This says it all. As we all knew anyway. AND the ironic part is that this was done in their own country. www.aspiringminds.com/automata-national-programming-report
I am from India on H1b, did my masters here from a reputed US university, lived here for more than 6 years, payed my taxes, law abiding, always learning and improving, i think i did everything right. I might have to adandon my American dream very soon. Though i think i am victim of the stringent laws . I am glad that USCIS has started cracking down on those malicious consulting companies who have been exploiting and abusing the H1b system. Trust me, I know for sure, not all H1b holders and employers are bad, there are some highly qualified competent workers, who are victimized by the new executive orders. However, one has to understand that, its becasue of those few bad ones we can't nice things in this world. This is just my personal opinion.
As an Immigrant who came here on H1B and become.a proud citizen my advice to young H1B aspirants is to give up the US dream, unfortunately it is dead and long gone, go back to your family and friends in India and work towards your own progress. It may sound harsh. You have a true freedom in India and business and growth opportunities are much better than what it was when I left the country almost 25 years ago. Take advantage of growing Indian economy
Avinash Patil No it is not. The US is a different country. You are not entitled to anything. Only the best went to the US before when the salary cap was $60k. Now any tom, dick and harry goes there, gets a degree from some third rate college and wants a green card. Not everyone of those people are sundar pichai. Indians are not entitled to jobs in the US.
People who has come on H1B from india and got citizenship has to be sent back to india as they didnot spend anything instead they are taking dollars and jobs from united states people who spend money and time(Education) has to be eligible for greencard and H1B this is what trump administration is doing thats good idea too why the shit these H1B people we need when we can utilize the people who has been educated here go back H1b from india
FYI his mother (Trump’s mother) was an Scottish immigrant and got naturalized citizenship thru marriage. As far as read so far, based on merit point system trump’s administration is suggesting for the future immigrants to enter this country, his mother would not have been able to get here ! Irony to the extreme!
There is no compulsion on the part of the United States to offer jobs to foreigners. In a country where the median hourly wage has been stagnant for 30 years, this is understandable. These tech companies that hire foreigners while not training local citizens have done the country a disservice. About time that local resources are trained and used. Anyone who suggests that learning technologies is a long drawn process is wrong- 5 years ago maybe, but not anymore. Give me six months and anyone with a college degree can be trained in internet technologies such as Ruby on Rails, Ruby, Json etc This presentation that the United States needs foreign resources is no longer true. Technologies are no longer that complicated that they need a two year CS graduate from abroad.
Yes , true fact . Deportation is the only solution for American to get the jobs back . Trump alone can do the unimaginable .Bring back jobs to the American citizens first.Thank you American love you from India.
Well-said Subramaniam and Yankee7000, I have seen this development too and the claim of a "skills shortage" among Americans is dumb, American students and grads can be easily trained in short time periods for the key skills and then trained again.
THANK YOU! I've been talking about on the job training for a long time to mitigate rampant migration.. The colleges and universities hate this, because it negatively impacts their business.
There is no targeting. You cant just abuse a system for years only because it is fine to abuse sustem back in your country. This was long due, now stop crying foul. Be happy that you guys are not put behind bars.
Trump is doing right for Usa. Why others cry on this? Denials based on Lack of expertise is the right way to deny. Every country has right to save jobs for its citizens.
No, Vinoth, they don't "need" H1B, too many US companies are corrupt or even treason committing, they do H-1B to have their own slaves, most Indians have enough self-respect to refuse, but a few are willing to sell themselves into slavery for peanuts, and workers all over are hurt by that pathetic lack of self respect.
her firm is losing business because of too many rejections..she is smart in making it look like its wide problem and not just for her firm....she already made millions on h1b visa programs...she didn't fight for GREEN card backlogs for indians...because doing so would lose her evergreen easy h1b money making business...
As U.S Citizen with 30+ years of U.S experience and all the advanced industry certifications and degree from top notch Stanford University, I have been told that my candidature is not a close fit with their needs. This has been the case for last 3 years. I have been told that they will hire first the people on the bench. This is a clear violation of the rights of U.S Citizens.
Buisness does not decide who immigrates,works here,WE THE PEOPLE DECIDE. I was born in 1970,since 1965 the largest wave of immigration has occurred during the 40 year period in history. The toll on economic,social,taxes,etc has been too much.
What crap are you talking? you think business will just waste their money for someone they don't need...are they finding ways to donate or making profits? and you are going to teach them? and you really think there are local talents available to completely replace immigrants? then why the hell would the company take all these pain of sponsoring visa? be logical man. Either bring the skill here or the whole project is going to be outsourced and that will be more job loss for the locals. btw and where did you or your ancestors some from?
@@innovawiz9102 That what you just said has been happening already... "bring the skill here or the whole project will be outsourced"...since the rise of China entire projects, not only in the manufacture sector but also in engineering, science and technology have moved to china...just because there were not enough "cheap skill" in the US...H1bs are paid half than their counterpart americans....work extra hours and holidays with the same regular salary...Disney was just a pitfall in the system...in the overall...the H1bs have shaped the technology industry in the US catapulting it to the world's top....
I called(7/12/19 1:56 pm) Murthy Law Firm and surprised to know that they are do not challenge USISC against any unfavorable decision in federal court , then what is this video all about ???
I am an Indian.. and I think what Trump says should not be questioned . you being an Indian don't buy or hire Indian. The president should always look for his people who are the blacks and whites they have been there for long enough . you go to the land of opportunities and criticize the leader of the nation you should be ashamed
+thomas samson pardon me and my colleagues who work at Silicon Valley earn much more than most Americans, you clearly still live in the 20th century lol
If the applicant is a foreign educated lawyer with license to practice law in the US (CA), have you encountered RFEs on this case with regard to specialty occupation issue? What are the usual issues for this case?
Rubbish, the United States owes those here on employee visas nothing more than what was agreed to when that visa holder first entered the country. Regardless of how long the stay, an employment visa is a temporary visa and a path to immigration is neither implied nor in any way suggested. What must be done to bring the H-1B system back into balance is end the duel intent nature of the visa. In 1990 it was simply an employment visa. It was later changed.
You know what I recommend your clients do: take a closer look at some of the resumes of US citizens you been throwing away without looking at. I am sorry about the racists up here though, it's embarrassing.
