Link’s the kind of guy to write a review for a restaurant saying “everything was great. The food was incredible and the service was wonderful. Three stars.”
Yeah, I think we all knew that the ranking was just going to come down to whatever Link liked, since Rhett was going to be pretty fair/even across the board.
Link: “I don’t like that, 57.” Rhett: “what?? I was going to give it higher than that!! 61.” Link: “that’s great! 80!” Rhett: “I don’t feel that great about it. 78.”
I think its because they arent similar flavours and the chocolate or whatever would clash with the next. They organized it with flavours. But u have a good point😃
@@Klaudia0027 What did I spoil? That Rhett likes everything and Link doesn't like anything? Cause if you didn't already know that, this must be their first video you watch.
Was I the only one just staring at link the whole time visually struggling to think, eat and score every ice cream. Never have I been so stressed watching a man eat ice cream.
I don’t blame him. I’ve never had a B&J’s ice cream I didn’t like and most are very good. Link is giving them failing scores and saying he doesn’t like them? Wtf
@@TheHilltopperNation I didn’t like this triple chocolate something one. I expected it to be good, and it was good. But I don’t like hard chocolate pieces and ice cream to be combined...
It’s one thing to not like tomatoes but the fact link doesn’t like caramel, banana, mint, etc and is just in love with peanut butter is 100% a detriment to the ranking system
I really appreciate when Rhett contradicts Link by saying "I dont feel *that* great about it" or " *what??* I was gonna give it higher than that???" then proceeds to rate with a difference of 2-4 points *Exhibit A:* 5:44 *Exhibit B:* 7:10
One of the better flavors. Best thing to do with these you tubers that rank food is just never pay attention to their ratings. I’m here to see the things I’m not going to eat be eaten, it stops at that.
In which Rhett and Link taste 50 variations of something, pick four things that contain peanut butter and then choose the one with the strongest, most pure peanut butter flavor.
ORORORORO!!! I spend half of my day sleeping! ORORORO!!! Then I sometimes get up and tell you that I am a famous content creatorORORORORO!!! Please don't sleep while driving, dear melanch8
Often people think they are milk intolerant but they are actually milk allergic. Both make u feel gross. Some things are worth it every now and then :)
Does he actually like ice cream though? I think I’d give similar scores, but I only kinda like ice cream. I’d rather have fruit sorbet. Maybe he doesn’t love ice cream? Or he’s just super fussy 😄
I remember back when I used to watch this channel early in the morning, watching this now shows how much I've missed and I'm sad I stopped watching it, you guys are still as wonderful as I remember, if not better, thank you all for continuing this wonderful series.
Just discovered your channel and I'm so happy. This is right up my alley as I always want to know what the best is. Respect your decision and love the process! The tonight dough is my favourite but I guess I have to try PB world. Ben and Jerry's is great but Baskin Robbins is ever better! Would be awesome if you could do a similar video sometime down the road! Keep up the good work!
I'm wondering if he works in the same studio that both GMM and Funhaus are in. He's been popping up randomly in all of their videos without acknowledgment. XD
![BLACK BAG - Official Trailer [HD] - Only in Theaters March 14](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/Du0Xp8WX_7I/mqdefault.jpg)
Link’s the kind of guy to write a review for a restaurant saying “everything was great. The food was incredible and the service was wonderful. Three stars.”
If he doesn't absolutely love something then his automatic reaction is "I don't like it".
😂😂😂
So basically you're saying he's german?
Says everything was perfect, gives a passive.
Alexander Dombrowski this got me good
Rhett: "78, this is good"
Also Rhett: "not a fan, 78"
🐔
He stayed in the 70s almost the whole time! At least Link jumped around!
sarahelizaf link scored so low!! It’s as if he doesn’t really like ice cream
@SomethingReallyStrange many ice creams would have the same scale so they have to narrow it down a lil bit
Link: “Amazing, unique and an overall great experience, 42.”
Also Link: “I’ve had better. 73.”
