Why Palestinians in East Jerusalem are losing their homes | Start Here
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 7 май 2024
- Palestinians in occupied East Jerusalem are losing their homes to Israeli settlers. It’s happening through a process of evictions and demolitions. Sandra Gathmann went to East Jerusalem for #AJStartHere to explain what’s happening and why.
This film was shot in August 2023, before the war on Gaza.
Chapters:
00:00 intro
02:10 - Sandra meets Noura Ghaith-Sub Laban, who’s been evicted.
03:35 - What happened in 1948 and the Green Line
04:55 - How Israel applies Israeli law in East Jerusalem
06:00 - The significance of the 1970 Legal & Administrative Matters Law
06:37 - “Protected tenancy” for Palestinians
07:15 - How Israeli settler organisations are operating in East Jerusalem
08:38 - Sheikh Jarrah and the Salem family
11:22 - Zoning restrictions in East Jerusalem
13:25 - Silwan and demolition orders in Al Bustan
15:30 - How Israeli settlements are expanding in East Jerusalem
This episode features:
Noura Ghaith-Sub Laban
Mounir Nusseibeh, Human Rights Lawyer & Academic, Al-Quds University
Amy Cohen, Director of Intl Relations & Advocacy, Ir Amim
Fatima Salem
Ibrahim Salem
Yonatan Yosef, Jerusalem City Councilman
Arieh King, Deputy Mayor of Jerusalem
Nidal al-Rajabi
You can find all Start Here episodes here: bit.ly/3o0BEIW
Subscribe Al Jazeera so you don’t miss future episodes: bit.ly/AJSubscribe
Follow Sandra Gathmann on Instagram and X: @SandraGathmann
And let us know in the comments if there’s a topic you find confusing and would like Start Here to cover ⤵️
You can find the full Start Here playlist with all our episodes here 👇
ruclips.net/p/PLzGHKb8i9vTxodrArxXFPziklf0iqFdC5
Astonishing to me that the Israeli’s believe they deserve to both annex the land of the Palestinians, give them no rights and then expect complete and totally safety therein
The lady did not mention that if person does not have a title to a property , then this person is a tenant and supposed to pay rent to the owner. They stopped paying rent decades ago. Would you be happy to allow your tenants not to pay you rent ? 😂
read the old testament of Jewish Bible, Israel genocided the local residents to occupied their lands under name of "God"
@@monkofkrayak6235true, the irony. They go according to the bible but it only applies to stealing land. They should take a DNA test for the truth.
😈😈😈😈😈😈Not one Palestinian was consulted when the UN decided to form the State of Israel. Jews were there paying off the crooked politicians of UK, USA , FRANCE ect .. The European colonialize powers of USA , UK, FRANCE, ect.. decided to give their White European Brothers land of the dark skin people known as arabs in Palestine. Remember this was in 1947 when white European nations such as UK and France were still themselves colonializing African nations and India. When white south Africa apartied state was still being supported by the western powers. Nobody is talking about how Isreal was established and recognized as a State by the same western powers who themselves at the time were some of the worst burtal colonializers in history. Nobody talks about how Isreal only became a country by the military support of Western powers and the fraudulent back room deals made by the Jewish community who had loaned the western world money for wars. So people please remember that Isreal literally took over by force and colonialized Palestine land by saying it was originally there land 3000 years ago according to the Bible. Also remember that even if the bible is the word of God there is sero proof the white European jew today are the same Israelites of the bible. The white European jew you see today converted to the faith of Judaism. The bible even says to be aware of those who call themselves jews but are not jews but are of the synagogue of Satan 👿
@@Irin31Its their land
Y would they pay rents
Zionists invaded the land
I recently watched a video of a Jewish Israeli shouting at a Palestinian. He has taken possession of her house, she was rightfully complaining. "You have stolen my house, my family home," she said. He replied, "If I don't steal it, someone else will!" I believe this says it all.
Yeah, I saw that. Israel makes up reasons why the titles, or traditional ownership of Palestinians is invalid then seizes the land and states that the Palestinians are illegally on the land even tho they've lived there for generations. Israel claims that any claims Palestinians make are in themselves moot because they do not exist legally and their ownership claims cannot be proven even if they have titles, deeds, and historic claims with pictures and documents from British Mandate era. The argument per Israeli Supreme Court is that these documents even if proven to be valid are not legal in the Israeli court system. Basically nothing they say, do or act will be deemed legal even if its peaceful legal battles, protests and filling out every form and document to the letter. The fact that they are Palestinian invalidates their claims.
The settlers are not settlers. First and foremost, they are land grabbers, terror mongers and fanatics.
Ah yes that’s the Jewish prophet Jacob of Brooklyn New York
Are you saying Jews are cheap and greedy?
@@wheres_bears1378prophet. Smh. Lol.
How can people claim lands for themselves and displace the indigenous population and say it is the Bible that gave them the right to do so. That's so ridiculous to me.
European colonials are still at it
the average person is stupid af. they can just be greedy, steal land, and point the bible out and everyone will believe them.
They spit on Christians but reference Bible for the ownership of Palestine land ?
@@matthewrock1467exactly…very strange!
It is ridiculous for everyone to know this nonsense claim but nobody can help Palestinians😢
They believe in the Bible when it serves them , but draw a line when it comes to the parts that say “Love your neighbour as you love yourself “
Exactly my thoughts.. That's the first thing that came to my mind when that guy who looks not different from the Palestinians. ❤️❤️
Yea it's funny because they call themselves Jewish and people of the book ,claiming the land is there ( which I don't believe they are ) but then the forget the same law that tell them there can only be one law for the jew and non jew . The God of the bible doesn't allow aprtide or discrimination or unfairness against different people in the same land . But the entire west bank is completely against what they are told to do .
