በዜግነት እና በብሄር ማንነት መካከል ባሉ ጉዳዮች ላይ ያተኮረ የምክክር መድረክ ክፍል 1

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 окт 2024

Комментарии • 170

  • @AbomaAbdissaOlaa
    @AbomaAbdissaOlaa 2 года назад +22

    The difference is visible.
    Eyasped Tesfaye proud of you!!!❤❤❤❤ Young man with wise mind & reality!

  • @fuadali122
    @fuadali122 2 года назад +14

    Eyasped is beyond the Abysinian imagination! Amazed by this young man who is making a very valid point every seconds of his time.
    Eyasped has huge potential to change the history of this country and put the country on a right path.
    Proud of you Eyasped!

    • @alamaetaddesse6198
      @alamaetaddesse6198 2 месяца назад

      እያስፔድ የምትገርም ስው ነህ ተባረክ እንዲህ አርገህ ዝርዝር አርገህ አስርዳልን እናመስግንሃለን ድጋግመህ ናልን እንድንማር እናከብርሃለን

  • @ko-keafrica2389
    @ko-keafrica2389 2 года назад +5

    Eyasped, an extraordinary young and matured person and run only by logic and principles more than his age !! The country will be beneficial if use such young professionals to bring civic dialogue in our country. He is always No 1, wherever he come for discussion. Humble man . God bless you man !

  • @Tamene-nn8lj
    @Tamene-nn8lj 4 месяца назад

    Eyasped's outlook is scientific and as clear as crestals,bravo continue like that.

  • @kitabamagarsa1025
    @kitabamagarsa1025 2 года назад +6

    Eyaspede: you hid the nail on the head! You articulated the real issue of that country’s crisis. Keep up the good work.

  • @dabalebonsa1138
    @dabalebonsa1138 2 года назад +17

    Eyasped is so special person. He knows what he speaks

    • @yenayena8676
      @yenayena8676 2 года назад

      አይ ብሔርተኛ በቃ በሀሳብ አታምኑም ግርርር

  • @ዓለምአቀፍጉዳዮች
    @ዓለምአቀፍጉዳዮች 2 года назад +1

    My heart rejoices when I see a young man like Eyasped who qualified himself not by fairytale but by reading.

  • @abichoadema4515
    @abichoadema4515 2 года назад +9

    Eyasped real expressed the real world and Ethiopian context! Good job Eysped

  • @aberakura9580
    @aberakura9580 2 года назад +6

    Eyosaped, I am really highly proud of you. Well articulated!

  • @youtubelessons
    @youtubelessons 2 года назад +3

    Eyasped, wonderful presentation and speech. very coherent and consistent in your arguments. You are the winner ! Well done!

  • @blessgirma6217
    @blessgirma6217 2 года назад +6

    Great job Eyasped Tesfaye. You focused on core point based on facts and findings of intellectuals not based on wish.

  • @bekamafekadu8314
    @bekamafekadu8314 2 года назад +2

    I have no word to santif Eysped Tesfaye he is idea is truth and santific. I am delighted he's explanation

  • @abaatahriahmed9596
    @abaatahriahmed9596 2 года назад +2

    I appreciate all the participants for sacrificing their time for this magnificent debate. I admire their rule of agree to disagree with mutual respect.

  • @yohannesnagari4100
    @yohannesnagari4100 2 года назад +7

    Eyasped. Your skill & wisdom is highly appriciated. We need fact based presentation rather than conispiracy & perception!

  • @milkessanegeriofficial
    @milkessanegeriofficial 2 года назад

    Eyasped highly informed and awared with viable evidence about what He talks. I wish every political group discusses like this without disrespecting each other

  • @solomon6733
    @solomon6733 2 года назад +13

    I proud of you eyaspade all the time I like to hear from you!!! Your idea and your thought.

  • @miknova6876
    @miknova6876 2 года назад +2

    Eyasped! Good work, fact explaining nice presentation. You're the Man! Keep up the good work.

  • @girmakatisso5360
    @girmakatisso5360 Год назад

    What a research Eyasped did. ...what a biriliant he is. ..
    I do agree with Eyasped how he defined ctezeen which was granted first for people living in city before Roman power.

