Tosca: “Vissi d’arte”

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 16 дек 2024

Комментарии • 251

  • @josevillagarciamunoz3426
    @josevillagarciamunoz3426 6 лет назад +43

    Amazing
    She is perfect! I was there, she touched my soul and made me cry.
    Then I told her and thanked for her performance.

    • @debbiejohnson2789
      @debbiejohnson2789 4 года назад +4

      Jose’ you were so lucky to have been there!! God bless you, Sir!

  • @Knightoftheorient
    @Knightoftheorient 7 лет назад +27

    Magnificently performed not only vocally but in terms of expressing the raw emotion too.

  • @annina123100
    @annina123100 6 лет назад +8

    I just saw her this afternoon. Its been a long long time since I have seen a Tosca played with such depth and passion. After a few years ago's modern version of Tosca - this was a beautiful blessing. The stage scenes were amazing and I could actually feel tosca's hatred for the pig police lieutenant and her love for her painter lover. Sonya Yoncheva was absolutely amazing...Cant wait to see her in La Boheme.

  • @oddbod8655
    @oddbod8655 2 года назад +1

    For me this is the most beautiful and best rendition of the song I have heard. Its made me cry. Bravo.x

  • @johnparti2460
    @johnparti2460 6 лет назад +3

    I'm back again. Can't get enough . How I love the pain.

  • @vasilikos12
    @vasilikos12 6 лет назад +71

    please don't criticize opera through a video.opera is meant to be experienced live.anything else cannot even reflect the live performance.

  • @Cinetyk
    @Cinetyk 3 месяца назад

    You can even see a tear streaking down her face, alongside the very smooth vocal performance. Very nice.

  • @corneliusbates460
    @corneliusbates460 2 года назад +3

    She is a beast here. The voice the acting
    Amazing

  • @peteradaniel
    @peteradaniel 5 лет назад +1

    She breaths every other second and it's so high.

  • @johnpillow481
    @johnpillow481 4 года назад +2

    Beautifully sung and wonderfully acted. What more can you want?!

  • @richardtaylor1197
    @richardtaylor1197 4 года назад

    Just wonderful! She was just brilliant in this entire opera. Watched it several times....one of the best Toscas.

  • @SimonBostic
    @SimonBostic 7 лет назад +43

    It seems this remarkable lady can turn her wonderful voice to almost anything right now. What an exciting prospect she is - have seen her 5 or 6 times now at Covent Garden (Antonia, Norma, Marguerite, Michaela etc.) and each time she has blown the audience away with her bright and excitingly edgy yet beautiful tone. However, I do SO hope she is not doing too much too quickly and learning too many roles. Time to consolidate now and perfect, perfect, perfect and PROTECT. The MET and her management MUST work with her to protect this most wonderful instrument from overuse and over extension too quickly. What a devastating loss it would be if her voice were to develop problems and cause her early decline. Back to UK ASAP please, Sonya. We adore you!

    • @OLIVCHEN77
      @OLIVCHEN77 7 лет назад +6

      I would agree with her Michaela, her fantastic Marguerite- the Antonia was ok- but Norma was a mistcast. Its so sad- she sings a repertoire which is doesnt suit her- Ich befürchte die Party wird bald vorbei sein...Schade

    • @SimonBostic
      @SimonBostic 7 лет назад +1

      NEIN... kann und soll nicht sein! :(

    • @pj10128NY
      @pj10128NY 3 года назад

      Like Levine did to Scotto?

  • @johnparti2460
    @johnparti2460 Год назад

    I couldn't stay away from this one. That one lonely little tear.

  • @theoldar
    @theoldar 7 лет назад +26

    She was fabulous last year in Traviata. She should be great in Tosca as well.

    • @jermainejr11
      @jermainejr11 7 лет назад +4

      theoldar, YES THE HELL SHE WAS!!!

