Watching this video again, it seems the Lane assist switches off, when there aren't two white lines for it to drive inbetween. That makes sense, as the system it uses is camera-based and needs those hi definition cues to work properly. I think it is more designed for use on large carriageways; motorways and dual carriageways. I personally wouldn't use Lane keep assist in an urban environment, where cars could pull out in front of you, from side streets etc. It is certainly an incredible system and is certainly a stepping-stone to full autonomy. I have ordered my Nissan Tekna Plus.
Thanks for this test! Thanks for this test! Japanese designers have a problem with Europe. They have wide roads everywhere, even in cities. Therefore, their systems are designed according to their conditions and, as other reviewers have noted, the assistant system is disabled in narrow lanes. It works as it should on the main intercity and high-speed roads, but it is worse in cities, because the system was not created for that. Eropean manufacturers know what cities in Europe look like and therefore these systems are also good on narrow roads. This has been explained to the Japanese for years, but they are stubborn. However, as I wrote, the systems are good for extra-urban driving. I watched German tests about it.
I can see this system being abused. It is only a driver aid and not to be used as a fully autonomous system. I have seen a post where someone hung a lightweight item on the steering wheel; which fooled the car into thinking someone was holding the steering wheel. In the video, he drove miles without holding onto the steering wheel. Perhaps the car new what it was doing, but if someone had pulled out in front of him, or if the system switched itself off, like it did several times in your video; there could be a major problem. If anyone needs a system to keep them in lane; perhaps they shouldn't be driving. Just saying.
i agree i think the pro pilot is just a ridiculous extra and not needed, my qashqai dose not have it and i am pleased, it does have the intelligent cruise control which is really handy as it saved you having to keep adjusting the cruise control, but as for pro pilot i think its just stupid and needless.
Yep your right. We just picked up the new xtrail and they explicitly say in the walk through do not expect this to be a self driving car. It’s called assist for a reason. Pretty cool to see where the future will go but this isn’t close to self driving.
From my experience, the Lane Keeping Assist (steering) only kicks in less than half of the time and when it does, not immediately, and then any slight changes in the lane markings will disengage. Quite useless if it is so intermittent in usage.
A trick I have learned is to put a pouch with about a pound of rocks on the steering wheel to avoid the 10-second Hands-On steering wheel notification. Works real well and I drove from Texas to New Mexico without touching the steering wheel once
Tried on the new xtrail today. It was pretty sloppy on a very mildly curving road at 67km/h. Almost took us over double lines . Will probably turn it off but a good function to have during highway driving just in case with all the assists and built in warning. Definitely not close to a self driving car and should never take your hands off the steering wheel with pro pilot
@@piotrk1722 yes, same thing in his new toyota highlander from what i've seen. Maybe they can upgrade like Tesla does ? I hope so. Nissan has been really improving since Renault breakup
@@piotrk1722 yeah... this is scary, I don't understand what happened here. It clearly detected vehicle in front but didn't want to slow down. I understand that this ProPilot thing is only assistance, but this situation was so obvious...
Hello, among the hatchback cars you've tested, which hatchback cars have the best security assistants and advanced driver assistance systems? Can you do a ranking?
Jak mogłeś zobaczyć na filmie: sam podjeżdża jeśli zatrzymanie nie jest dłuższe niż kilka sekund. Później trzeba dotknąc pedał gazu bądź użyć przycisk "resume"
@@1001carsI’ve used RAV4 Hybrid and it keeps lane and steering wheel on my drive by city. But it doesn’t have a cruise control. So seems it’s activated always on some cars. I’m a bit surprised that on Nissan it turns off when it wants, that lowered down my expectations. I hoped it’s packed with a lot of useful assistants. But now looks like they don’t work as expected. A bit scary to allow it to keep line on the highway. Or you felt pretty confident on highway with this adaptive cruise control? Thank you for the video. Really helpful. But I didn’t understand many situations as it was unclear if it breaks automatically before the front car, or you used a pedal. And the same when cars in the front moving - have you pushed a pedal
@@1001cars yes, true ;-) But better to say or describe in the future such cases to highlight where car stopped itself and started move after a stop. It will make easier to understand what is happening. Anyway you did great job. Thank you 🙏
@@1001cars Do you mean Nissan ProPilot is better than Hyundai High Way Driving Assist? You channel is so good. You will be successful soon. I'm from Taiwan. If you can add Chinese #tag it will help your channel a lot.
Watching this video again, it seems the Lane assist switches off, when there aren't two white lines for it to drive inbetween. That makes sense, as the system it uses is camera-based and needs those hi definition cues to work properly. I think it is more designed for use on large carriageways; motorways and dual carriageways. I personally wouldn't use Lane keep assist in an urban environment, where cars could pull out in front of you, from side streets etc. It is certainly an incredible system and is certainly a stepping-stone to full autonomy. I have ordered my Nissan Tekna Plus.
Thanks for this test!
Thanks for this test!
Japanese designers have a problem with Europe. They have wide roads everywhere, even in cities. Therefore, their systems are designed according to their conditions and, as other reviewers have noted, the assistant system is disabled in narrow lanes. It works as it should on the main intercity and high-speed roads, but it is worse in cities, because the system was not created for that. Eropean manufacturers know what cities in Europe look like and therefore these systems are also good on narrow roads. This has been explained to the Japanese for years, but they are stubborn.
