“Do Women Have Penises?” Julia Hartley-Brewer Clashes With Labour Shadow Minister
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 18 сен 2024
- TalkTV’s Julia Hartley-Brewer has clashed with Shadow International Trade Secretary Nick Thomas-Symonds over whether a woman can have a penis.
It comes after protesters stormed a talk with feminist Kathleen Stock at the Oxford Union before one of them glued themselves to the floor.
Julia fumes: “Why won’t you answer my question?”
Nick replies: “If you go through the process of the Gender Recognition Act, you would become a woman.”
#talktv #talkradio
It's embarrassing how frightened politicians are of an aggressively vocal minority.
It's the mainstream media who jump on these things. They force the cancel culture purely for ratings
Well we've all seen how violent they get.
@@catwoman7462 The new Kymer Rouge
you mean like the people that try to burn down shelters for asylum seekers, that aggressively vocal minority?
@@zoltan-zq3xe 👍"This is the Year Zero, and nothing has gone before".
You can summarise his entire response in just a few words: 'Don't ask me this, I'm too scared to speak the truth'.
Why do you care though? Aren't there more important issues?
@@aaronaaronson7600 Because so many 'news' companies won't stop going on about this pointless issue, we would very much like to resolve it and get on with the more important matter of rebuilding the country and healing the wounds these idiotic politicians have inflicted on our country and society.
@@aaronaaronson7600 @Aaron Aaronson Do you mean issues like male rapists in women's prisons? Men in Women's sports? Or how about the mutilation of children, cutting of their genitals and cutting off the breats of young teenagers and leaving them sterile and life time dependants on hormone medication. And there worse.
Indeed. What could be more important than the truth. They can change the language all they like but they cannot change material reality and those depraved murdering butchers, yes they have murdered a man with their frankenstine surgery, cannot turn men into women or women into men.
@@aaronaaronson7600 : You obviously care though, every single time this topic arises, your weird little mug pops up, and you’re asking why anyone should care! 🤦🏻♂️🤡
@@aaronaaronson7600 Aaron... is that a man's name. Yeah, you'll never understand. Keep watching porn flix.
This is my local MP... what an embarrassment. You cannot be a woman when you was born a man or vice versa... its biology 101!
When you were born...
Let's hope you get a POW candidate in your area in the next election so you can boot him out.
You have my deepest sympathy.
@@bengleiss9416 doesnt matter - in the entire history of human life, no man has ever given birth - because no man is a woman... basic nature my friend... get over it.. :)
Don't mock the afflicted, he's had a logic bypass.
No one should vote for a political party that doesn't know what a woman is
To be fair it's an unknowable question/answer in 2023?
@@Neil-Aspinall How do you work that one out... If individuals can't tell the difference between a male and female, then there is something very wrong with the society we live in.
@@nigelbevan8449 I agree whole heartedly Nig.
@@Neil-Aspinall only to people who go along with this madness.
Everyone knows, it's just that they're terrified to say.
He thinks voters won't notice that they want to eradicate women's sex based rights.
"Trans Community" - what a load of baloney! The amount of "communities" in the UK these days is both mind boggling and, more importantly, a nonsensical lie.
"Community" is obviously a word most beloved by communists everywhere
I so agree. There is a never ending succession of celebrations for various communities. I’m gay but I would never go to what used to be known as Gay Pride - but is nowadays known as a string of ridiculous letters - LGBTQI+ Pride. I am nobody’s victim and don’t need self-appointed left wing agitators “representing my interests” as a jumble of irreconcilable letters. 🤣😂.
wait till 2050 when white people are the minority...thinking the trans and the religion of peace will lead to some great live reality tv
sick to death of hearing about them.
You be careful talking common sense ,
How can ANYONE VOTE for ANY party that CANNOT explain what is a women …..it is ridiculous……
Please confirm what a woman is?
You'd be surprised what people are capable of.
@@bengleiss9416A biologically female human without a penis.
@@megaxenu753 You explain to us less educated then yourself oh wise one
@@robertsmith9810 Twat …. Women do NOT have a dick ….. DICKHEAD ….
Absolutely shocking..he can't be honest..how can you trust people who can't speak the truth
@@laurenceBDontYaNo
Explain the issue for me, please.
@@laurenceBDontYaNo truth is there are ONLY TWO SEXES MEN AND WOMEN...now go and have a cry
@@laurenceBDontYaNo heres an idea take your head out yer bum
@@laurenceBDontYaNo He's talking bollox. If you think that's the truth then it's YOU who should read a book. A biology book might be useful. One which explains what mammals are.
