Why Donald Trump’s Plan To Take Over Gaza Is “A Truly Radical Idea”

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025
  • I spoke to Richard Haass, an American diplomat who was president of the Council on Foreign Relations from July 2003 to June 2023, prior to which he was director of policy planning for the United States Department of State and a close advisor to Secretary of State Colin Powell in the George W. Bush administration. We spoke about Donald Trump’s plan to take over Gaza, how other Middle Eastern countries might react, what guard rails could prevent him from doing this, and how it is a costly reminder that when you vote for a candidate you often get more than you bargained for.
    Sign up here for daily email updates from me, Katie Couric, on the news that matters most to you:
    katiecouric.co...
    Subscribe to my channel: / katiecouric
    Follow me on Instagram: / katiecouric
    Subscribe to my podcast: ApplePodcasts.com/KatieCouric
    Follow me on Facebook: / katiecouric
    Follow me on Twitter: / katiecouric

Комментарии • 701

  • @joeledj
    @joeledj 5 дней назад +230

    "Radical" is such a polite way of saying absolutley batshit insane & dangerous.

    • @bikeymikey748
      @bikeymikey748 5 дней назад +6

      Boom!

    • @leviashanken7281
      @leviashanken7281 5 дней назад +1

      Diplomatic, exactly as he said.

    • @isobelmcbride46
      @isobelmcbride46 5 дней назад

      It's demure white woman speak for "imperialist and inhumane"

    • @leviashanken7281
      @leviashanken7281 5 дней назад +1

      @@joeledj almost everything becomes an understatement during crises. Why even bother trying to articulate the overwhelming?

    • @conniejohnsoncj8724
      @conniejohnsoncj8724 5 дней назад +4

      How the hell is this even happening? If this is democracy, no thank you!

  • @alibulle6251
    @alibulle6251 5 дней назад +78

    Gaza had 2.2M .Now 1.8m.What happened to 400 000 Gazans. ? Murdered?

  • @PeaceFan1
    @PeaceFan1 5 дней назад +168

    It is an INSANE Idea, Just RIDICULOUS!!! And HOW do the Palestinian People Feel about this???!!!! WTF!!!!

    • @garyeberle62
      @garyeberle62 5 дней назад

      Scarier, how does Hamas Hezbollah & Isis feel. WW3 will take 76 mins for our beautiful Mother Earth to be destroyed. That’s on Trump and his supporters. And it’s on Netanyahu. He’s trouble for years now. Used to be good. Now he’s just well another Felon 47 double.

    • @iridefast1
      @iridefast1 5 дней назад +1

      Since 160,000 already live in America 🇺🇸 it makes sense to relocate to a place with jobs,nice homes and safety.

    • @gamma-rayburst4611
      @gamma-rayburst4611 5 дней назад +11

      ​@@iridefast1so your saying Israel is and has been terrorizing Palestine

    • @demejiuk5660
      @demejiuk5660 5 дней назад +6

      @@iridefast1 And if I say it makes sense for me to own your home....? As in wtf difference does your opinion that "it makes sense" make when discussing other people's sovreignty?

    • @demejiuk5660
      @demejiuk5660 5 дней назад +2

      @@iridefast1 Trump thinks it makes sense that Canada belongs to the US. You've seen what the Canadians think of that right?

  • @cats10999
    @cats10999 5 дней назад +158

    Radical? How about INSANE?

    • @CarolynsRVLife
      @CarolynsRVLife 5 дней назад +7

      I came here to say the exact same thing!!!

    • @stephenr6913
      @stephenr6913 5 дней назад +9

      How about criminal?

    • @wandameadows5736
      @wandameadows5736 5 дней назад

      If people will take off there EMOTIONAL HATS for a second & think about what Trump's proposing you will realize it's not crazy & its really just a different type of solution. If your OK with taking in Immigrants from Gaza & having them build a life in America or any Western Country then why not help them build a Life in Gaza? What Trump is proposing is is an actual solution to the issues in GAZA & building a real society & economy for Gazans while having an investment as well. America already sends Millions if not Billions to Gaza for Aid but it's obviously not going to make Gaza better just to throw cash at an issue. The UN has had all kinds of influence in Gaza & they've done NOTHING to solve this issue. America Investing in Gaza should be welcomed by Gazan Citizens & if they don't want it then so be it but they need to be the people that decide. There's also the fact that when you want help it has stipulations. People playing Politics with Gaza needs to stop & think about what's really best for these people. My question is why isnt neighboring Nations offering this kind of transformation of Gaza? Also if you want Gaza & Palestinians in General to be recognized there's no better way to do it than let America help rebuild & create a functioning Economy & stable Society. No one is talking about removing or transforming anyone's Culture although id imagine it might change a little naturally & citizens would welcome the change. If your really about helping Immigrants from these unstable countries then you should be in favor of helping them solve the issues in there own country. Now Gaza is unique because its small & something like this would be hard in bigger countries with functioning Governments & Societies. If you really want the conflicts to end & people in that region to live in relative peace you have to create a better situation & make partnerships.