  • @mikeg2008ful
    @mikeg2008ful Год назад

    I think I was a bit late to hear this very interesting and educational discussions.
    The discussion was quite interesting to me that I did watch and carefully listen to both the presentations (Part 1 & 2) made by the persons- Muligeta and Eyasped, and also to the opinions and questions raised by the people on the floor. After watching the debate and the questions/suggestions/opinions given from the young people on the floor, I felt that Ethiopia does indeed has young brilliant people who will be its asset to resolve the chaos that the Ethiopian peoples found themselves for so long both in the past and in the present. Having said that, allow me to express myself how I perceived both speakers- Muligeta and Eyasped:
    - Eyasped: Your presentation was very very educational for the Ethiopians and relevant to the purpose of the discussion! Your research, on the technical terms, your knowledge about the subject at the hand from the standpoint of the history of Abyssinia and modern Ethiopia, your courage to address straightforward some of the subjects most people seem to sideway or avoid at all, and the intelligence you demonstrated in handling Muligeta's emotional attacks, even his upset, did testify your true intelligence, sir! So, I feel I would like to say: Thank you for the hard work, the courage and the intelligence you have demonstrated in this discussion. Young brilliant people like you in the country are certainly the asset for Ethiopians to deal with the challenges they found themselves in and adopt a better future for them as a nation. Keep it up!!
    - Muligeta: I have no problem to hear whatever an individual believes in and express it out. But the problem is that how one expresses his/her point of views and how one treats other peoples' points of views. Does one control his own emotion, understand that his/her own opinions are not absolute, meaning other options/ways may exist, may be addressed by other people, etc.? So, what I observed in Muligeta's presentation was that at the very outset he started his speech not only by attacking Eyasped's points of view but also with a sense of upset. It was so obvious that the person leading the discussion rebuked him. Right? So, Muligeta's incompetency to present something relevant for the purpose of the discussion is evidenced right there! There are a number of other shortcomings he does not seem to understand them in himself. For examples: there is a clear evidence of a constant self-assertion in his speeches, amplifying his own opinions and point of views while trying to belittle the opinions/knowledge or authorities of the others. In the ancient Eastern wisdom, it is said that, "one who is absolutely confident in his opinion/knowledge is a dead man!". Obviously, it does not mean at a physical level. Also, he seems to value too much feelings, which is part of emotional manifestations. He also seems to have difficulties to accept facts as they are, and tries to deny and instead imposes on others forcefully what he thinks is "right" without providing convincing reasons. So, I would like to remind Muligeta (Dr.) what people who have learned life long from life experiences say, which goes like this: 'Arrogance exists where there is self-ignorance while intelligence exists where there is humility.' It implies then that, a thorough self-understanding may not be attainable as the result of higher education at school; much more than that. In fact, most people who operate only at intellectual level are not intelligent but arrogant! Can that explain anything to Muligeta?
    Otherwise, I really feel that such a discussion is very necessary for the Ethiopians and need to be encouraged to continue even at a wider scale than it is now, because understanding the root cause of their problem, which is mainly political is critical for only then the willing to do something differently can happen.
    Keep it up!
    In closing, I would like to leave one question for Eyasped if I may: King Haile Selessie wasn't from Abyssinia as you know. Why then he embraced the Amharization/Abyssiniazation of the rest of the modern Ethiopian regions? Was there a higher authority (a decision-making group, if you will) behind him? If so, who are they, and was it applicable to the kings/Ras prior to Haile Selessie as well?
    Thank you.

  • @henokemolla8204
    @henokemolla8204 2 года назад +3

    I think this is great debate!! all debates should lead to a better future! which means it should indicate the way out!! it should not focus on playing with peoples emotion!!!

  • @christhomas6893
    @christhomas6893 2 года назад +5

    Eyasped malet tinishu Jawar

  • @sisaybersisa8079
    @sisaybersisa8079 2 года назад +11

    ወዳጄ በርታ እግዚያቤር ካንተ ጋር ይሁን በተሣተፍክበት ቦታ ሁሉ ለተበደለው ለተጨቆነው የምት ሟገት ትክክለኛ ሰው ነህ የውሸት ኢትዮጳዊ ራቁቱን እያሰቀረህልን ሰለሆነ በርታ አለን አንተ

    • @ethiotube4805
      @ethiotube4805 2 года назад +1

      ክፋት ጥላቻ በቀል አፈጣጠር
      ጭቁን ጨፍጫፊ ከተባለ ክ እናንተ በላይ ሰው የጨፈጨፈ አለ?

