Bar Keepers Friend Powder VS Soft Cleanser (What's the Difference?)

Поделиться
HTML-код

Комментарии • 99

  • @dccd673
    @dccd673 8 месяцев назад +18

    I used the powdered one before on my stainless steel pans and pots but I made the mistake once of not wearing gloves (as the bottle suggests) and I thought something horrible would happen to my fingers. It was as if I soaked my hands in water for days. I switched to the soft cleaner and have stuck with that ever since. I wear disposable gloves when I use it every time, and for my, I felt like I didn’t have to scrub as hard as I did with the powder one. I use it with scrub daddy and works great.

  • @laurenskee2665
    @laurenskee2665 Год назад +29

    The powder is personally my favorite, but the cream is somewhat easier to clean showers.

  • @mimiseeyou
    @mimiseeyou 7 месяцев назад +6

    Came for cleaning silverware with this product and you solved my other problem which is glass shower doors. Thanks!

    • @Andie-
      @Andie- 6 месяцев назад +4

      Be sure to test a small spot first, on any porcelain sink or tub, as the label says. I didn't, and the acid in BKF powder removed most of the shine on my sink.

  • @Dalyluvr
    @Dalyluvr Год назад +28

    The soft cleanser works amazing on copper bottom pots. I'd argue it works better than the powder. It was my go to for my revereware pots.

  • @stephenbozzone1116
    @stephenbozzone1116 Год назад +10

    For tarnished copper, lemon juice and salt works like magic (actually it’s chemistry-oxidation/reduction reaction)

  • @priz1997
    @priz1997 Год назад +84

    Of the 3, powder wins! Squeeze bottle smells awful and you definitely need gloves. Spray cleaner didn't really do much for my shower.... I love the powder and use it on pretty much everything!

    • @dccd673
      @dccd673 Год назад +14

      You’d still need rubber gloves especially for the powdered ones bc it will affect the skin. I made a mistake once using it without gloves, took my fingers days to go back normal.

    • @vivianhudacek1556
      @vivianhudacek1556 11 месяцев назад +4

      I hate the smell of both!

    • @Natalie-ym8pj
      @Natalie-ym8pj 11 месяцев назад +11

      Omg yes!! The liquid/soft scrub one smells horrible. I can't take it. I don't notice the powder smelling though.

    • @lillywildflower
      @lillywildflower 4 месяца назад

      Thank you 😊

  • @kathrinekerns8398
    @kathrinekerns8398 Год назад +14

    I like Bar Keeper Friends, but I prefer Bon-Ami. I love how it shines my Stainless Steel sink.

    • @vivianhudacek1556
      @vivianhudacek1556 11 месяцев назад +1

      And it smells so much better than BKF!

    • @ladyofspa
      @ladyofspa 10 месяцев назад +2

      Love both but you are right and no smell

  • @angeewells
    @angeewells Год назад +13

    Good morning. Thanks for letting us know the differences.

    • @CleanThatUp
      @CleanThatUp  Год назад +2

      You got it, I appreciate you watching!

  • @ooohlaa13
    @ooohlaa13 8 месяцев назад +1

    luvlee touch, the confetti! thanx just bought More for toilet bowl and tank build up because I dont want to erode the ceramic coating with abrasives, only to have it invite more rust. Toilet is only 9 months old and slowly it is starting to yellow from well system. Thanx very helpful.

  • @1ycj
    @1ycj Год назад +1

    Excellent video. Just purchased some revere stainless pots and pans with the copper bottoms and can’t wait to clean them.👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼

  • @madestmadhatter
    @madestmadhatter 3 месяца назад +1

    Powder is better for vertical or sloped surfaces too, all though completely vertical surfaces require a bit more work to get them on, but once it's on it sticks to where you put it until you whipe it down which garuntees that you got it where you need it.

  • @dionnewhite9264
    @dionnewhite9264 Год назад +8

    Love your videos, they are so easy to follow and I have found them so very useful. Had a question for you though. How do you clean older sticky wood furniture like chair backs.

