This song was deeply emotional as part of my history listening to Pete Seeger as well as Peter, Paul and Mary sing. This message is still unfortunately poignant and we all are singing with you brilliant young musicians. Thank you for your beautiful heart felt sharing.
My girlfriend turned me on to this song a great rendition, I've seen the Kingston Trio several times, my girlfriend had to leave the US for cancer treatment a year ago, she's in Belfast Northern Ireland fighting a uphill battle, I miss my Irish Rose 😥😥🇮🇪🇮🇪
What a superb rendition of a great song....so emotional sitting here listening to it...almost feels like I was there when it was being sung.....great great song....performed by great great singers and great great musicians. What a privilege to listen to such talent!
This is filling me up. Most beautiful version I've ever heard of a song that is just as relevant and poignant now, if not more so, than when I first heard it over 60 years ago. Thank you for posting it 🌺
I was moved when I first heard this song by Pete Seger (and I really adore him), but your performance is on a completely different level (which is about the greatest respect I can show). Folks, you are terrific.
I grew up listening to folk music, though I didn't really understand the meaning of the lyrics of many songs until I was older. This is one of the few songs which will bring me to tears every time I hear it. It's message is just as apropos today as when it was first written. Almost Irish, this was an absolutely beautiful rendition. Thank you for using your talents in the name of peace and harmony. Maybe someday, someone can pen a new final verse the question by saying mankind now understands; we have finally learnt.
This version is so fabulous and powerful with a touch of sadness. This song written by PETE SEAGER and sung by MARLENA DIETRICH, Peter Paul and Mary , Bob Dylan....and many others does tug at the heart ❤️
This rendition makes me year up every time, my girlfriend turned me on to this, she's in Belfast Northern Ireland fighting a huge battle with cancer, she left the United States a year and a half ago because treatment was less expensive, she is doing better but I miss my Irish Rose 😥😥🇮🇪🇮🇪
Brilliantly adapted to flute, really enjoyed watching the young men inherit probably one of the most influential songs in history that still plays a great part of our lives today
Beautiful version. One of the most powerful songs ever. Heard when I was a kid and it informed me more than much of schooling did. Pete Seeger spoke 'truth to power'. Thanks to this band for continuing the voice, may it be truly heard one bright day.
Beautiful song folks and excellent performing. I enjoyed it so much. Seeger will be proud of yez. Btw. I used to tour a lot with mij Dutch/Irish band Amadán all over Europe and we were in Danmark and Sweden too for some 30 gigs on a row. Great times.
I grew up in Greenwich Village in NYC. We had assembly on Friday mornings and Pete Seeger would teach us these songs. I still know all the words and verses to this, as well as This Land Is My Land. like most children in our neighborhood we had no idea that these grownups were famous.
Where have all the flowers gone? Long time passing Where have all the flowers gone? Long time ago Where have all the flowers gone? Girls have picked them every one When will they ever learn? When will they ever learn? Where have all the young girls gone? Long time passing Where have all the young girls gone? Long time ago Where have all the young girls gone? Taken husbands every one When will they ever learn? When will they ever learn? Where have all the young men gone? Long time passing Where have all the young men gone? Long time ago Where have all the young men gone? Gone for soldiers every one When will they ever learn? When will they ever learn? Where have all the soldiers gone? Long time passing Where have all the soldiers gone? Long time ago Where have all the soldiers gone? Gone to graveyards every one When will they ever learn? When will they ever learn? Where have all the graveyards gone? Long time passing Where have all the graveyards gone? Long time ago Where have all the graveyards gone? Covered with flowers every one When will we ever learn? When will we ever learn? Songwriters: Peter Seeger
This is possibly the best cover I’ve heard of this moving song. These musicians really seemed to feel the meaning of the lyrics. Cheers guys, I’ve become a fan
in this day and age we are still asking "when will they ever learn?"
Love this version. The band have such a mellow way of getting their music across.
We certainly need this more than ever now🙏
This song was deeply emotional as part of my history listening to Pete Seeger as well as Peter, Paul and Mary sing. This message is still unfortunately poignant and we all are singing with you brilliant young musicians. Thank you for your beautiful heart felt sharing.
My girlfriend turned me on to this song a great rendition, I've seen the Kingston Trio several times, my girlfriend had to leave the US for cancer treatment a year ago, she's in Belfast Northern Ireland fighting a uphill battle, I miss my Irish Rose 😥😥🇮🇪🇮🇪
Thank you for your comment. We send our warmest thoughts to you and your girlfrend
My thoughts are with you both.
While we still sing this song Pete lives on and the futility continues!
Brilliant version. Why can't we all live in peace?
BEING "AMERICAN IRISH" MAKES THIS SONG EVEN MORE SPECIAL FOR ME...TY☘️
Absolutely beautiful track in these dark times! 😍 😍
This is the most moving rendition of this song I’ve heard, and I grew up in the US in the 60’s. Thank you. 😢, and ❤️
It’s great how about Peter Paul & Mary?
