Nah, the Opus Dei freaks would see it as a badge of Honour. Turn the other cheek etc. would be invoked. To be cast out of an unjust church is a sign you are righteous because the greatest danger to *Money Changers* -winks- . No one hates Jesus like fundamentalists. They don't like it when you point out the church itself is heretical to Christ because it was founded by a man who was cast out of the faith for preaching dogma that was not inkeeping with the cult of Jesus.
Norwegian king Sverre had to crawl up to the pope and beg forgiveness to resolve the issue. I guess JD Vance, despite being a supposed Catholic, has never begged forgiveness from anyone. Why should the church offer him communion? Seriously.
Back then, an excommunication could be a death sentence. A peasant would lose access to basically anything their community had to offer, they would have been left to their own devices to survive in the wild basically. A king could lose all his political power, because the idea backing the absolute power of a monarch was that his position was given by God. Therefore, if the voice of God on Earth, the Pope, said you were no longer in the graces of God, effectively your crown was no longer a symbol of power, just an expensive hat. There was a real chance that someone else, someone more in the grace of God (read "the Pope") could replace you, if you were a king in that position, and said replacements at the time would have, more often than not, been violent. A king getting excommunicated back then was a real big f-ing deal. Today someone in a position of power being excommunicated would be in the news for a couple of days and nobody would think too much about it. Even for those who still care about the grace of God, the Pope no longer has a stranglehold on deciding who has it and who doesn't. And it's not even because the Pope no longer has the same kind of political power he used to have, a big part of it is that, in the Middle Ages, within European politics there was no alternative to the Catholic Church. You were either a Catholic or you were an enemy of the Church. After the Protestant Revolution stuck, after the various new denominations took hold and became too entrenched to just eradicate by force, like they would have done in the middle ages, the Pope suddenly found himself not having the monopoly over people's faith. That was the real point of no return. The King of England no longer wants to abide by the Catholic Church's teachings? No problem, he can make his own Church, no need to go begging for the Pope's approval. It's been centuries since that point of no return, and the Pope's power has done nothing but declining since then. Nowadays even Catholics often feel alright openly criticising the Pope and what he says.
Is this the first time a Republican politician has worried about having a violent murderer in schools? I thought nothing could be done about that except hope and prayers.
Trump told people, "We got to get over these violent murders happening in our schools." Vance said, "It's just a fact of life that violent murders come into schools and murder our children." Now it's a problem because brown? Alright. Freaking ridiculous.
No, you just watch MSNBC with your mouth open. Why dont you want to address the real issue of mental health. How many mass shooting in 1960? What about in Switzerland where everyone is forced to have a rifle in their home? Durrrrr! Are you worried about trans psychos since more and more shooters fit the narrative? Whooooops! Got em!
JD Vance calling out the Catholic Church for worrying about their bottom line… as a deflection from this police state fascism… is just… so unbelievably hilarious
@@DefaultSettings-kz8vsI’m sure you found some info already but just in case ( and for others): “An Indiana man who was recently pardoned for his participation in the Jan. 6 Capitol riot was shot and killed during a traffic stop by a sheriff's deputy Sunday. Matthew Huttle, 42, was involved in a traffic stop at 4:15 p.m. by a Jasper County sheriff’s deputy, authorities said in a news release. It alleged that Huttle resisted arrest and was found to have a firearm on him.”
He's not too worried about sex trafficking when he was going to vote for Matt Gaetz if he had to break a tie in the Senate. Why don't we have competent journalists who can counter their stupid talking points?
nearly all of them have been fired from "respectable places" and now have set up their own versions of "majority report", or just switched careers. it's hard to be a free thinker when everything revolves around money.
I absolutely hate the fact that the reporter did not push back against Vance's bs. This is not about taking killers out of schools or churches. It's about grabbing anyone who's undocumented. Journalism is dead in this country! They hardly give any pushback and always let politicians get away with changing the subject. That pisses me off so much!
when the Pope denounces you... you're probably not good at practicing Catholicism. I currently go to a catholic private college, I am a 31 year old atheist. I am required to take some religious classes (faith religion and society as well as the Christian scriptures) from my study in the faith class which covered Catholicism Judaism and Christianity, Catholic doctrine is very liberal leaning on everything except abortion. In catholic social teaching one of the core tenets is " option for the poor and vulnerable" In that there is even mention of encyclicals from the church talking about "homes should not be left in fallow" which means empty, the Catholic church is against commodification of housing lol. Now obviously the catholic church is not perfect, but there are solid policy on the higher level. policy which of course American right wingers will ignore because it's 'woke'
@@draxthemsklonst Basically it's not considered good because openness to life is part of the idea of sex, HOWEVER it's fine if you don't want children currently to use natural ways to avoid pregnancy (Natural Family Planning services, tracking apps, etc) and also if one needs birth control for a medical reason that's fine.
Shows why you're so easy to manipulate. They're all Romans Look into it ALL OF THEM Demand Govt by referendum without Politicians, using Mascot Candidates to promote a 70/30 split yes/no/redraft. And March every Oct 14 under a 🏳️ Share and spam
“Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law. And a person's enemies will be those of his own household. Whoever loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me, and whoever loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me.” -The only aspect of jesus’ character that republicans (especially trump and his ilk) want to emulate.
But the pastor said I should hate gays, Mexican criminals, poor drug addicts, and everyone else I can punch down on. Oh wait, the Bible says here that isn't true in this new testament thing, but the old testament kinda does say that... I'm so confused, somebody tell me what to think! God, are you there? I can't hear you!
@Jack_Flapper strange since I always regarded that the verse meant that Jesus is talking about his speech been the sword not a literal one. Since in god’s word is suppose to be greater than any material object.
