Understanding the Role of the Speaker, Parliamentary Procedures, Conventions and Rules

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 24 дек 2024

Комментарии • 111

  • @Gulshan07.
    @Gulshan07. 4 месяца назад +23

    "A speaker is the only person in the house who should not speak"
    One of the biggest takeaways from the conversation

  • @Rohitkumar-vg9ow
    @Rohitkumar-vg9ow 4 месяца назад +13

    I think Kapil sir is providing much needed information to us at current topic ❤❤

  • @anthonypereira3272
    @anthonypereira3272 4 месяца назад +11

    Such interactions are very essential as they give the layman an insight into principles of democratic discipline

    • @sendy2366
      @sendy2366 4 месяца назад

      Anthony bab, thank you for watching Dil se with Kapil Sibal. Please watch 4PM news.

  • @K_Vjay
    @K_Vjay 4 месяца назад +5

    Since 2014 majority of representatives are not using their consciousness. Lack of knowledge led us towards the unemployment, price rise, hatred. This type of social talk will help us to understand better about the cause and solutions. Congratulations to Mr. Sibbal for doing the great work for all of us.

  • @इन्द्रकुमारगुनाणी

    Hardly anyone has political and legal experience, you have lived both yourself, you are a true patriot, you have a lot of love for the country in your heart, salute to your spirit.

  • @SeemaDevi-nd3vh
    @SeemaDevi-nd3vh 4 месяца назад +6

    Sir every year there should be a meeting by intellectuals like you and members selected, should give suggestions to enrich the house procedure. Nothing should be stagnant. So refreshing leads to improvement sir.

  • @SKD1947
    @SKD1947 4 месяца назад +1

    Kapil sir you are doing or presenting a great service to the nation...... Nice to see PDT sir ❤🙏🇮🇳

  • @SeemaDevi-nd3vh
    @SeemaDevi-nd3vh 4 месяца назад +2

    Namaste and respect to Sri. Kapil Sibal sir.

  • @Gulshan07.
    @Gulshan07. 4 месяца назад +7

    Please have a conversation on pros and cons of Sub-classification of SC category and also the model of creamy layer which should be implemented in the SC category

  • @SurinderKumar-ln1sh
    @SurinderKumar-ln1sh 4 месяца назад +2

    Good discussion. What is the use if we get the impression that this will not be done or they wont do it etc. Viewers should get to know what needs to be done so that impression is created and spreads that things are not right and need to be changed. Then only change can happen.

  • @vinaikumar6997
    @vinaikumar6997 4 месяца назад

    Thank you Kapil sir for such an enlighten debate on our parliamentary proceeding... as govt changed IPC to BNS, they should change the rules of procedures of LS/RS, increase time of proceeding for coming out of colonial hangover.

  • @dip-tree
    @dip-tree 4 месяца назад

    Every episode of your channel is so informative. These necessary information should have been taught to us right from high-schools.

  • @GurpreetSingh-xq4so
    @GurpreetSingh-xq4so 4 месяца назад

    Very good discussion and something to act upon.

  • @visa3267
    @visa3267 4 месяца назад +2

    Got to learn a lot from this episode .

  • @FathimaM-n8y
    @FathimaM-n8y 4 месяца назад +2

    I believe both PM HM and both speakers listen this and make necessary change instead of acting like baffuns in circus favouring their party and treating others as slaves of their home, whom people have elected..

  • @gurdeepsingh1616
    @gurdeepsingh1616 4 месяца назад +4

    Very true ji

  • @Gulshan07.
    @Gulshan07. 4 месяца назад +3

    Should the chair be beyond criticism? I think time has come to think over this question too

  • @girikshitsharma9687
    @girikshitsharma9687 4 месяца назад +4

    Speaker making politically or personally inclined statement is moral and substantial deviance from parliamentary role which is that of a mediator and a class monitor of a nasty noisy class called Parliament saying so, it is also a reciprocating duty of the parliamentary to not poke the speaker of biasness or irresponsible remarks.
    As of the issue regarding the mic, it is not just mps duty to file the breach but also inherent duty of the speaker as the one among all to ensure the safety of their rights

  • @baqirhemraj7639
    @baqirhemraj7639 4 месяца назад +3

    A speaker is responsible for presiding over assembly debates and maintaining order and discipline in the house during legislative sessions. He/she decides "when a member should be called upon to speak and how long he be allowed to speak".

