Indira Gandhi's UNFILTERED Story Explained In 11 minutes - Rise & Fall
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 19 июн 2023
- Watch The Full Episode Here: • Jounalist Nitin Gokhal...
Follow Nitin Gokhale's Social Media Handles:-
Instagram - / nitinagokhale
Facebook - / nitin.gokhale
Twitter - / nitingokhale
LinkedIn - / nitin-a-gokhale-56b7b158
Additional Links:-
/ @stratnewsglobal
/ @bharatshakti6583
✅ Subscribe To Our Other RUclips Channels:-
BeerBiceps (English Channel):
/ beerbicepsofficial
Ranveer Allahbadia (Hindi Channel):
/ ranveerallahbadia
TRS Clips हिंदी (Hindi Podcast Highlights):
/ @theranveershowhindi
BeerBiceps Shorts (English Shorts):
/ @bestoftrs
Ranveer Allahbadia Shorts (Hindi Shorts):
/ @bestoftrshindi
RAAAZ. :
/ @raaazofficial
RAAAZ Shorts :
/ @raaazshorts
BigBrain Plus :
/ @bigbrain_plus
In this episode of The Ranveer Show, we have Nitin A. Gokhale, one of South Asia’s leading Strategic Analysts. He has been in the media business for over 40 years as a conflict reporter, Editor, author, and now a media entrepreneur. He is the founder of two most prestigious defense-related websites BharatShakti.in and StratNewsGlobal.com.
In this amazing conversation, Nitin Gokhale puts light on his career as a media reporter and how he has experienced the most disturbing situations in his profession. He dwells on his time as the Kargil War reporter where he faced the most outrageous injuries incurred by the Indian soldiers. He talked about multiple topics such as the Legacy of Indira Gandhi, the history of India, the Indo-China War, the violent phase of the 1990s, the current situation in North East, and much more.
This is the most knowledgeable episode we have recorded and would help many young people learn about India's history. Please feel free to let us know what you think in the Comments. We hope you enjoy this episode.
#nitingokhale #history
--
INSTAGRAM : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
FACEBOOK : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TWITTER : @beerbicepsguy
/ beerbicepsguy
LINKEDIN : @beerbiceps
/ beerbiceps
TELEGRAM: @beerbicepsguy
t.me/beerbicepsguy
SNAPCHAT: @beerbicepsguy
----------------------------------------------
About :
TRS Clips is a collection of SHORT CLIPS from The Ranveer Show podcast. Enjoy our latest knowledge-fueled videos from the BeerBiceps team. Every conversation on #TheRanveerShow is intellectual, deep & progressive. We cover everyone from entrepreneurs to Bollywood film stars to even athletes.
Today, The Ranveer Show or TRS - Happiness Through Curiosity. A show where we host the world's greatest success stories and try digging out their secrets to success. Every conversation is an EXTREME learning experience for the viewer.
Intelligent Pm from the South of India Mr.PV Narasimha Rao paved the way for the modern India.
It was forced decision
@@rakshithnayak1206whatever.. But due credit should go to Narsimharao.. One of the finest PM...
While giving credit to Manmohan Singh, Congress conveniently forgets PV Narsimha Rao, who took the tough decisions at the risk of loosing his PM ship and shown the spine to implement those reforms. None of the previous PMs had shown the spine for the same.
it was bold decisions from all points in the leadership that turned things around.
PM Rao should deserve more appreciation. He is largely ignored when talking about the 1991 economic reforms by the media.
Agreed
Credit should go to Manmohan Singh and Montek Singh for reforms
@@B..._598they are HMV and their names are taken to suppress Rao 's name. In such case, the army generals should be given credit instead of Indira Gandhi for Bangladesh liberation.
@@B..._598Manmohan failed as PM, didn't succeed in a single sector.
Bcz dynasty can't see non-Gandhi-Nehru leader overshadow them
Narasimha Rao is Really a Bharat Ratna. Today's India is Rao's India.