That’s in the New Testament not their Bible.
“The biggest insult to the memory of the Holocaust is not denying it but using it to commit genocide against the Palestinian people.”
Norman Finkelstein
What genocide?
@@Woobieeee👎
Norm still a Zionist.
@@Woobieeee The 15000 civilians that you have no empathy for because you don't value human lives, nevermind the hundreds of thousands injured and affected
Dude you look the numbers and details yourself. The Palestinian population is only growing. There is no genocide stop crying.
The words “human rights” is officially a joke.
I know, just look at Ethiopia, 500,000 people got slaughtered last year. Death toll in Yemen is 233K and climbing but the UN turns a blind eye. Gaza is a drop in the ocean....
The western human rights is a man can marry a man, That is the civilised world of the western world
@@JDMB001 UN is american what can you expect from it? America is the reason these countries are at war
@@JDMB001
The numbers are staggering
there never were human rights, we made them up
Its so frustrating to hear them say God gave them land. Clearly the UK gave them that land but they can't even admit that, and pretend they've been there the whole time. Delusional.
The UK didn't give that land. Jews had to fight the UK and Arab colonialists, to return to them what they believe theirs.
UK were the colonialists, Jews aren't.
God doesn't give land to ppl 🙂.
Jews lived in that area througout the history. Palestine Its the only place in the world where Jews have always kept some presence.
Only small minority of Arabs in Israel/Palestine are not colonialists from neighboring countries.
Read Ezekiel 36 and 37. Identifies Israel in the 1940’s. Chapter 38,39 the time of war coming against Israel ( this is the battle of Armageddon ) chapters 40-48 are the new Jerusalem where Jesus Christ rules.
@@RonlovesLordJesus
We, the Jews have eaten humans??? that's where I stopped reading 🙂
No. God did give Israel that land. It's all in the Bible and the Bible never lies.
"The LORD said to Abram, “Leave your country, your relatives, and your father's family, and go to the land I will show you. I will make you a great nation, and I will bless you. I will make you famous, and you will be a blessing to others." (Genesis 12:1-3)
The "land" is the promised land to the Israelites. That land has always been Israel's. It has and always will be.
@faveaugust "a blessing to others"? 75 years of humiliating atrocities committed gleefully against the Palestinians, and now more than 20,000 innocents slaughtered. Is that what being a blessing to others constitute?
This enrages me. How can a group of people support so much destruction and justify atrocities?
I don't know. It's so disgusting and mind-boggling
Brainwashed by Zionist snd Evangelical BS since birth
Disgusting to see a crook walking out of a house he just stole from a helpless Palestinian.
A crook with a gun. Imagine what he’s teaching his children.
That woman is now dead. Died young about 70. Probably died from a broken heart having her precious home stolen from her by Zionist settler scumbags, all approved by their scumbag enablers America and the Uk
They are Evil You Can Tell He's Face
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
Teaches them to steal
I know it’s very sad.
if i were a jew israeli offered a home from where a palestinian family was distributed, i would be ashamed so deeply only by the offer. i cannot imagine how coldhearted a person must be to come from usa or europe to claim yeah, this is mine. it even hurts by trying to understand this.
What about arabs that occupied Jewish homes all over Middle East? Do you feel the same pain?
If you were an Israeli you would know that the Holy Bible written by a King James version in 1600s transcribed by Christian monks that Jerusalem was under Roman occupation eradicating the Israelis from their homes through New Testament Scriptures. Apostles Paul and John moved up to Rome to try to educate the people of Rome on Christianity due to Jesus Christ's teachings. There is nothing in the Bible mentioning a Palestine people in and around Jerusalem and Bethlehem, Israel that didn't belong to Israel of the Old Testament's stated "from the river to the sea" Palestinian people beliefs anti-Bible. The Palestinian people after the Ottoman Empire somehow got educated in the wrong direction that the Old Testament's marked out territory for Israel wasn't for Israel as an anti-God but a Muslim only false god "Allah faith" trying to impose Muslim people's "war of the Filistines" when Arabs (who are recognized Syrian from Assyrians, Lebanon, Jordan, Egypt, etc but never Palestine).
Same, a life full of shame
@@Irin31If you cannot reply with facts and logic, at least you can save yourself from looking foolish.
@@Irin31please. Crooks will always be crooks and then cry wolf. Get out of people land cowards
Like a split little child who licks all the candy before grabbing it all for themselves.
If we raised children like this we'd be ashamed to take them out of the house.
I think the state of Israel has lost its raison d'être.
Israelis steal land, murder children, commit genocide...
In short: Israel is breaking the law and endangering world peace.
My thoughts exactly 💯
"I have no mercy or compassion in me for a society that will crush people, and then penalise them for not being able to stand up un-der the weight." - Malcolm X
I went and looked this quote up and I would like to thank you for quoting a meaningful and real phrase. RUclips has so much bs
Netanyahu in English: we are fighting for western values like democracy & freedom.
Netanyahu in Hebrew: we are fighting for greater israel & I know how to lie to American people in English 🤣
Netanyahu in Hebrew lies even more than in English. His political partners doesn't trust any word he says.
However, he lived in the US for many years and defending their values in Israel instead of Jewish values. Its sad he has so many voters and able to win time and again the elections.
The "Holy Land" is the most unholy region on earth... 🙄
yeah, if only Palestinian arabs would decide to live in peace, the land would be peaceful
@@Irin31free Palestine
@@Irin31 You know that's not the real issue.
