If you’re wondering what became of the people on board the Titan sub, when the aft section of the sub was brought up, the people doing the salvage noticed a greasy substance within the wreckage, it was DNA tested and confirmed it was the five on board, so…..a greasy smear is all that was left of them.
In the 80's there was an Argentinian Navy sub that imploded. The U.S. assisted in the recovery and almost nothing of what could be recognizable as body parts were found. After an extensive investigation it was determined that the water and debris rushing in would have almost completely mulched those sailors. This is what is believed what happened to the people on the Titan.
I'm surprised people dont believe this/think there must be remains. There are companies out there who use jet powered water to cut through metals-everybit as effective and accurate as a laser;this should prove to anyone with any sense how immensly powerful-and lethal-water at huge speeds is, and the water crashing in on the people in that imploding sub was moving at an enormous speed.
Kyle hill also made a great video/stream on this footage. He also said that most likely, whatever’s left of the occupants - if any (bone fragments, teeth etc) is literally on screen inside the crushed vessel.
I saw some submarine channel talk about the remains. Dude, toothpaste. Human toothpaste. That's over the top even for a horror movie. If you put that in a horror movie it would get an NC-17 rating and wouldn't be allowed in most theaters.
I don't feel safe "flying into a Boeing". But tbf the same is true for almost everything else. Also this was something even Boeing threw away. Also from various submarine and ship findings i learned that the human body doesn't remain intact at these insane pressures. It was pointed out (i think by James Cameron) that for that reason, the boots and shoes that you can see in Titanic footage were not just footware, forgotten or dropped there. That is literally everything that is left of people. There are no bodies bones or anything. And that's physics, not biology like at less pressure. . As for the controller thing, the Navy has their people steer really expensive gear, drones and stuff with almost gaming controllers, since younger people are just way more experienced with hat than joysticks. It makes no sense to readjust that.
Almost correct, however the people that sunk with the Titanic did not immediately disintegrate. When sinking to the bottom of the ocean, the pressure increases slowly enough such that ones body remains intact. However they will have quickly been eaten by any deep sea critters.
Almost. However when sinking to the bottom, the human body won't get crushed. That's because the pressure will equalize with the ambient pressure due to the slowness of sinking and the lack of air in the lungs.
its honestly far from some of the worst ways to go if you think about it. basically an instantaneous transformation from being a human being into the elements that make up a human body....
When they put the ring on i would think you would want to see at least a Tiny bit of glue coming out... Makes it look like they were a little cheap on it And makes me wonder if that glue was made to handle so much temp changing .. From the over surface to the chilling depths by the Titanic over and over
It was sad to see the hall of what was left of it and thinking of the people that were in it I am at least pleased they decided to show us more finally instead of just parts with blankets being lifted off the boat
They had planned 18 bolts to link the hemisphere to the carbon fiber cylinder. But in order to get people in and out faster at the start and end of the dive, they were only using 4 of those bolts, according to one of the recent testimony...
the stream i saw from Kyle Hill covered some of the released transcripts from the investigators when they questioning people. My dads an engineer and the answers really piss me off. i really suggest you take a look, its enlightening and i think may show a deeper indication of what could of gone wrong.
“Already making jokes” I was making jokes since they announced the sub was missing. I said they were all dead lo and behold I was right. Yes I sleep just fine making jokes about them
It’s easy to mock the games controller, but that was one of the few intelligent choices Rush made. (Though I’d have gone with a wired one.) Games controllers, often off the shelf, are pretty commonly used for lots of important applications, from military drones and remote weapon stations, to rescue robots, to camera cranes. They’re adaptable, robust enough to survive teenagers, and a familiar form factor that’s easy for most people to learn. The controller was the one thing on that bucket that was not a problem.
In general, I'd agree, but im pretty sure I've used that exact contoler for projects before and replaced it because of some accuracy and responsiveness issues which developed over time. Maybe my bad luck but still makes me give it side eye.
The horrific thing about this accident is knowing the physics about wat would happen, and in the instant the hull failed the air would have been super headed par boiling instantly anyone inside, the saving grace is that when it failed the air super heated and instantly smashed everyone to a meaty pulp, faster than the human brain can process information so it was over before they even realised it had started.
My engineering professor called that implosion event like the inside of a cylinder in a combustion engine, with our carbon-rich bodies being the fuel to combust. A little crude and simplified, but I can't really argue with the basic ELI5 explanation.