Nationalization of banks was a big achievement of Indira Gandhi
That was suggested by Karunanithi.
Achievement or disaster?
Disaster
This gentleman is highly charitable to Indira and Manmohan. Indira strangulated the economy with license-permit,bank nationalisation and FERA.She didn’t allow new production even while people waited for ten years for two wheeler,telephone,cooking gas etc and cement was available only in black. Banks didn’t lend to common people for home,vehicles,consumer goods,small businesses etc. Income tax marginal rate was 97%.From 1971 Manmohan was Chief Economic Adviser,Finance Secretary,RBI HEAD and Planning Commission Head. License permit related policy is handled by Industry Minister and not Finance Minister. Rao was handling Industry portfolio also. Rao did it but Manmohan got the credit while he was the main architect of such socialist,evil policies in the seventies and eighties.
no one would be interested in hearing the reality, there are many more things that indira did and got away with it.
Still people are voting for Congress(due to Nehru and Indira)
True.
@@Fun_doon where people vote for congress now
Operation blue star...not mentioned
I can’t believe that this host has such a following and great guests!
I am scared of the future.
😊 You are right!
Pm Narsimha Rao ji is one of the best PM's India has had...it is unfortunate this hero of India does not get his due credit. The nehru dynasty has been a true curse to modern India.
Sounds like the story of Daenerys Targaryen 😂
Dany Stan here
Who? @@vincentgogh2389
Hi Ranveer… great content! would love hear about P V Narasimha Rao.
He’s definitely journalist wearing this outfit
0:24 Those to black britishers are Successors of the Britishers.
Britishers gave pass thier power to them and ask them to clean Britishers image though mindwashing and self-desrespecting.😢😢
Thankyoy brother for the all you doing
As a Sri Lankan, I applaud the decision of not opening the economy to West too early. We did in 77 and see the plight.
I live in Sydney because of Both PVN RAO AND MANMOHAN SINGH
Manmohan Singh got the credit for the genius measures of P V Narasimha Rao
Allahabad Court Justice Sinha wrongly debarred Indira Gandhi from the Parliament.
Ya u were present there and so very sure booth capturing never happened.
9:42 By that time Indian businesses were handful of them (eg TATA, Birla) and were not that developed than foreign businesses. If we had opened up the economy Indian businesses would have faced massive losses due to people's aspiration for foreign products . All the money would had gone outside India.
Basically, the decision was took to protect Indian businesses.
Just slightly other perspective rather than blaming "socialistic" way of thinking of .......so & so
I tend to agree. Pakistan has always had an open economy and it is intirely import based. Even the car plants that were set up in 90s with the specific purpose of localisation stil to date only act as assemblers with all parts being imported. So I guess it was the right decision to open the Indian economy later. We are paying the price here today.Wish we had a Finance Minister like Manmo Han Singh and a Prime Minister Nasima Roa who can take tough decisions on the economy desipite knowning that it will lead to his loss in the next elections.
More businesses set up after foreign investments and set ups of big MNCs our people learned and built big companies and MNCs after LPG reform.
India's iron lady:
India ll not forget important achievements of Indira Gandhi while also criticizing her;
1. Green Revolution: Indira Gandhi's government spearheaded the Green Revolution, transforming India from a food-deficit nation to self-sufficiency in food production through technological advancements in agriculture.
2. Liberation of Bangladesh: Under her leadership, India played a crucial role in supporting the independence movement of Bangladesh, leading to its liberation from Pakistan in 1971.
3. Nationalization of Banks: Indira Gandhi nationalized major banks in India in 1969, aiming to expand banking services to rural areas and promote economic growth by increasing access to credit.
Jai hind.
Yes and also the Sikh genocide of 1984
Nationalization of banks ? Konsa achievement hai ye ?
@@Vanillevirus That was caused by huge Outrage from Indira's Radical Fans after her Death.