@@daydreonmckinney and what is the real issue? That Arabs are the ones that actually are the occupiers? As Jews has lived in Jerusalem for the last 3,000 years. And Arabs have a problem with that and want all the ancient Jewish lands all to themselves only?
World 🌎 just watching
No justice any more for Palestine 😢
This is disgusting. They go against everything in the Bible but put all emphasise on the verse that claims that the land belongs to them.
A book with unknown authors
Most religions do this
Well the land does belong to Israel
🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮
@@faveaugust The land is isreal, it doesn't belong to those that fled germany to seek refuge in isreal, how dare they go there after fleeing injustice and behave in that manner and they are not 'yews'. Oh well, times a ticking because America is spooked and scared right now, thinking they would get away with doing this again in China and I'm sure you've seen how that's turned out, you better be careful because dilapidated America is loosing power and favour right now, but I digress... Long live Snowdon
This happened to my parents in Cape Town South Africa...Around 1960's... Got displaced with many others making space for white people...
This apartheid should end like in Africa.
Was it district six? I remember seeing a documentary once that concentrated on how vibrant the cultural life was there. These settlers though have taken European arrogance to another level. Glad the south Africans are taking a stand against their citizens who serve in the IDF.
You are forgetting that Jews originated from these lands
@@Irin31no they don't. I'm a South African and don't try your fairy tale stories with me. Jews are from European descent.
@@Irin31you are foolish, stupid nut
While calling itself human right defender, US has always oppose basic human right such as freedom and self determination of Palestinians in UN since 1948 because of the lobby.
When was the freedom and self determination given to Jews when they were removed from their land 1500 yrs back
@@abram8874 Shameless maggots, always talking lies, trying to change history. Filthy and abhorred creatures like you cannot change the truth.
Jewish are lier that land don't belonging to them it's belonging to Palestine. Palestine have rights to get their land back from Israel regime. It's all American strategy to destroy Palestine people son of Jesus Palestine and mary megdelina. The one crossing Jesus are Jewish
The one who bring Palestine in jurusalem are Jesus Christ and build dome of rock
They lost battles, countries are formed by wars and diplomacy. Not some GIFTS!!! @@abram8874
This is disgusting, thinking because of their book they have the right to just occupy.
They don't occupy. It's their land. And the prove is based not only on "the book", which by the way is cherished by 3 billion people. There are also archeological proves that Jews lived in the territory for the last 4,000 years
You're right, sweetie ❤❤
They do. After all, this land is Israel, not a name given by Greek conquerors that the Arabs adapted as "theirs".
there s a famous saying from 3000 years ago in China that "there s no such thing as chosen people by heaven because the heaven only blesses those who are most virtuous"
"Blessing those who are most virtuous" are not a form of selection or choosing. If heaven don't choose, it blesses all whether it's virtuous or not. *Sigh… May the heaven bless your generations to come with intellectual to comprehend logic.
@shin4655 Your " If heavens don't choose" is a conditional statement based on your logic, so it s bizarre that u choose to insult me because ur logic doesn't agree with my translation.
You clearly don't have a clue on the how my translated statment was a rebuttal on the original Chinese statement where the King of a destroyed dynasty once proclaimed that their clans were the chosen people by heavens, and so he thought he could do nothing wrong despite slaughtering countless civilians and officials unjustly.
Are you going to argue China never had similar statement as chosen people by heavens because you insist everyone needs to follow your logic that IF heaven doesn't choose, it would bless everyone? like everyone is stupid because they don't agree with your metaphysics and religious view? Really?
@@jackjhmc820 like I said, may the heaven bless your generations to come with intellectual to comprehend logic.
p.s. getting emotional won't help.
@shin4655 lol you insist China should NOT have a religious belief 3000 years ago. Give you a time machine and go back, what phrase would you use to rally the troops to rebel against the King who felt so entitled to do all kinds of evils because he thought he was the chosen one? What s the prevalent belief back then? Every King was blessed by heavens, and it is very sinful to kill a king, which is also common even in medieval Europe. So your so called logic is totally irrelevant from a historical perspective.
you insisting that someone cannot comprehend logic just because they translated a Chinese statment 3000 years ago is as bizarre as saying Einstein could not understand logic because he read and translated a statement from Aristotle. Where is your logic in stating such absurdity?
@@shin4655 I apologise for getting emotional as many arrogantly used what they think are the correct metaphysics and logic to justify colonisation all over the world in the past 200 years and committing genocide.
Claiming that heaven blesses everyone, regardless of their actions, is just plain absurd. Apparently heavens blesses Mother Teresa and Hitler equally using your bizarre logic.
It completely ignores justice, moral accountability, and the importance of virtues literally in all religions and philosophy in shaping a just and compassionate society.
Referring to the bible for ownership of lands/houses is so mind blowing. The Palestinians have made THE mistake they are to madly regret by welcoming survivors of the holocaust. Anyone with some common sense should be outraged.
What do we do? We bring them back to Hitler that our religion commands us to secure the weak, and if it wasn't for Britain, all this would not have happened.
@@generaldisdain8837 Im not a religious person. But If there is a devil, the Palestinian are be haunted by it. Free Palestine from evil God.
That is an understatement. To use a Bible, Koran, or any other religious book. To claim ownership of another people's land. Is indeed outrageous. Why is Israel allowed to get away with such a clear violation of international law, is beyond me? The chosen people, as they refer to themselves. That kind of thinking. Smaks of superiority complex. I believe Germany in the 1930s,1940s had such a complex as well.
