How serious is he? Trump's plan for Gaza • FRANCE 24 English
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 10 фев 2025
- Donald Trump has told the world in the company of a beaming Binyamin Netanyahu that "the US will take over the Gaza Strip". Should we take at face value what he's selling as a grand development scheme and what critics denounce as a quixotic pipe dream that can only lead to the ethnic cleansing of the two million Palestinians who live in Gaza?
How does one rebuild Gaza after destruction on a biblical scale? In the aftermath of past wars, Gulf states footed much of the bill. The money went to housing, but was also sometimes diverted by Hamas. We gauge regional reactions after Tuesday night's bombshell announcement out of Washington.
And where in the short term does the promise of a US takeover leave the current ceasefire deal? Did Trump just torpedo his administration's own efforts? What's the next surprise going to be?
#Gaza #Trump #Netanyahu
Read more about this story in our article: f24.my/AvTT.y
🔔 Subscribe to France 24 now: f24.my/YTen
🔴 LIVE - Watch FRANCE 24 English 24/7 here: f24.my/YTliveEN
🌍 Read the latest International News and Top Stories: www.france24.c...
Like us on Facebook: f24.my/FBen
Follow us on X (Twitter): f24.my/Xen
Browse the news in pictures on Instagram: f24.my/IGen
Discover our TikTok videos: f24.my/TKen
Get the latest top stories on Telegram: f24.my/TGen
End the occupation.
End apartheid.
There is no occupation.
study history.
Make Gaza Great for once.
The real question is what will the world do if this does happen?
Nothing as they were cowards not to help Palestine, with a few exceptions like south Africa & Ireland
people will keep tiktoking and do nothing. and the other part of the World will do nothing. its all part of the plan once you have the Audience dumb down, (it took a couple of decades)
The world don't care about Palestinian 😂😂😂😂😂😂
No MAGA, BABA instead. ( Buy Anything But American)
Nothing
He was sitting with the man who made it hell
Sinwar is no longer with us thank god
You cannot accept other option for peace and prosperity what is your idea? Not 2 estate solutions
khamas made it hell... Bibi gave the land the justice it deserves, and he is not done yet❤
@jovybecina8583 wonder if you have the same views if Putin remove all the Ukrainian people.
Hamas sure turned Gaza into a Hellhole😂
no word of the horrific suffering of these poor people, no empathy. The cold flippant smiley approach here offends my humanity and accomodates these two despicable war criminals.
Days before the president even took office he stopped the war. People today are alive because of this man. If you can’t see this as a good thing then you really do have mental issues. Who is expected to pay for the reconstruction? Who wants to invest in more Hamas terror tunnels? This has to change. If the people of the Gaza region refuse to get along with a neighbouring country that has a different religion and culture then things need to change. “diversity is our strength”.
It was still during the Biden administration when the ceasefire was agreed upon. What are you talking about?
When it comes to Israel he’s serious. America first politics is Israel first😢
Of course. Israel is America’s proxy in the Middle East
Yup
Don't worry, Trump will make billions out of this. Money that will be fed back into US economy. If you're the other half of Americans that have a passport, you could have a tax-free job in gaza as well. How's that for American first?
Nutenyahu and Gallant have arrest warrants.
Give the Palestinian the job and the money to build it themselves
🤔⁉️⁉️⁉️🙄 Palestinians will use the money for built more Tunnels
@@podge689tunnels leading out of the open air prison Israel locked them in for decades?
@podge689 wouldn't you build tunnels if you were kept in concentration camps? That's right, no one else matters except the zionists. Lunatics. Narcissists.
No , they lost and have no say.
@@timkincade9763 they lost what? When? And who decided that they lost? God's chosen or God's impersonators?
These program are made because of haltered for Trump rather than simpathy for Gaza
Hatered
Americans learned long ago that when Trump says something, believe him. It’s the world’s duty to stop his madness.
Countries should join both BRICS+ (for economics) and SCO (for security) as well as New Development Bank (for investment).
Come stop it
absurdity
Then why is every news tittle about "How serious is about this issue?". He wasn't taken before the election, and now that he is on an international rampage with American allies you are still sticking your heads into the ground. I wish you would have taken him more serious from the start and prevented this from happening.
what madness?
Before this, we understood that we would not solve anything with wars, on the contrary, we would worsen the situation. If Trump helps Israel apologize to Palestine and achieve peace and friendship between these countries, and does not evict Gaza and help restore it, this will be a truly glorious American
I think he's VERY serious. He can change his mind but people keep forgetting he's NOT a politician. He does not think like one.