@@sudu916 Then Banks were mostly available in Urban Areas and Less than 3% Loans are given to Farmers. The money generated by Banks is going Capitalists and Politicians in the form of Funds. So many Banks are running is closed and so many have already been closed so People have insecurity feeling about their money in Private Banks. Nationalization of Banks is Master Stroke .
1. It made Loans available to the Poor and the Farmers.
2. Banks Revenue is used for Social Welfare.
3. Increase of Banks in Rural Areas.
It also helped Indira gain trust of the People and Crush her Opponents.
Genocide of sadhus who followed Karpatri Maharaj in the procession, who waited for her to take the decision that she promised and went back on her word. Many were put in jail. Even Rajnath Singh was jailed and was refused bail to attend to his mother's last rites
India and Sikh community is still paying for it ... 40 years later! Well said, Ranveer 🙏👏🌸💜
Not India, just Sikhs
What Sikhs are paying for?
SG died in 1980 and not 82
Would love to see Ranveer have the cojones to talk about Narendra Modi and Georgia Meloni in the same light that he just referred to Jawaharlal Nehru and Lady Mountbatten.
Sanjay Gandhi passed away in 1980, not 1982.
Regardless. He was ultra useless & a very dangerous & entitled.
Indira used Gandhi as sir name instead of feroze.
Instead of Gandy . His name was Feroze Gandy , a Parsi from Bombay. The family conveniently changed their surname to Gandhi to appease the masses.
@@nidhisubbaiah1688 Indira had many affairs as well, you can check yourself. PM with lust, Jaisa Baap, waisi Beti.
@@filegotfilesearchengine9877Tera baap bhi bhot affairs pe tha news mein aya
Firoze is a surname??
There's no evidence to it. Secondly someone's personal matter is not your Busines. @@filegotfilesearchengine9877
Indira Gandhi has not been portrayed properly in this talk.
Nice sir 🔥🔥💪
Answers from Nitin ji were amazing as usual…
But the questions asked by the host shows lack of preparation… like booth capturing term is known to lots of youngsters but hosts reactions were of surprise… which is odd.
Good part about the show is they bring a very diverse set of guests to the podcast which is a difficult thing… amazing work there.. kudos to the team..
Why congress loyal followers never talk about Sanjay Gandhi
Bank nationalisation was the most important work she did.
I was reading Life of Pi and wanted to inform myself about mrs Ghandi, I thought she was his wife or sth. Thanks for the info, really interesting!:)
2:50 lady Mountbatten 😅
Indira Gandhi did a interview in America(60 minutes?) which points to America's CIA involvement in the Sikh riots. Please look it up and play it in schools in Punjab so they start thinking beyond their limited understanding. The reason India has so much problems is lack of communication. ALL Indians should be taught how geopolitics works. India is a global country and needs to think globally, everyone not just the politicians. Indian have to be taught to use their spare time to improve themselves through knowledge. India needs beautiful libraries so learning, reading is fun. Young children can learn to play chess with the computer, sudoku, etc. even old people can learn skills to improve their problem solving abilities, skills to improve the other side of your brain. It would cost India nothing, since everyone has a cell, education apps can be free. Ranveer you have grown into yourself and make things interesting, fun and in your own young uncorrupted mind make people to question. There is another young person on "think school" who also makes you think, his podcast should also be played in the schools. Indians love knowledge so throw everything intelligent at them from within India and global knowledge from the four corners of this planet so they can have the intellect to dissect it. Know the truth from lies, propaganda. Get rid of drugs in India that is the new weapon of war. The Italian Mafia(Vatican included) has teamed up with the Nigerian Mafia to sell drugs and prostitution to the world. The Wahabi Muslim movement is a terrorist evil and should be banned in India. Even in Saudi Arabia they are considered evil extremist? It is like ISIS, Taliban, traitors Pakistan should have known better, lack of education, uneducated inflated ego causing a lack of reality check has made Pakistan broke.
