'If India is threatened tomorrow, there is no ambiguity that it will use force', says S. Jaishankar
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 сен 2024
- External Affairs Minister Dr. S. Jaishankar said that If India is threatened tomorrow, there is no ambiguity that it will use force. While speaking at an event to launch the book 'Grasping greatness: Making India a leading power', the External Affairs Minister added that India mostly used force when it was threatened.' The book has been edited by Ashley J. Tellis, Bibek Debroy & C. Raja Mohan. Watch the full conversation between Dr. S. Jaishankar & Ashley J. Tellis at the Global Technology Summit organised by Carnegie India.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Join our channel to get access to perks. Click 'JOIN' or follow the link below:
/ @theprintindia
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Connect with ThePrint
» Subscribe to ThePrint: theprint.in/su...
» Subscribe to our RUclips Channel: bit.ly/3nCMpht
» Like us on Facebook: / theprintindia
» Tweet us on Twitter: / theprintindia
» Follow us on Instagram: / theprintindia
» Find us on LinkedIn : / theprint
» Subscribe to ThePrint on Telegram: t.me/ThePrintI...
» Find us on Spotify: spoti.fi/2NMVlnB
» Find us on Apple Podcasts: apple.co/3pEOta8
Oh, I just love it...I thank Modiji for bringing so many great people together to run this great country in so many different levels...God bless my country...
Modi G is eulogising Tipu the Kafir killer as emblem of upcoming G20 headed by Bharat
⁰⁰
How to convince other Bongs?
We Bengalis take time for change...we tolerated communist party for so long who destroyed the industries and work culture entirely....now again another kind of struggle going on ....but people understand about development as so many Bengalis are doing so well everywhere. They also want their state to prosper.....
Couldn't agree more👍👍
Imagine a cabinet full of people like Shri Jaishankar
A Hevan of knowledge and growth 🗿
Excess of anything is bad, different kind of work needs different kinds of skills set so diversity among cabinet is desirable and necessary. According to me🎶
If the whole cabinet is full of learned and honest people they will lose the next elections. People do not vote for such qualities... India votes for religion, caste , language and all the other things that actually pull the country back. Just my opinion.
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cc although all these factors India is slowly and steadily developed 👍👍👍and this is the beauty of democracy 👍👍👍
Giga chad country growth 🔥
Having a professional diplomat as the External Affairs Minister has made a world of difference. A political appointee would not come close to having the skills of Dr. S. Jaishankar. Hats off to him.
Was hoping for a more critical and analytical exposure of the Foreign Minister.
Proud to have such a nice & great person as our minister. Bold, clear & an excellent communicator. Country's pride.
Very enlightening conversation.
Modi Sarkar has brought in a huge change in the perception of India.across the globe and this is due to the inherent strength of our country in our ancient civilization.
There is no doubt Bharath will be the biggest moral power the entire world will seek after.
The world is watching and killings of minorities will not be seen in good light.
Very insightful & visionary. But still few points I disagree with him on global view of trying to take burden of world & moral power. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
The UPSC interview panel that selected DR. Jaishakar, must be sooo proud
Haha yes!
Probably in a wheelchair but yes they would be proud!
Yeah, back then civil services actually attracted some good talent, even broken clock is right twice a day, mostly it's just superficial elites babu's.
@@jagadeeshks4601 certainly would have kicked the bucket
😀😀😀 so true indeed! Nice observation
His father was a already a foreign secretary.
This man is a genius.!!! Wish I had the capability of answering such difficult question with such clearity of thoughts and at same time maneuvering via counter logic. His answers are pin pointed and open ended at the same time. I haven't been so amazed by any speaker, who can be such technical, practical, political, to the point ,optimistic and positive that too while speaking about Indian foreign policy. I can listen him all day.
Both are educated and intellectual. Wish entire country had these kind of edurites
Edurite?
Great conversation. India has to keep in mind
1. Geopolitical realities like no country has such a long continuous hostile border and the threat of coordinated attack. To make matters worse even Myanmar has fallen to China almost as vassal state
2. Close cooperation between America and Pakistan and that for 75 years Russia has stood solid with India come what may
Now russia is in no position to influence world politics nor they can help us.
