Former FBI Agent Breaks Down Universal Body Language | WIRED

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 14 май 2024
  • Former FBI agent and body language expert Joe Navarro breaks down the unintentional non-verbals that are displayed by human beings around the globe. Joe explains how the limbic system functions and why we act the way we do in certain situations.
    Check out Joe's book "The Dictionary of Body Language"
    www.jnforensics.com/
    Books By Joe Navarro: www.jnforensics.com/books
    Joe Navarro Body Language Academy: jnbodylanguageacademy.com
    Still haven’t subscribed to WIRED on RUclips? ►► wrd.cm/15fP7B7
    Listen to the Get WIRED podcast ►► link.chtbl.com/wired-ytc-desc
    Want more WIRED? Get the magazine ►► subscribe.wired.com/subscribe...
    Get more incredible stories on science and tech with our daily newsletter: wrd.cm/DailyYT
    Also, check out the free WIRED channel on Roku, Apple TV, Amazon Fire TV, and Android TV. Here you can find your favorite WIRED shows and new episodes of our latest hit series Tradecraft.
    ABOUT WIRED
    WIRED is where tomorrow is realized. Through thought-provoking stories and videos, WIRED explores the future of business, innovation, and culture.
    Former FBI Agent Breaks Down Universal Body Language | WIRED
  • РазвлеченияРазвлечения

Комментарии • 482

  • @eshabilnanacak
    @eshabilnanacak 3 года назад +1329

    I can listen to this man for hours.

    • @miguelahorta
      @miguelahorta 3 года назад +22

      He is indeed an excellent communicator, for sure a great professor.

    • @damaribrackett1159
      @damaribrackett1159 3 года назад +13

      Same but I cant listen to my teacher of 30 mins b4 falling asleep

    • @NerdyCatCoffeeee
      @NerdyCatCoffeeee 3 года назад +10

      @@damaribrackett1159 You must be studying physics

    • @LadySamurai88
      @LadySamurai88 2 года назад +5

      Same here.
      The way he tells it is interesting.

    • @SquidBeats
      @SquidBeats 2 года назад +6

      Jesus Christ is God and is the only way. Turn to Jesus Christ before it’s too late

  • @antoniovalencia2984
    @antoniovalencia2984 3 года назад +728

    All the quiet kids in the corner are already pros..

    • @sand4brainz506
      @sand4brainz506 3 года назад +52

      someone actually said it.
      i gotta agree w you, as a former quiet kid who sat in the corner

    • @BadazzGregg
      @BadazzGregg 3 года назад +50

      Quietest person is the most observant.

    • @dashiellgillingham4579
      @dashiellgillingham4579 3 года назад +20

      I used to track social groups and the speed of interactions at my high school by saying something weird and specific and making a note every time I heard those exact words.

    • @chadsknnr
      @chadsknnr 3 года назад

      Well, I guess that makes me Argus . . . .

    • @borisdawelf4500
      @borisdawelf4500 3 года назад +1

      *Hi*

  • @indiciaobscure
    @indiciaobscure 3 года назад +317

    I feel better knowing there's a reason for freezing up when something scary happens to you. I was molested in the street, and froze up. Afterwards I could not understand why I didn't respond in any way. It's not very useful nowadays, but I'm glad to know it has some survival function.

    • @jdhama
      @jdhama 3 года назад +42

      I really felt bad after reading that you were molested

    • @GMAMEC
      @GMAMEC 3 года назад +53

      So sorry to hear about your experience. Yes, it is not uncommon to freeze when you are in a dangerous or scary situation. It wasn’t your fault and it wasn’t consent. While we all have different ways of healing, please consider counseling with an experienced specialist or support group.

    • @SueBoo2
      @SueBoo2 3 года назад +5

      Hindsight is 20/20. Evidently, your reaction saved you. 😓

    • @acousticintervention7163
      @acousticintervention7163 3 года назад +2

      Yeah, that happens because if you run they'll do a heck of a lot worse. Interesting, isn't it? (Sad, really.)

    • @acousticintervention7163
      @acousticintervention7163 3 года назад +8

      @@Elektrikkiss very true. I should have said, "I always thought it happens because..." Because that is what I really meant. Thank you for correcting that.