    • @MaxPilloni
      @MaxPilloni 6 лет назад +2

      Well, they are two different parts which need two different voices.I don't find her "ready" and there are points in which in the registration seems to lack energy and "espressione". I hope I'll have the change to listen her Tosca live and make a myself a real opinion because registrations are not the best way to judge a singer.Tonight I'll see her at Teatro alla Scala for the general rehearsal of Bellini's "Il pirata" and I lvoed her twice for last year's "La bohème" :)

  • @debbiejohnson2789
    @debbiejohnson2789 4 года назад

    She is so fantastic!! . Beautiful, strong voice. I will keep listening to her.

  • @Muttonchop_USA
    @Muttonchop_USA 7 лет назад +1

    Just saw the premier. It doesn't get better than this!

  • @nataliayatsevich2934
    @nataliayatsevich2934 7 лет назад +5

    Браво! Великолепно изпълнение.
    Bravo! Magnificent performance.

  • @lissandrafreljord7913
    @lissandrafreljord7913 6 лет назад +37

    I have been on a Tosca RUclips spree. So far, no performer has moved me on this aria like Maria Callas has. But I must say, this lady here is pretty good. She has a great voice and technique, and by the ending, she managed to loosen up from focusing too much on the technique and actually connect emotionally to the song. When she shed that tear it felt pretty real.

    • @pugh.joseph
      @pugh.joseph 3 года назад

      If you are still on that Tosca RUclips spree, you might like this audio recording with Corelli,Price and MacNeil. I have only done half of the subtitles but I will probably get it all done within 1-2 weeks from today 👍

    • @loornard
      @loornard 2 года назад

      try Angela gheorghiu at the ROH . Divine !

    • @araucariapasquale1
      @araucariapasquale1 2 года назад +1

      Generic waffle. You don't know squat about opera.

    • @amaliacarocci8269
      @amaliacarocci8269 2 года назад

      La Callas la divina..prima al mondo ..la Garifullina è la seconda..voce forte e bella.

    • @judith6571
      @judith6571 Год назад +1

      @@araucariapasquale1 I am with you. ( "Pretty") as he would say, arrogant.

  • @operaforever13
    @operaforever13 6 лет назад +7

    Beautiful Tosca! Regret to read the systemic negative trolling below. It does not matter one little bit for those who witnessed the magic yesterday . What an amazing performance!

  • @duffman7793
    @duffman7793 7 лет назад +24

    I was there last night this Woman is a vocal beast

  • @MyLady120
    @MyLady120 5 лет назад +1

    Beautiful voice and song!!

  • @johnnyyu819
    @johnnyyu819 3 года назад

    Bravo!!!....such devoted emotion expressed so brilliantly yet tenderly !!

  • @brianhamilton4911
    @brianhamilton4911 6 лет назад

    All three soloists hit it out of the park today. Great performance.

  • @glennmosher1338
    @glennmosher1338 Год назад

    Fantastic rendition of this classic!

  • @tylercesario1427
    @tylercesario1427 4 года назад +1

    I would like to say that Sonya is the singer who made me fall in love with this roll. The definitive Toscas are her and Shirley verret for me.

  • @ppanggoo98
    @ppanggoo98 5 лет назад +2

    I love you sonya♥ I'm your big fan!!!!

  • @ludwigvanbeethoven4215
    @ludwigvanbeethoven4215 6 лет назад +1

    Beautiful Sonya !

  • @FranciscoFerrerGaliana1930
    @FranciscoFerrerGaliana1930 7 лет назад +11

    Maravillosa Aria en la voz de Sonya Yoncheva..!!!

  • @seanxu1802
    @seanxu1802 4 года назад +5

    This aria sung by her is worth listening to again and again.