ChokeAnd Poke 😂
link has read my soul bc i would do the same thing tbh
link is the best, man
Time stamp?
Timestamp
I feel like Link’s parents raised him on chicken nuggets and Mac n cheese
Why?
I agree
and sugar cookies, and kool-aid
FR
@@Mustafe_Fr because he is so picky
Rhett: “not a fan of this flavor, 78”
Link: “this flavor is amazing, 47”
HAHAHAHAHAH
So true
Lmfao
Omg I just realized what you meant hahaha XD
I'm pretty sure that link wasn't that aware of what he was saying, per usual.
Links’s idea of being generous: 37
Rhett’s idea of holding back: 65
Yeah, I think we all knew that the ranking was just going to come down to whatever Link liked, since Rhett was going to be pretty fair/even across the board.
rhett: *eating the tonight dough* 'It's good, it's simple'
The tonight dough: *Chocolate and caramel ice cream, chocolate cookie swirls, chocolate chip cookie dough and peanut butter cookie dough*
me: 'yes, of course, simple'
a lot but simple ingredients
it is but REALLY good
He must not have gotten a chunk of anything.
Very delicious ice cream I must say 😋
Best flavor
Holy shot, 1 year later you can see WHY they gave link the emotional chart 🤣🤣🤣
I need them to redo this with Link having his reference chart.
Just liked this comment to make it "333". Thanks.
Holy shot
so true
Lies again? Believe Japan School F**kers
Link: * rates everything really low *
Also Link: *on peanut butter round* "I'm gonna be really rough on these, 'cause they're my favorite"
Kevin Stark also link again: **at peanut butter round** “im gonna give it a 70 (around that)
"really rough on these" right... gives everything peanut butter the highest scores. Very rough indeed...
Link: “80!”
Rhett: “I don’t feel that good about it... 78”
Technically he is correct. He doesn't feel that good about it. "that" as in links 80. So 78 was not as good as 80
Link: I like this one
Rhett: I don’t really
Also link: *rates lower than rhett*
Link: “I don’t like that, 57.”
Rhett: “what?? I was going to give it higher than that!! 61.”
Link: “that’s great! 80!”
Rhett: “I don’t feel that great about it. 78.”
Lmao
the first number only matters to Rhett
When link gave the cookies and cream cheesecake a 51 and Rhett just said no and gave his score I was crying😂😂
Yeah I was so confused when that happened.
Link: "It's a meh" 72
Also Link: "It's Good!" I'ma give it a solid 50...
1st
Last
@@EatMyBallSack last last
Not last
plot twist: hes using negative numbers.
Me wondering the whole time why the Core flavors didn’t get their own category...
cookies and caramel too
I think its because they arent similar flavours and the chocolate or whatever would clash with the next. They organized it with flavours. But u have a good point😃
Does anyone know where they got ALL of the flavors
@@artbykimchi2766 Check the B&J website they let you know what stores near you carry what
And the Truffle ones
Alternative title: Rhett and Link Making Up Numbers as They Eat Ben and Jerry’s ice cream
@Andrew Sunde LMAO
Dawiie Is cheese LMFAO
The final four really loses its power when you realize they’re technically just all of Links favorites that got an average score from Rhett.
Literally. Link is a little bit*h
True
No they wern't the lowest score Rhett gave was "Tonight Dough" 76 the rest we mid 80s which isn't an "average" score
@@mattey456regardless most of these gut checks are weighted by links scores.
Oh...never thought about it that way...
it's almost like Rhett is Fahrenheit and Link in Celsius
Well.. Then my scale wud hv been in kelvin.. Considering my luv fr ice cream😂😂
This is the best comment I’ve ever seen in my entire 16 years
@@thebeast4837 Kelvin is lower than Celsius. By a lot.
@@lexisanoddperson8680 Uhhhmmm... Freezing point of water - 32 F, 0 C, 273.15 K. Like, freezing point of the universe in Kelvin is 0.
@@lexisanoddperson8680 nope it isnt man... N I actually meant it in a diff way coz my rating wud start at 273😂
Link: "80!"