  • @bunagimbii2712
    @bunagimbii2712 2 года назад +9

    ኡባንቱ ሚዲያ በርቱ የምታደርጉት አስተዋፅኦ ከፍተኛ ነው 🎯

  • @BibleismorePropheticWord
    @BibleismorePropheticWord 2 года назад +1

    Eyasped explains knowledge based understanding

  • @tezeraberheto5398
    @tezeraberheto5398 2 года назад +5

    Thank you , Eyasped. You have shown what knowledge-based discussions should be like. Though I am on the other side, it’s shameful that almost all of them use intimidation and masking instead of using principles and evidence. That’s why we will never win. By the way, this uneducated man should never be here.

    • @l2h773
      @l2h773 Год назад

      Mulugeta Aregawi - resorted to intimidation and name-dropping to camouflage his shallow understanding of the issues.

  • @abaatahriahmed9596
    @abaatahriahmed9596 2 года назад +2

    I watched part one debate but didn't get a chance for part 2 nonetheless. It was a great political lesson and I thank all the participants.Keep up with the magnificent job and hopefully you will lead us to the right direction.

  • @dachaasngussa6282
    @dachaasngussa6282 2 года назад +1

    Eyas!! Ilmi dhugaa siif haa dhalatu🙏👌👍

  • @munasabdella8701
    @munasabdella8701 2 года назад +3

    Oh my goodness!! All are facts!!!

  • @amanuelelhanan4716
    @amanuelelhanan4716 2 года назад +1

    Wow, Amazing. I loved it a lot

  • @amansiisqanaatee3738
    @amansiisqanaatee3738 2 года назад +3

    Eyasped is as scholar and professional as usual but I apreciate also the other presenter and the whole mood of discussion. Special salute to the last speaker.

  • @yohannesmulu1096
    @yohannesmulu1096 2 года назад

    I liked Eyasped, he is real Intellectual. I liked the second presenter as well, for the first time in history, he admitted that Ethiopia was contracted by oppressing and suppressing some nations.

  • @mesfingose759
    @mesfingose759 2 года назад +6

    የዋሽንቱ ምሳሌ በጣም የተሳሳተ ነው። አንድ ሶማሌ በእውነት ያንን ዋሽንት ጃፓን ውስጥ ቢሰማ does he/she care? "የኢትዮጵያ" ናሽናሊስቶች ቢሰሙ የኔ ሊሉት ይችላሉ።

  • @sahlezewdinhe5360
    @sahlezewdinhe5360 2 года назад +2

    በአሁኑ ዘመን የተለያዩ ብሄሮች በሚኖሩበት ሀገረ -መንግሥት ( state ) ውስጥ የአብሮነት ግንባታው ( Nation Building ) ሂደት መከተል ያለበት መንገድ ፣ብሄሮችን በኃይል በመጨፍለቅ አንድ ወጥና ልሙጥ የሆነ የጋራ ማንነትን ( " ኢትዮጵያዊነትን ") ለመፍጠር ሳይሆን ፣ ላሉት የ ብሄሮች ማንነቶች መኖርና መቀጠል ዕውቅናና ክብር በሚሰጥ መንገድ መሆን አለበት።

  • @MuhaajirwalAnsaar1
    @MuhaajirwalAnsaar1 2 года назад +25

    ኢትዮጵያ የሚንልክ ልጆችን ብሄር ባህል እና ቋንቋን የሚታቀነቅን እንጂ የብሄር ብሔረሰቦችን እኩልነት የሚታስተናግድ ሃገር አይደለችም አትልፋ::

  • @DefendTheTruth1
    @DefendTheTruth1 Год назад

    Wow, Eyasped👏

  • @tesfayeboyissa8367
    @tesfayeboyissa8367 2 года назад +2

    Eyasped, literally scholar

  • @tesfayemidega4887
    @tesfayemidega4887 2 года назад

    Natinalism telito yemayalq shinkurt new. I like this explanation. Awuqen kaltewnew mekefafel maqomiya yelawm. Be oromo dereja andinet metebeq kechalni be ethiopia derejan andinetachin metebeqim yichalal. Sewoch lemekefafel banirot tiru new. Endet andinetachin enamta yimilew neger lay gin wuyiyit yasfeligal.