  • @janey783
    @janey783 3 года назад +457

    Joe is a genius! I've been using his body language knowledge to be a better actor, his books are so worth it

    • @francescaa8331
      @francescaa8331 3 года назад +20

      Interesting use of the information. I could see how it might make a performance more convincing.
      Also, do you feel the addition of the body language adds to your emotional connection to the character? Just curious.

    • @songbird1154
      @songbird1154 3 года назад

      Me too!

    • @nishi704
      @nishi704 3 года назад +9

      Oh my. I'm glad I found your comment cuz as an artist it's one of my goals to be able to imitate the human figure on the canvas. I'll look into his books immediately ty!

    • @jurassicthunder
      @jurassicthunder 3 года назад +1

      @@francescaa8331 emotions are directly connected with your body

    • @francescaa8331
      @francescaa8331 3 года назад +6

      @@arjundube8380 artist and actor were discussing body language and how to use in art. I was commenting on that. I have no idea what your WTF is about.

  • @andrenewell9483
    @andrenewell9483 3 года назад +410

    This was extremely fascinating especially the reflexes in babies.

  • @lostpuppy6951
    @lostpuppy6951 3 года назад +84

    His hands are open palmed most of the time....welcoming behaviour.…human body language is very interesting. Couldnt have been better explained than this. I definitely learned something today.

  • @kathryncarter6143
    @kathryncarter6143 3 года назад +56

    On new born hospital wards, testing the Babinski reflex is part of the routine health check

  • @loonyspoonie3655
    @loonyspoonie3655 3 года назад +30

    I never had any clue that I consistently grasped at my heart when I would hear sad news until my husband told me. When I payed attention I realized that I would actually feel a pain there that felt like it needed to be soothed.

    • @oxide9679
      @oxide9679 Год назад

      Vagus nerve, most likely.

  • @ImAssassinX
    @ImAssassinX 3 года назад +223

    Every guy is now like "Sorry honey, I'm not trying to ignore you by watching sports, I can't help it. It's part of my survival instinct!"

    • @HerbFlowers
      @HerbFlowers 3 года назад +2

      It's part of ur coping

  • @fevre_dream8542
    @fevre_dream8542 2 года назад +13

    Fun fact - Babinski reflex is part of the infant neurological exam in medicine. Very useful for assessing spinal chord injuries or abnormalities.

  • @animeyahallo3887
    @animeyahallo3887 3 года назад +32

    People after watching 3 videos of this guy : Hi I am a non-verbal communications expert.

  • @Boopierthanmost
    @Boopierthanmost 3 года назад +161

    Joe Navarro: talks about complexity in human brain.
    People in comments section: tiger in Africa?

    • @otbfitness1313
      @otbfitness1313 3 года назад +9

      They are a little bit behind on the evolutionary scale

    • @kingdoublegee1681
      @kingdoublegee1681 3 года назад +6

      No they’re speaking facts..besides zoo’s, there are no wild tigers in Africa

    • @kaemincha
      @kaemincha 2 года назад +3

      @@kingdoublegee1681 To cut him some slack, he's an expert in humans, not animals haha

    • @halointheworld
      @halointheworld 2 года назад

      Probably there was the saber tooth tiger back then

  • @henk-3098
    @henk-3098 3 года назад +327

    How does 'normal' non verbal communication differ in people on the autism spectrum and other psychiatric disorders?

    • @CyberCheese392
      @CyberCheese392 3 года назад +47

      People go to school for years and write books and books to answer that kind of question.
      But Ill say this: Aspergers disorder symptoms were a lack of emotional awareness and expression. The disorder was reclassified as "low functioning autism" some years back. So with Autism, I would say most of the time nonverbal communication is absent (However, I imagine an esoteric subject that they are into might contain a signal that might noticably grab their attention).

    • @nexusSix_237
      @nexusSix_237 3 года назад +58

      @@CyberCheese392 don't you mean HIGH functioning? I'm pretty sure asperger's is on the high end, not low end

    • @CyberCheese392
      @CyberCheese392 3 года назад +53

      @@nexusSix_237 Yes you are correct. I got mixed up. It is called high-functioning autism, which is low on the autism spectrum.

    • @youareaclown3659
      @youareaclown3659 3 года назад +1

      "normal"??

    • @youareaclown3659
      @youareaclown3659 3 года назад +1

      like voluntary stuff??

