We bought the worst Apple product

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 янв 2025

Комментарии • 871

  • @macaddress
    @macaddress  2 года назад +180

    Thank you for watching! Emails take a longer time to go through than you’d expect sometimes. Make sure you’re prepared with an all-in-one writing tool like Grammarly! It’s FREE, why not? Sign up for a FREE account and get 20% off Grammarly Premium: grammarly.com/MacAddress

    • @arnandegans
      @arnandegans 2 года назад +2

      Just throw in a SSD for some extra speed. But yes, $800-900 for a 4 year old 2nd-hand computer is dumb... Still, if that's what you want, just replace the drive and max out the memory.

    • @soyanchd5439
      @soyanchd5439 2 года назад +1

      Call out the WhatsApp scam in the comment section

    • @cpyt
      @cpyt 2 года назад

      I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY! I HATE GRAMARLY!

    • @PersonHuman456
      @PersonHuman456 3 месяца назад

      Hey horst if you see this i wanna know if i could contact you via email or any non social media

  • @radiobrojo
    @radiobrojo 2 года назад +872

    Tip: Look for these offline. Many university comms/ed departments and creative firms that bought these for interns have been so angry with their performance that they recycle or fire sale them on the regular ( free to well under $500). Just buy an external SSD like a Samsung T5 and boot macOS off it, and it runs just fine.

    • @ghomerhust
      @ghomerhust 2 года назад +106

      for only a few dollars more, get the screen glue kit and a wheel tool to pop the screen out, and install the ssd directly inside. just load it with the OS before hand, and install it. a good time to toss in a little extra ram too

    • @nicl83
      @nicl83 2 года назад +61

      @@ghomerhust on these modern Macs you don’t even have to load the OS before you install the SSD, just hold R/command-R on boot and it’ll download it from the internet for you

    • @kfj6709
      @kfj6709 2 года назад +26

      Even in academia there are dumb sheep who buy products without knowing the specs? What's the IT dept or procurement and purchasing dept doing?

    • @thejpkotor
      @thejpkotor 2 года назад +26

      A lot of times big IT places will net boot or use them as thin clients; in these cases the onboard drive and speed don’t matter at all.

    • @Validole
      @Validole 2 года назад +46

      @@kfj6709 IT and tech are using windows or linux, and don't know for sure how the specs match up to usability on MacOS, outside synthetic payloads. If the input to them is "we need macs, doesn't matter which, as many and as cheap as possible", then they get macs, as many and cheap as possible. GIGO.

  • @MisterBloodBunny
    @MisterBloodBunny 2 года назад +2089

    I'd say it's still a nice deal, since you got a stand for free.

    • @BramBiegstraaten
      @BramBiegstraaten 2 года назад +123

      If you see it from the stands point of view it got a free computer, mouse and keyboard attached to him.

    • @varszegimarcell
      @varszegimarcell 2 года назад +51

      You’ve got a computer for a price of a stand xD

    • @krishnamanchundiya
      @krishnamanchundiya 2 года назад +4

      Omg😂😂😂😂

    • @blackhatson13
      @blackhatson13 2 года назад +19

      Exactly! Will definitely pick this any day over the $999 stand, such a bargain!

    • @krishnamanchundiya
      @krishnamanchundiya 2 года назад +1

      @@blackhatson13 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

  • @DistrosProjects
    @DistrosProjects 2 года назад +618

    Fun fact: the hard drives in these iMacs are slower than the drives that were shipped in 2003-2012. There's absolutely no reason why they can't ship a 7200 rpm drive in them.

    • @vamwolf
      @vamwolf 2 года назад +1

      Sata 1 port .like PS3 and 4 .

    • @robertt9342
      @robertt9342 2 года назад +29

      @@vamwolf . Those consoles have Sata 2.

    • @wellzi2546
      @wellzi2546 2 года назад

      I think those macs used a 3.5" drive, not a 2.5". The entire chassis of an iMac changed in 2012. I still agree with your sentiment though.

    • @DistrosProjects
      @DistrosProjects 2 года назад +14

      @@wellzi2546 7200RPM drives exist in 2.5 inch sizes, although they are likely slightly slower and more expensive.

    • @arjunyg4655
      @arjunyg4655 2 года назад +9

      Throwback to when you could get 10k or 15k RPM SAS drives in Macs. Kinda want to buy one now just for the experience. Never could afford them when they were relevant lol.

  • @InsightCheck
    @InsightCheck 2 года назад +83

    I worked at the Genius Bar for over 5 years and these things were the bane of my existence.
    I felt so bad for anyone that bought it. It was genuinely offensive that they sold these things into 2020.
    Anyway, the reason there are so many iMac Pro and these iMacs on the refurbished store is that when all the stores closed due to the pandemic, the vast majority of the staff converted to work from home and were given these.
    Initially my we got 27 inch iMacs, but then they ran out. So they started giving iMac Pro. Then they finally had to give these once they ran out of all the others.
    It’s also why they’re in good shape all things considered. They were used by one Apple employee for a few months.