Trying to say that the cops would try to detain a violent criminal at church or a school is a crazy notion. They normally want to detain them in a place where the public is least at risk…so definitely not a building with a bunch of people inside that aren’t involved in the crime. This guy watches too much dramatized police shows…
Kinda wild that Vance thinks he can tell Catholic Bishops what to do or think as a layperson? That's wild. They'd do the world a favor if they excommunicated him.
Something JD said when he was a kid in his book Hillybilly Felony was that we would all be sorry when he was President, and I bet he’s right on this one
I'm a devout Catholic, that's why I sneered like a little child during a sermon and oppose Catholics being Christly and kind. I'm definitely a devout Christian though guys.
If you support Francis and all his weak nonsense, you are no Catholic. Catholics have their beliefs written down in black and white. You don't have to wonder. The Church, itself, will happily tell you whether you're one of them or not. If you support Francis, you are NOT.
American Catholicism is and always will be the religion of immigrants. Irish and Italian Immigrants of the early 1900s and now Mexican, central and south American immigrants today. Jesus says to welcome and care for the foreigner and the stranger!
Jesus also said fear not the money lenders for they shall be as dust in the wind. Well... Those money lenders are setting the air on fire, I can't breathe. Where's Jesus now? He's dead.
@@RecklarAU "The money lenders" has been a dog whistle, going back to at least the time of Shakespeare. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you're unaware of this?
Catholicism has always been the religion of immigrants from Mexico, Central and South America. States like Florida, California, Texas , etc. were once Mexican territory which was colonized by Spain just like Puerto Rico, Central America and most countries in South America were. Names like San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Antonio,Santa Barbara, San Diego, etc. are all based on Catholicism.
Don't hate the player when the game is rigged, Dems have felicitated the Right wing at every turn, you really think it's just coincidence they're all in lockstep on literally every policy? They're all Romans Look into it ALL OF THEM Republicans are not Capitalists they're Authoritarian Communists using Purity politics to enforce a social hierarchy based on identity politics using Accusations in a Mirror 🪞 or Blame the Victim Demand Govt by referendum without Politicians, using Mascot Candidates to promote a 70/30 split yes/no/redraft. And March every Oct 14 under a 🏳️ Either we are all equal under God, or no one is ... Share and spam
All sane Catholics should call their bishops and suggest they're aware of someone who needs to be excommunicated. I won't say his name but his initials are JD Vance.
Whenever JD Vance says the name of his interviewers, it makes me cringe for some reason. It's like there's this weird emphasis with a tinge of misogyny. It's so fucking weird to hear
Don't hate the player when the game is rigged, Dems have felicitated the Right wing at every turn, you really think it's just coincidence they're all in lockstep on literally every policy? They're all Romans Look into it ALL OF THEM Republicans are not Capitalists they're Authoritarian Communists using Purity politics to enforce a social hierarchy based on identity politics using Accusations in a Mirror 🪞 or Blame the Victim Demand Govt by referendum without Politicians, using Mascot Candidates to promote a 70/30 split yes/no/redraft. And March every Oct 14 under a 🏳️ Either we are all equal under God, or no one is ... Share and spam
@@ajkulac9895 That is the problem with Catholicism...what to do when your leader is not a Catholic....it's a conundrum that is unique to Catholicism...no other organization places a man in power who is their enemy...
Vance needs to go somewhere, sit down, and close his mouth before the whole world knows he is lost. He appears to not have a clue and will never get one.
Wish Vance had stayed with his initial sexual leanings. He would be more accepting of others, instead of hating himself so much it spills out and contaminates the rest of us.
The obsession with the Laken Riely case has always been very telling to me because the macro data has been consistent over the last 20 years; immigrants do less violent crime on average than natural born citizens. Undocumented immigrants with way more to lose commit significantly less. Almost 50% less in some studies. Crime rates have gone as immigration has increased. The reason they won stop talking about Laken is because the statistics don't support their claim. It's the example they always give of the dangers of immigration because it's the ONLY example they can name on the top of their heads. If the stats were on their side, that's what they would reference instead of a single anecdote.
I’m tired of anyone claiming the boarder is wide open. I live in Southern California… you need your passport… they don’t just let you go through a wide open gate. Same up at entry points at the Canadian boarder
Just as Aslan welcomed the Earthling Children to Narnia, and Yoda warmly welcomed younglings to Coruscant, from every corner of the galaxy. Except that throughout history, the Catholic Church has far more in common with Jadis and Palpatine.
The biggest sin of Sodom & Gomorrah was the lack of hospitality. Rather than provide shelter and food to the strangers (foreigners), as dictated by God, they sought to torture and kill them for not leaving immediately.
You don't have to believe he was God's son to believe he existed and got killed for opposing the Pharisees. The same Pharisees who went on to support Bar Kokba's rebellion that killed Christian/Roman men, women and children.
@@Shockguey I don’t think the existence of the historical Jesus is disputed by most scholars. I do, however, think that the fantastical claims of impregnating your teenage mother with yourself, rising yourself from the dead and sacrificing yourself to yourself in order to forgive yourself for rules that you made up yourself is something that lacks evidence. And as ridiculous as that previous statement sounds, that is the Christian doctrine in a nutshell
If there is a violent criminal in a church or school, why is ICE involved. It’s a matter for local law enforcement. ICE only comes in after they catch the guy.
When forced to choose between their religious views and their political views, religion will always take a back seat to further their political agenda.
First time I’ve ever been happy to have been raised catholic 💀 I left the church (I’m agnostic) when I was 18 but I’ve got to say, Catholics really don’t give af what other people think about them. For better or for worse.
Tbh this has been great for the church where I'm defending them because the things they are getting critized for by these nutters for the actual good things about Christianity. OMG love your neighbor?? What a terrible concept. That guy might not have papers!