  • @ifaneg8750
    @ifaneg8750 2 года назад

    THIA KIND OF DISCUTION IS VERY IMPORTANT, IF WE ARE INTERTANNING IT POSITIVELLY. WE HAVE TO IMMERG FOR NEW CIVIC IDENTITY

  • @CaliforniaMuslim
    @CaliforniaMuslim Год назад

    Eyasped💝

  • @kedirahmed8265
    @kedirahmed8265 2 года назад +2

    Eyasped 👍

  • @ebiwakjira5365
    @ebiwakjira5365 2 года назад +4

    Eyasped is special !! The second man is aggressively talking about the history of some other countries. Ofcourse the difference is vissible!! Eyasped 💪💪

  • @wiliiifta5533
    @wiliiifta5533 2 года назад +1

    Hi my favorite Ubuntu where have you been?
    What happen to you?
    Is everything good?
    I hope you are in good

  • @dammaqechifranduga
    @dammaqechifranduga Год назад

    a wise man fills his mind before emptying his mouth-:" African proverb EyAsped is real African! live longest

  • @theconfusedoromo5361
    @theconfusedoromo5361 2 года назад

    much love eYASPEED

  • @milkessanegeriofficial
    @milkessanegeriofficial 2 года назад

    እያስፔድ በድብቅ ደባብሶት አጃጅሎ የምያራምዱትን ብትንትኑን አውጥቴ ስለገለጥክ ክብር ይገባሃል! በእውቀት መጥቄ ብልቱን እና አጥንቱን ለያይተ ፣ የአብስንያን ተንኮል ራቁቱን ገልጠሃል! እግዚአብሔር ክፉ እና አታላዩን ስርዓት ለዘለሃለም ይድፋው!

  • @natanimbekele5563
    @natanimbekele5563 2 года назад

    Eyaasped Tesfaye proud of you

  • @bekamafekadu8314
    @bekamafekadu8314 2 года назад +1

    Eyasped Tesfaye youngest bravo

  • @abuhuzeyfa2053
    @abuhuzeyfa2053 2 года назад

    ኢያፕሴድ ተጨባጩን በአስረጅና አመክንዩ እንዲሁም አካዳሚክ በሆነ መንገድ አስቀምጧል። ተወያዩ ሙሉጌታ ግን ሲጀምር ስሜታዊ ነው የሆነው አቀራረቡ አካዳሚክ ከለር የለውም።
    You did great Eyapsod 👍🌟👍🌟👍🌟

  • @natykebede6542
    @natykebede6542 2 года назад

    Where Could I get paper written by Eyasped?

  • @nebiyutegegn6667
    @nebiyutegegn6667 2 года назад +3

    እያስፔድ በእውቀት ላይ የተመሰረተ ትንታኔ እና ምልከታ ስላቀረብክ አመሰግናለው።

  • @berhanetsehayteklewold1460
    @berhanetsehayteklewold1460 2 года назад +1

    Can we get the slides please?

  • @bunagimbii2712
    @bunagimbii2712 2 года назад +3

    ገና mic ስጨበጥ ትምከት ማሳየት ምን የሚሉት ነው? 🤔

  • @ebrahimabdela8808
    @ebrahimabdela8808 2 года назад +1

    Well come

  • @amansiisqanaatee3738
    @amansiisqanaatee3738 2 года назад +5

    በኢትዮጵያ ያለው ችግር የ theoretical framework ማጣት ወይም በ concepts ላይ ያለመግባባት ችግር አይመስለኝም:: ችግሩ የአንድ ብሔር ናሺናሊዝም ሌሎችን ብሔሮች የማሸነፍና የመዋጥ ፍላጎትና ይሄንን ባልተቀበሉት መሀከል የሚደረግ ትግል ውጤት ነው:: የአማራው ማንነት በአንድ የታሪክ አጋጣሚ በተፈጠረ ወታደራዊ የሀይል ሚዛን መበላለጥ ሌሎቹን ብሔሮች አንበርክኮ ለመዋጥ ሞክሯል:: ይህ ሙከራ ለ150 አመታት ያልተሳካ ቢሆንም ዛሬም እየሞከረ በመሆኑ ይሄንን ሀይል ለመግታት ከየአቅጣጫው እንቅስቃሴዎች በመበርታታቸው የገባንበት ችግር ነው እያተራመሰን ያለው:: ይሄ ሀይል የለውጥ መንግሥት የተባለው የአብይ መንግሥት የከሸፈውን የሚኒሊክ ህልም ነፍስ ይዘራበታል ብሎ አምኖ የነበረ ቢሆንም ይሄ መንግሥት የሀይል ሚዛኑን አይቶ ቀዝቀዝ በማድረጉ በራሱ መንገድ ሳልሳዊ ሚኒሊክ ለመፍጠር እየተውተረተረ ያለበት ሁኔታ ውስጥ ገብተናል:: ይሄ ደግሞ ችግራችንን ያወሳስበዋል:: ስለዚህ ኢያስፔድ ያነሳው መፍትሔ ለመተግበር አስቸጋሪ ቢሆንም ፈውስ ሊሆን ይችላል:: እኔ ግን ዘላቂ መፍትሔ ነው ብዬ የማምነው ኮንፌዴሬሺን ብቻ ነው::