  • @DavidMalcolm
    @DavidMalcolm 2 года назад +532

    I"m so glad that Apple has taken hard drives completely out of their line up. Way too many well-meaning customers bought the entry-level iMac and ended up very frustrated with how slow the drive makes the computer. I honestly wish they would have just had 128 gig SSDs and then allowed people to get external HDDs it would have been much easier on everyone.

    • @DistrosProjects
      @DistrosProjects 2 года назад +17

      Even the Fusion drives are way faster in my experience. I used them for several months at my school with sub-30 second boot times and reasonable speed.

    • @MementoMori-xx5qo
      @MementoMori-xx5qo 2 года назад +44

      The amount of money I've made upgrading peoples iMacs to SSDs. Thank you Apple lol.

    • @the_wiki9408
      @the_wiki9408 2 года назад +4

      Would be nice if we could add a HDD as a second drive, though, especially in the iMac and Mini. SSD is great and all, but I'd rather not spend $800 for a 2TB SSD to store my photos and videos on, when a HDD will do just fine. Internal HDD beats external storage.

    • @rmendez011
      @rmendez011 2 года назад +10

      @@DistrosProjects Thats because a "fusion drive" is 2 separate drives, the NVMe for boot, and the HDD for applications. According to Wikipedia, the 2017 iMac with the 1TB Fusion drive comes with a 32GB NVMe SSD, 2TB and 3TB fusion drives come with a 128GB NVMe SSD.
      Search Google for "fusion drive" and click on the Wikipedia link, it shows what years came with what space.

    • @mgzukows
      @mgzukows 2 года назад +6

      @@the_wiki9408 Are you buying the SSD from apple? Where the hell would a 2TB SSD cost $800 at current pricing. Maybe in 2015.
      I guess you can be thinking with install cost to switch it out. But even that would not be $800

  • @gorfmaster1
    @gorfmaster1 2 года назад +268

    "Apple doesn't believe in depreciation" no truer words have been spoken. Even their old iPads that don't get updates are still absurdly expensive.

    • @dangelo2728
      @dangelo2728 2 года назад +3

      That’s certainly been true with the iPad Mini for a long time, but with the new refresh, they seem like they’re gonna refresh it on a regular basis at this point. Even the base level iPad is refreshed annually.

    • @KeiAngelus
      @KeiAngelus 2 года назад +47

      They believe in depreciation if you do a trade in with them!

    • @chrishbeatboxing2291
      @chrishbeatboxing2291 2 года назад +2

      Yet on the software side they deprecate everything (I’m talking about OpenGL)

    • @_sparrowhawk
      @_sparrowhawk 2 года назад +3

      If by old iPads you mean, older than 5 years... If you were going to rip Apple for anything this is not it. Apple hardware gets software support for years and years and years.

    • @larrythehedgehog
      @larrythehedgehog 2 года назад +2

      @@_sparrowhawk hey genius. They’re talking about how apple devices don’t lose value over time. Not how apple products get support for a long time. Two different concepts.

  • @TurntableTV
    @TurntableTV 2 года назад +579

    I’m both a PC and Apple user and I have to say that this channel is one of the best. I love that they also address (pun intended) the bad/cons in Apple products. Happy subscriber here.

    • @biotechben
      @biotechben 2 года назад +18

      Completely agree, too many Apple/Mac channels treat the product as worth it weight in myrrh, and that if you disagree that you just need to bask in your wrongness. Love that Jonathan is objective and able to provide that viewpoint and be an apple user without being fanatic. I personally dislike apple products, mostly because of how apple treats their customers or can belittle people who disagree, but Jonathan sometimes makes me go "you have a point there, that thing is actually a good thing"

    • @_sparrowhawk
      @_sparrowhawk 2 года назад

      @@biotechben "I personally dislike apple products, mostly because of how apple treats their customers or can belittle people who disagree" What the hell is this sentence? You dislike the prices? The design? The leadership team? The lack of games? (Of course it's the lack of games)
      What the ever loving fuck is this reason you gave?

    • @nijigaharaTV
      @nijigaharaTV 2 года назад +4

      @@_sparrowhawk You are literally the people he's complaining about. The worst kind of people: Company Fanboys

  • @Crasher_7
    @Crasher_7 2 года назад +202

    “You might think that this 890 dollars iMac is a great deal, but I don’t think it is. Which is why bought it”
    Lol

    • @halvardlundnorway
      @halvardlundnorway 2 года назад +5

      Best reasoning ever.

    • @alphaquasar3089
      @alphaquasar3089 2 года назад +3

      Came down here for this lol

    • @TR-qf2gt
      @TR-qf2gt 2 года назад +1

      They bought it so we dont have to hahaha salute to the dedication

    • @x_ktrs
      @x_ktrs 2 года назад

      @@TR-qf2gt no shit sherlok :/

  • @Some-guy-on-the-internet
    @Some-guy-on-the-internet 2 года назад +175

    It's clear to me that modern versions of macOS aren't designed to run on HDDs. I sold a 2012 Mac mini a while back and added an SSD to it because Catalina took over 6 minutes to boot and several more to "warm up" after logging in on the old 5400rpm HDD it came with. Booting off the SSD took only about 5-10 seconds. It's no wonder why not a single modern Mac has HDDs as an option. macOS is literally unusable on anything but an SSD.