He's looking rough. Ozempic turning him into a shrinky-dink? He seems to hate violent offenders I think that anybody who attacks cops should be deported. Right, JD?
Who cares what a second hand account Written minuimum 50-75 years after. That is just rehashing of stories handed down since the beginning of time. I have more faith in my last issue of Sports illustrated…
Emma nailed it when she said this aggressive overpowering of immigrants deflates their victimhood mentality. But victimhood goes hand in hand with Christianity and their Christ who sacrificed his life for their sins, the ultimate "victim"
This topic is about immigration... Since when did a NATURALIZED CITIZEN who gained citizenship as an adult have the right and authority or insight to wage war on the leader of said country? Do you believe that naturalized citizens should remain quiet and docile while leaders dictate their future? It is shown that naturalized citizens have more knowledge about government than those born into citizenship because they study and choose to be citizens
@@disobedienttiger6240 Where does the religion of the convert Vance demand that you treat immigrants like cattle and worse than dogs? I will agrfee witjh you on one thing however. As a former exhange student to Kansas 35 years ago, I don k now more abouit American history than you do. Maybe I should get citizenship, and you get yours revoked. Not that I would want to, since my country is better than yours in so many ways. 😁
He turns a simple question into something totally unrelated. That’s cruel. But cruel is what he is. Watching his bottom never mind the forlorn. The forlorn be damned. And they call themselves Christian’s. And we applaud them. We get the politicians we deserve.
JD Vance's facial hair looks like it was drawn on with a felt tip marker.
День назад+2
I live in Brazil. My Priest (a well-traveled, highly educated bi-lingual man) completely supports Trump. He will not accept any arguments against Trump. Masters in Psychology. It's very hard to accept
The Pope is God's representative on earth within Catholic doctrine. What he's says, goes. Claiming to be a devout Catholic, yet contravening God's representative is an oxymoron. Cruel and stupid. A dangerous combination.
Tell the world you've never read the bible without saying you haven't read the bible. 😅 People have a seriously warped disneyfied delusion as to what 'christianity' is 🤣
I am not a Roman Catholic, but I am a fellow Christian. Catholic social teaching is one of the best analyses of what Jesus would have as do in our contemporary society. Kudos to your action .
Sorry, but liberal Catholics are, generally speaking, just LIBERALS....they are fatuous and weak-minded, utterly wrapped up in all this WOKE buffoonery...
Violent criminals are not in schools, they are in jail. Because if we know they committed a violent crime, it is because they were prosecuted. This is so dumb.
I wish every interviewer would literally just ask "so when are groceries going to get cheaper?" How is persecuting people over their skin color going to help the economy? Answer, it's not.
I agree with you all completely and I think all of those immigrant should be sent to the Vatican and be allowed to live in the Vatican City which is one of the most ancient cities in the world. That would be putting where your money where your mouth is whether you're the host on this show siding with the Pope and the bishops or whether you are actually the Pope in the bishops and you want to show you're not a hypocrite and you put your body on the line and you will allow them to live with you sleep with you eat with you and do everything else a human being does.
I thought we had" Separation of Church and State?" Why are secular people bringing religion into this? If he referenced his Catholic faith in regards to abortion policy, you'd have a whole tirade. Just like you claim they shouldn't cherry pick their religion to further policy, you shouldn't cherry pick theirs while fighting for a secular government.
@ Sadly back in March her dad was outspoken about how he felt. He said he feared it was being used to incite people and he said people from both sides were lashing out at his family. ‘"I think it's being used politically to get those votes," Jason Riley said. "It makes me angry. I feel like, you know, they're just using my daughter’s name for that. And she was much better than that, and she should be raised up for the person that she is. She was an angel.”’
It's worth noting that a lot of these culture war points come directly from traditional catholic belief. Abortion, for example, is only an important voting point for conservative evangelicals because conservative catholics were able to successfully inject it into the conversation. Their beliefs are fully dogmatic, they understand this, so they do everything they can to make them important in the public sphere without invoking their religious foundations. Look at any interview with Matt Walsh and the way he talks about natural law -- that's a way of getting around saying "I believe this because it's in my religion."
If they’re going into schools, they’re not necessarily looking for children/ students. Sometimes, they’re after a teacher, a professor, or another staff member, maybe even a janitor, or a cafeteria worker. That still doesn’t mean they’re necessarily looking for a “violent criminal” either. During the Drumph’s first term, there was a science teacher, at Kansas University I believe it was, who had been in the US & teaching at KU for a long time - at least fifteen years, I think. ICE came after him because he had forgotten to renew his work visa, or something like that. There was a good deal of protesting over his arrest, and I think that finally got him released. But, if someone like him has to go through all that again … that pot’s likely to boil over into a super huge mess.
Also, notice how Vance gets slowly a tiny bit louder during his speech. Notice the increasing echo due to him shouting in order to keep himself as the talker.
The criminalization is the same as what happened to the natives, and to descendants of slaves. The US allegedly was forced to discriminate against them, and prevented from giving them civil rights, because they were brutes.
I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him, $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
Well, the Roman Catholic church hasn't crowned itself in glory since its formation, to be honest. Vance is despicable, but I have no respect for the Roman Catholic church.
In the middle ages, the pope wouldn't flinch to excommunicate someone from the church.
It's time, your holiness.
Nah, the Opus Dei freaks would see it as a badge of Honour. Turn the other cheek etc. would be invoked. To be cast out of an unjust church is a sign you are righteous because the greatest danger to *Money Changers* -winks- . No one hates Jesus like fundamentalists. They don't like it when you point out the church itself is heretical to Christ because it was founded by a man who was cast out of the faith for preaching dogma that was not inkeeping with the cult of Jesus.