Everyone wants to live a better life, whether you like it or not - an Indian who can will come into US on a H1, a black family who can afford will move in a rich neighborhood, a chinese family who can live in a rich white neighborhood....That's how simple life is you know.....
All these desi immigration attorneys will be out of business if USCIS starts scrutinizing the applications and hire only so called "highly specialised" resources
Well hold on for a moment. I thought USA is the epitome of Capitalism and a champion of free-market, is it not? Then why exactly we don't let the "Market" decide what is the best for us? If the businesses((market) are happier to employ cheap labors from outside, why should we intervene like a communist country?:P
Half of IT jobs doesn’t need programming skills. Anybody with some training can easily do the job. Most of the IT companies from South Asia are just body shop who make money off the cheap labor available plentiful due to unemployment in India in college graduates 🎓
How is an H1B Visa an immigration issue? It's for a foreign worker to work here for a temporary period and then return to their country of origin. Immigration is when a foreigner comes here with the intent of staying here and becoming a legally naturalized citizen.
Dear friends .. I was in the same situation as many of you . My extension took more time than usual and just got approved recently . ( Premium processing ) . It took 3+ months for me to get my visa approved ( got an RFE in the middle ). Dont get disappointed or be panic by watching this video . Lawyers like Murthy will not spend their valuable time in youtube without a return . They actually don't care you and me . They just want to create panic situation and get more business for their lawyers.
Awaiting Bee hi.....exactly how long did it take for ur approval...actually me n my husband is stuck with 221g processing since Feb. ...it's for h1b extension
Just lost my job to an Indian. My org at Walmart Labs (my recent employer) was hiring dozens of Indians every week straight out of India. Never ONCE hiring someone born in America, despite it being in Sunnyvale, CA. These Indians work more hours for less pay usually on contracts without any paid vacation, benefits, or anything. And they will do it all with a smile on their face because they are desperate. Those of us born in America that like the 40 hour workweek, vacations, basic benefits, etc are losing their jobs left and right to these people that are absolutely flooding the tech industry and costing Americans millions of job every year.
You reap what you sow. I was myself a victim of h-1b visa abuse. There is no tech shortage. H-1b should be for geniuses with special skills that cannot be found or taught. And once an Indian visa person gets into a management position they only hire or promote h-1b Indians from their specific clan. They bring their caste system with them and impose it on Americans if they can. In other words Americans are on a lower caste than them. Time to go home and give Americans the jobs and pay they deserve.
As an American citizen, I had to leave the engineering profession because they did not want to hire me.... they wanted to hire an H1-b Visa... I'm sorry.... but you had the gravy train and didn't realize who you were hurting in the process.... I'm glad that Trump is President. There were so many engineering grads who could not find jobs after graduation, yet we always couldn't understand why those who applied for H1- B visas always had one. Oh and don't let my name fool you.... I am not white....
nicely said. whoever want's to make money & fortune attack the govt & Any policies in name of liberty , Democracy , But hiring undersliled , rampant immigration is also not democratic values even it is Irrelevant to very liberty & Democratic values ,& keep on going their businesses & money making. its illegal. Indians tend to Betray their own for even little gain. whenever that little gain is hampered than comes the agitation.
@Snow 123 yup , u got dat right bro. Are u of Indian origin or American native local citizen u have good knowledge about that. Actually it used to be certain indians who reached the heights in India ,certain ethnicities, class of people ,but after economic liberalisation every shitty ones getting money ,& only dream of them is getting to USA & Europe. I had several opportunities , I declined. My relatives we're there since 1970 s ,in research, now many in finances , & Law. They were totally assimilated with the culture . But indians , especially large of dem from South indians in IT , & North indians , majorly Punjabis , Gujjus & every other North indians always brag , fantises about largely America ,or Europe - west , getting der , being successful , iys like a status quo or like dey are getting to Moon , but dey barely understand the culture. rather than solving 99 problems from over population of certain inferior races which diminished the very good sides . This should have happened. And Donald Trump is giving Indian s a golden chance to improve our own country , nation's. But no they gotta do it in America. Why America doesn't owe us H1B s or any visas. Most culprit is J1 hotel worker ,or short 1 year visas. Most easy to access USA for Indian cheap hotel workers , sometime dey are scammed ,& overstayed and never leaves. Which Donald Trump even knows. As a hotelier. He should ban J1 and other work program visas , as H1 B to other outsourcing countries .
@Snow 123 more of different nations was unified by the Britishers , most beautiful pinnacle of an Empire by the Britishers ,Calcutta from which dey did global domination. But later destroyed by a filthy dictator family after independence. It is more of amalgamation of unified nation's , cause each single state represents different ethnicities.
@Snow 123 yaa ,see bro. Cause I'm sub contious mind they adore the white supremacy , not just Whites as superior talented but their desire to mingle and stay and be like dem. This is ridiculous. They will only complain when there is no other way or he is done playing all the cards and denials & hypocrisy
Throughout the United States, education leaders and policymakers are joining forces to bring computer science classes to our schools. Since January, 20 states from Alabama to Wyoming have passed laws and funded $49 million to expand access to and diversity in K-12 computer science.
Nice job you made the case as to why H-1B should be scaled back. There is no reason that a job should be helped by and H-1B use her for 20 years. That's long enough to conceive birth raise educate and train somebody for that job.
I am on H1B and I feel like what mr trump is doing is right for his country . He is president of the United States so US is his first priority. I hope he will more regulation on H1B and limit the IT companies from India from hiring people on H1B. Being on H1B is choice, if someone does not like it than just leave it and return back to ur country it’s simple
Americans first ...teach the children here first! If we don’t have enough physicist raise their pay and increase grant for students who pursue challenging carrers. We need more homegrown physicists scientist engineers etc who do the hard work applying solutions to complex problems.
"In the spirit of President Trump's Executive Order on Buy American and Hire American, today's partnership adds to the Civil Rights Division's tools to stop employers from discriminating against U.S. workers by favoring foreign visa workers," explained Acting Assistant Attorney General John Gore of the Civil Rights Division.
Then, why are you there. You must also go to your own native country of our grand father. Who are you to decide America needs or not. Let's all H1B's from Microsoft and Google and big companies come back. Then see how it works. The Americans who are still jobless is because they are lacking some speacialities not because of H1B.