    • @nisahmed9121
      @nisahmed9121 4 дня назад +2

      Gigi & Bella Hadid father said when Jews were oppressed in Europe and their ship was denied entrance to UK, USA they head to Palestine. Palestinians open their hearts & homes to those refugees! His father took 2 families into his home for 2 years. When Haddid pregnant mother was about to deliver him, she went to his grandparents house. When she returned home her guests took over her house and wouldn't let her in. Palestinians then became the refugees in their own country !!!

    • @nisahmed9121
      @nisahmed9121 4 дня назад +2

      They’re originally Polish, Ukrainians, Russians, Americans, British, but the Palestinians are the ones who should move?!!

  • @kayecastleman6353
    @kayecastleman6353 5 дней назад +86

    Yeah, displacing the residents of the area to turn it into waterfront resorts is a typical Donald idea. The man has dollar signs where his heart and brain should be.

    • @kathleentrinity7367
      @kathleentrinity7367 5 дней назад +2

      Well said!

    • @nisahmed9121
      @nisahmed9121 4 дня назад +3

      Gigi & Bella Hadid father said when Jews were oppressed in Europe and their ship was denied entrance to UK, USA they head to Palestine. Palestinians open their hearts & homes to those refugees! His father took 2 families into his home for 2 years. When Haddid pregnant mother was about to deliver him, she went to his grandparents house. When she returned home her guests took over her house and wouldn't let her in. Palestinians then became the refugees in their own country !!!

  • @mybrkly
    @mybrkly 5 дней назад +298

    Please do better. Normalizing this as a radical idea is not acceptable as a teaser headline. This is illegal, dangerous, and insane.

    • @mrhammondb3
      @mrhammondb3 5 дней назад +25

      Very illegal and I’m surprised Katie even entertaining this sociopath chaotic issues.

    • @dwoodwoo65
      @dwoodwoo65 5 дней назад

      “Hitler has radical idea of invading Poland”

    • @dr.victoriadisclafani739
      @dr.victoriadisclafani739 5 дней назад +10

      Yes, your 'leader' is confusing and frankly deceptive. Constructed to draw in maximum viewers but very dishonest. Get some dignity Katie!

    • @c.l.montoya2972
      @c.l.montoya2972 5 дней назад

      @mybrkly
      “A truly radical idea” is quoting Richard Haas in the opening. He does go on iterating the dangerous nature of trump’s “solution” to the longstanding conflict in Gaza. I don’t believe the intention is to “normalize”, trump and his cohorts in crime by not stating, the obvious fact for those who know The Constitution, everything
      trump & musk have done, in these long two weeks, IS ILLEGAL. Many times situations are normalized by overstating key words repeatedly across media. I think we all need to “do better” at understanding our role, as motivated citizens, and get busy protecting our Democracy. We the people as a whole, have the power; let’s not piss it away by wasting energy on sidebar distractions.

    • @nayaab5980
      @nayaab5980 5 дней назад +14

      Thank you for saying it.
      I felt the same, like they are in somehow normalozing it.

  • @SybilStephens-o3i
    @SybilStephens-o3i 5 дней назад +40

    You notice the reporters use 'polite' terms and normalise the insanity because they are already living in fear.

    • @Jim-pm6jk
      @Jim-pm6jk 4 дня назад

      True, which makes them complicit in the destruction of their own countrys democracy.

  • @wendyf2228
    @wendyf2228 5 дней назад +162

    All Americans need to get busy or you are going to lose your Country. 😢

    • @ailleananaithnid2566
      @ailleananaithnid2566 5 дней назад +11

      That ship has sailed. On November 5.
      This is making me so angry because I warned the people who told they couldn’t vote for Kamala because of Gaza. Because she was a “tool of Israel.” I kept reminding them that Trump was going to give Netanyahu everything he wants.
      I hope the people who refused to vote for the qualified candidate (Kamala) are happy. They were PLAYED by Trump.

    • @Lynn-i2w
      @Lynn-i2w 5 дней назад

      @@ailleananaithnid2566 you do not get that the ship sailed decades ago because of the Israeli lobby. Our foreign policy has been run by Zionists.

    • @misterguts
      @misterguts 5 дней назад

      @@ailleananaithnid2566 You are right ... Son-in-law Jarad said in an interview BEFORE the election , "Just bulldoze a spot in the Negev desert and move the Palestinians there, then develop Gaza as Mediterranean prime beach property." The Trumps never made any mystery out of it, I wonder why American Arabs would ever consider Trump.

    • @lindaflesch7303
      @lindaflesch7303 4 дня назад +3

      We have.

    • @1991jdclark
      @1991jdclark 4 дня назад

      ​@@lindaflesch7303you won't think that when it works against you.

  • @margiestroud919
    @margiestroud919 5 дней назад +176

    His greed is out of control. He and his children need to be STOPPED!!!!!