However, as I wrote, the systems are good for extra-urban driving. I watched German tests about it.
The Nissan Qashqai was designed, developed and built in the UK. Perhaps the autonomous driving system was designed in Japan though.
I can see this system being abused. It is only a driver aid and not to be used as a fully autonomous system. I have seen a post where someone hung a lightweight item on the steering wheel; which fooled the car into thinking someone was holding the steering wheel. In the video, he drove miles without holding onto the steering wheel. Perhaps the car new what it was doing, but if someone had pulled out in front of him, or if the system switched itself off, like it did several times in your video; there could be a major problem. If anyone needs a system to keep them in lane; perhaps they shouldn't be driving. Just saying.
i agree i think the pro pilot is just a ridiculous extra and not needed, my qashqai dose not have it and i am pleased, it does have the intelligent cruise control which is really handy as it saved you having to keep adjusting the cruise control, but as for pro pilot i think its just stupid and needless.
I personally would not use a drone in an urban environment
That is a fair comment.
Yep your right. We just picked up the new xtrail and they explicitly say in the walk through do not expect this to be a self driving car. It’s called assist for a reason.
Pretty cool to see where the future will go but this isn’t close to self driving.
hi again,the steering assist can be activated at speeds over 60km/h
That hard braking coming up to the first traffic light was kinda scary, it really didn’t recognise the stopped cars from far enough
From my experience, the Lane Keeping Assist (steering) only kicks in less than half of the time and when it does, not immediately, and then any slight changes in the lane markings will disengage. Quite useless if it is so intermittent in usage.
A trick I have learned is to put a pouch with about a pound of rocks on the steering wheel to avoid the 10-second Hands-On steering wheel notification. Works real well and I drove from Texas to New Mexico without touching the steering wheel once
Thanks! So do you recommend it? Thanks a lot!
Tried on the new xtrail today. It was pretty sloppy on a very mildly curving road at 67km/h. Almost took us over double lines . Will probably turn it off but a good function to have during highway driving just in case with all the assists and built in warning.
Definitely not close to a self driving car and should never take your hands off the steering wheel with pro pilot
Looks like a pretty good system 👍
I'm not sure to be honest. 9:45 definitely shows this is far from good system
@@piotrk1722 yes, same thing in his new toyota highlander from what i've seen. Maybe they can upgrade like Tesla does ? I hope so. Nissan has been really improving since Renault breakup
@@piotrk1722 yeah... this is scary, I don't understand what happened here. It clearly detected vehicle in front but didn't want to slow down. I understand that this ProPilot thing is only assistance, but this situation was so obvious...
Hello, among the hatchback cars you've tested, which hatchback cars have the best security assistants and advanced driver assistance systems? Can you do a ranking?
Mercedes A Class and Golf/Audi A3
@@1001cars Thank you first. Include standard or with optional? (My English is bad, sorry.)
Optional equipment
@@1001cars Thank you.
Czy w opcji "asystent jazdy w korkach" on sam podjeżdża czy trzeba np. dotknąć gazu żeby ruszył za samochodem przed Tobą który stał a podjechał?
Jak mogłeś zobaczyć na filmie: sam podjeżdża jeśli zatrzymanie nie jest dłuższe niż kilka sekund. Później trzeba dotknąc pedał gazu bądź użyć przycisk "resume"
Dzięki. Właśnie nie widziałem czy aktywujesz to pedałem gazu.
At 09:50 it didn't brake or was it planned to switch a lane?
The car's ACC did not recognise the car in front, so I decided to change the lane. So it is car's error.
Is this on JUKE Hybird too or not ?
No, Juke has different system
Hi Can you set lane assist always on without cruise control
No, you cannot. Most cars do not allow to use lane keeping assist without ACC right now.
@@1001carsI’ve used RAV4 Hybrid and it keeps lane and steering wheel on my drive by city. But it doesn’t have a cruise control. So seems it’s activated always on some cars.
I’m a bit surprised that on Nissan it turns off when it wants, that lowered down my expectations. I hoped it’s packed with a lot of useful assistants. But now looks like they don’t work as expected. A bit scary to allow it to keep line on the highway. Or you felt pretty confident on highway with this adaptive cruise control?
Thank you for the video. Really helpful. But I didn’t understand many situations as it was unclear if it breaks automatically before the front car, or you used a pedal. And the same when cars in the front moving - have you pushed a pedal
@@AntonDanilchenkoIt is easy to recognise: if the ACC is active I did not use the brake pedal :)
@@1001cars yes, true ;-) But better to say or describe in the future such cases to highlight where car stopped itself and started move after a stop. It will make easier to understand what is happening.
Anyway you did great job. Thank you 🙏
Dzięki za film. :) A jakie jest twoje zdanie na temat tego systemu? Jakbyś go ocenił?
Thanks, witch lane assist is better between Tucson and Qashquai ?
Are you asking about Lane Assist or Lane keeping assist? If the second one: Tucson.
@@1001cars Do you mean Nissan ProPilot is better than Hyundai High Way Driving Assist? You channel is so good. You will be successful soon. I'm from Taiwan. If you can add Chinese #tag it will help your channel a lot.
Lane assists only works above 60km/h.
As you can see, lane keeping assist works also below 60 km/h :)
very bad system