Yes I saw a video that a woman and daughter can find accommodation due to high rent in California ,they had to live in a big car to sleep . earning only 2000 $ per month .I felt really bad .Why outsource jobs when citizens are suffering . Trump can do the unimaginable .Bring back Jobs for American and enjoy .Love you from India .
Subramaniam Iyer , first because that woman has poop in her head, she needs to re evaluate how she spends her money, they seem middle class so they confuse luxury with necessity they are obese, you can t be poor and be obese, a lot of money goes to food, but they like to eat in expensive places, and other things like storage. she could cut many thing and get loft. second they suffer because they dont have higher education, it is very expensive in america. not H1b visas
This is called the "Casino" business model. Approve student visas of like a zillion people regardless of qualifications (raise their hopes for a better tomorrow), make them invest 20-30k $ for education, make them walk the plank for finding a decent job... And then the final nail in the coffin - once they've done the seemingly impossible, tell 'em "Hey, thanks for all that revenue. But you're shit outta luck. Vacate our premises, go back home". There ya have it. Casino!
You got it right. As for these so called talented Americans I’ve yet to meet one most are good for sales positions at most or working at Starbucks while pursuIng fine arts or atleast accounting degrees in college. Most lack aptitude and patience to pursue a stem degree. America does not deserve the choice pick of the worlds talent time to change that trend let the racists who were jealous of colored people being successful have their time in the sun trump is not going to change anything’l for the they are a dying demographic anyway
www.computerworld.com/article/2915904/it-outsourcing/fury-rises-at-disney-over-use-of-foreign-workers.html This has been the experience of millions of citizens.
Yes I am back in India, leading by example now. I am the first of many to return. India needs it's heroes and many are rising up to take up that mantel. As for Americans being dull, go to University and see how many Americans are in STEM. You see a handful of Mexican-Americans, and the rest are Asian-American or mostly International students. STEM is something where Americans are lacking. Frankly being called dull is not bad, Americans have done worse, using the N-word, calling other;s dot-heads, a racial tag for every race. I can say whatever I want America owes me nothing and I am in India in my castle living my life.
She did not mention anything about the misuse of the H1B visa. The H1B was meant to bring in high-level outsider engineer to fill a gap but it seems companies abused the H1B to "replace" existing American citizen employees. Several Indian engineers have also complained against this trend that is undermining the worth of truly competent Indian engineers. Business interests cannot rule over the national interests of any country. Please tell us the whole truth.
I read all these comments, but current unemployment rate is only 4% which is historically low !! why every hater here is hating for those 4% ? Its just bit... like they do in homes and at their current jobs !!
no, a lot of what they are doing is just making harder what is already really hard, it is really difficult to work legally, you can only petition a certain time of the year and they ask for so many things, you have no idea how difficult it is. So only the best get asked for a H1B. So with no change in constitution it is clear its because there is more open hatred.
H-1B should be decreased rapidly. The persons who should be allowed stay are those who come here and get MS and/or PhD in STEM areas. Just forklifting a programmer from India to come and do some coding are really not needed. These jobs can be automated and hence outsourced.
Ok so you believe the MS/PhD's from here are superior to a programmer with several years of experience back home? well my experience seems to differ. I have seen several MS grads from here who might speak better english than the back-home programmer, but are clueless when it comes to writing a simple SQL query or putting together a static html page. Education is not a substitute for experience.
Srinivas Ganti: there are anecdotal examples where someone from India with only 2 courses in Java or C++ had been forklifted and brought here in USA and displaced Americans. (Disney is an example). Second, I have seen other examples where Indian code masters write no superior code than Americans or US educated foreigners. Code functions can be automated or the entire process can be outsourced to India. Why forklift people from India and bring them here to displace Americans? If the companies want to make profit with cheap labor, they should move operations there! Finally it is not the fault of the Indian IT professionals to come here and face the uncertainty. The fault lies clearly with these US companies who are too greedy.
Deb: The comparison was between Indian US STEM grads Vs Experienced programmers "forklifted". I don't think they teach many languages & technologies at US grad schools, neither it is necessary IMO. I personally trained and groomed many programmers myself - both US grads and forklifted, and I don't see much difference except for little english skills which can be taught easily. I leave the matter of who should come and who should not to the citizens of USA, since this is their country and they decide their future.
Srinivas Ganti: well put. Just one issue: all routine jobs shall eventually be automated, including ones that involve cleaning toilets. The pervasive use of Artificial Intelligence coupled with Big Data Analytics (Machine Learning etc.), would kill the potential of human involvement. But greedy company CEOs and VPs and Wall Street honchos are not willing to make that initial investment into automation. They are thus just hiring medium skill people and thus paying them wages that are sub par. And finally Computer Science is *not* about programming languages. It is about algorithms. So, your implied response that programmers are computer scientists, is not quite correct.
I'd leave the automation to the businesses as it's not the point of discussion here. And I did not imply anything. I'm merely saying a US degree won't make anyone great (other than knowing how to market himself).
H and L visas are perhaps the only visas which you need an attorney to file . Most of the other work visas for any other country can be processed by the person themselves. The US goverment has created labyrinthine rule book for these vias and is feeding this industry.
Simple - if you are “employed” by a company who’s office you never visit ... and you are working off-site in the USA ... YOU have replaced a US IT worker who probably trained you. Indian body shop companies are unfortunately rampant with this. You have been abused ... but are part of the problem. You are NOT exceptional or “highly skilled” - you have just replaced an American IT worker. Hate to point out the facts ... but that was not what H1B program was used for. If you’re ever on “bench” or paid a penny in terms of your immigration or H1B fees or legal fees to your company, or have a payment method to do so in the future ... look in the mirror! It is illegal!
The days of cheap labor for silicon valley are coming to an end....Indians need to find jobs in India and Americans need to fill the jobs available in the United States
Ha ha. No, you cant, because most of your asses cant afford to get a BA, masters, etc... so your not qualified nor specialized... boom! America needs them
Well Armed Lamb , true and America needs to manufacture within and sell all products within America. Why do they need Asian or Latin market for selling Kellogg’s or coke Pepsi? No need for selective protectionism.
Ashwin Kumar bro the thing is this that highly unqualified and uneducated people are able to immigrate to the US using the marriage loophole and family Immigration. They don't want to touch the marriage visas or family Immigration because their own relatives are using these routes to enter into the US. Take the example of Maleina Trump's family, just last week the become the US citizens through the chain family Immigration. So of you want to immigrate to the US get married and live like a king.
