and losing Parvati the game.

  • @punkrockcharts9148
    @punkrockcharts9148 Год назад

    Awesome list. 1, 2 & 3 are all bang on the money. I'd probably swap 4 & 5 but it's close. I'd also switch 6 & 7. Sandra outside top 10 is also correct.

  • @IggyUKoopa
    @IggyUKoopa 4 года назад +10

    A lot of people are mad that Tommy is in the top 10 above Ear, Yul, and Tom lol I personally think you nailed it.

  • @spammail06
    @spammail06 4 года назад +3

    I just binge watched Fiji this week and Earl was one of the best winners of all time. The dude played great strategy and had control throughout the game. He played great socially and was liked. He read people well and made a good tight alliance that he kept until the end. He never had a vote against him. He was the first unanimous winner. Fiji is definitely not one of my favorite seasons, but Earl deserves all the credit in the world for a great game.

    • @TheKicksBoy
      @TheKicksBoy 4 года назад

      THIS

    • @kennethreichelt
      @kennethreichelt 4 года назад

      I just binged it too. He's horrible. What you said about control and alliance was right, but he's incredibly bad at all challenges. Dreamz would have easily won if he didn't accept the truck from Yau. And Yau would have wasted both players if he would have got in. He's lucky, smart, and good guy, nothing else.

    • @spammail06
      @spammail06 4 года назад

      @@kennethreichelt The control and alliance part is the core of any good strategy whether its Parv or Boston Rob or Kim or Tony. Also Earl's final tribal performance was great. The only thing Earl was bad at was challenges. He was good at everything else. Yao was the top player that season, but when Dreamz provided the opportunity, Earl took it and voted Yao out in a way he could explain away.

  • @topsportshorts2906
    @topsportshorts2906 3 года назад +14

    What about Spencer??? He played from the bottom the whole game, and he was up against Tony's alliance. Spencer deserves to be here. He even started the "new school" gameplay. Parvati is #1, but it was close

    • @TheMurrmursonbottle
      @TheMurrmursonbottle 3 года назад +3

      Definitely not at all. Spencer is good i’m Cagayan but not great, Tasha ended up being a bigger threat than him throughout the merge and it’s only by the grace of Tony that he survives as long as he did, not his own social or strategic game. He also ends up being a zero vote finalist in cambodia because of his arrogant personality and was inferior to Jeremy in every aspect of the game

    • @raheemfielder-bey998
      @raheemfielder-bey998 3 года назад

      Spencer can’t win a jury vote on most seasons. The only reason he would have won Cagayan was because his tribe came in with the numbers. And the opposition was filled with people who pissed them off like Tony, kass and woo. By voting out abi over Kelly Spencer actively threw away one of his goats lost his own winning F3 senerio.

    • @noahtawil8793
      @noahtawil8793 3 года назад

      @@TheMurrmursonbottle lmao what are you talking about, he was the second best player in Cagayan and only didn’t go further because of how easily tony manipulated everyone in that game, and in Cambodia he had a really underrated game and he got screwed over by everyone just liking Jeremy more

    • @TheMurrmursonbottle
      @TheMurrmursonbottle 3 года назад +1

      @@noahtawil8793 It wasn’t just that they liked Jeremy more, they actively disliked Spencer. Rewatch the Cambodia FTC and you’ll see multiple jurors (Savage, Kimmi come to mind) criticize Spencer for his behavior. The only reason he didn’t come across that way in Cagayan is because he was betrayed by Kass (another fault in his game - his petulant relationship with Kass, and being unable to keep her as an ally which led to him being on the bottom for so long) so he was an underdog. Spencer literally got outplayed by TRISH at the merge, who swayed Kass to her side when he was initially in the majority. He’s not that strong.

    • @jesuisencoler
      @jesuisencoler 2 года назад

      @@TheMurrmursonbottle Spencer should at least be mentioned on honorable mentions. Wendell was mentioned and not Spencer, it hurts

  • @martianfromjupiter3
    @martianfromjupiter3 4 года назад

    I hope you make a non-winners version too :D

  • @seancampbell8793
    @seancampbell8793 4 года назад

    Did you consider Yau Man or any players from Australian Survivor?