  • @SeemaDevi-nd3vh
    @SeemaDevi-nd3vh 4 месяца назад +3

    Whats happening in house is usually many wrongs, one member uses uncivilised language , no action by speaker, another member takes up genuine issues, his phone switched off. .No action taken. Members have to beg give me a little time. So time has to be according to importance of topic.

  • @roodysingh2655
    @roodysingh2655 4 месяца назад

    Satyapal Malik sir, we are missing you 🙏🏻✨🇮🇳
    ↕️The voice of truth and honesty
    Kapil Sibal sir thank you for your constant teachings and for sharing knowledge and prudence 🙏🏻✨🇮🇳

  • @John-d2n3s
    @John-d2n3s 4 месяца назад +1

    The speaker has become a loud speaker.
    He's supposed to keep the debate on track so things don't go out of control.
    The cams and audio-visual are there to see if the script is notedited

  • @kuldipguleria2615
    @kuldipguleria2615 4 месяца назад +2

    Speaker's remarks should be scrutinised and be open to review for their justiciability by the SC.

  • @Prashant-uk8rx
    @Prashant-uk8rx 4 месяца назад

    This is what we call a productive conversation ❤

  • @pbghosh5305
    @pbghosh5305 4 месяца назад +2

    Significance of Money Bill, its scope, legality, and why this provision is necessitated.

  • @omarpeerzada1721
    @omarpeerzada1721 4 месяца назад

    Very informative discussion.. regards Omar Peerzada

  • @OnkarSingh-lq8ck
    @OnkarSingh-lq8ck 4 месяца назад +2

    Speaker Om Birla and Chairman Dhankar of their respective houses must rise above their party Affiliation and must be MADE to attend a CRASH COURSE on How they should CONDUCT themselves in their respective houses.
    They MUST not think they are ABOVE the CONSTITUTION of India and the PROCEDURES of the respective houses and both MUST BE criticised in the MEDIA, in the LAW Universities of this country, in the LAW JOURNALS of this country as and when they deviate from the traditions of the parliamentary CONDUCT!!
    The Parliament belongs NOT only to the members of Parliament, that is, the MPs, and the rules of business of the houses, the Parliament, the members, the rules , the traditions, but ALL of them in TOTALITY belong to the PEOPLE of this country.
    The Speaker as well as the Chairman have NO BUSINESS to take the people of this country for granted. They are their because of the people of this country.
    The courts must take NOTE of this FACT.
    The Courts too need not think that they can take the people of this country for granted.
    The CIVIL SOCIETY MUST rise to the OCCASION and EXPOSE the Speaker, the Chairman, the MPs including the PM, as well as the judges of the Court, and also the MEDIA!! Because today all the institutions of this country are under a BIG QUESTION MARK ‼️
    A very bad slide downwards of the democratic values.
    The Supreme Court in a particular case decided on what are the issues to be decided. Once the issues have been decided and argued, what CHEEK did the Supreme Court have to have not decided on one issue. How could the Supreme Court NOT DECIDE on a ISSUE which it had DECIDED, which article gave it the POWER to IGNORE in NOT DECIDING on an ISSUE!!

  • @Realchap
    @Realchap 4 месяца назад +1

    Excellent 👍

  • @sahi67
    @sahi67 4 месяца назад +6

    Mr Sibal. The new broadcasting bill has to be discussed. It is highly draconian.