Thank you so much:)
@@ericlevi5729 And the Kingston Trio ? Of course !
Cant believe I've just discovered this group. The best EVER version I have ever heard.
Same here , what a great voice on singer. My icon is something grandson added. But love this version.
The Irish people should lead the world for peace!
What a superb rendition of a great song....so emotional sitting here listening to it...almost feels like I was there when it was being sung.....great great song....performed by great great singers and great great musicians. What a privilege to listen to such talent!
What a beautiful voice and rendition of this wonderful song.
I'm crying everytime I heard this song,,songs for unknown heroes
Love this song. Makers me home sick Prode to be irish
Thank you for your comment
Love
God bless the Irish ☘
This is filling me up. Most beautiful version I've ever heard of a song that is just as relevant and poignant now, if not more so, than when I first heard it over 60 years ago. Thank you for posting it 🌺
The best version of this song.
Beautiful song , presentet with a irish heart and soul ❤️🇮🇪☘️
That is a magnificent rendition of a great song. Didn’t think anyone could sing with that great Irish accent. ❤️
Beautiful version of Pete Seeger's song. I'm sure he's smiling
Absolutely moving
The best
And I grew up on the song
Geoffrey Abrams
NYC, NY 10011
I was moved when I first heard this song by Pete Seger (and I really adore him), but your performance is on a completely different level (which is about the greatest respect I can show). Folks, you are terrific.
Thank you very much for your kind comment:) it makes us proud
Superb
👍👍👍
I am hooked
World needs this song, especially in these days. Peace for Ukraine.
Thank u💙💛
@@MsMonochromeRainbow this is for Donbass
and Gaza
Time to build a wall around America - the world would be safer …
@@ManelBioscayes. The genocide must stop
Fujarki rewelacja!
I grew up listening to folk music, though I didn't really understand the meaning of the lyrics of many songs until I was older. This is one of the few songs which will bring me to tears every time I hear it. It's message is just as apropos today as when it was first written. Almost Irish, this was an absolutely beautiful rendition. Thank you for using your talents in the name of peace and harmony. Maybe someday, someone can pen a new final verse the question by saying mankind now understands; we have finally learnt.
Thank you so much for this comment. It means a lot. I hope we can make that final verse one day
People joinig them in the choros...beautiful.
Beautiful rendition of an all time classic, music doesn't get any better than this.
Det er som om at få hældt lunken sirup i øregangen..❤
Så flot
Hilsen fra Haiti
I love this version of such a wonderful song. And all such beautiful talented young men.
Great musicians great vocalist. Pete Seeger would be proud.
Pete Seeger would be so proud he might just burst.
Thank you:)
Thanks for this beautiful rendition, sing with a lot of emotion.
I luv this version.
Bellissima e molto bravi questi Irlandesi👍
This version is so fabulous and powerful with a touch of sadness. This song written by PETE SEAGER and sung by MARLENA DIETRICH, Peter Paul and Mary , Bob Dylan....and many others does tug at the heart ❤️
Thank you. It is a bit of a sad song. Sadly
It is based on an old Cossack folk song and this is a beautiful rendition.
👍👍👍
Came across this recently.....just beautiful really struck a chord definitely one of my favourite versions the talent here has captured me.
We must unite to apply the wisdom of our elders. Today more than ever, let these words mean something meaningful
Beautiful song and a beautiful voice - Many thanks - Joe Malta
This rendition makes me year up every time, my girlfriend turned me on to this, she's in Belfast Northern Ireland fighting a huge battle with cancer, she left the United States a year and a half ago because treatment was less expensive, she is doing better but I miss my Irish Rose 😥😥🇮🇪🇮🇪
Brilliantly adapted to flute, really enjoyed watching the young men inherit probably one of the most influential songs in history that still plays a great part of our lives today
This is the best version i ever heard by far, can you relis this on Spotify
full of emotion. love the arrangement.
Excelente versión y muy buenos musicos. Enhorabuena !!!
Beautiful version. One of the most powerful songs ever. Heard when I was a kid and it informed me more than much of schooling did. Pete Seeger spoke 'truth to power'. Thanks to this band for continuing the voice, may it be truly heard one bright day.
que bella interpretacion de esta hermosa cancion del maestro Pete Seeger ......
fools keep fightin 4 the elite structures, let's go creative society, wake up people
Fantastic! I've never heard such a great version before. And the two whistle players are really great.
Thank you very much. Alexander and Chris makes you feel like two birds in full play when they lock into each others music.
Yes ... they did good... startled my synesthesia
I miss my Dad becahse of this song.
He have a huge tape & CD collection of classic hits.
THANK U for your cover. ✌🎸
Beautiful song folks and excellent performing. I enjoyed it so much. Seeger will be proud of yez. Btw. I used to tour a lot with mij Dutch/Irish band Amadán all over Europe and we were in Danmark and Sweden too for some 30 gigs on a row. Great times.