Hey lion Roar..sounds like you didn't get the point, plz read my comment one more time slowly. Regarding Maleina Trump parents citizenship, its a big fraud, I know that, even their attorney denied to reveal when her parents got the green card. Moreover, there plenty of homeless US citizens, still some illiterate Europeans and American had been crying on highly educated Indians. Hope you got the point now. :-)
Its just an Executive Order, its not permanent. I say make money and move away from anyobody whos is making under 75K annual income. Americans who are making over 75K are mostly happy and seems to have less Racism and HATE.
at 2:33 "...even though a lot of the people that are being asked are actually doing Federal govt, State govt, County govt. projects...." Is she saying Americans are not available to do these routine jobs? This is pure BS.
Good. Why should Americans live on welfare, while CEOs hire people from India for tech jobs? Indians should continue to work for microsoft technical support from India.
I've come to the US to get a physics PhD, which was 100% funded by US money, clearly because not so much american- born citizens like to spend the needed effort. Now, after I got my degree and ready to benefit the economy and pay my share of taxes, the government tells me 'No, Thanks. Please go benefit another society'. Doesn't sound very clever to me!
Every country can have it's own policies on immigration and borders. If they don't need/want more foreign people in the US then it is what it is. Stop crying and face reality.
Being on H1 for more than 5 yrs is an indication you haven’t made your mind to stay here. Sorry you need to go back. Honestly we have enough talent here, need no more. This woman though knowledgeable is making up scenarios which don’t exist. Hail Trump 🙏🏽.....no more H1s, Sorry.
Ms Murthy, the job of the US Government to take care of the best interests of its citizens, not to ensure that the companies get cheap human resources and that law firms like you keep making money.
bro, if there is high rejection rate, eventually the applications will decrease...the bottom line is in future these immigration lawyers will be out of job..
more RFE only temporarily...later less applications and less RFEs...overall bad for them in long term...also she is trying to say its not her fault for RFEs...
Issuing Visa is a discretion of that country's laws and immigration policies. Indian immigration also states the same that its the discretion of embassy to issue or not to issue visa so US is no different. Visa's cannot be issued just cus someone bought home/car etc. Its based purely on merit and skills. If USCIS says certain case does not have the merit then that is enough for a denial. Follow laws and do things right and this country welcomes everyone. We should stop whining and fighting for unjust causes.
I wish they stop is h1b visa asap at least then the dependants can have a life in India. Or may be stop giving dependant visas so that dependants dont have to come here and feel like rotting in hell
Good relevant comments below, in short H1 are an asset because they are grunt coders and can travel across the US with a 2 weeks notice. "americans" want a 9-5 job and are more diverse in their skills and functionally better as the have a better understanding the business process. I have been in this business for 20 years (hiring americans and h1's) and am a president of a IT consulting firm. US Citizen
Should anyone with GC be worried of not being able to get a new job because of the hire American exec order? What are the implications of it going for citizenship?
Have you ever found an Indian director or CTO in a team just by himself? I have been worked in IT/Computer/Software company for 20 years.. In general, as my personal opinion, Indian tends to hire Indians, and outsourcing job to India. If one Indian becomes manager, most likely, half of his/her team will be Indian for short of period of time. The worst is most of them is less qualified... My personal opinion, India tech's company culture, just cheap and slavery and less of loyalty, sooner or later, it will destroy american culture in general.
![Blox Fruits Dragon Rework Update [Full Stream]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/EqDAp8udhm0/mqdefault.jpg)
Get them all out .Out out out out out out out out out out out out out
Us Americans need jobs too. They can work in India if they get denied
This says it all. As we all knew anyway. AND the ironic part is that this was done in their own country. www.aspiringminds.com/automata-national-programming-report
Good about time!! Americans need jobs!!
I am from India on H1b, did my masters here from a reputed US university, lived here for more than 6 years, payed my taxes, law abiding, always learning and improving, i think i did everything right. I might have to adandon my American dream very soon. Though i think i am victim of the stringent laws . I am glad that USCIS has started cracking down on those malicious consulting companies who have been exploiting and abusing the H1b system. Trust me, I know for sure, not all H1b holders and employers are bad, there are some highly qualified competent workers, who are victimized by the new executive orders. However, one has to understand that, its becasue of those few bad ones we can't nice things in this world. This is just my personal opinion.
As an Immigrant who came here on H1B and become.a proud citizen my advice to young H1B aspirants is to give up the US dream, unfortunately it is dead and long gone, go back to your family and friends in India and work towards your own progress. It may sound harsh. You have a true freedom in India and business and growth opportunities are much better than what it was when I left the country almost 25 years ago. Take advantage of growing Indian economy
guldukan Isn't it hypocrisy?
Avinash Patil No it is not. The US is a different country. You are not entitled to anything. Only the best went to the US before when the salary cap was $60k. Now any tom, dick and harry goes there, gets a degree from some third rate college and wants a green card. Not everyone of those people are sundar pichai. Indians are not entitled to jobs in the US.
Guldukan. You are a fucked up cheap hypocrisy... Why not you come back and Make India Great Again ?
@@avinashpatil2505 no. I don't think so. It is a reality of today.
People who has come on H1B from india and got citizenship has to be sent back to india as they didnot spend anything instead they are taking dollars and jobs from united states people who spend money and time(Education) has to be eligible for greencard and H1B this is what trump administration is doing thats good idea too why the shit these H1B people we need when we can utilize the people who has been educated here go back H1b from india
FYI his mother (Trump’s mother) was an Scottish immigrant and got naturalized citizenship thru marriage. As far as read so far, based on merit point system trump’s administration is suggesting for the future immigrants to enter this country, his mother would not have been able to get here ! Irony to the extreme!
There is no compulsion on the part of the United States to offer jobs to foreigners. In a country where the median hourly wage has been stagnant for 30 years, this is understandable.
These tech companies that hire foreigners while not training local citizens have done the country a disservice.
About time that local resources are trained and used.
Anyone who suggests that learning technologies is a long drawn process is wrong- 5 years ago maybe, but not anymore. Give me six months and anyone with a college degree can be trained in internet technologies such as Ruby on Rails, Ruby, Json etc
This presentation that the United States needs foreign resources is no longer true. Technologies are no longer that complicated that they need a two year CS graduate from abroad.