Well, he may not be a politician, but if he ever opens another university and offers a course in politic, I sign up in a second.
He is a politician, just not who have control over his tongue.
@IndiaTides good joke😂😂😂😂
But he can answer a simple question from Sisi or the King of Jordan and all this will be forgotten, they ask him to open his border to his neighbours he calls criminals and they open their borders to what he calls terrorists. Can he do that? the answer is NO so the case is closed for good.
He is a politician. He’s been one going on over a decade.
The whole world needs to go back to the Bible and read it meticulously. It simply means that the whole world needs A COMPLETE RESET.
Don't forget the Occupied West Bank.
If the US truly care for the Israelis, the US should relocate and welcome the Israelis in California and New York City. It would not Only ensure their security and safety, it will also save the US hundreds of billions of US dollars to rebuild the USA and make America great again. It is a win-win situation.
Read your Bible
This man is talking a lot of nonsense hamas is still there
He will go in there as a developer with Netanyahu calling the shots.
If Trump and Netanyahu really want Gaza to be rebuilt, why not let the UN organize it? There are so many countries like Indonesia and Ireland who would love to help Gazan rebuild
The Saudis need to take their money back from Jared.
Can't imagine why the Palestinians wouldn't want a glistening trump tower built where there used to be a university.
FORGET ABOUT THE "2 STATE SOLUTION"!! OCT 7 DESTROYED THAT OPTION FOR GOOD!!
This clown and his delusions...The un respected way after the horrible war. He can't understand the situation there...
hes dreaming of never never land look who is in charge of middle east affairs now its absurd Zionists are embedded in congress for sure unbelievable
He's ALWAYS serious. He has zero sense of humor.
His humor is laced with scottish sparsity, inherited from his (scottish) mother.
Mr Trump has good tastes in humor.
@@emilschattner3407 incest
He's serious right but he can't think before saying BS, The fact that he closed his border to refugees mainly from his neighbours calling them criminals, and wants others to open their borders to the people he calls terrorists. Surely anyone who asks you to do something he doesn't want to do himself doesn't take him seriously
😂😂😂to a real estate developer... every land near a sea is a Riviera 😂
Never a boring day in Donald Trump presidency. Wondering who will run this proposed luxury resort, and will there be any casino's ?
His son in law Kushner with the assistance of Baron Trump.
Trump's son-in-law (Jared) was saying the exact same thing about Gaza during Trump's first term. I would say they are serious.
And who will pay for this? Maybe Musk with all the money he steals from the US treasury?
What a joke
Will it come with a golf course?
GREAT idea. Breaking News, HAMAS has decided to cease as a group. A new group will be formed SAMAH that will manage Gaza ....... so Yaay! Hamas is no more. And we can live happily ever after.
No gaz for Europe, no Gaza for Palestinians, no Greenland for Dannish, no Canada for Canadians... what's next?
Who the heck is mr Alkhatib to have a proposal, to know what to do in Gaza?
Probable Mossad agent. They have the french/Israeli and the Arab/Israeli making ludicrous plans that Muslims can then laugh at. Maybe, get Norman Finklestein or some neutral commenter, so your show does not become more of a laughing stock, France 24? Before 10-7 there were reportedly 5000 innocent Palestinian kids, women, and men (like doctors) held as hostaged and tortured horribly, which apparently were intended to be traded for the new hostaged. The pis plan proposed curiously overlooked that.
The izrl lobby caused these problems by making Kamela lose (because we could not support their crimes and Jen 0'side) and getting their bribed rump elected to create this kleptocracy. Gulags are now coming to America.
And more, massive, land theft and we, Americans, get to die and pay more tens of billions to accomplish it. Follow the money: the billionaires who own mass media and what quid pro quo they may have been promised, like tens of thousands of US troops dying or getting crippled in the ME to conquer a planned, foreign empire for izrl.
Another "refugee"😂😂😂
Good reporting. Thank you. Strong Ukraine. Strong NATO. Strong Poland. STRONG EUROPE!!!!
Why not open a Mc Donalds on Mars or Jupiter?
There will be numerous McDonalds
Jupiter? You know no reasons why nit to build "on" Jupiter?
I find the narrative of this so called debate. We are talking about a people who are occupied. Hamas is void that fills the gap in the action and creation and the use of force by isreal. You cant act violently or terrorists against a people and not expect them not grow to be a monster also
Israel did not occupy gaza since 2005.