    • @OtterBoiMilo
      @OtterBoiMilo 2 года назад +1

      How did you get the ssd going? I have a 21.5 2014 model, but with an ssd replacement, it's extremely slow. I understand that you need to enable trim, but I couldn't get it to work

    • @myrealusername2193
      @myrealusername2193 2 года назад

      Really? Monterey takes ~1-2 minutes to boot up and “warm up”, and open up all of the previous apps. Using an m.2 NVME SSD

    • @PvtAnonymous
      @PvtAnonymous 2 года назад +11

      the keyword here is APFS. It's literally designed to run well on SSDs. Hence newer versions of macOS use APFS by default and run much better that way.

    • @Fay7666
      @Fay7666 2 года назад +12

      It's also a simiar story on Windows land. I ran Win10 RTM on a hard drive just fine, and also ran it on an old PC with HDD & only 2GB of RAM just fine for a month or so. But I tried it last year, and it was _pain_ even on a new system with an enterprise 14TB hard drive, no debloat script saved it.

    • @ej_tech
      @ej_tech 2 года назад +10

      Microsoft made a big deal about requiring TPM 2.0 and Secure Boot to run Windows 11 (officially) but never made it a requirement to have an SSD (or even eMMC flash) boot drive. Windows 10 is already *just* tolerable on a mechanical drive, but with Windows 11 it's unresponsive more than half the time.

  • @EricLS
    @EricLS 2 года назад +35

    I bought a mid-tier iMac in 2014, and said “naaaahhh” on the fusion drive, despite technically understanding the underpinnings. What I had not realized is that OSX all but presumed an SSD at that point and was absolutely unbelievably slow. Worst tech mistake of my life.

    • @Starach
      @Starach 2 года назад

      Same here, looking forward to a M1/2 27” when it comes out.

    • @EricLS
      @EricLS 2 года назад

      @@Starach have an M1 13”, it’s literally hard to believe how fast it is

    • @Elloqus
      @Elloqus 2 года назад +4

      My company had gotten me an iMac 27" 2019, upgraded one, with 8-core i7 and 16GB of RAM if memory serves (pun intended), but it had a Fusion Drive. Due to the corporate nature of the device, and the large number of logins and software booting at startup, the device booted as if it had a hard drive (since the SSD part of a Fusion Drive is just 32GB, which is barely enough for the base MacOS). In general very poor experience, I couldn't believe how Apple is ok with someone spending over $3k for a professional device and getting such poor performance.

  • @rec0n97
    @rec0n97 2 года назад +15

    Until a few weeks ago, I used to have this computer at my workplace. I’m a graphic designer that usually has 3-4 adobe apps open at all times, plus Spotify and safari. This computer was the worst thing I’ve ever used, don’t know why the still sell this (even as refurbished)

  • @Handl3sAreStupid
    @Handl3sAreStupid 2 года назад +10

    When I worked for Applecare, someone called with one of these asking why her brand new computer was so slow. I recommended she return the computer and get one with an SSD.

  • @Gosu9765
    @Gosu9765 2 года назад +73

    That table was so wobbly it was actually distracting :)
    Never understood how the same company that pushed SSD only laptops was selling macs with spinning rust in them.
    It always bothered me they actually sell those. Cost cutting in worst place possible.

    • @brianmiller1077
      @brianmiller1077 2 года назад +8

      It was for the K-12 market where they're basically always on.

    • @Clarkzer0
      @Clarkzer0 2 года назад +23

      @@brianmiller1077 Having slow computers at school made me and my family purchase my own to bring in or use at home, three times until I was finished k-highschool, just because it's "for kids" doesn't mean it should be useless, and if we want them to have the tools necessary to succeed, we should actually be doing the opposite.

    • @meair
      @meair 2 года назад +1

      @@brianmiller1077 we had two of these in the GT room in my freshman year, easily the slowest computers. somehow the windows machines were faster

    • @wta1518
      @wta1518 2 года назад +8

      @@meair what do you mean "somehow"? MacOS takes forever to boot from an HDD, Windows has always taken slightly less than forever.

  • @angerylandbarge4352
    @angerylandbarge4352 2 года назад +16

    How the hell does a computer from 2017 boot slower than a base model iMac G3 slot loader and still have a value in 3 digits?

    • @the2323guy
      @the2323guy 2 года назад +2

      software inefficiency

    • @prplwzrd1720
      @prplwzrd1720 2 года назад +2

      @@the2323guy it’s the same reason why the iPad Air gen 2 lasted as long as it did

  • @Toma-621
    @Toma-621 2 года назад +5

    My school used these for our photography/photoshop class. Used it to get my adobe certification and I didn’t notice any issues for intensive photo manipulation. Of course the personal computer I had at the time was a lot worse so anything was much better

  • @taylor1038
    @taylor1038 2 года назад +1

    My old job bought one of the 5k iMacs with a 1TB HDD. They had this idea that just buying a new iMac meant it would be fast and didn't believe me when I complained of how unbearably slow it was. A big thing driving me out of that job was the glacially slow iMac for just doing simple things like opening Excel.