    • @mrhammondb3
      @mrhammondb3 5 дней назад +14

      FACTS!!!!💯💯 And he better stop these chaotic moves because it can end very bad in a extremely dangerous way.

    • @garyeberle62
      @garyeberle62 5 дней назад +11

      He’s never leaving, he thinks he’s King, which Unsupreme Court made him. Everyone’s for the green in his cabinet e all of congress. American people? Shure, never intended too.

    • @mrhammondb3
      @mrhammondb3 5 дней назад +8

      @ If congress enforce the 25th amendment he will have no choice but to exit.

    • @ronitknight3078
      @ronitknight3078 5 дней назад +4

      Permanently.

    • @iridefast1
      @iridefast1 5 дней назад +1

      How bad to think Palestinians would like a home,job and the safety Trump is offering.

  • @lornaduncan5273
    @lornaduncan5273 5 дней назад +57

    America should clean up their backyard before threatening people who has been through so much for so long. Use the money to help the homeless who seem to be getting in greater numbers under this administration.

    • @scottsammons7747
      @scottsammons7747 4 дня назад

      The best that he can do is to deport the homeless.

    • @nisahmed9121
      @nisahmed9121 4 дня назад +2

      They’re originally Polish, Ukrainians, Russians, Americans, British, but the Palestinians are the ones who should move?!!

  • @gabrielaperaza9156
    @gabrielaperaza9156 5 дней назад +39

    The greed of his son in law has no limits, this two men are evil they have no regard for human life or anyone, that statement is very dangerous this could have nasty effect on the peace of the region.

  • @aeshareif
    @aeshareif 5 дней назад +46

    By "Radical idea" you literally mean Ethnic cleansing !

  • @simpleconcepts5110
    @simpleconcepts5110 5 дней назад +71

    This is illegal..The fact that people try to rationalize is pure evil.

    • @phil3924
      @phil3924 5 дней назад

      Illegal? International law doesn’t exist

  • @Beowulf-l6b
    @Beowulf-l6b 5 дней назад +74

    You are ignoring the elephant in the room: ILLEGAL OCCUPATION!!!

    • @kathleentrinity7367
      @kathleentrinity7367 5 дней назад +2

      100% Agree!

    • @joshallen4502
      @joshallen4502 5 дней назад

      The same Maga fools who who called Bush a neo conservative occupying Iraq and spending too much money on wars are ok with Trump doing the same thing. It's beyond amazing how blind they are to their hypocrisy.

  • @jamesboucher1903
    @jamesboucher1903 5 дней назад +38

    get with the rest of us Katie the idea is insane

    • @leviashanken7281
      @leviashanken7281 5 дней назад +2

      She's doing her job as a professional journalist - asking leading questions in a measured way. Let the audience decide from the facts.

    • @nyohaku
      @nyohaku 4 дня назад

      @@leviashanken7281Now let’s hear from the other side.

    • @tonyrivers8688
      @tonyrivers8688 3 дня назад

      ​@@leviashanken7281Katie was very cute in the 90s

  • @chilli_bean_23
    @chilli_bean_23 5 дней назад +15

    Why should “responsible Palestinians” sign up to israel running Gaza? What about Palestinians running Gaza?

  • @angelamoordigian-to8gy
    @angelamoordigian-to8gy 5 дней назад +90

    Somebody needs to use the 25th amendment and get Trump out he will catastrophically destroy the United States

    • @mrhammondb3
      @mrhammondb3 5 дней назад +11

      I really think this is soon to come, because he is really out of control worst than when he was in office his last term.

    • @margiestroud919
      @margiestroud919 5 дней назад

      @@angelamoordigian-to8gy At once. He is an evil mad man.

    • @barbaravyse660
      @barbaravyse660 5 дней назад +9

      And take Vance with him. I’m sure he’s just as bad given the chance.

    • @nancyhooper9817
      @nancyhooper9817 5 дней назад

      @@barbaravyse660nothing was worse than Biden…..

    • @nilcarborundum7001
      @nilcarborundum7001 5 дней назад

      He will destroy a lot more than just the united states!! Don't you people care about the world at all?

  • @MNP208
    @MNP208 5 дней назад +69

    Is Trump’s mental health ok? His party needs to have him evaluated. 😳

    • @anthonybanchero3072
      @anthonybanchero3072 5 дней назад +1

      They are with him.

    • @LauraCasey-t9v
      @LauraCasey-t9v 5 дней назад +4

      They all need to be evaluated. They are a bunch of lemmings following him over a cliff. His party won’t evaluate a damn thing.

  • @mylist4039
    @mylist4039 4 дня назад +17

    I'm from Toronto, Canada. I went grocery shopping today. Every item and produce has now been labeled with the country of origin. Very few items on the shelves are from the US. People are checking carefully and buying non-US products and produce. The hurt of Canadians is running deep. The talk is that this is permanent. We are not going back. Permanent damage has been done with the insane Tariff war that was imposed by the US on Canada. Trust has been broken, and it will take a lot for the US to regain that trust.
    But having said all this, it is nothing compared to the grief and agony of the Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank. The people of Gaza have gone through hell. Tens of thousand are buried under that rubble and died a horrible slow death, deliberately inflicted by Israel. The US is fully complicit in this genocide. And this insane man wants to level it and build waterfront resorts? This is beyond insane. It is inhumane, illegal and evil. Call it for what it is!