  • @ilovepickle
    @ilovepickle Год назад +9

    Thank you so much for this video it's greatly appreciated! One question for you is that would you use the spray on fiber glass tubs and showers? I know with fiberglass stuff you have eto be super careful and can't use any abrasive cleansers or tools to clean them with.

  • @Barb6106
    @Barb6106 Год назад +6

    I’m still looking for the MORE spray, but I really enjoyed this clarification of the differences! Thank you!

  • @tckoppang
    @tckoppang 5 дней назад +1

    The problem with the powder is that there's no easy way to seal it up between uses. Moisture gets in there and causes serious clumping.

  • @kiawilliams5541
    @kiawilliams5541 Год назад +5

    Great information, as always. Thanks, Brandon!

  • @kathrynp7595
    @kathrynp7595 Год назад +1

    Thanks Brandon, another great video! Love your enthusiasm 😊

  • @jcolley31b
    @jcolley31b 2 месяца назад

    Blanco sinks recommend this for stubborn stains

  • @lynnettawilliams2138
    @lynnettawilliams2138 Год назад

    Lol BB e barkeepers friend I'm a new big fan of it just recently tried

  • @crqdea6654
    @crqdea6654 9 месяцев назад +3

    THANK YOU👍🏿

  • @Jzmakes
    @Jzmakes Год назад +1

    Thank you! This is very helpful

  • @vikings1984
    @vikings1984 5 месяцев назад +1

    How long do you let it sit in the bathtub before washing/rinsing out?

  • @chriswalls5831
    @chriswalls5831 Год назад +1

    Soft I haven't seen until here my new idea is ajax soft cleaner

  • @noemimatias3729
    @noemimatias3729 Год назад +1

    Thanks so much for the video 👍🏼 I found it very helpful.

  • @chrisumali9841
    @chrisumali9841 Год назад

    Thanks for the demo, and info, have a great day

  • @christinefisher877
    @christinefisher877 Год назад

    one way to clean copper easier than scrubbing with BKF is using a tomato. Cut it in half and wipe it all over the copper. Raw Tomatoes work better than Ketchup, taco sauce.

  • @crystalmas6685
    @crystalmas6685 5 месяцев назад

    Thank you for explaining and the links!

  • @CallieWatkins-ft8oo
    @CallieWatkins-ft8oo 5 месяцев назад

    Can you do a how to video on outdoor cleaning like decks, deck chairs, etc

  • @stevenwinderlich2891
    @stevenwinderlich2891 Год назад +1

    There should be more channels like yours here in germany, also you may want to get some proper microfiber detergent to have your microfiber last as much as possible

    • @moodyboobsjanna
      @moodyboobsjanna Год назад +3

      There is a microfiber cleanser/detergent? I had no idea!

    • @stevenwinderlich2891
      @stevenwinderlich2891 Год назад +2

      @@moodyboobsjanna Theres many nowadays, mainly found in car care supplier shops. Theyre made specifically to clean Microfiber without clogging the fibers or leaving anything behind that can reduce the function of the fibers, any other detergent will clog the fibers up or get them sticking together which kills their function.

    • @jaytee2642
      @jaytee2642 6 месяцев назад

      ​@@stevenwinderlich2891
      Interesting!
      I'll have to look for that.👍🏻

  • @DoctorsSong
    @DoctorsSong Год назад +6

    I'd use the liquid versions if they didn't stink to high heaven. I have Chemical Sensitivities (aka Environmental Illness) and can't stand chemical or fragrance smells. So it's just the powder for me

  • @hudbabible
    @hudbabible Год назад

    I so wish we had this in my country..

  • @MrPathorock
    @MrPathorock 5 месяцев назад

    Is it safe to clean porcelain tiles? Will the microabrasions track dirt and dust in the future?