  • @MosesDkhar-cl7og
    @MosesDkhar-cl7og 4 месяца назад

    In the real democracy,a member once elected as a speaker or chairman of the house must rise above his party affiliation and he must be impertial and non partisan,but in today's democracy ,the speaker is spokeperson of the ruling party,it is for the people to judge whether democracy is alive or dead.

  • @rashmirajsonal8971
    @rashmirajsonal8971 4 месяца назад

    Just love this show

  • @Life.is.a.library
    @Life.is.a.library 4 месяца назад +1

    We should also need to talk about the future, is there any current opposition party who's promising to make things better or who is promising to change the recently made draconian laws like broadcasting law, data protection law, telecommunication law, to reduce the unjustified power of the police, to strengthen the judiciary and election commision, or everyone in the opposition just waiting for their turn so they can also enjoy these unconditional power. We should also think about that. I dont think there is any party in the opposition who's promosing all these things

    • @naresh-lk3lh
      @naresh-lk3lh 4 месяца назад

      Never have thought like that, hmm you're right

    • @mariappansengodan7596
      @mariappansengodan7596 4 месяца назад

      This is what many of us dream for.
      Day dream...sad.
      Saner voices may prevail one day,to bring in real democracy, the good of all.

    • @Life.is.a.library
      @Life.is.a.library 4 месяца назад

      @@mariappansengodan7596 what day dream man, dont you know the politics or politicians in our country. Although in my opinion its always society which has to be blamed because politicians are no aliens, they come from this society only, and i think our society is low standards in moral and thats the root cause of poor political scenario in our country. But i also thinks that it only take one good leader to change everything, but for right now i can say India haven't witness that leader yet

  • @Jafrinsiddika456
    @Jafrinsiddika456 4 месяца назад +1

    #plz help us sir 🙏u r the last hope of neet aspirant atleast 13 lakh qualified ko justice mile neet pg ke sath itna bura hua plz sir ekbar health system bhi dekhiye 🙏

  • @zeeshpara4356
    @zeeshpara4356 4 месяца назад +3

    Present two presiding officers are like the old angry uncle of colony.

    • @dip-tree
      @dip-tree 4 месяца назад

      Neighborhood uncles ko gali mat do. These are two chamchas of Modi. period !

  • @ranjanasharma1331
    @ranjanasharma1331 4 месяца назад +3

    Please sir help us we want reneet😢

  • @cooffe2nik
    @cooffe2nik 4 месяца назад +3

    Dhankad speaks more than any party or combined opposition. It's their another ploy.

  • @HimanshuAggarwal-qj1kw
    @HimanshuAggarwal-qj1kw 4 месяца назад +4

    Sir reneet

  • @RaviRanjan-vf9sf
    @RaviRanjan-vf9sf 4 месяца назад

    Much interactive session ❤😊

  • @mmddssi
    @mmddssi 4 месяца назад +4

    Speaker is not controlling the Mike , EC is not hampering the EVM than who is playing with the Indians. Golmal hai bhai goolmal hai!

  • @indrapalmaurya3424
    @indrapalmaurya3424 4 месяца назад +3

    We want justice. We want RE NEET.
    SIR,
    Ham baccho ke sath bahut bada injustice hua hai. Hamare sare sapne Tut chuke hai. Hamne apna sab kuchh is exam ke liye chhod diya tha.Lekin hamari seat koi aur paiso ke bal par khrid le gaya.
    Ek supreme court se badi ummid thi vaha bhi hamare sath injustice hua. Aaj ham sabhi students ka aur unki family ka supreme court se vishvas uth Chuka hai .
    Aaj Aisa lag raha hai ki ham apne hi desh me tanashahi ki shikar ho gai hai.
    Bas sir ab apse hi akhri ummid hai. 23 lakh students ka future ab aap hi bacha sakte hain.apko and apke pariwar ko bahut duaa milegi .
    Agar aap bhi sath chhod denge to mere paas suicide ke alava koi option nhi bachega😭😭😭😭🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • @EdwardDSouza-e4c
    @EdwardDSouza-e4c 4 месяца назад +2

    Speaker only speaks and questions Opposition only to BJP. The speaker rules and regulations should be applied to bring in speaker who deserves the chair and to throw out the existing speaker.