  • @johnparti2460
    @johnparti2460 6 лет назад +43

    I don't get it. Some people can talk about the woman like she's nothing. Callas got some tears out of me with this one, but this woman FAR SURPASSED the emotion brought with Callas. The orchestra actually had to wait for her to get her composure. She really was crying. FABULOUS

    • @jvonm618
      @jvonm618 3 года назад

      I agree - I find her performance more powerful

  • @rojasrod
    @rojasrod 7 лет назад +68

    Very nice. A bit of a Callas-esque color to her voice (this is a compliment)

    • @jermainejr11
      @jermainejr11 7 лет назад +2

      Rojaslee Violin, I noticed that too and I love it! Such a sublime and even sound! Love Yoncheva!

    • @tristanhnl
      @tristanhnl 7 лет назад +5

      Agreed, she has a nice smokey/grainy colour. I also love how her vibrato wobbles on that Bb like Callas, too.

    • @junefun55
      @junefun55 7 лет назад +3

      Rojaslee Violin more than a bit like Callas, wobble and back of the throat . It’s an impersonation not a performance?

    • @justintime42000
      @justintime42000 7 лет назад +1

      junefun55 No soprano would impersonate another singer’s wobble or purposely force one from their voice.

    • @rojasrod
      @rojasrod 7 лет назад

      Cathy Wood gosh, nobody claimed it was an impersonation.

  • @cescman47
    @cescman47 4 года назад

    This is a magnificent rendering of this most famous of arias in the most iconic role Tosca, although I haven’t seen the whole performance of the opera yet- I’m saving it for when I go onto Met on demand- I am mightily impressed. Like a lot of other comments have said her voice has a lovely dark rich quality which really does remind you of Callas. Having said that Yoncheva is a superb soprano in her own right, and just hearing her sing this aria makes me forget all the terrible atmosphere and woes of our current situation. Once we get through this dark period I will look forward to getting the chance to see her live at the opera again. Let’s all keep listening to these wonderful videos. Long live opera, long live RUclips.

  • @justintime42000
    @justintime42000 7 лет назад +3

    Beautiful singing! I liked this better on my second listen than the first. I can feel the emotion. If you can’t, try just listening. Inside the Met she should sound fantastic. I’ll be there in a few weeks!

    • @booe34
      @booe34 6 лет назад

      Did you enjoy? I was there on the 23rd

    • @justintime42000
      @justintime42000 6 лет назад

      booe34 Yes, I enjoyed it very much.

  • @robertryan952
    @robertryan952 4 года назад +1

    My favorite aria.

  • @oper2307
    @oper2307 7 лет назад +10

    Это потрясающе ♥️

  • @aliciasarramida
    @aliciasarramida 7 лет назад +3

    Wonderful Sonya ♥

  • @colinbrigham8253
    @colinbrigham8253 2 года назад

    Thank you that was very moving 😔

  • @jeremycouplan3526
    @jeremycouplan3526 6 лет назад +6

    Wonderful, I can hear Maria Callas in her voice. X

  • @danbarthy3819
    @danbarthy3819 7 лет назад +2

    Belíssimo! Brava!!! 👏

  • @marie-louiseericsson9252
    @marie-louiseericsson9252 4 года назад

    Lot s of love from me in Sweden 🇸🇪❤️

  • @doyleperkins4916
    @doyleperkins4916 4 года назад

    The most beautiful Aria in all Opera...It is as if angels were singing in One Voice....

  • @alastairkerr6081
    @alastairkerr6081 2 года назад

    Beautiful Voice, WOW !!!

  • @elenawinellcomposer
    @elenawinellcomposer 6 лет назад +4

    I saw her in this role in January and she was fantastic. She 100% consciously channeled 60's Callas in this role and I didn't mind it (it's the only era of hers that people can try to impersonate, ya can't impersonate 50's Callas...just can't be done). Her Violetta was better than the Met's had in a good while. She's taking on Cherubini's Medea within the year so I definitely think Callas's influence is felt through her which I appreciate and just hope she doesn't spread herself too thin.

    • @jjh2456
      @jjh2456 6 лет назад

      Spencer Winell She’s also singing Norma soon.

  • @brianhamilton4911
    @brianhamilton4911 6 лет назад +1

    Never saw so many negative comments. Everybody is an expert!!