    • @SurvivorBoy-qe1of
      @SurvivorBoy-qe1of 4 года назад +2

      He was only ranking players from US Survivor he did an Australian survivor rankings last month.

  • @ryanbrady9309
    @ryanbrady9309 4 года назад +3

    *me before watching the video*: cirie better be on the list

  • @brazilianpanda4691
    @brazilianpanda4691 4 года назад +11

    Honorable Mentions:
    Richard Hatch- Survivor: Borneo and Survivor: All-Stars
    Tina Wesson- Survivor: The Australian Outback, Survivor: All-Stars, and Survivor: Blood vs Water
    Brian Heidk- Survivor: Thailand
    Rob Cesternino- Survivor: The Amazon and Survivor: All-Stars
    Sandra Diaz-Twine- Survivor: Pearl Islands, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, Survivor: Game Changers, and Survivor: Winners at War
    Jonny Fairplay- Survivor: Pearl Islands and Survivor: Micronesia
    Chris Daugherty- Survivor: Vanuatu
    Tom Westman- Survivor: Palau and Survivor: Heroes vs Villains
    Yul Kwon- Survivor: Cook Islands and Survivor: Winners at War
    Todd Herzog- Survivor: China
    Amanda Kimmel- Survivor: China, Survivor: Micronesia, and Survivor: Heroes vs Villains
    JT Thomas- Survivor: Tocantins, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, and Survivor: Game Changers
    Tyson Apostol- Survivor: Tocantins, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, Survivor: Blood vs Water, and Survivor: Winners at War
    Russel Hantz- Survivor: Samoa, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, and Survivor: Redemption Island, and Australian Survivor: Champions vs Contenders
    John Cochran- Survivor: South Pacific and Survivor: Caramoan
    Denise Stapley- Survivor: Philippines and Survivor: Winners at War
    Malcolm Freberg- Survivor: Philippines, Survivor: Caramoan, and Survivor: Game Changers
    Natalie Anderson- Survivor: San Juan del Sur and Survivor: Winners at War
    Michelle Fitzgerald- Survivor: Kaoh Rong and Survivor: Winners at War
    Aubry Bracco- Survivor: Koah Rong, Survivor: Game Changers, and Survivor: Edge of Extinction
    Wendell Holland- Survivor: Ghost Island and Survivor: Winners at War
    Domenick Abbate- Survivor: Ghost Island
    Nick Wilson- Survivor: David vs Goliath and Survivor: Winners at War
    Top Ten:
    #10- Sophie Clarke- Survivor: South Pacific and Survivor: Winners at War
    #9- Earl Cole- Survivor: Fiji
    #8- Tommy Sheehan-Survivor: Island of the Idols
    #7- Rob Mariano- Survivor: Marquesas, Survivor: All-Stars, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, Survivor: Redemption Island, and Survivor: Winners at War
    #6- Jeremy Collins- Survivor: San Juan del Sur, Survivor: Cambodia, and Survivor: Winners at War
    #5- Ciries Fields- Survivor: Panama, Survivor: Micronesia, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, and Survivor: Game Changers
    #4- Parvati Shallow- Survivor: Cook Islands, Survivor: Micronesia, Survivor: Heroes vs Villains, and Survivor: Winners at War
    #3- Sarah Lacina- Survivor: Cagayan, Survivor: Game Changers, and Survivor: Winners at War
    #2- Kim Spradlin- Survivor: One World and Survivor: Winners at War
    #1- Tony Vlachos- Survivor: Cagayan, Survivor: Game Changers, and Survivor: Winners at War
    (Why is Jerri not even an Honorable Mention?????)

