Is Israel losing the information war on Gaza? | UpFront
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 окт 2024
- Marc Lamont Hill talks to documentary producer Sut Jhally about Israel’s information warfare strategy.
As Israel's attacks on Rafah spark public outrage, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's war campaign is coming under fire despite continued support from the United States, raising questions about the efficacy of Israel's public relations strategy.
Sut Jhally’s 2016 documentary The Occupation of the American Mind exposes the extensive pro-Israeli propaganda that has been targeting American audiences for decades. Since October 7, this narrative, which focuses on combating "terrorism" and the dehumanisation of Palestinians, has intensified.
As the world continues to witness the horrors committed in Gaza, is Israel losing the war for public opinion? Does this signal the decline of a once renowned propaganda machine?
This week on UpFront, Marc Lamont Hill speaks with Jhally, professor emeritus of communication at the University of Massachusetts in Amherst and founder and executive director of the Media Education Foundation, about the media narrative shaping public opinion on Israel’s war on Gaza.
It is embarrassing that the IDF after almost 8 months has not been able to fight an enemy without tanks, modern artillery, fighter jets in an area a marathon runner would have run across in 6 hours
Its so sad that youtube thumbs up is only one time..i would like your comment for 1000 times
What do you expect from the Diaper Force? 😂😂
Thank you Al Jazeera!! ❤️
The complicity of global governments in silencing dissent and genocide is unprecedent
Global cesnorship = Global fascism...
@@theseustoo We actually ought to recognize fascism when we see it by now.
Can't people just be on the right side of humanity!? Why is this so difficult?
The Milgram experiment suggests about 65% of humanity needs a leader to dictate their values to them while 35% of us lose our minds. Fascinating experiment, and its kind of amazing there has been no further endeavors to understand this better, unless you realize its probably going to get you tossed out of grad school. Jung vs Bernays, what side of history are you on?
I swear I feel so alone when I ask the same question.
Ahha Victim card
Religious divide
Always has been
Greed, Money, Oil off Gaza's shore in the Mediterranean.
Well done Marc L.
Losing?! Lost. Just lost and gone for good.
Thanks to TikTok for allowing pro-🇵🇸 content
Will the world ever see or know peace so long as zionist israel is permitted to continue to exist????
That's WHY the US congress wants to ban TikTok.
AIPAC is trying to stop that
Thanks to I'D'F self-snitchers for shamelessness & hubris that tells us really everything that they shouldn't want us to know.
If lsræI was not deluded, it woukd have banned Tik-Tok.
Totally. GenZ & Millennials do deep dives that blow my mind. That's why z**nists want it banned in the US 😊✌️
You can't spell ISRAEL without LIARS 😏
Liars extraordinaire (for left over e)🇪🇭🇪🇭🇪🇭
And you can't spell Hamas without HAM: paLaStInE, also contains LIES... and PANTS.
You are all right ✅
🎯💯🇵🇸✊.
😂 exactly
Well done for differentiating between Judaism and Israel.
Even my cat knows Israel is a liar 👈😺
This is something that is contentious with my acquaintances, its constant, like they are just trying to see what they can get away with. You can't give them an inch or they will be racketeering.
Now that's a smart cat.
So u and ur cat support Hamas got it.
@@davidmhale521the car support humanity, but guess what don’t be sad we saw a snake nearby it supports Israel
Not surprising, as you aren't any different from your cat.
Go live with hamas ok..
The mask is slipping
The mask is on the floor
The IOF are using this mask as a diaper.
the mask came off months ago.
Yes......everyone now knows what liars they are.....especially Netanyahu!
Israel has gone ftom bad to worse
And will get away with it backed by the US
And from worse to worser!
Agreed. I rarely pray. But I do pray that the horrors israel is inflicting on Gazans will one day knock upon every israeli home.
No peace while peace is denied to others.
@@Emmadaniels100i don't see hamas winning
Horrific to even more horrific.
Great interview. Thanks for sharing it.
Free free pelestine,Isreal stop Genocide
October 7th - never forget, never forgive 🇮🇱
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Yes, free palestine from hamas...
Take off the aluminum hat
Son of God does not mean that God has a child in Christianity!