    • @mv894
      @mv894 4 дня назад +1

      I'm American and I agree with you 100%.

    • @emailuser8668
      @emailuser8668 4 дня назад

      Good you coward! We'll make sure we block the 250,000 Canadians that commute daily to jobs and businesses in Washington, Michigan, New York from entering the U.S. Then they'll have to settle for being broke because of your political lunacy. Then there's the frozen food and processed foods that come from Canada that are sold in the U.S. as store/generic brands- those can go to the garbage now. Keep booing American NHL/NBA teams, good luck being lapdogs to the European Union. By the way, your medical professionals hate Health Canada so much they've been frequently calling hospitals and clinics in the U.S. to see if they can get jobs and just commute from Vancouver, BC; Windsor, ON; London, ON; Hamilton, ON.

    • @turnthepage867
      @turnthepage867 4 дня назад

      Arab voters in Michigan delivered the election to Trump. Take responsibility.

    • @emailuser8668
      @emailuser8668 4 дня назад

      @@mylist4039 There's been no genocide. If you believe the death statistics from the Hamas Minstry of Health you are a moron. They claim 40,000 Palestinians were killed in the war, but there are 2 million Palestinians in Gaza with over 300,000 Hamas soldiers. If there were mass casualties, it was the terrorist soldiers working for Hamas which had said it doesn't distinguish Hamas soldiers from civilians.

    • @Jim-pm6jk
      @Jim-pm6jk 4 дня назад +1

      And we know which family will have their hand in the till to take profit.

  • @kiwiyogi2846
    @kiwiyogi2846 4 дня назад +2

    When describing Gaza he forgot to mention the Nakba. Pretty obvious whose side he's on.

  • @mandygish6405
    @mandygish6405 5 дней назад +45

    Oh my goodness remember when we used to have a humanitarian heart

    • @wandameadows5736
      @wandameadows5736 5 дней назад +1

      This is MORE HUMANITARIAN than just throwing Money at a problem & the bad people getting it and building Armies like Hamas to keep conflict going. When you PARTNER up with a problem & invest directly in a solution you actually care more & are more likely to create stability. People that's against this idea are not actually thinking about Gaza.

    • @demejiuk5660
      @demejiuk5660 5 дней назад

      @@wandameadows5736 Here's an idea. Instead of throwing money at Israel to kill Palestinians and then throwing money at Palestinians so they can eat and rebuild their homes, how about just stop funding Israel and use your power to force them into a two state solution?

    • @lindaflesch7303
      @lindaflesch7303 4 дня назад

      Our government never had one, it's a facade.

    • @victoriaZimm62
      @victoriaZimm62 4 дня назад

      You're only half awake. That is a false memory they planted to make you idolise the US. The native Americans, Africans, African Americans, Japanese, basically every other nation on earth knows the US has never operated like a country led by humanitarian people.

  • @P.Galore
    @P.Galore 5 дней назад +36

    Trump needs to be removed by any means necessary. And the Puffy Muskrat too.

  • @ZZ-ek7mx
    @ZZ-ek7mx 4 дня назад +3

    Why not get a Gazan person on to discuss this?!

  • @LauraCasey-t9v
    @LauraCasey-t9v 5 дней назад +16

    If I were a Palestinian, I would be tremendously offended. Trump, stopping pretending you are a king. FAFO

  • @BloomByCC
    @BloomByCC 5 дней назад +21

    TRUMP WORKS FOR ME, FOR US, CONGRESS WORKS FOR US! Remember that and speak up every day. Call or email your Senator every day...

  • @MrDRS12
    @MrDRS12 4 дня назад +3

    Some people in Gaza were forced-transfered several times, for example, in 1948, 1967, 2023. And every time people start their life from zero under occupation and for the last 17 years living in open air prison. People are asking why October 7 happened. The West thinks the good Gazan is the one accepting all of this without resistance.

  • @carlkuss
    @carlkuss 5 дней назад +17

    Genocide is not fixed by putting a cherry on top. "Bad luck" is such an obtuse way, an ignorant way of describing the way that Israel has treated the Palestinian people. So sorry about your bad luck! That is so ignorant. Unworthy. Let us call things by their names. We are not addressing the injustices suffered by the Palestinian people. Tell the history. Lay aside religious fundamentalism of all types. Live together.

  • @daynacase8528
    @daynacase8528 5 дней назад +39

    Katie, thank you for the qualified insightful guests. This podcast is value-ad during these fluid news days.

    • @jockstrappery
      @jockstrappery 5 дней назад

      Insightful? Haas is as delusional as you.

    • @Lynn-i2w
      @Lynn-i2w 5 дней назад

      Why don’t you get guest that give the Palestinian point of view? These people are tired old Zionists and they have ruined American foreign policy.