  • @MrPAPAGAYO46
    @MrPAPAGAYO46 5 лет назад +9

    La voz de la soprano Sonya Yoncheva cantando este fragmento de Tosca, me recuerda mucho el timbre de la ya desaparecida Maria Callas. La intensidad y sentimiento de su fraseo, respirando pausada y con técnica, logra también una perfecta vocalización, ninguna nota se le quiebra ni siquiera en el agudo final. Creo que con su canto, Sonya Yoncheva le rinde un admirable tributo a su antecesora.

  • @johnb340
    @johnb340 Год назад

    Beautiful

  • @MsManners123
    @MsManners123 4 года назад

    Absolutely beautifully heartbreaking!

  • @debbiejohnson2789
    @debbiejohnson2789 4 года назад

    This lady is unbelievable!

  • @rosofficesolutionsinc1572
    @rosofficesolutionsinc1572 2 года назад

    Thank you Ann G for introducing me to Tosca and the opera 22 years ago.

  • @xanthirudha
    @xanthirudha 3 года назад

    WOW this is heaven

  • @LornaKellyZim
    @LornaKellyZim 3 года назад

    Just listened to Netrebko sing this aria then came across this recording of Sonya's and how fresh and uncontrived it sounds by comparison. Quite moving and beautiful.

  • @davidsohngen2021
    @davidsohngen2021 6 лет назад +2

    Фантастична!!!❤️❤️❤️

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +5

    a little colors of callas or an
    imitation of callas natural
    voice and then,people got
    crazy about new sopranos!!
    let maria callas rest in peace
    please!!once and for all!!
    thanks!!

  • @mariacasemyr
    @mariacasemyr 6 лет назад

    Stunning ❤️

  • @Jaydoggy531
    @Jaydoggy531 7 лет назад +2

    Incredible set and cast. This will be one for the ages. I admit I'm happy to see Bondy's idea a thing of the past.

  • @mariacasemyr
    @mariacasemyr 5 лет назад

    Very beautiful performance of this marvellous aria by Puccini

  • @johnparti2460
    @johnparti2460 4 месяца назад

    I watched each and every rendition of this aria. This woman is the VERY BEST,,,, nobody better.

  • @npdtprocess
    @npdtprocess 3 года назад +1

    Giacomo Puccini - Tosca, Vissi D' Arte (High-Quality Audio)
    ruclips.net/video/q4naxCoTGqI/видео.html
    processed using NPDT Process
    #giacomopuccini
    #mariacallas
    #tosca
    #highquality
    #npdtprocess

  • @petercallahan7321
    @petercallahan7321 6 лет назад +7

    Love youtube "experts" who say she's taking on too much too soon. She's in her late 30s, about the same age every famous Tosca who ever sang the part sang wa. Is she just supposed to sing Mimi forever? And maybe people should get out and actually attend the opera instead of giving themselves authorities based on recordings of Callas in relation to videos of Yoncheva on youtube from an HD broadcast. We are, I assume, talking about a living art form.
    Also in case anyone has actually bothered to attend opera in the past century, the last Tosca productions were premiered by Hildegard Behrens and Karita Mattila respectively and revivals were populated by the likes of Urmana, Racette, Malfitano, and late Vaness. Anyone who can say in all sincerity that those women were better Tosca's than what is in this video clearly don't care about music as such. ALL of those ladies had problems with the notes and none of them had anything remotely resembling the style, which Yoncheva audibly does.

  • @JB-uy8uo
    @JB-uy8uo Год назад

    Can someone please tell me who this is? Thanks! Frustrating that if you're trying to learn about Opera they don't tell you who the singer is. Some of the comments say it is Sonia but I don't know who that is. Thank you if anyone can help!

  • @shodanart
    @shodanart 6 лет назад

    Lovely!

  • @Colin-wd9fu
    @Colin-wd9fu Год назад

    I agree 😊

  • @СеклитаЛимариха

    Люблю Тоску.