Assosiation with russia is becoming a liability.
It may sound selfish...but national interest first.
@@Jahapanah-e-hindustan
Really!! Give me some oil then dumb fk
What an as-sine comment.
If you have an inferiority complex, go see a shrink.
Very insightful & visionary. But still few points I disagree with him on global view of trying to take burden of world. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
@@surojeetchatterjee agreed that is your view point....why give something free to some of the countries? my view is simple give and take...you give something when it is required and take something you require.
'Don't get sucked into endless, open ended conflicts', (Dr Jaishankar). 'If you do not put out a fire, it will burn itself out', (Sun Tzu). Dr Jaishankar has mastered the Art of War through his words more than any Chinese premiers have.
Its refreshing to see some quality books on foreign policy which has always been a wanting of many Indians. I think all aspiring civil services student and autodidacts should read this book. _Grasping greatness: Making India a leading power_
The expression and analysis of our foreign minister are outstanding. Probably the best in the world and a great asset to India.
He is a finest cabinet minister that India ever had. The prime minister who never was. Still nothing taken from honorable PM modi. But the way honorable jai shankar speaks every one is becoming a fan.
5.3k views within 1 hr .... this is power of jai shankar Sir
What a Masterclass
Knowledge , Witt ,Will ,Morals , of course love for Nation. That's our foreign minister Dr Jaishankar
Wow, what an intellectual conversation? God bless you dear EAM.
Thank you Dr. Tellis for bringing precise and pointed questions from an intricate analysis in simple format that an ordinary person can grasp.
Big Fan🙏🙏! Wishing Mr. Jaishankar lots of success and good health!
A pleasure as always 😊
The voice of Ashley Tellis... So soothing. I heard you first time... Such a gentleman!
Voting for BJP was a good decision overall.
Well do again only for this gem.
EAM is important, but not more than road, railway, power or agriculture
@@mlg1279 lol... BJP did lot better than Khangress
WOW!!
Just too good!!
True legend
What a charm to listen to FM and Mr. Telli
The selection of Sr. S. J to the EAM is a marvellous movement .He is the need of the hour for India at the current global scenarios
What a fine discussion by the fine gentlemen
SJ is best diplomat in the world. We are so lucky to have him.
You are a Rock star Dr Jaishanker. Thank you Sir.
Exemplary and thought provoking outcome from one of the best brains of India. His views are pious,pragmatic,patriotic and noval with the nuances of diplomatic relations,while keeping his mind stayed in the security and economic development of India above all. Hats Off to him. My real thinking is, if such gems would have been identified and put in the place they worth for Indian would have developed even earlier. But alas, we are living at a time of greedy people surrounding us.
A man with such exemplary qualities you ascribe to him can never work under Modi whose only enduring legacy is pogrom 2002
@@jojicherian Your view is something - 1.3 Billion minus 1 - Indian (read : Modi ) never grasp.
I dont mean to sound mean but I can never understand why Indians do not ever TRUST their own race.
@user-ip3co6zx3h what caused , who caused, Muslims responsible are all irrelevant Spontaneous or not it was a pogrom. A pogrom is called so when the state machinery actively participate in it. Whether you admit it or not this pogrom is the only legacy Modi will leave behind every thing else is irrelevant
@@leolee1959 How many jerricans trust Biden
@@jojicherian frustrated rice bags detected. 🤣 India will not run according to ur masters wish, always remember that.
It is very rare moments where diplomacy is defined generically.
My next PM for India, if we have to take/continue/endure the momentum forward! I am not kidding you!
That day is coming much sooner than people think.
Policy influenced decision Vs Capacity influenced decision… beautiful analysis. Will go way far in making right decisions even in our own personal life.
God bless you Dr. jaishankar
Brave words. Not that I doubt Jaishankar, but I hope India can live up to it.