  • @terrymckenzie857
    @terrymckenzie857 4 дня назад +2

    Gaza is not "lagging" on development when it comes to education. That tiny strip of land held 26 colleges and universities and 36 hospitals. All now bombed to rubble. The Palestinians are a ridiculously well-educated population. They have had to be to survive.

  • @FFP1948
    @FFP1948 5 дней назад +2

    Having the nerves to utter "relocating ethnic people" from their home land and not condemning it as "ethnic cleansing" shows how truely EVIL we are.

  • @nisahmed9121
    @nisahmed9121 4 дня назад +7

    They’re originally Polish, Ukrainians, Russians, Americans, British, but the Palestinians are the ones who should move?!!

    • @homebg2163
      @homebg2163 4 дня назад

      Palestinians are Saudi Arabian, Syrian and Egyptian . Jews are Judean.

  • @icedfullmoon1573
    @icedfullmoon1573 4 дня назад +4

    I can see his frustration & anger all over his face & in his movements. You are not alone. God bless. 🙏

  • @deselby6669
    @deselby6669 4 дня назад +1

    Ethnic cleansing and genocide is not radical its criminal..

  • @jennydrozd29
    @jennydrozd29 5 дней назад +16

    4 years of this and then the next administration will spend 4 years fixing it. It's going to be at least a decade before we get down to the real issues. #sigh

    • @bikeymikey748
      @bikeymikey748 5 дней назад

      After the current attacks/disrespect/threats recently levelled at us Canadians by tRUMP I believe no amount of time can ever repair the damage and betrayal he and his supporters have managed to inflict upon us. Admittedly, some of us will likely have short memories regarding this, but MANY of us now have no difficulty adjusting to our new reality of cutting ties with the US in any way we can on a permanent basis. It’s a shame really, tRUMP managed to destroy in a very short amount of time a relationship that took generations of hard work to create. The saddest part? Both Canadians and Americans come out of it the worse for it.

    • @EagleWolf2
      @EagleWolf2 5 дней назад

      Every four yrs, the naive like to believe that. But the knowing ones are well aware, I t will not happen.--- As long as the People feel the need to be ruled. There will always be the ones who glorify. Ruling over the working masses.

    • @robynjeucken3391
      @robynjeucken3391 5 дней назад +1

      4 years??? You're way more optimistic than me 🫤

    • @karenbourke3751
      @karenbourke3751 4 дня назад

      These are the real issues - you are about to be bankrupt.

    • @lindaflesch7303
      @lindaflesch7303 4 дня назад

      There will not be a "Next administration" only a personnel change.

  • @karenwhite8839
    @karenwhite8839 5 дней назад +17

    Trump and Jared were very transparent about Gaza. I don't understand WHY people are shocked. Trump had Jared speak about their waterfront intentions back in March 2024. Can our military just drop off Trump and Elon in Gaza? They can build their waterfront properties on the Gaza strip and stare off into the sunset on the Mediterranean Sea

  • @lordhighexecutioner
    @lordhighexecutioner 5 дней назад +5

    Gaza exists as a separate entity because Egypt refused to allow people to be driven into it in 1948... so it was accepted as a dumping ground for people subject to ethnic cleansing by Israel.

    • @someone-w9n
      @someone-w9n 4 дня назад +1

      Gaza was never part of Egypt. The borders of Egypt with the Othman empire in 1800s ended by rafah in Gaza.
      Gaza was always part of Cannan (mandatory Palastine), even in ancient times, Gaza was home to philistines, not Egyptians.
      So it belongs to Palastinains and only them. This is their last home after they got displacement from everywhere.

  • @brainstem2023
    @brainstem2023 5 дней назад +10

    Just him saying this out loud to the world with Netanyahu standing beside him is enough to destabilize things more than they already are.

  • @libarjesteh2467
    @libarjesteh2467 5 дней назад +11

    You are a truly voice of unjust and injustice!

  • @daynacase8528
    @daynacase8528 5 дней назад +23

    Oligarchy regime is what we have 🇺🇸

  • @kathywinecoff5046
    @kathywinecoff5046 5 дней назад +22

    This stupidity about Gaza IS NOT ANTHING we need to giving Air or Airtime too. It's that ridiculous, it defies even talking about it. Let's talk about the stealing of the Treasury and the like.

    • @simplytruth9729
      @simplytruth9729 5 дней назад

      YES!!!!!!

    • @gina_dee.1111
      @gina_dee.1111 5 дней назад +4

      Yes, the crazy talk is just a ele distraction from what is really going on. It is a lame attempt to cover up what is really going on.

  • @bellhilljj8793
    @bellhilljj8793 5 дней назад +6

    Trump envisions another Dubai.

  • @salyol7
    @salyol7 5 дней назад +14

    What's with your President meddling so much with other countries enough is enough.He needs to take care instead of all the issues in your country!