Norwegian king Sverre had to crawl up to the pope and beg forgiveness to resolve the issue. I guess JD Vance, despite being a supposed Catholic, has never begged forgiveness from anyone.
Why should the church offer him communion? Seriously.
Back then, an excommunication could be a death sentence. A peasant would lose access to basically anything their community had to offer, they would have been left to their own devices to survive in the wild basically. A king could lose all his political power, because the idea backing the absolute power of a monarch was that his position was given by God.
Therefore, if the voice of God on Earth, the Pope, said you were no longer in the graces of God, effectively your crown was no longer a symbol of power, just an expensive hat. There was a real chance that someone else, someone more in the grace of God (read "the Pope") could replace you, if you were a king in that position, and said replacements at the time would have, more often than not, been violent.
A king getting excommunicated back then was a real big f-ing deal. Today someone in a position of power being excommunicated would be in the news for a couple of days and nobody would think too much about it. Even for those who still care about the grace of God, the Pope no longer has a stranglehold on deciding who has it and who doesn't.
And it's not even because the Pope no longer has the same kind of political power he used to have, a big part of it is that, in the Middle Ages, within European politics there was no alternative to the Catholic Church. You were either a Catholic or you were an enemy of the Church. After the Protestant Revolution stuck, after the various new denominations took hold and became too entrenched to just eradicate by force, like they would have done in the middle ages, the Pope suddenly found himself not having the monopoly over people's faith.
That was the real point of no return. The King of England no longer wants to abide by the Catholic Church's teachings? No problem, he can make his own Church, no need to go begging for the Pope's approval. It's been centuries since that point of no return, and the Pope's power has done nothing but declining since then. Nowadays even Catholics often feel alright openly criticising the Pope and what he says.
@brodericksiz625 I just think he shouldn't get communion and access to his local church.
At least a refusal of ecclesiastichal communion would be well in order given their stance against the pope
It'd be genuinely hilarious if the Pope just said "JD Vance is no longer catholic."
Pope casts Excommunication Spell
Opus Dei won't let him.
@@ajkulac9895 Vance save-rolls high, invokes hillbilly swarm on the Vatican.
@@TheMercilessEye that won't work in the Vatican City by a looooooot of reasons.
Talk to some real Catholics....they'd take JD over Francis, ANY DAY...Francis is a joke...He has been from DAY ONE...
Is this the first time a Republican politician has worried about having a violent murderer in schools? I thought nothing could be done about that except hope and prayers.
Trump told people, "We got to get over these violent murders happening in our schools."
Vance said, "It's just a fact of life that violent murders come into schools and murder our children."
Now it's a problem because brown? Alright. Freaking ridiculous.
💯💯💯💯
YYESSSSS thank you
No, you just watch MSNBC with your mouth open. Why dont you want to address the real issue of mental health. How many mass shooting in 1960? What about in Switzerland where everyone is forced to have a rifle in their home? Durrrrr! Are you worried about trans psychos since more and more shooters fit the narrative? Whooooops! Got em!
JD Vance calling out the Catholic Church for worrying about their bottom line… as a deflection from this police state fascism… is just… so unbelievably hilarious
He’s just a pig
Let's say it all in unison, "Every accusation is a confession".
Hey bro you should give your local immigrants shelter from ICE. Be the hero you fantasize about being
@@daroachdoggSRbet you support trump
@@sifunmon Don't care about him. I don't care for self righteous cowards like you or the OP either
These are the same dumbasses that just let a ton of violent criminals out of prison right? One of the guys got smoked by the cops already.
Thoughts and prayers.😂
Womp, womp
For real 😅?
I gotta google this thanks 😂
@@DefaultSettings-kz8vsI’m sure you found some info already but just in case ( and for others):
“An Indiana man who was recently pardoned for his participation in the Jan. 6 Capitol riot was shot and killed during a traffic stop by a sheriff's deputy Sunday.
Matthew Huttle, 42, was involved in a traffic stop at 4:15 p.m. by a Jasper County sheriff’s deputy, authorities said in a news release. It alleged that Huttle resisted arrest and was found to have a firearm on him.”
@@Povryan Oh no. Anyway.
He's not too worried about sex trafficking when he was going to vote for Matt Gaetz if he had to break a tie in the Senate. Why don't we have competent journalists who can counter their stupid talking points?
They are very frustrating.
Trickle-down corruption's insidious.
Because as soon as a journalist asks tough questions they avoid that journalist or station after calling them lefty anti American communists.
Because their bosses are in bed with Donnie
nearly all of them have been fired from "respectable places" and now have set up their own versions of "majority report", or just switched careers.
it's hard to be a free thinker when everything revolves around money.
Hes hasn't been a catholic for very long and now he's trying to tell the pope how to do his job.. wtf
I wonder his risk for excommunication...
This pope doesn't count. He's either an imbecile, or perhaps something worse....in either event, he is among the worst the Church has seen.
I absolutely hate the fact that the reporter did not push back against Vance's bs. This is not about taking killers out of schools or churches. It's about grabbing anyone who's undocumented. Journalism is dead in this country! They hardly give any pushback and always let politicians get away with changing the subject. That pisses me off so much!
This guy is a bad fart away from the white house
Thankfully, the far more common occurrence happens to be diapers being shat.
😈
@shawnmurphy282 he is universally loathed, that would be a short presidency.
I have never laughed so hard into a stonewall than from this comment.
Would it really be any worse than the presidency we have now.
There was a violent killer in a schiol in Uvalde and no one went in to get him.
when the Pope denounces you... you're probably not good at practicing Catholicism.