This could be used for other nations too
I like his point about capacity building in foreign policy. That is a fundamental concept in foreign policy theory
To have any impact on the Global stage, India must address its shortcomings first....The fist and foremost issue is that 20 % of our population i,e, about 200 million live below the poverty line. This has to be the highest priority.....Secondly, the number of scams affecting the economy of the country is staggering......and is widespread in all sectors of the economy..These two factors will have to be addressed before there is confidence in the National stance.
🙏🙏👌Nation's pride 🇮🇳🇮🇳Jaishankar Sir🇮🇳🇮🇳👌🙏🙏
Great interview 👍
I can listen to him for hours, what a brilliant personality we have as our EAM.
Extremely informative discussion. Thank you
What a great conversation! Both speakers lay out the premises of the discussion and consistently go downstream from there without divergence.
Ah! A wonderful discourse. You are a gem Dr. Jaishankar! Thank you for disentangled my locks. Blessings! Not Sad.
ايها.الساده.الكرام.انه.يعز.علينا.طلبكم.وانكم.متاخرين.المره.القادمه.انت.من.ا ولياتي.وشكرا.لكم
Foreign policy discourse in this country was considered an exclusive entitlement of a clique of "gyaani " diplomats / strategic thinkers , select media heroes , public intellectuals who sat in commentary and judgement and monopolized the public opinion. We all were in awe of them and they would pontificate & even arrogantly put down political leaders like Modi who, in their opinion was unworthy of dealing with the subject. Foreign policy was the "Vedas" for these "brahmins" which was beyond the pale of lesser folks. The EAM quite obviously been given the task to (a) democratize, simplify and popularize at the commoners' level the theory and practise of foreign policy (b) demystify the esoteric portions into comprehensible parts. The EAM is making political dialogue with both his domestic and international constituents to push the emergence of India as a serious global player. This is part of narrative building and embellishments of comprehensive national power and forging of awareness among the common masses . Great work.
You must be a BIG fan of England.
Your Colonial Masters must be so proud - the Indians gifted with Independence from colonial Britain - idolized everything British; culture, language, customs, . . . . .
Huge fun of Jaishankar ... He is so clr in his speech...
Very insightful & visionary. But still few points I disagree with him on global view of trying to take burden of world. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
His arguments are well reasoned out . He has become my favourite communicator amongst the Ministers. By that I do not belittle other Ministers I must add. I acknowledge him .
Excellent and talented minister 🎉
Good choice of words by both speakers. Learned a lot
That is diplomacy
@@mohitoberoi4089
Very insightful & visionary. But still few points I disagree with him on global view of trying to take burden of world. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
This is called patriotism be proud of bjp which belongs to hindu. We hindus always brilliant. Nehru congress always betrayed hindu.21st century belongs hindus of naya bharath. We are the one we are the world. Jai hind jai bharath.
Very complex thinker, which is what a foreign policy skill should be all about.
very good discussion
360p? Seriously? Do better
Love from Poland 🇵🇱
Let the force be with you.
He is a great leader. Modiji congratulations for your vision
India will grow. Thank you
Jaishankar looks far younger than his age - may be due to his passion for diplomatic approach to solve international issues for India
Very nice and thought provoking session.
India our new super power
India needs a Jai Shankar in the Finance Ministry !
We have right ministers, prime knows when to change who? So fat it worked out well!
@@madhumadhavan5015
Ask your RSS boss , Su. Swami , what ails Modi cabinet especially Nimmy !
@@josephandrews5467 of course we can ask swami but not an Italian lady or Pope!
@@madhumadhavan5015
Khaki nikker walahs are always fond of sniffing at the backside of Sonia Gandhi ! You are no exception !!
@@josephandrews5467 Look at your name whose original identity is lost. Low life converts like you are the once that need white god and white leaders!
Jaishankarji is the best 👌
We need professional defense minister as well.
Rajnath Singh is not doing a bad job at all until now. We managed the China clash pretty well although I am not sure what part Mr Rajnath Singh played in it.