Yes , true fact . Deportation is the only solution for American to get the jobs back . Trump alone can do the unimaginable .Bring back jobs to the American citizens first.Thank you American love you from India.
Well-said Subramaniam and Yankee7000, I have seen this development too and the claim of a "skills shortage" among Americans is dumb, American students and grads can be easily trained in short time periods for the key skills and then trained again.
THANK YOU!
I've been talking about on the job training for a long time to mitigate rampant migration..
The colleges and universities hate this, because it negatively impacts their business.
There is no targeting. You cant just abuse a system for years only because it is fine to abuse sustem back in your country. This was long due, now stop crying foul. Be happy that you guys are not put behind bars.
Jr Jtt de novo e 5j tu tá Jr tá Jr 5kkkkkkkkkj
Trump is doing right for Usa. Why others cry on this?
Denials based on Lack of expertise is the right way to deny.
Every country has right to save jobs for its citizens.
It's not about employees....Indians don't need H1B...but the companies do need the H1B visa so that they can do business
Praveendra Singh and
I wish Mr. Kumaran would have said something graceful like this. I respect your thought on this one. :)
No, Vinoth, they don't "need" H1B, too many US companies are corrupt or even treason committing, they do H-1B to have their own slaves, most Indians have enough self-respect to refuse, but a few are willing to sell themselves into slavery for peanuts, and workers all over are hurt by that pathetic lack of self respect.
Well-said, Praveendra.
Good. Deny them all.
her firm is losing business because of too many rejections..she is smart in making it look like its wide problem and not just for her firm....she already made millions on h1b visa programs...she didn't fight for GREEN card backlogs for indians...because doing so would lose her evergreen easy h1b money making business...
Rahul Sharma do you really know what this lady said for her business if that's the case shame on her making india US relations look so bad.
Abolish H1B and deport ya'll stinky ugly looking people. Why are you so desperate to live in America moda fcuker?
As U.S Citizen with 30+ years of U.S experience and all the advanced industry certifications and degree from top notch Stanford University, I have been told that my candidature is not a close fit with their needs. This has been the case for last 3 years. I have been told that they will hire first the people on the bench. This is a clear violation of the rights of U.S Citizens.
Thank heavens for Donald J Trump!!
Buisness does not decide who immigrates,works here,WE THE PEOPLE DECIDE.
I was born in 1970,since 1965 the largest wave of immigration has occurred during the 40 year period in history.
The toll on economic,social,taxes,etc has been too much.
What crap are you talking? you think business will just waste their money for someone they don't need...are they finding ways to donate or making profits? and you are going to teach them? and you really think there are local talents available to completely replace immigrants? then why the hell would the company take all these pain of sponsoring visa? be logical man. Either bring the skill here or the whole project is going to be outsourced and that will be more job loss for the locals. btw and where did you or your ancestors some from?
Innova Wiz ask the latest Disney people.
@@innovawiz9102 That what you just said has been happening already... "bring the skill here or the whole project will be outsourced"...since the rise of China entire projects, not only in the manufacture sector but also in engineering, science and technology have moved to china...just because there were not enough "cheap skill" in the US...H1bs are paid half than their counterpart americans....work extra hours and holidays with the same regular salary...Disney was just a pitfall in the system...in the overall...the H1bs have shaped the technology industry in the US catapulting it to the world's top....
Im cheerokee american and we need to focus on helping the Natives first before foreigners.
These companies low ball and take advantage of those foreign workers
Kudos to Mr Trump. Doing what he promised.
Were you born here Sanjay Garg? Why do you not want Indian people to hold jobs like you once did?
Well-said Sanjay.
I called(7/12/19 1:56 pm) Murthy Law Firm and surprised to know that they are do not challenge USISC against any unfavorable decision in federal court , then what is this video all about ???
If u are here temporary why would u buy house n taking up permanent space
For her, more immigrants more money. These attorneys who have insatiable appetite for money creating the problems
I am an Indian.. and I think what Trump says should not be questioned . you being an Indian don't buy or hire Indian. The president should always look for his people who are the blacks and whites they have been there for long enough . you go to the land of opportunities and criticize the leader of the nation you should be ashamed
You really want to get likes, don't you?
+thomas samson pardon me and my colleagues who work at Silicon Valley earn much more than most Americans, you clearly still live in the 20th century lol
I respect your Opinion
@thomas samson and rising the home prices....
well said maria
Just leave
This should have been done long ago. Too many gultis , and enough fraud & misuse.
If the applicant is a foreign educated lawyer with license to practice law in the US (CA), have you encountered RFEs on this case with regard to specialty occupation issue? What are the usual issues for this case?
Rubbish, the United States owes those here on employee visas nothing more than what was agreed to when that visa holder first entered the country. Regardless of how long the stay, an employment visa is a temporary visa and a path to immigration is neither implied nor in any way suggested. What must be done to bring the H-1B system back into balance is end the duel intent nature of the visa. In 1990 it was simply an employment visa. It was later changed.
You know what I recommend your clients do: take a closer look at some of the resumes of US citizens you been throwing away without looking at. I am sorry about the racists up here though, it's embarrassing.
GREAT!MAGA Trump!
Why these people are not helping own country, USA does not need anybody help. People from abroad come here for help.
Everyone wants to live a better life, whether you like it or not - an Indian who can will come into US on a H1, a black family who can afford will move in a rich neighborhood, a chinese family who can live in a rich white neighborhood....That's how simple life is you know.....
Madam..DO not get worked up, Let's respect the sentiments of Americans. They do not need us. They can automate those jobs and still sit pretty.
All these desi immigration attorneys will be out of business if USCIS starts scrutinizing the applications and hire only so called "highly specialised" resources
I think she is running out of business.
Americans first
sunny passionz Ur right from india
Native Americans first
Car Buyer yes I do agree local talented be preferred first I'm from india
Well hold on for a moment. I thought USA is the epitome of Capitalism and a champion of free-market, is it not? Then why exactly we don't let the "Market" decide what is the best for us? If the businesses((market) are happier to employ cheap labors from outside, why should we intervene like a communist country?:P
Native American Indians first, sorry.
What is wrong with looking after your own house first?
Half of IT jobs doesn’t need programming skills. Anybody with some training can easily do the job. Most of the IT companies from South Asia are just body shop who make money off the cheap labor available plentiful due to unemployment in India in college graduates 🎓
India should put ties with the US on hold and take their business elsewhere ,because it's not only trump it's American people in general.