This time palestinians should think smartly and secure their new lives in the so called neighbouring countries. Demand the jordanians and Egyptians a full citzenship rights.
Trump's constituency is very serious about it. Enough trusting others for our Holy Land.
The Palestinians see it as their Holy Land to though. The Al-Aqsa mosque is the third most holy site in Islam. Personally, I think that was a lot of opportunism on the behalf of Mohammed and early Muslims, but the modern Muslims do see the site that way.
Yes to answer you, What will countries do if this does take place
"....this could be something that could be so bah.... this could be so magnificent..." Which one is it Mr.President?
So… Trump is a Political Disruptor! Here is a beautiful stick… find me the carrot 🥕
He’s not a real estate developer. He’s a convicted felon who should be behind bars just for the suggestion he made let alone all the atrocities. The US are explicit in with regards to Gaza.
Mr Ahmed talking how Palestinians want to stay and rebuild their land: and how much of that did they do in the last 80 years, 350 miles of tunnels aside? Biggest tragedy in Gaza is that people over there do not have a constructive bone and are solely focused on destruction of their neighbours, there's nothing else what matters even remotely close to this. Palestinians will not rebuild Gaza.
I am not suggesting forced relocation, especially by Western forces, my only hope is the Arab neighbours, many of which were inspiring hatred for decades, would take responsibility and help with the next steps - controlling Gaza while it's cleaned from terrorists and destruction of tunnels and slowly building the nation.
I'm hopeless dreamer, I know.
You seem to just see Palestinians as people who can't make up their minds. Imagine Palestinians dictating about politics of Israel. Mind you isreal is the causative in this issue. It not like Hamas woke up like the guest was saying Israel couldn't trust Hamas when they don't want them to be free and rule themselves without interference
Just because you can do better, doesn’t mean you can’t steal the land and build condos.
@@whysoserious8666 isn't that a twisted way of thinking where taking other people's property is now deemed ok
Racist dishonest fool.
He found Gaza city of rubble and left it a city of Gold
Only China can stop his madness😂
Maybe Israel and The US can provide homes to the Palestinians while they rebuild what has been destroyed.
Everybody wants 2 states except Gaza.
Trying to understand what a lunatic means is a heck of a waste of time. 🇺🇸🍊🤡
This is a debate?
Fight back!
Trump Towers will be a 100 Storey TRUMP sign on top, lighting up the skies at night.
Trump must be STOPPED by all means possible. Period
Greenland, canada, panama and now gaza. Whats next? Europe?😅
Why people are debating about if Trump is serious or not?
He is not a baby or crazy to find excuses of what he says. He is the present of USA. The most powerful position in the world. Wake up.
With what he said, all Middle East and Africa is in a huge mess.
So, which option is good? " To follow up the ideology " From the river to the sea"?
"Trump Syndrome" at its worst .
Viva la France. Viva the Palestinians.
Great and humerous anchor
offensive to terrorists? do you have better idea?
The US might stay there unless things get better for Israel, and then the piece of land would be gifted to Israel later.😮
And never think that Allah is unaware of what the wrongdoers do. He only delays them for a Day when eyes will stare [in horror].[Quran 14:42]
Palestine land is Palestine land
That’s President Trump.
Oh no a pack of know it alls rather than the facts.
Earnings fr foreign countries?
Those people in the Middle East has nothing to lose you have already giveaway your birth right. What you have to do is a massive loud voice , enough is enough you take the loud voice now speak of what is justice all in a very load voice
Why is support for the Palestinian cause a must for all arab countries? Religion or politics? I think the former, which makes me wonder why all Western countries don't support Israel which is run on democratic values of the west?
Hamas started a war on October 7 2023,and you cannot cry for free handouts now, all of your views are insufficient
This decade the ICC is to overtake the ECHR by the number of filed cases 😂
He say the true only 15 days people are tired of talk Trump talk too much 😊
America First ? ; Rebuild American Infrastructure ! .
You are missing the point, there is no Israel involved and they are same people but we are different and Israel]s security and favour is different
The world should be brace for 3 yrs old 10 months for Donald trump insanity 😮😅😊
Panel is discussion is not balanced.
😂Trump is truly a goon...😂
Jared is a Jew and he says that Gaza is part of the land the LORD promised him and his people.
support trump for major development in gaza.🎉wow.🎉
MAGA ❌
MIGA ✅
My house, did you spent money to construct that building, or build it out of your own hard earn money
Of course not
It's not called Mar-a-lago, it's called The Fountain of Youth, where did you think it was in Texas?