I would rather have a Palestinian as my neighbor than some gun toting Zionist land grabber who quotes the Bible as an excuse to go trash a neighborhood. They are ruining the beautiful Palestinian culture of East Jerusalem.@@lexsteel12
Those jews were forced on them
How can anyone sleep in homes they steal? Morality aside, arent they afraid owner might come back at night.
They know that, that's why more than a million Zionists came out and immigration movements were established, such as let's leave the country together, as they believe that their entity will not be eighty years old. Barak's Jews wrote about it in one of their newspapers, and Netanyahu and Beijing said that.
Only they can
they got no shame
Well they have guns IDF and the Israeli state/IDF protecting them.
Why would any type of person want stolen land are house protection r not I wouldn't
3:00 this lady was kicked out of her home after decades? And has to watch as Jewish settlers come in and take their house? Mind boggling and sick
Al Jazeera is the best media channel
Just a simple question, if the settlers can obtain the access to return, then what happens to Palestinians who were displaced 1948 from their homeland? Shouldn't they have the right to get their homes back? Wow! What a double standard. I myself getting educated from this excellent report.
❤❤❤
Wars have consequences, especially when there is a winner and a loser.
@@tomwellington4255only clowns believe that a war can be started from inside a concentration camp. 🤡
@@tomwellington4255it was no war the Palestinians had no army the jews came and forced their way in with the help of the British simple as that
Its pure racism.
What happened to the 800,000 Jews, who were displaced from Arab lands.. can they go back to those lands? Can they get their homes back? Sometimes you lose wars, and then you move on with your life. That’s the way it works and the rest of the world. Only the Palestinians stay refugees forever.
Disgusting...who can take someone's house and live in it! What kind of people are capable of such horrible injustice .
No one is more to blame for the misery off the Palestinians then themselves.
a. Beginning in the 1920s they attacked and killed Jews in the region
b. They supported the Nazis in World War 2
c. In 1947 they rejected the UN resolution to create 2 states
d. They continued to reject the 2 state solution from 1948-2008 at which time the Israeli electorate turned to the right and elected Bibi
e. Rather than negotiate the 2 state solution they engaged in numerous acts of terrorism not just against Israel but against Jews in other parts of the world . Some examples of both are Munich , Maalot, Entebbe, hijacking,, Achille Lauro, Passover bombing, and many more
f. Fired rockets at Israeli civilians for over a decade from Gaza
g. October 7th slaughter of not just Israeli and Jewish children, women , elderly ,disabled but also of Bedouins and some migrant workers from Africa
h. Took hostages and not only have refused to release them but actually chose to not continue the ceasefire because it required further hostages
i. Even now they continue to reject the idea of 2 States and express no remorse for the deaths of Israelis or Jews
I could cite other examples of how they have caused their own misery because of the bad choices and conduct. Sure, Israel has blood on its hands too but stop pretending the Palestinians are not the real cause of their own suffering and that they have blood on their hands.
The blunt truth that I know the Pro- Palestinians do not want to accept is they could have had a state in 1948 with a future but they chose to prefer to eradicate Israel and kill Jews. As a result they have had 75 years of no future, no stability, no peace, misery and no state ….. and they could have changed it numerous times by abandoning their bloodlust to eradicate Israel. All the false narratives of Israelis being settlers and colonizers, nor the online posts of marches will change their status of misery as only they can change their fate by wanting a true peace based on a 2-state solution. So, until they do that then they can continue to nothing but misery with no future because all the online posts, social media and marches will not change the fact that Israel exists and it can put an end to every country in the region because of is extensive nuclear arsenal.
that's right. The land belongs to Jews. Palestinian arabs are immigrants, and occupied Jewish territory/
Lol settle organization is biased
Perhaps some of us are unaware of the history of so-called white people.
amazing video that describes the situation
but believe me you can never imagine how it is miserable to live in such place where you are not considered as human
I don’t know why people can’t be at peace to everyone despite differences. May God bless their hearts 🥺
You are a good woman... The reason is the desire to possess what others have the right to possess through force, and they never think that humility and compromise for the sake of understanding is the best solution. ❤❤❤
Settlers are just a glorified term for squatters. They are squatters 😤
The settlers are not settlers. First and foremost, they are land grabbers, terror mongers and fanatics.
And the far-right government likes that.
Israeli out
Hmmm...more like devils.
Why are the terrorist referred to as settlers?
That's crazy. Palestinians need to defend themselves.
How can they w no army
THAT IS WHAT THEY ARE DOING NOW AT GAZA. IF THEY NOT RESIST,THEY WILL BE LIKE THE OTHERS AT WEST BANK. BUT THE WORLD CALL THEM TERRORIST.
no, they need to decide that they want to live and live in peace and let people around them to live in peace instead of promoting hate and raising their kids in hate
@Irin31 you need to stop watching that propaganda. That's the 1st step. 2nd, watch real reporters that are not biased on one side, like obviously main media. 3rd, all of Palestinians should take arms cause it really looks isreal aim to genocide. Kids, doctors, reporters, disabled people, women, and elder murdered. I am married to a Palestinian who was born in Jerusalem. Her parents never taught hate. I have spoken to her childhood friends, and they have not spoken about hate. However, I have seen old videos on parents teaching isreali kids to kill all Arabs. This is why you see in tiktalk it is so easy for these young adults (now) to say hateful unimaginable things to the Arabs. Honestly, don't be a poppet for isreal, cause all they are doing is fooling evangelical Christians in the west. Evangelical Christians do have their oven agenda
@@Irin31where will they "live in peace" when Israelis are literally stealing their houses?
Dude didn't you watch the video you are commenting on😂?