  • @wadesmith3135
    @wadesmith3135 5 дней назад +4

    Journalist Stepford Wives-seriously? We’re pretending this insanity deserves rational discussion?

  • @kathleentrinity7367
    @kathleentrinity7367 5 дней назад +6

    There are responsible Palestinians but Israel's occupation, arrests of moderates along with radicals, and splitting of political forces among Palestinians has thwarted their efforts. When Palestinians have tried peaceful protests and communication, they were met with indiscriminate violence. Israel has co-created this fraught and tangled situation. It's right wing is dead set against any vestage of Palestine.

  • @JohnBeerschoten
    @JohnBeerschoten 5 дней назад +21

    Mister Orange is insane.

  • @garyjohnson8327
    @garyjohnson8327 5 дней назад +11

    It's not radical. Its American Indian policy

  • @JN-om6rw
    @JN-om6rw 5 дней назад +23

    No mention of golf courses in the Balfour Declaration

  • @Alaskasnowcrystal
    @Alaskasnowcrystal 5 дней назад +19

    Trump is such a simpleton.

  • @norakatz-rhoads390
    @norakatz-rhoads390 5 дней назад +11

    2 criminals do a typical turf real estate development However, close by powerful neighbors may collaborate to do a different real estate deal.

  • @brainstem2023
    @brainstem2023 5 дней назад +3

    Oh, this won't start world war 3.

  • @yokomotooto1255
    @yokomotooto1255 5 дней назад +7

    Genocidal

  • @colchiandragon7396
    @colchiandragon7396 5 дней назад +6

    Sort reminiscent of crazy Roman emperor Caligula declaring war on the English channel and ordering his army to collect sea shells from the beaches.

  • @joycew7727
    @joycew7727 3 дня назад +1

    Expects other countries to take Palestinians yet he never wants to take immigrants/refugees in to the U.S., etc

  • @reemzaben4026
    @reemzaben4026 5 дней назад +23

    Gaza is Palestine. Period!

    • @Canadiangirl1234
      @Canadiangirl1234 4 дня назад

      No it’s not

    • @someone-w9n
      @someone-w9n 4 дня назад

      ​@@Canadiangirl1234😂😂
      You can't argue with history. Gaza is a historical Cannan, and Palastinains have full Cannanite DNA. Cope harder.
      If they leave, they will go to Europe and within few generations they will demand to return

  • @maravedisresearch
    @maravedisresearch 5 дней назад +5

    why not call it what it is: "ethnic cleansing"??

  • @karenkaren3189
    @karenkaren3189 5 дней назад +9

    I’m Jewish and very pro Israel but I find this proposal repugnant, not to mention a total nonstarter

    • @someone-w9n
      @someone-w9n 4 дня назад

      Trump doesn't understand that if those Palastinains left, they'll end up in Europe and no one can deport them because their land will be gone.

  • @nanaontherun1968
    @nanaontherun1968 5 дней назад +9

    Maybe he should look at making Puerto Rico a great place again and using the US to fund it as it's already thiers. I thought he was about making USA great again. Seems he is more interested in all his neighbors then his own back yard.

  • @silverleafmaple
    @silverleafmaple 5 дней назад +10

    Whose family members will be sent to clean up the land mines all over Gaza? Jared did indeed comment on the waterfront's value there in 2024-thanks for mentioning that comment. I was up half the night unable to recall who made that comment and when.

    •  5 дней назад

      jareds a nephilian and the antichrist

    •  5 дней назад

      jareds a nephilian and the antichrist

  • @RicardoValdes-r6w
    @RicardoValdes-r6w 5 дней назад +6

    Every single one of his ideas are a disaster

  • @joshallen4502
    @joshallen4502 5 дней назад +4

    Why is his smiling and laughing about something so serious? This is a serious thing that too many talking heads are taking so lightly calling this "Radical."

  • @maryalicecoleman4661
    @maryalicecoleman4661 5 дней назад +1

    You can’t reason with a sociopath. You just have to push back hard.

  • @mauretteeric2806
    @mauretteeric2806 5 дней назад +17

    Free USA from AIPAC

    • @MojoZ20
      @MojoZ20 4 дня назад

      does that mean getting rid of 3/4 of Trump's cabinet & WH staffers 😂??
      Sounds a whole lot easier than moving 2 million palestinians out into neighbouring countries.

  • @theresaz.zebrowski3784
    @theresaz.zebrowski3784 5 дней назад +1

    Katie…thank you for keeping us updated on matters that are occurring so “fastly” and “stupidly”. Hopefully Americans (MAGAS) are paying attention.

  • @tymman18
    @tymman18 5 дней назад +4

    To say this plan is anything but dangerous and insane lends credibility to this madman. Shame on you.

  • @hrvojesvetec3058
    @hrvojesvetec3058 4 дня назад

    Come on..EVEN Bibi looked at him like "dam you lost your mind dude"😂😂😂

  • @jamestord6480
    @jamestord6480 5 дней назад +19

    "A Truly Radical Idea" stop with the sanitising and call it what it is.