  • @JohnPullum
    @JohnPullum 3 года назад +31

    Joe is amazing. He was a guest on a series I hosted for the Discovery Channel a number of years ago. Super smart guy and nice, too!

  • @gregkral4467
    @gregkral4467 2 года назад +13

    This man is so fascinating, and for Autistic kids, who cannot really read body language, great lessons as well in human interaction and interpretation.

  • @galtab8479
    @galtab8479 3 года назад +15

    I need a channel with just this man. I have watched all his videos

  • @Bryle_P.
    @Bryle_P. 3 года назад +126

    I'll avoid these when im lying, an outstanding move for me.

    • @lilbertsmom3561
      @lilbertsmom3561 3 года назад +24

      Better yet, don't lie and you won't have to think about your non-verbal cues.

  • @yourmathtutorvids
    @yourmathtutorvids 3 года назад +28

    I've always found it hard to focus when I'm at sports bars (the ones with huge tvs everywhere). Now I know why!

  • @HunterCihal
    @HunterCihal 3 года назад +24

    This has to be the most interesting thing I've listened to in months.

  • @flowerlullaby
    @flowerlullaby 3 года назад +27

    If he taught a class I'd be there every day

  • @ThresholdGaming
    @ThresholdGaming 3 года назад +150

    During my training as a psychologist, I was taught to recognize subconscious body language. So now when I have to speak with those in law enforcement...I purposefully send certain signals to cause relaxation & comfort and familiarity. If they're being azzholes, I send different signals to throw them off. Once you know how THEY have been taught to think, they are easily manipulated.

    • @matthewsalvador9783
      @matthewsalvador9783 3 года назад +14

      My gma is a psychiatrist she reads me every day. I do believe you. It’s a bit intimidating.

    • @jakubstupka2922
      @jakubstupka2922 3 года назад +16

      make a video about it ))

    • @redweather6315
      @redweather6315 3 года назад +11

      what are some signals that you use to cause comfort and familiarity?

    • @LuchadorMasque
      @LuchadorMasque 3 года назад +21

      I have problems exhibiting and evaluating social and emotional responses, and learning these body language cues help me a LOT.
      For example, grasping the back of your neck while someone is talking indicates that you are listening to them. I have horrible adhd and I do this one whenever I realize I'm not paying attention.
      Another big one is eye contact. It's so complicated it drives me crazy. I Iearned that if you keep your gaze just above someones eyes (brow or forehead) it asserts confidence and makes people see you as somewhat dominant.
      Social cues suck.

    • @nexusSix_237
      @nexusSix_237 3 года назад +9

      @@LuchadorMasque maybe you have a touch of asperger's along with that adhd? ?? ...its a good thing!

  • @helenalderson6608
    @helenalderson6608 3 года назад +12

    Cool! As a dentist, I am constantly battling limbic response

    • @kalki3060
      @kalki3060 2 года назад +2

      wow yeah, we feel like we're in danger in the dentist's even though we're really not and our body goes into survivor mode.
      Never thought about that 😀

  • @MamaPinks
    @MamaPinks 3 года назад +8

    I absolutely LOVE this man! I love how he explains things and his passion for the craft is evident.

  • @JessicaReinke
    @JessicaReinke 3 года назад +1

    Love Joe Navarros books! These videos with him have made me buy and finish 3 of his books so far

  • @MichaelGaryScott90
    @MichaelGaryScott90 3 года назад +63

    *Sweats in Limbic*

  • @rosal7429
    @rosal7429 3 года назад +2

    Thankyou for making a Joe a regular on your videos!

  • @ItoNarasimha
    @ItoNarasimha 3 года назад +30

    I love this series, so interesting to learn about these kind of stuff

  • @sandraklein2651
    @sandraklein2651 3 года назад +4

    This is by far the most fascinating and interesting view. Thank you for your profound vid.

  • @maryged6624
    @maryged6624 3 года назад +184

    should have done former FBI agent plays among us or smt

    • @joebush372
      @joebush372 3 года назад +12

      Yeah and then he starts calling people sus

    • @hannibalburgers477
      @hannibalburgers477 3 года назад +4

      There is actually S.W.A.T youtuber who plays Among us. Pretty nice guy actually. Forgot his name tho

    • @matthewtheniceguy1159
      @matthewtheniceguy1159 3 года назад +5

      @@ionela7374 just vote him out

  • @shadytreez
    @shadytreez 3 года назад +2

    He communicated so well...love him!