Rhett: *puzzled look* "I don't feel that great about it! 78."
Sam Williams
I was hoping someone else caught that 🤣 he did it a couple times too lol
The title should be "a guy that loves everything and a guy that hates everything but peanutbutter rates Ben and Jerry's"
what if there were tomato flavours
I love your pfp
Yes😂
@@Klaudia0027 What did I spoil? That Rhett likes everything and Link doesn't like anything? Cause if you didn't already know that, this must be their first video you watch.
baconfromhell666 I think it was his first time
Correct title of this episode: “We like peanut butter more than ice cream!”
WHO DOESN'T LIKE CARAMEL? THESE GUYS! WTF
Plot Twist:
Gus Johnson is slowly kidnapping all the crew members.
Please do this.
Yes at it again. Lmao checking if we are really paying attention.
Is Gus a crew member?
You’re weird dude...
Hes everywhere
"57."
"What? I was gonna give it higher than that. 61."
"80."
"I don't feel THAT great about it. 78."
I was just about to comment the 80 one 😂
The 10’s place really twists people’s perception of numbers
Lol
I would never want Link grading my test in a class. May score 90 or 27 seemingly on a whim.
Are we not gonna talk about Gus Johnson randomly being there
Yes
I knew he looked familiar
I was so confused and I still am
rhett: “it’s not the greatest thing but it’s alright, 78.”
link: “it tastes really good, 21.”
me: 💀😂
Well he didn't know what the standard ranking would be.
he said i dont love this alot
not i love this alot
rhett: “this limited shirt is only available for 17 hours”
me watching this video 17 hours after it was posted: 👁👄👁
@Mrs. Riggsiib4bd I 5 0
me reading this comment 17 hours after it was posted: 👁👄👁
This was 17 hours ago that you said this.
That face... needs a fren 👁👅👁
Sauce wait who, me or pleb?
I've learned that I can't trust R&L's taste in sweets. They love peanut butter too much for my taste. Buttt I'll still watch and love every minute
when they scored the first 2 peanut butter flavors i knew that the top 4 were all going to be peanut butter
Was I the only one just staring at link the whole time visually struggling to think, eat and score every ice cream. Never have I been so stressed watching a man eat ice cream.
I love how Rhett is just so upset at half of Link's scores.
It's unnerving how link scores in general.
I don’t blame him. I’ve never had a B&J’s ice cream I didn’t like and most are very good. Link is giving them failing scores and saying he doesn’t like them? Wtf
Most of the time Link waits for Rhett to score first then he scores lower
@@TheHilltopperNation I didn’t like this triple chocolate something one. I expected it to be good, and it was good. But I don’t like hard chocolate pieces and ice cream to be combined...
To be fair, Rhett's scores are just as inconsistent but Link doesn't react to that
I hope Ben and Jerry’s sees this and makes a new flavor called Good Mythical Munchies and it’s just layers of the boys’ favorite picks. 🍦
Heather Latta this is genius, how do we make this happen?!
Sooo just peanut butter?
Tomato and pork blood flavor??
Heather Latta and pork blood
AMAZING IDEA
I would have liked a 3 hour episode where they went VERY in depth about how they feel about every flavor
I feel like they could’ve done a whole “Core” category
and cheesecake
And caramel
Link: gives most flavors under 50
Peanut butter flavors come
Link: iM gONna bE TouGh oN tHEse
Alright, Link.
If he hadn't been tough on those, they'd have probably all been 100
No one gonna talk about how Rhett is lactose intolerant
He probably supplements lactase digestive enzyme before he does these videos
There is quite a selection of non dairy options for Ben & Jerry’s ice cream.
Jackie McCann I doubt they would do that for a taste test without stating it’s dairy free tho
Lets talk about that..
Jackie McCann none of these were dairy free.