I currently go to a catholic private college, I am a 31 year old atheist. I am required to take some religious classes (faith religion and society as well as the Christian scriptures) from my study in the faith class which covered Catholicism Judaism and Christianity, Catholic doctrine is very liberal leaning on everything except abortion.
In catholic social teaching one of the core tenets is " option for the poor and vulnerable"
In that there is even mention of encyclicals from the church talking about "homes should not be left in fallow" which means empty, the Catholic church is against commodification of housing lol. Now obviously the catholic church is not perfect, but there are solid policy on the higher level. policy which of course American right wingers will ignore because it's 'woke'
Damn, got em 😂
Isn't the church against contraception as well?
@@draxthemsklonst Basically it's not considered good because openness to life is part of the idea of sex, HOWEVER it's fine if you don't want children currently to use natural ways to avoid pregnancy (Natural Family Planning services, tracking apps, etc) and also if one needs birth control for a medical reason that's fine.
JD Vances true relgion is wyte supremacy
Shows why you're so easy to manipulate. They're all Romans
Look into it
ALL OF THEM
Demand Govt by referendum without Politicians, using Mascot Candidates to promote a 70/30 split yes/no/redraft. And March every Oct 14 under a 🏳️
Share and spam
Proverbs 19:17: "Whoever is generous to the poor lends to the Lord, and he will repay him for his deed".
That's not what Republican Jesus says, it's the opposite.
“Do not think that I have come to bring peace to the earth. I have not come to bring peace, but a sword. For I have come to set a man against his father, and a daughter against her mother, and a daughter-in-law against her mother-in-law. And a person's enemies will be those of his own household. Whoever loves father or mother more than me is not worthy of me, and whoever loves son or daughter more than me is not worthy of me.”
-The only aspect of jesus’ character that republicans (especially trump and his ilk) want to emulate.
But the pastor said I should hate gays, Mexican criminals, poor drug addicts, and everyone else I can punch down on. Oh wait, the Bible says here that isn't true in this new testament thing, but the old testament kinda does say that... I'm so confused, somebody tell me what to think! God, are you there? I can't hear you!
Christianity and religion in general is nothing but a means of manipulating the masses. Its a tool, and so is every religious zealot.
@Jack_Flapper
strange since I always regarded that the verse meant that Jesus is talking about his speech been the sword not a literal one. Since in god’s word is suppose to be greater than any material object.
I'm glad he mentioned he was a practicing Catholic. I was beginning to wonder if he'd forgotten.
He's still getting used to being Catholic. Give him time
His practising is not very good, if you think you can tell the leader of your faith that he is lying.
He needs to practice a bit harder if he wants to get it right
He misspoke, what he meant to say is that he's pretending to be Catholic.
@@silith7027 Too many Hail Mary's for him to preform, the next time he pretends to go to Church.
This is the equivalent of someone holding a mirror in front of you and you getting mad that they made you look at an ugly face
Tim pool complaining that his own music sound awfull when The Majority Report put it on ^^
Trying to say that the cops would try to detain a violent criminal at church or a school is a crazy notion. They normally want to detain them in a place where the public is least at risk…so definitely not a building with a bunch of people inside that aren’t involved in the crime. This guy watches too much dramatized police shows…
This!
You actually don't want the police to do this at school or in a church. It's why vehicular pursuits can be much more dangerous and lethal.
Good point
The way he constantly repeats the person he’s talking to name makes my skin crawl
Your skin is very perceptive.
He is so creepy. Arrogant asshole.
And when are these knuckleheads going to start arresting the illegal immigrants and the company executives that hired them?
It's a communication tactic to force your attention and personalize the discussion to make you more inclined to agree.
Part of his word salad
Kinda wild that Vance thinks he can tell Catholic Bishops what to do or think as a layperson? That's wild. They'd do the world a favor if they excommunicated him.
Catholic Bishops have no authority in the government.
@bubbiesdad they do have authority over Vance as he is a Catholic.
If you want to defend a pedofilic ring you have that right. Good job 👏
Something JD said when he was a kid in his book Hillybilly Felony was that we would all be sorry when he was President, and I bet he’s right on this one
I'm a devout Catholic, that's why I sneered like a little child during a sermon and oppose Catholics being Christly and kind. I'm definitely a devout Christian though guys.
I don't care, I'm saved. I can do whatever I want, Jesus said I'm saved. I don't even have to pray for forgiveness anymore, I'm already saved.
@RecklarAU fr I was raised Catholic and a lot of these US Catholics, especially converts, are indistinguishable from Evangelicals to me.
If you support Francis and all his weak nonsense, you are no Catholic. Catholics have their beliefs written down in black and white. You don't have to wonder. The Church, itself, will happily tell you whether you're one of them or not. If you support Francis, you are NOT.
@@RecklarAUI honestly can’t tell if you are making fun of them or being serious. I’ve seen similar posts before that were serious
@@trappedinamerica7740 sarcasm, but it's pretty sad that I agree with your point.
American Catholicism is and always will be the religion of immigrants. Irish and Italian Immigrants of the early 1900s and now Mexican, central and south American immigrants today. Jesus says to welcome and care for the foreigner and the stranger!
Jesus also said fear not the money lenders for they shall be as dust in the wind. Well... Those money lenders are setting the air on fire, I can't breathe. Where's Jesus now? He's dead.
Jesus said fear not the money lenders, but those guys are really making things hard now. Where's Jesus? I need that 12 bucks.
Mexicans were here before the Italians and Irish, even before this was a country.
@@RecklarAU "The money lenders" has been a dog whistle, going back to at least the time of Shakespeare. I'll give you the benefit of the doubt and assume you're unaware of this?