  • @melaniegacis1063
    @melaniegacis1063 2 месяца назад

    What do you mix with the powder? Is it water only?😊

  • @Houndog545
    @Houndog545 8 месяцев назад +2

    Can i use this on the inside of my frying pan or is that not recommended?

    • @sharoncontini3284
      @sharoncontini3284 3 месяца назад

      I wet a sponge, add the BKF and scrub away. Then I rinse and wash out with Dawn. I only use stainless steel. I don't know about other cookware surfaces.

  • @Neve-m9e
    @Neve-m9e 11 месяцев назад +2

    BKF took the sheen off of my stovetop in some areas as I was trying to remove a burned on stain...which it did not remove. Is there a way to restore the shine to the dulled sections now? Thx.

    • @Andie-
      @Andie- 6 месяцев назад +3

      I have the same problem with my porcelain sink. I left BKF powder on too long, and it removed most of the shine. I've tried to polish it with other non abrasive cleaners and a soft cloth, but nothing helps at all. I think they should put a much stronger warning on the label. My sink is destroyed!

  • @lzarEus304
    @lzarEus304 Год назад

    Would you recommend using bar keepers friend liquid on silgranite or composite granite kitchen sinks? Have a few hard water stains I have yet to get rid of. In your video I saw you use the BKF on a sink and it looked like granite composite. Thanks for the informative video.

  • @yancyhammondjr
    @yancyhammondjr Месяц назад

    Which do you recommend to clean Aquarium glass?

  • @florencesolis9636
    @florencesolis9636 15 дней назад

    how about cleaning hard water stained tiles?

  • @Macsrus5
    @Macsrus5 Год назад +1

    Works great!!!!

  • @mtnluvr
    @mtnluvr 3 месяца назад

    Can I use this on my stainless steel refrigerator?

  • @PowderyHandzASMR
    @PowderyHandzASMR 10 месяцев назад

    Powder all the way!

  • @cocasio7190
    @cocasio7190 Год назад +1

    Thank you!!

  • @lynnhutto7660
    @lynnhutto7660 Год назад

    Hey Brandon , I have a question … what would you suggest to use on a RV awning ?? When the RV is not in use of course we have the awning rolled up , well it rains here in the afternoon in Florida . So there may be mildew stains , what product would you suggest to use on the awning without harming the vinyl the awning is made of .

  • @MsThai1982
    @MsThai1982 Месяц назад

    Used the liquid on my stainless steel roaster oven and now leaves a residue..any suggestions for removing this?

  • @cdgates1
    @cdgates1 6 месяцев назад +1

    I just bought the powder. Can i use it to clean the silver burner on my stove? I am trying to clean the grease

    • @xenn2996
      @xenn2996 18 дней назад

      I don’t think you’re supposed to use it on sliver .

  • @loriplate729
    @loriplate729 7 месяцев назад

    Can I use in my stainless fridge door? it has a water line I can not get off.

  • @wemcal
    @wemcal Год назад

    Great video and great information

  • @nicholaslandolina
    @nicholaslandolina 11 месяцев назад +1

    The powder is an abrasive

  • @somerset6646
    @somerset6646 6 месяцев назад +1

    I used the powder today to get a dried on gravy stain out of a shirt. And I use it on my All-Clad stainless.

    • @TonyaJones0788
      @TonyaJones0788 6 месяцев назад

      I have a stain on my favorite shirt, I’ll try the powder. Thanks

  • @Swi2thMummbles
    @Swi2thMummbles 6 месяцев назад

    Do you not use steel wool when cleaning?

  • @teem9010
    @teem9010 Год назад +5

    i would love to know why Comet cleanser is not more popular in cleaning videos? Compared to bar keepers it works SO much better for everything! what am i missing? or is it just some fad? thanks

    • @peggiebrown5569
      @peggiebrown5569 Год назад

      I feel like Comet contains chemicals. Isn't BKF more natural like Bon Ami? I'm just guessing but Comet has bleach type properties.