  • @Life.is.a.library
    @Life.is.a.library 4 месяца назад +1

    I believe the real problem isn't the rules or procedures, and its also not true that previous gvrmnt's were so pious. It's about the absolute power/majority that the current government has, which previous governments lacked from 1989 to 2014.
    Fruitful parliamentary discussions and debates on new bills are rare nowadays because the previous two regimes had a clear majority, and the current one has a high number of seats. This wasn't the case for the old regimes from 1990 to 2009.
    If you dig a little deeper, you can easily see that history is repeating itself. When Congress got more than 200 seats in UPA 2.0, a big jump from around 140 seats in 2004, they also started behaving like the current regime. There were scams upon scams, poor economic performance, strengthening of laws that provided them unaccountable power, and overconfidence because they believed people were blindly supporting them. Moreover, it's always the same case with absolute majoritarian governments, whether it's BJP or Congress. The regimes of the late 60s, early 70s, or 80s were typically the same or even worse than the current government. The Emergency was not the product of a specific political figure or party but the result of absolute majority, which made it possible.
    In my opinion, in a republic like India, it's not healthy to have an absolute majority government. The corrupt nature of our people makes it difficult to handle. Yes, I'm saying 'corrupt people' and not 'corrupt politicians, because politicians are not aliens; they come from our society.

  • @Darwin-l8x
    @Darwin-l8x 4 месяца назад +3

    Sir please support for re neet
    😭😭 life ka sabse worst time chal rha h
    Bohot mental pressure h 🙏🙏

  • @RashidKhan-jx7ph
    @RashidKhan-jx7ph 4 месяца назад +1

    Kapil Sibal Sahab Aapse ek iltiza ek Guzarish hai Ki Aap Apna Show Hindi Me Kiya Kare TaaKi Hum Gao Me Rahne Wale Log bhi Aapki baat samajh Sake

  • @rayr5408
    @rayr5408 4 месяца назад +1

    This comment is in regard with the "Mike in the Parliament " being muted, at an exact time when a opposition member gets wants to say his or her opinion is happening only with more knowledgeable electricians, who could have helped in the wiring systems of the entire area covered along with that of cameras too.
    Wiring for both camera and Mike has been taken out of that hall into the meeting rooms or any other rooms where still executives still work from there even though the session of discussion with ruling and opposition is going on.only appointed person for this kind of coveted ness knows, for this person not only hears sitting in some rooms,he has been given the powers to mute,put the camera off,turn the camera, all this with the power of technology,wiring,hidden aggression. The fake mannerisms is around authoritative dignitaries,
    No technician will be able to say a word of truth, even though he would know.
    For the FEAR they all have been induced is far more greater than the strength of the voltage passing through those wires.

  • @srajansingh3822
    @srajansingh3822 4 месяца назад

    Well done ankita

  • @kmochhary6160
    @kmochhary6160 4 месяца назад +1

    P D T Achary , Lok Sabha Secretary General

  • @Aditav8680
    @Aditav8680 4 месяца назад

    Sir will you pls bring retired judges & Abhijit Ganguly the Ex of Bengal on a conversation with you and ask on Labour law reforms, Population Control!

  • @avraman7040
    @avraman7040 4 месяца назад

    The Speaker /Chairman not only expresses opinion and even says something like the member is very senior and not expected to say/ behave what was said or done

  • @tasneem5423
    @tasneem5423 4 месяца назад

    I feel the speaker should not be from any party. Naturally he'll be biased. He'll have to take up for his party

  • @NiranjankumarSingh-hr2rv
    @NiranjankumarSingh-hr2rv 4 месяца назад +1

    Ustar,Us,Santo,ki,Najar,Say,Gerana,Enki,Path,pud,Garema,Clankit,Carna,Khalayga,Jo,Sunghyan,Nagawar,thi,or,Sadav,Rahaygi,Bhachho,may,Wishvas,Sardha,snatan,Dharm,ka,Ahat,hogi.