STOP!!! This neeeds to STOP!!!!!!!! 😞😞😞😞😞😞
It is interesting that humanity, especially in supposedly democratic countries, has always turned a blind eye until October 7th and did not want to know about the criminal acts committed against this people for decades and are still being committed. The country responsible for these genocidal acts has been portrayed mainly as a victim by journalists and media, driven by financial motives. Now, however, we witness children, women, families, and civilians being bombed through cowardly acts. This dilemma, caused by Western countries, is now unfolding, revealing the true face of this wolf in sheep's clothing. Through these reprehensible acts, people are often stirred, and their conscience no longer allows such criminals. They become aware of the situation🥱🥱🥱
Yeah but alot of us in America didn't know about this unless we apart of the Islamic community are live around them there good people and the media fkn lies here in America we didn't know nothing
These cultures have been fighting against each other since recorded history. The West is not the cause of the hatred. One day after the UN declared Israel to be a country in 1948, the Arab world attacked them and it's been back and forth for 75 yrs. For you to blame the West is ridiculous. You may not like the US policy to support Israel after they are attacked by Hamas but the US is not the cause of your problem. The US has given more aid then anyone and had a ceasefire that Hamas would not cooperate with. If Palestine is to be a free country they need a government that is not corrupt and supports/cares about them.
Same here in Canada. However, we do now!
Unfortunately our corrupt government (Trudeau) picks and chooses if and when he listens to the Majority of Canadians.
Please remember, people are Not their government, there’s many Israeli’s that are against these occupations- they have been recently and criminally silenced by Netanyahu and his goons.
Jews are very hypocrites: they persecute the God in the Bible which is Jesus, and at the same time they claim that the same God gave them the land. Israel has lost their land on many occasions described in the Bible. This land belongs to Palestine. Jesus called the Pharisees "hypocrites" 2000 years ago. Jesus is still right even to this modern day. Most Jews in Israel still use the pharasic law. Jews are hypocrites.
A crash course on the history of the PALESTINIAN STATE:
Every time i get a response its the phrase free Palestine, BUT they can't prove me wrong. so if someone can teach me something new, I would be happy.
1. Before Israel, there was a British mandate, not a Palestinian state.
2. Before the British Mandate, there was the Ottoman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
3. Before the Ottoman Empire, there was the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, not a Palestinian state.
4. Before the Islamic state of the Mamluks of Egypt, there was the Ayubid Arab-Kurdish Empire, not a Palestinian state.
5. Before the Ayubid Empire, there was the Frankish and Christian Kingdom of Jerusalem, not a Palestinian state.
6. Before the Kingdom of Jerusalem, there was the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, not a Palestinian state.
7. Before the Umayyad and Fatimid empires, there was the Byzantine empire, not a Palestinian state.
8. Before the Byzantine Empire, there were the Sassanids, not a Palestinian state.
9. Before the Sassanid Empire, there was the Byzantine Empire, not a Palestinian state.
10. Before the Byzantine Empire, there was the Roman Empire, not a Palestinian state.
11. Before the Roman Empire, there was the Hasmonean state, not a Palestinian state.
12. Before the Hasmonean state, there was the Seleucid, not a Palestinian state.
13. Before the Seleucid empire, there was the empire of Alexander the Great, not a Palestinian state.
14. Before the empire of Alexander the Great, there was the Persian empire, not a Palestinian state.
15. Before the Persian Empire, there was the Babylonian Empire, not a Palestinian state.
16. Before the Babylonian Empire, there were the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, not a Palestinian state.
17. Before the Kingdoms of Israel and Judah, there was the Kingdom of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
18. Before the kingdom of Israel, there was the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, not a Palestinian state.
19. Before the theocracy of the twelve tribes of Israel, there was an agglomeration of independent Canaanite city-kingdoms, not a Palestinian state.
Actually, in this piece of land, there has been everything, EXCEPT A PALESTINIAN STATE. 🤔
Shame on Israel.
After all that happened recently and how the American government is complicit in ever horrendous actions thats done on Palestinians , every time we blame ( it’s not real ) America should also be blamed as much because non of this would have happened with their approval of it.
Shame on Hamas, Islamic Jihad and all their supporters. 85% of Palestinians support them and are part of them. Are you one of those terrorists?
@@TAMIRQzyeah always blame someone else
So heartbreaking for the Palestinians lands & home, forced to be evicted by settlers.
Palestinians have the rights to live with piece without being harassed by Evil settelers.
May Allah protects you our brothers & sisters🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸❤️❤️❤️❤️
look who is really evil here. Palestinians who don't want to live in peace with their neighbors. Do you go around and kill your neighbors only because they are of a deferent nationality then you are? That is what Palestinians do. They don't want anyone next to them, only their own.
But The Jews don't have the right to live in peace? How many suicide bombers come from Israel into Gaza? HAMAS loves war, Palestine supports HAMAS, war is horrible and it's worse for the looser.
Why didn't she mention the Nskba , in 1948, when Israel on day of its birth launched a massive offensive on Palestinians massacring thousands of Palestine civilians, burning 50 villages poisoning their water Wells, and forcing thousands of civilians at gun point to leave their homeland. Its this horrific actions that the Arab people intervened to stop, they didn't start war with Israel as the video seems to be implying.
True.
Cowards lie and make excuses for their own failure. I feel pity for these people. Those loser attacked first in 1948, they though they could buly the weak, but they were turned down instead. After running away in fears, now these people come back lie to themselves, to their own people, and drowned in pity illusion. Its god punishment to be born as palestinien.
False. The Arabs attacked Israel with genocidal intent in 1948. And in 1967. And in 1973. The Arabs claim all of the geographical area of Palestine from the river to the sea. When you lose a war you started you lose territory. That’s how war works. Stop attacking Israel and you won’t lose any more
Because you you idea of reality is not true… hence why they did not mention it.