    • @tic857
      @tic857 Год назад +4

      For me, I don't like the smell of comet. The second reason is the ingredients and method of removal. Its calcium carbonate which is more or less ground up shell, so its a physical cleaning removal. Whereas bar keeper is oxalic acid which is a chemical reaction that breaks up hard on grime. For me, Comet works fine if a space is kept routinely clean. But since i use to live in bad apartments often and people didn't clean there would be layered in grime which may need a little dissolving power, to get cleaning done faster. Especially since I have chronic fatigue, if something can do more of a breakdown without me scrubbing, it saves more energy for other things. Even in the lab I work in if the soap and brush arent working...we're using the acid to acid wash our dishes.

    • @YanaSLee
      @YanaSLee Год назад

      @@tic857I love the smell of Comet 😂 thanks for explaining this

    • @WhoCaresAlisha
      @WhoCaresAlisha 9 месяцев назад

      I personally use this cleaner because Comet triggers my asthma attacks. This doesn't effect me at all.

  • @ideklex
    @ideklex Год назад +5

    The liquid smells absolutely awful, I won’t use it again.

  • @tukulitozakayamas2103
    @tukulitozakayamas2103 6 месяцев назад

    am trying to decide between bar keeper and pink stuff. which one is better?

    • @freshr.8571
      @freshr.8571 5 месяцев назад

      Bar Keeper is better and cheaper

  • @fredcdobbs823
    @fredcdobbs823 10 месяцев назад

    Oxalic acid is used as wood bleach

  • @bpxl53yewz29
    @bpxl53yewz29 Год назад +6

    I don’t like any powder form cleaner because it feels like the powder is getting into my lungs.

    • @sharoncontini3284
      @sharoncontini3284 3 месяца назад

      Powders, sprays, and mist all bother me since COVID. I have to use a mask just to clean.

  • @mjgregory205
    @mjgregory205 9 месяцев назад

    I live in a house that was built in 1905. I have the original porcelain tub and it is very difficult to get dirt and grime out. I have tried many cleaning products including the Bar keepers soft scrub on it and nothing seems to get the grime out of the porcelain. Can you please help me!?

    • @pr9177
      @pr9177 6 месяцев назад

      Your problem is probably that the tub needs to be reglazed. Nothing will keep it clean for long. I would use Comet or a similar product, but that also depends on your water. If you have iron water, bleach will make it worse. An iron filter would be your first step in that situation.

    • @main2333
      @main2333 6 месяцев назад

      @@pr9177use iron out/ rust out powder

  • @rocky-fo4qe
    @rocky-fo4qe Год назад

    so its safe to use on a composite sink?

  • @andreaB8
    @andreaB8 Год назад

    O pó pode usar no box?

  • @33RPMVinyl
    @33RPMVinyl 2 дня назад

    Bar Keepers Friend is complete garbage. Used it in an attempt to clean a drip pan with burned on grease. It didn't do a thing. The only thing that removed the grease was a putty knife. Perhaps I should do a video on how to clean cookware with a putty knife.

  • @dianamatthews2613
    @dianamatthews2613 Год назад

    Help!1 My 3yr. old granddaughter wrote on my apartment walls with crayon and marker.

    • @CleanThatUp
      @CleanThatUp  Год назад +6

      Oh no! I might try some Zep foaming wall cleaner.
      Also for permanent marker you can write over it with a dry erase marker and it will come right off.

  • @HannahMattox
    @HannahMattox Год назад +1

    I've been using it for many years, but there's a random new fad going around the cleaning side of RUclips 😂

  • @EmanElrashidi
    @EmanElrashidi Год назад

    😎👏🏻

  • @stevethea5250
    @stevethea5250 5 месяцев назад

    0:40
    2:30
    3:40
    3:50 only told us the very end its sponsored

  • @bdianes6339
    @bdianes6339 8 месяцев назад

    👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏

  • @RETUSAF1995
    @RETUSAF1995 3 месяца назад

    Can't stand the smell of Soft Cleanser.