@@laurenceBDontYaNo How does he really speak the truth?
For example Michael Jackson had facial reconstruction and bleached his skin. He may have looked like a white caucasian man. But he was in essence an African/American male because that's what he was born as.
The same applies to fully transitioned male/females.
They may have had their genitalia changed and their reproductive system may be neutered but it hasn't been changed. They may well be recognised by law as a female but not by nature.
It is shocking that in this country we can all be held to ransom and told what we can think and say by a rabid minority.
that's our own fault we in the main are too busy lazy to put a stop to it. Let the idiots get on with it is our attitude, but politician's always need a law to impose these ideas on the rest of us, each law such as this restricts our freedoms. today there is nowhere near the freedom we had in the sixty's, an enlighten time as where the people
How anyone who cannot answer such a basic question as this can be in charge of anything is just mind-blowing.
How any woman can vote for Labour is beyond me.
How any woman is allowed to vote is beyond me
@@davidg9057 is that women with or without a 'PENIS'.
I agree with their non existent support flr dv victims and sa victims oh right oh you mean suppoty bigotry no one wants that
I agree with their non existent support flr dv victims and sa victims oh right oh you mean suppoty bigotry no one wants that
Never vote for labour
What a complete embarrassment this man is. A Shadow Secretary of State who can't answer a simple question. How on earth can we take this party seriously? They can't even agree on what a man is or what a woman is. The electorate won't stand for such ridiculous and weak behaviour, what a laughable shambles the Labour Party have become
Not long ago this sort of crap made stories in the Sunday Sport.
Everyone urging him to say YES or NO
Two words not in a politician’s vocabulary
What a twat
Labour can't (won't) define a woman, take money from Don't Stop Oil, knelt to show their allegiance to BLM and did not oppose or suggest a strategy during the biggest con in th history of human civilization (in fact we'd probably still be under lockdown and force us all to take a medicine that many of us rightly oppose).
And they're electable how exactly?
How is it even remotely a 'simple question'? You may have your own answer which you will never veer from, but that doesn't mean that it's right, or that there even is a right or wrong answer. It's a hugely complex issue. But there are human beings in the middle of it, and they should be treated with decency, not with some bland attempt at a 'gotcha' from a presenter who always looks like she's trying to do the crossword rather than actually listen to her guests.
@@dansmithwave what if you have a medical issue,do you want the hospital to treat you as you identify? It’s utter madness. I truly feel for people who are confused and believe they should be able to live as they please..but don’t force me to call you something you are not!
How can anyone vote for a politician who cannot answer such a basic question? We’ve gone mad.😊
They've gone mad - we're the sane ones round here!
Has Julia got a penis
@@chairmakerPetenone of us are sane if we continually and habitually vote for the dross of Tory or Labour .
Moreover the fact that we do is just sheer laziness on our part when it comes to political discourse .
@@brianmurray8247 agree entirely. Both of the legacy parties need to go, along with the Lib Dems (what are they for, actually?).
Fresh start. Bar anyone who has ever been in parliament from political involvement, and have 5 years with no government whatsoever. Let the civil service run the country on a "care and maintenance" basis, much as Belgium did a few years back when they were unable to elect a stable administration.
A few years of no government, and people would realise we barely need one.
Lol seriously let the civil service run the country 😂 they are worse than Labour , more woke and more anti Britain
God help us if labour get back in power.
it doesn't bear thinking about scarey
I've voted for Labour my whole life and now even I'm worried! 😩😂😂 (I left the left)
Tories introduced the madness and forced Church of England to accept Gay marriage.
The same applies with Tories we are fucked either way.
Little wonder that politicians are held in such little regard
The absolute state of these people.
What a fool this man has just made of himself 👍
Politicians have spent the last couple of years telling the public they have to respect the science.
Now with trans issues apparently we can ignore it now.
You win the Internet! Fantastic point!
Comment of the week, bravo!
Except medical science actually supports trans people and being trans and giving gender affirming care to teenagers
@@Phoneybeetlemaniacxs I work in the medical field and no one says this!
@@indiechana9771 You work in the medical field yet rely upon anecdotes instead of studies? Who cares if you don't know anyone that says this when you look at the studies they show that trans people who are accepted/ allowed to transition have much lower suicides than those who don't. Look up the Trevor project if you want actual science instead of the "I don't know anyone who says this" position.
I hope nobody will vote this kind of politicians.