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    The legal fraternity is giving different colours to the present situation and not allowing government to function for the betterment of poor people of this country

  • @AbhiDilDostiAndMasti
    @AbhiDilDostiAndMasti 4 месяца назад

    Can we have a legal PM question hour? When only PM is responding to questions. Whatever duration and frequency can be. We have borrowed from British Parliament.

  • @pmishraofficial
    @pmishraofficial 4 месяца назад +1

    Chakshu Roy keeps denying other people’s points and then just says the same thing in a different format. 😅

  • @rockhy9109
    @rockhy9109 4 месяца назад +1

    Parliamentary democracy gone completely with Andhra Pradesh bifurcation 😂

  • @Pppppppppbbbbbb5
    @Pppppppppbbbbbb5 4 месяца назад +3

    #pleasehelpkapilsir neet aspirants

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Corruption ko kam karne ke liye as leading lawyer of the country kuch kar sake then people of this country will remember you forever

  • @sklux6147
    @sklux6147 4 месяца назад +1

    Soon India will have a Supreme Leader, an Ayatollah like figure, who by virtue of heading the Parent Organisation will be allowed to excercise power over the Constitution. President, VP and Speaker are bowing before the PM inside the parliament. Elected PM will bow before the non-elected and extra Constitutional - Supreme Leader. Parampara, .....
    Righteousness and the Superior Wisdom of our glorious heritage are given primacy over the Constitution. The values, drawn from hallowed & inspiring sacred sources, namely Sabyata - Parampara - Maryada - Sanskar - Sanskriti etc. are used extensively to replace Universal Democratic values such as Equality - Freedom - Rights - Justice - Diversity - Inclusivity - Federalism etc. The Republic will corrode and Constitution will become irrelevant while India will become Shresth Bharat.
    India will return to pre-independence type Feudal State with Varna based social order. That will mark the completion of restoring of our ancient heritage to it's original glory. Leadership and the govt have charted Amrit Kaal to collide the sacred goal of achieving - Uniformity over Unity - with the celebrations to mark the 100th anniversary of Independence in 2047.
    Satyamev Jayate ✌️
    Jai Hind 🫡

  • @Neerafun
    @Neerafun 4 месяца назад

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤ sir

  • @pmishraofficial
    @pmishraofficial 4 месяца назад

    In a country of 1.4B people, mere 8k have watched this video! Shows the priority.

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Discussion depends on the intellect of members and top leaders and their intent

  • @kaushikchoudhary1512
    @kaushikchoudhary1512 4 месяца назад

    From i can gather from this insighful discussion, we have created a democratic system on the surface and we dig deeper into its working , its getting worse than colonial times practices.

  • @Millions0fDreams
    @Millions0fDreams 4 месяца назад

    Sir please reply...i know you check all these comments...how we can contact you? Your PA nirmal sir isn't allowing me to meet you... can i come to your address tomorrow? Our matter is pending before Supreme court and we need you... it's our last hearing... Please reply sir

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    What are your views on AAP and RJD corruption Mr. Sibbal ji please

  • @umarraje3710
    @umarraje3710 Месяц назад +1

    Sar ji aap apne program mein Hindi ka jyada istemal Karen

  • @locationsmumbai3411
    @locationsmumbai3411 4 месяца назад

    ❤❤❤

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Everyone is knowledgeable nowadays n leaders are opposing their own interest not for country

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Discussion should be on netas corruption rather than running the parliament

  • @locationsmumbai3411
    @locationsmumbai3411 4 месяца назад

    ❤❤

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Nothing is going to gain opposing only Modi ji