  • @yenayena8676
    @yenayena8676 2 года назад

    ብሃርተኝነት በቃ ሆ ብሎ መደገፍ ነው እያስፔድ ምን ቢናገር ዋው በርታ ብቻ አረ ሀሳብ ይግዛችሁ. ኢንጅነር ጌታሁን እናመሰግናለን

    • @natykebede6542
      @natykebede6542 2 года назад

      እንደ እያስፔድ Logical አለ? የጠቀስሽው ሠው ጌታሁን ሄራሞስ ስለ እያስፔድ ያለውን ሠምተሻል?

  • @seifet.k.afrikano1415
    @seifet.k.afrikano1415 2 года назад

    እንደ አለመታደል ሆኖ፣ አሁን ያለው ትውልድ እጅግ በጣም አድሏዊ እና የአስተሳሰብ ተስፋ አስቆራጭ፣ በህወሓት ፕሮፓጋንዳ በአሉታዊ መልኩ ሰለባ ነው። ሙሉጌታ ታላቅነትን አሳይተሃል።

  • @tedhs2282
    @tedhs2282 2 года назад

    Mulugeta’s; perspective par excellence, indeed know him, appreciate your presentation & faculty, as well, but this by no means whittle away the other.
    Premier program

  • @sisayantalo6834
    @sisayantalo6834 2 года назад +2

    Eyosafed is a political scientist !!!

  • @seifet.k.afrikano1415
    @seifet.k.afrikano1415 2 года назад

    My main complaint is that the exam was built around the Eurocentric, Stalinist, socialist nation-state question, which was supposed to be the panacea for all of Russia and her satellite republics' ills. Soviet Russia and Ethiopia were worlds apart politically, culturally, and ideologically. It was also important, before imposing an alien philosophy on Ethiopia, to gain an appreciation for the country's feudalistic and lagging manner of production.

  • @seifet.k.afrikano1415
    @seifet.k.afrikano1415 2 года назад

    not just the state, the nation, or the ethnic group, but also other ethnicities were repressed and assimilated over the all of Africa and the rest of the world.

  • @bekamafekadu8314
    @bekamafekadu8314 2 года назад +1

    Ubuntu first .

  • @romankebede4105
    @romankebede4105 2 года назад

    Nice!!

  • @natan7997
    @natan7997 2 года назад

    ይልቅ በየ ትምህርት ቤቱ በአግባቡ ማስተማር ነው የሚሻለው ምክንያቱም የመደንዘዝና የግለኝነት ችግር ነው የዜግነት ማንነት ሰው ሰው የሚሸትና አለማችንም የምትጠቀምበት ዘመናዊ ዲሞክራሲያዊ ፈጣሪን የምታስብበት ሰው የመሆን ሚስጥር ነው ብሔርተኛ ማንነት እኔ ብቻ ማለት ነው ፓለቲካዊ ሲሆን

  • @nahimii1senna240
    @nahimii1senna240 Год назад

    ብታምኑም ባታምኑም ትግላችን ለነፃነት እንጂ ለሌላ ዙር ጥገኝነትና ቀኝ አገዛዝ ማመቻቸት አይደለም
    ኦሮሞ በነጻነቱ አይደራደርም❣የኦሮሞ ህዝብ❣

  • @samuelgeremew3027
    @samuelgeremew3027 2 года назад +5

    You see ,"especially, oromia should be rearranged to different and vast regions. If not, all ethiopian regions have to be rearranged " said. What does this political motives mean? Does any region asks the rearrangement of all regions or the fragmantation of Oromioa regional state other than those under the cover of Ethiopianism? And why only those 🤔

    • @negashbirrmeji6679
      @negashbirrmeji6679 2 года назад

      እግር ትበላላቹ እንላለን
      ኦሮሚያ ቲያ ⚫🔴⚪

  • @misrakmekonen5755
    @misrakmekonen5755 2 года назад +4

    Wow eyasiped you did a great presentation keep it up

  • @zeedam6066
    @zeedam6066 2 года назад

    Eyasped, when you mention Karamra as.your example it delebrately implies your divisive oratory is to undermine the unity of Somalia region. This discussion may help the political pundits by obeying such philosophy and theory as presented.