  • @Vanilla_Neko
    @Vanilla_Neko 2 года назад +2

    I actually have that neck reaction pretty often when I'm dealing with a situation that's stressful or uncomfortable I usually end up reaching up and placing my right hand like halfway on the side of my neck and halfway kind of wrapped around the front gently
    I'm so glad to hear that this is just a normal sort of reaction and not some weird tick

  • @timothywilson3785
    @timothywilson3785 3 года назад +15

    I thought this was going to be more practical examples, but I learned a lot.

  • @traveljunkie1324
    @traveljunkie1324 3 года назад +6

    Utterly enthralling-I could listen to this stuff all day! 😍

  • @bitflip8191
    @bitflip8191 3 года назад

    Absolutely fascinating! Great content.

  • @jesseling144
    @jesseling144 3 года назад +2

    Thank you for this valuable lesson.

  • @stephenryan8492
    @stephenryan8492 3 года назад +8

    Who else is watching this and feels like all your senses are super heightened? I’m like looking around the room all quickly like “yeah my orientation reflex is strong 💪”

  • @marlencitaflores
    @marlencitaflores 3 года назад

    This information is unvaluable.
    Thank you to the investigator

  • @misse7154
    @misse7154 3 года назад +29

    This is really interesting. But just as much as this is nature, the limbic system can be conditioned. For example survivors of trauma can get stuck in a state of freeze.

    • @marinalechner556
      @marinalechner556 3 года назад +6

      Wouldn't you call that a manipulation instead of conditioning? English is not my first language so I might be wrong but wouldn't conditioning be training done with a goal in mind? I don't think when experiencing a trauma people do that to train their brains

    • @user-lr6eq5fj8v
      @user-lr6eq5fj8v 2 года назад

      @@marinalechner556 what is your first languagev

    • @briseboy
      @briseboy Год назад +2

      @@marinalechner556 Conditioning is EXACTLY a manipulation. Training has some goal, and is never random activity. One can train one's brain to dissociate, or to become more effective and attentive. Dissociation is to enormously reduce attention to sensory reality.

    • @maryatkinson2006
      @maryatkinson2006 Год назад +1

      @@marinalechner556 Manipulating in English tends to have a pejorative nuance to its meaning, when applied to living creatures. We don't manipulate ourselves, in English, because of this. People tend to consider manipulation an external force, either used on us or used by us upon someone else, but not in a good way for the recipient's benefit. Think Miss E is using 'conditioned' in the passive, so the human being is not conditioning themselves but becoming conditioned by some habitual or frequent danger or by a danger so threatening that even one experience can trigger off the same freeze, for example, at the slightest hint of a possible similar threat recurring: it is not voluntary, it is not conscious or deliberate. That is a conditioned reaction that usually involves a trauma which convinced the person that his or her life might end at any minute and is a memory so strong that it is not recognised by the conscious mind. In short, terror.

  • @gretchenbaker7435
    @gretchenbaker7435 2 года назад +3

    The amount and variety of what he needed to study blows my mind!

  • @lnc-to4ku
    @lnc-to4ku 2 года назад

    This was incredibly fascinating!
    This guy is so brilliant!

  • @sweetangel199219
    @sweetangel199219 3 года назад +2

    And bears oh my. I couldn't help it 🤣🤣🤣

  • @clascaulfieldjr3653
    @clascaulfieldjr3653 3 года назад +2

    How interesting. I learned about the rooting and moro reflexes long ago in developmental psychology but was never told why we do that.

  • @matchdust7049
    @matchdust7049 2 года назад +3

    First time I went wild camping alone a Cougar sniffed my neck through my tent (Ionosphere snugpak) and I froze for like 20 mins. Scary af and I wondered why I felt paralysed when I wanted to try to scare it away. Very interesting video.

  • @tanawilliams7498
    @tanawilliams7498 3 года назад +8

    I have PTSD. I always look around at any difference in pattern or movements. It is a reflective response due to what gave me PTSD

    • @chellefell1331
      @chellefell1331 2 года назад +4

      Same! I have cptsd, and my senses go off chart all the time... it's very tiring. I wish sometimes I could turn off my hypervigilance.... I don't know how to explain it, but is really is absolutely exhausting....