Its easy to have a take on someone after that person leaves, depends how one is pictured so to totally paint a one sided is not correct reporting. 30 years later some one else might be greyed
Fact check:- 6:52 Sanjay Gandhi died in 1980 and not 1982.
After watching this episode, love and respect towards Modi just increases more as the very first thing he did after being prime minister is giving each and every citizen low cost internet for self study at remote places
Think of computers first.
No room for correct historical facts in a head filled with dung! 😄
The purpose of his political podcasts are to put modi in a positive light somehow. It took a while for me to realise this.
Yeh home arrest king of sikkim at his own palace with all the power and army she had and had him sign the merger into india. Though m glad we became indian state but tht phase of assistant is haunting. Wonder we could become peaceful nation like Bhutan if not merged 😢
No , China tension was main problem you wouldn't withstand and why a new country no need as Shikkim was part of India with monarchy rule , the king started calling himself king of independent so then with a democratic party in Sikkim help the king was house arrested with public support in Indian favour all thanks to RA&W and Sikkim democratic party.
There was Rise, Fall and Rise of Indira Gandhi.
Essentially she underwent a mad queen arc
Is this person competent to judge. This is like reporting all instances before you became a journalist.
We were very young in 84 , when this happened but one question has always bothered me , Sikhs always Blame the Then PM for attacking the Golden Temple... but I've never heard anyone ever ask how did so many weapons and bombs enter The Gurudwara... what were Bhindranwale and Gen Shahbeg Singh doing inside and why Bhindranwales Taking over the Akal Takht not outrage the Sikhs?
There were enough weapons inside to hold the Indian Army for 2 days.. why are the Sikhs not offended by this and what would they expect a government to do ? Did they not know and realise that such weapons couldn't have come in Without the help of Pakistan ? My question being that the Sikh community was offended by the Indian Army entering but were they not offended and hurt by what Bhindranwale and gang were doing inside their holy place in complete conduit of Pakistan in an attempt to break India ? I would really like to know this x..
Good question.
Bhindranwale was getting support from CIA. Indira wanted to kick out all the usa elitemen connections from India. Usa wanted to overthrow Indira at any cost.
Excellent question 👏
Operation Bluestar was executed on a the day of Sikh Festival. So many common innocent Sikhs who were visiting the Golden twmple from all over the country/world were killed during this Operation. So the outrage among Sikhs is quite justified
Gave up 90k pow to Pakistan in 71
Do invite Maneka Gandhi and if possible Sonia Gandhi to podcast
Broadly ok few facts are wrong. Example Allahabad high court verdict is not on booth capturing. But for using official govt clerk and rs 500 of Govt funds for party meetings sound system. It is better to do follow up with some senior leader like arun Shourie or Subramanian swamy on this topic
Not opening economy in 1971 or 1973
Cold war was there
Nationalisation of banks HELPED A LOT. The political game...I tell you, China 🇨🇳 implemented a lot of socialist policies ON A LARGE SCALE and now they are about to surpass USA. Because of those socialist policies, even in the times of Indira Gandhi, they were ahead of India in many ways. Now, we stand competing with Bangladesh 🇧🇩 whose per capita gdp is higher than us... the country we helped free
Lmao, china is not a full socialist state. They are capitalist with high government regulation.
Mitrokhin archives says very funny things about indira gandhi and india. Have you made a video on this subject?
Create this kind of podcast critical of BJP and you know what will happen to you and your company. And its something even you know.
Nehru Lighted a cigarette of Mountbatten? Was it not the reverse. HA HA HA!
He was " Fair" point to be noted. No matter where you reach you still equate fairness with handsome or beautiful..sad
Ur content never disappoint!
Why did then congress stalwarts choose to be adviser to a novice n not select a good leader from party. Was primeminister ship inheritance property ? Even if you don't know anything about it. This family is ruling India like monarchs under the garb of democracy
Didn’t the economy open on 1991?