  • @hibaamede4173
    @hibaamede4173 2 года назад

    ሁሉም የኢትዮጵያ ሕዝብ ኃላቀር ነው አገሪቱም በኢኮኖሚ ኃላቀር ነች ስለዚህ አሁን ሁሉም ክልል እራሱን አስተዳደረ ነው፡ ስለዚህ ባህላቸውን ማሳደግ ይችላሉ፡፡ እርግጥ ትንንሺ ብሔረሰቦች በቂ ድጋፍ ሊሰጣቸው ይገባል፡፡ በዚህ ላይ መነጋገር መልካም ነው፡፡ ካልሆነ ያለፈ የታወቀ ችግር ደጋግሞ ማንሳት መፍትሔ አያመጣም፡፡

  • @solomon6733
    @solomon6733 2 года назад +1

    እውነትን ተናግሮ የመሽበት ማደር ማለት ይሄ ነው።

  • @zeedam6066
    @zeedam6066 2 года назад

    Eyasped keep your lecture for classroom. Ethiopians are not ready to dismantle Ethiopia in order to reorganize arround your theory. Axumite empire survived through Ethiopia and Ethiopia will prevail. All the partispant should read about The SIRRARA merchants of the North. South, East and West in the 18th and 19th century.

  • @chuchu046
    @chuchu046 2 года назад +3

    Eya ቁልምጭ ያለ አውቀት አኮ ነው ያለሽ

  • @willyou2030
    @willyou2030 2 года назад

    የመጀመሪያው ተናጋሪ ከጀርባው በተንኮል የተሰበሰበ እውቀትን በማሳመን ችሎታ ለሚከተሉት አቅርቧል!
    ሁለተኛው ተናጋሪ ግን ሃቁን በተጨባጭ ያለንበትን እና የሆነውን ልንሆን የምንችለውን ነው ያብራራው
    በአጠቃላይ ግን ጥሩ ተናገረ አስረዳ ማለት ትክክል ነው ብለህ አትነዳ ነጭ የጻፈው ሁሉ ለራሳቸውም አልሆነም ዋናው ነገር እንዴት እንኑር እንቀጥል ነው !

  • @eyasu977
    @eyasu977 2 года назад +1

    የጸሃፊዎችን ስም ከመጥራት በስተቀር ውጪ ፍጹም ዝብርቅርቅ ያለ ሃሳብ በብዙ ህጸጾች የተሞላ ጥራዝነጠቅ ሃሳብ

  • @willyou2030
    @willyou2030 2 года назад +1

    የሚገርም ነው የወላይታው ተናጋሪ አውቃለሁ ባዩ ምሳሌ ሲሰጥ የኢትዮጵያ አየር መንገድ አስተናጋጆች የሚለብሱት ልብስ ጥለቱ አቢሲኒያ ነው ሸማው ግን ከወላይታ ነው አለ እና ችግሩ ምን ላይ ነው ? ሸማው እኮ ወላይታን አሳይቶአል የሸማ አመጣጥ በእውነት ከ ወላይታ ከሆነ፣ ነው ጥለቱ 90ብሄር ይሁን ? ወደድህም ጠላህም አሁን ያለው ባንዲራ አረንኋዴ ቢጫ ቀይ ነው አንተ አቢሲኒያ የምትለው
    የነበሩት መንግስታት እኮ አንተ የመጣህበትን ብሄረሰብ ሰውን ከነ ነብሱ ሲቀብሩ ያስቆመ ያስተማረ ነው ያ ባይሆን ኖሮ ምንአልባትም ያንተም አያት ቅድመ አያት ተቀብረው አልቀው አንተ ዛሬ ኖረህ በእነኝህ ሳይማሩ ሃገርን ባቆዩት ላይ አፍህን አትከፍትም ነበር ! አንድ ነገር ደግሞ እወቅ የዛሬ 200 ዓመት ወላይታ ምን ይመስል ነበር ? እንዴት ነበር ምትኖሩት ? የምትጽፉት ፊደል ነበር ? ትጽፉ ነበር ታሪክን ? አርሳችሁ ነበር የምትመገቡት ? ምን አይነት ልብስ ነበር ምትለብሱት ? ምን አይነት እምነት ነበራችሁ ? ብዙ ብዙ ነገሮች አሉ መመለስ ያለባቸው አሁን ቁጭ ብለህ ለዚህ ያበቁህን መንግስታት አታቃል ! አሁን አንተ እና መሰሎችህ ለወላይታ ምን አደረግህ ? በተሰራ ስራ ላይ ከመተቸት ውጭ እስኪ የተሻለ መፍትሄ አምጣ ? ሌላው ያንተን ችግር እንዲፈታልህ ከመጨቃጨቅ