  • @PurpleShaman121
    @PurpleShaman121 9 месяцев назад

    As much as i love Angela Gheorghiu's singing voice, i have to admit that her version to this aria is seriously lacking for some reason but that this singer has totally nailed it. 10/10 easily ...

  • @MaestroWenarto
    @MaestroWenarto 7 лет назад +10

    to the MET technician, how come her voice comes only from my right speaker?

    • @MrQwerty88
      @MrQwerty88 7 лет назад +3

      It comes from both speakers on mine

    • @MaestroWenarto
      @MaestroWenarto 7 лет назад +2

      hmmm. maybe my system but I have three computers at home with three different sound system

    • @MASMusic1102
      @MASMusic1102 7 лет назад +1

      She appears to be standing very far to STAGE RIGHT (that's Audience Left!) Perhaps the stereo effect is emphasizing her stage position, which would put most of her voice primarily on the LEFT speaker, perhaps your speakers are connected backwards?

    • @eilishfriedman6361
      @eilishfriedman6361 7 лет назад

      Maestro Wenarto ii

    • @juliatimmons2542
      @juliatimmons2542 6 лет назад

      I have the same problem, just on the left

  • @guldenvurandemir6859
    @guldenvurandemir6859 3 года назад

    a delicious review

  • @organojid
    @organojid 6 лет назад

    Брава Соня Йончева! Прекрасное исполнение!:-*

  • @yuki_t_soprano
    @yuki_t_soprano 6 лет назад

    God all these comments about how this role is wrong or right for her... everybody has a different opinion about every singer, i should know. Truth is, some people just tell their opinion though they don’t have ANY IDEA how to actually sing. Unfortunately, these people are often opera directors, too. Says how wrong the world is. I think that people should sing roles that suit them. Of course, there are Fachs, but some roles can be sung by different kinds of voices (of course I’m not saying that a Königin der Nacht can sing Walküre, but lirico, lirico-spinto...really ??) All I see and hear is that Yoncheva sings this beautifully with a musicality that begins to be rare these days and that she gave me freaking goosebumps (am I the only one who saw that she actually shed a tear ??) anyways, please stop saying “she is this or that so she couldn’t sing this or that”. Isn’t it all about music ? You could say “I don’t like her in this role because....” or “I prefer this other singer” but please stop trying to say that you know the whole truth. Because the whole truth is that no one has no fucking idea.
    Please feel concerned if you feel concerned. I’m not pointing fingers.
    I love music. Peace.

    • @johnparti2460
      @johnparti2460 6 лет назад

      No you're not the only one. That sweet face twisted when the pain was realized, then that one teardrop on her right cheek. I'm hooked. Nobody like her. (she got more than one teardrop out of me)

  • @housecaesarscaliphs9205
    @housecaesarscaliphs9205 Год назад

    Magic

  • @commandert5
    @commandert5 3 года назад +1

    Interesting that she doesn't (as far as I can tell) fall to her knees here. I wonder what the director's thought behind that was

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +3

    can people let callas rest in
    peace?any new soprano is
    compare to callas!!callas was
    unique in so many ways.
    read the book about her by
    her husband meneghinni
    thats a good description
    of voice,talent,hard work
    and ambition. let maria
    callas rest in peace for
    once and for all!!

  • @willowcitron9519
    @willowcitron9519 7 лет назад +2

    What is the matter with you people. Can't you just enjoy a beautiful aria sung by a wonderful singer and leave it at that?

    • @certoromano59
      @certoromano59 4 года назад +1

      It is a beautiful aria, she is a great singer, but....no Tosca! The voice is cold, no passion, almost metallic with heavy breathing....

  • @demetrisefpraxias250
    @demetrisefpraxias250 7 лет назад

    Oh these big cheasted sopranos!She really has the lungs for it and she is very good!malatets!mprava!