How is an H1B Visa an immigration issue? It's for a foreign worker to work here for a temporary period and then return to their country of origin. Immigration is when a foreigner comes here with the intent of staying here and becoming a legally naturalized citizen.
most legal immigrants from India have a h-1 at some point of the immigration process
Dear friends .. I was in the same situation as many of you . My extension took more time than usual and just got approved recently . ( Premium processing ) . It took 3+ months for me to get my visa approved ( got an RFE in the middle ). Dont get disappointed or be panic by watching this video . Lawyers like Murthy will not spend their valuable time in youtube without a return . They actually don't care you and me . They just want to create panic situation and get more business for their lawyers.
Awaiting Bee hi.....exactly how long did it take for ur approval...actually me n my husband is stuck with 221g processing since Feb. ...it's for h1b extension
Awaiting Bee thanx for being real
it took me 4 months ( premium processing )
Krishnamaya Choudhurimayum 221g is a shit hole to be honest ,all they will say it's under administrative processing
Garbage fcuk!
Just lost my job to an Indian. My org at Walmart Labs (my recent employer) was hiring dozens of Indians every week straight out of India. Never ONCE hiring someone born in America, despite it being in Sunnyvale, CA. These Indians work more hours for less pay usually on contracts without any paid vacation, benefits, or anything. And they will do it all with a smile on their face because they are desperate. Those of us born in America that like the 40 hour workweek, vacations, basic benefits, etc are losing their jobs left and right to these people that are absolutely flooding the tech industry and costing Americans millions of job every year.
You reap what you sow. I was myself a victim of h-1b visa abuse. There is no tech shortage. H-1b should be for geniuses with special skills that cannot be found or taught.
And once an Indian visa person gets into a management position they only hire or promote h-1b Indians from their specific clan. They bring their caste system with them and impose it on Americans if they can. In other words Americans are on a lower caste than them.
Time to go home and give Americans the jobs and pay they deserve.
H1B for smart & brilliant. Not for garbage one more cheap worker.
As an American citizen, I had to leave the engineering profession because they did not want to hire me.... they wanted to hire an H1-b Visa... I'm sorry.... but you had the gravy train and didn't realize who you were hurting in the process.... I'm glad that Trump is President. There were so many engineering grads who could not find jobs after graduation, yet we always couldn't understand why those who applied for H1- B visas always had one. Oh and don't let my name fool you.... I am not white....
Consulting company = foreign temp agencies
Hi..may I know if we are selected in lottery but got RFE and then rejection, do we get our money back which they took from us
Yes, sue the govt and pay the lawyer so theycan make more money off you
Kashif Choudhry
😂😂
This bitch is more interested in that then the actual plights of H1B workers from India.
nicely said. whoever want's to make money & fortune attack the govt & Any policies in name of liberty , Democracy , But hiring undersliled , rampant immigration is also not democratic values even it is Irrelevant to very liberty & Democratic values ,& keep on going their businesses & money making. its illegal. Indians tend to Betray their own for even little gain. whenever that little gain is hampered than comes the agitation.
@Snow 123 yup , u got dat right bro. Are u of Indian origin or American native local citizen u have good knowledge about that. Actually it used to be certain indians who reached the heights in India ,certain ethnicities, class of people ,but after economic liberalisation every shitty ones getting money ,& only dream of them is getting to USA & Europe. I had several opportunities , I declined. My relatives we're there since 1970 s ,in research, now many in finances , & Law. They were totally assimilated with the culture . But indians , especially large of dem from South indians in IT , & North indians , majorly Punjabis , Gujjus & every other North indians always brag , fantises about largely America ,or Europe - west , getting der , being successful , iys like a status quo or like dey are getting to Moon , but dey barely understand the culture. rather than solving 99 problems from over population of certain inferior races which diminished the very good sides . This should have happened. And Donald Trump is giving Indian s a golden chance to improve our own country , nation's. But no they gotta do it in America. Why America doesn't owe us H1B s or any visas. Most culprit is J1 hotel worker ,or short 1 year visas. Most easy to access USA for Indian cheap hotel workers , sometime dey are scammed ,& overstayed and never leaves. Which Donald Trump even knows. As a hotelier. He should ban J1 and other work program visas , as H1 B to other outsourcing countries .
@Snow 123 more of different nations was unified by the Britishers , most beautiful pinnacle of an Empire by the Britishers ,Calcutta from which dey did global domination. But later destroyed by a filthy dictator family after independence. It is more of amalgamation of unified nation's , cause each single state represents different ethnicities.
@Snow 123 yaa ,see bro. Cause I'm sub contious mind they adore the white supremacy , not just Whites as superior talented but their desire to mingle and stay and be like dem. This is ridiculous. They will only complain when there is no other way or he is done playing all the cards and denials & hypocrisy
Get this hipity hopotos outta here. Sue my government for your benefit?
Throughout the United States, education leaders and policymakers are joining forces to bring computer science classes to our schools. Since January, 20 states from Alabama to Wyoming have passed laws and funded $49 million to expand access to and diversity in K-12 computer science.
Nice job you made the case as to why H-1B should be scaled back. There is no reason that a job should be helped by and H-1B use her for 20 years. That's long enough to conceive birth raise educate and train somebody for that job.
People from xxhra state is more bothered because they can’t show fake profile in their own country where they live
I am on H1B and I feel like what mr trump is doing is right for his country . He is president of the United States so US is his first priority. I hope he will more regulation on H1B and limit the IT companies from India from hiring people on H1B. Being on H1B is choice, if someone does not like it than just leave it and return back to ur country it’s simple
Americans first ...teach the children here first! If we don’t have enough physicist raise their pay and increase grant for students who pursue challenging carrers. We need more homegrown physicists scientist engineers etc who do the hard work applying solutions to complex problems.
Yea baby!
Sheela they should deny 100% That would be fair.
"In the spirit of President Trump's Executive Order on Buy American and Hire American, today's partnership adds to the Civil Rights Division's tools to stop employers from discriminating against U.S. workers by favoring foreign visa workers," explained Acting Assistant Attorney General John Gore of the Civil Rights Division.
Good! Enough is enough! We don't need more immigrants here, Americans first. There still lots of Americans without jobs!
All unemployed software programmers kind or the high school graduate kind?
Ya, they have skills in doing cocaine, weed or methlab...