  • @jessemanex
    @jessemanex 2 года назад +2

    You could get an entry level gaming laptop for less than you would pay for that slow iMac.

  • @GalahadFranco
    @GalahadFranco 2 года назад +2

    5:32 "Now, to confirm my hypothesis..."
    Jonathan, you used hypothesis instead of theory. Thank you!!!

  • @lucasloud
    @lucasloud 2 года назад +27

    LTT: See, we’re not biased against Apple, we created Mac Address!
    Mac Address: “We bought the WORST Apple product!”

  • @markerichannelly
    @markerichannelly 2 года назад +73

    Worst part about it by far is the mechanical HDD. Crack it open and put in an SSD, or even put MacOS on an external USB or TB3 drive and it becomes so much more usable 🤷‍♂️

    • @FungleFunTime
      @FungleFunTime 2 года назад +13

      Crack is an an apt word here. That adhesive is so much fun!

    • @JeanSamyr
      @JeanSamyr 2 года назад +2

      @@FungleFunTime i hate how this adhesive glues to the frame, man, I spend more time cleaning the adhesive residue than servicing the machine.

    • @groszak1
      @groszak1 2 года назад

      No so usable anymore onece you write too much because SSD can't handle too many writes.

    • @benadamsondxb
      @benadamsondxb 2 года назад +3

      @@groszak1 Get Sensei from Cindori, it's a useful app and includes an Apple-certified TRIM enabler for your external SSD. Helps keep it healthy for much longer.

  • @5urg3x
    @5urg3x 2 года назад +34

    6:48 Do *NOT* sell the ram it comes with. If you ever do need a warranty claim, they will deny it, if the original OEM ram has been swapped out for 3rd party RAM.

    • @zoruaboy
      @zoruaboy 2 года назад

      Idk where you’re from but for users in the US, we have a law where it’s illegal to void a warranty for broken warranty stickers or modifications to the hardware
      Apple would have to prove that your modification is what’s causing the issue.

    • @5urg3x
      @5urg3x 2 года назад +1

      @@zoruaboy This is Apple we’re talking about here. You know that right? This is the company that told CBC that it would cost over $1000 to fix their MacBook Pro when all it needed was a new internal DisplayPort cable, or the pins unbent on the current cable, which could’ve been repaired in five minutes. They’ll use any excuse to sell you a new machine. And what are you going to do if they try to pull something? Hire a lawyer?

  • @MK73DS
    @MK73DS 2 года назад +4

    0:24 Well, that's all of their products isn't it?
    ...
    Hey, don't hit me, I'm just kidding, I have an Apple device... I own a sister who owns an iPhone!

  • @personwhohasnoname
    @personwhohasnoname 2 года назад +3

    I think I have an historic example of an amazing buy from the refurb store. In 2008 I bought a refurbished gen 1 iPod touch, which was used for work purposes so was able to claim it as a tax deduction. That iPod was used for 18 months for app testing, then "retired" to be used as a bedroom music player. It has been used almost every night and is still going strong.

  • @cobaltretrotech
    @cobaltretrotech 2 года назад +2

    I put a two and a half inch SATA SSD in my 2012 Mac Mini and it's boot time went from 5 minutes to 30 seconds. It's crazy how slow mechanical drives were and that we put up with them for so long

  • @alter-ego-
    @alter-ego- 2 года назад +20

    It's crazy!! I tried to buy an iPhone 11 Pro last month (wanted a decent 5.8" phone) and it still costs almost the same price as when it was released!!!

    • @JohnAdams-qc2ju
      @JohnAdams-qc2ju 2 года назад +7

      @PERLINNOISE Not when it is the same price as a 13 Pro. Often you can get it for $100 off but that is SOMETIMES. Unless you prefer buying 2 year old tech at the same price vs brand new stuff??

    • @tomwatts1692
      @tomwatts1692 2 года назад +1

      I went from an iPhone 11 Pro to and iPhone 13 (normal) and it's a massive improvement. Same physical size too

  • @tdm3bros
    @tdm3bros Год назад +1

    What is that 1080p screen for 170 bucks??? You can get 1440p ones for 60 bucks!

  • @MassiveDerek
    @MassiveDerek 2 года назад +1

    Costco is selling this for $599 with an SSD right now.

  • @hazqier
    @hazqier 2 года назад +1

    0:02 What music is that? It’s so relaxing and nice that I just want to fall asleep while listening to it.

  • @sekazi
    @sekazi 2 года назад +2

    My current 2015 model 15" MacBook Pro came from the Apple Refurbished store. What I like about the store is that the items look brand new. Zero scratches or anything. I am still using that same MacBook today and it still performs extremely well.

  • @saturnuria1217
    @saturnuria1217 2 года назад +2

    My Dad has one of these. It wasn’t a bad computer when he bought it but a few years ago it got dog slow. Probably the slowest computer I’d ever used. So I wiped it and it was all fine.
    Long story short, whenever the file system gets switched to APFS, the system slows to a crawl. I ended up cracking it open and replacing the Hard Drive with a cheap Crucial SSD. It was like a brand new computer again.
    After a lot of testing I was able to pretty much confirm that the combination of APFS and a spinning hard drive is the problem. I can’t explain it in any more detail but, as long as you avoid that combination, it’s a perfectly serviceable computer for email, web, office, etc.