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
*what a mistake in the Qur'an!*
Allah himself testifies that he has a son and he is the son as Christians understand it! Only the Koran writer was too ignorant to know what Son of God means! Allah's word which created everything is Allah himself too! *The Word Allahs which created everything is the Son of God according to Christianity!*
How Anti-logic, Anti-dialogue, Anti-Humanity Anti- Sanity The War Profiteers Must Always Be.
Lie never win over truth
Criticize Israel on social media will result in you comment being deleted 👎🏾🇿🇦💔💯
Israel is a despicable entity!!!!!! 😆
It is true i face many time, ❤ 🇿🇦
💯 truth!
says the guy on the most ONE SIDED Media
Nonsense
Need to get a whistleblower from their botfarms.
Very informative guest, and Marc gets straight to the point as always. Thank you
Without Al Jazeera we would all be much worse off, thank you for shining a ray of truth.
I agree!
100%
a shame for the brain wash, 100%you our more younger then older
@@rachelshreiber7735 Feel free to write in your native language. We can use Google Translate.
MARC LAMONT HILL bravo! i solute you you are simple show the world true issue. please keep such good job
Great interview!! Spot on!
Free palistine
So where are the geographical roots of the so called Palestinians???????
Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad, aired by Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012. Stated..........we all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties. Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in the Gaza Strip are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians.
The so called Palestinians are not even from Palestine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes
Good content ❤
Thanks Marc.
Like alway Love your chanel. Thank you.
This is brilliant journalism a very good piece.
Thanks for this very informative video. Great work Al Jazeera as always
Once a liar always a liar....
Keep the world informed @ AJ. ❤
Thank you for mentioning the Kuwaiti incubators. I’ve been thinking back on that for months.
I’d be nice if we could start thinking about how to answer the establishment’s inevitable conclusion that this all stems from an excess of democracy again…
Talk!! they capped the most!
The host said "it's obvious Hamas committed war crimes on October 7th..", I disagree..I don't think he has any legitimate claim to make a statement like that.... You have to pay attention to everything people say...a little statement like that can give away their true position..
Thought killing innocent civilians was a war crime.
Hamas videoed themselves committing these acts.
@@davidmhale521 ...they are an illegal occupying force...and a large majority of them are IDF reservists...the ones that are not reservist have been armed by the government to serve as militia forces...sooooooooooo ... technically none of them are non combatants.. the term "non combatants" is how the Geneva convention defines people in a conflict zone... Not civilian..a civilian that has been armed is a "combatant".... By the Israeli government giving free assault rifles and ammunition to illegal settlers they automatically classify as "combatants" ... They don't go by Geneva convention guidelines so I doubt they ever studied the terminology regarding the rules of engagement in a conflict zone.. so...now you know... If they want to be reclassified as "non combatants" they can surrender their arms and ammunition to Hamas or Hezbollah.... Otherwise they are legal targets..
It is obvious that Hamas committed war crimes.
@@davidmhale521The IOF commited war crimes thinking no video or CCTV footage would emerge. No international journalists allowed in (why?). AJ and AP is banned in Isrel (why?).
Imagine over the decades, how many war crimes have been commited with no video evidence..
@@davidmhale521 The Geneva Convention identifies people in a conflict zone as "combatants" or "non combatants" not civilians.. When the Israeli government issued free assault rifles and ammunition to the illegal settlers they automatically became "combatants" under the Geneva Convention guidelines.. arming the settlers automatically classifies them as militia...which are "combatants" ....that makes them targets...legally under the law.
Lies losing to truth. Brutality losing to humanity
You can't hide the truth forever as much as they try.
Quite the opposite. Israel is winning on all fronts, also the media sphere.
Hezbollah is no more.
Syrians and Lebanese dance and sing outoors after Nasralla chose the wrong bunker.
Hamas has lost most of their fighters and tunnels.
this generation is alright 🫡🍉
This may be their only chance to turn things around
and head us on a friendlier, healthier path in life...
The walls between people are slowly crumbling;
the Wall between Govs & Folks must fall before it's too late.
Thank you for your beautiful smile;
a moment of serenity in time of turmoil...
@@bobsanborn2395in your head star of David is strong and united than ever
Let us Agree ??
- that Absolute, Unadulterated, Honest and Objective TRUTH and JUSTICE be both Sought and Prevail regardless ??
towards PEACE > > >
😂"Mr. Patton, do you want to win the "info" war for feelings? Or win the Battles?" Patton: (SLAp!!)
Thank u JSC
Israel is fighting an army of professional victims.
