SMC vs HRB Battery Comparison in the Freewing F-4 8s Setup

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 29

  • @PhilBender612
    @PhilBender612 2 года назад +1

    Nice comparison, yes, I remember your last pack comparison video. I'm all about this. I can see your performance with the SMC pack overall yes, but isn't the consistency of the HRB pack worth something. I'm impressed that all three passes were nearly identical. Great stuff thanks.

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад

      Yes. I fully agree. It held its own well. I did note that. So it depends on what people want to spend.

  • @timjoostens8887
    @timjoostens8887 2 года назад +2

    Love my SMC packs! Worth every penny!

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад +1

      I have done several reviews now and agree completely

  • @Mrtcoltpilot56
    @Mrtcoltpilot56 2 года назад +2

    Cool 😎. Thanks for being informative but it was above my realm of my telemetry thinking. Anything has to be better than the so called Smart packs. Catch ya next time. Hope to make it to Jet Jam with the PJ-50. Coast Guard livery.

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад

      Sweet. Time will tell

    • @M4rkmcc21
      @M4rkmcc21 2 года назад

      Why hating on a brand? Just buy what u like.

  • @DadsRCHangar
    @DadsRCHangar 2 года назад +1

    Great comparison, I do like the F4 👍🏻

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад +1

      It’s a neat plane. Wish it cornered a bit better but it’s fast

  • @davidmcneill3809
    @davidmcneill3809 7 месяцев назад

    I had purchased several HRB's. The ones I purchase 3ish years ago still good. The ones I purchased in the last few years ago are already going bad. Just purchased my first SMC to check them out.

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  7 месяцев назад

      You will love them. Still love mine.

  • @ret737
    @ret737 2 года назад +1

    Love my SMC's!

  • @paulwoodward3944
    @paulwoodward3944 2 года назад

    Great info as always, question where do you get the caps for the as 150 battery plugs? You may have said before and I missed it

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад

      I buy 10mm silicon caps off of Amazon or eBay. Red for discharged. Green for charged. Then I always know the state. Great question. Make sure to use the silicon and not plastic

  • @trullmann
    @trullmann 2 года назад

    I could hear the difference at take off, the HRB packs did not have the grunt like the SMC's.
    Danny has done a really good job on these 40C packs he created.
    From what I understand these 40C packs are the best performing per weight of any battery we can get at the moment.

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад +1

      Fully agree. It’s noticeable as u stated. Thanks for watching

  • @Reis4four
    @Reis4four 2 года назад +2

    Sorry, but the 300mah is your difference in performance. not apple to apples.

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад

      IF you add even more weight to the hrb it still wouldn’t be in the same realm. It would be over weight and lose even worse in that comparison. So IR to weight becomes a bigger issue. It’s a fair comparison. Again not putting down hrb but I don’t see 300 making up several thousand rpm. I didn’t run number on amps or rpm per mah but I bet if I did the comparative scale it would still show an advantage.

  • @dutchloveRC
    @dutchloveRC 2 года назад

    good work friend

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад +1

      Thank you. Thanks for stopping in as always.

  • @davidgerlach1132
    @davidgerlach1132 Год назад +1

    I've had my share of SMC LiHV go bad on me after 100 cycles. Should get 300-500 cycles with responsible throttle control. Always a cell that shoots up to >15Ohm and spoils the whole party... IMHO, HRB are as generically manufactured, and reliable as most others, for the most part.

  • @M4rkmcc21
    @M4rkmcc21 2 года назад +1

    Shame SMC isn't sold in UK. Isn't even a consideration when u look at lipos for myself

  • @mytubehkjt
    @mytubehkjt 2 года назад

    Just wish I could get SMC packs down under...

    • @JustPlaneCrazy
      @JustPlaneCrazy  2 года назад

      Yea sorry. Not sure where u can or can’t get them. They are great.

  • @brianbrissette9444
    @brianbrissette9444 2 года назад

    Good hard Data

  • @jeffjackson6358
    @jeffjackson6358 2 года назад +1

    Come on. You left out the most important statistic, the HRB’s landed better.