@@ParminderSingh-ft3cc I am not saying he did bad job. But we need a professional from defense forces who can give strategic depth to the job. (Not merely saying that 'hum POK Leke Rahenge' ;). )
@@krishnaxyz POK lenge bhai... har cheez ka time hota hai. Can't just charge on the enemy like an idiot. You do not disturb the enemy when they are making a mistake... Pakistan is in turmoil and making disastrous decisions themselves... why disturb or divert them? Wait till they have a civil war.
What about the finance minister?
@@hpremjit she is professional. Good or bad can be debated.
one of our modi giuvts gems.
Very insightful & visionary. But still few points I disagree with him on global view of trying to take burden of world. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
Bravo Print!
Even if the event of change of govts Dr Jaishankar should remain as FM as long as he could deliver
*Congress Gave us Foreign minister like - Jairam Ramesh - Chidambaram both are useless no doubt..*
*BJP gave us - Sushma Swaraj then S. jayshankar.. that's the difference*
Very insightful & visionary. But still few points I disagree with him on global view of trying to take burden of world. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
Currently ranked the best foreign minister in the world. Intelligent, diplomatic and geo political knowledge - Wise.
The most important point is identify the root of the problems within the india and indians. ......then you analysis of the needs of the mother india and only. ....import or export the goods or services.
Then only. ...Mother india will know what we need from other countries and try all our best to avoid the unnecessary things from any country in the world.
So our great minister sir, Subramaniam JAYASANKER always say, i am a indian, always my problems are not other country problem, but we love and help and share our knowledge with any country in the world. ..whether they are poor or rich country in the world.
His diplomatic mindset automatically come out from his own inherited indian blood. .......we always love to go with the world. .....relationship, that is the modern scientific and technology global village concept. ......international relationship. ....no the wars, disputes. ...or just going to. .....religious places and promises. ...god, we are gods childrens and after coming out from the religious places and. .....try to make the world. ...bloody ocean. .....better as our great minister always keep the international relationships. .....because he knows the future the whole world will loose and face. ....more than 70% world will. ..suffer from water, food, shelter, medicine, energy, transport. ....so the world leaders must use the brain not the. .....power of mouth, hands, legs or their just. ...weapons. ......the future. ...wireless, sensor and mysterious electronic latest devices will more power than. .....donkey leaders in the world.
,Tellis is very intelligent
INDIA become regional power as far back as 1971 when india bifurcated Pakistan and made them to sign Shimla agreement without the presence of any Vito wielding powers of UNO
Please, someone capable and reading this comment, make a movie in Sh. Dr. Jaishankar!!
Jaishankar is indeed a very articulate, forthright and intelligent man. One cannot but help agree with his realistic views. Too bad that he's aligned himself with a fascist hateful dispensation whose divisive ideology will be seen to be (and sometimes is) buttressed through his articulations. He and his masters (whose attitude in fact DOES seem to be the "My nationalism vs the world" that he says he rejects) should also understand that economic and political development is meaningless without human and intellectual development as well as a content/peaceful society of truly free citizens. If India wants to sit at the high table of the world's powerful and advanced countries, it will have to take their sensibilities and requirements into account (particularly of those countries whose investments and technologies India clearly needs and covets) instead of being seen to be in bed with questionable regimes and theocracies.
A threatened India will use force. BS. A threatened India looks like giving up. Why Indian side of LAC converted into no man's land after "de-escalation" with China at multiple locations then? Also why is PLA is still occupying position on Indian side of LAC in Depsang Plains? How long the talks would continue?
Did you visit the borders? Or did you collude with China? I am sure you vote for CPI/CPM. Speaking so sure of China.
@@srim6241 I visited Wagag border and Nathu La, but not LAC. So, I did not visit LAC, so I couldn't know? I also didn't visit Balakot, but I know Indian Airforce struck them. That I mention uncomfortable truths, so I become China supporter? I am furious that parts of land on Indian side of LAC have been converted to no man's land and want GOI to ask Indian Army to recover them. I am furious that parts of Depsang plans on Indian side of LAC are still in PLA hand. All these information is on open domain in all newspapers - English and regional, but not reported by Godi media.