Even one year, nothing changed still war to hames
RUclips is own by who please ?
GOOGLE = Z10N1ST$
G00gle >Alphabet Inc >>Jewish😂
Zionists own and control RUclips
Jews🤮🤮
Google
Judaism is NOT Zionism
*Leviticus 19:11,14 to 16:*
" You shall not steal; nor shall you oppress your neighbor, nor rob him... You shall not curse the deaf, and you shall not put a stumbling block before the blind... You shall do no injustice in judgement; be not partial to the poor, and favour not the mighty; in righteousness shall you judge your neighbour. You shall not go up and down as a talebearer among your people ; neither shall you stand idly by the blood of your neighbour : I am the Lord. "
The Talmud (higher authority to the Torah), states very clearly that Gentiles/non Jews are NOT you neighbours! So those only apply to other Jews.. BTW, the word 'Lord' translates back into Hebrew as "Ba'al".
@@mattkalk9162 Twisting God Almighty's words!!! Long story short, go check out the debates Rabbis vs Rabbis on this particular subject. Also relook at the thirteen principles of Judaism. That should clear up neighbors means any human being.
@@mattkalk9162aaaah there's the loophole see...they're so clever
@@mattkalk9162 The Talmud is NOT a higher authority to the Torah. The Torah is the Jewish holy book, whereas the Talmud is an opinion piece written by a group of Zionist Rabbis.
For perspective, Qatar is one of the most unsustainable countries on earth.
Maybe Israel and America are less sustainable. They're surely not morally superior as we are showing the world.
A few days ago I was able to block the fake post on twitter but apparently that is no longer an option. Was this done on purpose?
Netanyahu must go pun"ish the Germa"ns not the Pales"tinians and ask them for a homeland
seytanyahu want stay in power to avoid jail
They have been, now it’s gotten so out of control that I have to stick up for the normal Israeli citizens.
Even The Real Devil 😈 is extremely a shamed to Name IDF
God has used this crisis to expose them to the world.
The discussion would have been meaningful if he had discussed other Nations besides the US or Europian nations.
The discussion would have been meaningful if he had discussed other nations besides the US and Europian nations.🤷🏻♂️
What are human rights? What is information? 🌊
Cant help people like this.. They can only see the losses incurred and consider that some sort of cheating by Israel.. In reality thats a just a sore loser.. not gracious in defeat..
Let's call him by his real name Benjamin Meleikowsky
And still will not change anything. Israel keep going. Social media can never end the war
Slam Dunk Lost !
A Feral Mind With A Lying Tongue and A Deceitful Heart, Always. Repeat.
Hamas was in and out within two hours They fired off 5000 missiles in 20 minutes at the Gaza Division responsible for terrorizing the people of Palestine and wiped out the entire contingent of some 500 soldiers. Did Hamas and not the other groups, actually take civilian hostages or did Hamas take military prisoners of war? It should be pointed out that the proof is that Israeli forces actually killed 65% of the civilians on October 7th as they were ordered to shoot at any vehicle heading towards Gaza. The vast preponderance of those Hamas killed were Israeli military. So again I ask, did they actually (intentionally) take civilian hostages or was that the plurality of other resistance groups involved? Also, why is the global media and the world's governments still promoting the same 1200 civilians killed as being victims of Hamas?
Their lies boil my blood because those babies and innocent people are being murdered 💔
Like Mouin Rabbani says 🌬️ Israel is incapable of defeating a second order militia in a 365 kilometers x kilometer that is the Gaza Strip because of Palestinian Nationalism 🇵🇸
U can't spell Israel without liars 😂
Free Pelestine
So where are the geographical roots of the so called Palestinians???????
Hamas Minister of the Interior and of National Security Fathi Hammad, aired by Al-Hekma TV on March 23, 2012. Stated..........we all have Arab roots, and every Palestinian, in Gaza and throughout Palestine, can prove his Arab roots - whether from Saudi Arabia, from Yemen, or anywhere. We have blood ties. Personally, half my family is Egyptian. We are all like that. More than 30 families in the Gaza Strip are called Al-Masri ["Egyptian"]. Brothers, half of the Palestinians are Egyptians and the other half are Saudis. Who are the Palestinians? We have many families called Al-Masri, whose roots are Egyptian. Egyptian! They may be from Alexandria, from Cairo, from Dumietta, from the North, from Aswan, from Upper Egypt. We are Egyptians.