  • @AndyofCT
    @AndyofCT 2 года назад +4

    my biggest fuck up was getting a 2017 27" iMac with the fusion drive. It's basically been relegated to a $1800 Netflix box since I picked up an M1 Pro MBP... but even 5 years later, that screen is still so pretty...

  • @theaterlightman89
    @theaterlightman89 2 года назад +1

    My first mac was a refurbed core 2 duo macbook from 2007... it's still running today... not as my daily driver though

    • @theaterlightman89
      @theaterlightman89 2 года назад

      The biggest problem that computer had was a 32mb shared video memory

  • @JeanSamyr
    @JeanSamyr 2 года назад +1

    On my College they had a lot of these iMacs, I remember to use verbose mode to delete the config file to create a new administrator user account to install anything that I like, and to bring a external SSD to run Win10 sometimes..

  • @saturnuria1217
    @saturnuria1217 2 года назад +2

    Just to repeat, the problem is APFS. An iMac with a hard drive will never be fast but, for some reason, combining an HDD with APFS is an absolute killer. Run the same HDD on HFS+ and it’s much, much more responsive. See my other comment for how I discovered this.

  • @gsblendzz
    @gsblendzz 2 года назад +1

    i bought one of these and couldnt stand the slowness so i used more money and bought an m1 iMac

  • @theolms8915
    @theolms8915 2 года назад +1

    Trust me, this is not the worst Apple product. The worst Apple product is the 2016 15” MacBook Pro or the iPhone 7.

  • @wescrowther655
    @wescrowther655 2 года назад +1

    I’m still running an iMac from late 09, 27” 2k screen, 32gb ram, 3.3ghz i7, Radeon 6970 2gb vid card, 2tb hybrid drive. Yes, I upgraded out of warranty with many creative parts. A lot of them. Still runs like a champ.

  • @sarahparrish7206
    @sarahparrish7206 2 года назад +14

    Of all the LMG channels, I love the production quality of this one the most. (This is not just because I'm an Apple fan, which I may be). I especially love the videos set outside, like the iPad one or the airtag one. Most creative imo

  • @hukmai
    @hukmai 2 года назад +6

    Funnily enough, at my local Costco the 21.5 inch imac with the 4k display and 8th gen i3-8100 ( 4c/4t) is 889$ while the one youre reviewing is
    (7th gen dual core hyper thread i5) is 600$ is good ole USA

  • @DetroitTintStudio
    @DetroitTintStudio 2 года назад +18

    I spent $1600ish on a 24inch iMac years ago (right before they launched the 27” iMac). I was so happy when I got it. Then later on I realized it’s horrible for gaming, couldn’t upgrade hardly anything but the ram. Can’t use it as an external display. It’s just a paper weight now, but it’s too pretty for me to just throw away.

    • @artemis4575
      @artemis4575 2 года назад +1

      you can stream cooking tutorials on it

    • @humanwaveform
      @humanwaveform 2 года назад +3

      Linux time

    • @rochitgurung9090
      @rochitgurung9090 2 года назад

      Football manager runs smoothly so I don’t need to upgrade anything

  • @EllieSky
    @EllieSky 2 года назад +1

    An SSD upgrade was the best thing I ever did for the family 2013, 21.5 inch iMac. Sped things up 10-fold and is still used pretty much daily to this day.

  • @brianmiller1077
    @brianmiller1077 2 года назад +8

    Many years ago, I ordered an i5 8 GB 2013 iMac from the refurb store and I got an i7 16 GB ram instead. I still use it everyday, but I really want the next iMac variant (even the low end M1 Pro will do). hopefully they will announce it at the March event.

  • @sanguinesomnambulist
    @sanguinesomnambulist 2 года назад +1

    @6:31 that is the most late 80s/early 90s computer I've seen that's basically new. Half as much RAM as it has Storage, and costs more than my first car.

  • @dtemp132
    @dtemp132 2 года назад

    I helped a family friend with a Late 2015 27” iMac running macOS 12 today. It had a 1TB spinner and ran like absolute garbage. The CPU or RAM wasn’t being taxed, and I don’t believe any program was hammering the disk. Disk Utility didn’t say there were SMART issues. But loading any program took minutes.

  • @Jan-vw5cg
    @Jan-vw5cg 2 года назад +1

    I absolutely love this channel. As a tech enthusiast, I love how your coverage is both critical and fair.

  • @Maximara
    @Maximara 2 года назад +1

    This is why you boot from an external SSD with any Mac with an internal platter drive. It is insanely slow to boot up. I got in the habit of booting from external drives as I went cheap and the internal HD were _slow_ .

  • @joshiepooh
    @joshiepooh 2 года назад +3

    You could get a baseline M1 Mini from Costco for $670 and have a 90 day return policy.