    • @marcmenard9121
      @marcmenard9121 Год назад

      @@chellefell1331 Breathe. 😃

  • @FingeringThings
    @FingeringThings 3 года назад +50

    Former FBI agent spies on my FBI egent

  • @Coffee_Is_Magic
    @Coffee_Is_Magic 3 года назад +1

    Saw this guy again whilst scrolling and was like 🙌🤩 I have to watch this ASAP

  • @nexusSix_237
    @nexusSix_237 3 года назад

    Love this content!!

  • @lorry2763
    @lorry2763 2 года назад

    Absolutely fascinating!

  • @corycourtney8923
    @corycourtney8923 3 года назад +8

    I have watch everything that has Joe's name on it. His books are also fantastic.

  • @chadsknnr
    @chadsknnr 3 года назад +3

    4:30 I have heard a different theory; newborns and infants spent 9 months crammed into a small, warm space, so when they reach out, they are expecting to feel the comforting confinement of the uteral walls. They wake-up when they reach out, and feel nothing but air, it startles them. I imagine that most normal functioning people out grow that reflex by about 2 years old . . . .

    • @notyouraccount7497
      @notyouraccount7497 Год назад

      That makes so much more sense than the evolution theory.

  • @lxstyexr349
    @lxstyexr349 3 года назад +11

    i think this guy is sitting there wondering
    "am i really teaching 40 thousand people on youtube how to read body language in 10 mins, yet it took me years for it?"

  • @AdamBechtol
    @AdamBechtol 2 года назад

    I can see how these are so popular, such interesting stuff.
    (And I'd been curious about that suprasternal notch bit at the end once I came across this guy, nice)

  • @cadothree
    @cadothree 3 года назад

    these videos have made me analyse everyone i talk to

  • @dominicalarissa7269
    @dominicalarissa7269 2 года назад

    I love this man!! So fascinating!!

  • @TouchTheStars
    @TouchTheStars Год назад

    Eyyyyyyy Madison Wisconsin wooooo!
    That seriously took my by surprise lol, did not expect to hear my hometown

  • @a.mcwhorter8573
    @a.mcwhorter8573 3 года назад +9

    I really like Joe. His video on the election candidates made me look at both of them completely different as I spotted a lot of the behaviors he talked about. It was really interesting.

  • @snittykitty1
    @snittykitty1 3 года назад +2

    I love this guy, body language is fascinating.

  • @rebelliarosetm2008
    @rebelliarosetm2008 2 года назад +1

    Also, I noticed the DSM-V on your shelf. Is there any correlation between your insights and experience into body language reading and the determination of mental health issues? Thank you in advance.

  • @CSAccetura
    @CSAccetura 2 года назад

    These videos are so helpful for those of us that use it in nefariously

  • @joecarter5018
    @joecarter5018 3 года назад +2

    Thanks super interesting!

  • @piercedsiren
    @piercedsiren 3 года назад +9

    Obviously i prefer light to obscurity.
    I'd rather take a longer road that i can see at night rather than a dark alley.

  • @simonbd5373
    @simonbd5373 3 года назад +5

    Read his book, it’s brilliant

  • @richcarroll3264
    @richcarroll3264 3 года назад +1

    He’s very knowledgable about neuroscience .💯

  • @anonymousbosch9265
    @anonymousbosch9265 3 года назад

    I’m in Madison, Wi and I had a limbic response when he said it

  • @juniorwichayapol4357
    @juniorwichayapol4357 2 года назад +1

    Thank you Joe Navarro, especially for 3:15-3:50

  • @gracehall5608
    @gracehall5608 3 года назад +2

    0:57 and bears, oh my!

  • @logann8243
    @logann8243 3 года назад +1

    This is mind blowing info. I like this guy.

  • @joyceyt6722
    @joyceyt6722 3 года назад +7

    the way i just wrote my college essay about this topic

  • @Scixxy
    @Scixxy 3 года назад +5

    Hey, I just bought this guy's book!

  • @Rodner14
    @Rodner14 2 года назад +1

    this is my favorite video with this guy

  • @kaitlynrush3484
    @kaitlynrush3484 3 года назад

    Joe Navarro, a legend

  • @jo-cx7pb
    @jo-cx7pb 2 года назад

    Fascinating.