  • @mercywilliams2698
    @mercywilliams2698 5 дней назад +6

    I think this is entirely consistent with his branding thing. Go into this war torn area and clean it up turn it into a Trump World destination . ..complete with Dubai esque high rises state of the art casinos and of course golf course. I remember this kind of conversation when I was a young college student listening to Trump talk about making over New York locations..Penn Station..what problems the city had (1970’s) and how to remake it. To my ears at the time memorable. Decades later it is what my mother referred to as pie in the sky ideas..which she chided to do with family friend making money with various schemes…
    Can’t imagine this is primarily about geopolitics so much as it is another place to leave a lasting visual imprint.

  • @lovaofsoul
    @lovaofsoul 5 дней назад +7

    No, the choice should be responsible Israeli’s working with responsible palestians. Israel is a disproportionate aggressor. They do not act in good faith!

  • @larrychernoff6887
    @larrychernoff6887 4 дня назад

    Congratulations to Mr. Haas on the success of his 50 years of work on the conflict. We look forward to the future his generation of thinkers have provided that resulted in the stability the region is currently enjoying.

  • @user-sq7nk9us6f
    @user-sq7nk9us6f 5 дней назад +6

    Americans what do you stand for? It is not clear to the rest of us at the moment. But what we hear is pretty disgusting. We cannot ally ourselves with your kind of meglomania.

  • @malikaeddakhch3015
    @malikaeddakhch3015 5 дней назад +5

    Imagine I décide that you are incapable of taking care of your falling apart house, so - because I’m powerful and I have the means- come to your front door and order you to pack, pick up your family and leave your falling apart house because your other neighbour, four blocks away, has agreed to restructure it and embellish it and together (I & him) will turn your house into a beautiful hotel that will make us amounts of money…. I wonder what would be your reaction 🧐

  • @CraigFisherArts
    @CraigFisherArts 5 дней назад +4

    Great piece.
    On a side note, you should shift your ring light so that it shines from a bit of an angle. At the angle it is at, it reflects on your glasses. 😊

  • @leviashanken7281
    @leviashanken7281 5 дней назад +3

    When i saw Trump say, "We'll own it", and how netanyahu tried not to giggle, i actually wondered if that was the first he heard this news. Maybe he agreed to the rest but that went a little too far. So he went with the flow?

  • @GoodAfternoonDave
    @GoodAfternoonDave 5 дней назад +6

    That idea is entire basis for Israel as a state so how "truly radical..." is it? To them it's an incomplete colonial project until all the natives are gone.

  • @FreeEnergy137
    @FreeEnergy137 5 дней назад +7

    I love interviews with people who speak "common sense." Thank you.

  • @Badgerbeard
    @Badgerbeard 4 дня назад +2

    Anything illegal could be described as "radical" because it is against the law.
    Civil society depends on consequences - It's called “just” law, including international law. The consequences of perpetuating impunity is the break-down of civil society.

  • @crista6899
    @crista6899 5 дней назад +9

    At this point in time here in the UK the sentiment is that we want to Boycott the US and Israel. Your president is making pariahs of both.

  • @GinaCoroneos
    @GinaCoroneos 4 дня назад +1

    Putting this on the Palestinians is an intellectually and morally dishonest approach and you know it.

  • @takaboom5830
    @takaboom5830 4 дня назад

    I come to you, Katie, more and more, for the truth, and toward your guests. I miss you each day at the news desk, and I will always recall that you allowed us to be happy in the morning.

    • @MrCph2200
      @MrCph2200 4 дня назад

      Does it make you “happy” with her and this guest talking about Palestinians in Gaza like they are cattle???

  • @ทิพวรรณแซ่ลิ้ม-ธ9ช

    He has dementia and you still won't call out his craziness, "Complicit."

  • @colinbrown7305
    @colinbrown7305 5 дней назад +5

    I think you are using the incorrect word for this Idea. It is completely insane.

  • @terrymill
    @terrymill 5 дней назад +5

    Here is how you unpack this Katie….this guy is a wackjob and can we report on how crazy and mentally unfit he is for office

  • @DaveFrank
    @DaveFrank 4 дня назад +1

    This is a great thing you are doing Katie. Thank you and I subscribed)

  • @AMERlCANNA
    @AMERlCANNA 5 дней назад +5

    WTF DJT????? Take Care of Our Country....Stop being a Bully...of the world!

  • @susandobbis
    @susandobbis 4 дня назад +1

    Love diplomacy but with current situation there's a bit of a disconnect for us to have to reckon with. We need to take immediate ACTION ON THE COUP. Trump's fickle avaricious nature is not something anyone can rationally deal with. Thank you for trying though.

  • @josephnotoempire2949
    @josephnotoempire2949 5 дней назад +7

    Israel is a US colony. Gaza is a concentration camp of the United States. Mask off. This guy isn’t criticizing US genocide of Palestinians.

  • @Middlescholar
    @Middlescholar 5 дней назад +3

    It’s not a radical idea, it’s an already dreamed of plan.