  • @djsnowpdx
    @djsnowpdx 2 года назад +46

    60-80 megabytes per second would be great.
    These drives run ideally at 60-80 megabits per second in the best case scenario, sequential reads. That’s 1/8 the speed of 60-80 megabytes per second, and it gets worse. In random data access, SSDs are 100+ times quicker to retrieve small bits of data, such as what is required to boot the machine and launch a program. In random data reads, though it is a flawed metric, you can expect hard drives to operate in the range of 1-2 megabits per second, and access latency doing one thing can be a couple of seconds. Access latency doing several things at once can be 30 seconds or more. Disgusting. You’d literally be better off installing the operating system to an SD card and putting it in the slot on the back.

    • @ElNeroDiablo
      @ElNeroDiablo 2 года назад +7

      Ehhh, presuming that's SATA III (6.0gbps, or 6000mbps) in question, that's a max theoretical throughput of 600MB/sec (using 8/10 encoding, 2 bits of parity for every 8 bits of data meaning 10b of throughput = 1B actually sent), and even high-end SATA SSD's have problems cracking the 550MB/sec mark.
      So 60-80MB/sec isn't too far-fetched for old spinning rust at 5400RPM made to go in a laptop, to cap out at.
      Now if we were talking PATA/IDE 5400RPM hard drives, they're even WORSE, as the IDE bus for drives capped out at 133MB/sec (just below the theoretical max throughput of 150MB/sec on a SATA I 1.5gbps/1500mbps bus) and the spinning rust couldn't fully saturate THAT at the time!

    • @andyrharris
      @andyrharris 2 года назад

      I have this computer at work and I barely ever use it cos it's so bad. I know they would never pay to replace or improve it, so I have actually bought a SD card which I plan to put the OS on.

    • @djsnowpdx
      @djsnowpdx 2 года назад

      @@andyrharris That’s what SSD enclosures are for. Why pay for the storage in an SD card when a real SSD is so much faster again? Running an OS from an SD card is rough. You’re right - it’s better than a hard drive, but again, an external SSD in an enclosure is a way better choice for that application, and would be a similar price per GB.

    • @djsnowpdx
      @djsnowpdx 2 года назад

      @@ElNeroDiablo You’re right. It was I, not Jonathan, who had megabits and megabytes confused. But the bigger point I’m trying to make is that hard drives perform way worse than 60-80 MB/s most of the time - SSDs excel in access latency. I’m sure you know that, but for anyone else reading who wonders why SSDs are touted as being so much quicker when they don’t look that much faster, looking at sequential performance alone.

  • @reganbrannigan3006
    @reganbrannigan3006 2 года назад

    My Mam and Dad both have an iMac from 2013 that both had hard drives. They were incredibly slow at doing any tasks and from my perspective weren’t usable. It kept on saying there wasn’t enough ram but what the problem was is that the hard drive was so incredibly slow it pretty much bricked the whole system. After a fresh ssd was installed they both now run much better, still slow, but now they’re at least usable.

  • @micahbdev
    @micahbdev 2 года назад

    We have a slower clocked version of this in my Graphic Design class... We get **nothing** done in that class.

  • @mitchhannon
    @mitchhannon 2 года назад

    The worst part of these machines is the awful integrated graphics trying to populate the screen. We had some designers stuck on these once, and while Photoshop or apps with rasterized images were usable, Illustrator or anything vector was the messiest most awful experience.

  • @DennisStewart
    @DennisStewart 2 года назад +1

    I'm not an apple user anymore, but I really appreciate the channels "pros/cons" weigh in for usability value vs $$.

  • @dtronic
    @dtronic 2 года назад

    Booting macOS on an external SSD and leaving the internal drive for storage is the way to go on these old iMacs. I've been doing it for years on my 2015 5k iMac. It's a great way to avoid having to take the screen off and the speed improvement is insane.

  • @YouAreBreathing
    @YouAreBreathing 2 года назад +1

    My oldest laptop that's currently working in my posession is an 11 year old Lenovo Thinkpad laptop, and I upgraded the spinning hard drive to an SSD.
    I only have hard drives for storage on my desktop computer, but I'm thinking of replacing them with SSDs, so the only spinning things in my desktop computer would be the fans on the CPU cooler, case fans, and video card fans.

  • @Ebalosus
    @Ebalosus 2 года назад +1

    TBF the education iMacs sucked back in the day too. I’ve always steered potential customers away from them.

  • @enjoyeverymomentvideos2687
    @enjoyeverymomentvideos2687 2 года назад +1

    I got 2017 27inch with 1tb fusion drive , it was to slow ...
    so what I end up doing was buying an external thunderbolt drive from tekq and now it's around 1.4gb/s and it takes around 20sec to boot it :)
    also bought a corsair ram and now it's 48gb from base 8gb that is unusable for photoshop with A7RIV.
    Now I don't fell a big difference between this and my m1 macbook pro base model.

  • @AmmarVanKorsha
    @AmmarVanKorsha 2 года назад

    My dad has the 4K model, and it was painfully slow. He thought it was from ram, so he got someone to upgrade it, nope! It was barely noticeably faster, but he upgraded the hard drive to an ssd and now it’s really fast!