@@tl-ih8ukmonster
Every Muslim country should educate their students through course on nakba so they understand what Palestinians have gone through and freedom struggle from israel so they don't get brainwhased by western media
those that go to muslim schools will not be brainwashed of western media. only those going to american or western schools will be brainwashed.
Nakbah classes ! ???????
OK, so should they also educate their students on the thousands of Jews who were evicted from their homes in Muslim countries (as stated in this documentary)? IMO, people have to stop taking sides, as both Israelis and Arabs (so called "Palestinians") have done very wrong to the other. Also, IMO, the Arabs have gone about this in a way which is antithetical to a peaceful and even rational co-existence with the Israelis (not to say that Israelis have been all good) with their car bombs and suicide bombers of the 70's and 80's and now their missile attacks. All of these acts of violence only serve to help Israel and confirm that the Arabs (Palestinians) are a violent terrorist group.
In Muslim countries we learn how the West is amazing and we hv no history
Yes of course
The British also Separated our Greek land and put a Green Line in Cyprus Greece. Is anyone surprised. Everywhere the British go there's chaos ...'
In the 1950s. My great grandfather was tortured to death by the British and my grandmother survived but she had to run to escape rape, and torture and she managed to hide in a well, gashing and breaking her leg on the descent. She died a few years later in my mothers arms. She [said] that she was lucky that Cyprus has the oldest wells in the world.
I know that some British people had nothing to do with invading our homes and land, but there is still some semblance of hate within me towards them.
In Australia the Brits tried to genocide the indigenous, they tested their nuclear weapons here, indigenous were classed officially as Fauna! Demented religious types stole babies from arms of mothers, they dug up and stole the bones of the ancestors, they destroyed culture and life.
And yet Israel wonders why the rest of the world despise them….
And who said the rest of world despises them ?? 😂😂 even you beloved Arab states kissing their hand 😅
@@jonathanm4019 Which Arab states?? THE WORLD DESPISE THEM MY FRIEND. Even those that pretend to be friendly can't stand them in reality.
Not every country despises them.
Isn't it utterly outrageous that these people are being allowed by the government to live for DECADES in a house that they don't even own!!??? I'm shocked that the government is being so lenient and generous, why are they allowing people to get away with this theft? To live in a house they don't own!
My heart is burning
take some pepto
These peoples justification to the questioning of discrimination and dehumanization is just despicable. Absolutely heartless and bigoted.
That was a sobering, momentous presentation by the Palestinian ambassador. But I'm very wary as to how the next week plays out. Delivering aid while bombing continues seems impossible.
حسبنا الله ونعم الوكيل.. الظلم ظلمات ..
..Justice must prevail free Palestine
This is discusting if it was any other country breaking the law like this it would be punished
"I have two rules i live by, i don't believe anything the Gov't tells me and i don't take the press seriously." ~ George Carlin
Great reporting Al Jazeera. Wish your viewership grows in the west.
one can now understand why God punished them....
"Those who deny freedom to others deserve it not for themselves, and, under a just God, cannot long retain it."--Abraham Lincoln
🏆Start Here has been nominated for two Webby Awards, which honour the best of the internet. If you enjoy this series, please vote for us via the links below. It only takes a minute and we appreciate every vote! 🙏
vote.webbyawards.com/PublicVoting#/2024/social/social-content-series/news-politics
vote.webbyawards.com/PublicVoting#/2024/video/video-series-channels/news-politics
From Sandra & the Start Here team
Its Palestine 🇵🇸 people land and they got all right to defend their own land
Palestine is a roman province
No you are not !
These are the videos we need to share the media Will never show this. Please share for humanity.
This is south africa all over again. We were evicted under the slums act and the group areas act. Alot of the old people died shortly after eviction from their childhood homes.
Palestine is only the beginning. Syria 🇸🇾? Iraq 🇮🇶!? Lebanon 🇱🇧!! Egypt 🇪🇬! The biblical holy land includes deez!!! Praying 🙏 for Palestine bcuz we are Palestine! I love ❤ y'all
Cases just came out of them taking over Cyprus now
Israel mentioned it will be taking Southern Lebanon as it is part of historical Israel as is the lands around the Jordan River. They may take Sinai from Egypt down the road but that's TBD. They already stole Golan Heights from Syria and they even renamed a new development after Donald Trump.
And you will have to tell your children and grandchildren that the G-d of Israel rained down vengeance on the Palestinians. And then they will ask you “ what is this Palestine as I have never heard of it “.. Then they will ask you “ so tell us again how your brothers slaughtered your other brothers and sisters in Yemen, Syria, Libya, Sudan, Iraq, Afghanistan as we like that story “”
The Zionists jews feel they are chosen by God and that they are above other people. They honesty believe in "greater Israel" which is that entire area. Gaza is only the beginning. Zionism makes them believe they have a right to kill and destroy others. They even resent non-zionist Jews and Christians and will hurt or kill them if they oppose the Zionist agenda. Zionism is a satanic cult.
Shame on so called human right defende US and it's Allies saudi UAE
They all are sleeping bro no-one thinks about Palestinean. You can't believe Arab world
Arabs proud of themselves.
They never support ummah that's the reason they reached. Iran yaman support than those but not much because they were poor
One thing that this video neglects is that Israel did not just “take over“ in 1967. Five armies were preparing to invade Israel, and unfortunately, for the Palestinians, who are usually the victims, Israel won the war. By the way, you may note that, although the United Nations granted the Palestinians state at 1948 in the partition, Jordan took the Westbank and Easter, Muslim, and Egypt took the Gazza strip. Israel did not deprive the Palestinians of their state their brothers did.