  • @tesemayeruq4920
    @tesemayeruq4920 2 года назад +1

    የአማራው ተወካይ ምን ሆነው ነው የሚዘባርቁት። ያለቦታቸው ተሰልፈው ግራ ገባቸው

  • @mameali328
    @mameali328 2 года назад +1

    eyaasped wonder full❤❤❤

  • @samuelgeremew3027
    @samuelgeremew3027 2 года назад +1

    State building process has both positive and negative out comea, but on the way we all should accept both. Why you guys, under Ethiopianism shadow neglect those facts? Not even as nation, family to family dispute are resolved based on facts and amending by both side. This in fact much more wide and nationality matter to accept and make amendments to live together, that is the way we may have stong country

  • @awolababiyaa4652
    @awolababiyaa4652 2 года назад +1

    ሰዉዬዉ ባሌን ታሪክ ሳይረዳ ከጠበቃ ወንድሙ እብሳ ወሬ ሰምቶ ነዉ እንደ? የጄኔራል ዋቆ ጉቱ ታሪክ መስማት ስላልፈለገ ወሬ ያዉራል እንዴ?

  • @mesfingose759
    @mesfingose759 2 года назад +4

    intetesting! ውብ የሆነ ውይይት ነው!

  • @fisahatekalign1507
    @fisahatekalign1507 2 года назад

    Eyasped qimem iko nesh.

  • @bekamafekadu8314
    @bekamafekadu8314 2 года назад

    Dhugaa raabi Nama akka Eyasped Tesfaye nuuf haa bayyisu raabi. Go head

  • @tesemayeruq4920
    @tesemayeruq4920 2 года назад +1

    ተስፋፊነት ማለት ከጎጃም ከጎንደር ተነስቶ ደቡብ ወርዶ ያገኝፕውን ጭፕፍልቆ እፕጥፍቶ መውረር ነው።

  • @bachudebela6256
    @bachudebela6256 2 года назад +2

    The guy after Eyasped literally said if he doesn't understand something, then that thing doesn't matter. Typical ethiopian ignorance!

  • @seifet.k.afrikano1415
    @seifet.k.afrikano1415 2 года назад

    መንግሥት ብቻ ሳይሆን ፣ጎሳዎችም ወይም ብሔረሰቦች ጭቆና አድርሰዋል ወይም ሌላው እንዲዋሃድ አርገዋል
    ይህም በመላው አፍሪካና በተቀረው ዓለም ነበረ። እና የኢትዮጵያ ፖለቲካ ልዩ አያደርገውም።

  • @tesfayemidega4887
    @tesfayemidega4887 2 года назад

    Sewoch beteregaga menfes teqemto biweyayu silemigbabu teregagten endaniweyayi gize endinatana simetawi honen endangibaba lemadreg ferenjoch kefaflon yemiyawagun. silezih neqten lewyiyit gize ensit nechochn ansimacjhew. enesiu awqew yehesab liyunet endsefa yeteleyayu hasabochn yichnubinal.

  • @wiliiifta5533
    @wiliiifta5533 2 года назад +2

    What kind of person illusion person, we never heard and used so called Washint in Oromia.

    • @samrawittassew630
      @samrawittassew630 2 года назад

      Yeah He thinks what he felt is universally true. Aysazinim. Yeagere musika yilal... Ene it breaks my heart, as that reminds me the death of Meles. That was the only thing we listened to for a week.

  • @seifet.k.afrikano1415
    @seifet.k.afrikano1415 2 года назад

    Unfortunately, the current generation is extremely biassed and has a pessimistic outlook, which is perpetuated negatively by TPLF propaganda. Mulugeta you have exhibited greatness.