It’s one thing to not like tomatoes but the fact link doesn’t like caramel, banana, mint, etc and is just in love with peanut butter is 100% a detriment to the ranking system
Mythical Crew: March Madness is coming up, this would be perfect for a bracket style week of shows
Also Mythical Crew: let’s do it in one show
And taste all at the same time with salt in between
Should have made it ASMR while at it
rosshenderson96 would’ve been the perfect march madness
To quote Chris Morocco "there's mint chocolate chip, then there's everything else"
*throws spoon*
@@axeavier *throws another spoon*
@@amiraabdelkader2751 *throws multiple spoons*
Sniffs and takes small bites
I get it's a quote... but I can't stand mint chocolate chip 😂
An accurate representation of the college admissions process
😂 so true
Yeah but they wouldn’t have let any chocolate in
@@jequelamaquez7794 yikes
LMAOO
Jeque Lamaquez they let a lot more chocolate than they should(even if it’s not deserved). Affirmative action...
Link is the most dramatic human on the planet, who else could be recoiling and flinching and grimacing and whimpering when eating ice cream lol
People with sensitive teeth lol
I'm loving the Gus Johnson cameos
who is Gus Johnson?
the_nikster the guy about 10 minutes in who was at the desk all of a sudden, he also replaced chase in the dart episode recently.
@@the_nikster1 How dare you!!
roadchewer PE this town ain’t big enough for the both of us
Gus Johnson is the Stan Lee of GMM
Link is the guy whom you would never want to grade your papers
He's that one friend who you will be lenient with when grading who will never get the cue
“Not enough peanut butter”
R/rareinsults
You get 9/10 questions right but he gives you a 53
I really appreciate when Rhett contradicts Link by saying "I dont feel *that* great about it" or " *what??* I was gonna give it higher than that???" then proceeds to rate with a difference of 2-4 points
*Exhibit A:* 5:44
*Exhibit B:* 7:10
haha I noticed the same... such a dramatic reaction to then score 2 points away
I’ve never even had “Ice Cream Sammie” and yet something about Link giving it a 3 is infuriating
It's amazing
One of the better flavors. Best thing to do with these you tubers that rank food is just never pay attention to their ratings. I’m here to see the things I’m not going to eat be eaten, it stops at that.
He later jitters and visibly suffers through other flavors he gives way higher rankings to
@@hdhshdhs5503 except Rhett is usually on point with his grading scale because he likes almost everything lol
Peanut Butter Round
Link: “Imma be tough on these cos these are my faves”
Also Link: “87 89 80 72 87”
Straight Peanut Butter: "100"
15:30
Link: “We love peanut butter!”
Rhett: *fanfic flashbacks*
🤣🤣
AAAAA NO
It's sad watching other people living your dream
Jael Beer exactly !!
HIGHKEY
same
and then doing it better
Same
In which Rhett and Link taste 50 variations of something, pick four things that contain peanut butter and then choose the one with the strongest, most pure peanut butter flavor.
Link: *Says his score*
Rhett: *laughing at this man for being so absolutely rediculous with his scoring choices*
Rhett and link: "thank you for making us apart of your daily routine"
Me: *watching this at 11:59 PM*
"You're welcome"
Ikr
IMG Oh c’mon it’s only 11:50 PM 😂
Hey wait a second., for me when I started it was 11:5something
It's 1:07 A.M. for me.
It was like 11:20 I think when i watched it
They should've done the top winner in each category.
Yes. That probably would have worked better.
Yeah
Should have just done it tournament-style like they did with Halloween candy, etc.
the couple times link relies on math:
Rhett: "47" Link: "I think I'm gonna go- 53"
Rhett: "43" Link: "No, I think im going to go with... 57"
Okay, so Gus randomly appearing is going to be a running gag now...I’m okay with that.
TheRealSullyG hey sully but timestamp please
Never mind
@@aknavvy3188 timestamp?
10:07
lmao what
I love how Gus Johnson just randomly pops in. Excited to see his future cameos
“Oooh I like that! 80” -Link “I’m not feeling THAT great about it... 78” -Rhett lol
Apparently a 2 point difference speaks volumes to Rhett. 😆
Rhett's reactions to Link's scoring is probably my favorite part of the episode.