Sushma Swaraj and Jaishankar have been the most effective External Affairs Ministers
He is doing great but I sometimes feel recently he is exposing his view too much.
Does not matter . We have (a) had no one take up this function of formal expressions on foreign policy framework ( it was left to a small clique of arrogant " experts" drawn from the service and media stars who made it their exclusive domain gyaan ) with as little jargon as possible. (2) Today we are embarking on a new journey of self assurdemess in our foreign policy which was not the case earlier. These discussions were considered beyond the common man's grasp. That elitist stance is being systematically dismantled by the EAM
Sometimes he gets carried away is my impression when asked about the nitty gritty of foreign affairs. But then he recently said the PM and him plan weeks ahead what to say where (yeah, I am a fan boy ☺️, I follow every available speech and interviews of him)
I disagree. His talks are optimistic and realistic. They provide sense of faith in young minds about what his/her country is doing to achieve its larger goals in global space. What are methods and mechanisms in place to achieve them. This is quintessential during this digital era where false information is spreads like wildfire when truth is tumbling to prove its character!
@@bvenkatesh1943great observation 🧠
Not allowed nuclear weapons
Very good that all over the world
It is my earnest request to the viewers of this video to propagate the knowledge of geopolitics at an equally faster pace as other nations are developing strategies ,cunningly to suppress India. We have to put and support a government who are capable of handling international affairs to benefit our economic development. This is the need of the hour. Instead,we are engaged in useless petty politics of regionalism etc. Very sorry state of affairs.
The interviewer was constantly breathing Into the mike and making weird noise, it was difficult to listen to the guest.
Jaishankar is all talk and no action 😂
What do you expect him to be acting upon????....take a kalashnikov in bands....wear a Kevlar, go to the Frontline and start defending the motherland????!!!!!!😂😅🤣....... his very job profile entails to be 'talking clever' ......!!!.....that's what he is appointed there for
@@shankhadeepmandal978 in short . Blowing hot air 😂
@@shankhadeepmandal978 Very insightful & visionary. But still few points I disagree with him on global view of trying to take burden of world. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
@@blueeyes6192 well he said we will defend the land not attack on enemy land you scum
@@Jagan-qd5xq isn’t he speaking the obvious ? What’s he suppose to say the opposite ? Wow so insightful 🤣🤣🤣
Hi friends !
I would like to ask to you in the name of God to give to all who try it the oportunity to rectify please.
Kind Regards
from
Canary Islands.
Why is the quality only 360p?
I am eternally terrified by the hindus converted to abrahamic religions
MRSHAISHANKAR KINDLY NOTE I THANK YOU FOR UR CLEAR IDEAS BUT IF UR IN UR IDEAS ALONE WHEN ENEMY IS CAPTURE UR LAND OR OCCUPIED NEAR COUNTRY U HAVE FAILED TO AVT
Sure we do, If we are threatened we cannot outsource our protection to some one else. I think we need to take some good lessons from ukraine thing, Russia has to do it and has what it takes to do it.
EXAMPLE CHINA HAS. MET 19 COUNTRY JUST BY THERE COMMAND I FEEL ATTACK INDIA
Any political appointment may not serve the purpod
Aust help but we don't have big army like u
QUAD countries must listen to this conversation and learn from Dr. JS.
Our country is great but something
Add to indian army bombers . and nuclear weapons more and more
Always indian army is strong but now
This is a newjan policy1= 2
So Russia us right to use force for its security.
We saw the advantages...what are the disadvantages for having a civil servant as a minister?....why shouldnt Modiji have all his key cabinet portfolios from IAS/IPS/IFS
Disadvantages: Bureaucracy / Bureaucrats - are status-quoist and are not designed or geared for change. It is leaders like Modi who decide a change in tone and policy - which the Bureaucrats carry out. If every minister was a bureaucrat - the country will be status-quoist by definition, imho.
It is the mindset of every bureaucrat to not make any change and that is the real problem.
Brilliantly and eloquently answered...@Shyam kumar
@@ShyamKumar-zb2mw perfectly said, Very insightful & visionary. As on few points I disagree with JShanker on global view of trying to take burden of world. World doesn't work like that on humanitarian help basis. World only respects military & economic power, rest little humanitarian help works as cherry on the cake.