Could we revive this song?? reach out to the world??? - very touching and spiritual
One performance at the time:) thank you for this comment
brillant. I love their rendition. This song written in the 1950's still relevant today with wars still going on in Ukraine and Middle east.
100K views, wishing you all well wherever you may be 😇🙏🕊
A Classic, more important now, than ever. Updates welcome...
chills and tears immediate response to this beautiful rendition and God-like vocals
Thank you. We are very human though. And now blushing human:)
This song makes me cry
I grew up in Greenwich Village in NYC. We had assembly on Friday mornings and Pete Seeger would teach us these songs. I still know all the words and verses to this, as well as This Land Is My Land. like most children in our neighborhood we had no idea that these grownups were famous.
That such a lovely memory you have there. Thank for sharing
Love love love
Sublime version et quelle communion ❤
great cover as good as the one by peter,paul and mary still true today maybe even more with the crazyness in the world
Brilliance.
Bravi! Iscritto. Greatings from Italy
Fantastic !!!!!!!!!!
Seems like only yesterday.....but perfect for today.
WOW! A great folk tune with Irish music arrangement and amazing vocalist, that's awesome!
A very precise description. Thanks:)
Where have all the flowers gone?
Long time passing
Where have all the flowers gone?
Long time ago
Where have all the flowers gone?
Girls have picked them every one
When will they ever learn?
When will they ever learn?
Where have all the young girls gone?
Long time passing
Where have all the young girls gone?
Long time ago
Where have all the young girls gone?
Taken husbands every one
When will they ever learn?
When will they ever learn?
Where have all the young men gone?
Long time passing
Where have all the young men gone?
Long time ago
Where have all the young men gone?
Gone for soldiers every one
When will they ever learn?
When will they ever learn?
Where have all the soldiers gone?
Long time passing
Where have all the soldiers gone?
Long time ago
Where have all the soldiers gone?
Gone to graveyards every one
When will they ever learn?
When will they ever learn?
Where have all the graveyards gone?
Long time passing
Where have all the graveyards gone?
Long time ago
Where have all the graveyards gone?
Covered with flowers every one
When will we ever learn?
When will we ever learn?
Songwriters: Peter Seeger
A really great performance well done
Lovely real irish
Love ireland
This is powerful
Beautiful rendition. Brings back many memories of time past when life was a little more simple. Instrumentals beautiful.
Pure Class 👏👏🇮🇪
Brillant
pure
what a great version !
Awesome!!
Ireland, land of The Troubles, pray for the Ukraine and that peace may soon cover that nation. When will we ever learn, learn peace is the answer?
❤
Very moving version of this song, I love it, excellent music and vocals
Hey hey !! Cool !! Perfect !! Thanx - super boys !!
Amazing👏🏻
When will we ever learn🇺🇦?
when will putin ever learn
Beautiful!
Super song
Fermosa versión. Very good cover.I like.
This is possibly the best cover I’ve heard of this moving song. These musicians really seemed to feel the meaning of the lyrics. Cheers guys, I’ve become a fan
Anawhim Marlene Dietrich does a better hands down
Thank you. Its deep felt and touching to sing powerful songs like this one
Thank you! With love from Yaroslavl, Russia!
Thank you. We would love to travel with this music in Russia one time
formidable
Thank you... Cheers from Poland!
Ja też dziękuję w szczególności Pani za zainteresowanie tym szczególnym ponadczasowym dziełem. Serdecznie pozdrawiam.
Thank you. We would love to tour in Poland one time
@@Armunk When you do my tears will flow from happiness. Let me know when that will be.
@@jadwigapietrzak3170 when we do we will announce it here on the chanel and make sure you are informed:)
Absolutely amazing🙌🙌🙌🙌
Fantastic ! Thank you from Milan
Thank you. Lovely city.
Im just lost for words
Hermosa interpretacion me emociona profundamente
Muchas gracias
Fantastic rendition
Lindo!!! Love from Brasil!
Gracias
Interesting version🍀
Awesome
❤️
When will they ever learn? That’s what I want to know. FREEDOM
Amazing!!!! Deep to the heart.
Great! So emotional!
If I didn't know before that this was an American folk song, I thought it was Irish folk songs
...Leafing through his notebook he saw the passage, "Where are the flowers, the girls have plucked them. Where are the girls, they've all taken husbands. Where are the men, they're all in the army."[6] These lines were taken from the traditional Cossack folk song "Koloda-Duda", referenced in the Mikhail Sholokhov novel And Quiet Flows the Don (1934), which Seeger had read "at least a year or two before...©
It was written by the great American folk musician: Pete Seegar.
The best known covers are by The Seekers and Peter, Paul and Mary.
Written by an American but folk song of the world. Universal in its musical and lyrical language
I love this song and your version of it. Loved your concert in Skagen as well! :)
Thank you Fiona