  • @kanwalburmi7342
    @kanwalburmi7342 4 месяца назад +1

  • @tylert9875
    @tylert9875 4 месяца назад +1

    75 years on still figuring the role of the speaker. Lol

  • @manoalex6575
    @manoalex6575 4 месяца назад

    Sibal..just tutured this lady who seemed to be a fresher

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Leave all political positions and as a neutral person do good for the country as individuals

  • @ashwiniu3316
    @ashwiniu3316 4 месяца назад

    Sir kya aap unemployment k mudde par baat kar sakte
    Hai ,aur future of youths aur unko aaj k samay kya karna chhiye sarkar kya rol nibha sakti hai
    Abhi ki sarkar kha galti kar rahi hai

  • @kavishmishra4245
    @kavishmishra4245 4 месяца назад

    I wonder what would have happened if The man of your stature and knowledge would work towards building a nation and not destroying it.. You have all the power to do good yet you choose to stabd with the wrong side every time..

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Don't waste time discussing these issues just for your personal interest only

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Kya congress ne ordinance nahi use kiye

  • @manoalex6575
    @manoalex6575 4 месяца назад

    MODI Govt going the Hasina way...silencing the opposition when it requires at their behest

  • @imaculadagonsalves6158
    @imaculadagonsalves6158 4 месяца назад

    Sir please have the conversation in English.

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Sabal ji ye sab aaj kyo change karne ke idea de rahe ho apne samay kuo nahi kiya

  • @sdar148
    @sdar148 4 месяца назад

    Let Opposition elect.an able ,responsible member as LOP irrespective of their number.
    What yu are discussing now is attributable to an LOP ,who himself ,has no clear view ,and competance.and command on su ject.
    We did watch the parliament functioning when Vajpayee and PV NarasimhaRao functioned as Leader of house and LOP ,
    .Both have full command on the subject they were speaking and also aware of conventions and decorum of house and total control on their party members.Vajpayee used to sit down,when PV rose to make a point and converse was also happened. They behaved responsibly and respected each other,irrespective of whether they were in treasury or oppn.benches.
    Unfortunately this is not happening now. LzoP ,never stops or with draws his party members from shouting or going into the well and surrounding g Speaker. They do not even allow Soeaker to give his ruling on a point of order..
    If yu are discussing ,what is convenient to yu and what is not stated in the rulebook.loke ,ye hons chalice, ye nshi Honda chaahiye is unfair. Yu are wasting our time once again apart from live streaming of house proceedings and yr behaviour as a member.

  • @mintusaren895
    @mintusaren895 4 месяца назад

    As far my knowledge leprosy four . Gaon me hai district health dept bhi enha vertical hai. Christ is associated

  • @jayoopatwardhan4040
    @jayoopatwardhan4040 4 месяца назад

    It seems like speaker is like the goal keeper of one party while being a part of democracy He should only watch and be a referee . Why are rules being distorted ? What is authentication . Also they have made their own rules and do not understand the implications of being in democracy in the discussion to rule better . The meaning at large must be understood for the good if the country . At present it’s all a tamasha !

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Already defeated in top court

  • @dualmaterial9096
    @dualmaterial9096 4 месяца назад

    Call any Gandhi family member on ur show.

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Aaj jo ho raha hey bo isliye ho Raha he kyoki caste politics ke bajah se non- deserving candidate ko lekar aaoge to yehi hoga

  • @explorerlife2787
    @explorerlife2787 4 месяца назад

    Om birla & dhankar have become over talkative these days than the members in both the houses of parliament. Frequently acting like a class teacher. This trend is threatening for democracy.

  • @pranaynlu
    @pranaynlu 4 месяца назад

    Bhai why torturing her 😂

  • @Vidhata786
    @Vidhata786 4 месяца назад

    Birla ji know.little little.english.

  • @pradeepkumarsharma2869
    @pradeepkumarsharma2869 4 месяца назад

    Sibbal ji aapne jinko bulaya bo aspki language hi bol rahe he ye koi sahi baat nahi

  • @Night_owl_day_dream
    @Night_owl_day_dream 3 месяца назад