The space that eam is JS is asking for sounds more like LEBENSRAUM
Not to me.
But to some diseased and contaminated minds, it could, I guess.
Ooooooooooooo
Just a fleeting thought, did a "so called superpower" covertly help PAKISTAN develop nuclear bomb, after India demonstrated the same? is it so?, possible? Questions to be answered.
It is well known that China helped PK get their nuclear weapons - in a bid to neutralize IN. I am surprised that this is not to well known in IN.
Yes both China made the design, US over looked the supply of uranium. Only Israel informed India, but PM of India messed it by phone calling Pakistan counter part making them alert. 🤷♂️
all evil
starts with this
India is threatened today, what force are you using to evict Chinese intruders from Depsang and Demchok? You have been "talking" for 2 years - saying "na koi ghusa...". Talk is cheap, we are waiting for you to restore status quo.
If Pakistan gives threat and Chinese defend Pakistan and invade Jammu then?🤭
Your prime minister is going to saudi to get $3 billion loan ??? Know your worth...u cant survive sheer industrial output of india in all out war.....
@@Scientist1351 Pakistan will not spend a penny. Saudi Arabia will take care of it because it will be OIC vs India war to rekindle Delhi Sultanate. 🤔😂🤣
@@shakibmusfiq2478 ok sir good luck 🤞
@@shakibmusfiq2478 chutiyo se apni govt chal nhi rhi...usa regime change kardi lekin jhatuo ko Sultanate banani hai india mein ok sir good luck 🤞
@@Scientist1351 There's no point to wish. You can not fight any war. Because you don't have powerful countries beside you. Saudi Arabia and China are critical to finance and military means in any war. Both will support Pakistan openly in any war with India.
Diminutive engaged by Modi to demolish the leviathan, Jawaharlal Nehru. That is Jyasankar
Leviathan ceded more territory and committed more foreign policy blunders than anyone can possibly dream to emulate much less recover from.
. @@thrinethran2885
Read history before making comments like Jyasankar and Rijiju. And try to learn the circumstances. Try to read at least one page from "Discovery of India" Modi's jealousy of Nehru can not be cured by his chumchas or you however much you try
Same goes for you.....read history, before commenting.....
Why do I have to read a written material from the same author who I am critical about????
That's like saying reading a book about "why colonialism is justified in india" from an author like lord Clive????!!!!!!!!
Stupidity and absurdity at it's best!!!!
That's like saying "why nationalism is damaging india" from ROMILA THAPAR or "the beauty of violence on innocent civilians" authored by OSAMA BEN LADEN or "the beauty of forced conversion" authored by emperor AURANGZEB !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
????..???????????
Before lecturing others to be more literate and knowledgious, be rational first and try to do the same what you are preaching I.e., do your side of studying first:
Read the following books:
•THE GOD WHO FAILED by Madhav God bole
•VIRDICTS ON NEHRU: RISE AND FALL OF A REPUTATION by RAMA Chandra Guha
@@shankhadeepmandal978 .To criticise some one you should know him/her for what she/he is. Study him. Go to critics only after knowing. I don't know Godble. But as far as i know Guha is an ardent admirer of Nehru.
@@jojicherian going by your logic:
I have to study likes of OSAMA BIN LADEN or ADOLF HITLER, just to ponder why they did what they did. That in itself is self explanatory
• Did I ask you to refer to Google by any chance in my comment??? What are the citation materials that I referred to you????......to the best of my knowledge, they are books not net?......so why is this argument even consequential????
•yes, that is why I have specifically referred to a book authored by GUHA........let yourself decide what to deduce when a self proclaimed ardent socialist follower himself criticises the so called person, what we make of the entire argument
Mr foreign minister, back up your words by evicting the Chinese from the Indian territory China has occupied since June 2020. Galwan valley remembers misses India 🌾
Give proof of what you are stating so that you are not taken to be an ardent bum licker of that half Italian IDIOT.