The crushing is too fast for combustion to happen. The heating is also very brief and dissipates quickly. A paste like substance found in the recovered parts of the Titan. It contained DNA of all 5 people.
You know everybody that's being interviewed is just trying to be respectful when they talk about Stockton Rush you know what they are really thinking they are thinking God I hated that guy I told him this would happen
One thing I find reassuring is the thorough forensic investigation that took place both after the Titanic sinking and 110 years later, Titan's implosion. At least there's that.
I do feel bad for the innocent passengers. That said, the moment I saw them using a knock off playstation controller, I’d never have gone inside the thing.
Hi Kit. I watched another video on this particular investigation, which features a lot of the same Clips, and they commented that it was a non-sterile environment that they had to disinfect the entire surface of the rings, as well as the fact that they were apparently handling the rings after disinfecting it, meaning it wasn’t sterile at all. It also mentioned that the titanium was too smooth. They needed to rough the surface up a bit to encourage proper bonding of the glue that they were using. As well as the fact that carbon fibre was a very not very certified material for the depths that they were intending to take this sub. Mr rush was a very arrogant, egotistical man who thought he knew better than the experts he had hired to assist him in the creation of the submersible. Then fired said experts. And the fact is he paid with his own life. The only sympathy I have is for the passengers; Rush essentially killed himself, and he took 4 people with him.
Your entire beginning about not feeling sympathy for Rush but you do for the passengers. You do realize that they were all adults, including the 19 year old. They all signed waivers warning them literally of death. They still chose to get in. Whether Rush downplayed it is irrelevant. They signed documents warning them of death. So they were aware.
*Any* remotely physical activity with the slightest risk will include that in its waiver. It’s intended to cover reasonable risks, not to absolve the kind of negligence Rush showed. That waiver means “we’re doing everything we can to keep this safe, but there’s always a tiny chance something unexpected will go wrong”; you’ll see that mention of “grievous injury or death” in the small print of gokarting, bungee jumping, gliding, paintballing, even most cruises. Don’t fall for Rush’s “they knew what they were doing” gaslighting.
@@awmperry Rush’s gaslighting? Rush is dead. And there was no small print. David Progue the reporter read the waiver on a very popular video clip and the word death is right there in plain size lettering. Infact the word death is mentioned multiple times not just once. My point is they were all adults and they all made the decision to get into that sub after reading and signing that waiver. I wouldn’t have and I’m Titanic obsessed
But you *are* buying into it. Waivers mention death; that's what they do. For instance, the very first result I got for a family gokarting site includes a waiver for "any and all liability, loss, damages, costs, claims and/or causes of action, including but not limited to injury to the person or property and emotional and bodily injuries, including death". *Mentioning death in a waiver is not an indication that it should be seen as a likely result*, or for that matter any excuse for Rush's negligence. The carrier bag I brought my shopping home in disclaimed liability for death. The idea that one could not feel sympathy for Rush's victims because they signed some boilerplate waiver is abhorrent.
While I get that safety will be a second factor in innovation, there is a clear issue when all of your experts aren’t “this should work.” And are more “this looks like a problem.”
If you’re wondering what became of the people on board the Titan sub, when the aft section of the sub was brought up, the people doing the salvage noticed a greasy substance within the wreckage, it was DNA tested and confirmed it was the five on board, so…..a greasy smear is all that was left of them.
In the press business, that stuff is called strawberry jam. You'd be surprised how large an area a former finger can cover.
In the 80's there was an Argentinian Navy sub that imploded. The U.S. assisted in the recovery and almost nothing of what could be recognizable as body parts were found. After an extensive investigation it was determined that the water and debris rushing in would have almost completely mulched those sailors. This is what is believed what happened to the people on the Titan.
I'm surprised people dont believe this/think there must be remains. There are companies out there who use jet powered water to cut through metals-everybit as effective and accurate as a laser;this should prove to anyone with any sense how immensly powerful-and lethal-water at huge speeds is, and the water crashing in on the people in that imploding sub was moving at an enormous speed.
They found a paste that had DNA from all 5people in the Titan wreckage.
I heard they found paste on one of the parts, which when tested, contained DNA of the passengers. All of them.