Unfortunately the brainless will
Of course he doesn’t actually think they are women.
But he knows what will happen if he says as such
This is why you don't vote for anyone who won't give you a straight answer.
That includes everyone then?
A woman is a woman and a man is a man, stop all this bollox
Why never a straight answer....a man can never be a woman...an apple cannot become an orange even if you wrap it in orange peel...a trans can have surgery to remove penis and testicles and replace with something which has to be dilated twice a day....the still cannot conceive a baby.hsve a baby..feed a baby..or get pleasure from intimacy...because they are biologically male. And women cannot be men..their physiology is female..they can only look and dress -male....what's turns sane trans people into heckling and physical bullies.....is the male aggression unable to be suppressed even after transgendering....more to being a woman than a dress and a wig or long hair...
@@laurenceBDontYaNo Stop with the bulls**t.
It's why I don't vote full stop. Democracy is bullshit, it don't matter who in power they all follow an agenda, including this clouding of tha simple people of tha worlds minds, and letting kids chop their private parts up, along with tha covid bullshit🤪 It's all weird as fuck, glad ma kids are 18 and 21 now and theyv never mentioned wanting be but what they was born as, a boy and a girl. This gender agenda is mental illness at its best.🫣
I love Julia. Shes such a smart arse. But it really is a very simple question and im glad she keeps asking it. Screw the press office.
Well nailed JHB
Love watching MPs tie themselves in knots over this issue.
I am trans and I cannot think of anything that society has not allowed me to do ! Except have children of course. Saying that trans people are being prejudiced against is false unless you seek to be prejudiced against. STOP shoving it in people's faces, is being trans ALL that you are in life, is it the only thing that defines you ? Can you not be defined by kindness, intelligence, humour or any other trait ? 'trans' is now simply a prefix and a political tool.
When I was a very young child, my father told me, "What you want, and what you get, are two different things." I believed him then, and I believe him now.
Haha I got told that too!
Labour 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 Nick Thomas-Symonds 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
Honestly it absolutely baffles me how politicians think this sort of answer is preferable to just answering and taking any backlash.
They are absolutely TERRIFIED to answer it honestly.
Because government are partially funding the brainwashing along with big banks , none profit foundations.
He believes it.
He should not have appeared on this program.
Because they are dumb enough to believe it, politicians are never the brightest people.
I love the way so many politicians refuse to answer that question. What are they actually so scared of? Do they really think most people think men who transition are actually women?
In actual fact they are fishing for votes because they are that desperate for power . They are afraid of upsetting anyone so play along in the hope of getting said votes. Illegals (when labour gives them asylum ) eu nationals( when they get the vote) 16 year olds( when they get the vote) anyone on benefits and all the remainers when starmer climbs off the fence again and any other group who decide they don't like Britain.
@Miscellaneous Viewing Yes, I think that is the bigger issue. If it was just a few groups with extreme views it would be easy to ignore. But there is an ideological fad (motivated by postmodernism) which has taken control of many parts of society.
They can never answer such a simple question 🤦🏾♂️
Cant wait till Kellie Jay keen stands against Starmer.
Unfortunately she appears to have been banned from RUclips for speaking the truth.
_"If you are a biological man, you can go through a process to become a woman."_
A grown-up actually said this in front of other grown-ups and wasn't instantly sectioned? Remarkable.
Brilliant again Julia 👏👏👏👏.. this is unbelievable that these fools know women can't have a penis but are afraid to say it 🙈
Makes you wonder what they get up to at the weekend
This women is brilliant.
Saying a man cannot become a woman is a hate crime. Woke Labour
Almost unbelievable idiocy from Labour again.
Agsin…. Is that a NatC term?
@@Drmerlin604 : QWERTY keyboard, a next to the s, I think it’s fairly certain this is a typing error, easily done and missed. 🤷🏻♂️ What is 100% certain though, you are a pedantic twat! 🤷🏻♂️🤡
@@Drmerlin604 Yes, its the diddy keys on a phone. Computers and Phones were not invented when I passed O-Level English and you had a slot on Comic Relief.🤣
@@Drmerlin604 take a day 'OFF', you cloxn!
@@polaris7122 Cloxn? Another NatC term?
Get a straight answer? No chance. Dump the politicians.
This goes to show that the gender recognition act is totally insane
It's the modern way. Gay sex education need to be taught earlier in school and advertised as natural and normal.