He has the indecency of calling a Massive GENOCIDE as simple riots !!! And praising the person who commited it !!! 😱 😳
❤
Thats what modi do in manipur sending army to tackle their own people ..
8:44 overwhelmed by the wrong judgement? WTF she was a slayer..
9:39 Man , I think it's 1991 not 93 !
How can Soviet Union pressurize India to maintain Socialism?
Please give credit to actual hero Mr. Rao and not Manmohan who was pappu when he himself was a PM
Mr Rao gives political backing to Manmohan Singh, from Suriname
Why did she not have the integrity of not accepting Dynastic nepotistic false Entitlement...
Hi Ranveer,
I like your show and admire what you have achieved at such a young age. I like your width of subjects and choice of guests.
I feel that as a much liked and viewed TV presenter, eapecially with the younger generation, who are trying to come to terms with this country's history and politics, its your responsibility to ensure that enough research is done to understand and then discuss and present correctly any subject.
Leaders of the time gone by cannot come and share their circumstances and reasons for the decisions they took. It's up to us to find out and present with intergity thier lives, circumstances and decisions and the impact it had on the Nation and people.
I feel in this episode on Indira Gandhi, so much was left out.
This episode seemed to potray that crucial time period (nearly 20 yrs) and her role in it rather inadequately. And as a result make the episode lighter rather than with some gravitas, unlike some of your other episodes.
Look forward to other exciting episodes.
You mean they were trying to whitewash or make her appear less or more evil?
I agree. I have not seen any leader like Indira Gandhi. She was a seasoned politician.
A lot of political clips for TRS are coming back in my feed. Is it just me?
The most ignored, insulted, humiliated PM of India, by his own Party was P V Narasimha Rao. He provided the political backing & will for the economic reforms which saved India from financial disaster. Manmohan Singh was the technocrat MoF who provided the expertise.
Greatest PM regarding defense of India. ISRO, Pokhran, 1971 war and so many other things. All these people are only focused on trivia.
Correct. These 2 rupee jokers talking about Indira Gandhi ji😂
I don't think you watched the video, just came with 2 rupees from IT cell to comment here. Watch again, they talk about both good and bad. Also he was kind not to talk about much bad things of Indira and how she strangulated our country
Sanjay Gandhi was ambitious, wish he lived much more
He slapped his mother publicly.
Invite our S.L Bhairappa to know more about then political situations..
Beerbiceps : Nehru had a Swag ! WTF… idolizing a crook
May be he meant a ladies man
Clearly a lighthearted joke...not "idolizing"
In serious conversations like this, it may be a good idea not be an idiot periodically with your quips.
TRS is now TRSS
C, nobody in this whole world cannot b second Indira Gandhi at any cost,
dude call sadhguru or go to his ashram, zara spirituality missing hori hai
Trs I like ur show, hope u wont become godi.......👍
This session hasn't gone in depth like your other podcast...
The kavla says shades of grey but in this discourse which tries to mock play being neutral and unbiased - there is no shade of white for the Truth that is supposedly grey all together
What Mr Nitin . Ex honorable pm Indira Gandhi was iron lady and she taired two parts of Pakistan , you all bjp won't respect women
Lucky we have EVMs and congress is out.
Sanjay Gandhi was making sure that Muslim population doesn't rise exponentially. Sad that he died early & we have the mess that is today.
Why wouldn't he want that? Wasn't he half Muslim?
@@Inkulabi Nah was probably Parsi
@@dannydonnybrook7173 ohhhh that would make sense
@@dannydonnybrook7173 he was Muslim, Nehru spread the rumour that he’s Parsi
Entire Congress has only done bad things for India
We know more than this speaker😂...He is diplomatically skirting around core issue.
Raveer is becoming a Chamcha ,
First comment❤❤❤
What about Operation Blue Star !!! You respected, highly insensitive Sir 😒 😏?????