The so-called Palestinians are not even from Palestine!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Yes, because one can't just lie onself a place that's not even been defined. What's the strategic aim again?
Isre lies I don’t trust anything from there
who told you that the IDF is in Gaza if not the IDF... idiot, who told you that israel shot down the internet if not the IDF..
Yet you believed 500 people were standing in that small hospital parking lot
but you trust al jazeera. ha ha ha.
NATEYAHU does not even believe words coming from his own mouth.
Even my cat knows Jewish lives are more expensive than rest!
You are here saying Hamas humiliated Israelis army when we are seeking peace to prevail, what do you think it will happen if Israelis army hear this, won’t they continue to show up their might? This social commentators are also pouring fuel into what is ongoing.
In al Jazeera world maybe but most people despise hamas as well
Free palastine
A discussion between tweedle Der snd tweedle dumb
Truth hurts for you? Scream “anti-sem” now? Boohoo.
Rabbi schmuley is that you
I have a 7 month old baby boy. New mom. I am in gym last night and running and the little boy popped up in my head. Awful 😖
Even if they watched the doccie they would still call it anti-Semitic.
The discussion would have been meaningful if he had discussed other communities besides the Jewish community. 🤷🏻♂️
He just talked about the USA propaganda on Iraq!
@@PamDigiovanni Oh, my comment was on Israel. Thanks for the secret discussion.😀😀
It is 🇮🇱 that advances antisemitic tropes
Oh...are you playing the 'antisemitic' CARD AGAIN! How 'unusual'! That ol WELL WORN and threadbare non-stop MARKETING narrative!
If I had a dollar for every time Israel lied, I would be the new owner of Amazon tomorrow.
Nitanyahu is crazy dog
Both bidden and satanyahu are living in the 1950s when everyone had to go to the cinema for the news.
وَلَا تَحْسَبَنَّ ٱللَّهَ غَـٰفِلًا عَمَّا يَعْمَلُ ٱلظَّـٰلِمُونَ ۚ إِنَّمَا يُؤَخِّرُهُمْ لِيَوْمٍۢ تَشْخَصُ فِيهِ ٱلْأَبْصَـٰرُ. Do not think ˹O Prophet˺ that Allah is unaware of what the wrongdoers do. He only delays them until a Day when ˹their˺ eyes will stare in horror-
But Muhammad said “I will expel the Jews and Christians from the Arabian Peninsula and will not leave any but Muslim.”(Sahih Muslim 1767a Book 32, Hadith 75). Who started its, may I ask?
These guys need a different job. Their life mission to specialise in Israel is repetetive and still so ignorant. They need a deeper dive into 3000 years Jewish history to help him know what Hasbara means.
End to the hasbara. Learn israel learn..
Misquoted Noam Chomskys Manufactured consent - it’s deserving and undeserving victims not sympathetic
Israel is getting desperate.
You mean propoganda
The end of the artificial entity is nigh. Dual ppt holders booking it out of there. 😮
I listen to Sut Jhally and I hear an Australian accent....is that my imagination or is it a combo Indian/British/???
Help Me Understand. A 2 State solution is being driven by all as a solution to this Gaza/Israel war. Does that mean that the Palestinians should go back to Gaza? Gaza has been destroyed and the Palestinians go back to the prison state of destructed. Just guide me please.
They are loosing I because israel should bring in journalist to show the world these tunnels they found but they are always putting it out then self. THEY should have independent reporting
EXACTLY! nobody believes them anymore, they need independent observations
@@lafemmenikita123 yes your right.
Yeh Hamas, no ceasefire bro,..
We don't lose. Israel has spoken.
BEGGARS of USA has spoken people.. 😂😂 The joke of the world now. Liars extraordinaire.
nobody is listening to that BS anymore 🥱
It is not losing, it lost already at least 6 month ago and it will lose the war in the end too and Palestine WILL be free!!!
MLH is on Al-Jazeera now. Okay, yay. Is he still doing BN Network to? Idk, but first black male I've seen covering international even employed by them.
Free Palestine love from Vienna Austria.
Lost it
Two professional lyers who cares what they say?
Uncle rukus??
Just look at how they weep. You were told. Israel has spoken.
My cat pees on Benzion pics
@Hlth-cn4fh, weeping for hostages?
Nonsence.
Learn how to spell, uneducated hillbilly. F zionist rats.