Then, why are you there. You must also go to your own native country of our grand father. Who are you to decide America needs or not. Let's all H1B's from Microsoft and Google and big companies come back. Then see how it works. The Americans who are still jobless is because they are lacking some speacialities not because of H1B.
Yes I saw a video that a woman and daughter can find accommodation due to high rent in California ,they had to live in a big car to sleep . earning only 2000 $ per month .I felt really bad .Why outsource jobs when citizens are suffering . Trump can do the unimaginable .Bring back Jobs for American and enjoy .Love you from India .
Subramaniam Iyer , first because that woman has poop in her head, she needs to re evaluate how she spends her money, they seem middle class so they confuse luxury with necessity they are obese, you can t be poor and be obese, a lot of money goes to food, but they like to eat in expensive places, and other things like storage. she could cut many thing and get loft. second they suffer because they dont have higher education, it is very expensive in america. not H1b visas
what would be wrong with going back to India and work?
This is called the "Casino" business model. Approve student visas of like a zillion people regardless of qualifications (raise their hopes for a better tomorrow), make them invest 20-30k $ for education, make them walk the plank for finding a decent job... And then the final nail in the coffin - once they've done the seemingly impossible, tell 'em "Hey, thanks for all that revenue. But you're shit outta luck. Vacate our premises, go back home".
There ya have it. Casino!
You got it right. As for these so called talented Americans I’ve yet to meet one most are good for sales positions at most or working at Starbucks while pursuIng fine arts or atleast accounting degrees in college. Most lack aptitude and patience to pursue a stem degree. America does not deserve the choice pick of the worlds talent time to change that trend let the racists who were jealous of colored people being successful have their time in the sun trump is not going to change anything’l for the they are a dying demographic anyway
www.computerworld.com/article/2915904/it-outsourcing/fury-rises-at-disney-over-use-of-foreign-workers.html
This has been the experience of millions of citizens.
Did they come for an education?
When they have one, done deal.
If people go there to study it's to study....once they have completed let them go to back to their countries with the "specialised" knowledge.
Yes I am back in India, leading by example now. I am the first of many to return. India needs it's heroes and many are rising up to take up that mantel. As for Americans being dull, go to University and see how many Americans are in STEM. You see a handful of Mexican-Americans, and the rest are Asian-American or mostly International students. STEM is something where Americans are lacking. Frankly being called dull is not bad, Americans have done worse, using the N-word, calling other;s dot-heads, a racial tag for every race. I can say whatever I want America owes me nothing and I am in India in my castle living my life.
She did not mention anything about the misuse of the H1B visa. The H1B was meant to bring in high-level outsider engineer to fill a gap but it seems companies abused the H1B to "replace" existing American citizen employees. Several Indian engineers have also complained against this trend that is undermining the worth of truly competent Indian engineers. Business interests cannot rule over the national interests of any country. Please tell us the whole truth.
I read all these comments, but current unemployment rate is only 4% which is historically low !! why every hater here is hating for those 4% ? Its just bit... like they do in homes and at their current jobs !!
She's complaining because the government is finally enforcing the law.
no, a lot of what they are doing is just making harder what is already really hard, it is really difficult to work legally, you can only petition a certain time of the year and they ask for so many things, you have no idea how difficult it is. So only the best get asked for a H1B. So with no change in constitution it is clear its because there is more open hatred.
I also work in US but think that H1B holders incl me are not immigrant but temporary worker.
Average American software developer salary also increases to over 1 crore (INR) pa . Is this a coincidence?
AMERICA FIRST. TRAIN AMERICANS FOR THESE JOBS. GET THESE EXPERTS TO TRAIN AMERICANS AND THEN SEND THEM BACK TO INDIA. MAGA☝️
Give the jobs to American citizen
She must an H1B petitioner running a body shop for indian employees or something
H-1B should be decreased rapidly. The persons who should be allowed stay are those who come here and get MS and/or PhD in STEM areas. Just forklifting a programmer from India to come and do some coding are really not needed. These jobs can be automated and hence outsourced.
Ok so you believe the MS/PhD's from here are superior to a programmer with several years of experience back home? well my experience seems to differ. I have seen several MS grads from here who might speak better english than the back-home programmer, but are clueless when it comes to writing a simple SQL query or putting together a static html page. Education is not a substitute for experience.
Srinivas Ganti: there are anecdotal examples where someone from India with only 2 courses in Java or C++ had been forklifted and brought here in USA and displaced Americans. (Disney is an example). Second, I have seen other examples where Indian code masters write no superior code than Americans or US educated foreigners. Code functions can be automated or the entire process can be outsourced to India. Why forklift people from India and bring them here to displace Americans? If the companies want to make profit with cheap labor, they should move operations there!
Finally it is not the fault of the Indian IT professionals to come here and face the uncertainty. The fault lies clearly with these US companies who are too greedy.
Deb: The comparison was between Indian US STEM grads Vs Experienced programmers "forklifted". I don't think they teach many languages & technologies at US grad schools, neither it is necessary IMO. I personally trained and groomed many programmers myself - both US grads and forklifted, and I don't see much difference except for little english skills which can be taught easily.
I leave the matter of who should come and who should not to the citizens of USA, since this is their country and they decide their future.
Srinivas Ganti: well put. Just one issue: all routine jobs shall eventually be automated, including ones that involve cleaning toilets. The pervasive use of Artificial Intelligence coupled with Big Data Analytics (Machine Learning etc.), would kill the potential of human involvement. But greedy company CEOs and VPs and Wall Street honchos are not willing to make that initial investment into automation. They are thus just hiring medium skill people and thus paying them wages that are sub par.
And finally Computer Science is *not* about programming languages. It is about algorithms. So, your implied response that programmers are computer scientists, is not quite correct.
I'd leave the automation to the businesses as it's not the point of discussion here. And I did not imply anything. I'm merely saying a US degree won't make anyone great (other than knowing how to market himself).
The only company that's mad is Infosys
H and L visas are perhaps the only visas which you need an attorney to file . Most of the other work visas for any other country can be processed by the person themselves. The US goverment has created labyrinthine rule book for these vias and is feeding this industry.