Kyle hill also made a great video/stream on this footage. He also said that most likely, whatever’s left of the occupants - if any (bone fragments, teeth etc) is literally on screen inside the crushed vessel.
What happened? Hubris and arrogance.
Semper Fi, brother.
from an engineering pov, that's relatively thin as an explantion.
When you don't respect the power of the ocean, people will die.
18:20 they found a paste and the paste contained the DNA of 5 people
the coast guard has MUCH nicer seats for their hearings than the NTSB....
A horrible but small mercy that it was over before the brain could even process something happening.
I saw some submarine channel talk about the remains. Dude, toothpaste. Human toothpaste. That's over the top even for a horror movie. If you put that in a horror movie it would get an NC-17 rating and wouldn't be allowed in most theaters.
@@matthewlister3755 It’s honestly not even toothpaste, more like a mist.
Toothpaste + mist.
I don't feel safe "flying into a Boeing". But tbf the same is true for almost everything else. Also this was something even Boeing threw away.
Also from various submarine and ship findings i learned that the human body doesn't remain intact at these insane pressures. It was pointed out (i think by James Cameron) that for that reason, the boots and shoes that you can see in Titanic footage were not just footware, forgotten or dropped there. That is literally everything that is left of people. There are no bodies bones or anything. And that's physics, not biology like at less pressure. .
As for the controller thing, the Navy has their people steer really expensive gear, drones and stuff with almost gaming controllers, since younger people are just way more experienced with hat than joysticks. It makes no sense to readjust that.
There are precision eye surgeries done ising an Xbox controller.
Almost correct, however the people that sunk with the Titanic did not immediately disintegrate.
When sinking to the bottom of the ocean, the pressure increases slowly enough such that ones body remains intact. However they will have quickly been eaten by any deep sea critters.
Almost. However when sinking to the bottom, the human body won't get crushed. That's because the pressure will equalize with the ambient pressure due to the slowness of sinking and the lack of air in the lungs.
Humans never learn. 🤦🏻♀️ Our societies always crumble, attacked & ruined by ourselves. Titan made the same mistake Titanic did.
its honestly far from some of the worst ways to go if you think about it.
basically an instantaneous transformation from being a human being into the elements that make up a human body....
When they put the ring on i would think you would want to see at least a Tiny bit of glue coming out... Makes it look like they were a little cheap on it
And makes me wonder if that glue was made to handle so much temp changing .. From the over surface to the chilling depths by the Titanic over and over
Reminder the CEO wanted to be an astronaut got turned away. Then proceeded to try and explore an even less hospitable location than space.
It was sad to see the hall of what was left of it and thinking of the people that were in it
I am at least pleased they decided to show us more finally instead of just parts with blankets being lifted off the boat
They had planned 18 bolts to link the hemisphere to the carbon fiber cylinder.
But in order to get people in and out faster at the start and end of the dive, they were only using 4 of those bolts, according to one of the recent testimony...
the stream i saw from Kyle Hill covered some of the released transcripts from the investigators when they questioning people. My dads an engineer and the answers really piss me off. i really suggest you take a look, its enlightening and i think may show a deeper indication of what could of gone wrong.
Hey, even Abraham Lincoln made morbid jokes about the civil war. Probably kept him sane through it.
“Already making jokes” I was making jokes since they announced the sub was missing. I said they were all dead lo and behold I was right.
Yes I sleep just fine making jokes about them
The carbon fiber was not use by boeing. It was discarded by Boeing because it didn't meet their quality standards
It's even worse
I’m glad Fred Armisen is back on YT
It’s easy to mock the games controller, but that was one of the few intelligent choices Rush made. (Though I’d have gone with a wired one.) Games controllers, often off the shelf, are pretty commonly used for lots of important applications, from military drones and remote weapon stations, to rescue robots, to camera cranes. They’re adaptable, robust enough to survive teenagers, and a familiar form factor that’s easy for most people to learn.
The controller was the one thing on that bucket that was not a problem.
In general, I'd agree, but im pretty sure I've used that exact contoler for projects before and replaced it because of some accuracy and responsiveness issues which developed over time. Maybe my bad luck but still makes me give it side eye.
@@hippoblue6458 Aaaah. Yeah, if that specific model is known to be rubbish, then yeah - I'd choose a different one.