Catholicism has always been the religion of immigrants from Mexico, Central and South America. States like Florida, California, Texas , etc. were once Mexican territory which was colonized by Spain just like Puerto Rico, Central America and most countries in South America were. Names like San Francisco, Los Angeles, San Antonio,Santa Barbara, San Diego, etc. are all based on Catholicism.
I hate how Vance uses the reporter's name several times in every interview, MARGARET.
my dude i cannot stand the way he says people's names, like a cryptid pronouncing something phonetically to complete the disguise
I know it’s so calculated and fake. He just emotionlessly inserts their name at the end of key sentences like a machine.
Don't hate the player when the game is rigged, Dems have felicitated the Right wing at every turn, you really think it's just coincidence they're all in lockstep on literally every policy?
They're all Romans
Look into it
ALL OF THEM
Republicans are not Capitalists they're Authoritarian Communists using Purity politics to enforce a social hierarchy based on identity politics using Accusations in a Mirror 🪞 or Blame the Victim
Demand Govt by referendum without Politicians, using Mascot Candidates to promote a 70/30 split yes/no/redraft. And March every Oct 14 under a 🏳️
Either we are all equal under God, or no one is ...
Share and spam
It’s so radical
Calling someone by their name is offensive to people now? But when Biden miss pronouncing people name is a ok. Sounds like priorities over logic.
I'm a Catholic. JD Vance ain't it.
Me too and I agree
Does Vance and his family sit alone in the pews? And do the actually mean it when we say "peace be with you" during mass. I think not...
He's a lot closer than Francis will ever be...
@@tgriffin3059Then you obviously have no clue what being Catholic is.
All sane Catholics should call their bishops and suggest they're aware of someone who needs to be excommunicated. I won't say his name but his initials are JD Vance.
But...wouldn't Joe and Nancy have to go first???
Whenever JD Vance says the name of his interviewers, it makes me cringe for some reason. It's like there's this weird emphasis with a tinge of misogyny. It's so fucking weird to hear
It's got that tonality that some people use when talking down to children. He does it to grown women in a professional setting.
Powerful antenna😮
He does it in EVERY interview. It’s this awkward condescending power move but it probably works with his supporters
Don't hate the player when the game is rigged, Dems have felicitated the Right wing at every turn, you really think it's just coincidence they're all in lockstep on literally every policy?
They're all Romans
Look into it
ALL OF THEM
Republicans are not Capitalists they're Authoritarian Communists using Purity politics to enforce a social hierarchy based on identity politics using Accusations in a Mirror 🪞 or Blame the Victim
Demand Govt by referendum without Politicians, using Mascot Candidates to promote a 70/30 split yes/no/redraft. And March every Oct 14 under a 🏳️
Either we are all equal under God, or no one is ...
Share and spam
Using someone's name is s*xist now?
He’s been a catholic since “Tuesday” and now he’s makin the rules. Just like everyone else the church will roll over.
He's clearly not. If you're a Catholic what Pope says goes.
@@ajkulac9895 He hasn't read up on those very dark sects yet, or he would be very worried.
@@ajkulac9895 That is the problem with Catholicism...what to do when your leader is not a Catholic....it's a conundrum that is unique to Catholicism...no other organization places a man in power who is their enemy...
Vance needs to go somewhere, sit down, and close his mouth before the whole world knows he is lost. He appears to not have a clue and will never get one.
Because....he wants to jettison people who have no legal right BEING here, to begin with? That is the ONLY sane position to hold...
You poor poor lost soul..
what an awful awful man.
Wish Vance had stayed with his initial sexual leanings. He would be more accepting of others, instead of hating himself so much it spills out and contaminates the rest of us.
The obsession with the Laken Riely case has always been very telling to me because the macro data has been consistent over the last 20 years; immigrants do less violent crime on average than natural born citizens. Undocumented immigrants with way more to lose commit significantly less. Almost 50% less in some studies. Crime rates have gone as immigration has increased.
The reason they won stop talking about Laken is because the statistics don't support their claim. It's the example they always give of the dangers of immigration because it's the ONLY example they can name on the top of their heads. If the stats were on their side, that's what they would reference instead of a single anecdote.
Yet they want everyone to buy guns. Bunch of dumbasses
Yep. And most of us Can prattle off several names of black men that were killed by police.
This man being president is even scarier than Trump imo
Yeah because at least trump doesn’t actually believe in a taliban social order, this guy clearly does
I’m tired of anyone claiming the boarder is wide open. I live in Southern California… you need your passport… they don’t just let you go through a wide open gate.
Same up at entry points at the Canadian boarder
A violent murderer in a school? In elementary school? WTF is he on about?
He is telling what he was like at school.
If Jesus wasn't a fairy tale I feel like he'd be pretty pro migrant
Just as Aslan welcomed the Earthling Children to Narnia, and Yoda warmly welcomed younglings to Coruscant, from every corner of the galaxy. Except that throughout history, the Catholic Church has far more in common with Jadis and Palpatine.
The biggest sin of Sodom & Gomorrah was the lack of hospitality. Rather than provide shelter and food to the strangers (foreigners), as dictated by God, they sought to torture and kill them for not leaving immediately.
You don't have to believe he was God's son to believe he existed and got killed for opposing the Pharisees.
The same Pharisees who went on to support Bar Kokba's rebellion that killed Christian/Roman men, women and children.
@@Shockguey I don’t think the existence of the historical Jesus is disputed by most scholars. I do, however, think that the fantastical claims of impregnating your teenage mother with yourself, rising yourself from the dead and sacrificing yourself to yourself in order to forgive yourself for rules that you made up yourself is something that lacks evidence.
And as ridiculous as that previous statement sounds, that is the Christian doctrine in a nutshell
@@Ergorexestu I know that's what I believe, I was trying to meet you halfway on your terms without being antagonistic.