  • @benhofb
    @benhofb 2 года назад

    The thing that genuinely destroys me is how Apple can sell these still and stick to their "vintage vs. obsolete" repair guidelines. Anything older than 5 years is considered "vintage" by them, and anything 7 and older is deemed "obsolete." Shouldn't they sell this as a "vintage refurbished" device then? And how long can they even guarantee any sort of Apple Care or manufacturer warranty on something like this? It's so nutty to me.

  • @mohammadhaitham5644
    @mohammadhaitham5644 2 года назад

    I work at an apple store, we have those backstage. Believe me when i tell you those take us a SHIT ton of time to boot

  • @JhonnyBomby
    @JhonnyBomby 2 года назад +1

    Oh so great I just realized that my computer is a laptop with a big screen

  • @JasonChamberlain
    @JasonChamberlain 2 года назад

    where i live, they do call it the “Refurbished and Clearance” section. Which to me supports the idea that some of the Macs aren’t actually used.

  • @MrTrickBrick
    @MrTrickBrick 2 года назад +5

    That moment when you've been binging this channel again and then they upload. Great well produced content as always. 👍

  • @_amrbadr_
    @_amrbadr_ 2 года назад +1

    no apple product is worse than 1k usd stand, hell the fuckin $20 polishing cloth is more useful

  • @glujaz
    @glujaz 2 года назад

    Fun fact, I have an old Mac mini from 2009 which I use as a server. It's still booting from a spinning drive, into Debian. Working pretty well ! 😬

  • @lucidnonsense942
    @lucidnonsense942 2 года назад

    The crazy memory iMacs were for institutions that, like university computer labs, that load a virtual machine into memory each time a user logs in. You have a "base image" on the harddrive, then user deltas get loaded off the central server. When you log out they get written. Since the whole filesystem exists in memory, they offer a decently fast experience.

  • @heyitsevan758
    @heyitsevan758 2 года назад +1

    I remember working with these at my old high school. When you are replacing the ancient eMacs in the spED department with these, it doesn’t seems as bad.

  • @StormagedonBOD
    @StormagedonBOD 2 года назад +1

    900$ for a dual core system, might as well overvolt a fan and put your money in

  • @BareFinn1986
    @BareFinn1986 2 года назад

    1:44 What sorcery is this?! Detachable cable?!

  • @sriramsundar8388
    @sriramsundar8388 2 года назад +2

    This iMac should've been discontinued all the way back in 2015 when the other 21.5 iMacs were updated to 4k resolution.

  • @aelaan12
    @aelaan12 2 года назад

    An anecdote: I am in a Jump+ store (September 2021) where I am dropping off my 15" 2015 to have the battery replaced under the exchange program. An older lady is waiting at the counter, she is very nervous and excited because she just purchased this model. In agony I see her pay well over 1200 Canadian dollars for the unit. I made some short talk with her about the weather and how beautiful the summer had been so far. She explained that her old MacBook Pro had been so slow (2012 model) and that she was now retired and did not need to travel with a computer, this was the best solution, in her eyes. The sales associatie started shooting daggers at me, but I never told her not to buy it.

  • @williamcharlesjames
    @williamcharlesjames 2 года назад

    The store is actually “Refurbished and Clearance”. There is a clearance section on the page but I haven’t soon anything there in a long time. I imagine they just sell those clearance products as refurbished either to make more money (clearance usually implies a bigger sale price) or to not have the “embarrassment” of having a product in clearance to prevent the _____ was a huge flop videos from being more prominent that they already are.

  • @idkjuststop
    @idkjuststop 2 года назад

    they just sell the leftovers that are already made of a discontinued model on a refurbished store

  • @fonskarssemakers
    @fonskarssemakers 2 года назад +4

    Buys crap so we don't have to...My man!

  • @jackliddell8739
    @jackliddell8739 2 года назад +1

    my school is full of these, and they're anemic af

  • @quitelikeryan
    @quitelikeryan 2 года назад

    2:37 that mac getting cut off in the top right corner… 😂

  • @goobfilmcast4239
    @goobfilmcast4239 2 года назад

    I have a similar setup for my M1 Mini....except I purchased a Cheapie Walmart ONN 4k 43 inch HDTV to use a Monitor....with a little tweaking of the color settings in both the TV and the Mac, I have an awesome budget setup.....my Mini...now 424 days old, is the fastest Mac I have ever owned (going all the way back to my first Performa in 1995). I fully intend to get the next-gen Mini and simply plunk it down in place of my current Mac. I will pass that one down to my niece.

  • @pitsnipe5559
    @pitsnipe5559 2 года назад

    Wow, who would have thought. Thanks for the info. Look forward to the next installment.

  • @aigorythmics8141
    @aigorythmics8141 2 года назад

    7:19 You put the speakers the wrong Sides. 😂

  • @Muhluri
    @Muhluri 2 года назад +6

    I was also browsing the refurbished section a while ago. I don’t know why anyone would spend nearly ~$1000 on a 2015 macbook when they can get a used M1 pro

    • @mxmobile5619
      @mxmobile5619 2 года назад

      Ports and the old design

    • @handlemonium
      @handlemonium 2 года назад

      Or the fact that the used Asus ZenBook I just snagged for under $250 has an 512GB SSD *and* a faster quad-core CPU (i5-8250U).