  • @ourcommonbeliefs
    @ourcommonbeliefs 4 дня назад +1

    It would be compassionate to offer helping Gaza's rebuild using the Gazans to rebuild their own country. That would be the "sane" thing to do. Not this insane idea of Trump.

  • @garyeberle62
    @garyeberle62 5 дней назад +14

    Ty Katie..you are always so on point. Great talk today. Many Americans when they speak of support of Trump, they speak that they lost $ from Biden. All of his voters were for money. Will always be. Even if it costs us our lives. This is so scary, ty for your calm kind words realistic words regarding this situation. You are so appreciated.

  • @martindean3822
    @martindean3822 5 дней назад +1

    The Dictatorial playbook requires the Military to be on side...the U.S. military has been very quiet so far...while DT continues to make one deranged pronouncement after another, many of the international supposed ambitions will require the military....the military swear allegiance to the constitution, not to DT...I can't see U.S. high command agreeing to invade Greenland, Gaza, Canada, ... the Panama Canal perhaps...it will be interesting to see...meanwhile, the DT administration will exhaust it's adrenal gland at some point...watching with interest...it is disappointing to see the leaders of the rest of the OECD world being so gormless in their response...perhaps they are biding their time...

  • @AraBedrossian-y2w
    @AraBedrossian-y2w 4 дня назад +1

    Radical my behind Katie! How ignorant can you be to avoid the white elephant in the room. It is 100% starts with E and ends with ing! 100% also starts wiTH G and ends in E.

  • @jenniferwilliams4852
    @jenniferwilliams4852 5 дней назад +1

    And people were mad at VP Harris 😤

  • @hiltonwatkins6750
    @hiltonwatkins6750 3 дня назад +1

    We’ll own it… OMG, does this guy have no idea of history of the world…? What an absurd administration this is…

  • @daryjohnmizelle
    @daryjohnmizelle 5 дней назад +1

    There is only one humanity. Work on a one state solution. All people are one family. Give up hatred and ignorance. It is very simple.

  • @selbermachenguru
    @selbermachenguru 5 дней назад +5

    Karoline Leavitt in the white house press conference described this as a charity operation. If we fall for that everything that will happen will be also on our watch.

    • @stephenr6913
      @stephenr6913 5 дней назад +3

      Charity operation? I can see the gates of the new home for the Palestinians. The sign will read "Work will make you Free".

    • @Jim-pm6jk
      @Jim-pm6jk 4 дня назад

      @@stephenr6913 Very true given the overall Nazi flavour of Trump, Must and company.

  • @twowisehands1234
    @twowisehands1234 5 дней назад +14

    I hope the people who voted for Trump in Dearborn are happy!

    • @Lucinda.100
      @Lucinda.100 5 дней назад +3

      Been thinking the same of my Michigan neighbors.

    • @Mimicry161
      @Mimicry161 5 дней назад

      What a gross vile response to people being murdered. My god, this is exactly the kind of thing you would hear from a liberal. Yuck.

    • @karenwhite8839
      @karenwhite8839 5 дней назад +4

      I live in Michigan as well and I hope they are happy with their vote and non vote!

    • @Momma7492
      @Momma7492 5 дней назад

      Both are 2 sides of the same coin , both bought by AIPAC , Biden and Trump are getting their orders from their AIPAC guy

  • @lauracohen4914
    @lauracohen4914 5 дней назад +1

    trump is surrounded by yes men. And he always says that, "everybody's saying."

  • @alisonyahna8041
    @alisonyahna8041 5 дней назад +11

    Israel needs to be a democratic state.… Not a Democratic exclusively Jewish estate for people who came from Europe, while displacing indigenous, Jews, Christians, and muslims whose homeland this is.

    • @emailuser8668
      @emailuser8668 4 дня назад

      Israel is a democratic state. There are two million Israeli Arabs, Muslims, Christians that can vote, own property, get jobs, attend public schools and universities, drive cars, own businesses, have careers in Israel. Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank aren't Israeli citizens so they don't have the rights of Israeli citizens. That's not racist or un democratic. Maybe if you looked up facts instead of being brainwashed by political hacks you would know that.

  • @allenmorgan
    @allenmorgan 5 дней назад +3

    Trump deserves credit for uniting all the major European leaders, Russia, China, Australia, Iran, Saudi Arabia and the other Middle Eastern players. That's a first.

    • @bikeymikey748
      @bikeymikey748 5 дней назад +1

      Uniting them in their distrust and disgust at his and his supporters’ fumbling? Ya, that’s a great reason to be proud…not 🥺

  • @roviannematovu3756
    @roviannematovu3756 5 дней назад +5

    Nobody mentions the gas & oil in Gaza?

    • @irenbartok9823
      @irenbartok9823 5 дней назад +2

      Rarely mentioned. There is trillions of dollars of natural gas off shore in Gaza. THIS is what this g3nocide has been about. Real estate + natural resources PERIOD
      Makes me sick to my stomach.