  • @abck23
    @abck23 2 года назад +1

    ቢቻል በአማራኝ ቃላት ተጠቅማቹ ብታወሩ

    • @aynalemtadesse2684
      @aynalemtadesse2684 2 года назад +1

      ለምን? የአማርኛ ትርጉም ለሌላቸውስ?

  • @tarekegnfite8706
    @tarekegnfite8706 2 года назад

    the second presentor is hopeless. thank Eyu!!!!

  • @abbaagoolee4496
    @abbaagoolee4496 2 года назад

    I am looking for such debate for the long time . But Mulugeta Haragawi is came on the stage to reject every academicians expertise . He believes he is the only academic . Let me say this * SAINT MARY help him . I believe he is a graduate of * WASHA UNIVERSITY * .

  • @seifet.k.afrikano1415
    @seifet.k.afrikano1415 2 года назад

    እያስፔድ ተስፋዬ ግራ የተጋባ ግለሰብ ነው; በተፈጥሮ ሳይንስ እና በማህበራዊ ሳይንስ መካከል ያለውን ልዩነት መለየት አልቻለም.

  • @bunagimbii2712
    @bunagimbii2712 2 года назад +3

    ለምን አማራ እንደ ምሳሌ አልጠቀስክም? ለ ምሳሌ ቂማንት, አጋው?? 🎯

  • @bachudebela6256
    @bachudebela6256 2 года назад

    The dude after Eyasped says The Roman Empire hasd a strong relationship with Roman Catholic Church. LOL. The Roman Catholic church was founded about 600 years after the dissolution of the Roman Empire.

  • @tesemayeruq4920
    @tesemayeruq4920 2 года назад

    ተሪክን መካድ ነው ትልቁ ችግራችን፣

  • @kichuu129
    @kichuu129 2 года назад

    Eyasped you are on the right track; but the other guy is just justifying the killing of the Habeshas and their superiority complex 😮

  • @mesfingose759
    @mesfingose759 2 года назад +1

    ሚኒሊክ is not the point of discussion. አቶ ተስፋዬ እዚህ ላይ ለምን እንዳተኮረ አልገባኝም

  • @mesfingose759
    @mesfingose759 2 года назад +2

    "ባሌ ናሽናሊስት" ? ይሔ ሀሳብ ከየት የመጣ ነው? ማነው የባሌ ናሽናሊስት ነኝ ብሎ የሚናገረው? እጅግ አሳፋሪ ነው!

    • @tsegawoldeselassie6378
      @tsegawoldeselassie6378 2 года назад

      ምርጥ ገለፃ ግን ፌክ ኢትዮጵያዊኒስቶች ተንጫጩ

  • @alijosu1689
    @alijosu1689 2 года назад

    እያስፔድ የሚገርም ትንታኔ ነው

  • @tesfayemidega4887
    @tesfayemidega4887 2 года назад

    Yalewn sihitetoch endesihtet teqebilo lalemedgem memoker wanaw guday new. Manim yaderegew guday new bilo maqlel tikikil aydelem. enga beza zemen bininor min enaderg neber bilo meteyeq tikikil bihonim zemenu yasederegew neger gin sihtet ena tifat mehonun mamen gin gid new. Aqrabiw tesastowal. Eyasped degmo yemirabawyan asetesaseb bicha ende wabi maqreb tikikil layhon yichilal. enesu egnan liyakefafilu new teqarani hasabochn yemiyanesut. Lemisale Amerikan mengist wust siltan eyalachew andu weyanen sidegf andu Abiyin yidegfal. Hulum legna bilo aydelem liyabalun new enji. tigray tv yenesun degafi endezi tenagere yilalu endezaw degmo EBCm yeabiyin degafi yaqerbilihal. Etiyopian degmo amerikanoch awaqi nachew bilo selemiyasb yenesun hasab yiqebelal teblo new. Enesu gin be ewnet eyeteqarenu aymeslegnim egnan liyabalun new enji. Silezih Berasachin teweyayten yemiyawatanin hasaboch memret new mefthew. Yenesun hasab ende menesha mewsed yichal yihonal enji ende wesagn neger mewsed ligoden yichlal yemanin eneqebel bilo kirkir silemifetr malet new.

  • @kasahunabera4936
    @kasahunabera4936 2 года назад +1

    በጣም ጥሩ ውይይት ነው። ነገር ግን በሰፊው ሀገራዊ አጀንዳ ሆኖ ውይይት ቢደረግበት የተሻለ መግባባት ይፈጥራል