The horrific thing about this accident is knowing the physics about wat would happen, and in the instant the hull failed the air would have been super headed par boiling instantly anyone inside, the saving grace is that when it failed the air super heated and instantly smashed everyone to a meaty pulp, faster than the human brain can process information so it was over before they even realised it had started.
My engineering professor called that implosion event like the inside of a cylinder in a combustion engine, with our carbon-rich bodies being the fuel to combust. A little crude and simplified, but I can't really argue with the basic ELI5 explanation.
The crushing is too fast for combustion to happen. The heating is also very brief and dissipates quickly.
A paste like substance found in the recovered parts of the Titan. It contained DNA of all 5 people.
You know everybody that's being interviewed is just trying to be respectful when they talk about Stockton Rush you know what they are really thinking they are thinking God I hated that guy I told him this would happen
Stockton bragged about the power of his deep sea implosion. His minature test models failed, and Stockton gloated "it shook the entire building".
One thing I find reassuring is the thorough forensic investigation that took place both after the Titanic sinking and 110 years later, Titan's implosion. At least there's that.
I do feel bad for the innocent passengers. That said, the moment I saw them using a knock off playstation controller, I’d never have gone inside the thing.
The Logitech controller was the least bad part of it.
There are precision eye surgeries done using Xbox controllers.
It's not impossible that they didn't see water creeping in from the cracks before the pressure took over.
Hi Kit. I watched another video on this particular investigation, which features a lot of the same Clips, and they commented that it was a non-sterile environment that they had to disinfect the entire surface of the rings, as well as the fact that they were apparently handling the rings after disinfecting it, meaning it wasn’t sterile at all. It also mentioned that the titanium was too smooth. They needed to rough the surface up a bit to encourage proper bonding of the glue that they were using.
As well as the fact that carbon fibre was a very not very certified material for the depths that they were intending to take this sub.
Mr rush was a very arrogant, egotistical man who thought he knew better than the experts he had hired to assist him in the creation of the submersible. Then fired said experts. And the fact is he paid with his own life. The only sympathy I have is for the passengers; Rush essentially killed himself, and he took 4 people with him.
Your entire beginning about not feeling sympathy for Rush but you do for the passengers. You do realize that they were all adults, including the 19 year old. They all signed waivers warning them literally of death. They still chose to get in. Whether Rush downplayed it is irrelevant. They signed documents warning them of death. So they were aware.
*Any* remotely physical activity with the slightest risk will include that in its waiver. It’s intended to cover reasonable risks, not to absolve the kind of negligence Rush showed.
That waiver means “we’re doing everything we can to keep this safe, but there’s always a tiny chance something unexpected will go wrong”; you’ll see that mention of “grievous injury or death” in the small print of gokarting, bungee jumping, gliding, paintballing, even most cruises. Don’t fall for Rush’s “they knew what they were doing” gaslighting.
@@awmperry Rush’s gaslighting? Rush is dead. And there was no small print. David Progue the reporter read the waiver on a very popular video clip and the word death is right there in plain size lettering. Infact the word death is mentioned multiple times not just once. My point is they were all adults and they all made the decision to get into that sub after reading and signing that waiver. I wouldn’t have and I’m Titanic obsessed
But you *are* buying into it. Waivers mention death; that's what they do. For instance, the very first result I got for a family gokarting site includes a waiver for "any and all liability, loss, damages, costs, claims and/or causes of action, including but not limited to injury to the person or property and emotional and bodily injuries, including death".
*Mentioning death in a waiver is not an indication that it should be seen as a likely result*, or for that matter any excuse for Rush's negligence. The carrier bag I brought my shopping home in disclaimed liability for death.
The idea that one could not feel sympathy for Rush's victims because they signed some boilerplate waiver is abhorrent.
@@paulhowse6169agreed. They signed, they knew the risks. There should be no way to sue
They had no idea anything happened. That’s crazy.
"Americans Learn."
What a novel idea.
Basically vaporized, yes.
If it's Boeing I'm not going!!!
While I get that safety will be a second factor in innovation, there is a clear issue when all of your experts aren’t “this should work.” And are more “this looks like a problem.”
21:20 Titan, atleast it is a quick death and I return to the Embrace of the Great mistress, The Sea.
One thing to say about that controller tho it survived the wreck and it is laying next to it perfectly intact
They are like this now ~> l
This video reveals all communication showing they knew something was wrong
EDIT: Nevermind, its fake
Fake. Do your fact checking