Yep, just about everything you mentioned is wrong. Israel Instigated the war in 1967 by attacking neighboring countries and never stopped colonising Palestinian land
Yes with the help of america. America is islam, islam is America, aka WS, but I bet that's a little nugget you didn't know. Well now you do. Grow up and stop making excuses for your saTan spawn govt
Prophet Muhammad (SAW) said:
"When authority is given to those who do not deserve it, then wait for the Hour."
[Sahīh al-Bukhārī 6496]
😲 Leave me alone sir. 😯 😮 😙 🤭 😗 🙃 🙂 Smile 😊 ☻ -👀 😉; )
*😲 Government wouldn't care.☹*
Terrible people, have no words🤬🤬🤬
Dear Palestininans our herts with you❤
Jewish fanaticism is a massive threat to world peace.
Free Palestine ❤
from Hamas and Islamic Jihad
🤲✌✌Pain is never permanent.💯💯❤🤲
I think the state of Israel has lost its raison d'être.
Israelis steal land, murder children, commit genocide...
In short: Israel is breaking the law and endangering world peace.
My God, during the war we Filipinos was the only Asian country who whole heartedly welcomed here in the Philippines jews fleeing from extermination and this what their descendants have become. We Filipinos are very much welcome in Israel and is classified as among the righteous among nations. It is this very classification that we should not turn a blind eye on this because its the very essence of being one. What a shame.
God sees 👀 everything. Justice will prevail. I love the hospitality of the Palestinian Christians. Pray for peace, not fighting 🙏 ✨️ 🙌.
They Bible also says love your neighbor but I guess forget that 😂 these Jews are a complete joke. My heart goes out to all the strong Palestinians standing up for theirs rights. Freedom fighters 🇵🇸
Those stone buildings are amazing.
Doesn't rot, aesthetic, great insulator and resistant to weather damage.
Your brain is rotten 🤡🐱🐱🐱
They are also difficult to insulate and modernize, and Jerusalem is in the hills and gets really cold and wet in the winter, the old buildings are not so comfortable. But there is old world charm.
Oldest and most ingenious trick in the book: divide and conquer, create a false spider's web doctrine to keep us all realising that we are all connected.
What the moderator failed to mention was the 2 state solution 30 years ago was rejected by the Palestinians.
Well of course it was slow coach, the 'settlers' were already given 78% of the land and wanted to further split the 28% given to the palastinians, after already breaking the original agreement that the land would be split 50/50 after 5 years. Well AMERICA IS STARTING TO LOOK LIKE A 3RD WORLD COUNTRY ITSELF SO I SEE WHY YOUR MAD
Every time Al Jazeera journalist report. They might lost their life.
Thank yo for risking your life so Palestine civilian have a voice to the world.
I am from Singapore and thank you for letting us know the factual and reality of Palestinian life.
I hope u understand its Al Jazeera. It is never credible.
I used to feel so bad when I watched those world war 2 movies and the atrocities committed by evil. Now I feel like they were just movies. My heart is with the Palestinian people now because i an alive to see the truth
They literally voted for a terrorist organization to represent them in Gaza. They got what they voted for. Just like we did in the US with Biden...
thank's abby for keeping the story transparent
He doesn’t mention that they were also kicked out of countless countries in Europe. Even Africa said get the F out.
Why not respect the desires of the Arabs of East Jerusalem who are terrified of the possibility of being moved under a Palestinian government?
Where are you getting ''fact'' from? Don't just spew nonsense without any sources.
@@Walkerrrr Put your email i'll send you sources every single survey which asks them. The majority of them say that. Large percentage of them say they would move away to different neighbourhoods should the threat of being moved under Palestinian control materializes. Look up "Special Public Opinion Poll Among Palestinians of East Jerusalem 2022"
@@Walkerrrr
@Walkerrrr Every single survey which asks them. The majority of them say that. Large percentage of them say they would move away to different neighbourhoods should the threat of being moved under Palestinian control materializes. "PCPSR Special Public Opinion Poll Among Palestinians of East Jerusalem 2022"
@@Walkerrrr The truth is 99% of the people pushing this agenda don't care about the Palestinians at all they would love for them to suffer in any form possible if they think it would harm Israel.
@@liadx2672 Provide sources. Even if that's true, does not justify settlements
Settlers are not innocent people
The settlers are not settlers. First and foremost, they are land grabbers, terror mongers and fanatics.
Neither are terrosits
@@calenphillips2631 IDF. I agree.
Thanks for such information
I have no dog in this fight, it is not holy to me but if you invite a beleaguered guest to stay at your house and he turns around and ousts you and steals your house i think that is despicable and loathsome.
The Jews were the indigenous population ousted by the Romans in 70CE centuries before Islam. Try to study history.
Allah protect Palestine and give them peace and freedom and victory ameen ameen
Most of the settlers are from U.S. the so called defender of human rights.
I think the state of Israel has lost its raison d'être.
Israelis steal land, murder children, commit genocide...
In short: Israel is breaking the law and endangering world peace.
This would be easier to hear without music I can’t listen to it, it stops about 2.5 min in hopefully it doesn’t start again
THE BEST SERIES ON THE INTERNET.
Israel steal homes omg😢😢😢
I want to visit there. It looks really beautiful :)
Programme was Very well presented excellent from UK
illegal occupation is the rootcause of the problem ..
A rather shocking oversight that Al Jazeera doesn't mention the fact that Jews were living in many of these properties before the current Arab occupants and the Jordanian army destroyed their homes and forced them to flee.