    • @dustojnikhummer
      @dustojnikhummer 2 года назад

      @@handlemonium 8250U for 250 dollars? Jeez

    • @handlemonium
      @handlemonium 2 года назад

      @@dustojnikhummer Yeah the guy ran out, but a few months ago I guess he refurbished a bunch and just wanted to get rid of em.
      The laptops themselves were 2017 refreshes of the same 2016 model.

  • @franklinjeh
    @franklinjeh 2 года назад +1

    Ouch, my iMac got "Worst Apple Product"... but mine has a Fusion drive and I bought it 3 years ago... so, not feeling too bad

  • @FlyingPigChannel
    @FlyingPigChannel 2 года назад +4

    I had to use an (I think exactly) identical mac configuration for communications tech. Absolute hot garbage, took minutes to boot up applications and was just a horrible experience. Thankfully we were allowed to use our own computers, and my 2015 MacBook Pro with a new NVMe ssd absolutely creamed that thing.

  • @mordecaiepsilon
    @mordecaiepsilon 2 года назад

    These videos always go way way deeper than the title would have you believe, but in the best way possible

  • @jenibond
    @jenibond 2 года назад +4

    There was trash can ! On apples Uk website !!!! ON the 3 Nov 2021 there was listed a 12 core 2.7 refurbished 6.1 mac pro still
    But for £5,149 (about $6,900usd) you have to be mad !!!

  • @suioganwilliam
    @suioganwilliam 2 года назад +1

    At least you got a stand.

  • @BerserkBrownie
    @BerserkBrownie 2 года назад

    "We bought the worst Apple product"
    me: you have any idea how little that narrows it down?

  • @only1gameguru
    @only1gameguru 2 года назад

    I had someone I worked with who got a 2018 Mac with an i3 8GB of ram and the 5.4k rpm driven... You can polish things so much before you realized you polished a paper weight

  • @axilleas
    @axilleas 2 года назад

    With the prices of SATA SSDs being what they are EVERY old computer should be upgraded with one. I refuse to use spinning drives for anything but data storage these days, it just isn’t worth it.

  • @foskr4
    @foskr4 2 года назад

    love how i just stumbled across this. My mums got this 2017 one and i always thought it was SO SLOW. Sad really for the price

  • @cohenturley2049
    @cohenturley2049 2 года назад

    “I think it’s a bad deal, that’s why I bought it” that matches my mindset a little too well sometimes

  • @pbpx
    @pbpx 2 года назад +2

    Helped a friend with their mac recently. it was slow as hell but he said it was brand new. This was the problem :(

    • @KHudso
      @KHudso 2 года назад

      Be a good friend and swap the HDD with an SSD. Night and day difference he will owe you big time lol

  • @weeksy79
    @weeksy79 Год назад

    They sell these for people who need like-for-like replacements on weird/unique systems. Normally in those scenarios you get completely gauged, so this is a good deal

  • @SammyDumanauw
    @SammyDumanauw 2 года назад

    The moment you said “hard-drive” that’s when I straight away say “GET OUTTA HERE”

  • @JoshGuessWho
    @JoshGuessWho 2 года назад

    “It’s not expensive”, the proceeds to show us a computer for $900. Not including taxes and shipping.

  • @HenrikoMagnifico
    @HenrikoMagnifico Год назад

    Apple refurbished store doesn't exist in scandinavia sadly :/

  • @n00dle_king
    @n00dle_king 2 года назад

    You complained about needing to use a SATA SSD if you upgraded, but testing on the LTT channel revealed that in real world tests the difference between NVMe and SATA was not noticeable. Granted that was gaming load times, but I'd expect OS loads to be similar.

  • @noirarmire1246
    @noirarmire1246 2 года назад

    I'm a PC guy, but I was thinking of buying an Mac mini that is referbished. I'm just waiting for a 16gb M1 referb to show up. I want to play around with it for some light audio and random photo editing so I don't want to buy brand new as it'll probably sit unused most of the time. I don't hate apple products, I just think they have a specific use case and not daily drivable for the average person. But Great video as always Jonathan. Perhaps a video on features new Mac users should know and the history of how they came about or how to easily transition?

  • @Dygear
    @Dygear 2 года назад

    I had the 2015 version of this and yeah, it was not great for startup, but once it got running! Once it got running it ... still wasn't great.

  • @EastsideBodega_
    @EastsideBodega_ 2 года назад

    That camera angle @ 02:06 can really be used as a 2010’s case study of Apple’s minimalist design aesthetic

  • @gammaboost
    @gammaboost 2 года назад

    I have a base model mid 2011 iMac running High Sierra, that I upgraded to 12gb. It's never been opened fully and is almost definitely filled to the brim with dust, as I could see when upgrading the RAM, but it still boots faster than this Mac. In all my experience with old computers with HDDs, it's never been this slow to boot. In fact, those computers were actually usable.