    • @brazilianpanda4691
      @brazilianpanda4691 4 года назад

      Jairo Garcia ok thank you I’ll add that

    • @bossjenkins5875
      @bossjenkins5875 5 месяцев назад

      Jerri sucks she was a pawn every time bro 😭 she had control a lil bit in Australia but her ego cause her Allies to turn on her to

  • @grantgoffin4774
    @grantgoffin4774 7 месяцев назад +1

    My top 10:
    1. Tony
    2. Sandra
    3. Sarah
    4. Kim
    5. Parvati
    6. Earl
    7. Tom Westman
    8. Cirie
    9. Jeremy
    10. Natalie A

  • @kristoffer5988
    @kristoffer5988 4 года назад

    In the video you Said candace and Amanda had personal vendettas against parvati but they seemed to be quite close on earlier seasons. Why is that?

  • @MA-hb3le
    @MA-hb3le 4 года назад +6

    My top four Tony, Boston Rob, Kim Spradlin, Cirrie

    • @gqprince2
      @gqprince2 3 года назад +2

      Parvati gotta be in that 2

  • @roopeshgudepu4278
    @roopeshgudepu4278 3 года назад +4

    Jeremy played an excellent game

  • @michaelbuell3711
    @michaelbuell3711 Месяц назад +1

    Sandra's Game changers appearance is why I think she has to be top 10, she dominated even though everyone knows she was a huge threat! Swap screwed, she proves that if you just bring her to the end her jury performance can win her any game. Her winners at war performance seemed as though she didn't want to be there on probably the most competitive season ever so she obviously was one of if not the worst player that season. I have her at 4, behind Boston Rob, Kim and Tony, (Sarah 5).
    Also Cirie, I love her but she's never won, she can't be in the top 10, let alone at 5!!! Crazy

  • @sinspeed7345
    @sinspeed7345 4 года назад +2

    TheMernianReview: *Makes a subjective top 10 survivor list*
    Comments: *It's complaining time.*

  • @blyrellblashington1835
    @blyrellblashington1835 4 года назад +10

    i would honestly put yul in the top five. his social game in cook islands was one of the most dominant social games of all time with jury management to match. if it weren’t for ozzy being such a physical dominance, yul would’ve swept the jury.

  • @Sweetg1996
    @Sweetg1996 4 года назад +43

    Earl is infinitely better than Tommy omggggg this list is whack

    • @tdt8854
      @tdt8854 4 года назад +5

      Sweetg1996 well we’ve never seen Earl play when everything is against him while at the Final 11/10 of IoI Tommy was able survive against all odds

    • @Sweetg1996
      @Sweetg1996 4 года назад +1

      Total Drama Turtle if it isn’t for Deans coin flip Tommy goes to the end with Janet who he definitely loses to! He also would’ve lost to Lauren, Elaine, Missy...

    • @victorgant5086
      @victorgant5086 4 года назад +1

      @@Sweetg1996 There is no way that Missy would've beat Tommy.

    • @Sweetg1996
      @Sweetg1996 4 года назад

      Victor Gant multiple post game interviews show that she was a huge jury threat and was playing hard. She 100% beats Tommy who needed to sit next to Dean, Noura or Karishma specifically to win.

    • @victorgant5086
      @victorgant5086 4 года назад +2

      @@Sweetg1996 That sounds really hard to believe. I don't remember Missy doing anything worthy of the win. Then again, my memory could be false.

  • @savageguineapig5857
    @savageguineapig5857 4 года назад +1

    Can you do the top 10 worst moves of all time for survivor us please? Thanks!

  • @Spudder452
    @Spudder452 4 года назад +1

    I think Sandra deserves some more credit. Her mistake on WAW is actually kind of unfair and here is why: tokens were not explained at all to the players. They had no idea how powerful they were going to end up being. All Sandra knew was that 1 token = 1 idol because thats what she payed for. Using that logic, not having one was a huge disadvantage so the move she made to get 2 was a decent. Its not her fault she didn’t know that they were completely worthless towards the end. Also, Denise just happend to be one of the players that wanted her out as soon as possible. Maybe her first two wins had some luck to it, but so did her two boots.

  • @jessehartmann2634
    @jessehartmann2634 4 года назад +5

    Confused on why it's a hole in parvati's game that she came in as a threat and made it to the end in 2 of those seasons...