Lighting a cigarette for a last standing beside you was what a man did for a woman in western cultures. Laughing with a western independent woman of international stature doesn't mean anything more than a relationship of mutual appreciation
Bro I am looking for a job I am willing to praise bjp and bash congress can you refer me please
😂
you people have family business of bomb.go create for next ram navmi
Looks like somebody is butthurt, go apply some burnol
For that don't have to praise and bash anyone. You just need to have to the qualifications for the job you looking for!!!
Looking for a job, you must have started with with the EVM manipulation scandal.
First like ❤
I don’t look upon her with respect. She was a wild woman who was so afraid of defeat so many crimes washed underground because of her. With the corruption and corruption she did a lot. And see her daughter I. Law. And grandchildren vendetta was her another name
Uff man if sanjay would get chance ever...
What kind of india would have formerd
Capitalist mindset.. Right wing on the same side.. His religion lovers and anti-muslim too
He's just a right winger with half knowledge n lies ..more like a what's app University graduate
Why do people still call it 1984 Riots when it was a genocide? A discussion on this would interesting with the right host. Sikhs were specifically targeted and murdered. Those who led the attack never put on trial but promoted to higher seats in the Indian government. Similar to Nazi Germany. So no action against those that belonged to the Hindu community for committing these atrocities but no problem sending the army to and destroying Darbar Sahib and imposing presidents rule in the only Sikh majority state. What bothers Sikhs most is how many Hindus say just forget and move on. The Jewish community has not forgotten about their Holocaust so why should Sikhs forget their genocide? It's so easy for people to say "Khalistani terrorist" but people still like to use the word "riots" to describe this. Interesting to also know how this is being taught in schools from a historical perspective. No person no matter how big or important they may be should justify mass murder, rape, destruction of places of worship, and theft.
Riot - a violent disturbance of the peace by a crowd.
Genocide - the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group.
Nehru wanted to make the nation into a communist state still the great grandson is pursuing the same policy
She was dictatorial in sence where she promoted family dynastic rule, and that is no no for india. Indira used old british tactics of devide and rule between hindus and Muslims and gave higher preference to Muslim and Muslim appeasement.
She typically spoiled Muslim and made them begging bowl on india just like pakistan is today. Glad congress is gone now. Still, they can not get out of gandhi/nehru grip.
Why do you want to degrade people who are dead. They cannot defend themselves. At present in political scenario they are so many problems. I think my state Andhra Pradesh will disappear from map if present condition continues. Centre and prime minister are not aware of condition in southern states. Why don't you interview about present condition and problems of different states than show past.
If our family is not doing well, first we have to question head of the family than the area councillor. If state is not doing well then ask the CM not PM
Our country is so diverse and consensus among its all populace is non-existent. Every leader, be it past or present is open to criticism. Every intelligent civilization learns from its past, and criticism is best ways
Why do you want to control people by silencing their opinions on past leaders?
Past is over. We came way a head. Indira Gandhi was our prime minister. You criticize someone so they change. She is not here. Respect people. No one is completely right. Try to better your present.
When people beg for votes on her namesake then there is no wron in criticism, she is still responsible for the one and only emergency after 1947
Where was Congress when she was paraded in Canada, not a word.
The new dalaal Anchor❤ Godi Anchor 👍
Ranveer, your expressions are so amusing!!! 😅😅😅
Your videos appear to be like for School students. Kids
For him Modiji is super white
Ahh the irony
How many know sanjay gandhi and rajiv gandhi fathers are different?, but same mother...
Don't write rubbish 🤦♀️
@@anuradhaare1787 I did research on that madam ,,plz don't spread ur gulami thoughts...
@@anuradhaare1787kya pata hai tumko iss Antonio maino maharani rajmata ke family ke baarein main
Even if it were to be true, how is that your business?
Please read history books and other relevant reference books. Podcast is not a medium to learn history.
He's now a bjp influencer...propoganda machinery
yes got it
This guy is chatting nonsense. Stick to defence