If there is a violent criminal in a church or school, why is ICE involved. It’s a matter for local law enforcement. ICE only comes in after they catch the guy.
Not sure they use logic in their analysis, I mean.. clearly..🤣🫡🇬🇧
So Doctor Phil can appear on TV again.
Its horrendous the trauma that they will be causing all those kids and families 😢
Hardly. If the kid has no legal right to be here, then throw him OUT....
Ya know how violent murders are in schools all the time… eye rollllll
lets remember they accosted a US military veteran. wasnt w violent criminal
Accosted, they took him and other citizens into custody.
@ correct i wanted to leave room in case i heard something that was in error
@@kiwihibthat's not democratic that's definitely fascist Jack booting
They also detained a woman who is on the process to become an US citizen in Florida.
When forced to choose between their religious views and their political views, religion will always take a back seat to further their political agenda.
Devout Catholic? More like devout politician.
First time I’ve ever been happy to have been raised catholic 💀 I left the church (I’m agnostic) when I was 18 but I’ve got to say, Catholics really don’t give af what other people think about them. For better or for worse.
Please don’t make me pick between the Catholic Church and JD Vance lol
Church is worse, countless millions dead and tens of thousands kids diddled. Jd has a lot of work to do to catch up
Tbh this has been great for the church where I'm defending them because the things they are getting critized for by these nutters for the actual good things about Christianity.
OMG love your neighbor?? What a terrible concept. That guy might not have papers!
He's looking rough. Ozempic turning him into a shrinky-dink?
He seems to hate violent offenders I think that anybody who attacks cops should be deported. Right, JD?
South Georgia Island sounds like a nice place to send 1496 people.
Makeup is rough on the skin…
Matt Gaetz is the first fabulous vice president to be sponsored by a mascara brand
You shall also love the stranger, for you were strangers in the land of Egypt.
Deuteronomy 10:19
2:50 Listening to Epstein’s best friend’s VP get on a pedestal about child sex trafficking is rich
I almost wanna go back to church to defend catholicism
Converts are the worst.
Immigrants who choose to become citizens are the worst.
The bible says he is wrong 😂😂😂😂
Who cares what a second hand account Written minuimum 50-75 years after.
That is just rehashing of stories handed down since the beginning of time.
I have more faith in my last issue of Sports illustrated…
Emma nailed it when she said this aggressive overpowering of immigrants deflates their victimhood mentality. But victimhood goes hand in hand with Christianity and their Christ who sacrificed his life for their sins, the ultimate "victim"
its always the converts that make everything weird, they convert to a new religion while truly learning nothing
Laughs in Pogroms Inquisitions Witch Trials and the Crusades
Mostly peaceful Opus Dei
I hate how hard JD gish gallops. He sounds like he's generating a script for everything
What about the Preists and sexual abuse cover ups.
I got a few PragerU ads on instagram !! Literal climate denial ads sponsored by Instagram !!
Since when did a CONVERT as an adult have the right and authority or insight to wage war on the leader of said religion`?
This topic is about immigration... Since when did a NATURALIZED CITIZEN who gained citizenship as an adult have the right and authority or insight to wage war on the leader of said country?
Do you believe that naturalized citizens should remain quiet and docile while leaders dictate their future?
It is shown that naturalized citizens have more knowledge about government than those born into citizenship because they study and choose to be citizens
@@disobedienttiger6240
Where does the religion of the convert Vance demand that you treat immigrants like cattle and worse than dogs?
I will agrfee witjh you on one thing however. As a former exhange student to Kansas 35 years ago, I don k now more abouit American history than you do. Maybe I should get citizenship, and you get yours revoked. Not that I would want to, since my country is better than yours in so many ways. 😁
@@disobedienttiger6240 the topic is immigration but the reasoning is constantly tied back to “Christianity”
@@disobedienttiger6240
No the American Founders would not recognize JD Vance as Americans.
As far as Benjamin Franklin was concerned he is "swarthy".
@@Shockguey founding fathers are dead...
He turns a simple question into something totally unrelated. That’s cruel. But cruel is what he is. Watching his bottom never mind the forlorn. The forlorn be damned. And they call themselves Christian’s. And we applaud them. We get the politicians we deserve.
JD Vance's facial hair looks like it was drawn on with a felt tip marker.
I live in Brazil. My Priest (a well-traveled, highly educated bi-lingual man) completely supports Trump. He will not accept any arguments against Trump. Masters in Psychology. It's very hard to accept
The Pope is God's representative on earth within Catholic doctrine. What he's says, goes.
Claiming to be a devout Catholic, yet contravening God's representative is an oxymoron.
Cruel and stupid. A dangerous combination.
Dear Cool Pope, please excommunicate Vance.
Thank yall from the bottom of my heart.
Tell the world you've never read the bible without saying you haven't read the bible. 😅
People have a seriously warped disneyfied delusion as to what 'christianity' is 🤣
JD pulled himself up by his bootstraps, so why can all poors do it. Say, JD, what's that shade of lipstick you're wearing? Thiel brown?
Thiel Cream?!?!
Why would a "convicted criminal" be in a church service and not in jail?
Cuz he is president.
JD Vance being concerned about sex trafficking while working under Trump is comical.
I want to point out that the VP just said that the way to protect people from violence was by using the state to do violence itself.
Would it be reasonable for the Catholic Church excommunicate JD Vance?
jd is like trump they make stuff to prove a non existant point.
I am not a Roman Catholic, but I am a fellow Christian. Catholic social teaching is one of the best analyses of what Jesus would have as do in our contemporary society. Kudos to your action .
Sorry, but liberal Catholics are, generally speaking, just LIBERALS....they are fatuous and weak-minded, utterly wrapped up in all this WOKE buffoonery...