@@ofHerWord I am sorry but this has nothing to do with Gay sex . To say a woman can have a penis is an out and out lie. To keep repeating a lie will not make it true.
What lunatic thought that up , all the mp's that voted for it should loose their seat .
You just cannot make it up, FFS these people represent us and get voted into the positions they hold.
Why are they so scared of the minus 1% of the population.
Put one hundred men and ten women on an island. In one hundred years, you'll have a community. On the other hand, put one hundred men and ten 'pretend' women on an island. In that case, after one hundred years you will have one hundred and ten male skeletons.
Shhh.......Common sense is not allowed in the 21st Century.
You seem to be 'cursed' with common sense.
Excellent explanation. That should end the argument once and for all. Please post it to Sir Kier Starmer to help him understand..
Exactly. They can call themselves what they want but the skeletons and dna traces will still say XY and indicate male.
@@cyberleaderandy1and so do most of their tombstones
Shifty little con man....
He'd make a good insurance salesman..
@@terry6985 Or a used car salesman.
Or a used car salesman! He'd probably try and sell a Lada and said that as it looked a bit like a Merc it is one !!!
You spelt it wrong, one too many f's
@@catwoman7462 DelBoy comes to mind
Just answer the bloody questions ❤❤❤
Julia you are fantastic
Never vote Labour again.
FFS , the guy just squirms his way through and can't answer the question.
This is the problem with our government, they are scared to stand with the majority of stable minded law abiding citizens, and not upset the minority of mentally unstable or illegal criminals.
He's Not in government Yet 🤣 maybe next year sometime.
@@johnmacaroni105 : God I hope not!
So do i
Well done Julia, politicians are so weak and weird nowadays.
He can't answer a straight question because he is afraid of being sacked by Herr Starmer.
She is a gem 💎
Never voted in my life, I’m 45, the reason being is because, in my voting life time, there has not been a single time that there has been a worthy person to vote for, they flip flop issues or blatantly bullshit about what they’re going to do once elected, or take power through party votes because the “ leader” quits, which has been the case over the last to many years. I’m waiting for a person that can listen to a direct question and give a direct answer, even if a don’t agree, I may actually vote for them, but that’s not going to be in my life time, if I was American I’d vote trump, just because he doesn’t toe the line, like the puppets.
If he can't answer i cant vote for him
Nice one Julia. You got the poor sap on the ropes. Tell this public servant to be honest and answer the question honestly. You cannot change biological facts!
This guy gave about 9 different answers to the same question
Our country is mental ,the answer is no you want be a woman easy.
It's 2023 and the most basic question in the world is impossible for some people to answer
Why are we even having this conversation or asking such unbelievable questions?
Ridiculous . He won't answer because of fear of being crucified.
Well, the fact is we now know that Nick hasn't got the balls. To answer a simple question that never was a question since the Dawn of Life. And still isn't to 99.9 % of the world population.
Exactly. No woman present, past or future had, has and will never have a dick.
Simple question and he goes into an unnecessary speech. Typical politician.
Julia.... she is GOLD!!!!!!!!! GOLD I tell you!!!!
5:15 Julia Heart-Brewer you are definitely in my top 10 people right now. Love how you have such a fantastic way of cornering these ridiculous notions ❤
Yes. "You hope people will forget about this at voting time."
"Er, um, um no. I hope, actually, yes. You won't put this on RUclips will you Julia. Please. Pretty please."
Keep up the good work Julia, these fools are kidding themselves that the public are behind them !
And this lot want to be in POWER
Any politician that can’t tell you, what a woman is is to be avoided ! Why would you trust these idiots on anything? If they can’t answer one simple question. They are also petrified of such a minority of foolishness. It’s unbelievable.
Unbelievable how can they be voted
What an absolute prat, tied himself in knots to not answer a simple question, both sides of the argument would think him wrong. He would be more respected if he had answered the question, at least then one side could have some time of day for him
@@miscellaneousviewing7916 this is it, isn't it? They just can't say 'no'. Unless it's helping with the cost of living or the disabled or elderly, then politicians have no problem with the word 'no'.
Bloody insanity
Wow ! And he's not the only one ! Labour winning the next election? No chance
Sadly I’m not so convinced. Most people don’t realise this is their position.
@@WHEREAMI42 or, and just hear me out here - most people aren't so obsessed with stranger's genitalia that they let it dictate their entire political stance.
@@splaffyduck5787 But we DO care about whether politicians acquiesce in losing our safe spaces, language, history, sports, literary and artistic prizes, ability to speak in public. In other times and places it was F-sc-sts and N-z-s who did this, now it's the blue-haired Blubberati.