  • @Maso_Ndy
    @Maso_Ndy 7 лет назад +4

    Beautiful. Her voice reminds me of Callas

  • @ChrisBartleyLeo
    @ChrisBartleyLeo 3 года назад

    She sounds similarly to Callas to me. I love it

  • @thomasscottwilliams6672
    @thomasscottwilliams6672 4 года назад +3

    Every performance is unique and beautiful and opera is an incredibly difficult art form, so let’s celebrate it not criticise.

  • @riccardograndi5368
    @riccardograndi5368 4 года назад

    Has anyone noticed the tear on his cheek? Great interpretation! Although few details can be improved

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +4

    ponselle was very good in
    traviata!!there is her live
    performance from 1935!!
    and she was a dramatic
    soprano with a great colo
    ratura technique,but!!she
    never,ever sang puccini
    like the great italian drama
    tic soprano anita cerquetti
    who wants to sings traviata
    and never did,because her
    weight!!then came caballe
    who was bigger!!hello?and
    sang violeta succesfully!!
    cerquetti like ponselle never
    ever sang puccini.

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +8

    attempting to famous bflat
    she has tremolous in the
    b flat!!means she is forcing
    her essentially lyric soprano
    voice!!

  • @tashah.3082
    @tashah.3082 3 года назад

    ❤️❤️❤️

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +1

    at least they had great drama
    tics voices!!thats exactly
    what we lacking today!!*in
    any repertoire!! verdi o pucci
    ni,wagner and the others
    give me brake homo.

  • @maximusextreme3725
    @maximusextreme3725 6 лет назад

    Czas Honoru season 4 brought me here 😊

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +3

    what about callas low register?those cavernous
    dramatic,powerful!!resonant
    low notes?you can find those
    notes in parsifal or in la
    gioconda!!middle and low
    register are important too!!
    no only the high notes!!high
    notes are for ignorant peo
    ple!!

  • @marisarossi6692
    @marisarossi6692 Год назад

    brava.

  • @juancarlostealdo
    @juancarlostealdo Год назад

    Maria Callas was unique,this Soprano is very good,but Callas a goddess.

  • @bvvloten84
    @bvvloten84 5 лет назад

    Is this Goddess crying in the end? I know she made me...

  • @daniel_5606
    @daniel_5606 6 лет назад +1

    Buena voz, me recuerda a Mirella Freni

  • @ПавелПогорелов
    @ПавелПогорелов 6 лет назад +1

    Дорогие друзья меломаны и любители оперы!!! Вам не показалось что пение Сони Енчевой в этой арии очень напоминает Марию К.? Как будто по пластинке учила партию.

    • @alexusachev1
      @alexusachev1 6 лет назад +1

      Да, что-то есть. Включил тихо на фоне, показалось, что видео переключилось. Что-то есть в тембре и манере. Мб учила по записям Каллас и скопировала манеру

    • @ПавелПогорелов
      @ПавелПогорелов 6 лет назад

      Александр Усачев здравствуйте, не в обиду памяти Марии К. Но как сказал про неё Николай Гедда :-Как горячая картошка во рту!!! Звук как будто в щеках путается, или щеки резонируют. На мой слух у обеих одинаково.

    • @alexusachev1
      @alexusachev1 6 лет назад

      У Каллас были недостатки в голосе, но все же она гениальная певица, у нее ясно слышна старая школа бельканто, которой больше практически никто не обладает. Слышал у итальянских басов и баритонов, и то немногих

    • @ПавелПогорелов
      @ПавелПогорелов 6 лет назад

      Александр Усачев о!!!! Да вы уже не спите!!!! У нас в Новосибирске 6.35 утра. На счёт её школы мне трудно говорить, я очень мало божественную Марию слушал. Хотя по мнению одной " специалистки" вокал её"" сплошная" химия", всё на горле. Но по сути она уникальный исполнитель. Три голоса в одной глотке как говорили её современники.