The devil has never respected churches 😂😂😂😂or homes or organizations
Violent criminals are not in schools, they are in jail. Because if we know they committed a violent crime, it is because they were prosecuted. This is so dumb.
Great show Emma and Matt.
He’s so catholic he knows better than the pope
Porky the Vance is a little chubby man 🍼👶😂
He talks about the Catholic Church being worried about their bottom line when he and Trump are worried about the bottom line.
Oh, you’ve forgotten how Elementary School is!
Full of vicious little monsters…..
JD Vance looks like Chuckie
🎯Thinks like him too.
Except half the people they’ve rounded up haven’t committed a crime.
I wish every interviewer would literally just ask "so when are groceries going to get cheaper?"
How is persecuting people over their skin color going to help the economy? Answer, it's not.
I bet people are saying "woke pope" LOL
Excommunicado!
I agree with you all completely and I think all of those immigrant should be sent to the Vatican and be allowed to live in the Vatican City which is one of the most ancient cities in the world. That would be putting where your money where your mouth is whether you're the host on this show siding with the Pope and the bishops or whether you are actually the Pope in the bishops and you want to show you're not a hypocrite and you put your body on the line and you will allow them to live with you sleep with you eat with you and do everything else a human being does.
I thought we had" Separation of Church and State?" Why are secular people bringing religion into this? If he referenced his Catholic faith in regards to abortion policy, you'd have a whole tirade.
Just like you claim they shouldn't cherry pick their religion to further policy, you shouldn't cherry pick theirs while fighting for a secular government.
But you released Jay Sixers, who committed violent crimes. You need to look in the mirror.
Reporter: What would Jesus do?
Jd Vance: Jesus would deport all immigrants obviously. 👏👿
I’m so sick of them weaponizing Laken Riley’s case.
Is her family okay with this? Her legacy is being reduced to violent racism! I'd be absolutely appalled and raging!
@ Sadly back in March her dad was outspoken about how he felt. He said he feared it was being used to incite people and he said people from both sides were lashing out at his family.
‘"I think it's being used politically to get those votes," Jason Riley said. "It makes me angry. I feel like, you know, they're just using my daughter’s name for that. And she was much better than that, and she should be raised up for the person that she is. She was an angel.”’
@@feliciascorner9795 She only HAS a legacy because of the animals who HER OWN SOCIETY turned loose on her.
@@skateywatey that pisses me right off. How fucking dare they! 😡
I grew up catholic and I know a lot of catholics who are just like this. I am not surprised by this even a little.
If J.D. Vance isn't a part of Opus Dei then I will convert to Catholicism.
He sure is opus dei, never Jesuit . Pope Francis is Jesuit.
Opens dei aka non-Catholic Catholic. When you're too weird for the Catholic Church...
@@ValeriaBellettiniJervesEcuador oh man Opus Dei is nuts and that doesn’t surprise me one bit if he’s part of that
Anything other than Guaranteed Healthcare and Living Wages is a distraction.
"Am I out of touch? No it's who I believe to be the Voice of God on Earth who's wrong."
- Jesus Dronestrike Vance
It's worth noting that a lot of these culture war points come directly from traditional catholic belief. Abortion, for example, is only an important voting point for conservative evangelicals because conservative catholics were able to successfully inject it into the conversation. Their beliefs are fully dogmatic, they understand this, so they do everything they can to make them important in the public sphere without invoking their religious foundations. Look at any interview with Matt Walsh and the way he talks about natural law -- that's a way of getting around saying "I believe this because it's in my religion."
If they’re going into schools, they’re not necessarily looking for children/ students. Sometimes, they’re after a teacher, a professor, or another staff member, maybe even a janitor, or a cafeteria worker.
That still doesn’t mean they’re necessarily looking for a “violent criminal” either. During the Drumph’s first term, there was a science teacher, at Kansas University I believe it was, who had been in the US & teaching at KU for a long time - at least fifteen years, I think. ICE came after him because he had forgotten to renew his work visa, or something like that. There was a good deal of protesting over his arrest, and I think that finally got him released. But, if someone like him has to go through all that again … that pot’s likely to boil over into a super huge mess.
Apparently convert JD thinks he knows Catholicism better than the Pope?!
Every convert has beef with the Pope for some reason, they just don't get how the system works.
The religions of forgiveness and repentance criticizing Trump's hatred and filthy behaviors is not something I expected, but I am all for it
Also, notice how Vance gets slowly a tiny bit louder during his speech. Notice the increasing echo due to him shouting in order to keep himself as the talker.
The criminalization is the same as what happened to the natives, and to descendants of slaves. The US allegedly was forced to discriminate against them, and prevented from giving them civil rights, because they were brutes.
I'm favoured only God knows how much I praise Him, $230k every 4weeks! I now have a big mansion and can now afford anything and also support God’s work and the church.
Wow that's huge, how do you make that much monthly?
Only God knows how much grateful i am. After so much struggles I now own a new house and my family is happy once again everything is finally falling into place!!
I'm 37 and have been looking for ways to be successful, please how??
I earn from investing in the digital market with the guidance of (Ms. Evelyn Vera) Brokerage services. I'm happy to talk about it!!!
I earn from investing in the digital market with the guidance of (Ms. Evelyn Vera) Brokerage services. I'm happy to talk about it!!!
Nobody can think that Eyeliner Vance, can be taken seriously.
Also, police have historically been very scared about entering a school with a violent killer in it (see Uvalde)
Maybe Vance will get excommunicated.
Well, the Roman Catholic church hasn't crowned itself in glory since its formation, to be honest. Vance is despicable, but I have no respect for the Roman Catholic church.