Simple - if you are “employed” by a company who’s office you never visit ... and you are working off-site in the USA ... YOU have replaced a US IT worker who probably trained you. Indian body shop companies are unfortunately rampant with this. You have been abused ... but are part of the problem. You are NOT exceptional or “highly skilled” - you have just replaced an American IT worker. Hate to point out the facts ... but that was not what H1B program was used for. If you’re ever on “bench” or paid a penny in terms of your immigration or H1B fees or legal fees to your company, or have a payment method to do so in the future ... look in the mirror! It is illegal!
Thanks to Indian consultancies... We all internationals are screwed.
Sheela, are you afraid of losing the Business? What are you saying?The best solution is stop outsourcing so the H1's will get jobs in US
The days of cheap labor for silicon valley are coming to an end....Indians need to find jobs in India and Americans need to fill the jobs available in the United States
Ha ha. No, you cant, because most of your asses cant afford to get a BA, masters, etc... so your not qualified nor specialized... boom! America needs them
Well Armed Lamb , true and America needs to manufacture within and sell all products within America. Why do they need Asian or Latin market for selling Kellogg’s or coke Pepsi? No need for selective protectionism.
We are on the planet earth. America is one spot on the globe. If you are an intelligent, you can live as a king where ever you are. that is that.
Intelligent person. Please talk some sense into your people
like what you gas station worker? r u f'in racist as well, u want easy money & don't wanna study? back off man.
Ashwin Kumar about time...about
Time to go someplace else
Ashwin Kumar bro the thing is this that highly unqualified and uneducated people are able to immigrate to the US using the marriage loophole and family Immigration. They don't want to touch the marriage visas or family Immigration because their own relatives are using these routes to enter into the US. Take the example of Maleina Trump's family, just last week the become the US citizens through the chain family Immigration. So of you want to immigrate to the US get married and live like a king.
Hey lion Roar..sounds like you didn't get the point, plz read my comment one more time slowly.
Regarding Maleina Trump parents citizenship, its a big fraud, I know that, even their attorney denied to reveal when her parents got the green card. Moreover, there plenty of homeless US citizens, still some illiterate Europeans and American had been crying on highly educated Indians. Hope you got the point now. :-)
Entitled much?
A person with a temporary status must sued the government ..that mean a HB-1 visa holders have the right to stay in the US
Its just an Executive Order, its not permanent. I say make money and move away from anyobody whos is making under 75K annual income. Americans who are making over 75K are mostly happy and seems to have less Racism and HATE.
at 2:33 "...even though a lot of the people that are being asked are actually doing Federal govt, State govt, County govt. projects...."
Is she saying Americans are not available to do these routine jobs? This is pure BS.
Good. Why should Americans live on welfare, while CEOs hire people from India for tech jobs? Indians should continue to work for microsoft technical support from India.
Attorneys are losing business?
RUBBISH...... YOU SHOULD GET INVOLVED IN INDIAN POLITICS NOT US POLITICS!!!!!!!
US Ambassador to UN, Nikky Haley's father came from India. She's now enjoying her big mouth at UN Security Council.
I've come to the US to get a physics PhD, which was 100% funded by US money, clearly because not so much american- born citizens like to spend the needed effort. Now, after I got my degree and ready to benefit the economy and pay my share of taxes, the government tells me 'No, Thanks. Please go benefit another society'. Doesn't sound very clever to me!
It’s another money making gimmick
Every country can have it's own policies on immigration and borders. If they don't need/want more foreign people in the US then it is what it is. Stop crying and face reality.
Its hard to be president anyone who cannot stand his policy feel free to return or stay in india dont attack trump it will backfire to you
Being on H1 for more than 5 yrs is an indication you haven’t made your mind to stay here. Sorry you need to go back. Honestly we have enough talent here, need no more. This woman though knowledgeable is making up scenarios which don’t exist. Hail Trump 🙏🏽.....no more H1s, Sorry.
It is not the visa holders' choice.
Ms Murthy, the job of the US Government to take care of the best interests of its citizens, not to ensure that the companies get cheap human resources and that law firms like you keep making money.
What about hiring Americans citizen
Attorneys are losing business, Period.
Bro if, H1 are get rejected, they will send RFE, then the company got to contact attorney, more refusals means, more business for them - right?
Ashwin Kumar correct Bro
bro, if there is high rejection rate, eventually the applications will decrease...the bottom line is in future these immigration lawyers will be out of job..
its NOT only about India, more RFE means more business for them ,
more RFE only temporarily...later less applications and less RFEs...overall bad for them in long term...also she is trying to say its not her fault for RFEs...
Issuing Visa is a discretion of that country's laws and immigration policies. Indian immigration also states the same that its the discretion of embassy to issue or not to issue visa so US is no different. Visa's cannot be issued just cus someone bought home/car etc. Its based purely on merit and skills. If USCIS says certain case does not have the merit then that is enough for a denial. Follow laws and do things right and this country welcomes everyone. We should stop whining and fighting for unjust causes.
I wish they stop is h1b visa asap at least then the dependants can have a life in India. Or may be stop giving dependant visas so that dependants dont have to come here and feel like rotting in hell
YES, YES, YES, YES, YES... AMERICAN GOVT IS NO GOOD BUT INDIAN GOVT IS A VERY VERY GOOD GOVERNMENT.
do not believe everything here, creating artificial panic. situation is not so bad, if you are talented and have right skills and education.
Good relevant comments below, in short H1 are an asset because they are grunt coders and can travel across the US with a 2 weeks notice. "americans" want a 9-5 job and are more diverse in their skills and functionally better as the have a better understanding the business process. I have been in this business for 20 years (hiring americans and h1's) and am a president of a IT consulting firm. US Citizen
It’s going to be even more difficult for Indians to get a tourist visa let alone an hb1. That will be fully in effect soon..
Should anyone with GC be worried of not being able to get a new job because of the hire American exec order? What are the implications of it going for citizenship?
This woman is simply ranting.
It appears she is advocating for open boarders
Have you ever found an Indian director or CTO in a team just by himself? I have been worked in IT/Computer/Software company for 20 years.. In general, as my personal opinion, Indian tends to hire Indians, and outsourcing job to India. If one Indian becomes manager, most likely, half of his/her team will be Indian for short of period of time. The worst is most of them is less qualified... My personal opinion, India tech's company culture, just cheap and slavery and less of loyalty, sooner or later, it will destroy american culture in general.
Tech companies will outsource more jobs to out of USA, as they just don't have enough tech workers
For cheap labor.
You got sold into this myth of labor shortage.