“Netflix and Chilled”
Rhett: “why is that so gooey?”
Lmao
I think we know why
LoL
lmao
What are the odds
Basically this whole video is just Rhett judging Link for what he scores the ice cream 😂
Totally! Why can't he just let him do what he wants?
@@littleredhairedgirlsteph3922 Why is Link scoring everything so low!
@@jaredd9602, because that's how he sees it...?
Rhett didn't like when Link scored things higher than he did, either. Just no making him happy.
@@littleredhairedgirlsteph3922 I didn't see a part where he stopped him from doing what he wants.
Lmao
I feel like Gus Johnson is that one friend you never get photos with
That Gus cameo is the greatest thing on the face of the planet
Omg it was so insane when that youtuber was in that youtube vid
*Strawberry Cheesecake ice cream*
Rhett: “It has some graininess.”
It’s graham crackers crumbs...
MelancholyMountain12 thank you , I can’t thank you enough.
MelancholyMountain12 literally the best flavour hands down.
By far the best flavor
ORORORORO!!! I spend half of my day sleeping! ORORORO!!! Then I sometimes get up and tell you that I am a famous content creatorORORORORO!!! Please don't sleep while driving, dear melanch8
It’s my favorite flavor!
this video is a lot sadder when you remember that rhett is lactose intolerant
Rhett's toilet: Please sir, I have a family!
@@hoover6291 bruh ahahhahahahah im choking hahahaha
Often people think they are milk intolerant but they are actually milk allergic. Both make u feel gross. Some things are worth it every now and then :)
Made me laugh but I don't wanna change the like which are 666 so...
@@CarroLoveEd it's been changed anyway, how dare people
666 is a great number
Link: "oooo i like that, it's smooth. 68"
*confused* "i dont like it. uh.... 69"
Would have liked to see the favorites from each category.
same ☹️
i haven’t yet recovered after the pb story and y’all just keep adding more and more 😩
I just commented the same lmaooooo
I wonder what Gus does with his day that he is just standing around, and able to sneak into these videos.
"We like peanut butter." Flashback to the fanfic.
Amanda LeLoup I’m so sorry but what fic?¿
@@just.vaibing9151 episode from last week
AHHHHAHAHAH
HOW DARE YOU!!!! :((
The swirl!
"Netflix and chilled "
Rhett "what is that gooey stuff"
Me : you don't wanna know 😏
Nice lol
That’s the best flavor too
Rhett’s Favorite: Peanut Butter World (90)
Links Favorite: Cinnamon Buns (94)
Thanks! Yeah, I wish they'd also shown the top 4 for EACH of them, SEPARATELY.
Cinnamon buns is by far my favorite. I side with Link, would have loved it to take a place lol
deprofundis No problem! I wish they did that too.
Rhett - “I was a chubby hubby like, one year in to marriage.” 🤣
rhett's face when link said "we LOVE peanut butter!!" was the face of a man who remembers the time him and his friend sharing a jar of peanut butter.
hahahahaha dude! nice one
Nathaniel Pendleton oooohh scary experience
Someone needs to do a video compilation of Rhett reacting/criticizing each time Link says his score.
Rhett: Good palette.
Link: "I don't like ice cream."
Kiro Haas *palate 😉🙂🙂🙂
LINK DOSENT LIKE ICE CREAM!!!!!!!?!???!????
The should be fear-ded dragon prob because of his sensitive teeth
RaRted 2.0 Cuz I got banned for some reason ok I have sensative teeth too
The should be fear-ded dragon same I cant bite ice cream either
When these two agree on something it is automatically factual
underrated comment
@Miasma LOL yes
deluded
They both like almond joy so I’m not to sure about that
I think this should have been done tournament-style, like y'all did with the Halloween candy, etc.
goodspeed29 i think so too
Milk and cookies didn't get a fair chance. That thing has 3 types of cookies and most of the time you get a whole ass cookie in there
@10:08
"Sorry babe, I know you're in the hospital right now but I'm doing an accountant bit at the moment"
Link hated everything this was just an episode of what link doesn’t like 😂
Does he actually like ice cream though? I think I’d give similar scores, but I only kinda like ice cream. I’d rather have fruit sorbet. Maybe he doesn’t love ice cream? Or he’s just super fussy 😄
Nicole B 😂 you could be right
Marcos Castelan 😂
PEANUT BUTTER!!!!