    • @alexusachev1
      @alexusachev1 6 лет назад +1

      Я бы сказал не "уже", а "еще". Москва 2:43. Собственно, 3 голоса в одном и есть ее недостаток и еще все остальные, вытекающие из него

  • @peteradaniel
    @peteradaniel 7 лет назад +3

    Vibraaaattooo

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +6

    i like bigger voices for tosca
    than her!!in no time she is
    going to loose her voice
    if she is keeping tosca and
    others dramatics roles in
    her repertoire!!. remember
    the sad case of the italian
    essentially lyric soprano
    katia. ricciarelli,von karajan
    destroid her voice or she
    died on herself!!

    • @westleymontgomery3242
      @westleymontgomery3242 7 лет назад +1

      Alfredo Loyola have you heard her voice in the house? It’s quite a large instrument.

    • @vinnytesla9731
      @vinnytesla9731 7 лет назад

      shut the fuck up....you're annoying

  • @coda_o7
    @coda_o7 6 лет назад +2

    Apparently, because it's Opera, all the snooty would-be critics decided to come jizz all over the comments section >.> smdh

  • @mariorossi1067
    @mariorossi1067 6 лет назад

    Ottimo! Migliora le doppie nella pronuncia italiana!

  • @ethangalloway7342
    @ethangalloway7342 5 лет назад

    Damn girl.

  • @roydlchen2004
    @roydlchen2004 6 лет назад +2

    How come only Montserrat Caballe can sing the word Signor in one breath?

    • @alvarodecampostabacaria4223
      @alvarodecampostabacaria4223 5 лет назад

      Really? Have you listened to all records or all live shows from all times? And are you sure not to sing the whole signor is not a choice? I'm astonished how people can come up with statements like yours...

  • @user-ic5xu4jh6z
    @user-ic5xu4jh6z 4 года назад +2

    Awful chin movement, throaty, knödel, too airy...she sings about her life she spent for art and love? Well, maybe love but not for art....she makes beginners mistakes and nobody seemed to have worked with her on the lyrics...no quality, no chestvoice, only pretending the drama of Tosca. Opera is much more than nice costumes, it must go to the heart! But as long as the audience is happy with this stuff, nothing will change. If someone is really interested in higher quality he can listen very closely to old records and compare many artists and their expression. There was a time of revival of bel canto ( Tebaldi, Callas, Del Monaco, Granforte, etc) which was much better than this new style of 'singing'. Old shool singers are much more audible, they never sang it in an easy light or weak way like today, its exhausting, this was art!! Im also very unhappy to read about peoples comments and their opinions about good or bad- its not about personal taste it is about correct technique and knowledge of pyhsic and anatomy. The audience always decides- they pay!!, but they should not go so far to call someone good, if they have no idea about it, but they can say i like it or not. By the way some opera celebrities have also no idea about correct singing. Poor students spend a lot of money in private lessions and get nothing than hot air- same on unsiversities today...

  • @mechilu
    @mechilu 6 лет назад +1

    TE AMO

  • @burxana22
    @burxana22 3 года назад +3

    This is rubbish, all amplified by mics. The high notes are lacking depth and squillo.

  • @СеклитаЛимариха
    @СеклитаЛимариха 4 года назад

    Люблю всіх Тосок світу.. Але... Але де ви - Гоббі-Каллас-Кореллі?..

  • @alfredoloyola921
    @alfredoloyola921 7 лет назад +1

    who are you,to told me to
    stop my comments?if do
    not like my comments!!
    simply do not read them!!
    as simple as that!! i have
    the right to comment like
    everyone else. i do not
    do you any favor,my
    comments are my comments
    you like it or not!!if you do
    not like it?i said again!!do not
    read my comments!!
    happy new year!!

  • @andrenewcomb3708
    @andrenewcomb3708 7 лет назад +1

    Lush orchestra. Should be a candle front & center at singer's eye level for her to sing to.

    • @andrenewcomb3708
      @andrenewcomb3708 7 лет назад +1

      With air so still that her breath moves light.