    • @thesolesurvivor35
      @thesolesurvivor35 3 года назад

      She wasn’t rlly a ‘threat’ in Micronesia people just wanted her out off the bat because she’s flirtatious but yea in HvV it shouldn’t be a knock

    • @ilovetolurkaround
      @ilovetolurkaround 3 года назад

      @@thesolesurvivor35 She was clearly a threat in Micronesia- Day 1 people want her out. They're itching to take her out, you wont itch to vote out someone just coz they're flirt. Penner added up a target coz he can read through Parv

    • @thesolesurvivor35
      @thesolesurvivor35 3 года назад

      @@ilovetolurkaround theres a difference between being targeted for being a threat off the bat, and being targeted quickly because you had some social missteps. In HvV, yeah she was targeted quickly for being a threat. In Micronesia I really don't think so.

    • @softbleach487
      @softbleach487 3 года назад

      Doesn't make sense how he puts her at #4 yet all he does is basically explain that she's overrated

  • @user-vc8ow6kn9k
    @user-vc8ow6kn9k 4 года назад +4

    14:42 I'm picking up star wars Rey vibes from those clothes and stature. Just Me?

  • @martimgoncalves6723
    @martimgoncalves6723 4 года назад

    Hi can u do a video that u talk of what game changers cast did for be in that season?

  • @joejoejoeil3165
    @joejoejoeil3165 3 года назад +1

    I think Adam should’ve been an honorable mention at the least, but hey your list, your opinions, your philosophy on the game.

  • @patrickcallahan9206
    @patrickcallahan9206 4 года назад +6

    what about ANDREA or WENTWORTH?

  • @brendanfechter4889
    @brendanfechter4889 4 года назад +4

    Dude... JT didn't even have the idol in his pocket it was AT CAMP 😂

  • @dillonriedmiller8306
    @dillonriedmiller8306 4 года назад +8

    Spencer Bledsoe doesn’t only deserve an HM but should be in the top 10. His Cagayan performance was one of the best non winning games of all time plus he made it to the final tribal against one of the best casts of all time.

    • @Claaarize
      @Claaarize 4 года назад

      I was rooting for him the whole time the first time I watched Cagayan. It took a second watch before I got to appreciate the GOAT that is Tony.

    • @bc1173
      @bc1173 4 года назад +2

      his cagayan performance wasnt anywhere near one of the best non winning games of all time.

    • @dillonriedmiller8306
      @dillonriedmiller8306 4 года назад

      Bruce Crawford he played the underdog role like a champ always convincing Tony to target people in his own alliance. The fact that he made it to the final 4 when he was down in numbers basically the whole game is incredible and shows how good of a player he is.

    • @bc1173
      @bc1173 4 года назад +1

      Dillon Riedmiller show me the video where tony admits that Spencer was manipulate his vote the entire game, I’ll wait.

  • @zxch251
    @zxch251 2 года назад +2

    mike holloway? this guy had a 6v1 in the top 7 and still won

  • @patdriscoll
    @patdriscoll 4 года назад +12

    No honorable mentions for Spencer Bledsoe (highest average placement of multi-time players) or Vecepia Towery (one of the best from-the-bottom wins in Survivor history)?

    • @freakyfridays135
      @freakyfridays135 4 года назад +4

      Not higher than Michele

    • @stayinalive92
      @stayinalive92 4 года назад +1

      Michele has the highest average placement for a multi-time player.

    • @patdriscoll
      @patdriscoll 4 года назад

      @@freakyfridays135 This is true. I was thinking pre-WAW.

    • @rambo8550
      @rambo8550 4 года назад

      ​@@stayinalive92 @Driscoll Productions You're both wrong, it's Natalie. 1st and 2nd.

    • @stayinalive92
      @stayinalive92 4 года назад

      Will Rambo Sure, I didn’t count her because she did basically get voted off first, but final placement matters the most so she qualifies (with an asterisk imo).