  • @acspirit6842
    @acspirit6842 3 года назад +1

    Doesn't take body language to get a vibe, but very helpful for watching leaders on television. Thanks

  • @wolfe4410
    @wolfe4410 3 года назад +2

    I freeze when my crush sees me and moves on without acknowledging I was ever there

    • @equaius893
      @equaius893 3 года назад

      no no, you gotta run after them

  • @zachbowman3483
    @zachbowman3483 3 года назад +2

    Can you imagine trying to play poker with this guy? 🤣

    • @Arch55567
      @Arch55567 3 года назад

      Why not, if not all in. 😁

  • @Eleora1997Msia
    @Eleora1997Msia 2 года назад

    nice tips
    now i can read body language toward patient in hospital...

  • @XPRT10R
    @XPRT10R 3 года назад +64

    Tigers in Africa??

    • @XPRT10R
      @XPRT10R 3 года назад +3

      @Thot PoliceThen again, probably not. Also: "were", not "was".

    • @XPRT10R
      @XPRT10R 3 года назад

      @Thot Police ... Whatever.

    • @TheTabaK23
      @TheTabaK23 3 года назад

      @Thot Police there weren’t tigers in Africa 2.5 million years ago, better?

  • @zioazalin
    @zioazalin 3 года назад

    more, please.

  • @alirezazadeh
    @alirezazadeh 3 года назад +6

    I’m not sure, when I’m low on gas I just go to the nearest gas station

  • @dawned9947
    @dawned9947 3 года назад +12

    Alternative title:
    Former FBI Agent gives 10min lecture of Biology

  • @acosta829
    @acosta829 3 года назад +2

    As a nurse, I spend a semester on these reflexes

  • @y2kkitten
    @y2kkitten Год назад

    This guy is awesome!

  • @Itsandinicole
    @Itsandinicole Год назад

    This guys needs his own RUclips channel!

  • @JoshKnoxChinnery
    @JoshKnoxChinnery 3 года назад

    The thumb tucking is proof that ninja running is the most optimal form

  • @serenityane
    @serenityane 3 года назад

    I love this dude

  • @pinnedcomment8614
    @pinnedcomment8614 3 года назад +27

    Fun psych fact: Memories can be strong enough to invoke the exact emotions a person felt when the experience originally happened.

  • @ryanchenger5196
    @ryanchenger5196 3 года назад +2

    Could the tucking in of thumbs have something to do with the face that when chimps attack humans, they go for the face and the fingers/hands?
    It might be how we used to fight amongst ourselves or at least how our common ancestors did?

  • @luthiellequeiroz405
    @luthiellequeiroz405 Год назад

    I can't see a Joe's video just once
    thank you

  • @edwardmclaughlin7935
    @edwardmclaughlin7935 2 года назад

    8:09 The infamous Komrad Kamala cackle.

  • @alexiane250
    @alexiane250 2 года назад +4

    the oriental reflex is why you turn to look when someone enters a classroom (lecture hall), even though you instantly can go back to your task. its just a reflex like blinking

  • @AmyCrawford360
    @AmyCrawford360 3 года назад +4

    Casually tells story of his coworker getting his thumb ripped off. Ok. Cool cool.

  • @ihatespam2505
    @ihatespam2505 Год назад

    0:54 - Lions and tigers and dogs! Oh, my!

  • @maryrichardson6029
    @maryrichardson6029 2 года назад

    Thank you

  • @TheLittleSquidge
    @TheLittleSquidge 3 года назад +1

    “Lions, tigers” . . . and bears, oh my!

  • @ModernVince
    @ModernVince 2 года назад

    i love this guy

  • @theman5324
    @theman5324 3 года назад +4

    Why did I think he was going to say his name was Jeff???

  • @elisekathleen6070
    @elisekathleen6070 3 года назад +9

    where was this man when i was trying to learn calculus. i feel like he could explain anything.

  • @frankflaherty5074
    @frankflaherty5074 2 года назад

    When a person is calm, composed, and compassionate, they fold their hands, no threat. No need to demonstrate defense

  • @OtnielSantiago
    @OtnielSantiago 3 года назад

    im buying all his books.

  • @good-questions
    @good-questions 2 года назад +1

    Light doesn’t “represent” visual clarity - it IS visual clarity. It’s more information.