@@splaffyduck5787 stands up and applauds 👏
He can't even answer a simple easy question and he might run this country. I dispair, this country is knacked.
Yet another slippery politician wriggling out of answering a simple question.
Our politicians do not serve the people any more.
When they're pushing their insanity in your face 7 days a week, annoyance transitions into anger.
If there was a law saying anyone could identify as an elephant, would that law actually turn a human into the species of an elephant? He looks uncomfortable, you can see him going red.
Yes, according to him the law has the capacity to change reality at the atomic level. Well I never . . .
I identify as invisible..... im trans-parent...😂
i hope there is a law where i could identify as an Elephant otherwise i will have to change my name 🤣🤣
Hardly ever discussed is the zero number of “trans men” demanding access to male sports, changing rooms and male prisons. Curious that isn’t it.
God no wonder this country is in such a bloody mess with people like this fella
It is incredible that reasonably intelligent people cannot - or will not - answer this simple question.
What if some people say 2+2 =5? Does society have to accommodate that delusion for the sake of inclusion?
This is another example of why you have to be totalling crazy to vote Labour! Oh and have you seen the other Labour Politician in the House of Commons moaning she is all for immigrants BUT JUST NOT WHERE SHE AND HER CONSTITUENTS LIVE!!! Really?
This is why women are leaving the Labour Party
I can't vote for any party. Full of BS the lot of them.
The irony of wanting to ban conversion therapy, whilst simultaneously sanctioning the cutting off, of 15 year olds breadts', is not lost on me.
The banning if conversion therapy actually goes hand in hand with the cutting off breasts.
Trans conversion therapy = any form of therapy that doesn't automatically AFFIRMS the trans person but instead investigates possible other reasons of being gender non conforming. The latter might lead to the trans person realizing they are NOT infact trans but autistic, gay, suffers from trauma, etc. That person is thus CONVERTED from trans into something else. See how that works?
@@miscellaneousviewing7916 yep, this is the loophole. If they word it properly, it would entail the "affirmation" therapy, and the placement of children in these groups.
When you are dead and buried and your bones are dug up 100's of years later regardless of what you did to your body or if you called yourself Arthur or Martha when you were alive your remains will tell you that you where created either male or female
So this man thinks “Conversion therapy” should be banned. Meaning any child of any age can say “I’m a member of the opposite sex”, and the very act of an adult questioning this is would be against the law.
Yes!
Our politicians have all gone crazy
The idiocy of the Labour Party laid bare for all to see
Julia really should be our prime minister.
Honest people don't make it into politics. They are not the kind of people that those that "pull the strings" choose.
So you don’t think the current NatCs are ridiculous and incompetent enough for you? How sad.
@@nelm612 Julia ain't honest
@@aaronaaronson7600 by comparison to our normal MPs and councillors she's as honest as they come.
@@jdizzle1779 mate she doesn't even believe in manmade climate change, are you having a laugh?
My god these clowns turn to jelly when asked a straight forward question how did we ever get to this
Very entertaining. You had him in a right pickle xxx
DONT VOTE LABOUR
He looks sane but clearly he is bonkers in his reasoning.
I wish these politicians would grow some balls 🤭
This is the funnest thing i have seen in years.
This is insane.
I do love the idea that Labour is so hamstrung by ideology from their left wing. Seeing politicians arguing that guys with full meat and two veg are women is hysterical. The panic in their faces and voices is fabulous! :)
But the NatCs are not dominated by ideology? Stay away from scissors.
They know that they have painted themselves into a corner and are panicking madly trying to find a way out.
@@janettesinclair6279 Of course people with at least an average IQ understand that the alt-right are so vile, corrupt and bereft of ideas that all that they have left is to appeal to the hard-of-thinking with this pathetic culture wars nonsense.
Let’s all rant about penises rather than focussing on the penises who have brought us Brexit, destroyed public services and the economy.
And this cowardly yes man may one day hold a ministerial post in a Labour government. God help us all.
Yes great question " do women have penises ? " it just shows how perverted and morally bankrupt this world has become.
I laughed so much. Thanks Julia.
How are people like this allowed anywhere near parliament. What a joke. Does he even believe what he is saying or is he just too scared of the repercussions to be honest.
If he's scared to answer a simple question like that, then how can he possibly be a member of the Government and lead our country?
How anyone can vote for liebour is beyond me.
You never get a straight answer from a politician