Al Jazeera is a typical muslim channel with typical muslim mindset .
So it's not oversight buddy
It's deliberate .
It's right she mentioned that the Jews were equally expelled from Arab countries YET none of them ever mentions their right of return.Or is it only the Arabs who has right of return? Your comment too is correct.
❤ I love my people❤
This is so disgusting, When will Leaders learn that it is always better to work together. When they divide us, We all lose
I think the eyes are going to be open now for the world to see.
They love that eviction process,here in the U.S court rooms and halls are filled with mostly jewish lawyers ready to evict folks from their homes,even during covid they tried and succeeded to do so.
It was the same tactics the nazis used
Shameless 😢😢😢😢 my God how they will die 😢😢😢 thats insane. 😢😢😢😢
Waaaait wait wait.
So he evicted them because he actually purchased it from the people who had the documents that it belonged to them?
People do that in the US with renters if the home or property is purchased by a new owner??
Yes, they purchased the land and the renters who put additions on homes they do not even owe or pay taxes on refuse to leave the property even after they violated the terms of the lease, same thing goes on all over the land, someone buys the property and cannot use the land for decades. Long term entitlement.
May Allah help our Palestinian brother.
Ala , Dios , Jehová todos que ayuden al pueblo palestino y las personas tambien
THOSE SETTLERS ARE DEVILS AND HISTORY WILL NEVER FORGET!
I think the state of Israel has lost its raison d'être.
Israel is stealing land, murdering children, committing genocide...
In short: Israel is breaking the law and endangering world peace.
The settlers are not settlers. First and foremost, they are land grabbers, terror mongers and fanatics.
Heart breaking doc
Surah Al-Maidah Ayat 21 berikut ini
يَٰقَوْمِ ٱدْخُلُوا۟ ٱلْأَرْضَ ٱلْمُقَدَّسَةَ ٱلَّتِى كَتَبَ ٱللَّهُ لَكُمْ وَلَا تَرْتَدُّوا۟ عَلَىٰٓ أَدْبَارِكُمْ فَتَنقَلِبُوا۟ خَٰسِرِينَ
Artinya: Hai kaumku, masuklah ke tanah suci (Palestina) yang telah ditentukan Allah bagimu, dan janganlah kamu lari ke belakang (karena takut kepada musuh), maka kamu menjadi orang-orang yang merugi.
Surat Al A'raf Ayat 137
وَاَوْرَثْنَا الْقَوْمَ الَّذِيْنَ كَانُوْا يُسْتَضْعَفُوْنَ مَشَارِقَ الْاَرْضِ وَمَغَارِبَهَا الَّتِيْ بٰرَكْنَا فِيْهَاۗ وَتَمَّتْ كَلِمَتُ رَبِّكَ الْحُسْنٰى عَلٰى بَنِيْٓ اِسْرَاۤءِيْلَۙ بِمَا صَبَرُوْاۗ وَدَمَّرْنَا مَا كَانَ يَصْنَعُ فِرْعَوْنُ وَقَوْمُهٗ وَمَا كَانُوْا يَعْرِشُوْنَ
(Artinya: "Kami wariskan kepada kaum yang tertindas itu, bumi bagian timur dan bagian baratnya yang telah Kami berkahi. (Dengan demikian) telah sempurnalah firman Tuhanmu yang baik itu (sebagai janji) untuk Bani Israil disebabkan kesabaran mereka. Kami hancurkan apapun yang telah dibuat Fir'aun dan kaumnya dan apa pun yang telah mereka bangun.")
Ibnu Abbas menyebutkan, yang dimaksud dengan 'Kami berkahi sekelilingnya' dalam surat Al Israa ayat 1 itu adalah bumi Palestina dan Urdun (Yordania). Sementara Abul Qasim As Suhaily menyebutkan, bumi yang diberkahi tersebut adalah Syam yang meliputi Yordania, Suriah, Lebanon, dan Palestina.
What these Palestinians are crying about? That they are not allowed to build in particular areas? And that they are evicted from properties to which they have no homeownerships/property titles? If they are to get these rights, then the same rights should be given to Jews that were forced from their homes that they actually owned all over Middle East in 1940-1950s. But Jews are not even allowed to travel back to the lands where they had these properties. So Arabs need to look into mirror to see who is at fault here putting all these divides between people and nations.
Both acts are wrong I agree, but there is no question of double standard if two apply a permit one Jew , one Palestinian one approved in a month or two , the other a year or more or be denied I don’t agree with what’s going on , but there’s evil on both sides one just covers it up better
Did they not got kicked out after they claimed Israel, a land that has native Palestinians?
Quite correct.
@@moman3r33 what do you mean by "native Palestinians"? Over a million of Palestinian Arabs migrated into what is now Israel from surrounding areas at the beginning of the 20th century for better job opportunities and better health care, after educated European Jews moved into the area.
@@Irin31 oh so you are saying before Israel the land was empty? That smells like bs
A one state solution was implemented in Jerusalem and Arabs were offered an Israeli citizenship.
No one wants "Israeli citizenship" coz no one wants Israel
What's been going on there for years is desgusting
The powerful wins? Move on guys!
Amerikkka is not winning now, they're scrambling and scared because their usual tactics such as the one seen here are not working anymore, did you see b!dens puppet looking lost and defeated in China the other day. Oop. looks like times up. B!den fxcked up lololololol
I have been forced out of my home in Los Angeles, U.S.A. when the property I rented, was bought out by a new landlord & he wanted to re-rent my apartment to a new tenant that could pay alot more. I can relate but it is all legal. Sad, but legal.