@deborah DeborahR Lol I remember that! When he got hypnotized to like tomatoes
Gus Johnson strikes again.
So is Gus Johnson now to GMM what the alien was to South Park?
4:21 Rhett: I’m gonna give that one a 83 cause I know he is gonna score it really low
Link: (laughs) yeah I gotta give that a 19
Rhett: (laughs)
Link: 80
Rhett: I don’t feel that great about it, 78
😂
This just made me realise how small the Ben and Jerry's selection is in the UK. We only have about 10 of these flavours
About 4 in Australia
Same in Canada
Same in canada!
In Australia I've only ever found 2
Maybe 3 or 4 in Hungary
I’m living for Gus Johnson slowly taking over the GMM crew lol
I’ve noticed him in the videos but don’t know who he is, can someone explain?
I didn't watch any last week was he in some of them too?
@@victoriakennerly1304 just type gus Johnson in the search bar.
Victoria Kennerly he’s a RUclipsr
I come back to this every once in a while to find new flavors.
I feel like cookie dough and cheesecake should've has it's own category lol
AND the caramel
Avdol? 👀😳
@@optimisticopossum5167 please dont tell jotaro I watch Rhett and link
Link: sorry don’t like a lot of things
Everyone: it’s ice cream
I don't like ice-cream
Rhett: Ah I didn't really like it as much... 72
Link: *3*
they should’ve done a caramel category there was quit a few carmel’s
I remember back when I used to watch this channel early in the morning, watching this now shows how much I've missed and I'm sad I stopped watching it, you guys are still as wonderful as I remember, if not better, thank you all for continuing this wonderful series.
7:10 Rhett: “I don’t feel THAT great about it” *goes just 2 points under Link*
Haha
A 1-10 scale with one decimal point would have helped Links’s brain.
As a chocolate and coffee lover I was hoping the best would be one of those categories. Gotta try their PB range
Rhett: i’m lactose intolerant
Also Rhett:
I didnt even know the coconut one was dairy free when I got it but it was so good.
Link: "51"
Rhett: "No"
SBeckerDTD I read this as they said it and I was shook
76😂
Jessica Hulan Sameee wtfff
52 Ice creams
did I get it right?
GUS JOHNSON I JUSY POOPED MYSELF THE TRANSITION WAS SO BEAUTIFUL
Yes! That's the second time I've seen him! How rar back does this go!? I've heard no mention of GMM lately from Gus or G&E.
Just discovered your channel and I'm so happy. This is right up my alley as I always want to know what the best is. Respect your decision and love the process! The tonight dough is my favourite but I guess I have to try PB world. Ben and Jerry's is great but Baskin Robbins is ever better! Would be awesome if you could do a similar video sometime down the road! Keep up the good work!
yessss agreed, I would love to see them do that one!
I know this comment is from three years ago but woww I forget not everyone grew up watching these guys doing "will it popsicle" and stuff😂
I love that these two best friends in the world have nearly opposite tastes in food, except where peanut butter is concerned.
Are they close because Rhett seems to not like him to much, or is that just a joke?
@@PreposterousPotatoe its a joke they are childhood friends lmao
So we aren’t gonna talk about Gus Johnson showing up AGAIN?!
I'm wondering if he works in the same studio that both GMM and Funhaus are in. He's been popping up randomly in all of their videos without acknowledgment. XD
lol yeah. what other episode did he show up in?
Korvin SMOSH makes their videos in the same building and he is a regular there.
Lmaooo I laughed, was not expecting him
NO
Lovin' the Gus cameos
Just have him on the show already!
Phish Food is grossly underrated here...
Agree 💯👍