  • @gabihunter1749
    @gabihunter1749 4 года назад +31

    I think with your honorable mentions you mostly just listed dominant winners that only played once or twice

  • @colinduncan9041
    @colinduncan9041 4 года назад +1

    You should do a list of the top 10 most dominant games

    • @kingklub
      @kingklub 4 года назад

      That’s basically the winner rankings

  • @ShroobInvader
    @ShroobInvader 4 года назад +1

    YESSSSSS

  • @sheikhnjie2245
    @sheikhnjie2245 4 года назад +3

    From the merge in Micro Parv was 100% in the final

  • @liamduffy4589
    @liamduffy4589 4 года назад +20

    No Wentworth in honorable mentions?

    • @fatseal9999
      @fatseal9999 4 года назад +5

      Liam Duffy I think Wentworth isn’t here because she was voted out pre merge once, she was voted out with an idol, and she’s hasn’t controlled much

    • @kyjo0011
      @kyjo0011 4 года назад +5

      EeveeFan rob was voted out pre merge twice

    • @fatseal9999
      @fatseal9999 4 года назад +4

      Comanderr But his RI and all stars games were amazing. The pros outweigh they cons

    • @fatseal9999
      @fatseal9999 4 года назад +6

      I will say she’s one of the best players to play from the bottom though

    • @emmanuelnwade2873
      @emmanuelnwade2873 4 года назад +2

      In my opinion, Wentworth's Cambodia game lacks influence over how the game goes. She was always reacting to things instead of being proactive due to the lack of strong bonds. Her EoE is her strongest game because she had a lot of influence on Manu and Lesu. She lost control at the beginning but was able to get some Kama members on her side to get out David. Despite it probably being the wrong move, she had influence.

  • @MvpNew
    @MvpNew 4 года назад

    Great video as usual...
    I guessed that you was going to say Earl and Tommy at Number 9 & 8, when you were talking about them as players.

  • @nh979
    @nh979 3 года назад +1

    As someone who met Wendell at the premiere party he held for WaW and thought "Goddamn this guy is cocky", well before we got the cocky Wendell edit, I'm very happy someone else is finally commenting on it

  • @brenchengbrencheng4794
    @brenchengbrencheng4794 4 года назад +22

    Sophie has always been an all time great in challenges involving solving puzzles from the very beginning, not just during the 2nd time playing. She isnt just a strong physical player back then and because of her quick response mindset towards solving puzzles at the final Immunity Challenge in South Pacific against Ozzy, she basically paved her to win the game and earned the way to the final 3.

    • @lorettahoffman2751
      @lorettahoffman2751 2 года назад +3

      Coach dominated that season and carried Sophia to the end. Sophie did what so many winners to float through the game letting everyone else take all the risks then make one move at the end of the game and call her game a social game with one big move. Her social game was staying loyal to coach that's it

    • @wills3210
      @wills3210 Год назад +1

      Also in Winners at War on the coconut challenge she placed second in front of other huge physical threats like Wendell, Tyson, Danni, and Parvati

    • @itzwakk335
      @itzwakk335 10 месяцев назад

      this is the truth, albert and sophie tried to take credit for it afterwards but coach is the main reason the upolu allaince was succesful@@lorettahoffman2751

    • @trololololol1111
      @trololololol1111 9 месяцев назад

      Stop patronizing a talking dishwasher. You'll puff up her ego and she'll try to leave the kitchen.

    • @itzwakk335
      @itzwakk335 9 месяцев назад

      ?@@trololololol1111

  • @mindovermatterbecomingyour1561
    @mindovermatterbecomingyour1561 4 года назад +3

    Watch cirie come back 4 legends & FINALLY win notice that during advantagegeddon NOT A SINGLE VOTE HAD HER NAME ON IT that was the final 6 & by that time cirie had LONG since established herself as a legend & a massive threat 2 watch out 4 yet EVERYBODY was going 2 let her get 2 the final 5 also notice how she handled that loss she took it on the chin w/ a smile on her face & found the silver lining of the situation that's a classy lady rite there

  • @majorzally24
    @majorzally24 Год назад

    I’m so happy that Sandra isn’t on your top 10! I fully agree

  • @alinsofan501
    @alinsofan501 4 года назад +1

    Respect and kudos to everyone. Forever favourite players Boston Rob & Kim Spradlin.