The Gaza has decades of conflicts devastation, and destruction. This region needs transformation with peace stability restoration and rebuilding to make Gaza fit for human living.
All Arab states like Egypt Jordan, etc, are enjoying peace, stability, and wealth prosperity. Etc The Palestinians need to enjoy the same quality life by relocating to the Arab States. It will takes decades to design and rebuild the Gaza Region. I encourage Egypt Jordan and the Arab States to reach out with love care and compassion to the suffering Palestinians. I write with concern and interest for all the Palestinians. Keep up the good work François.
Remember the Nakba
Thanks for honouring my heartfelt comments for the Palestinians. I trust all will go well with the changes needed to transform the Gaza.
Nobody discusses the only scenario under which this crazy idea could be possible. At least hypothetically. And this comes from the statement by Saudis. First, Jewish settlers leave the West Bank creating conditions for a meaningful Palestinian state to emerge, which will take most of the people who will leave Gaza as the price for Palestinian independence. Saudis never said that Gaza needs to be in the new Palestinian state, which means that they be ready to give it up if Jewish settlers move out from the West Bank. In this scenario Gaza may become a sort of US administrated commercial hub run by Saudis or Emirates. This seems the only mathematically possible scenario for me. It also requires that Israel don’t demolish the settlers houses in West Bank when they leave so that people from Gaza can be settled there. Maybe Trump was referring to those houses when he said people in Gaza can move to very nice houses. I think Israel may be happy with this deal as they will get an American anchor right next to them, possibly with a small military base which will exponentially enhance their security . And they may pay price for that. I know this may sound silly but don’t see any other scenario. Trying to rationalize
But Israel moved out from Gaza in 2005.…what did gazans build when Israel left ? Built Death tunnels to fight Israel and die as martyrs?
Who do you think will live in this demonstrated hub? Trump clearly said Egypt and Jordan would take them you ignored the fact Trump's first thing he did was to lift the sanctions on the settlers this shows he's not going to move them out also he got 100 million donations to take over the West Bank in return.
The Saudis were clear, about the two-state solution and the 1967 borders that surely included Gaza and it's not theirs to give up.
Facts the ICJ demands are clear end the occupation within 12 months the reason Netanyahu went to the US is because there's only one month left, and Trump needs to find a good excuse to veto the UNSC surely he can't say there is no occupation. The ICJ case was going on long before Oct 7 and it has nothing to do with what happened after. this is about the occupation even though all US allies want the end of the occupation. If Trump vetoes with a stupid excuse it will go to the general assembly vote and for sure is going to be the whole world yes and 2 no.
Why? Is the leader of the Free world turn to a Joker. Is that the case now, 21st century
Gil lies in all his appearances. He is fake news. Stop giving that throwback a voice.
Can Hamas trust Israel?
No
Ahmed your proposal is full of nonsense
Tihs man is the words so Worlds man
I will stand by with trump whatever… nevertheless I don’t care
You talking impossible 😂😂😂😂😂😂
10/7 une autre attaque sous faux drapeau
On the Riviera by the Mediterranean's embrace, Where the sun kisses the shore, a valuable place, World-class beauty, where blue waters foam, A haven of lebensraum, many call home.
But beneath the surface, where the rich villas lay, There's a tale of the people who were led astray, Displaced from the heart of this coastal array, Their voices like whispers, slowly fading away.
Once happy they were, in their humble abode, Now searching for shelter, a new place to unload, Yet hope springs eternal, and dreams never fade, For a life that's both happy and in health's gentle shade.
May the Riviera's charm, with its allure so heady, Find room for all souls, both the ready and unsteady, To bask in the glow of a world-class view, Where every heart's healthy, and every smile true.
Hell gaza. News 8 billion people world ?
European countries must recognise the Palestinian state now to counter this.
Who will rebuild Gaza if not Trump?
Nobody
Israel is broke.
Yes but they are not rebuilding it for the Palestinians and will use tax payer money to do it but trump will sell the land lol
Exactly right, nobody.
They'll come around, and if they don't, fine. They'll have to do something on their own.
Only wise palestinians leave gaza. If they stay, most will not survive. And the rest of survivors only suffers more because gaza is back to stone age. If they leave, they are saving the future generations of gazans.
For Jared kushner!!!!
Panel is discussion is not balanced.